[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/a/ - Anime & Manga


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


I find it funny how people are still so traumatized by Naruto that any hint of "destiny" or "bloodline" in a series turns them away, no matter how unimportant it ends up being to the actual characters or story. As soon as a character is revealed to be part of a prophecy or related to someone important, this apparently erases all of their other character traits and relationships and becomes their entire personality (regardless of whether this revelation has any significant impact on the character's characterization or not).
>>
>>283466464
It doesn't even apply in Naruto's case. Naruto's destiny was to kill or be killed by Sasuke, and this destiny didn't come true proving that prophecy is bullshit
>>
>>283466464
Yeah people being granted powers from magical bloodlines and driven by destiny is ruining modern fic-
>>
>>283466748
The Naruto case has a lot more than just that one issue going on
>>
>>283466464
It reminds them that they're not special and are NPC's who will die unremembered and that's why they hate it with such a passion.
>>
>>283466464
I think Naruto in general is the reason why Shonen gets such a bad rep in America.
>>
>>283470256
Nonsense statement.
>>
ITT Shounenfags very slowly gain self-awareness, then reject it and return to fighting the same age old battle instead of trying new shows out.
>>
>>283466464
The genetically deformed members of the audience know that they will never be a powerful hero, and that power comes from the blood, and even if you cope by saying that athletes are genetically gifted physically but still have to work hard to bring out those gifts, you forget that the brain and motivation are governed by hormones, chemicals, and these are heavily influenced by your DNA too. Even though external factors matter, there's no escape from the influence of what cards you were dealt, and how these allow you to deal with external factors, especially at the limit where the best are milliseconds apart or a few kgs of weight ahead. You can see it in sports. You will NEVER be able to run like Usain Bolt and his genetically perfect centre of gravity that has been scientifically shown to give him an advantage even next to other runners.
Now take the seething against that reality, and put in the context of a shonen battle show that is constantly going on about freedom and hard work, while what we are shown reaffirms the fact that bloodlines and breeding matter. It doesn't matter if the anime is anti-racist or whatever, because on the individual level it's going to treat the characters as if they are carefully bred horses. That's the perfect recipe for nuclear level seething by mutants with scoliosis, lazy eye syndrome, and muscle dystonia born to impoverished inbred families.
>>
>>283471112
What a tragedy, I will never be the best ever!!!11 I should give up and never try.
>>
>>283471323
Well, it doesn't apply to normal people. We can at least try and then the results will be normal. Not elite but not deformed mutant either. A 3 foot 3 half fish mutant dwarf with asthma isn't going to feel happy seeing his hero handed things by destiny when he was only given pain.
>>
>>283471341
>A 3 foot 3 half fish mutant dwarf
Wtf are you talking about
>>
It depends entirely on how early it's established. Even back in the day, people bitched about YYH for randomly pulling it out nowhere in the last stretch. And that was BEFORE Naruto did.
>>
>>283471427
People who seethe about bloodline destiny in battle shonen.
>>
>>283471445
Hokuto no Ken did it in its second half with the Hokuto Souke stuff.
>>
Gon works case because everything around him is interesting.
Luffy was fine until the ass pull.
Naruto's situation was bullshit because of his mom.
>>
File: BL-IK_4_100339_MF1.png (381 KB, 1000x1000)
381 KB
381 KB PNG
i find it funnier that john bleach have 4 "bloodline" if i iirc correctly
>>
>>283466464
A do kinda agree that the chosen thing can work well sometimes (unironically look at Harry Potter, one of the flew things the Hag or her shadow writer did well), but Luffy case is utter shit.
Now , thanks to the nikka stuff:
>we got a beloved fruit and luffy’s creativity retconned, it was all merit of the god god fruit
>shifted from cool paramecha weird fruit to zoan, which were always the most boring type of fruits
>making it the most important fruit made defacto the most important fruits in the setting the god zoans one,which again were always the most boring one yet now they are the most important in the world to the point the old geezers and probably Imu have it too
>retconned the zoan awakening from cool mindless beasts into “actuashally they all turn into super sayans with funny clouds around” , confirmed with the 5 geezers and Lucci too
>Imu and the 5 Geezers sucks as villains and now the whole plot revolves around them, also the WG went full saturday morning cartoon villain tier without anything interesting left
>the whole god valley crap where now Rocks is Oden-tier wanking and sad backstory for Teach
>probably Teach’s fruit is a god zoan too
>now Oda can pull from his ass that secretly every single fruit is the god god fruit all along, so who cares?!
>the whole nikka stuff is just boring and Luffy could’ve done most of that shit with a simple awakening and just pointing out how creative he is…to the point it could’ve leat to “actually anyone has the potential to become Joyboy ,but it is so difficult you get one every 100+ years” and just explain how Imu culled all the rest over the centuries

It was just that bad and unnecessary, and is only bringing worse stuff than good stuff
>>
>>283471512
Wasn’t Raho the one destined to kill Kayo and Kenshiro just become the new chosen because he defeated him?
From what i recall, kenshiro just happened to be the blood related brother of Kayo’s adoptive brother, who later just happened to be adopted by Raho and Toki’s father alongside Yaji
>>
>>283471677
Ichigo is an odd case because, just like Yuji Itadori, he is a Ubermutt specifically breed and tutored from the bad guys (Aizen and Ywatch)to be that once they got the chance to make their super evil project.
From the day 1 he was a special entity and had shady stuff going on.
The truly bad part of Ichigo is how most of his powers are Asspulled either for a transformation or a slightly higher powerlevel (resulting to jobbing right at the next fight) or just Getsuga Tensho harder.
>>
>>283473276
The first three points are just you being mad at labels and categorisation. It didn't really change anything about the fruit itself. Not to mention that Luffy needed to be creative to use it regardless.

>retconned the zoan awakening from cool mindless beasts into “actuashally they all turn into super sayans with funny clouds around” , confirmed with the 5 geezers and Lucci too
It was never confirmed to turn you into a mindless beast. We only had the beast guards in Impel Down to base our understanding on awakening, which we still don't even know how they awakened their fruits. For all we know, they could've been failed government experiments.

>the whole god valley crap where now Rocks is Oden-tier wanking and sad backstory for Teach
He's been wanked as the most feared pirate in recent history already, what the fuck did you expect? And Oda likes to introduce characters with their horrible reputation first just to pivot to a way better depiction later.

You're just trying to find reasons to hate the manga after you decided to hate it.
>>
>>283470350
Go back to your doremi threads
>>
>>283474061
> Not to mention that Luffy needed to be creative to use it regardless.
Being creative because you are creative and realize the limitless potential of imagination =\= being creative because of my god god fruit.
One feels earned, the other is cheap
>the rest
I simply don’t like everything involving Imu and the Elders, simple as it. It was better when it was just the GW being shady assholes with some crappy nobles doing slavery and killings (but not island scale genocides) than turning it into the bullshit it is now.
And the whole final arc should’ve been a race between the Marines, Rufy’s fleat, blackbeard fleat and the revolutionary to reach Laughtale with Akainu and BB being the final villains instead of KAGUYAIMU



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.