The anime ending was great and I'm tired of pretending it wasn't. Leaps and bounds better than the borderline Gunsmith Cats Burst ending we get in the manga where we just leave Chrona on the moon cause we're weak little bitches
>>282203892Chrona deserved it. He's the shonen manga equivalent of that guy who keeps saying he'll kick the drugs and then steals money and valuables from his friends to buy more junk. He can come down from the moon when he's done being a retard. That said I still I don't think either version had a great second half.
>>282203941Yeah but the anime at least doesn't remind you, all the fucking time, about Black Star. And I LIKE Black Star, but goddamn SHUT THE FUCK UP ABOUT BLACK STAR
Courage punch. So good, am I right nostalgiatards?
>>282203941>He
I wonder why people hate the second half. War on the moon was really great from what I remember. I did read it all in one go, so maybe it was the weekly releases? Anyone here care to explain?
>>282203892somehow they're on par of left-fieldness
>>282204275The "actually witches are good except those two assholes we spent a third each of the series fighting" thing felt tacked on. I assumed he wanted a moral point beyond "fight evil with magic shonen powers" and slapped that together. The attempted rape and Maka's indifference to it was really weird too.
>>282203892>we just leave Chrona on the moonI remember finishing SE back in the day and I have no recollection of this at all. I just remember Kid was a eldritch abomination or something and that's about it.
>>282203892
>>282203892Its retarded in the anime.Leaving Crona makes sense. They can't defeat an Old God so simply and Crona killed an entire city and was crazy as shit. You don't get redeemed so easily. Leaving Crona there is better
>>282203892Another problem with the anime is that Asura was extremely generic "crazy". The animators couldn't replicate Ohkubo's writing.
>>282203892Great, now I have Psychedelic Souljam looping in my head again.
Manga had the threesome ending thoughbeitver
>>282203892it was dogshit, you could tell that it wasn't part of the manga and you can pretty much always tell even with old fmahow? because it becomes utter trash and you start seeing asspulls come up way too often
>>282208935The manga was trash too
>>282208803Damn...
Soul Eater was pretty dogshit overall. Manga at least has Blackstar v Mifune and Death the Kid v Mosquito, which are cool. Everything past that arc isn't worth it, so in some ways I agree the anime wins out by just not fucking around and concluding.
>>282210572Nah. The moon war was great and the book of Eibon and Noah arc had good parts. Becoming generic and ending generic isn't a plus for the anime; besides the manga also ended so, that can't be a plus for just one side. But at least you recognized how great BS v Mifune and Kid v Mosquito was.
>>282203892Crona shouldve been left on the moon for being an insufferable faggot.
>>282203892Anything is better than endless Black Star wank
>>282203892Nah, making Asura a weak little bitch that dies to a single punch from Maka because of """courage"" is dogshit and I don't give a fuck what anyone says. He's an absolute menace who's so powerful that his sheer presence drowns the world in the madness, if it was that easy to beat him then Shinigami would have done it himself.And the truth is BS, Kid, and Maka were weak little bitches compared to Asura, because they were just a bunch of 13 year olds. But they had the ability to get strong enough to beat him in the future and free Crona.
>>282210935You're just biased. The focus was not on Black Star.
