F should have gotten a full show instead of Ninth Jedi
>>283467323I like F, its a shame we may never see her again.
>>283467392Isn't it made by a Jap animation studio?
>>283467392>made by anime studios>not anime
>>283467577Disney's committed to making zero good decisions with Star Wars kek
>>283467682>>283467696Nobody cares, western garbage isn't anime.
>>283467323The happy medium is to make the 9th Jedi, insert The Village Bride as an episode in the middle, and have F join the cast as another Jedi in exile who crosses paths with them and helps them on their journey.
The new 9th Jedi episode was fucking awful, why was the animation so bad? The girl bacame a 3D model halfway through for some reason, and the background art renders were also ugly
>>283467323>no sex scene >no watch
>>283467719>highest grossing star wars films are all thanks to Disney >Lucas a hack
>>283468322Inflation means that the movie gross always goes up over time. Its not physically possible for the movies that came out int he 70s and 80s to match the gross for today, for the same reason that they could afford a house then and you can not afford a house now. Money changed how much its worth in between the two.
>>283468003I guess that might work
>>283468003>>283468649Doesn't work. F is a Clone Wars survivor, and 9th Jedi takes place in a far future
>>283468753Nothing in the Village Bride *requires* F to be a clone war survivor specifically. She's just a Jedi in exile, and after the clone wars is when that happens in canon. But given that The 9th Jedi takes place in a nearly identical situation for the Jedi, you can swap her in without needing to change anything. We're talking one line of dialog at most difference.
F my beloved
>>283468817the empire is in the new episode and we know ninth jedi is somewhere post tros cause of the interview from vol 1
>>283469450The fact that the F episodes try to fit into the movie timeline was odd since I thought Visions was supposed to be its own separate thing.
>>283468354>muh inflation Movie ticket prices haven't changed that much. The world spoke with their wallets and all agreed disney wars was better than Lucas slop
F was a lot more mechanical than I was expecting.
Sucks that they gave her a love interest
>>283469888I mean he existed and they talked but I wouldn't rush to anything drastic
>>283467323I'd rather see a comic or maybe a novel. I don't know how the Ronin's were but generally I think something that the higher ups might not be so focused on would be the best.
hate that ugly ass and unexpressive bitch she was the worst thing about the first season
>>283471071and your hatred is why they keep making more of her
>>283471071I love this beautiful quietly stoic cutieShe was t he best thing about the first season
>>283469640average movie prices are about $10 now. in the 70s they were about $2. which you can confirm with a quick google search. also star was is more universally popular now whereas in the 70s it was considered more of a nerdy thing. and even normies agree that the original trilogy was better as you can confirm on IMDB or rottentomatoes. I can't fathom why a person on /a/ would be defending them unless you're a paid shill.
>>283471348the value of 2 dollars today is not what it was in the 70s
>>283471506Isn't that what he just said?
>>283471690No.
I really liked the music in this episode.
>>283467323F is my wife.
Pumping F then dumping her to become a Sith Lord.
Star Wars is one of those franchises where people, whether they're for or against it, are schizo-level delusional about.
>>283471690>wronghole.png
>>283467323I would watch an F show. More Star Wars anime should be a thing. Retards forget that Howl's Moving Castle, one of the most iconic anime movies was based on a British novel.
>>283474423kek.
>>283467765every single anime and manga wouldn't exist without western influenceanime was born out of a westaboo's admiration and imitation of disney first and foremost and manga wouldn't exist without western comicsalso all of this wouldn't exist if japan never lost ww2 so nips should be thankful they got their ass bombed so bad then occupied for so longso keep your mouth shut faggot, the only you have anime and manga in the first place is because the japs got their ass handed to them by the west not once but twice
>>283467323Apperently The Duel is the one getting a full show next. I hope the book isn't canon since the writer decided to make The Ronin a fag for the lols.
Who would /a/ rather have sex with, F or Kara?
>>283475076F.
This is the only Visions thread I've been in without retarded schizo-posting.
>>283474780Really? Those episodes are fine, but the artstyle gets old fast. It would look better in color
>>283475260I thought they were fun as well. The writer going full ham on her obsession with alphabet people was weird, though, so I hope the book isn't canon to the possible upcoming show.
>>283469888yurifags BTFO
>>283475399Did yurifags even like F in the first place?
ive only watched the first two episodes so far but duel part 2 was goodused all the very obvious stock sounds from across the movies that I liked and it completely ignored that dumb tie in novel some woman shat out as a "sequel"
All I remember were the astro boy episode, the trigger one about the sisters, and the furry one
>>283476334V3 was pretty fun, not as good as V1 but much better than whatever the fuck V2 was.
>>283476416>sistersYou mean The Twins? One was a dude.
My favourites were The Twins and The Ninth Jedi.
>>283476334I hope the shitty book isn't considered canon if The Duel gets a full series.
>>283476508there were some parts of it that i liked but overall i'm glad the japs are ignoring it
>>283476552The Sith Wars were cool, but same, I'm glad the Japs disregard it.
>>283471348There's a dedicated base of retards who have twisted themselves into knots trying to tell themselves that Disney Wars wasn't a colossal mistake and it's still as good as the franchise always was.
>>283476483Those were everyone's favorites. Don't worry, it just means you're a normal human being.
>>283476812I'm glad The Ninth Jedi's getting a full series. The Twins deserves a movie.
>>283476483>>283476812>>283476861Twins was the worst episode of all seasons. It felt like a parody of Star Wars and also a parody of anime, only it wasn't even funny in the way parodies are supposed to be. Also, the animation and artstyle were garbage. Fuck Trigger
>Second episode>Ethan still confirmed for turbojobber
Kinema Citrus x Penkin never misses
>>283468280The B team worked on it instead of the original team, which is making the TV show, maybe.gave me GitS 2 innocence looks and I'm not entirely sure why
>>283469638The shorts aren't beholden to Canon, but plenty of the creative teams seemed okay with trying to keep their shorts as close to canon as possible. The Eldar and The Smuggler could very easily be canon with very little changes
>>283474464The book and film are pretty different from each other
Funny how this season has more Clone Wars era references than the last one, while the sequel trilogy era keeps being ignored by everyone
>>283480814weren't there some duckfaced stormtrooper helmets in the duel episode
>>283480914Yeah, but the Dual is a Chambara with some altered Star Wars props
>>283480960>b-butso it hasn't been completely ignored then.
>>283481008I think there's a difference between reusing some items from that period vs having a Short take place during that era of the series.
Why are 90% of the protags female?
>>283482670Disney mandate
nice reference
There really is no interest at all in this new season.Star Wars is definitely dead
>>283468322Highest grossing doesn't equate to cultural relevance or brand growth, Disney nearly killed interest in Star Wars that doesn't come from someone else now
Ronin getting sith pussy. Kino.
>>283484211I don't know that I'd say there's NO interest but the hype seems to not have the same buzz. I blame season 2 being a dud. Which is a shame because this was a huge improvement
>>283486479I don't think it was even an issue of quality since Season two did have decent episodes, but the Internet overall doesn't care about non-Japanese Animation.
>>283486582If that was the case, then how are there enough financially viable non-Japanese studios to produce all of those episodes?
>>283486479Nah, it's not just season 2 being a dud. Star Wars in general hemorrhaged virtually all of its enthusiasm over the past few years. No movies (not that it really would've helped), the cartoons squandered all their potential, virtually every show after Mandalorian Season 1 sucked ass, no good video games in 10+ years. Even if you really liked Andor, it was a flash in the pan that was never going to lead to anything bigger.Disney bought a cultural touchstone just so that they could slowly demolish it piece by piece through incompetence and malice.
>>283486947Fan response does not equal the financial success of a product.So you can get DC animated films, which are a financial success but outside of a niche fanbase don't generate much interest.
>>283486972>no good video games in 10+ years.Fallen Order was okay. But yeah saw what you want about the PT era at least we were still getting a lot of good side material. Honestly though I want to blame a lot of this on the game industry and its own list of fuck up issues. It takes too long and too much money to make a game these days so even when they do put something out that's half decent it takes ages. Then there was that whole loot box controversy with the new Battlefronts.
>>283484211>>283486479Season 2 just felt so fucking whatever compared to all the season 1 stories. They should've continued them in season 2 instead of waiting until s3.
>>283487100At least the more overtly series bait ones. I'm surprised the rabbit didn't get a follow up, though they probably saved that for season 4.
I did not like the Duel or the Ronin. I think they were style over substance Kurosawa bait.
>>283487082The Cal Cestis games were okay, but he really is a poor man's Kyle Katarn. The fact that we haven't had another serious KOTOR-like RPG in the 20 fucking years since KOTOR is one of the biggest missed opportunities in history.
>>283488057Didn't they announce a KOTOR remake a while back? I had a bit of fun with the MMO but it really feels like a new RPG is long over due and I don't know why they're dragging their feet.
>>283468322based retard
I thought this was Ahsoka for a moment
>>283476464Oh shit, my memory is so bad
>>283488086It got canned due to the Devs being rubbish
>>283484821>more people interested in paying for something doesnt correlate to growth ok,, reddit
>>283489215Probably for the best
>>283489295>70s movie was a cultural touchstone that to this day is beloved >Other films were mired in controversy at best and have been forgotten entirely by the people who claimed to like them R-tard
>>283487994I miss bunny jedi. And it looked good. F's episode did not look as good as the first one. They also tried to do a similar OST, but it really didn't hit the same.
I enjoyed Trigger's and the one in OP pic. Ninth Jedi was meh with he shitty change in art
>>283486972>virtually every show after Mandalorian Season 1 sucked assIt definitely doesn't help that every show is just a setup for another show.
>>283491066Was the lead's VA in the Trigger episode really bad?
>>283467765You guys were having threads about a redhaired Canadian a few weeks ago, get over it.
>>283482670Girls are cute when they're anime.
No love for the bounty hunter with exposed tummy?
>>283491545too flat
I just watched them all and how is nobody in here talking about Black? It's buck fucking wild, it's human instrumentality happening as the death star explodes to jazz music.
>>283491768Because we had threads and talked about already, it was a well animated trippy videoclip but it doesn't have anything else to be discussed besides that.
>>283467323It seems Disney is planning a bunch of series for visions episodes. The Ninth Jedi is the only confirmed one so far, but it's most likely a test run
>>283491837as long as it does well, hopefully they will learn the lesson of only having inhouse animation and how bad of a choice that is.maybe they even learned a lesson from giving the game license to EA only for a whole fucking decade, too.
>>283491768What's there to say about Black? It looked nice and it was really artsy but it wasn't much of a story or character.
>>283491768It's to Arthouse for most people watchers/ Star Wars YouTubers who all generally love generic slop
>>283491768It was cool but I was put off by how much they kept shoving that guy's ugly face in front of the camera. It's like the anime equivalent of the singing aliens added to Jabba's palace in the special editions.
>>283468003>9th Jediwould be genuinely great start for a sequel trilogy. But make margrave Luke as a plot twist.
>>283484211Star Wars peaked during clone wars. Anything outside that is mediocre at best.
mating press F
>>283469450>ninth jedi is somewhere post trosI actually had no idea but that explains a lot about the events of both episodes.
>>283477383I thought the art style was fine but the plot was pretty fucking stupid.
>>283483088This episode was interesting. The pacing could’ve been better but I didn’t dislike it.
>>283488965Are you saying Togruta>arr rook same
>>283494706Pacing is kind of an issue with all of these. I think they could do fine but you can see where more time to breath would help things.
>>283494995Naturally. They're trying to fit 2 or 3 episodes of content into 22 minutes.
>>283491343It was Snood's first VA role.
Dub F has a bit of a lisp
>>283467765Are you forgetting that Star Wars itself was inspired by a bunch of Jap films like The Hidden Castle?
>>283494216I'm assuming you mean the good one from 2003
>>283496879Hidden Fortress, sir.
>>283468322> Lucas spent like 1 million dollars and made back almost 19 billion> Disney spent 4 billion and still hasn't made it back
>>283496879Or that the word "Jedi" is inspired by "Jidai" or that Darth Vader's design was inspired by Samurai armour or that Toshiro Mifune was George Lucas' first choice to play Obi-Wan Kenobi.
Sex with F.
>>283496965Both. I'm not gonna deny Disney didn't try to fuck over clone wars as much as it could, but the good still outweighs all the bad from CGI clone wars.
>Visions thread>no mention of the furry???
>>283499752>>283499951She's been mentioned several times you illiterate furfag retard. Good fucking god I'm glad you weren't included this time because you were a monumental nuisance.
>>283467323Why was her master male with that design? Threw me off completely along with his random ass resurrection.For a show, not really possible now with how they fucked up her second episode. I can see F appearing as a cameo in a third Cal Kestis game if she made her way to Tanalorr as part of the Hidden Path.
>>283500454His voice in the dub was really weird with that design, too.
>>283492052They are definitely being less dumb than Netflix, who had Love Death and Robots, but never thought about making full series for its most popular episodes
>>283500508Reminded me of Robert Belgrade voicing Alucard in the original Castlevania: Symphony of the Night.
>>283500454GRIFFIIIIIIIIIIIIIIITH!!
>>283500454>>283500723What was with the holographic room? Has that been a thing in this franchise before now?
>>283496759She's from space Japan
>>283501076The word Jedi is a derivative of Jedaigeki
>>283467323I'm a Soi Wars casual but I feel like the franchise as a whole needs a 3rd major faction next to the Sith and Jedi in terms of the Force and philosophy, like a buddhist warrior middle path or something
>>283476812Am is my wife.
>>283501179grey jedi have been a thing in the EU for agesthe issue is that the jedi are, on paper, supposed to be the middle path, while the sith walk the paths of excess. but, in practice, the jedi are written more like paladins who see The Force as less like The Dao and more like an omnipresent deitylike you god anakin being a chosen one supposed to bring balance to the force, which communicates that there was an unbalance. but according to georgie lucas, the imbalance is there being any sith at all, because they use the force the wrong way or something
>>283501288In the Fate of the Jedi novels, Luke and his son Ben encounter a sect of Force users that see the Force as a rainbow, but then they realise that there is only light and dark and people using grey to justify tapping into the dark are only walking towards their own destruction. It's Legends, though, so I'm not sure if it's still like that in canon.
Was it really necessary for prince to have those dick sucking lips?
Who is the best Visions girl?
>>283500818>What was with the holographic room?Coolness >Has that been a thing in this franchise before now?I don't know, but Star Wars is famous for introducing new shit out of the blue and Visions did a lot of cool stuff thanks to that
>>283501404You're just baiting Lopniggers and F-aggots to post fanart, aren't you?
>>283501427More towards Karafags, but i wouldn't mind either way.
>>283501438Understandable, Kara a cute
>>283501450I wish she got more fanart, maybe when her show comes out.
>>283501179>I'm a Soi Wars casual but I feel like the franchise as a whole needs a 3rd major faction next to the Sith and Jedi in terms of the Force and philosophy, like a buddhist warrior middle path or somethingThat's what the Jedi were though..I mean, their ideals were. Not necessarily in practice all the time. And what the original movies were trying to bring back until it was bought out by Slavers.
>>283501483>>283501179George says jedi = balance and muh grey jedi = balance is fanfiction even if it's cooler.Luke's New Jedi Order was light side but less dogmatic and inflexible compared to the original Jedi Order, and it (ok, usually) worked out.
>>283501581Why did someone take a photo of a tumblr post instead of just screencapping it
>>283499323The more you learn about Japanese and Western culture after 1863, the less East vs. West faggotry makes sense.
>>283501635Yeah, pretty much.
>>283501581I remember Freddie Prinze Jr.'s rant about that since he said he learned a lot about Star Wars form George Lucas and Dave Filoni and that newer Star Wars fans were like shounenfags with their obsession with training and powerlevels.
>>283476861the twins got the atmosphere, plot, comedy and characters 100% right, while also cranking the anime lever to 11it was gloriousthe droid being the only one to use a space suit still cracks me up
>>283501698Same, The Twins felt the most Star Wars and simultaneously anime out of all the shorts. Also, it being set after TROS was really great since Star Wars has the problem of setting literally everything between ROTS and ANH.
>>283501698What fags call cringe, chads call soul.
>hate star shit>loved visionsI never thought the setting could be cool, what a waste. I checked Season 2 real quick and couldn't believe how inferior it was to Seasons 1 and 3, the only decentish episode was also the only Japanese one. You could probably make 10 good animes casually off this alone and put out a 300m dollar revenue anime movie costing 5 million to make every 3 years. It's like a gold mine, it's still unbelievable how the IP is unfiltered shit outside of Visions. All it would take is a mediocre amount of effort to salvage the franchise, what a waste.
>>283501848If it makes you feel better, everyone at Lucasfilm are massive weebs and are planning to make more Visions anime since The Ninth Jedi's getting a full series. Also, the only good short in V2 was probably the Korean one only because it felt more like a V1 short. The actual Japanese short of V2 about the nigs kinda sucks.
>>283488086>>283489215>>283490366They got new devs for it and say it's in active development. I hope it's treated as its own canon, though since there will most likely be fag options.
>>283501427Yes. Post sexy bnuuy!
>>283467323>Star Wars: :(>Star Wars (Japan): :)
>>283502051Who knew giving the IP to the country that inspired it would work?
>>283501848I liked the stop motion in V2
>>283501848>the only decentish episode was also the only Japanese one.You liked the blatant BLM propaganda episode that had bad animation?
>>283467323The only people still watching Star Wars in 2025 are autistic hatewatchers. Normies don't even remember what star wars is anymore.
>>283502118I'll give him benefit of the doubt and assume he thinks the Korean one is Japanese.
>>283502118>anti-imperialism propaganda bad>in star wars, where the rebels were explicitly based on the vietcong
>>283501581Lucas seems to treat the force less like a Yin-Yang duality and more like a God vs Anti-God concept that you see in Gnosticism or Zoroastrianism
>>283502129Nah, normies still give a shit, I'll see conventions filling up and lots of cosplayers on Halloween and stuff, also everyone, even the autists have teamed up to try to get Disney to make the Kylo Ren movie, even renting a billboard, hiring a plane and protesting in front of Disney's HQ. Shit's wild.
>>283502164Other Season 2 shorts did the anti-imperialism message better and were less obvious about what real-life events they were referencing
>>283502193Kids in general give less of a shit about old franchises since they're glued to influencers and gacha games.
>>283502211>and were less obvious about what real-life events they were referencingNot at all
>>283502211Not V2, but Lop and Ocho did a good job at that.
>>283502223They were, or if they were exceptionally blatant, like the French-made episode, they made sense within the Star Wars Universe, which the D'Art Shtajio-created episode did not.
>>283502286I didn't like V2 that much to be honest, Hell, even the Japanese studio they chose was western-adjacent. Journey to the Dark Head was fun, though.
>>283502286>they made sense within the Star Wars Universethe Empire has always been characterized as pro-human at the expense of other species
>>283502543>even the Japanese studio they chose was western-adjacent.I'm pretty sure it was created just to make music videos for American Rappers, and the Visions short was their biggest project at that time.>Journey to the Dark Head was funyeah, that was a decent episode.>>283502577I'm pretty sure all the slaves in the Pit episode were Humans, and all the civilians living in the city were aliens, so in that episode it's the reverse of what normally occurs in Star Wars.
>>283502543Screecher's Reach was the best one of seasons 2 and even better then some of seasons 1 episodes.
>>283502577Star Wars films have always reflected the political climate of their time, except the sequels, the sequels were politically neutered and they suffered for it. Nothing remotely interesting was happening in the mid 2010s (save for the 2016 elections) whereas now we have several wars and political conflicts, maybe if the sequels were written now they'd have some sort of edge to them.>>283502617Yeah, it's why I didn't like The Pit very much. I liked Journey to the Dark Head because it felt the most anime out of all the V2 shorts.
>>283502635Yeah, Screecher's Reach was probably my second favourite in V2 after Journey to the Dark Head.
>>283502543>Journey to the Dark Head was fun, though.Plus there was a potential mantle x girl ship, which is always good
>>283502713Interesting.
>>283502645>Nothing remotely interesting was happening in the mid 2010sDo you only get your news through the murdoch media empire? the sequels were neutered, yeah, but there was shitloads of conflicts and political controversies in the 2010's.
>>283477383The Twins was fine when you remember that a) The episodes don't have to try to follow canon and are just Star Wars inspired and b) Trigger made a more On Theme episode in the same season. They followed the assignment then included themselves triggering all over everything for a laugh.
>>283502763A shame J.J Abrams wasn't like George Lucas and didn't take advantage of them, he was just safe Hollywood guy.
>>283502799That's why he was picked to do the first new film at Disney
>>283502813A lot of people like to say Rian Johnson was political, but again, his "politics" were very surface level, such as arms dealers and animal cruelty.
>>283502799yeahwhedon is a hack but at least he wasn't neutered and tried to focus on the neo nazi as a power fantasy for losers thing with Kyle
>>283502827People were weird about TLJ, it doesn't even matter if it sucked or not, people were just being reactionary faggots.>>283502838Pretty much.
>>283467323Star Wars is an anime now??
>>283502910Yeah but we're not getting a weekly anime until sometime next year.There are also some Manga but I've not read those
>V3Visions only has two seasons.>B-but anon I...Visions only has two seasons.
>>283502935the luke manga was pretty good from the bits I saw when it was being storytimed
>>283467323Nah. She's cool, her fights are good, and I rather like the idea of carbonite grenades.They did a good job giving us a new story from a character whose initial short wasn't anything special and didn't leave any hanging threads to follow.Ninth Jedi really was the obvious choice though, and if they were going to pick anything else after that it really should have been Lop and Ocho.
>>283503012A S2 defender? Here? Fascinating.Which short from S2 would you pick for a follow up, and why is it obviously Aau's Song?
>>283503175Season 2 of Starwars Visions, the Japanese anime anthology, released on October 29th, 2025? I haven't actually watched it yet.
>>283503175You read it completely wrong - there's only two japan-made seasons and nothing else/
>>283502874It's basically impossible to legitimately complain about anything new now. A big chunk of people will say something sucks because of "politics", another group of people will get caught up in telling that first group to shut up, and all of that nonsense will drown out the real complaints talking about the actual reasons the thing sucks.The same phenomenon makes it difficult to praise anything good too.
It's dumb but I never liked how Star Wars in general handled lightsabers, a fencing style would make the most sense buy instead everyone whirls them around inefficiently
>>283476861>I'm glad The Ninth Jedi's getting a full serieswhy do people like ninth jedi so much? from what I remember it was all setup and no resolutiondid you actually like what was shown, or just what was promised?
>>283503230knifes
>>283503303I think a lot of people just liked the twist in the episode
>>283503303"We're not jedi, lol" scene was pretty cool
>>283503303It was cool and the one that felt the most "Star Wars" of the season. Hell, it felt more Star Wars than the whole sequel trilogy
>>283503457Being set in the far future also makes it so you can just pretend it is actually canon and nothing of what happened in the movies has any bearing on it because of that
>>283503303sith acolyte jobbers getting cut down was straight out of the Jedi Outcast/Academy games
>>283503608Yeah, the sequels do have a rather large impact on all the Disney+ shows since it makes much of their conflict completely pointless
>>283503224Exactly, hate things, you're a chud, love things, you're a shill. There's no winning.
>>283503303It's set in the most interesting and unexplored time in the timeline, the far future.
>>283503224I was on /co/ and /b/ at the time of TLJ's premiere and you'd be surprised by how many people were hyped and ended up enjoying it, it's only when influencers came out of the woodwork with their political takes that things became the way that they were. Whether TLJ sucks or not isn't even relevant anymore, there was this weird subculture it spawned.
>>283503303had some neat vehicle designs
>>2835039272017 was just after 2016, so I wouldn't be surprised if both ends of the reactionary spectrum was some kind of psy-op.
>>283503987Exactly, I get hating the movie, it was pretty weird, but everything was so fucking hyperbolic.
>>283467323Ngl it was kinda weak, Season 1 was way better.>ep 1Very good, but inferior to the previous season. Sith girl was unfiltered sexo. The villain was really nice. Best of the season off the bat.>ep 2 Sloppy slop slop slop. Didn't give a shit.>ep 3Okaish, I don't really care enough to see a series out of this. >ep 4Okay but nothing crazy. Flat tummy tomboy on screen helps it out.>ep 5Good, I'm glad it didn't take a darker turn. Enjoyed it fairly enough.>ep 6F is my wife but the final fight was so short it felt hollow. Still second best if the season. Loved the use if colors in this one. This is the one I wish had a series instead.>ep 7Another trigger mixed bag. The old lady retainer was cool, and it had some nice moments. How they made a tomboy I didn't like baffles me. The prince is a character I've seen a billion times over.>ep 8Complete ass. You think it's going somewhere and it's just the most tedious part of shonenslop. Predictable and without payout. Didn't dig the aesthetic either.>ep 9Well, it looks really good at least, but it didn't stick with me. A cacophony that didn't draw me in. I've seen enough arthouse anime and this isn't it.
>>283504113>How they made a tomboy I didn't like baffles me.Her voice didn't match the character
>>283503893Anything set after TROS is a win in my book, that's why I loved The Twins and The Ninth Jedi. I swear to God, Lucasfilm wastes all their best stuff on Lego specials.
>>283504113>Flat tummy tomboy on screen helps it out.If F wasn't already my wife, I'd choose Sevn.
>>283504240>Ren's voice by Christian Slater>Darth Revan's animated debutAnd all for kiddie gags...
>>283504296wonder which one is more likely to get a TV Show
>>283504353F
>>283504353Probably F since Lucasfilm is obsessed with the aftermath of Revenge of the Sith.
>>283504370Kinema Citrus seems rather booked up in 2026 not sure about Wit
>>283504353I want Am.
>>283504492The crazy Sith from the start of episode 8?
>>283504509The Sith(?) from The Twins.
>>283504530I forgot her name, but fair enough, I kinda doubt Trigger will bother doing a full Star Wars show unless Masahiko Otsuka really wanted to do one
I want them to animate New Jedi Order/Legacy of the Force, but that's never happening.
>>283504552I kinda hope that the next big push for Star Wars animation is anime set after TROS. Getting really sick of all the Dark Times bullshit Filoni seems to be wanking for his animated series.
>>283504552I don't see The Twins getting a full show, but a movie or OVA makes more sense.
>>283504585The only animated Star Wars show we have set outside anything before ANH was Resistance, and it was pretty mediocre. An anime set after TROS would be a godsend since the Mandoverse seems to be strictly live action.
>>283503927The fuck are you talking about? TLJ was hugely divisive since day 1.
>>283467323just finished F's episode, I couldn't stop myself I did the "absolute cinema" hand gesture.maybe there still is hope for Star Wars.
>star wars thread on /a/>actual discussion>no /tv/schizo diarrhea>proving once again tangentially offtopic threads are the best threads on any given boardHmmm.....
f is cute, CUTE!
>>283502935>>283503016Wow wtf, I've read the Star Wars part 4 "manga" 15 years ago, but it was more like a black and white comic than anything
>>283504826>this guy doesn't remember Ewoks and Droids
>>283505059it's because /a/ doesn't care about long-standing fandoms/universes' intricacies and lore as greatly, considering we watch tons of one-off shows and stuff.so Visions is basically a good anthology compilations, we watch them all the time for the ideas and art it presents.
Why tf is there a Star Wars anime? Are Japs producing it or this anither ploy of Disney to get more money?
>>283505185you're on the information superhighway. learn to look things up, dipshit
>>283505065Her master is cuter>>283505185>Are Japs producing it or this>Studios: Anima, David Production, Kamikaze Douga, Kinema Citrus, Polygon Pictures, Production I.G, Project Studio Q, Trigger, Wit StudioGee, i don't know - do they?
>>283505268GRIFFITH!
>>283505268>Her master is cuterThat's a man, baby!
>>283505291That's the best part
>>283504826You mean Rebels?Resistance was the show set during the Sequels
>>283505452I meant Resistance since Rebels is still set before ANH. Resistance kinda sucked.
>>283505059Back in the day, /a/ used to have the best Revan threads.
>>283505482Sorry misread your post, and it 100% did suck there was a reason it was cancelled after two seasons.
>>283505524It's cool and it's a shame, really, we need another show set in that era since the one we got wasn't good.
>>283505288
the random changes between 2d and 3d in ninth jedi part 2 was a bit annoying
>>283505600I thought it was oddly nostalgic since I remember a lot of early 2000s anime doing that
>>283505059We're just lucky with this thread, the last two Visions threads were a fucking disaster.
>>283505594>s03I didn't even know there were more seasons wow ok, are they good?
>>283505713s1 is all japanese studios, some of s3 were sequels of those episodewe don't talk about s2
>>283505713First season is generally alright, second season depends on your opinion on /co/ media
>>283505713s1 is gonna be hard to top, it was good.s2 just pretend it doesn't exist.s3 was decent, still not as good as s1 but leagues above s2
always makes me chuckle when they clearly use the english script for the subs
>>283505836Sevn, my wife.
>>283505883She's for droid use only
>>283505059Reminds me of the time we had a good Castlevania thread about the Curse of Darkness manga.
>>283503927Kinda crazy that TLJ is the only sequel movie that George Lucas actually liked, must be because it stuck closest to his original vision for Luke's arc.
this one isn't about a jedi outside of sevn's flashback and has this mechsuit droideka and a wilhelm scream. that makes it the best one
>>283506078eh there's not really any evidence of that. He said TLJ was a very well-made film, not that he liked it.
>>283506092Sevn saves fucking twileks so i can't like this episode. Fuck twileks.
>>283506107Pablo Hidalgo said in one of his books on the production of Star Wars that it was always George Lucas' plan to have Luke become a crazy hermit and die in the middle movie, it was one of many of Lucas' ideas for his sequels, not as crazy as the one that had Darths Maul and Talon run a criminal empire.
>>283506092I don't think Yuko Treaure had any Jedi stuff in it at all It was just kids, a Droid, some Pirates and a Krayt Dragon
>>283506228my torrent must have gotten the file names wrongits the bounty hunters episode, not yuko's treasure
>>283504576NJO is peak SW and even has a built-in 4-act structure that would work well as a TV show. But you're right, never gonna happen and that's probably a good thing
>>283506266I'm just conflating Episodes, sorry Ignoire me.
>>283506270NJO is really my favourite SW story arc. A shame ROTS performed so poorly in Japan that we didn't get more of Tsuyoshi Nagano's art for the characters since they stopped translating the novels there.
>>283506297nah, my torrent definitely fucked it up because half of the episodes were named wrong and I wouldn't have noticed it otherwise
>>283506270Jaina, my beloved.
>>283506328Bounty Hunters was episode 4 Yuko Treasure was Episode 6
I liked every episode in season 1 besides the garbage one with the band. How is the new season?
>>283506411Not as good as season 1, but still pretty great.
>>283506411No episode is as bad as the Band episode in season 3 but I don't think any episode is Amazing except for Black, which is just an Arthouse Music video
>>283486479>Flop after flop after flop>Make Star Wars but anime>It actually works>Disney's realization is "people like Star Wars... but animated!">Season 2 is 90% cartoon shit as if there wasn't enough already>flopsThe decision making power of these mofos is amazing
>>283506411the second episode with the protocol droid personal x-wing mech suit attachments for the protag was kind of ass but not horribly so
>>283486479The marketing was so shit, many people didn't even know it was coming out. Hope it doesn't turn out to be another Transformers One
>>283506604Fewer stacks than that since this is just a streaming show.
And I heard Kinema Citrus' made in abyss team did another episode about F? How was that? Did this fat aussie bastard crank out another awesome OST? I'll probably watch it later today.
>>283506663It was pretty solid.
>>283506663They did two episodes in season three, another one about F, and another episode that was a homage to early Akira Toriyama animated stuff at least in character design
>>283506639Yeah and a full anime series can confirmed, but I'm still kinda scared. Obviously I'm still pissed about transformers too, but that's out of topic
>>283506663Not as good as the original, but still solid. The OST wasn't that impressive to be honest, but visuals were
>>283506663Had a fun but short lightsaber duel.
>>283505117I'm pretty sure those were set before the films. Ewoks has the first time the Empire discovers Endor as an episode
>>283508576Oh shit you're right, sorry it's been a few decades since I've seen them and guess I just thought they were set after they were introduced in the movies
I always preferred the mechanical stuff (like spaceships and landwalkers) and the wildlife of Star Wars more
>>283503220Fair. That makes sense, considering the board we're on after all.I still genuinely think Aau's Song is the next best choice for a follow-up Vision, after Lop and Ocho.
>>283507709>Had a fun but short lightsaber duel.Duels are always best when they're short. Even Lucas didn't get that in the PT movies.
>>283509998Aau's Song felt like a reverse Screechers Reach
>>283507709The carbonite grenades were wicked
What is this, it looks fun. Is it like extended universe fun.
>>283511131An anthology of star wars stories by various animation studios.
>>283511131its what star wars should be, new content that has nothing to do with being canon-compliant or ""realistic"" in terms of established star wars norms. just fun little stories using the setting as a playground
Theres a star wars anime now?
>>283511327>now>first season aired in 2021
>>283511510I hate time so goddamn much
>>283511510fuck, never heard of it
>>283511510This shot makes it look like she's massively pregnant and giving birth. Nice.
>>283514340Cute nugget
>>283506107Only retarded people who don't understand what's happening on screen appreciate TLJ. In fact, its only virtue is its aesthetics, but if you analyze the film for what it is, it's awful.And at times it's unclear whether Rian is a psychopath or not. The scene of Rose "saving" Fin and then kissing him while in the background they break down the Resistance base door is so absurd it seems like a parody of Robot Chicken.
>>283517117>conveniently, the girl doesn't get cut.
>>283517135but Lucas did call it a "Beautifully Made” film
>>283506869yeh, there's nothing in the S03 episode that comes close to the moment the song in this scene cuts in. they tried with F's entry into the holo-cathedral, but it just didn't hit the same.
kinda wished the Shorts had more interesting vehicle design in them. Outside of the ninth Jedi, most shorts just relied on pre-existing prequel or original trilogy designs.
God I hate dubtitles so much.
>>283517310That's like praising the special effects or soundtrack. A backhanded compliment when you can't justify praising the story or characters but need to say something nice because industry elbows.
>>283518132One of the most interesting parts of Village Bride was how it seemed to have a more spiritual aspect to it. Seeing how the force exists outside of the main galaxy with people who don't know Jedi and have their own terms for things. Like whatever you believe or call things it's all still there and beyond you. So when all the force and magina stuff came to head it really just hit. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KaIVUTA1Dq0The second episode was good but it wasn't Magina may you rise
>>283517266will of the force
>>283501690>newer Star Wars fans were like shounenfags with their obsession with training and powerlevels.Well maybe Lucas shouldn't have created power levels like DBZ when he introduced midicholorians.
>>283519170That was a key element in Zahn's original Thrawn trilogy, Luke encountered all kinds of people who used the force in different ways, and struggled with what it meant in relation to what he'd been taught by Yoda. At one point (iirc, it's been an age) he ran into people who could use it to just manifest things out of thin air.That would actually be a really great angle for an F series, she has to stay out on the rim where the Empire can't just hotdrop Star Destroyers on her, but it requires navigating strange cultures with differing views on force-users. Not that we'll ever get anything that cool out of the Disneyverse, goddammit.
>>283519770It sword of goes with the samurai warriors pilgrimage too. Have her travel the outer cosmos and reflect on the force.
>>283520492>sword of
>>283520915Well there's only one way for me to save face now.
>>283520915>>283521218That actually caused me to laugh out loud, thanks anon.
PLANETOF VISIONSPLANETOF VISIONS
>>283517310Holdo's kamikaze is a beautifully done scene. Breathtaking even. But once you take even a second to think about it, it's one of the stupidest scenes in the entire franchise. It's a scene that rends the coherence of the entire setting for the sake of a fleeting moment. That's what TLJ is.
IF I PULL F's MASK OFFWOULD SHE DIE?
>>283523065IT WOULD BE VERY PAINFUL
You better watch out!
>>283518820Yeah, they're real DANK FARRIK
>>283467719I like Andor tho
>>283524259>I'm glad the Jedi lost>Now listen here you little shit
>>283524259>>283504113The only episode I really liked was Duel Payback. Everything else seemed a bit weak, although some episodes like Black and Bird of Paradise were interesting.The Lost Ones is kinda inferior to the first one. While the first episode had aesthetics, music, art, and spirit, this one feels a bit empty. The good is F, that remains one of Vision's best characters, and I was happy to see her again. I know what it represents, but I'm a little sad she lost her mask. it made her look more badass, especially considering how mechanized she is. Child of Hope was another one that left me a bit cold. It feels like filler devoid of everything that made the first episode great, even if it gets a few things right with the robot and the theme of sacrifice.The Bounty Hunters was good, but I think it lacks something to be truly memorable
>>283525471Child of Hope was created by a diffrent team compared to the first Ninth Jedi Episode so we can hope that they are team doing the TV show
>>283524003Season 1 was pretty good. Season 2's only redeeming element is the Ghorman arc, otherwise it's a melodramatic pacing disaster.
For me it's Lop's storyEven if the lightsaber design is silly
>>283527216Anon, be careful I got warned for posting western furry.
>>283525698Purin?
>>283527313>westernShe has katana and stuff
>>283527674Star Wars is a western IP
>>283527712So are Howl's moving Castle and Cyberpunk 2077, but there's no issues when it comes to posting those.
>>283527807Howl moving Castle is a book adaption so im not sure anyone counts that as a Western IP. but you got me on Cyberpunk
>>283527216>>283527313But does this race exist in the canon? I know there are Werewolves like Shistavanen and some other animal race (the little bears or Wookies), but this Zootopia bunny girl is kinda new to me.
>>283528225I think they're the Lepi, like Jaxxon.
>>283528271>it's real...>From a 1977 star wars comicWow, fuck me. Well done, i had no idea.
>>283528225
>>283528332Jaxxon also keep showing up despite Lucas hating him
>>283527216Visions was full of katana sabers in the other shorts, and those weren't even the stupidest ones.
>>283528370Star Wars has always been full of Japanese elements, a katana has never seemed out of place in the Galaxy far, far away.
>>283501179the problem here is that "balance" isn't meant to be "light and dark in equal amounts". The Dark Side is supposed to be like a tumor on the force, a disease that needs to be excised. Star Wars is a story about the triumph of good vs evilthe PROBLEM is that george is a fucking retard and even going back to the 70s he kept on describing the force as yin-yang, because he didn't really know what yin-yang means, and completely muddled the waters forever. Fanfic writers ran with it to make their "muh gray jedi" OCs and explore force as a balance between light and dark, and the rest is history But again, that's not how it's supposed to work, george just forced that interpretation into being by being a moron bad at explaining himself
>>283528432I think the MMO was clever about it, Revan trying to balance the Light and Dark within himself causing him to split into two beings was interesting.
>>283467323shame she only got second place on our popularity poll
>>283528370Trigger got the assignment, and did Trigger shit with it. Sky blue, water wet, etc.
>>283528456obviously the right answer is Kreia's solution of balancing the force by just killing everyone who is force sensitive
>>283528432From what i get, the Force is a fundamental aspect of the galaxy's nature, and its will is nothing more than a natural law, like gravity. The dark side uses the Force in an "unnatural" way, throwing it out of balance and corrupting it.The real problem is that nothing was ever really explained in the OT, so we have idiots like JJ and Rian who didn't understand anything and didn't even bother to check. Or maybe they did it on purpose because part of the fandom is obsessed with Gray Jedi everyone want to be some edgy stupid sith that fart lighting and wear a cool mask, but also good and honorable like Batman.yes, the ronin of The duel is also fully guilty of this
>>283528714again, george basically forced that interpretation into being by being bad at explaining himself in interviews and constantly calling the force a yin-yang I can't even blame rian and jj, if anything they were building on EU and fan consensus rather than WoG, which is fair enough even if it's wrong and fucks up the lorebut yeah, asians in particular LOVE "good and evil as an actual balance" type stories for whatever fucking reason so this interpretation was always going to crop up when they were given free reign to make semi canon stories
>>283528630TLJ turned Luke into Kreia from Temu when it comes to his views on the Jedi.
>>283528432George probably should have called it something else other than the Darkside
>>283529942Nah, Darkside work quite well. The lore clearly has a battle between good and evil. The concept of Balance in the force wad introduced in the prequels and that's what messed up.
is it actually worth a watch since i've been out of SW's stuff for a while now.
>>283530329if you want to watch some Star Wars stuff Visions is hardly the worst thing you could watch
>>283530134George's movies didn't really go into detail about balance, so people assume it was a balance between good and evil that was fulfilled when Anakin killed the jedi and brought their numbers closer to what the sith had. Some expanded universe writers may have fed into this idea, I don't know. George has said that the prophecy was fulfilled when he destroyed the sith, so the force is in balance when their aren't any sith abusing it.
>>283530329How do you feel about AU fanfiction? Because this series is basically a series of AU fanfics
>>283530594desu most of the short could easyly fit into canon without to much issue with ones like the Dual and the Twins being the notable exception from the first season
>>283530494Seems like this character is triggering a few people, what happens if I combine it with the second most hated thing on the net?
>>283530594The whole Sequel trilogy is narcissistic fanfic from Kathleen Kennedy and J.J.
>>283530818The Twins is set after TROS, so it could still fit into canon and the artbook said Am and Karre are genetically enhanced superhumans, which is why they could survive in space. Also, an article in StarWars.com said The Twins is "canon adjacent".
>>283530818If you are willing to play with timeline a bit and overlook minor aesthetic parts you could stick all of them into canon desu
>>283531024They are like Super Saiyans. Breathing in space is the least .
>>283531071The Duel could work in canon if you ignore the tie-in book.
>>283531414and the comic/manga oneshots done by Takashi Okazaki
>>283531414>>283531465The author of the book put too much gay shit in it and may or may not have made The Ronin a practitioner of Nanshoku.
>>283531651prose book is diffrent from the Marvel comic since Takashi Okazaki did write the Visions shorts as well
>>283531710Then I'll check out the comic/manga.
>>283528432The balance is knowing the darkside exists and you have to keep it at bay. The Yoda Clone Wars arc showed that even him has a dark side and he can't simply ignore it, you have to accept it as something that will always be part of yourself.
>>283531651The author of the book made The Ronin a fag because she herself is a fag. She actually admitted that in an interview.
>>283528473Who got first? I'm really hoping it's Am, but deep inside i know it's fucking Lop
>watching V1 with a friend>taking a shot between every episode and also having beers>skip the retarded band episode>very drunk by the end>at the end say that because we skipped an episode he should pick one to rewatch>"can we...uh...watch the one with the bunny girl again"I know what you are friend.
>>283532005I hope the book isn't treated as canon to the shorts.
>>283528432>The Dark Side is supposed to be like a tumor on the force, a disease that needs to be excised.Eh, there's some amount of natural Dark Side. Like the cave on Dagobah. And the Jedi use these places to test padawans sometimes. The ultimate lesson is usually that you need to acknowledge the darkness inside of you, but not let it dominate you. The problem with the Jedi Order is that their dogmatic ways could make it difficult for people to fully acknowledge the darkness before it consumed them. Anakin's fall was in large part driven by him being more comfortable talking about his fears and mistakes to someone outside the order, who just so happened to be a Sith Lord.
>>283532052Maybe he actually liked Ocho
>>283532005No self control with this people at all. That they can't even conceive of the idea of not making everything about them is astounding.
>>283532208Yeah, it pisses me off.
>>283532052>>very drunk by the endLightweight
>>283532159Kek no I have my suspicions, but I also dont care because I also like Lop for those same reasons. If anything Ocho might've reminded him of his wife and he just wanted to see Lop beat her ass again.
>>283532234It just shows an astounding lack of imagination. People will create vast galaxies, entire cultures, worlds and mythologies. tell tales of grand adventure and climactic struggles. Then the second they get anything it's "BUT ARE THEY GAY!?"
>>283532301It's deep narcissism and them making faggotry their entire personality.
>>283532073Lucasfilm never mentions The Ronin in any Pride Month listings, so chances are it's not.
>>283532208making half/most of the characters lgbt wasn't even the biggest issue with the author. she went hard on I'M ASIAN THIS MEANS SO MUCH TO ME AND MY CULTURE I DON'T LIVE IN in the author's notes at the end and that pissed me off more.
>>283533392>>283533392Exactly, she may have Asian blood, but she's not part of the culture.
>>283533392I've known white guys who've lived in Asia long enough who are more Asian than she is.
>>283532301I hate that her explanation is that he'd have sex with anyone who comes on to him.
Who is hotter, F or Sevn?
Now that all 2 (we don't talk about the one in the middle) volumes are out, what's /a/'s favourite?
>>283533392The absolute failure that was THE HIGH REPUBLIC™ was full of this shit. You have that, season 2 of Visions which was "what if my country... WAS IN STAR WARS????", then you have that one chink novel where a whole sector of the galaxy was nothing but chink names and people ate with chopsticks. And the less we talk about the ACKolyte, the better.
is Dooku in this show?
>>283534018>season 2 of Visions which was "what if my country... WAS IN STAR WARS????"a lot of season 1 and 2 of Visions could also be described like that.
>>283534024No, but he's part of F's backstory, he gave her her scar.
>>283534090season 1 and 3*
>>283534018>spoilerSol and the Stranger were the only good things about it. Kinda weird that they advertise it as based on martial arts flicks but cast a nig as the actress, makes sense that the only two Asian dudes are the standouts.
>>283534018>THE HIGH REPUBLIC™Geode™ This is the best they could come up with. Really.
>>283534090Yeah, I know Jedi are supposed to be based on Samurai but going fullblown with kataginu and katana-shaped lightsabers (Furloni and his super special Darksaber btfo) is too much, almost parody.
>>283468322>highest grossing in an economy that is essentially 100% fake and money laundering
>>283534207you should lucas for the Darksaber Filoni just wanted it to be a Vibroblade originally
>>283534184yep, that's a rock alright
>>283534282you should blame Lucas*
>>283534018I put up with a lot of high republic's dumb shit to enjoy some of the setting, but pic related was one straw too much for the wah wah wah muh daddy trans/enby character storyline
>>283534184Can you explain the context for why a deviantart tier drawing of a rock is featured as a piece concept art?
>>283534018I'm glad all the fucks who did The High Republic got it out of their systems since Disney's cracking down on gay shit to focus on the larger market they know they've lost. Now they're trying to win back young men.
>>283534342its from a race of sentient rock "people" and it has its own functioning mind and learned how to be a pilot, though it has no speech ability. nearly every character takes it at face value and treats it as a real character whenever it shows up. yes, it's an actual character, and those pieces of concept art were how SW announced new characters for the whole high republic line
>>283534342The High Republic was going to be their next multi media ...."thing" and one of the characters they were super excited to show off was.... a force sensitive rock. I'd compare their creative output to children but I think children would probably6 come up with something a lot better. Here's a picture of a white board from a creative meeting.
>>283534421Legends did it better with the force-sensitive Tsil crystals. They were literally just crystals, though they got robot bodies when they became Jedi.
>>283534181>Kinda weird that they advertise it as based on martial arts flicks but cast a nig as the actress>They made a big deal that they had the actress of Matrix' Trinity in the show as if she was gonna be Trinity (wire-fu included) again but Star Wars>Her character dies in the first episode to Ninjakwesha, stomping around like Mr. X while the other spins like a fucking top and throwing darts.
>>283534461The basic idea of the High Republic isn't terrible since the idea did have success in the OLD EU days with eras like the Old Republic, Dawn of the Jedi, and Legacy, it's just had terrible execution.
>>283534569my biggest problem with it was they got caught up in having everything happen in the same area of space, so we kept seeing or hearing about the same planets over and overif I ever have to see eiram and e'ronoh again I will nuke lucasfilm
>>283534555What a waste, really.
>>283534331For me it was the YA books that had not one but three separate brown/black teenage girls with mommy issues.
>>283534569The High Republic was never suppposed to be what Old Republic used to be. It was always just the Post Ruusan Reformation Republic because that is all the soulless corpos and their soulless puppets know of.
>>283534569the basic idea of the high republic is to set a space adventure story in a period of history were NOTHING FUCKING HAPPENED. It's called the HIGH republic for a reason. Now that isn't to say shit probably wasn't happening in the background, no period of history is without any conflict but the Old Republic and Dawn were filled with a lot more upheaval generally speaking.
>>283502164It's Endor and the gay Ewoks that were inspired by the Vietcong.Rather the Wookies were and we got Ewoks for gay budget reasons that George lies about being an artistic decision.
>>283534569The difference is that the high republic™ was "The Jedi are at their peak, everything is wholesome chungus, everyone is awesome and there is only HIGH ADVENTURE™ from The Watchtow- I mean, The Starlight Beacon!" no big war or enemy faction. You had, what? Some half-assed space pirate/vikings that looked like raiders from fallout? Meanwhile in the Old Republic you have the Sith Empire(s) as equals carving a large chunk of the galaxy, no room for quipping or jedi being smug self-inserts when an equal or bigger number of Sith Warriors are Force charging at you at mach speed.
I miss the Yuzzhan Vong. They were pretty stupid but compared to what we got I miss them.
>>283467323
The Ninth Jedi is a short film's worth of premise already stretched beyond its breaking point in a single 10 minute sequel.The core gimmick is cool. It works in context. Robbed of that it's just generic shit.
>>283534937You don't need a huge galaxy-spanning genocidal war the have a good story. However, the Outer Rim space vikings with nonsensical plot-driven tech weren't very interesting.>>283534969The Vong worked much better than I expected. As the series goes on their weirdass culture gets fleshed out and several characters get sympathetic arcs. Nom Anor was an extremely fun antagonist.
>>283535130>You don't need a huge galaxy-spanning genocidal war the have a good storyStar Wars needs sweeping archetypal good vs evil space opera. It's what it is. The more personal stories of the old EU are almost universally bad and are universally not Star Wars.
>>283534921Supposedly because he wanted a primitive planet and society for his vietcong propaganda, and he already established the wookiees as intelligent and pretty good with machines. Don't remember if Lucas himself or the EU established the whole "wookiees are hunted by Trandoshans and enslaved en masse by the Empire" but a Spartacus-like revolt on an occupied Kashyyyk would've been miles better than the Empire being btfo by ugly plushies throwing rocks and logs.
>>283535130>You don't need a huge galaxy-spanning genocidal war the have a good story.No but it's called STAR WARS. Generally speaking a galactic conflict among the cosmos is encouraged.
>>283535348It was probably easier and cheaper to find a bunch of dwarfs to play Ewoks than a bunch of basketball players to play Wookies
>>283528432It's closer to the Dark side is illness or disease. The Force is an energy field generated by all living beings and thus is influenced by people. The Dark side is natural the same as illness happens in nature. It's not good for you but it's natural and balance isn't permanently removing all if it, that would be as impossible as removing all disease ever, but reducing it to healthy levels. A tumor isn't natural but can naturally develop. The Dark side is there even in a healthy person.
>>283467323The only good star wars shit is ep 4, 5 and tartakovsky's animations.The end.
>>283535348The Ewoks have Wookie level strength in a small package and we're losing before Chewbacca hijacked the AT-AT.
>>283535421>5Worst out of the OT. It relied on the next to give payoff for its setups.
>>283535372This is one thing about Nu Wars fans that I'll never understand: The main draw of Star Wars are the Wars and how cool they look. Why do they want everyone to sing fucking kumbaya?
>>283535698The whole point is good vs evil and their conflict adverse asses don't want to reflect on that because it might show that they're not the good guys they think they are. Everyone has to accept everyone in some bullshit Steven Universe level of faggotry.
>>283535420>A tumor isn't natural but can naturally developcancer is natural, it's just a consequence of how cells are born
>>283535469*AT-ST, but now that you mention it there was at least one AT-AT stationed on Endor.
>>283535698The Nu-EU's biggest issue is that they can't tell large-scale stories for fear of being overwritten by planned movies... all of which end up being canceled anyway.
Would an anthology for Alien and Predator work?
>>283535698star wars was co-opted by women to go from a nerd fantasy escape to a real life stand-in escape to write out what they wish was happening, that they have no control over in real life, to make themselves feel betterorange man bad, his intent to start wars very scary, therefore we must write about stopping a war and keeping the peace while the real world falls to hell
>>283536007In theory yes, but I'm pretty sure the one they did for Predator was really bad so it would all depend on the execution
>>283533804F
>>283536470imagine the handjo... oh
>>283536874She still got her off hand
>>283536909she got two offhands now
>>283475513>Did yurifags even like F in the first place?Nah those so called "yurifags" always live in that retard head.I never saw any yurifagg giving a shit about anything Star Wars related aside of Aphra comics since she is maybe the only lesbian MC SW has and some interest in Ahsuka tv series with Wren character in it and her female rival.
>>283535891Most tumors aren't malignant.
>>283537247well yeah
>>283535597>>5>Worst out of the OT.Aight, I'll admit I've seen them years ago, but it couldn't have been worse than 6 and the fucking ewoks.
>>283467323Why do bob cuts look so good on anime girls? The asymmetrical ones are pure sex.
>>2835373045 relied entirely on 6 to deliver payoffs to what I set up, blew much screentime with Han and Leia flying through space and having romance, and other problems. 4 is the best OT film for being a self contained story.
>>283536007Fox finished an Alien vs Predator anime but Disney never released it
>>283537549>Long enough to be feminine>Sport enough to be practical>Frames the face>Nape
