[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/a/ - Anime & Manga


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: vegapunk-one-piece.jpg (399 KB, 1200x675)
399 KB
399 KB JPG
>can't invent a helicopter or plane, an invention that would change the One Piece world overnight
Also the effectiveness of guns is still inconsistent and just goofy
>>
>>282858838
>Also the effectiveness of guns is still inconsistent and just goofy
one piece used to be very lighthearted and goofy. stuff like this is only a problem now where the manga becomes edgier and more wannabe mature
>>
>>282858838
>mmhmm, so you see, if the author of one of the world's most popular and best-selling stories just followed my advice, he'd do so much better!
>Heh no I've never written anything, but if I had I'd obviously be the best
you have to go back
>>
>>282859037
>using you can't criticize x if you haven't made x yourself, the most debunked fallacy of all time, in 2025
Planned to come up with an insult for you but this is actually impressive
>>
>>282858838
You've gotta recognize that one piece technology and geography and such is subject to cartoon logic
In that light it's fine
>>
>>282859427
See your writing skills are so subpar you can't even think of an insult for anon despite how easy you claim it to be.
>>
The climate/weather is extremely unpredictable in the Grand Line. A plane or helicopter would likely crash pretty quickly. Not to mention the difficulties in navigation. Though I guess you could use log poses/eternal poses in an aircraft the same way you would in a ship.
>>
File: WE_News_HQ_in_Flight.png (984 KB, 997x888)
984 KB
984 KB PNG
The World Economic Journal HQ is literally an airship thoughever???
>>
>>282858838
The entire world map is fucking retarded
>DUDE EVERYTHING COOL HAPPENS IN THIS THIN EQUATORIAL STRIP
>>
File: 1710419446637567.jpg (215 KB, 883x800)
215 KB
215 KB JPG
>>282858838
>vegapunk can replicate lasers
>the whole world is still using flintlocks
>>
One Piece is genuinely 10+ years longer than it needed to be
>>
File: 1707013966838823.jpg (118 KB, 627x605)
118 KB
118 KB JPG
>oda writes a guy who can circle the earth 6 times in one second with his fucking lightspeed ability
>he spends all his time sitting around instead of finding Laughtale or murdering pirates

christ who wrote this
>>
>>282859732
just makes it weirder that none of that is mass produced
>>
>>282859852
Kizaru really makes no sense and that he never has to justify himself to the higher ups why he isn't using his ability more effectively. He should be able to kill everyone easily any time
>>
File: Yonji's_Raid_Suit.png (3.59 MB, 3246x2160)
3.59 MB
3.59 MB PNG
>>282858838
>can't invent a helicopter or plane, an invention that would change the One Piece world overnight
You should take into consideration that the government might be keeping a lid on certain things. For example, the capability for movies as entertainment exists but it doesn't.
Also, the Germa's Raid Suits grant a sort of self-propelled flight and they're not a member of the World Government.
>>
File: kizaru one piece.jpg (664 KB, 1572x2429)
664 KB
664 KB JPG
>>282859917
Doubt that's what Oda has in mind and he seems physically fit but the only explanation I have is that maybe his body is too brittle. Like the harder and faster you punch something the more damage you do but the more damage you also do to yourself.

But even then that's what Haki should be for, so no idea.
>>
>>282858838
when he made franky look like a rockem sockem robot
>>
haki, logia, awakening etc. all lack hard well explaiend rules and will probably never get them. luffy's rubber fruit suddenly being a god fruit but the marines letting him escape for so long anyway
>>
>>282859427
You can criticize whatever you want but nobody gives a shit. I'm explaining this for you as you seem to struggle with simple concepts like a comic strip for teens
>>
>>282858838
It's crazy how this should be Robin's arc but she is just invisible throughout all of Egghead. You notice it even more in the anime. The only way to excuse this is if the actually was doing something but we will only see it later in a flashback.
>>
>>282860126
kek
>>
>>282860085
Kizaru is retarded; oda confirmed. That's how powerful the pika pika is
>>
>>282860137
>haki, logia, awakening etc. all lack hard well explaiend rules and will probably never get them.
Sometimes the more something is explained, the less interesting it becomes & the less you wanted to know about it.
>>
Just in terms of writing qualtiy the whole "D" thing always feels clumsy to me when it's brought up. It's always portrayed like you inherit a name like a genetic physical trait or something. Yes I know it symbolizes a certain linage but we are talking about a name. Everyone can use the name "D" and everyone can just stop using the name D. Maybe Oda larped as a Nobunaga descendant and it snowballed into this.

Not too keen on the whole "chosen one" thing and more and more characters having legendary ancestors either. Sometimes less is more and you at least need good--very good--foreshadowing for drastic changes after 20 years. I've seen people argue that Sanji's new backstory was foreshadowed because he always had something aristocratic about him or something. Silly.
>>
>>282860404
We at least knew there had to be more to Sanji's backstory since we only got early on him as a kid working on a ship. Same with Nami. Bellemere found her so there's bound to be more there if Oda wants to go there. I don't think Oda planned the majority of the stuff that came later in the manga (maybe some had vague ideas early on) but in a medium serialized like manga is, people can be good or bad about making things up and having them fit (and fit retroactively in to seeming like they were foreshadowed), and for a long time Oda did it pretty well imo. I think the story has gotten away from him though at this point. There's the thing people sometimes bring up saying Oda is kind of condensing things and shifting things around, so that may be part of it, but he's also just getting older and 1100+ chapters is a lot to have to fit new content into if you want it to work.
>>
>>282858838
Has oil been discovered in the OP world?
Airplanes and helicopters are rather easy to invent but kinda pointless if you don't have a lightweight and readily available/replenishable energy source.
If petroleum is available I could see someone complaining that Vegapunk didn't invent gasoline, but to be honest I don't think it's such a huge oversight.
>>
>>282858954
>one piece used to be very lighthearted and goofy.
The ultimate eternal reminder of this. With all the astronomy stuff lately I wonder if Oda regrets it assuming he has no plans to bring him back which is sadly what it looks like
>>
>>282860480
>We at least knew there had to be more to Sanji's backstory since we only got early on him as a kid working on a ship
Yeah like I was an orphan and did kid things and then I ended up in my flashback. Not yeah I'm the son of One Piece mecha Hitler and kind of a cyborg.
>>
>>282859702
Helicopter, yes
Plane, no lmao
Planes travel above the clouds precisely so they couldn't care less about storms
>>
>>282860484
there are vehicles like smoker's motorcycle and vegapunk should be able to make an electric or steam based flying vehicle easily when he can make giant fighting robots and a futuristic city
>>
Is Loki still talking about how everyone simped for a chains moker while kids are being slaughtered?
>>
>>282859852
>>282859917
>and this guy will have the light fruit, that sounds cool
that's as far as oda's thought process goes, he doesn't care, he doesn't think

>>282860182
by now most if not everyone who follows one piece understands the only "character development" at this point within the strawhats is the monster trio increasing their strength. The long and tired cope of "this island will be [insert strawhat]'s arc!" is just the fanbase desperately pleading for oda to give the strawhats SOME development.
The fate of any strawhat, these days, that isn't the monster trio is to run around, do nothing, shout "ehhh!!? luffy gear 5??!" and stand around luffy's haki-sapped body, protecting him for some arbitrary amount of time to give the illusion that gear 5 has any consequence or drawback as if luffy won't just spring back up and reawaken gear 5 in a few chapters if not a few panels.
>>
>>282860728
>The fate of any strawhat, these days, that isn't the monster trio is to run around, do nothing, shout "ehhh!!? luffy gear 5??!"
Kek
>>
>>282859852
>>282859917
>>282860085
I figured that his lightspeed works realistically, it's just that he needs to slow down to handle the force and to see.
>>
>>282860851
>enemey is in front of me
>lightspeed into him
what's there to see
>>
>>282860490
Enel is the most special villain, only lost because of Pokemon logic and actually fulfilled his dream. Makes you wonder why Oda picked him of all villains
>>
>>282860895
Nothing, he's as fast as the light that's needed to see and he scared of the dark.
>>
File: croco bounty.jpg (206 KB, 830x1200)
206 KB
206 KB JPG
>>282858838
The bounty inflation. It doesn't even make sense and the manga being way longer than Oda initially envisioned isn't excusing it. Literally just don't give Luffy such a huge bounty increase every time he does something = crisis averted. Makes no sense for all those former warlords and other characters to have the tiny country they have relative to newer characters. Sure Luffy beating Crocodile didn't make sense either but you could argue it was just lightning in a bottle
>>
File: luffy eunuch one piece.png (648 KB, 1058x768)
648 KB
648 KB PNG
when oda castrated luffy off-panel 100 chapters in
>>
>five flying fruits
>>
>>282861010
Did Oda ever address this? So weird to limit yourself with such a precise number. Though desu it never bothered me too much and I just like to cope that Peru actually meant fruits that allow you to fly like an actual bird (are there 5 already?)
>>
File: Kaido.jpg (99 KB, 1080x1080)
99 KB
99 KB JPG
>>282858838
Everyone on Wano tolerating Yamato's troon retardation because Oda for some reason deemed it necessary to include a second troon character in the last 1/5 of Wano and then didn't have the balls to make characters realistically react to it because the current political climate.
>>
>>282860994
Luffy is just like Nami more
>>
>>282861057
>and then didn't have the balls to make characters realistically react to it
luffy almost did when they first met
>>
this thread confirms people either don't pay attention to a story for 12 year olds or are too dumb to understand a story for 12 year olds
>>
>>282858838
A lot of top tier characters forgoing devil fruits simply makes no sense, especially when they have a big crew that can always fish them out (and everyone should want to have a bunch of fishmen in their crew who specialize in that).
>>
>>282861165
How? Some are nitpicky but I mostly see legit points. Make an argument.
>>
>>282860994
luffy can only get hard with usopp stated by oda
>>
>>282860699
Yes
>>
File: piratechad.png (347 KB, 911x683)
347 KB
347 KB PNG
>>282858838
One Piece is a religious epic. One Piece has far surpassed the medium of manga and comic books. It has ventured into the realm of mythology.

One Piece is a masterpiece. No one in the modern age can write a story arc that takes place in a short amount of time with dozens of factions and characters at play, focusing on hundreds of plot points, building up a big climax while also delivering emotional payoff to every single one of those plot-points. There's not a single plot point that does not have a resolution in One Piece. It manages to do all of that while also tackling thought provoking themes and introducing characters that are infinitely more morally interesting than any other story that came before it. One Piece is the type of story you would see in ancient religious and fantasy epics like The Divine Comedy, Odyssey or Mahabharata that are hundreds of years old. No modern authors can replicate a story as masterful as One Piece.
>>
>>282861390
Didn't read. Didn't ask. Don't care. Die nigga
>>
>>282858838
It's still a better shounen to me than most. Anything conceived before the 90s has a bigger chance of not catering to otaku crowds and crybaby protagonists. Probably the best successor to DB. Every series since has been some downtrodden crybaby "pushing against his limits", with the same "rival" Sasuke/Bakugo sadistic characters to balance them out. Full of subtext borne out of the mangaka's school bully experiences. It's all so tiresome. Luffy and Goku don't have any of this stupid shit. I mean, they have rivals, but not in this unhealthy way.
>>
Everyone knowing CP9/CP0
>>
File: images(9).jpg (39 KB, 529x378)
39 KB
39 KB JPG
>>282858838
I love One Piece but it's nice to vent about aspects that aren't so great. I like the Dressrosa arc but Sugar's devil fruit is seriously poorly designed. It does way too much for one devil fruit it has instantaneous amnesia, eternal youth, soul control, loss of strength, instant transformation into a toy. Like wtf I just don't get the amnesia part of the fruit especially?
>>
File: animelaugh.jpg (28 KB, 255x195)
28 KB
28 KB JPG
>>282858838
You expected a coherent and sensible plot from One Piss?
>>
>>282858838
The fact that traveling is such a hassle but only for the strawhats, everyone else teleports around just fine
>>
>>282859824
so far lasers only have been used by relatively larger cyborgs, it's propably a big aperatus that doesn't fit into a gun that an average marine could carry around
>>
>>282859852
he's on "justice's" side and they don't do "unlawful" things
>>
>>282861563
CP0 doesn't seem to be a secret at all, they have distinct clothing and waltz around in public all the time
>>
>>282860981
maybe that was croc's very very first bounty and he immediately got a warlord invitation after that
>>
>>282859037
>>mmhmm, so you see, if the author of one of the world's most popular
you used to have editors keeping him from doing anything retarded, now they let him do whatever
>>
>>282858838
>I can suspend my disbelief at the notion of a man being made of rubber, phones being snails, a man fighting by holding a sword in his teeth, people slicing ships in half with a single swing from a mile away, giants existing, islands with a single seasonal ecosystem...
>but no choppas? No airplane? I-I just don't know anymore...
based Oda filtering midwits yet again
>>
>>282861437
>muh otaku le bad boogeyman
>one piece doesn't cater to otaku somehow
Kill yourself nigger parasite
>>
>>282858838
Anon did you even watch the show? Vegapunk doesn't want to build helicopters and planes, he wants to build nukes and the Internet.
>>
>>282861035
just from the top of my head, we have falcon, phoneix, albatross, pteranodon, pegasus, hornet, rhinoceros beetle, dragon.
and those are only the zoans, there are a bunch of paramecia and logia fruits that also let you fly
>>
>>282861973
>literal fucking androids
>but not the simplest of aircrafts
ok retard
>>
>>282858838
bad weather conditions for flying
>>
>>282859824
>be WG
>hire a scientist to invent lasers
>don't share them with the public
Seems rational to me
>>
D0Ul3es give me Total Oda Death
>>
>>282861974
>>one piece doesn't cater to otaku somehow
>Kill yourself nigger parasite
You sound like the kind of guy I'm talking about. Psychopathic dorks who get mad on a dime. No fun at all. One Piece is for happy people. lol
It doesn't have the bullied kid protagonist that otaku see themselves in. Or do much of the other typical shit. Luffy's pretty much oblivious to harems...if he has one at all. Just like Goku is oblivious.
>>
>>282858838
What would they power it with? We use Gasoline for those, which is refined from oil. Which we have none of in universe that I know of. Now, what they could have done at the very least is had electric engines, but those are not very efficient in use for flight and certainly wouldn't allow them to get from island to island. You have to remember that the One Piece planet is bigger then Earth and almost the size of Jupiter. This is why Vegapunk wants an unlimited energy source, so that people can easily get from island to island and not have to stop and refuel from anywhere.
>>
>>282861437
who is luffy rival i dropped it after 500 chapters?
>>282858838
when luffy beat croccodile with wet hands
>>
>>282862233
what powers stuff like pacifistas or law's submarine?
>>
>>282861973
>I can suspend my disbelief at the notion of a man being made of rubber, phones being snails, a man fighting by holding a sword in his teeth, people slicing ships in half with a single swing from a mile away, giants existing, islands with a single seasonal ecosystem...
no i cant thats why i keep saying its shit
>>
>>282861875
A lot of earlier characters have a low bounty though. Suspension of disbelief only goes so far
>>
>>282861973
>the what!? you expect some kind of inner consistency and basic logic which it clearly tries to have, even though there is this silly thing which x itself is clearly self aware of??? fallacy
>in 2025
110 IQ minimum for internet, now. I am tired of reading the same retarded debunked shit my entire life
>>
>>282862293
>who is luffy rival i dropped it after 500 chapters?
Koby lol..not really. He's been there from the start though. I guess Blackbeard. Nothing like a typical shonen rival though.
>>
>>282861980
Even if the government tried to force him and he said no (unlikely since he did worse things than build planes for them), Vegapunk isn't the only capable scientist, he just shows anything is possible
>>
File: one piece cast.jpg (321 KB, 958x1292)
321 KB
321 KB JPG
>>282858838
this
>>
>>282858838
seeing a map of the one piece world
>>
>>282862374
Not even the most sincere high budget live action could do one piece justice.
Maybe they knew that and decided to just not try at all.
>>
>>282862298
>Pacifista
Biofuel I assume, same way Vegapunk powered his clones by having York eat food for the rest of his bodies.
>Law's submarine
I don't think this was ever mentioned anywhere in the manga or by Oda or supplemental materials like the SBS, but it definitely runs on some kind of engine.
>>
>>282862298
Shit it could be cola. Welcome to Goofypiece
>>
>>282862293
>when luffy beat croccodile with wet hands
>to this day people believe there is some crazy secret surrounding crocodile because of what was said during impel down
i bet it was just shit writing to remind kids his weakness is water
>>
>>282862364
If One Piece was a modern shonen, Zoro would be his traditional rival.
>>
>>282862367
Oda is semi-realistic with his scientist characters and understands that research requires funds. Vegapunk needs WG bucks, Caesar needed Big Mom bucks, only Judge is a king and rich enough to fund his own shit, and he invested in cloning.
>>
>>282862424
he can absorb water from human body but weak against water lol
>>
>>282859880
there's a world government that's big on obscurantism
>>
>>282862374
they could've gotten an actual egyptian woman for vivi but no, we get the daughter of some indian producer
nojiko was funny because you can tell they begged oda to add at least one more nigger and he went "ok fine, you can do nami's adopted sister"
>>
>>282861437
>Luffy and Goku don't have any of this stupid shit. I mean, they have rivals, but not in this unhealthy way.
nigger, or should i say pajeet, goku and vegeta's rival relationship is so fucking dogshit that vegeta didn't have any issues to pretending to get brainwashed and murdering innocent civs so he could get a powerup and an excuse to beat up goku
it's not even a relic of old writing either, as early as resurrection F on super they take turns using freeza as a punching bag instead of actually teaming up and killing his ass, which ends up with earth being fucking destroyed and needing whis to bail them out
>>
>>282862198
Frankly this just comes off as projecting from bullied normalfags that grew up to be larping moralfags.
>>
>>282862633
There's no rivalry with Vegeta. It's completely one sided. Goku doesn't even give it a thought. It doesn't work like the anime I'm talking about at all. Goku is a based retard chad who never gives a fuck what's in his way.
Go back to /pol/.
>>
>>282862639
Wtf do morals have to do with anything? I have pity at best.
>>
>>282860404
Different kanji retard
>>
>>282862935
Please put your argument in an actual sentence.
>>
>>282861624
reminds me oda realized how useful mr 3's df is and just gave the same one to that blackbeard woman. shit like this makes me feel like i missed something in the story. bad coincidence blackbeard pirates are the ones that can steal fruits
>>
File: mr 3 giants.jpg (182 KB, 780x1200)
182 KB
182 KB JPG
>>282863396
*mr 2

but now that i mention mr 3, it's funny this absolute moronic fodder was able to overpower the giants that we are now 1000 chapters supposed to believe are tough warriors and that threw themselves at vice admirals and the ELDERS during egghead lol
>>
>>282858954
One piece is edgy as fuck what are you on about. Villains killing people in cold blood, torturing them in insane ways, plenty of rape and genocide
>>
>>282862374
no one care about nami's sister and she will maybe get a few crowd shots down the line. Vivi's casting is a disappointment though, a shame
>>
File: your one piece saar.jpg (320 KB, 1920x2160)
320 KB
320 KB JPG
>>282862374
The entire show is a tragedy, weird to say but the DEI castign is far from the biggest problem
>>
File: netflix piece.webm (2.87 MB, 1920x1080)
2.87 MB
2.87 MB WEBM
>>282863687
>>
>>282863521
>One piece is edgy as fuck what are you on about
Are you illiterate?
>used to be
Your "rape and genocide" is mostly newer arcs
>>
>>282863741
Rape is new but genocide was established quite early.
Actually, rape was also there from Sabaody
>>
>>282863429
>wax holds down a fucking giant
>perfectly fine
>rubber keeps being stretchy and bouncy when covered in Haki
>"IMPOSSIBRU! RUBBER SHOULDN'T DO THIS! THIS MUST BE A GOD GOD FRUIT!"
>>
>>282858838
>>282860484
this
it's highly possible that the natural ressources stock are completely different in OP's world. So if gaz and oil are extremely rare, and winds are stronger, flight and combustion are rally not that viable compared to good old sails

op is a fag
>>
>>282862633
>>282862666
HOLY /A/TARD THINK HE KNOWS EVERYTHING
GOKU TRAINED ON THE WAY TO NAMEK TO FIGHT BEJITA HE SPARED BEJITA BECAUSE HE LOST TO BEJITA AND WANTED DEFEAT HIM ON HIS ON
SUPER IS NOT CANON
AND YOU PROBABLY THINK GOKU AND ZFIGHTERS WANTINGS TO FIGHT STRONGER OPPONENTS IS NOT A REAL PLOT EITHER EVEN THOUGH THATS WHAT THEY'VE BEEN TRAINING FOR
HOLY FUCK ANIME TARD END YOURSELF ALREADY WATCHING ANIME DONT IMPROVE YOU ANYTHING AT ALL
>>
>>282858838
There is no logic or reason in one piece. The entire thing just runs on vibes and the non-existent standards of its low iq fanbase.
>>
I think the biggest problems of One PIece are the pacing and the characters. Too many unimportant characters that fuck up the pacing. A lot of plot points that go nowhere and that are uninteresting (Cf : Wano). This damaged Punk Hazard, Dressosa and Wano a lot and this is the reason as to why One Piece has been so bad post-ts. Elbaf is pretty cool though. And Egghead was ok, a good return to forms
>>
>yo these 4 niggas are so strong they are emperors of the sea and even the marines can't touch them
>why don't they go and get the one piece then?
>they just don't care lmao
>>
>>282861433
Woah Law you can't call him that just because he coated his whole body with haki
>>
>>282863741
Dude first chapter has a headshot, guy eaten by sea monster and an arm dismembered.

Arlong is implied to have killed more than just Bellemare.

The rape stuff does kick off a bit later.
>>
>>282861624
The ability is affected by the character's childhood hobby. It's the "Hobby Hobby Fruit", not "Toy Toy Fruit" like your images suggests.

- It turns victims into what you collected (Oda said if Luffy had the Hobby Hobby Fruit he would turn people into bugs).
- It gives you a childlike appearance because it's your childhood hobby.
- The control over transformed characters via a contract may be specific to Sugar turning them into toys, the idea may be based on how children playing with toys assign them personality and behaviour. Them losing strength is probably just "toy bodies are shitty".
- The amnesia aspect however, I guess that would even happen if Luffy had the ability? Everyone on earth forgets the transformed person and Luffy has a new bug for his collection now? There doesn't seem to be japanese wordplay or anything explaining this, it's probably one of the most extreme fruit effects.
>>
>>282862032
Wasn't queen close to frikken lazors as well? Franky figured it out from VPs old shit before he got nabbed by WG, so even before his contect with kizaru he was trying lazers. VPs an odd ball anyway, on one hand a large chunk of his science knowledge is crap he's read, and some of it is self invented, somehow he invented computing, robotics, cyborgs etc in isolation without his access to ancient history.
>>
>>282858838
i had no idea people took one piece seriously.
>>
>>282860677
VP keeps most his shit under wraps on his island(s) or they don't function outside them. Smoker IS the fuel for his bike. You really should question what the absolute fuck powers Laws sub more. Dude has a submarine, in a world where 99.99% have boats, but everyone knows what a sub is. What powers that mother fucker?
>>
>>282861057
What? She's a loon. Everyone who interacts with her thinks that on first contact. She's just a LARPer, that those around her get used to.
>>
>>282862318
Which other earlier character have bounties that are too low? Only ones I can think of are the warlords.
>>
>>282861985
There are balloons. And one aircraft that buggered off to the moon. Suppressed tech I'd say. The androids you mention are made by the one guy who can re-invent nuclear power, the other cyborgs we've seen are less advanced, at least for now. VPs satellites have more features than franky or queen.

Queen also seems to have more a bio-mech lean to his science, not seeing him be into astrophysics.
>>
>>282864577
Big Mom care. And Kaido did to a lesser extent. Whitebeard didn't give a fuck because he only wanted to sail freely and be a gay dad, Shanks is waiting for Muuuuuh fate.

Big mom simply lacked the access to the road poneglyph or the strength to crush her rivals. Kaido wanted a big army to crash the world and be done with it.
>>
>>282863429
>wax tanks Magellan’s venom
>wax tanks Sengoku’s punch
Mr. 3 is basically a shitter with an insanely OP ability. An admiral+ tier fighter with his fruit would be uncontested.
>>
>>282861624
Speaking of fruit designs, I absolutely hate the modern official designs of the actual fruits themselves where it's instantly obvious which fruit it is. The entire point was that the fruits were difficult to discern without an encyclopedia and their powers felt nearly random, like bananas turning you into a giraffe.
I'm 100% sure Oda didn't design them either, since the ones that actually appear in the story mostly follow the old pattern.
>>
>>282864934
Cut to the Gorosei talking about how it's not actually the wax wax fruit but the mythical goon goon fruit model: coomer that can defeat even the WG
>>
>>282859037
>>282859697
>>282860158
Any thread making wan piss niggers seethe like this is a good one
>>
>>282864971
>since the ones that actually appear in the story mostly follow the old pattern
remember the mera mera and its obvious flames on it. One piece became more and more a way to sell figures and goodies as time went on.
>>
>>282858838
>>can't invent a helicopter or plane, an invention that would change the One Piece world overnight
Imu would and the WG would kill anyone who started flying them dip shit. Stop trying to find flaws that aren't there. OP going into it's final saga is in a much better position then contemporaries like Naruto, Bleach, Demon Slayer and even HxH. Has chance to have a more fulfilling ending than FMA too. Cope nigger
>>
>>282858838
The weather on the Grand Line would make them crash. And the Calm Belt has a, uh, weird magnetic field or somesuch.
>>
>>282864566
>This damaged Punk Hazard, Dressosa and Wano a lot and this is the reason as to why One Piece has been so bad post-ts.
Wrong
>Doflamingo is a better villain than any pre timeskip villain
>Fishman Island has more lore and world building than any other arc
>Katakuri fight is better than any pre timeskip fight
>Gear 5 and it's reveals is more beloved than any Gear moment in pre timeskip and completes Luffy's character.
>>
>>282861390
I read. I asked. I care. Stay alive, anon.
>>
>>282859427
>muh heckin fallacies
>can't even muster an insult
wow I guess you really showed him
>>
Current summary
>>
>>282861985
>the smartest man on the planet can make androids in his exclusive island, but all the plebs in the rest of the world have to live like plebs because the world government shut it down
huh, so just like planet earth lmao, Imu confirmed for shapeshifting reptilian warmongering Hillary Clinton figure
>>
>wait 3 weeks for 5min of new contnet
god the anime stinks
>>
>>282860490
>Facebook
>India
>>
>>282858838
The complete lack of it?
One Piece setting was designed to avoid worldbuilding altogether
>just add a ndw island lol
That's where it's initial success comes from, can't fail worldbuilding if there's none
But then islands piled up and Oda decided he wants to wrap it up sometime in the future and that's when it went down the drain.
>>
>>282859852
He can't cross oceans, he can only move to a place he can see. He can move at the speed of light but he can't process the information and his reflexes are of a nornal human.
>>
OP is just a plagiarism of popeye physics and seatards.
>>
File: zolo-stairs.png (450 KB, 504x677)
450 KB
450 KB PNG
>>282858838
Stairs can kill a swordswoman stronger than Zolo
>>
>>282858838
>>can't invent a helicopter or plane, an invention that would change the One Piece world overnight
if you're going to complain about One Piece tech making no sense, how about just basic ship navigation tools like sextant. I pretty much wrote off the world making sense from the moment log poles got introduced as the only way to navigate the grand line.
>>
File: 1757329979790.png (1 MB, 1920x1080)
1 MB
1 MB PNG
>>282862374
>>282863701
Reminder: don't watch Netflixs adaptation, they're woke trash who hate fanservice and don't have the balls to sexualize female characters, they'll censor every Nami outfit, they'll censor every Robin outfit, they'll remove any and all lewd fanservice scenes, don't support woke trash or they'll keep making woke trash without female nudity nor female lewdness
>>
File: 1732670223085.jpg (94 KB, 639x726)
94 KB
94 KB JPG
>>282863687
>>
>>282860851
None of the logia powers is as powerful at the natural equivalent. Sakazuki isn't producing full scale volcanic eruptions, Enel doesn't create full power lightning bolts, Blackbeard doesn't create a supermassive black hole to devour the entire galaxy, etc. Kizaru is faster than anyone else, but he doesn't literally move at the speed of light.
>>
>>282858838
There’s two reasons that I can think of

1. The world government prevents the invention and use of aircraft’s since the whole point of the one piece world is limit freedom of easily crossing the seas

2. There isn’t an effective fuel source like oil in the one piece world. That is in till the mother flame was re invented by Vega punk,
>>
>>282858838
It felt more cohesive pre time skip, like everything else in One Piece, really. Post time skip is a circus.
>>
>>282862466
I think Law, Ace or Sabo would have been introduced earlier to fill that role.
>>
>>282868683
How? You can't even give a good example. It's just straight up bias and nostalgia making you say this. Many events and stories that started in pre timeskip now have conclusions or have further expositions in post timeskip.
>>
>>282858838
Flashback inception.
>>
>>282868851
>How?
Oda took a more "wild" direction post time skip, with less restrictions for basically everything, character designs, locations, devil fruit powers, character stories (I'm still mad about Sanji's new backstory), how some of these affect the plot (Sugar in Dressrosa), etc. Of course you can excuse it by saying "the New World is just like that" but it still feels off. Personally, the more simple aproach of pre time skip makes more sense overall. And fuck off with the nostalgia excuse.
>>
>>282858838
There's one super genius and maybe ten super geniuses. The distribution of intelligence is vastly different from the real world. Manufacturing at scale things Vegapunk invents is probably the bottleneck and even if he did invent a plane, the Gorosei wouldn't want the navy to use it in case it gets captured. The only innovation is in the form of special weapons that even the regular marines don't get to have. Everything is government approved and used for that purpose alone. The only reason they are now using Seraphim and so on is because the WG has been preparing for the old system to collapse, but the three power system of Marines, Shichibukai, and Yonko created stasis enough that they didn't to make the marines stronger. Now everything is in flux because the old Yonko sat on their asses and were good goys, but now the new Yonko are going wild, so they are letting tech move forward again.

You don't GET One Piece and what it's fundamentally about.
>>
>>282867730
Those abs look fake
>>
>>282863687
Who asked to see that? In the Fallout show there was a sex scene with a man and a woman and they did this as well. I get gay men exist, but they are a tiny minority. Do women really want to see sad dude butts that much?
>>
>>282858838
>>282862374
Kill yourself.
>>
>>282863687
Unironically the best character in the live action, it's like the writers tried to clown on him but he ended up being the most likeable character in the show.
>>
>>282866945
Jeets are the only people watching this garbage.
>>
>>282868851
>>282869318
It is interesting to see differences in opinion from people who got into One Piece either before or after the timeskip started.
>>
>>282870017
Everything wrong with One Piece started in pre-timeskip. Every single plot point set up in pre-TS resulted in Oda not being able to justify it. Haki? A solution to logia, which he mindless wrote in pre-TS. Void Century? Oda chewed off too much and now he has to live with it. Sichibukai? Fun little improvisation that Oda had to live through. One Piece being 1200 chapters? All because Oda wasted time in pre-TS.

Post-TS is not shit because Oda got worse. Post-TS is shit because Oda wrote pre-TS so terribly, he couldn't write himself out. Poor setup results in poor payoff.
>>
>>282870894
Such a poor critique
>>
>>282870894
>Oda wasted time in pre-TS.
But pre-TS arcs were short.
>>
I love how people attempt to say OP is bad but not matter where you look it's always rated amongst the highest of the anime/manga medium. For reference, contemporary shit like DBZ, Naruto, Bleach and even Demon Slayer don't have it's reception. I think if it were objectively bad/mid it would show in ratings. Like the others do.
>>
>>282870894
>Every single plot point set up in pre-TS resulted in Oda not being able to justify it.
it seems to me like there was no need to justify anything. everything was working just fine pre-TS.
>>
Loki action when?
Strawhat demon reversi when?
Sanji CoC-King reveal epic double spread when?
>>
>>282871081
It's because One Piece is so fucking huge. Thanks to its sheer number of arcs, there's always something that will appeal to somebody, even if the rest is crap.
>>
File: The Great Cleansing.png (346 KB, 800x371)
346 KB
346 KB PNG
>>282871081
Also, people are retards who don't understand that supposed inconsistencies are intentional government misinfo and we've already been told why the Yonko three powers system existed. It existed because the WG allowed it to, because it was convenient. Most "OP has a shit plot full of holes" attempts are based on head canons and the conflict between legends and what we're actually shown in flashbacks, in a series that's all about dreams and myth. What Roger's personality doesn't match my headcanon! That means Oda fucked up!
>>
>>282871463
Glad you brought up Roger because
>WG memoryholes all related to Joyboy and Void Century (also its own evil deeds)
>lets Roger speak to the crowd at his execution and tell them all to look for One Piece
And don't get me started on WG knowing about Luffy and his DF.
>>
>>282871291
Hopefully, ̶L̶o̶k̶i̶'̶s̶ H̶a̶r̶a̶l̶d̶'̶s̶ Rock's flashback ends soon̶
>>
>>282871593
The government can't magically stop all strong people blabbing. Why is that any harder to understand than existing governments being able to keep some secrets but failing to keep others?
Lots of people know of the Void Century as a concept, they just don't know what it is because no one dares research it. No one knows what the One Piece is, not only because of the WG but because the old guard seemingly don't want people to know either. Whitebeard seemed to reluctant to tell everything, and not just retroactively. That's pointing towards something. EVERYONE is waiting for Joyboy not just the WG.
>>
>>282871081
Dragon Ball stopped. Super doesn't stop. One Piece could never be Dragon Ball because Oda just doesn't have Toriyama's talent as a mangaka.
>>
>>282873267
Super doesn't count*
oops
>>
flying in a a machine is still subject to the weather of the Grand Line and would 99% crash
>>
>>282858838
Probably Haki. Not the idea of it but how it was introduced.
There were some crumbs already there to facilitate it being introduced like Kizaru being hit by Rayleigh and ARGUABLY stuff like Kyla no selling a direct hit to the chin from Sanji but I’m still not really buying it.
That and overall extremely poor power scaling that still makes me wonder how the world hasn’t either been taken over fully by the pirates or marines by now.
>>
>>282859852
Retard, they already established that it's impossible to find Laughtale without the Ponyglyphs.
>>
>>282858954
One Piece was edgy from chapter 1, retard.
It just mixed the edginess and goofiness well enough, like Luffy stealing a devil fruit and almost choking on it then saying it tastes like ass and three pages later one of Shanks’s guys shoots a guy in the head out of nowhere, or Zoro being fucking tortured, Naomi’s story and all that.
>>
>>282873499
planes fly above clouds to avoid shitty weather
>>
>>282861973
We got literal metal robots with advanced artificial intelligence walking around.
Planes unironically are a step tamer.
Wait don’t we already have bikes and cars?
>>
One Piece post-TS is one of the most overrated pieces of shit ever omg
>>
File: gimp.jpg (284 KB, 842x789)
284 KB
284 KB JPG
>>282859824
>>
File: one piece heist mask.png (119 KB, 636x568)
119 KB
119 KB PNG
>this thread
fine i'm dropping one piece. which shonen should i pick up instead? i ignored all of them because one piece was much better
>>
>>282864831
>Everyone who interacts with her thinks that on first contact
Weird that not a single character says it then
>>
>>282864865
>Only ones I can think of are the warlords.
So every big shot character whose bounty was revealed early.
>>
>>282863985
Floating in the room and being spelled out are two different things. The point is One Piece is obviously a lot darker now than back then

>>282864589
>Dude first chapter has a headshot, guy
Which was an anomaly in early One Piece and probably overall
>>
>>282860490
>>282866945
>>282869677
lmaooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
>>
File: super power of hair color.jpg (1.37 MB, 1193x1320)
1.37 MB
1.37 MB JPG
>>282873267
>Super doesn't stop
Sadly, though you are mentally retarded if you see Super as canon, especially now that Toriyama is dead and can't supervise it anymore
>>
>>282867730
are you telling me they made ace asian? wouldn't shock me even with the clearly white gold roger actor
>>
>>282876128
apparently they cast this fat beaner LOL
>>
>>282876157
If this is true I might drop One Piece as a whole. Oda letting anti-white Netflix rape his baby is just too much for me to hold in benevolent suspension. The cope was that he has an eagle eye on it but clearly he's stupid and already got contract-raped and has 0 power or he actually supports shit like this.
>>
>>282876231
You won't, you'll hang around letting this live rent free in your head. Maybe start posting that Alvida image too.
>>
>>282873267
Dragon Ball and Z do not get the same reviews and reception as One Piece does. This isn't subjective. It's objective.
>>
>>282876314
First, talking about "Dragon Ball" and "Z" rather than the manga shows you have no clue about the subject. The anime was always bad and perceived as such.
Second, Dragon Ball didn't come out at the same time as One Piece.
Third, and most importantly, "reception" is meaningless. One Piece will never be considered seriously like, say, Ghibli movies. That doesn't really say much about anything.
I don't need to refer to "critics" and "authorities" to tell you Oda sucks ass as a mangaka. I can open a One Piece volume.
>>
>>282876261
I will but I will also post about it, true.
>>
File: 1737624170195690.png (1.46 MB, 1066x1600)
1.46 MB
1.46 MB PNG
>>282863429
>was able to overpower the giants
It took a lot of scheming to drop Dorry via Mr. 5 explosives to the guts. Broggy also was breaking out of his wax cuffs until he also ate an explosion to the face and had to be further restrained. It just means that Mr. 3 and Mr. 5 were able to get the cheap shots in with powerful devil fruits.
>>
>>282871081
>contemporary shit like DBZ, Naruto, Bleach and even Demon Slayer don't have it's reception.

Counterpoint:
1) One Piece is the only one that is on-going. It had the advantage of being able too attract masses of third worlders and normalfag by filling the hole that was left by its competition who just want to jump on the hype train. I wonder if One Piece would have the same reputation or reception these days if it had ended in 2015.

2) Early One Piece was a great shounen, but it undoubtedly changed after the time skip and its not as good as it once was. Thus, people stick to One Piece because of how good the first parts were.
>>
>>282873267
>Super doesn't stop
It literally did, retard
>>
>>282878849
>>282873305



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.