I find it hilarious that something as obvious as this has to be spelt out to a certain fanbase
it is?
>gets genocided instead
>>283089244>GENOCIDE IS WRONG!!>but its okay when MY country gets genocided>im going to make no attempts to stop that>thoughts and prayers
>>283089274At least she would have the moral high ground until the end.
>>283089244Why is it obvious? It's not intuitive.
>>283089244>Killing is wrong>That means I will not kill the enemy that is trying to kill me despite not having any other way to stop them
>>283089244>Genocide is wrong unless its germanic white peepo goy
>>283089244Genocide IS wrong, but if you do it, you have to go through with it or otherwise the other side will genoicde you back, obviously.
>>283089244Didn't this bitch die in the dumbest, most unnecesary way possible? Obviously she won't care about figting back when she values her life so little.
>>283089244But it isn't. I want to eradicate all of humanity.
>>283089562Somehow thought stalling 100 colossal titans for an hour was a good idea. Somehow succeeded in stalling 100 colossal titans for an hour. Who knows why regular titans were ever a problem at all with her around
>>283089244Life is meaningless anyways, might as well answer to our base instincts, and they say genocide is good.
>>283089244The meme part is 80% of this certain fanbase are millenials who made their entire personality bitching about a specific genocide that happened almost 100 years ago. I guess they don't care about genocide only about that one in particular.
>>283089644Characters reach a new powerlevel every arc, it's called progress.
>>283090278>I guess they don't care about genocide only about that one in particular.What do you mean?
>genociding genociders is wrong
It's interesting the kind of replies these threads get.So much so, that it makes you think.Rather than come up with any counterarguments.All involved would rather meme and shitpost.Everyone's just showing their true apathy towards countless lives lost.Lives that had the potential to become something great, and even improve the world.
>>283090519Hange...
All the richest countries in the world were involved in genocide or caused mass death in the past century (including china if you count self-genocide). Genocide is good.
>>283090519>IMPROVE THE WORLD...! MY LAST MESSAGE...Oh you midwit you
and then 80% of the human population gets genocided and the guy responsible gets called the coolest guyand then the fanbase forgets any of that happen because 1. they're extremely retarded and 2. the author is extremely retarded
>>283090278Who gives a shit about them? The story presented itself rather bleak early on. The further it progressed the less bleak it became for better or worse. It was honestly completely fine until the start of the last arc. The retard can't write politics nor an impactful ending. I have to question whether or not he was drunk throughout the entirety of Marlyean arc.I liked that Eren was a fool till the very end, but not the execution. Everything else was garbage. Almost everyone was reduced intellectually to the level of a child. Genocide bad! Ancestral guilt good! It focused only on the ideological discussion, whike fucking it up left and right, instead of addressing valid points such as one's own survival or the possibility of an alternative. Normal humans don't act like that, like redditors. It's such a complicated situation I could write an essay about it. Of course the hack didn't even make use of the potential. It shouldn't have been a single arc, but "part 2" of the story which explores the everything from international politics to the horrible past which leaves everyone who experiences it so throughly traumatised they keep torturing an entire people, their own people, for generations.I was in favor of Eren's genocide because I knew what would ultimately happen in Paradise, infighting. It would have hit a lot harder to see everyone in the outside world killed before Elidians turned on themselves and essentially wiped out all of humanity.The avengers were fucking garbage.
>>283090986>because I knew what would ultimately happen in Paradise, infightingWhy? Just move to the now empty land and make a new Paradis.
>>283089244>CHUDCELCISM IS OK!
>>283090519The point is that paradis was pretty much into a “genocide or get genocided” situation, and their sole alternatives involved1) sacrifice the midget queen and attempt a low scale rumbling ,hoping it is enough for the world to not glass them all in the future (result, historia and her children are fucked, same for whoever inherit the AT, the CT and the beast titan)2)the same plan but Monkey man makes all you sterile so you will all die within that very generation , basically a gentle self-genocideEach solution is genuinely Horrible.It doesn’t make the genocide less awful on a moral ground, but it is still a situation where either you die or you get killed. And the story taking the most childish approach over it instead of being interesting and having the characters involved genuinelly challenged (like used to do in the past) was awful.All we got was Strawman over strawman with le evil Jeagerist and Eren ‘s whole character being reduced to “bhuu bhuu i just wanted to plow mikasa all along, see i was just an angry incel and my whole character arc during uprising arc and RTs was just a fakeout”
>>283090429No it's called poor writing
>>283089244if we are nature given sentience then anything we have to do to survive is natural and good including genocide
>we are the same
>>283089244Tell that Hamas, Israel and Americans
>>283091268I actively memory hole Ere'ns' entire speech at the end about loving(?) Mikasa out of nowhere and wanting her to stay single for at least(???) 10 years. OR was it all fake I don't remember lol. I was so cooked by the end I didn't even register anything he said as real.
>>283089244Rumbling wasn’t even genocide. That’s just war. Genocide is a single systemic attempt to eliminate a specific race, like what was being done TO the titan people.If Eren only wanted to rumble that one country across the sea. That’s genocide. But an act of war against offensive nations is not genocide even if those nations are destroyed by the war. There’s an obvious difference between the typical genocide of civilians (holocaust, pol pot, etc) and death from a large scale conflict that wasn’t targeting any specific group. AoT intentionally frames the rumbling as a genocide when it’s a defensive act of war because the whole point is that hange’s argument is wrong and it’s showing that people like her aren’t capable of making difficult decisions regarding war and survival.
>>283089290Is she a republican?
>>283095453Post nose.
>>283089244Not in the setting of SnK.
>>283090449Two wrongs make a right?
>>283097638Again, its not a matter or right and wrong. It is a matter of survival.The whole point of marley arc was eren not feeling any kind of revenge anymore against Reiner and the warriors because he realized how they were pretty much innocent children forced by circumstances , the same as him. And the cruel but sad part was how he was forced to act in a similar way and dirty his hands in the blood of innocent people because he was left with no other to protect paradis and his friends….at least until isayama went full retard from chapter 121 up to 139
>>283089244I hated how OOC Hange got in the final arc. Pre-timeskip she was a lot more pragmatic, and well I guess everyone was a lot smarter. Personally I feel like she got shoved into what should have been Armin's role and made a mouthpiece for dumb messaging, while Armin did absolutely jack shit until like the last 2 chapters because I guess the author didn't want to write a whole arc of his retardedly idealized outlook failing so it all gets dumped on Hange as the placeholder until Armin get gets made commander so he can "win" the final battle after Eren and Zeke commit suicide.And the irony is that a mass genocide *did* solve the island's problem and neither the characters nor the story presented any viable alternative. So what was even the fucking point.
>>283089244Don't write a scenario where it's genocide or be genocided
>>283099534This. Every other alternative completely failed, and I'm supposed to be surprised Eren resorted to the rumbling?
>>283089244>nooooo the based genocider was literally me!
Still can't believe he actually won...
