>doesn't cry like a fag>achieve his dreams>saved his brother>married, had sex and became a father>/a/ somehow hates this guy really makes you hmm
>>284136710It's just "popular bad"
/a/ doesn't hate him. One anon with a severe mental illness is addicted to shitposting about the series. Some other retards may occasionally join in for a few quick giggles, but the hate you see on this board almost entirely comes from one obsessed freak.
>>284136710he was cuck. he should had use souls to power up his alchemy in the last battle instead of kungfu shit
>>284136710everyone hates short men lol
>>284136710>achieve his dreamsno he failed and cope he never revive his mom
>>284136907he's quite big by the end>>284136936he moved on and found new dreams to fight for
>>284136936them trying to revive their mom was the cope, it was a literal unhealthy childish obsession with trying to get something back that is lost forever. Them accepting death is final is them growing up and moving on.
>>284137023How early in the series did that happen, that was pretty early right?
>>284137023Fuck off, looser. The father could create sun in his palm. Resurrecting humans is easy.
>>284136936Would it actually have been possible for them to revive their mom if they suddenly decided they were OK with using philosopher's stones?Seems you can revive people who have recently died in the universe, but I can't remember if it ever happened with people who were long dead.I remember when Edward digs up the failed resuscitation attempt they find out it has different hair and stuff and somehow that's meant to mean it would've been definitely impossible to revive her I think? But I never really understood that
>>284137068>posting about series he had never read>>284137077JJK thread is two blocks down, buddy.
>>284137100Hey, I've absolutely read it It's just been a few years
>>284137077How can you watch this and so completely misunderstand alchemy
>>284137100weak and emasculated men are afaird of sucrifice. all human achievements were made with human lives taken. alchemy is the most important thing in the world.giving up alchemy was the biggest KEK move.
>>284137138
>>284136774That one anon also likes the shit version of this character who dies a virgin in WW2 instead of the based version who marries his childhood girl next door and reproduces.
>>284137137homunculies are humans but better smarter stronger and immortal. he could create homunculy with his mom look and memory.
>>284136710Only 2 dedicated retards hate it, most anons are just indifferent towards it.
>>284137155The homunculi clearly need to be made with the souls of sacrificed people though, you can't actually create a personAlso, while Greed's memory was manipulated it was only wiped, and he actually recovered it after the fact because he was still the same soul hive mind abomination Even if you treat a thing that has the same appearance and memories as her as her, which it isn't because her soul isn't there, you couldn't even make that.
>>284137253"As her as her"Man, that was a terrible sentence. I need to make a habit of giving my posts a read over before posting.
>>284137068>that was pretty early right?it actually happened before the events of chapter1, as they accepted it when they were still kids.After they messed up reviving their mother, they realized death is final and their new goal became to get their bodies back
>>284137253>The homunculi clearly need to be made with the souls of sacrificed people though, you can't actually create a personplus the personalities of the homonculi were that of father. He didn't just created new souls out of nowhere, he cut up his own into 8 parts and distributed 7 of them, leaving himself as a hollow numb guy.
>>284136710He was an annoying arrogant edgy little shit who rarely saw the wrong in his actions, got constantly rewarded and he was a borderline Mary Sue on top of all that. Add to that an hilariously bad love story and a bunch of nostalgia chasing reddifag tier people singing praise to the series and you'll see why some people hate a mediocre overrated manga
>>284137363I thought they'd just given up on messing with death, fearing that they'd fucked up and killed their mother a second time Wasn't it only until after Hoenheim came back and they dug up the corpse that they fully realized her soul was unreachable to begin with and finally made peace with it?
>>284137465sort of."you can only bring them back as monstrous abominations that will die a gruesome death" and "you just can't do it" was sort of interchangeable in the way they talk. It was never really a plotpoint at all until Hohenheim brought it up out of nowhere and Ed confirmed it in a single chapter that he was right.Basically, even without Hohenheim, they already accepted to never even bother trying again.
>>284137460>who rarely saw the wrong in his actionshow to tell someone didn't watch a story, without telling me he didn't watch it
>>284137460Was he though? Yeah at the beginning of the series he kinda was, but that's because he was a literal child and the adults around him all acknowledge that and shield him from things because again he was a child Where are the constant rewards though? And how was he "borderline Mary Sue"?I don't know about "hilariously bad love story" so much as just "love story that felt a bit incomplete because of how little screentime it got" and really I'd take that every time before an overdone romance subplot with characters that don't actually work together
>>284137023that just them giving up so its a copeimagine scientists give up on their research just because of someone else's ideology on life you would still be doing witch hunt
>>284137460Ed hits very, very low on the edge scale as far as shonen protagonists go.
>>284137555I direct you here >>284137465
>>284137567>He had a more tragic past than Naruto and he justifiably acts like it, therefore he's an unbearably edgy cringefest
>>284137574what's wrong with trying to revive someone or building a humaned's attemp is just one of many of humanity just because he failed doesn't mean its all there is to itso its just a cope
>>284137540>>284137553An example that works for some of your questions: winry shitting on Al voicing his worries about his body to defend Edward, that the story ended up resolving with Edward being absolutely right and Al absolutely wrong, without the complete lack of subtlety (or calling out Edward shit attitude).
>>284137657The entire point was that he didn't "just fail" He was attempting the impossible
>>284137597Naruto is an hypocrite, his whole character is revolting.
>>284137684I don't understand at all why you'd say that I feel like your understanding of that plot point was so completely different from mine that we aren't ready to even have this discussion without a whole lot of questions beforehand
>>284137555Isn't it cope to spend your life on the impossible though instead of cutting your loses? Plenty of scammers and morons in science too. Like they just lie about their findings that can't be replicated, but morons latch on anyway. Cold fusion is a prime example.
>>284137091Should be if he went for the perfect philosophy stone
>>284137769>>284138112the idea of impossible is in itself is a cope for stop trying
>>284137769>>284138112how do you know what's impossible or possible talking with ppl like you i feel cuck energy emitting from my screen holy shit
>>284136789>marries his childhood friend and romantic interest (who is also a virgin btw), then beds her, resulting in multiple children>cuck
>>284136774>Some other retards may occasionally join in for a few quick gigglesYeah, I am guilty of that. I like FMA tho.
>>284137155>and immortal.Tell that to Lust.
>>284139076>>284139097Sorry anon, but 1+1 does not equal 7
>>284139302keep believing in jap woman ideology for being a cuck lmao
>>284139341>Just wish for it harder bro>Grit your teeth and scream like it's a battle shounen >Nothing is impossible >The universe owes you your scientific breakthrough if you keep trying >Physics itself will change in the background and create a way to do the thing you're trying to do
>>284139397the idea is to keep trying but lazy animetard like you just dont understand you would rather cope that's shit is impossible so you could keep watching anime and discussing it on /a/ what a cuck
>>284139450Keep trying what exactly?They figured it out They had their breakthrough And reality was not kind to them This is not about laziness, or about just giving up because it got too hardThis is about recognizing the truth when you see it and doing something other than wasting your life away for a dream you know you'll never get
>>284139450>escapism is proactive and masculineYou'll never amount to anything.
I imagine 2003's Edward would become a Super Soldier
>woman mangaka>writes/draws non-twink, non low T males as standard>no annoying bishounen/ikemen faglords>shounen that isn't cancerous like Naruto>as much fantasy adventure as fightan/a/ likes to hate but I never will, not my favourite manga (any of them) or mangaka but pretty good judged alone and better still when compared to a lot of the dogshit around.
>>284137155>with his mom look and memory.GTFO you no genuine-ness faggot.
>>284137684>winry shitting on Al voicing his worries about his body to defend EdwardWhat? That Al isn't a burden you mean?
