[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/a/ - Anime & Manga


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: isekai.png (1.29 MB, 2400x3501)
1.29 MB
1.29 MB PNG
Would Frieren receive the same acclaim if it were proper high fantasy instead of JRPG-inspired native isekai?
>>
>>284581700
When I reincarnate in the world of Frieren, I will fuck her and leave her with brown children
>>
File: isekai - concise.png (879 KB, 1806x702)
879 KB
879 KB PNG
>>284581700
dozo
>>
>posted it again
>>
>>284581801
fuck it, that's pretty based
>>
File: fantasy_comparison_fixed.png (1.48 MB, 2400x3501)
1.48 MB
1.48 MB PNG
>>284581700
It's entirely irrelevant to its success.
>>
>>284581801
Fpbp
>>
>>284581801
Imagine the shame of not only being a single mother elf to half human children but brown ones
>>
>shitposters will intensify native isekai posting next season
Grim
>>
>>284582037
today it's quite normal; the capitalist model must be implemented in the world of Frieren
>>
>>284581700
Yup. The reason Frieren did so well I'd argue was that it stuck to classical fantasy without any of the modern Jewry you'd get from Amazon and other semitic productions. There's no "orcs are the real victims" plot, there are no shitskin elves injected into it for the sole reason of niggering up something european (very semitic that), and there's no retarded gimmick about someone reincarnating from japan. It basically takes Elrond's warning to Arwen from LOTR and makes it the plot. What happens when the female elf has to continue living after the death of her hero. I suppose Lodoss War hints at this too, but Frieren made it the core conceit.
>>
>>284581700
>Native Isekai
>Video game UIs, levels/xp powerscaling
>"it's X but Y"
>Harem
>game-esque "magic system"
>reincarnation
>Frieren
at least try to make bait believable
>>
>>284581700
Demon king is just another way of saying dark lord moron. Every fantasy has a dark lord.
>>
>>284581700
Roger Ebert lost. It's time to admit video games can be art. Dragon Quest is merely one example. It's more than a game. It's a cultural artefact of Japan.
Old generations would never admit movies are art either. tbqh a lot of slop there. Ebert is full of lies.
>>
File: 97344839_p0.png (2.58 MB, 1668x2388)
2.58 MB
2.58 MB PNG
Shame that the joke thread about AI/Ai got instantly deleted, but bait like this not.
>>
>>284581700
the only anyone cares about Frieren at all is FERN'S BIG FAT PLAPP ASS
>>
File: 1764792493086614.jpg (122 KB, 1920x1080)
122 KB
122 KB JPG
>>284582887
>no video game uis
>no game-esque magic
ok kid
>>
>>284584848
Magic map ia a fantasy magic setting.
>>
>>284581700
What is going to happen the day they reveal Himmel was an isekaijin all along?
>>
>>284586610
They won't
>>
>>284585099
It looks too "digital".
>>
>>284585099
>I came up the idea called “map” - Hideo Kojima inventing the map
>>
>>284586774
>get to Ende
>"not only the souls of those that passed away gather here but continue to be part of the cycle of life"
>"and in there I saw the souls of many strange people foreign to this world, maybe lost from their own path"
Calling it now.
>>
>>284581973
What retard made that? Because OP IS shit, but this straight up made by somebody with a mental retardation for real.
>>
>>284581700
>native isekai
>looks inside
>so the first distinction is that it's not isekai at all actually
So another cope distinction that only the most brain-raped /a/ posters care about? Cool.
>>
>>284581700
Fate was one of the first native isekai
>>
>>284587620
>it's not isekai at all actually
it's native isekai obviously
>>
>>284581700
You forgot characters eating ice creams and burgers
>>
>>284581913
This, thanks
>>
>>284586805
you should look at some old TTRPG dungeon maps sometime soon
>>
>>284584848
You know modern anime sucks because it's all based on videogames.
>>
File: 1742830228522190.jpg (93 KB, 1228x294)
93 KB
93 KB JPG
>>
File: 1756322992404.png (1.38 MB, 2398x698)
1.38 MB
1.38 MB PNG
>>284581700
>>
File: 1766096543639960.png (859 KB, 1800x900)
859 KB
859 KB PNG
>>284581700
>>
File: 1741578072791842.jpg (239 KB, 570x670)
239 KB
239 KB JPG
>>284581700
>native isekai
>>
>>284581700
don't use buzzwords you don't know the meaning of
>>
File: 1766134945102944.png (1.23 MB, 2398x698)
1.23 MB
1.23 MB PNG
>>
File: fetchimage.jpg (169 KB, 604x340)
169 KB
169 KB JPG
>>
>>284581913
Native isekai
>>
>>284581700
>2 pander to pedos
>>
I would watch an actual native isekai, something like
>I was reincarnated after I got hit by a truck while walking drunk on the side of a highway and now I am trying to die of alcohol poisoning in a parallel world
>>
File: cool anime punch girl 2.jpg (2.15 MB, 2894x4093)
2.15 MB
2.15 MB JPG
Isn't her series actually native isekai?
>>
>>284589270
>it's native transported to another world
What world did frieren get transported to
>>
>>284591253
>N-worders are wojack posters
>>
>>284593440
They're mostly underage too.
>>
frierens author wouldnt have the talent to write a non-native isekai fantasy series

Like it'd be easy to keep mostly in fantasy with isekai tropes but no cat ear headbands or mystery steaks that arent supported with a modern factory farming system, but thats a funny joke to them. the best joke they could come up with
so thats the content you get
>>
>>284581801
Based grimdark fantasy enjoyer
>>
>>284593467
>noo this animey is not being serious for serious ppl like me
>>
>>284581700
>Native isekai
It has been three years, please let it die. Even /v/ermin knows when to stop forcing these made up buzzwords
>>
>>284593722
>stop describing new things with words
>The bible doesnt use the word anime
>>
Berserk has like half of these.
Demon lords, JRPG party, characters that clearly have classes, anachronistic setting.
>>
>be retarded third worlder who was born yesterday
>turn words you don't understand into an umbrella term for a bunch of other things you don't understand because you're a braindead mongoloid
>other braindead mongoloids now start aping this trend of inorganically changing definitions to the dumbest interpretation possible
Granting internet access to poopskins was a dire mistake.
>>
>Native Isekai
Goblin Slayer really did a number on fantasy discussion
>>
>>284581700
is Frieren not a local isekai?
>>
>>284596271
>another world (local)
ummm did you mean monoplanar isekai?? ahyuckhyuckhyuck xDDD
>>
>>284596271
these days Frieren is a bait isekai
>>
File: 1757108478145315.png (172 KB, 511x894)
172 KB
172 KB PNG
>>
>>284582887
you forgot
>plot
>>
>>284581700
One Piece has more acclaim than Frieren Beyond Reddits End.
>>
>>284581700
Based. Native Isekai is a valid term.
>>
>>284581700
>"""native""" isekai
Give up. It's as real as cold fusion being a real science.
>>
>>284581913
Nailed it.
>>
I don't play games, so can someone explain what tropes to look out for that make something JRPG inspired?
>>
>>284596175
Just isekaihater things, always coming up with shit that bite them in the ass later.
>>
>>284581973
What delusional butthurt retard made this chart? This is beyond optimistic and into the realm of schizophrenia
>>
>>284593386
A series about the main character trying to die to go back to their world but not being able to would be pretty funny.
>>
>>284581700
A lot of Japanese Fantasy is heavily inspired by Dragon Quest which is heavily inspired by D&D. That explains basically everything in your image.
>>
>>284599791
The first thing to look out for is grass. Games, specially jrpgs, have grass you step on. Anime with grass=jrpg.
>>
>>284601753
Europe had grass lawns as early as the 1600
>>
>>284599791
>numeric levels / "leveling up"
>adventurer's guilds
>adventuring "parties"
>letter rankings
>DnD/LotR races
>distinct character classes (mage/archer/warrior/thief etc)
>"skills" / skill trees
>dungeons/labyrinths
>goblins or slimes as fodder enemies
>bright, high contrast weapons and armor on people other than nobles/royalty
>>
>>284602072
This can't be right, none of the final fantasy games are like that.
>>
File: Dragon Quest 1.jpg (1.27 MB, 1200x1059)
1.27 MB
1.27 MB JPG
Speaking of JRPG manga/anime, how is the Dragon Quest Dai stuff?
>>
>>284581913
Isn't berserk another world?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.