What are some telltale signs that a manga was written by a woman?
>>287447496Is it the new shonen no abyss?
when the characters are well written
>>287447545>well written characters>female author
>>287447496Long fingersMC is a psychopath
When the female characters try to sound smart.
>>287447526yes
>>287447496What is this and why do I get ntr ing vibes?
>>287447496The women have big boobs
>>287447496Used goods apologism
>>287447496Big hands
>>287447622While a male author: Being a manwhore is the ultimate power fantasy.
>>287447496Height-gap
>>287447941
>>287447987>He dropped out of college...>He lives with his parents...>He never leaves the house...>He draws porn for a living...>He has bad posture...>But he's tall...
>>287447496Male characters having an ounce of testosterone.
>>287447496MC has a sex drive
>>287447496There are pedobait characters.
Male MC is a tall shy guy with a hidden talent that makes the Fem MC fall in love with him
>>287448062pretty sure he graduated
The male love interest is a tall guy with chiselled chin and broad shoulders and huge hands. If he's a boyfailure type character he will cover his mouth and look away whenever he's embarrassed
Use of males as performative set pieces rather than actual characters
>>287447496when the character development and relationships are thrown under the bus and the mc marries her daughter.
>>287448062>>287447987>>287447941>massive height gap in manga for womenZzzzz>massive height gap in manga for menMuh pedophiliaWhy this
>>287448168Male MC is an asshole gigachad who rapes me so good.
>>287447820Women and men are not the same. Holding a woman to the standards that you'd hold a man to (and vice versa) is retarded. That being said 'I woke up as chad and rape-enslaved all the women in the magical kingdom' emerges from a similar worldview as 'I was railed by 100 werewolves please marry me' albeit through a male lens.
>>287447606Best girl, needs to win
Attractive male characters and snazzy outfits. Characters that are attractive because of what they say or do (can still be physically attractvie ofc). Character quirks & relationships that seem to be based on real life, as opposed to based on other fiction.
Obligatory scene where the male interest takes care of a little kid maybe they get lost and are looking for their mom and we get a whole chapter about how hot tall guy is also good with kids and would make a good father
>>287448463You are simply excusing your hypocrisy because you want you self insert to fuck a harem of women and be respected while you scream "slut" if one girl fucked another guy.
>>287447496She gets the fairytale ending.
>>287447496MC is a woman and the artist gives a shit enough to dress her up /fa/shionably and she has a lot of outfits. Might even retract on the woman bit because men tend to be dolled up too but can't think of examples. Did Xiaoran have a lot of outfits?
>>287447622massive true, they protect their market value because that is the most vital part of their survival. Anything to escape responsibility, that is a woman writing.
>>287447820this is a disingenuous comparison. One is boldly accepting a behavior and not making excuses for it, the other is making excuses for bold behavior and not accepting the reality of the consequences.
>>287447496Shoujo/Josei artists: Objectively attractive yet somehow unsexy fmc.
>>287448912First one never faces consequences so there isn't anything bold about it. And if there are consequences they are a joke never make him look bad.
>>287447496An actual bitch or flawed female lead as opposed to a neutered "tsundere" fem-simp.
>>287449344Probably
>>287447496Main heroine sleeps with multiple men
>>287448755Nothing I said was hypocritical, and I never said that harems were good. My point was that although men and women have differing desires and express themselves differently, these 2 tropes emerge from a similar frame of mind.
>>287449344>flawedIf by flawed you mean victimized sure. Female leads made by female authors are rarely flawed
Extremely realistic menhera/bipoIar woman I would say.Also a fuck ton of needless suffering and drama type "he had an affair and now the conclusion is that the MC is homeless lolol"
>>287448486QRD?
>>287447638Chapters when?
>>287449262what consequences would he face? women love a man with experience, and abhor a man without it. That's not some incel shit, that's literally the sexual market. how are you going to point out hypocrisy when you are the very cause of the matter at hand?
>>287447496Sigh, I mean I know what kind of shit I'm getting into but I'll enjoy the trash anyway.I'm dirty whore for this kind of suffering
Other than what's already been said, female authors are more likely to write uncommon relationships (age-gap, incest, abusive, NTR, etc.)I think male writers are too worried about being labeled as perverts so they end up writing extremely pure relationship where the male refuses to make any move on the girl while female writers don't care that much about that
>>287450477men just want to love someone who loves themwomen are the neurotic weirdoes who demand they standout among their peers because female intra-sexual competition is absolutely insane Machiavellian game of social dynamics
>>287447496The male characters are more interesting than the female characters.
You just know that his male friend is turbogay for him and that this bitch was abused by her ojiisan uncle.
>>287450077If you want to fuck around you'll be around women who fuck around.
>>287450770Indeed, but the kind of men who fuck around don't mind the woman who fuck around, they just don't stick around. Its only the guys who want to commit that end up holding the bag.
>>287450609You expect she will copy paste Boy's Abyss?
>>287450826According to these boards if a girl had a boyfriend in the past she is subhuman while their fuckboy MC is fine for having fucked everything that moves.
>>287447496>What are some telltale signs that a manga was written by a woman?NTR/rape
>>287450995Oh I didn't know you were talking about incels/Otaku/oddballs. I was talking about normies and the larger social media circles at large. People here largely live in fantasy, without ever having the opportunity to practice their theory. I don't expect consistency, and their view of reality is through references twisted with a fantastical lense.
>>287451415sir this is an incel/otaku/oddball website
>>287448062Is height really that important to women?
Fucking crazy that Hellsing was written by a guy,it has all the signs of female author
>>287447496mango name?
>>287451932Haunted Peak
>>287452174>boy's abyss authoroh boy time for more mexican telenovela drama
>>287447559Yes, and?
>>287452223So far it seems a little more thriller and less missery porn than boy's abyss and I hope it remains like that. Boy's abyss was funny at how miserable the characters were at some point, but missery becomes boring at some point
>>287448416No one is saying this ITT
>>287452370Which is kinda funny considering in all those manga the male is an adult and the girl is underage
>>287450477Speaking of NTR, I keep seeing a Xitter post saying that it’s mainly written by women, but not so much a proper number to back it up in favor of “most popular categories”. Koreans gobble NTR up like candy, though.>>287451805It is, but there’s a lot of social media bullshit that conflates “tall” to being over 6 feet. Many women have a poor understanding of measurements.>>287451846Japanese in particular are more alike in certain writing qualities than you think.
>>287452332Both Himegoto and Boy's abyss featured trans characters, a girl being molested as a child, hags preying on younger men and NTR so I expect this new manga to include most of those too
>>287447496DV
>>287447496Besides the FemC being whisked away by Rapechad McBighands:>extra details on clothing, accessories, and costumes, particularly with frills, lace, swimsuits and underwear>”subtle” big breasts where they’re visible in baggy/loose clothing as opposed to being vacuum-sealed>historical fiction >sparkly water droplets, especially in bath and shower scenes>some focus on cooking at home>age gaps with both older men and women>>287450532Isn’t standing out good as opposed to jealous fat uggos wanting to make every girl a miserable slut?
>>287448583Women just want to fuck their dadsNow that I think about it, men just want to fuck their moms tooDo we all just want to fuck our parents?
>>287451805extremely
>>287452934>Do we all just want to fuck our parents?No. I want a daughterwife
>>287448062I'm liking this one so far, hope they get together early on
>>287453312I like it purely for the fact it makes normgroids who think the Horimiya anime is good seethe in agegap fury
>>287448168No>>287448426Yes
>>287447496The main guy doesn't react like he's getting his nails ripped off when he sees an extra square inch of skin
>>287452934Am sure Jung has some explanation for this but I was always into older girls/women and the only thing I want to do with younger girls is kick them with my steel boots,cannot be a pedo even if I wanted
>>287447941Rest in peace Cocoa Fujiwara my queen
>>287452677The MC's best friend seems to be gay already
>>287447496>What are some telltale signs that a manga was written by a woman?Males crossdressing.
>>287447987Height gap is surface level. You know it's the real stuff when there's a lot of emphasis on how easily the guy can carry and manhandle the girl and she looks like a child in his arms.
>>287454124
>>287454141
>>287454124I swear I've had girls hug me extra long just because I am a tall guy and it was a novel/first-time experience for them
>>287447987>His hand is larger than her head lmao
we've been over this
>>287454344kek and true
>>287453690That's textbook repression lmao
>>287447496Loli fanservice.
>>287450888She will surely mix some stuff to keep it spicy but I believe she will make this series very entertaining like boy's abyss. I'm just waiting on sensei 2.0
>>287447820If anything, a hentai protagonist is a much more honest depiction of what people want. Look at Rance.
>>287447496>spamming/template thread
>>287447622Trvke
>>287450995Because she is a subhuman. Are you trying to debate that?
>>287447496Scratchy line art. Men are tall and thin. 10,000 years put into the detail of dresses. Girls are pretty but not sexy.>>287447820I can't think of any male MCs written by men who are manwhores unless it's some porn harem series. They're usually virgins who save themselves for the Love Interest.Also, women like sexually successful men.
>>287454344No. I want a third option. I want THIS. Plus she's a hung futa.
>>287447496If the author has a woman's name.
>>287447622Based and redpilled
>>287455733Could be a pen name
>>287447820That's the western male author, japanse male author makes their male character cum inside their pants just by touching girls
>>287451805unfortunately, superficial men enable it too.
>>287448231People are always posting about rapechads but I feel like you almost never see them for real. Instead I feel like male leads in female written stories are all motherfuckers like this guy now and they might be even less realistic.>I want a man who's unappealing enough from the outside that I would never reasonably expect there to be any competition for him, but also he's secretly hot and puts me above everything ever and also knows exactly the right thing to say at all times and he'll never leave me because he has no better optionsLike you go through this thread and I'm not sure there's actually a single rapechad serial killer bad boy character actually being posted. It's entirely boyfailures who do triple fucking duty as your perfect boyfriend, the dad you're allowed to have sex with, and the son that's dependent on your approval to fix him.
>>287455140What
>>287447496Girl is frustrated at a guy (usually older) because he loves to sexually harass and tease her. Of course, he's only doing this because he's in love with her but she doesn't realize it yet. She falls in love with him eventually.
>>287448062I don’t really see the downsides, desu.It doesn’t take much for men to be satisfied with a very simple lifestyle, like that meme where there’s only a TV and a recliner. Only gold diggers get jealous.
>>287456057Women fucking hate that because they're status obsessed who want to show off and make other women jealous. A content man who isn't some ambition millionaire sociopath is hard to show off compared to you showing up to brunch with a Chanel bag
>>287451638>kyaa my dainty bare feet fit inside his big, strong handsSign of a female writer
>>287447496Rape fantasies.
>>287447496Everyone is hot
>>287447526>>287447572>Is it the new shonen no abyss?If this is nothing like Shonen i'm gonna find and kill both of you
>>287447496When there's an asshole spiky hair dude but somehow gets redeemed to be actually nice but kept some assholey personality after redemption
>>287456081I don’t disagree. Then again, a lot of women date and bang broke sociopaths before “settling”, too.
>>287455956>I want a man who's unappealing enough from the outside that I would never reasonably expect there to be any competition for himWhat are you on? It's a super common in shoujo for the male lead to be the most popular guy and all the girls are infatuated with him, but he chooses the MC because she's different.
>>287447496I just read thisWhat is this girl's problem? Predictions?
>>287457298she likes mc, and his gay/cuck friend isn't willing to fuck her for his sakeat the moment it looks like she's playing games with him
>>287457298Her dad uses her as an onahole since gradeschool
Woman falls for a bad boy and wants to devote her life to him. Honestly I fucking love shoujo manga. I don't know exactly what it is but it's likely a combination of the kinds of stories you typically get and how women tend to write character interactions. Not that all of it is good. I've read some garbage.
>>287457381Why are they giants floating above the clouds?
>>287457298She's a manipulative bitch and the gay best friend knows it.
>>287457338>>287457370>>287457438Why did we assume the best friend was gay?
>>287457405People who complain about shounen art should check out some shoujo manga at some point. There's plenty with good art but the threshold imo seems lower. That image is from the Ouran mangaka, iirc her first series. I think the art looks fine, though it's obviously more amaturish than her later stuff. They're in water. There's just no background and the water isn't drawn very well (or at all).
>>287457381>>287457487they're great with atmosphere too, that's why i read shoujo and seinen i should check out josei sometime
>>287447638if anyone doesn't know, drink water from a glass with a spoon in it. put the handle on your tongue. the mental effort to keep yourself from swallowing the spoon eliminates hiccups almost immediately.
unapologetically promiscuous heroines
>>287457298She is bipolar around him, we will found out later why
>>287454297Perfect for headpats
weaponized cuckoldry
>>287457381That's not even true for 99% of shoujo. There girl usually moves around between loves rivals like a sentimental hot potato until she settles for the male lead.
>character dates a million people while her one true love stays chaste
>>287447559More common than you'd think!
>>287458307Really depends. /a/ tends to focus on the smut bullshit that's like what you're talking about. I tend to read the ones that are like what I'm talking about.
>>287458609The only one I can think that's like you describe is Kimi na Todoke. The rest have love triangles or bullshit like that.Smut isn't shoujo, but they are more likely to have girls devoted to a single man by virtue of being 5 chapters long.
>>287447496>extremely mentally ill whore femcthat's it
>>287448486>Best girl, needs to winanon that's his cousin
>>287447496>oh cool, a rare thread for shoujo or shoujo-esque manga?>look inside
>>287454162>>287454141>>287454124name????
>>287458677I don't know. Try reading more I guess. Though I don't necessarily consider love triangles contrary to what I said depending on how they're handled. It's still often obvious imo who is going to win. Though I've seen plenty of people on /a/ that consider any relationship drama to be NTR.
>>287447545>>287447559Don't be stupid
>>287458829I do consider that NTR. Love triangles don't happen in real life among respectable people, and in the event they do they're also easy to end. Any recs of good shoujo without any of the drama shit. Bonus if they get together early on and it's a comfy read.
>>287448463NoWanting more than one woman is a disordered and broken state of mind as much as wanting more than one man is
>>287447941>this is what girls want
>>287447496I don't need to explain anything. This image speaks for itself.
>>287458812Norainu to Tenshi-chan
>>287447496That move where he grabs her chin and lifts it up to force her to meet his gaze so he can stare into her eyes. It's called agokui.
>>287459036And it’s fucking hot. You’d wanna do the same with a shortstack or loli.
>>287458198>real daddyWait, is she adopted?
>>287447496
>>287459214Mom started dating a pedo
>>287447496No idea, the general telltale sign is that it makes OPs seethe.
>>287448881Syaoran?
>>287447496Mouth rape
>>287459342The chainsmoker anime got ruined by the fags and NTR.
>>287447496The author's name is on the cover you goddamn retard
>>287451805Depends on the woman but on average its not tall it's "taller than me"
>>287459260Oh, but it looks like it's a nice one though? Also a common trope, I'm noticing.
>>287459397Yep, just two lines and a scene is enough to show how the writer is female, it's kinda funny.
>>287451846The giant tits are more typical of porn written by chicks.
>>287460475when women draw tits they look more supple too
>>287454344Am I who the serial killer targets?
>>287459194Only if I knew they thought it was hot. Otherwise I'll take some standing sex with a woman who will give me tall sons.
>>287458772Exactly
>>287447622NPBP
>>287448463>>287449649Logical, male argument>>287447820>>287448755Emotional, female hysteria
When she writes herself into the story for an arc as a female mangaka who is a cousin or relative or old classmate/coworker of the MC. Usually with jokes about being overworked and her editor being hateful.
I wish women are real bros
>>287447496male childhood friend never win
>>287448062Where's this from?
>>287450995Are you retarded? It's easy for girls to have sex, while it's hard for men to have sex consistently unless they're Chad.
>>287461482>It's easy for hot girls to have sexftfy
>>287447496>every male character is at least a foot taller than FMC with hands the size of baseball mitts>laid back badboy archetype >stern serious possessive archetype>'nerdy' guy archetype, who is just a handsome guy design but with glasses, somehow overlooked by everyone except FMC>love interest will be one or multiple of of the above>obligatory kabedon + chinlift scene>FMC has some overblown trauma she needs to get through>some kind of used goods apologism, often through FMC having a bad experience with a previous boyfriend >chapter where FMC has a mental breakdown over perfectly normal stuff for men to have such as an eromanga >strict father villian character>FMC has a more slutty freind who will try and push the realtionship along by picking risque outfits for her, will playfully flirt with the MC to bring out her jealous side as well>bitchy girl bully group either in the FMCs past or present, presented as either a part of previous trauma or a current hurdle she needs to get over
truth nvke
>>287461822Whoops. For >>287461453
>>287447496Rape
>>287447496>found family/adopted by father figure turns into the primary love interest.I've yet to see this trope not be written by a woman.
>>287458478Male centered haremshit with one winner does the same shit.
>>287462279This girl is used goods. Most male leads with a harem are virgins, just like his chosen girl
>>287462310Not even Tenshi had more than two virgins, and one was the loli (young).
>>287447496Beast of a man with a boy's face.
>>287462344Can you read English? I'm saying most male leads are virgins, unlike the female lead slut in the example I replied to. I also said they usually end up with a virgin
>>287461462Koi to Yobu ni wa Sasayaka desuga
>>287461453Wrong
>>287447496It's good
>>287460679The serial killer targets you if you're a cute woman
the main plot revolves around rape or incest
>>287466830That's hot
>>287455956Maybe men and women aren't so different after all...
>>287448062Picked up
>>287469792The manga art of Horimiya was definitely the best part of the series. Pity the story couldn't be saved by an editor.I hear the anime is even more atrocious adaptation wise
>>287447496Emphasis on smell
>>287470003I dropped the manga soon after they got together, the expanded cast was garbage and not worth wasting time on, it should've focused on FeMC becoming progressively masochistic
>>287470516yea, the high school shit was intolerable and the main relationship was developped like trash. I hear the Web Comic was better as well overall and that the manga sanitized the characters a fairbit and also toned down a lot of the masochism stuff.Cute main couple, but overall it was such a mess. I was so confused as to why people held it in such high regard when I was reading through it.
>>287470516>/a/ always hates when romcoms end as soon as the couple get together>when the couple does get together but continues people still complainI liked the other characters myself. I often find myself wondering if I'm reading something completely different from everyone else. Though it's not like I never come across manga I hate that everyone else seems to like.
>>287470516It was the opposite for me. I lost all interest on the main couple after the dude cut his hair but kept reading because I loved everybody else.
>>287470554>>287470516The masochism acts was a metaphor for them having sex, right? It didn't dawn on me until after he proposed since I thought they weren't doing anything as a couple that it clicked that were being a serious couple the entire time instead of just typical hold-hands at most romcom couple.
>>287462279real harem shit doesn't choose one, he chooses them all
>>287447496I have something that wins the thread. The most woman writing of woman writing. A girl and an oni fall in love, and due to various circumstances, he eats her alive. He has to eat her whole, as in literally consume every part of her body from head to toe, all down his gullet leaving nothing behind, her entire being digested inside of him. This is portrayed as tragically romantic.
>>287470662No? Not only it is pretty obvious when they start fucking, there is even a scene of them literally explaining to the little brother that they are fucking immediately afterwards.
>>287471029I really don't remember them ever talking about/showing sex after the bitemark. That's when the overt weirdly out of place masochism moments started
>>287447496When the art is hot as fuck and the author is a huge pervert>Mengo>Shimimaru>Norio>MoriSeriously I know 2D>3D but female mangaka seem to be the exception. I'd marry any one of these women if I could.
>>287470588I maintain that most romcoms have no reason to keep on going after the couple get together
>>287447496You can usually tell from the art style most of the time. The author of picrel is a man though.
>>287455956that's because it's one weirdass dude's fetish. never seen an imageboard forced meme "schizo" in your life?
>>287471147>shimimaruanon let it go... it's been more than 10 years...
>>287457487Season 2 of Mitty's show never
>>287471336Why did you post a blank image anon
>>287461586>It's easy for hot girls to have sex with exactly the guy they think they deserveftfy
>>287447941>>287447987>>287448062women do this and call you pedophiles for it
>>287461586You're absolutely retarded if you think a fat chick couldn't easily find a guy willing to pump and dump her
>>287458772out of 10!
>>287447561>MC is a psychopath>>287449344>An actual bitch or flawed female lead This is the biggest thing I notice. Male writers always chicken out when it comes to depicting truly batshit females.
>>287459101People should read this, it's really good. I guess don't read it if the normal level of complicated shoujo emotional drama gets to you, because this is way past that in an interesting way.What happened here is both of the characters were misunderstanding each other. "Rape" chad thought the heroine hated him and wanted to hurt her despite loving her, and the heroine loved him and thought he didn't love her and didn't just want him to sleep with her out of anything but love. There's a whole bunch of other tragedy going on, where everyone thinks the heroine is some innocent saint and the heroine is tired of no one caring about who she really is, even as she tries her hardest to be the literal saint they all think she is. Which makes the damaged bad boy the only one she can be genuine with.It's a pretty compelling story, with a turn of the century, scifi reincarnation twist. It's nice to have story where misunderstandings are there for more than just drama, they're there because the character have their own significant biases and prejudices, and above all the need to believe certain convenient interpretations are true for their own sense of self.
>>287451500>incel>>287451415>incels>normies>>287450077>incelGo back.
>>287471014That's just vore. It also happens in mainstream shit like CSM and YYH. Get some culture.
>>287472905You hide the yandere tag I see.
>>287472465You already said this
>>287447545facts
>>287451805Yes, second most important thing after face
>>287471336There's selfie shots of what appears to be a female on their Twitter
>bullying, written by a manWedgies and shit-talk>bullying, written by a woman11 ways to put someone in the hospital using children's scissors
>>287474998It do be like that sometimeshttps://youtu.be/Adhcs6IK-Wc
>>287447559you know youre dealing with secondaries that barely read manga when they say shit like this
>>287475229burgerbros...
>>287462724I was just gonna post, what is it in Q Hayashida's work that would hint towards her being a woman? I remember being utterly shocked when I found out.
>>287476176I was pretty surprised too, but when I first heard it I noticed just how hot Shin is made out to be.
>>287447496Virgin shaming.All simps, cucks and virgins are evil and selfish incels who chase an illusion instead of seeing reality.
>>287457338She hates MC and is hellbent on making him suffer or look at him eith contempt.Just look at how she didn't want to be helped by him or how her passive aggro remarks about MC are framed with extreme dark tones.And seens the root of her hatred is MC being a self-important and selfish white knight-ish simp.
>>287454891>I'm just waiting on sensei 2.0Special needs tomboy/NuPower will take that role.It will be painful when FeMC/NuMakima ends being involved in her inevitable death simply to spite on MC because she hates him so much.
>>287447496the female characters act like real women
>>287457484Because they are projecting Boy's Abyss beat for beat.
>>287447496New Haunted Peak chapter in a few minutes, I'm surprised the thread survived this long.
>>287447496kino pages like this
>>287477168Might as well be most hentai
>>287473357I thought vore was a sexual fetish for swallowing whole. The point is that it's portrayed romantically. Makima is a villain. What Denji does to her isn't romantic (even if he thinks otherwise).
>>287448102I try to reverse google search this and all I'm getting is worthless yurishit garbage. If it really was a rape in yurislop, then it'd be an improvement. There needs to be more dykes getting torn apart by dick.
>>287447606The prince is best girl.
>>287447496New chapterI don't think she's evil or mean to the MC. He's just overthinking everything.Then again with this mangaka's history...
>>287461453sauce?
>>287479860it's the latest translated NTR/BSS doujin made to make males feel bad
>>287451638mango name?
>>287455956I think you're thinking of josei adjacent stuff where they're courting women readers that have some sense of reality. Actual shoujo has aggressive cool BMOCs all the time, although they're usually nice morally good people.
>>287479901sauce?
>>287479973Cucks need to be dragged out of their homes and executed en masse, doubly so if they can't even find doujinshi on their own with a full page spread at their fingertips.
>>287478460He thinks it is and she knows he thinks it is or it wouldn't work because of her powers, so how is it not?
>>287447496Read the three chapters. Seems like she somehow wants his attention but at the same time she doesn't. Seems like her EGO from becoming the school princess got her acting all superior.MC is just autistic, but not a cuck.
>>287454344>signs a picture was drawn by a man
>>287480662>Seems like she somehow wants his attentionanon did we read the same manga? she doesn't give a single fuck about MC, she's just trying to make her actual boyfriend jealous, she even flirts with his ex-brother. And boyfriend is clearly tired of her bullshit
