So what kind of ending did people want?
>>281851108
>>281851108Maybe like an ending where theres a time jump generations later and Eren and friends are reincarnated and enjoying their time together watching a movie about the events of SnK, as its implied their will be a sequel
Eren retvrns home to Historia (wife) and his newborne child (Ymir parallel, now born free)The world outside Eldia razedEren can still be demonized and hated by the survivors, maybe put the trial. You could have even kept the Cringevengers trying to stop him, just don't have him cuck and actually have a plan to follow through. His plan being LMAO i forgot and Ymir really loved King Fritz was the edittors being asked to change the story
>>281851108Something involving sex.
Forgot pic relIf you ever author anything; do NOT do what Isayama did here. "Reveal the final panel" and then NOT EVEN USE IT fucking scumbag actual shit author for doing this. I dont care that EH didnt happen, I care that he betrayed his narratives
>>281851108a 'kill everyone and all the conflict in the world vanishes' ending, basically tards that didnt understood the story but said tards sympathized with pajeets and muslims so its to be expected
>>281851108Maybe actually treat Eren like he did something bad? Instead of everyone sucking his dick?
It's over. Let it go.
>>281851108>peopleHumans got the ending they wanted. Subhuman retards wanted a genocide based ending because the plotline flew higher over their head than the bird symbolizing freedom.
>>281851245He did use it, just half assed and pages before the actual final.
>>281851108Same as it was but it ends on Mikasa kissing Eren's severed head. Everything in the chapter afterwards was pointless. Ending on that kiss would be powerful, insane, and stick with people forever.>>281851245It shows up somewhere in the final chapter but it wasn't the final panel. Same thing happened with Harry Potter where "scar" was in the last sentence but wasn't the last word like she said it would be.
>>281851108>kill everyone outside of paradis>return home>live out the rest of his lifePretty shrimple>b-but muh cycles of violence Yeah if you kill everyone then it ends but if you want to be a fag just show Paradis falling into civil war.
>>281851573You’re not a human for wanting to help people that want you dead. You’re a spiteful mutant.
>>281851775>being a mouthbeather retard that could never let go of conflict got his people killed in the far futuredamn, he won so hard
>>281851775>proves my point by generalizing the plot in the most reductive way possibleWoe is me winning an argument without doing anything.
EHcucks ruined SnK threads
>>281851108>Eren kill everyone >All his friends die trying to stop it>Paradis devolves into civil war>Eren stands at the beach alone looking towards the horizon and says:>In the end, I was the Shingeki no kyojin all along
>>281853127Kino ending.
Eren should have just committed and said some shit like "fuck you armin, id do it again. When the rest of the world comes for paridis again you'll see I was right. See you in hell."
>>281851108Eren kills everyone then memory wipes all of Walldia to think mankind went extinct a long time ago and that there is no civilization beyond the walls oh and he plaps Historia
>>281851108It was one the better endings but plebbitors and midwits want to be contrarians over trivial nonsense.
>>281851961>being a mouthbeather retard that could never let go of conflict got his people killed in the far futureI posted Floche, not Armin.
>>281852022You’re calling it reductive doesn’t actually make it true. Especially given the whole world was coming for them.
>>281851108If you were there reading it month-to-month and theorizing about the ending, you don't have to be told why the ending was bad. If you binged the whole thing in one day because you wanted to know "what all the fuss was about," you'll never get it.
>>281854621weird cause armong was looking for peace in the end, meanwhile the retards influenced by floch and eren got their country destroyed like idiots lmao
Why is this considered a shit ending when it does the same thing with it's MC as Code Geass, which is widely applauded as an amazing ending?
>>281851108One where Reiner doesn't get away with a slap on the wrist after cheating death multiple times.Also, fuck that "actually I killed mom" crap.
>>281856939Code Geass was an inferior anime, so it is appropriate that it gets an inferior ending to match.The ending for AOT is underwhelming relative to the rest of the story.
>>281851108>reverse wall where the titans formed a new wall to cage the human who lived outside into a tiny town>timeskip>mc who was born inside the wall tried to get out
>>281855933Its not that fucking deep bro, AoT's dialogue is garbage compared to actual Novels like Shoshimin and you're dumb for dissecting it that much. Manga isn't that deep. No manga is ever that deep, faggot.
>>281851108I think the logical ending was the rumbling. I don't say that because I'm "hurr durr genocide". However, the situation that was presented in the story can only conclude with the rumbling. Every country in the world voted to wipe out the Eldians. The Cringevengers all watched them make that vote. They knew that Bert and Ernie were the ones who attacked their homes and killed their families. They saw Marley fly planes and parachute into Paradis, etc.
>>281851108Have Eren destroy the entire world and come home to Historia so they can become the new Adam and Eve. Someone posted a fanart with a similar premise a long time ago but I can’t find it.
>>281857051>DUNE>Fahrenheit 451>High literatureGood bait, made me reply.Honestly this chart almost works in reverse. Real ones know that the final redpill is kodomo anime saikou.
>center the ending on EreMika>it kills the entire series Kek EHchads were vindicated in the end
>>281857510Still deeper and more consistent that the shounen bullcrap AoT tried to pull
Will Isayama ever make another manga?
>>281851108eren getting his way ? people wanted the ending where everyone but the eldians and their friends were trampled
>>281851108>>281851149>>281851223>>281851245>>281853886>>281857092>>281857520Of course you're still seething about the ending. It was the perfect ending to this masterpiece. The anons who are complaining about it are generally self-inserters (who wanted him to go for 100℅ rumbling and then return back to Paradis as the new king of Eldia and stay in chad mode forever), EHshippers and the garbage AnR enthusiasts (which is a complete insult to Yams and SnK).The ending was slightly rushed since it seems that the author was forced to meet his deadline and wrap up SnK ASAP by his editor and publisher and also due to time constraint. MAPPA didn't have to fix much besides giving more it more time to breathe and changing some dialogue. It cemented itself as a cultural phenomenon of this decade. And we won't get anything as groundbreaking as SnK for a long time.
>>281856783>>281856795Why is it that spiteful mutants that hate the idea of people defending themselves always end up being samefaggot? >weird cause armong was looking for peaceYou mean peace with the people that were planning on killing them? That’s retarded>what a victum complexHyper specific accusations like this are always projections. But thanks for showing that you can’t argue and have to cope instead. And no calling it a headcanon is not an argument. There is a whole scene where they say they’re going to wipe out the island devils.
>>281858377This is said by someone that self inserts as armin and needs to project his retarded complex on everyone else.
>>281851108Eren being played straight as an endgame villain for starters. I don't think he should have won and vindicated the rumbler edgelords but his diet Lelouch plan in the completed story sucks ass. Especially because the bonus pages with bombers over Paradis in the flash forward ending were Isayama pandering to rumblingtards anyway and they still hated it. Reiner spends the entire story going through a great character arc and his final moments in this manga are wrestling a nonsensical plot worm and sniffing a letter. To say I wanted more pay off than that for his character would be an understatement. Zeke also goes fucking nowhere for how much was put into his character and Levi's revenge against him hits with all the gravitas a wet fart in an elevator. It stinks.Everything about Annie after she busts out of the wack ass tupac crystal prison is just ludicrous. The story bends in half to accommodate this obviously harebrained plot point that was set up with no resolution in mind and she's just slammed into a ship Armin so he can have a hole once the story's over. So many characters just fly wildly OOC and just look the other way on all of her shit. I don't think a single fan believed Mikasa was going to have a satisfying conclusion once Eren started to freak but the Eren seagull cuck shit is so much worse than anyone possibly could have imagined.
>Shitgeki no Kino
>>281851108The world getting stomped flat. >b-b-but that's edgy Yeah, retard, it's an edgy manga about people getting brutally killed by giants. Pay attention.
>kill six billion people>It's okay guys I was lelouchingIsayama, it doesn't work that way
>>281851108The one the author wanted to make, but his editor and publisher prevented him from making.The full on genocide the subhumans that lied for hundreds of years about us while doing to the world exactly what they claim we did end.
>>281858377You faggot. Everyone wanted a bittersweet or bad ending that fit the tone of the show. That means the outcomes people expected were either:-Casualties in the alliance-Eren dying pathetically -Rumbling succeeding at the cost of his friends’ lives, bleak ending.Instead we got a fucking Disney happy ending where everyone in the alliance somehow survives the hardest fight of their lives against thousands of shifter titans. I don’t do ships, but Historia having Eren’s child would’ve at least been consistent with his themes and character.What bugs me the most is that they chose to frame the story way past where it needed to end, with that whole "war, war never ends" crap. That’s just pretentious and only there to hammer the main theme. Imagine how stupid Breaking Bad would’ve been if instead of ending on Walter’s dead body, they cut to a message saying "le drugs are bad."
>>281851108They wanted a Turner Diaries ending
>>281851108The ending was fine really. Eren was a tard and a child with too much power, he said so himself. The ending was the result of the decisions made by an immature, emotional, and ignorant, actor with too much capacity for destruction. History is rife with egotistical dipshits who make decisions that result in nonsensical geopolitical outcomes. Maybe the tone of the "epilogue" could have been handled better, but I don't think another type of ending would have satisfied more people.
>>281851108he kills everyone outside the islands and he marries historia and grabs the baby at the end which is his
>>281858855probably this
>>281851108I wanted all the world to die but a small amount of humans who survived in a closed off city somewhere
>>281851108Humanity total extinction of course
>>281855933>Eren explicitly says he wants to END King Fritz world (Eldian Empire)So maybe Eren actually wanted to erase the eldians from existence but at the same time he wanted his friends to live peaceful life and that's why he did this, so eldia gets destroyed in the future after his friends died
>>281851108Me having sex with mikasa!
Should have ended here with the next panel being all black
>>281851108A 6/10 ending would have still been a positive in my book, I would have looked back fondly on the series.We didn't get a 6/10 ending
>>281851108What I wanted was for it to never have left their island and stayed primitive, instead maybe they find another city with walls during an expedition but everyone is dead and several walls breached, they're investigating and eventually make it to the central area and sitting on a throne or something is a titan and it speaks just a few words like "w..what.. have we.. done" and then attacks, they kill it, and in it's hand was a flag with a symbol like wall Maria except it's not one from where they came from or where they're at implying there is another city with walls out there.They eventually find it and I dunno.. mutants or whatever are kidnapping humans and making them into titans and the city is called Titan so they go back to muster an army and attack, thus Attack On Titan.Something less convoluted than whatever shit we got.
>>281860686That’s just Shinsekai Yori, and it’s better than AoT in every way.
>>281856783>looking for peace in the end,Paradis got nuked after Armong died.
>>281858377I wanted him to not chicken out, then return to Paradise and die thinking he saved his people only for the epilogue to reveal that factions within Paradise started a new war against each other. Conflict won't ever end.
>>281856939The moment Lelouch gets exiled he has nothing on his mind but destroying his Father and his Empire. He kills him and then knocks his brother off to take over their Empire, just to have it get destroyed when he “dies”, succeeding in what he always wanted to do. He never wanted power, he just wanted his Father and everything he stood for utterly annihilatedEren discovers the truth of the world and realizes foreigners that hate them have been weaponizing Titans against them for years to keep them isolated and afraid. Eren decides to hate them back and weaponize the colossal Titans they have on the island to destroy the world for real this time. Except he doesn’t, it was all a ruse. Eren has no reason to go back on what he set out to do, unlike Lelouch who was always shitting all over his Father. There was literally nothing that should have changed Eren’s mind once he set out to destroy the world. Lelouch stuck to his principals until the very end even after he took over the Empire
>>281860686That sounds lame as shit
>>281851108Go all in on the rumbling.
Why even ask when you already know what the overwhelming majority of the fanbase wanted. Eren + Historia baby and for him to complete the rumbling and probably die. Instead we got Isayama cucking out in every possible way and giving us a half ass piece of shit ending.
>>281851108The cringevengers stop Eren from committing global genocide, thinking they can make peace with everyone. They're wrong, and the Paradisians get wiped out anyway.
One where Ymir (lesbian) was alive and happy with her girlfriend Krista.
>>281857051Profoundly retarded image, like you would expect from a /lit/ faggot
>>281860956thanks to the fucking retards like floch, so he won in the end. he wanted conflict, he got it
>>281858555>idea of people defending themselveswhat happened was beyong that tho>samefagginglmao you are a retard and a schizo>peace with the peoplethat were utterly defeated and looking to rebuild the planet, there was no point to keep being a retard butting heads, but oh well they were and got what they deserved, the tables turneddon't tell me youre the type of retard that thought it would be an utopia with no wars after everyone was killed? because if yes then you are even dumber lmao>more victim complexwhatever, go get fucked by a pajeet or paki that you agree with so much
>>281858825>OF COURSE I wanted a bad ending.... if by bad i mean my retarded ship that never had any ground to stand was fulfilled
>>281851108shit was hilarious including the sea of rewrittes and fan endings that were all fucking awful, including one made by a pajeet with horrible editsgoes to show that the "based" fans of the genocide were all brown retards
What is it about retards who watched SnK as their first anime thanks to Netflix that makes them so vehemently defend the dogshit ending we got? Its okay to admit they flubbed the ending H A R D
>>281861827>any groundMy ground is the fucking red herring Isayama put, about Eren asking about making a baby
>>281851108>"they threaten to exterminate my people, I won't let them have their way">*visibly furious when Frida says Eldians deserve to be slowly killed off*>"I will not leave the fate of Paradis subject to chance">*in his head* "Ill kill them all every last one">holy kino this character dev is peak>*turns page to 139*>jk I don't give a SHIT about Paradis I only care about my wholesome chungus friends who are trying to save the nazis so they can get killed by them later>ignore that I let Sasha and Hange die and endanger everyone else (everyone miraculously survived the battle of heaven and earth, somehow)>I was actually only going to kill 80%>why?>because they oppressed my people and killed my mo->wait that was me lol>guess I just wanted to see the red smear against the hot asphalt of billions of people gored by titan feet>why?>idk why I just had to I guess>anyways idk what happens after I die, ill leave the fate of Paradis up to chance I guess, goodluck armong>*gets cucked and dies*>scouts almost immediately fail and die>luckily yams has plot armor and Armong was able to make peace with the rest of the world on behalf of a government named after the guy that genocided 80% of the world (comedy writes itself)>jk like 70 years later they get blown to smithereens>but only just after his heroic friends happily died of old age (very convenient)>their kids though get consumed by explosive fire and have their screams silenced by falling rubble>why didn't eren do the euthanasia plan then? >erm because...uh...b-because...he just didn't okay!?>the endCouldn't write a worse ending if I tried.
>>281851108Unironically an alien attack.
>>281853127Wow. So simple yet Hackayama couldn't hack it.
>>281851108Eren killed everyone.The End
>>281862421The funniest part was when that 20% started repenting for attacking Paradis, that shit was so corny. If you catch a tormentor, they don’t react like that.
>>281851108It has been a while since I read it but it all went to shit after the rumbling. Can't tell you what I'd want at this point because I'd rather forget about it, but I can tell you how you could have made it infinitely better:>Focus remains on Erin after the rumbling>Motives and goals explained from his perspective>Cringevengers are still doing their thing in the background, without showing the absolute nonsense that is that storyline>Final showdown of humanity vs Erin>Cringevengers win>Everyone is unitedThat's the best I can do. Still sort of undermines all the setup but it's a bit better now. Not fixed by any means but it's something.
>>281851108The true genocide ending. I hate that he has to make Eren a silent hero in the end. Also his relationship with Mikasa is pretty cringe especially the scene where he wished happy birthday to Mikasa.
>>281851108isayama should've commited at reskinning mla instead of trying to make the next Schindler's List
>s3 part 2>basement has a device to kill titans>use that to kill the monke>wipe titans from the island>make mikasa die for melodramma points>eren marries historia>medetashi medetashi
AoTspics, tourists and hood-weebs got the ending they deserved
>>281851108It could never satisfy everyoneThe whole point of the cycle of revenges etc is that there would be a tragedy in the makingI have my issues (Annie just appears at a table munching food and the group just accepts that in a second without at the very least a bit of drama, Mikasa never gets to become a real character, holocaust parallel was TOO on the nose jesus christ) but the ending was to be expected, I imagined something along those lines would play out.
Eren with a manbun was the worst thing to ever happen cuz it led to a bunch of overly edgy losers calling him a chad who is always in the right and that GENOCIDE IS BASED ACTUALLY.Never have I seen a piece of media where a ton of people actively wish for omnicide all because a fucking moron who became fate's bitch and ultimately hated that humanity existed regardless just looked hot.
>>281858377>unhinged seething meltdown screaming at imaginary boogeymen>muh “self-inserting”When did this phrase go from a criticism of fanfiction to some reactionary buzzword for insane people
>>281858377I can tell you are either EM faggot or regular faggot that was seething at heckin ebin Nazi themes because nobody besides those 2 faggot types got the ending in their acceptable range.
Isayama should be shot for what he did
>>281851108Eren defeats the alliance, but spares Mikasa and Armin. Stranded, they're forced to get back to Paradis the long way.After the Rumbling is complete, the Colossal Titans collapse and fall down, rapidly renewing the Earth where their bodies land.Gabi is killed, but Falco survives. Powerless, he's last seen in a Survey Corps cloak with Gabi's rifle, making the long trek to Paradis (where he plans to shoot and kill Eren.)Eren is the father of Historia's child. They name the baby Ymir. The real Ymir, having destroyed most of the world, peacefully fades away ending the curse of the Titans.There will be problems in the future, but that's a problem for another day. Eren holds his daughter and tells her that she's free.THE END.
>>281851775I agreeIsrael did nothing wrong
>>281858377Kek, all the replies are from people that don't know this an old copy and paste, right?
