Murder is inherently wrong.
>>286734109Yeah, it is. It's called murder for a reason.
>>286734109Is it wrong to murder a murderer?
>>286734421Yes
>>286734421If you murder a murder the number of murders hasn't changed. So you need to murder two or more murders for it to be a net positive.
>>286734421Murder is a sin
>>286734109Murder is evil. I will gladly become evil to protect those I care about.
>>286734109Breaking all your opponent bones and subduing him into full submission is based and redpilled.You should’ve trained your village into a bunch of CQC chads and subdued these natives
>>286734935There's a difference between murder and killing, anon.
>>286736808Yeah, semantics.
>>286734109being a cuckold is inherently wrong. Thors caused his son to be kidnapped by mercenary pirates and then become a slave for two decades all because he was a pussy.
>>286737780Wrong, he was a great man
>>286734109Retarded character, retarded manga, retarded author and retarded OP.
>>286734421Murder is a waste of human resources and it is a complete falure of competency. Outside of famines, immediate self-defense, and scarce few uneviable situations; there is ALWAYS going to be a better use for vanquished foes. Organisations from time immemorable have long since developed a tried and true playbook; put them to work, and tell them: "if you they work enough then you will be free.
>>286734421>Is it wrongEverything you do in life is wrong. The only way to win is not to play at all
>>286734935damn, i need to read TG soon
>>286734109The universe is intrinsically fashioned to be a violent arena. It is a fact of the cosmos.
>>286734109Which is why anyone who tries to murder you or your loved ones should be killed.
>>286734545murdering a murderer isn't murder imo.
>>286734109Murder is, but there are valid reasons to kill in self defense, or in the defense of others.The only reason Thorfinn's philosophy works out--even SLIGHTLY--is because he has anime superpowers and plot armor.He'd have died an inglorious, retarded death dozens and dozens of chapters ago otherwise, so...The manga just doesn't put up a very good case. If you need access to fucking magic invincibility for your philosophy to not be rendered moot instantly, then it lampshades how objectively bad it is for normal humans.The only circumstance where pacifism makes any sense is for Christians who literally intend to let themselves be martyred, because that shit definitely gets you killed FAST, especially in that time period.
>>286741599How about punishing murder? Or reoffenders?
>commonplace to tell tourists to kill themselves etc.>but somehow murder is wrong
>>286744275well you're not murdering them
>>286744445Yes, but encouraging suicide isn't that far down the moral ladder.
>>286734109Alot of today’s problems can be solved with murder.
>>286744537I don't think anyone is genuinely encouraging suicide, this is just a way of speaking. When faced with a real dead person most people (not all, but most) would feel appropriately shocked.
>>286734109he lost though
>>2867445524ch culture has proven historically to not really be like that, with suicides usually being turned into memes and mocked if the victim is deemed sufficiently "stupid", im sure not literally everyone saying "kys tourist" wants actual blood on their hands but its undeniable a pretty large chunk of people with those attitudes believe that death is a deserved thing for being mildly annoying to them over the internet when it comes to japanese cartoons
>>286745098Honestly I think these are two different beasts. Not sure exactly how many people have disregard for life sanctity but I think these are still majority internet tough guys rather than actual psychopaths.
>>286734109Yeah but murders usually don't care, and you can sacrifice yourself for those empty words or fight back
>>286734421Nah it isn't, it will avoid future victims.
>>286734109>Murder is inherently wrongOk tell that to the natives that killed his friends lmao.
>>286734588Sin is a concept that requires a god. So it's begging the question of which god deems it a sin? Because MOST of the characters ever called "god" have been more than ok with murder, even among the rare few who aren't reputed to have murdered anyone directly themselves (in fact, I do not actually know of any gods who haven't committed murder in their various myth cycles).So, I mean, I'm just as interested about what the fucking Jedi or Dumbledore have to say on the topic, and they murder pretty frequently in their stories. But at least they're modern characters with something relevant to say about contemporary life.
Murder is wrong, killing is not.Murder is always killing someone, killing is not always murder.Just as all squares are rectangles, and yet not all rectangles are squares.For example killing in self defense is not murder.Executing a convict is not murder.
>>286742631>t. Peter Singer
>>286738314He was a fool.
