[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/a/ - Anime & Manga

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1787855191293927.jpg (375 KB, 944x944)
375 KB JPG
New movie just finished airing.

Now we wait for cam rips
>>
Excited to watch it!
>>
SPOIL ME
>>
rip where
>>
>>290486643
So, is there any new lore on the walpurgisnacht witch? Whats the big reveal???
>>
>>290486509
real thread
>>
File: Spoiler Image (752 KB, 1229x674)
752 KB
752 KB PNG
So who are these girls?
>>
wait i thought it was in december?
>>
File: homura.png (1.11 MB, 1920x1080)
1.11 MB PNG
Let the spoilers flow
>>
>>290486798
Released in August for nips
>>
I remember back in the day with movies like Disappearance and Eva 2.0 we got camrips like a day after they began screening and /a/ held subbed camrip stream watch party. I doubt that'll happen now though.
>>
File: HEAwZW6bwAAGsNV.jpg (74 KB, 600x800)
74 KB JPG
>>290486760
Walpurgis is both the girl on the left and right
I'm still confused about what I'm hearing from the ending because either Homura got everything and then nothing or Madoka just has a job now and I don't which is which
Maybe I should sleep
>>
>>290486643
Let's go Homu
>>
>>290486643
"good girl"
>>
>>290486760
Far left is Wasu and far right is Margaret. Ancient parallels (or literal ancestors?) to Homu and Madoka, who eventually become Walpurgis
>>
meguca fatigue
>>
other thread was nuked.
>>
Was the sex scene between Homu and Madoka a bit too excessive? I mean I don't mind yuri but isn't one hour of steamy sex a bot too much?
>>
>>290486848
Is homusaya real like the trailer hinted at or was that bait
>>
Homura is one big fat coward.
>>
>>290486860
what was the reason?
>>
>>290486882
edition in the OP, likely.
>>
>>290486873
No anon, they had sex with faceless men and screamed how good dicking is for whole movie, then you wake up and see you pissed yourself a bit.
Yurifags won once again.
>>
File: NO MORE.jpg (24 KB, 290x433)
24 KB JPG
>>290486643
>Japan
>cam rips
>>
>>290486901
Do you think there’s porn of those two?
>>
Yuri kiss leak true?
>>
>>290486860
Steins;Gate troons got btfo
>>
>>290486924
Nah, no yuri or hetero kiss either.
>>
File: G7uc2g5aIAAKBxO.jpg (129 KB, 923x1704)
129 KB JPG
Like this not being the end make the whole Homura chills out in the LoC while Madoka shifts between being the LoC and Human ending that vs Homura is now stuck in a dream in the LoC while Madoka fucks off to still suffer ending that I've heard even more confusing
Because this is the SAME ENDING just interpreted differently (from what I can tell), which either means Homura won or Madoka is a massive cunt for no reason and I can't tell which will be true when they make movie 5
>>
>>290486875
Of course not. Literally the only "homusaya" in the movie was Sayaka explaining how Homura has feelings for Madoka. Because for some reason Homura herself is never allowed to say it.
>>
>>290486942
Either interpretation sounds like Homura lost honestly
>>
They kiss btw, with tongue
>>
Full plot and discussion on the madoka discord. The movie is horrible.
>>
>>290486968
post screenshots
>>
File: 1787852848193442.jpg (690 KB, 850x1189)
690 KB JPG
>>290486848
>"You fucking bitch... You did it again! We were about to have a conclusive happy ending and you just had to mess it up again and again!"

>"Oh, dear Sayaka. Its far to early to get off this quite profitable ride. After all... Its not like you will stop watching it."

>"Its...not...like i can stop...watching it...."

>"Good girl."
>>
>>290486968
>discord
Kys. Also my dad works for shaft and I can confirm the movie is a masterpiece
>>
Please tell me that it's completely finished and it won't have more future content anymore...
>>
>>290486968
link me pls
>>
File: HCKS8nWaoAA_-lu.jpg (246 KB, 1717x2048)
246 KB JPG
Maybe I'm tired as fuck and not getting something because either this is a (all things considered) good(ish) ending for Homura or she's been fucked over completely at the 12th hour.
Man, why couldn't she have gotten obsessed over any other character? From an in-universe perspective she chose the worst possible person because I can honestly see Madoka doing either option and that scares me
>>
>>290486848
>>290486991
Can you fuck off and let people just talk about the movie.
>>
>>290487007
Madoka will never be a memory.
>>
File: 1785816372875681.png (218 KB, 640x480)
218 KB PNG
Why did he do it?
>>
>Ending is open
>Again
>Status quo won
Sounds like what I feared has come true. Time to leave this franchise. I'm not dropping money on gachashit to continue the story for 13 MORE YEARS!
>>
uh oh
>>
File: HAoh_AMa0AAlv61.jpg (513 KB, 4096x2229)
513 KB JPG
>>290486966
I can see that but Madoka getting to be human (sometimes) is still way better than Homura being shuved into the dream box while Madoka is just the LoC
And the LoC is now under Kyubey's control too apparently so???
Just wtf man
>>
File: HC3lcReaAAAfmiS.jpg (822 KB, 2675x4096)
822 KB JPG
>>290487060
>>Status quo won
Just in terms of shipping shit
Either Homura (mostly) won a non-fucked version of Rebellion where she let Madoka take her or she got Sayaka'd and Madoka will still be always suffering as the Law of Cycles until it dies
>>
>>290487007
We are getting more Madoka, Shaft got their shit together and theyll do a tv season in a couple of years or we´ll have to wait for 2033 for thr 5th movie announcement
>>
1%
>>
>>290487066
A compromise between all 3 was something I had considered over the years, but I can't imagine being able to write that in 2 hours.
>>
File: HQviAdsXkAAumnT.jpg (217 KB, 1423x2048)
217 KB JPG
Can anyone be specific on what happens
>>
Either way it seems that either the next thing Madoka related will entirely focus on Madoka and Homura (what Kaiten should've done more of) or Homura won't show up at all depending on wtf happened at the end
>>
Any reviews? Good, bad, whatever it is.
>>
So, any big lore on walpurgisnacht?
>>
So who won?
>>
I haven't been paying any attention to Madoka since the last movie. What's the point of this one again? Didn't Homura became a god, enslaved QB and remade the world so that Madoka can live a happy life?
>>
This shit is gonna be mid
>>
>>290486760
Isn't the name Margaret related to Kriemhild Gretchen?
>>
>>290487201
wall-poop-piss-snatch won
>>
>>290487201
We all lost
>>
Frumious bandersnatch!
>>
So more ship wars for the next decade?
>>
>>290487201
Homusaya
>>
Reading spoilers on d*scord but apparently this movie explores the meguca system more, how it worked in the past, how past girls modified it too like Madoka did etc.?
>>
What was the point.
>>
>>290487066
>And the LoC is now under Kyubey's control too apparently so???
this can't be real
literally no one wants that little shit to win
>>
File: HMHherlawAAW9RQ.jpg (377 KB, 1536x2048)
377 KB JPG
>>290487201
Homura, maybe?
Kyubey, probably?
>>290487158
The movie is just big lore about how Madoka wasn't the first girl to try and fix the system and that Walp tried before her and created Witches to that meguca's wouldn't be forgotten
>>
>Madoka is just the MCU now
When are they crossing over with Bakemonogatari and Fate?
>>
As long as Homura remains in character and prioritizes Madoka over the rest of the world, I don't care what else happens.
>>
>>290486758
>404
mods = gods
>>
>>290487366
>When are they crossing over with Bakemonogatari
already did multiple times
>>
File: Meguca.png (201 KB, 880x1102)
201 KB PNG
>>290486989
Here. Read at your own risk.
>>
>>290487255
Yurifags don’t really have shipwars with other yurifags t.b.h.
Fans of loser girls in yuri “yayas” accept their miserable feito
>>
>>290487289
Entropy Doomer here, so Madoka is just the last in a long chain of hopeful wannabes just like I said and she is gonna get screwed too.
>>
>>290487393
Homura indian phone scammer confirmed
>>
>>290487393
And then there's the beach scene which means Homura either won or lost completely depending on how you interpreted it
Also apparently there's a post credits scene of Kyubey fucking around at the birth place of Witches, so I guess we will get a movie 5 focused on Homura saving Madoka in an absolute worse case scenario
>>
>>290487352
>created Witches to that meguca's wouldn't be forgotten
Hold on. So witches werent always a thing? What happened when the seed went overboard?
>>
>>290487393
>Sayaka getting good scenes and screentime
I'm happy. Sorry to all the other waifufags though
>>
>>290487350
Money grab
>>
This movie seems unnecessary. Rebellion was a good ending
>>
>>290486917
There is now
https://files.catbox.moe/087kld.png
>>
>>290486968
>discord trannies hated it
Based, we won
>>
File: 1761948931602057.jpg (64 KB, 610x660)
64 KB JPG
>>290487393
>Wasu, Selma, Choku

This is bullshit but I believe it
>>
>>290487437
I don't know anything that you don't.
>>
>>290487350
>>290487459
>retards learn for the first time that japs are as greedy as everyone else
>>
>>290487431
*bench scene
Anyway, uh, from everything else I read on other sites, the bench scene makes the whole devil Homura saving Madoka thing seem like it didn't work?
>>
>>290487479
Even worse.
>>
>>290487393
The story seems interesting, but it sounds like it would've been better as a TV show rather than a movie. The new characters are completely overwhelming all the old cast besides ironically fucking Sayaka.
>>
>>290487463
Anime version
https://files.catbox.moe/kb4kqv.png
>>
They should have branched out into a moe spinoff after the main series instead of doing Rebellion and this movie, desu
>>
>>290487393
Sayaka's bandages were nothingburger???
>>
>>290487479
>as greedy as everyone else
more like as greedy as tiny hats
>>
>>290487393
Wait does Homura want to return Madoka to the LoC or not the wording at the end is confusing
>>
>>290487393
Literally who the fuck are all those people and why is Homura who has godlike powers is being beaten by some random glup shittos? Am I supposed to play the gacha before watching this or something?
>>
>>290487514
Sayaka took up 90% of the original series dude
>>
>>290487560
They are not gacha slop characters thankfully. They do seem to be all part of Walpy however
>>
>>290487393
What's Choka's deal? It doesn't sound like she's explained. Why is she hanging out with an evil schizo like Selma?
>>
>>290487545
Homura wants to return Madoka, but the other characters convince her not to.
>>
>>290487545
She does, because the LoC was falling apart without Madoka.
>>
File: HHOkFKWakAAQLMP.jpg (257 KB, 1240x1561)
257 KB JPG
>>290487351
That's what's implied in the after credit scene apparently, or at least that the LoC will be under his control
>>290487437
No clue. Haven't heard anything about it. Maybe they just die
>>290487455
>Mami and Kyouko fags lost (at least they both get one fight with Nagisa/Madoka there too apparently)
>Madoka fags saw her do fuck all
>Homurafags will be arguing about the ending and wtf it means
>Yurifags got Homusaya shitposting, Fate x Nanoha Madohomu at best and cockblocking x kidnapping at worst, and Kyouko x green Kyouko
>Nagisafags got everything apparently
>Selmafags got Kyubey shit talking her
Fuck
I think everyone lost
I hope the good interpretation of the ending is true and Homura can just sit back as being the only aware person involved at all with the LoC still besides Doka herself, but the other interpretation could be true and we will have no idea either way until who fucking knows when
>>
>>290487393
kinda magia record-esque with the remembering magical girls and stuff
>>
>>290487598
>Homura decides she was wrong
>The other characters convince her that she was right
>Homura still fucking fails
lmao
>>
>>290487560
Apparently the excuse is that the Witch Library place is located outside the universe so Homura can't use her powers.
>>
File: HJ_dViybwAA97Ha.jpg (371 KB, 2048x2048)
371 KB JPG
>>290487596
She's fucking Green Kyouko apparently
As in, from what I've heard her backstory is just the same as Kyouko's, even down to the food tism
>>
>>290487596
Choka was a former part of the LoC, and got mad at Homura for taking it away. I guess she thought Selma thought the same, but apparently, Selma was just crazy.
>>
>>290487560
wtf is going on?
Everything is extremely contradictory.
Like wildly, we need the rip RIGHT NOW.
>>
>>290487638
Isnt the Madokaverse have infinite dimensions and timelines? How the fuck is homura going to be just 1x universal?
>>
>>290487612
I know people said there was no Homusaya, but given the spoilers I do think the buddycop thing they're gonna have is, well, going to be pretty good fuel.
>>
So what do I need to watch before this? I only saw the OG series and first season of Magia Record, which I didn't care much about.
>>
File: evilmastermind.jpg (109 KB, 1280x720)
109 KB JPG
>this is your movie big bad
Thoughts??????????
>>
File: HKkhaYdaAAAWY5r.jpg (369 KB, 2310x1500)
369 KB JPG
>>290487496
It seems to be intentionally obtuse which fucking sucks because either nothing worked out and Homura or Homura won completely
There are two very different ways this movie could end and there is no way to know which is which until you watch it
>>
>>290487697
OG and then Rebellion movie.
>>
>>290487393
Sounds kino. I want to see it
>>
>>290487670
>>290487612
>buddycop
It's exactly the same as Homura and Kyouko teaming up in the last movie. It will be literally nothing "shippy". But of course that won't stop the mentally ill people who like Homusaya.
>>
Sounds like the OG cast barely does anything. Homura is a jobber.
>>
>>290487697
OG series and Rebellion, that's it.
>>
>>290487702
Cute, but psycho apparently. Even weirding Kyubey out. And that says a lot.
>>
File: HNIJuXpaAAAaERw.jpg (921 KB, 2039x1377)
921 KB JPG
>>290487697
Rebellion
>>290487702
>Kyubey calls her a retard
>>290487670
It seems enjoyable. That and all the stuff about Walp seem great.
Whatever the fuck is going on with Chouka and Selma, as well as that ending, just don't sound great at all.
Choka just being Kyouko but with a bad design just seems like such a fucking waste man
>>
Sounds like I'm justified in skipping this and pretending it doesn't exist, the same as Magireco
>>
>>290487720
Uh, I'm pretty sure more people started to ship KyoHomu after that though.
>>
File: evilselma.jpg (434 KB, 1449x2048)
434 KB JPG
>>
>Mami
>Sayaka
>Now Choka
Kyouko has the highest amount of FFM possibilities out of any character. Literally you date Kyouko you win a harem
>>
>>290487393
Sounds really interesting honestly
>>
>>290487702
Its so funny to see she fucking loses because QB could not give less of a fuck about her
>>
It sounds like it would've been better if Selma and Choko were the same character to prevent the cast bloat the movie seems to be suffering from.
>>
>>290487638
>Witch Library place is located outside the universe so Homura can't use her powers.
Wow how convenient
>>
>>290487779
No non-mentally ill people who weren't already doing it.
>>
>>290487393
>>290487429
I was that waifufag who fantasized about calling. Man, I've never felt so BTFO'd before.
>>
File: HIH6G6FboAAuOXQ.jpg (292 KB, 1451x2048)
292 KB JPG
Oh, and the fact that everyone says Homura should go follow Madoka. That seems enjoyable as fuck too
Even if her ending might be shit I'm glad she gets some recognition as being the least retarded person around
>>
>>290487720
There is nothing "shippy" about anything in Madoka. Sounds like you don’t know how THAT part of the fandom works. It’s always been delusional exaggerations
>>
>nobody talking about the MadoHomuMami fusion character
So that's literally nothing?
>>
>>290487393
Wow this summary makes Homura sound so useless
>Wasu had imposed her original identity as Margaret onto Madoka
Not a fan of this. Nips always want to give their MCs a special background for some reason but it just devalues the actions they made with their free will.
>>
>>290487393
I'm not gonna lie bros, this is starting to reach MCU levels of convoluted slop bullshit and I don't know how I feel about it. As long as Homura gets Madoka in the end it's okay I guess...
>>
File: 72t7hmlffoed1.png (489 KB, 768x768)
489 KB PNG
>>290487830
Just some girl Homura scams
>>
>>290487806
The story doesn't work if Homura is powerful. She has to be a jobber.
>>
>>290487830
She's the Nagisa of this movie
>>
>>290487806
>Fucking marvel infinity gauntlet rules
>>
I'm so fucking glad I stopped spending money on this franchise a decade ago.
>>
>>290487826
Truthbomb here, it's always been a story about friendship. Literally two characters who show romantic interest and they're both hetero
>>
>>290487830
The ones that actually matter to the story are Wasu and Selma.
>>
So Homu won?
>>
>>290487819
If her ending's shit that means she's retarded bro
>>
>Homura just gives up
Trash movie
>>
>>290487830
She was a temporary magical girl to fight Wraiths. Homura promised her a wish in exchange, but just wiped her memories when she was done. Phone scammer.
>>
>>290487709
>>290487728
>>290487759
Thanks!
>>
>>290487393
Thr last line is the only part that matters to me. Everything is alright as long as my Homu gets her girl and her happy ending.
>>
Why didn't Homura just kill QB? Just genocide that fuck already
>>
>>290487702
I love evil little girls.
>>
>>290487903
There's a bench after this...
>>
File: HD7v_AfbgAApKqY.jpg (1.79 MB, 1688x2254)
1.79 MB JPG
>>290487885
Madoka pulling a fast one on her (maybe) doesn't mean she's dumb. She's done the best with what she could
She could've had a good ending depending on how you interpret it (maybe, no one understands wtf is happening at the end)
>>
>>290487830
She doesn't even have a name, she's just called Girl A.
>>
>>290487873
Ahem, Homura?
>>
>>290487916
He'll just regenerate. He's like an eternal roach.
>>
>>290487903
She either gets Fate x Nanoha'd or she loses completely after going to the LoC
>>
>>290487848
Homura jeet memes are going to be fun.
>>
>>290487916
Homura can't even kill 3 random magical girls.
>>
>>290487830
I thought Wasu was her wtf
>>
Nips are saying that Selma was heavily inspired by this character from the PSP game and she even wears a QB-inspired headpiece during the final battle:
https://dic.pixiv.net/a/%E9%87%9D%E3%81%AE%E9%AD%94%E5%A5%B3(%E9%AD%94%E6%B3%95%E5%B0%91%E5%A5%B3%E3%81%BE%E3%81%A9%E3%81%8B%E2%98%86%E3%83%9E%E3%82%AE%E3%82%AB%E3%83%9D%E3%83%BC%E3%82%BF%E3%83%96%E3%83%AB)
>>
Sayaka won
Madoka won
Homura tied
Everyone else lost
>>
>>290487393
HOMURA DOWNSCALE
>>
File: HHuLDVUboAAJLGm.jpg (193 KB, 1200x1200)
193 KB JPG
>Leaves you at a bench randomly while she fucks off to either do her job or suffer for all eternity
Y'know, maybe Madoka is the worst girl to Waifu
I'll stick with Homura
>>
>>290487974
I mean, i guess this is just a range downscale? Infinity gauntlet rules.
>>
>>290487393
>Homura transforms into a super-devil form and takes back Madoka
Why are people calling this an inconclusive ending? This seems pretty conclusive.
>>
>>290487988
It's unclear if she succeeds or fails and then it says "Madoka will return" like a Mahvel movie.
>>
>>290487988
Because there's a scene after that implies Madoka leaves
>>
Where rip
>>
>>290487988
>>290487479
>>
>>290487982
Your waifu is a phone scammer. Want to be her mindwiped servant? Too bad, you just get mindwiped and dumped. You could say that's what the devil would do.
>>
>>290487501
Nah, just as greedy. The west does the same with every franchise
>>
>>290488019(me)
whoops, meant to link to this instead
>>290487431
>>
>>290487393
>Literally all characters (except Selma) cheer Homura on.
Only line I didn’t like. I really hope this doesn’t end in friendship is magic all disagreements between characters magically disappear slop
Conflict between different characters is the core of this series
>>
>>290487393
>>290487988
Madoka will be have dozens of movies spanning centuries and every one of them will end with Homura transforming in an even superior akuma e kidnapping her girl
>>
>>290487982
Just because she does that to her friends doesn’t means she would do that to her lover
>>
>>290487393
>people believing this obvious shitpost
10/10
>>
I hate this because it sounds like a downscale.

And i dont want Homura to lose fights on Death Battle. (unless its Bernkastel)
>>
>>290486722
Mari takes Homura's collar and she gets a job
>>
>>290488079
It's poorly written, bu the overall story seems to be correct. I see the same comments about the story in Fusetter. Selma is definitely the antagonist.
>>
It's canon that I can beat up Homura
>>
>>290488051
Lmao, they can't even make 1 proper movie in 1 decade and now shaft will probably be busy with other projects.
>>
>>290488083
Yeah, I hope it makes more sense in context. PIS is annoying
>>
>>290488131
>collab with Sunrise
>collab with A1
They're just gonna get another studio to animate it for them.
>>
>>290487393
Now will all you Rebellionfaggots acknowledge the series should have ended with the original?
>>
I was there
Homura gave up and went back with Madoka
>>
>>290487393
Does it have shaftism(muh symbolism) and good fights? Yes or no?
>>
>>290488131
Twelve movies with the last coming out in 2140
>>
It's obvious that the reason the ending is open and ambiguous is so they can make more sequels in the future. This franchise is getting milked and you're going to like it.
>>
>>290488158
>>290486991
>>
>>290487393
We Wuz Gnostics and Sheet.
>>
>>290488143
They could have done the same with this movie but they didn't.
>>
File: 121627329_p0_master1200.jpg (960 KB, 742x1200)
960 KB JPG
>>290488025
My waifu loves her friends and does nothing wrong
>>290487988
Because that isn't the final scene for some reason
>>290488076
I've seen how she treats Homura, someone who leaves their friends to sleep on random benches while they fuck off to do something else makes a lousy wife
>>
>>290488154
Apparently Nagisa stabs Selma or something. Sounds like a good fight, though Selma still survived.
>>
>>290488158
What is the next sequel even going to be? Homura trying to cyberstalk Madoka because her phone number's been blocked?
>>
>>290488158
it's going to get milked 1 movie every 15 years or something
>>
>>290487886
>Homura just gives up
just like me!
>>
>law of cycles is inevitable
the GOOD ending
>>
>>290488221
tbf she was already halfway to giving up in Rebellion. Even her devil form had dead, tired eyes.
>>
It sounds like it should've been a season instead
Fucking Urobuchi was barely involved apparently
>>
>>290488212
Unironically, could be a Kyubey vs the Magical Girls kind of Avengers movie, since he seems to have some part of the LoC now, and no one could be happy about that.
>>
>>290487393
I am going to be honest... I am not reading that, I'll watch the movie.
>>
File: file.png (221 KB, 300x437)
221 KB PNG
why did urobuchi do it?
>>
>>290488208
Well, it's not like she can die since the only way to kill a magical girl is destroying their soul gem.
>>
>>290488242
>source: apparently
>>
>>290488242
I thought the script was written by Urobuchi a long time ago? All the Homura buckbreaking sounds like something he'd do.
>>
>>290488244
So Kyubey + Madoka (under Kyubey control) vs everyone else then
Half the movie is focused on everyone trying to get Homura to wake up from the bench
>>
>>290487966
Quitterie is Selma's witch
>>
>>290488253
Because he's a HACK
>>
>>290488242
>Fucking Urobuchi was barely involved apparently
bullshit?
thought he was the reason why there's no sequel to rebellion for years
>>
>>290488253
If the movie has cool gunkata fights I'll forgive him.
>>
File: 1786156397398730.png (207 KB, 772x678)
207 KB PNG
>nagisa centric scenes
make it stop...
>>
>>290488266
>>290488275
I checked the discord that people kept talking about and someone there mentioned it.
Urobuchi is a good writer and I want to believe he'd write something less scatter brained so I'm not out right dismissing it
>>
>>290488079
It's literally what happened. Multiple people have seen it and have corroborated the details.
>>
>>290488307
>I checked the discord that people kept talking about and someone there mentioned it.
If you bothered checking it why not ask the person about his source?
>>
File: tomato.png (191 KB, 833x416)
191 KB PNG
>>290488285
He wrote it around 2015, according himself.
The reason why it took too long was because they were stuck on designs, from Ume.
>>
>>290487393
i thought the movies will be more about homu's POV
i'm already worried with shit ton of new cast doing important stuff than the ogs
>>
>>290488257
tbf you dont see any magical girl regrow their head.
>>
>>290488285
No, apparently he did the scenario for it and then the guy who did Magireco actually wrote it
It's in the booklet apparently but honestly I would only trust it if you consider Urobuchi to be a good writer and don't want to believe he wrote this
>>
File: 1757014194532723.png (278 KB, 1184x571)
278 KB PNG
Urobuchi was busy writing............*checks recent credits*....the Ghost of Tsushima anime...
>>
>>290488307
Unless there's a source I'm not gonna take that seriously. I will say that there's likely been new ideas and edits from other team members as the years went by, but the main script should still have been written by Urobutcher.
>>
>>290488253
>Absolute trainwreck of a movie with a vague, inconclusive ending that people will form their own headcanons around and then keep arguing about for another decade
S A S U G A
>>
>>290488200
You'd best be dumping her like she'd dump you.
>>290488253
The problem with projects that are in development hell is that the script changes many, many times. There's a chance that there were drafts that were actually good but we'll never ever know. You can only keep something in the oven for so long before it burns.
>>
>>290488340
>then the guy who did Magireco actually wrote it
what the fuck?
>>
The REAL Madoka Magica ended with the original. Rebellion and Kaiten can be seen as spinoff slop now
>>
>>290488307
>source: discord tranny said so
>>
>>290488302
Based. I love her
>>
File: HMDW9OFXwAAKK1y.jpg (523 KB, 908x857)
523 KB JPG
What was the point in this character
Like genuinely why does Choka exist? If she's just Kyouko again but ugly than what the fuck is the point?
Why are we wasting time on a character that just exists for a fight with Kyouko? We should've gotten the TDS Mami and Kyouko teamup instead of making 2 different characters that don't do much for them to fight
I want to like her but we don't need a worse version of Kyouko. Just have Kyouko do stuff in the actual movie, it's not hard
>>
>>290487393
I don't get why the nips are so pissy about spoilers. Nothing happens in the movie. Maybe it's to stop people from finding out how shit it is so they go see it.
>>
let's ignore the movie for now
do you think rebellion is a good ending to the series?
or did the series have a better ending?
>>
>>290488401
She’s the new recruit in the harem of Kyouko’s future husband
>>
>>290488401
Kyouko was always a nothing character, it was simply cemented by foddering her off to Greenyouko so Kyoukofags can stop having delusions.
>>
File: HGNiUjCWkAATatO.jpg (74 KB, 600x500)
74 KB JPG
>>290488253
I hope this isn't another Phantom Requiem where the first 2 parts are kino and he just utterly shits himself in the third, only for the ending to be good until the last few scenes ruin it
>>290488372
I'd test my like with her before Madoka, Homura doesn't abandon her friends, only randos
>>
>>290488401
Completely useless. Only thing I can think of is to be a foil to Kyoko to give her some character moments to show her how much she has grown.
>>
>>290488427
Rebellion is an open ending
Series isn’t
>>
>literally whos actually having bigger roles in the movie than the old casts
oh for fuck sakes
>>
>>290488377
That's some good copium. I'll probably be smoking it. I mean I already do with everything else.
>>290488416
Japanese politeness.
>>
>>290488427
Both are inconclusive endings
>>
>>290488440
Still a het franchise thoughbeit
>>
File: 1782670943735.png (1.26 MB, 1905x820)
1.26 MB PNG
>Does nothing
What was the point of hyping up this character?
>>
File: HH8hhb9bQAAq9kV.jpg (239 KB, 1548x2187)
239 KB JPG
>>290488427
>do you think rebellion is a good ending to the series?
I'd say so
The ending song with Madoka and Homura reuniting at the end could've just been the ending. One day they will be happy together
Kinda like the ending of wolfs rain
Kaiten doesn't really seem necessary
>>
>>290488427
Rebellion depended on Kaiten and now it's definitely worse. Original show's better.
>>
>>290488485
To show how far Homura has fallen.
>>
>>290488427
>>290488450
Original feels more "final" so I'll go with that.
>>
>>290488467
The original is only inconclusive if you gaslighted yourself into believing Rebellion was a good ending instead of obvious sequelbait
>>
>>290488377
They should have just done Yuru Magi, a gacha game, and been done with it
>>
File: Gx0nIjlaIAA2yYo.jpg (547 KB, 2048x1843)
547 KB JPG
I will stick by that Rebellion had a good ending and Kaiten's being either complete shit for Homura or actually pretty good depending on how you look at it doesn't affect Rebellion
>>
>>290488466
>copium
Everyone thought the series ended when it ended and most people saw rebellion as just a way for shaft to use the ip for a big budget artsy movie. A lot of people never even watched rebellion, anime originals always have some movies and shit but most people ignore them. I don't see where the copium is.
>>
Don't know if this is some hot take, but some shows are written to not have sequels. Especailly Urobuchi shows like Madoka and Psycho-Pass, he writes all his characters to interact with the plot in very specific ways to say something. But when the main conceit of the plot is resolved and they want to do a sequel, they always struggle to come up with something new to do with the characters. Like in this one. Most of them do absolutley nothing.
>>
>>290488538
>Psycho-Pass
Nothing could measure to the sovl of the Ted Kaczynski-like villain. Pure kino
>>
Oh for the love of God, this gonna turn into GuP Das Finale shitty milking.
>>
>Madoka will be back in Doomsday
Really, Urobuchi?
>>
>>290488538
This is true, also I want to titfuck Mami
>>
File: G-d6MSGaoAAZcDi.jpg (523 KB, 2006x2837)
523 KB JPG
Rebellion negated the ending of the original in a way that made sense with the characters it focused on and set up a interesting conflict that Kaiten seemingly doesn't give a shit about
Rebellion's ending is also closed enough for me to not need a sequel to it.
Honestly if the movie is shit I'll just pretend that Rebellion was the ending and that Homura's world exists in perpetuity
I hope it's better as a movie than how I've seen it described
>>
>>290487702
>>290487966
Wtf? You really can't do shit in this world! I just want to be happy!!! https://youtu.be/JNPMTtWZTCo
>>
>>290488486
>One day they will be happy together
What part of Evil Homura will fight against God Madoka you don't understand
>>
>>290488427
This current movie being meh and not even a decisive ending will make Rebellion worse in retrospect because Homura becoming the devil or whatever didn't pay off. I expect Across the Spiderverse to have the same issue when Beyond is a disappointment that doesn't properly resolve what Across set up.
>>
>>290488574
Lol, madoka has already been milked with the gatcha and all of that shit. If this movie has a sequel after 2 decades it will be less of a milking than the previous shit
>>
In a perfect world we would've had like 4 different shinbo/urobuchi originals by now but certain forces dictate they be forced to milk the one thing they made together. Though by past comments made by shinbo I doubt he really minds just milking this
>>
>>290488582
Zero shame.
>>
>>290488599
Me too
>>
File: HD72mp9asAA_QKR.jpg (373 KB, 1536x2048)
373 KB JPG
Anyways
Mami sex I guess
Idk man. She doesn't even do anything again. Fuck
>>
>>290488599
rebellion didnt even cover wraith arc which was litterally manga exclusive
>>
>>290488616
in a perfect world shaft would've finished adapting SZS
>>
File: 1787821215405753.png (1.37 MB, 1200x1824)
1.37 MB PNG
>>290488623
She should tie up Homura and make ber forget about Madoka
>>
>>290488624
The wraith arc was garbage, out of all the things Rebellion did that was the least egregious
>>
>>290488538
>some shows are written to not have sequels.
This sequel was done 10+ years ago, is not a sequel. This is part of the original series
>>
>>290488538
I have that one too. Everything must end at some point. Want to know what happens when your childhood obsession becomes the biggest and most popular multimedia franchise in the world period? Quality dies and the brand continues from pure inertia with the creators doing nothing but shitting themselves and consoomers eating it. You don't fucking want infinity sequels.
>>
>>290488624
Wraith arc is slop filler
>>
>>290488612
I only liked the 1st spiderverse
>>
>>290488599
>Rebellion's ending is also closed enough for me to not need a sequel to it.
Are you insane? Literally Madoka divide into 2 entities and Homura barely maintaining the fake world
>>
>>290486643
I just want screenshots...
>>
>>290488427
Series because Rebellion amounted to nothing, built up a whole philosophical debate for nothing. No conflict, no Madoka and Homura talking, just fucking bullshit.
>>
>>290488340
If DoruInu wrote this, it makes sense. The focus on his own OCs is to hide the fact he can't write established characters. Except unlike in Reco's case where the gachafags can be ignored, PMHQ is legendary.
>>
>>290488664
>. Want to know what happens when your childhood obsession becomes the biggest and most popular multimedia franchise in the world period?
I hope you have something else in mind and not Madoka because that would make me feel extremely old.
>>
>>290488538
This is true, Rebellion was pushing it with how they pandered to fans with the Holy Quintet shit but at least the fanservice fights like Mami vs. Homura was tied into the plot and they really took the effort to make a believable departure from Homura's character at the end of S1. This new movie seems like retarded cast bloat shenanigans along the lines of the Nanoha series that fans absolutely hate. It only becomes more clear with each additional installment that there's nothing for Maki and Kyouko to do, and they won't even let Madoka do anything because if she gets any meaningful agency the story will have to end.
>>
>>290488712
Pokemon.
>>
>>290488710
>PMHQ
Puella Magica Headquarters?
>>
>>290488699
Was it even philosophical? I thought it was just a Homura character study as she crashes out.
>>
>>290488726
>a believable departure from Homura's character at the end of S1.
She was getting brainwashed by the dumb aliens. She didn't became that crazy by her own efforts
>>
>>290488726
>if she gets any meaningful agency the story will have to end
Couldn't have put it better.
>>
>>290487611
>She does, because the LoC was falling apart without Madoka
That sounds like a fake spoiler. We literally have 2 Madokas
>>
>>290487966
Huh, so it wasnt so subtle about that she was the needle witch from the PSP game.

Neat
>>
>Homura gets btfo by 3 random magical girls

AIEEEEE DON'T KILL ME I'LL EAT YOUR SHIT I'LL SUCK YOUR CLIT!!!
>>
>>290488761
She was also witching out. Homura's basically not meant to be persuasive logically in Rebellion, just emotionally.
>>
File: madoka_12.gif (2.01 MB, 498x280)
2.01 MB GIF
Finally arrived. With too much spoilers i can't know what spoiler is true or false.
>>
>>290487393
Total Rapemura victory
>>
>>290488646
>sora iro
Love this guy's work. Does amazing stuff.
>>
Where are the screenshots? Does your tranny discord have none? I thought white people(or sea monkeys in this situation) can do whatever they want in jap cinemas. Post screenshots, you fags.
>>
>>290488812
Let us know how the movie went!
>>
>>290488758
Yes, because of the debate regarding Madoka's agency and autonomy and the whole world as a whole. There's a reason whether what Homura did was right was a huge debate, because beyond the character stuff it was an action that made you think, "what if someone I loved was in this situation?" and the ethics of all of it in the end. Madoka and Homura's philosophies also clash, and there's no conversation to be had here or them reaching any compromise.

Doesn't matter any fucking more.
>>
>>290487393
Couldn't they just make an ending where devil Homura and Goddess Madoka talk, reconcile and become LoC together and make Kyubey fuck off?
>>
>>290488158
Heck, Urobuchi already said that way before Rebellion premiered

>https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2012-10-16/new-madoka-magica-show-considered-after-3rd-film

>Puella Magi Madoka Magica staff is considering a new television series after the third film, as well as more films.

>Plans for a half-year (two cours) series are being considered.

>Urobuchi added that he would like to bring in new writers for the hypothetical new series. He explained that if new writers are not brought in and if he was no longer around, there may not be another Madoka project
>>
>>290488624
WA is a noncanon spinoff that was made after rebellion
>>
Mami and Kyouko never mattered and Madoka was always more of a plot device than a protagonist. Also it's obvious why the film seems more interested in focusing on the new characters, then the old cast. The old seiyuu are getting too old for the newer generation of anime fans to care about, so they have to create new characters to cast more relevant ones. It's the same reason why there seems to be less Nanoha and Fate in the new Nanoha series.
>>
>>290488664
I agree anon. At this point I feel really stupid for anticipating this movie. In hindsight it was obvious from the fact that Shaft kept the script in cold storage for 6 years and then spent another 5 years in a hellish production with multiple delays, that the movie had little chance of being as good as the original series or Rebellion.
>>
>>290488888
insane level of cope if you genuinely belive that
>>
From what I read, the biggest problem seems to be that the conflict between Madoka and Homura and just Homura being evil in general was completely sidelined by turning Selma into the antagonist that did all the bad things in the movie so Homura could go back to being a clean good guy.
>>
File: HOaFxZTb0AAHRel.jpg (163 KB, 1125x1463)
163 KB JPG
>>290488609
It can happen after that
>>290488646
Fucking anyone should at this point
>>290488690
>Are you insane?
Yeah. But again I'm fine with semi-open endings as long as I get a rough idea of how things will go
>>
>>290487479
If they are so greedy, why did it take them 10 years to start milking the franchise?
>>
>>290488891
Just change the VAs. Sailor Moon did it with no issue
>>
A Null Magical Girl adaptation is the only thing that can save this franchise now
>>
>>290488919
>insane level of cope if you genuinely belive [objectively true thing]
>>
hachikuji sex
>>
>>290488876
There's also the fact some reviewers mention Madoka is treated more as an object of "what should be done" rather than taking into account what she thinks or wants. Which is what Rebellion was trying to talk AGAINST by having Homura tear her apart.
>>
>>290488899
Last time I'll ever trust something that's been in development hell. They always disappoint. Lesson learned and the one time I did...
>>
>>290488876
Sure, but the movie itself was never philosophical. It was a mystery, then a surreal character study, then there was the twist at the end where Homura became a devil. The "debate" came from the fans, never the movie itself. Madoka is never portrayed as in the wrong, Homura's devilry is simply a last-minute twist where the good guy becomes a villain.
>>
>>290488934
>A Null Magical Girl adaptation is the only thing that can save this franchise now
I can't believe I'm saying this but. Yeah, I agree with you
>>
File: HECGonCbQAAS9AA.jpg (202 KB, 735x1048)
202 KB JPG
>>290488880
>Plans for a half-year (two cours) series are being considered.
They should've done this
It would've been so much better if they did
>>
The story seems good but it probably need another pass at the script. For starters, Choko shouldn't exist at all. She seems to be there just so people are shocked when Selema reveals she's an insane QB cultist.
>>
>>290488891
If they wanted to continue the franchise while still ending Madoka's part of the story they could have done more of the Magia Record shit despite how terrible it was. I'd rather a clean definitive ending for Madoka and Homura, even if they have to fudge the perpetuity of the Wraiths/Law of Cycles in order to keep the core premise of the show alive for future donut steel OCs.
>>
>>290488969
What? Homura herself treats her as an object in Rebellion. She sure as hell never "talks" to Madoka about leaving the LoC, she tricks her, rips her out of it, then memory wipes her.
>>
>>290488934
*scene0 adaptation
>>
File: madoka_27.jpg (206 KB, 700x1000)
206 KB JPG
>>290488869
I wish to know but i can only see spoilers of movie, just like you.
>>
File: 1767900908559503.png (305 KB, 670x652)
305 KB PNG
>>290488932
Aoi Yuki is already ready to be replaced
>>
>>290488876
Isn't Homura did nothing wrong literally explicit canon now as admitted by literally everyone.
And hasn't it now been canonically established that Homura literally was never crazy or unreasonable to begin with, all of it sounds like Homura is like:
"Oh the LOC is breaking down now, its unfortunate but if thats what Madoka wants now I will let her go."
Everything here sounds like she is an even bigger saint then even us Homura did nothing wrong crowds were saying.

So basically now we are at: Homura did nothing wrong and was never obsessed to begin with, she just loves Madoka in a totally healthy way and when she realized that she was obsessed and started acting somewhat unreasonably she just out right corrected her own behavior?
>>
This should've been a gray conflict between two girls that would harm themselves in the names of those they care about then give a shit about themselves. Both Madoka's and Homura's worldviews should've been focused on
Instead there is no Madoka and the focus is on new characters that don't have much going on
Fucking Urobuchi wrote Psycho-Pass, he isn't a stranger to doing something like what I described. Wtf is this
>>
>>290488880
>Puella Magi Madoka Magica staff is considering a new television series after the third film, as well as more films
Sounds based but I don’t want it to be about new characters I don’t care about, I have the gacha for that.
AT LEAST if they’re gonna do that have the old cast show up as adults and their children be part of the cast or something, à la Inazuma Eleven Go. Don’t just act as if they never existed, that would suck
>>
>>290488969
>There's also the fact some reviewers mention Madoka is treated more as an object of "what should be done" rather than taking into account what she thinks or wants.
I think this makes sense. This is not God Madoka, this is her weak helpless human part
>>
>>290488988
No fuck you. They should have made this movie just about Madoka and Homura. I don't need another anime about random girls from the madoka universe, at that point make your own original mahou shojo anime(like Yuki Yuna). Horrible idea.
>>
File: 1440294343097.jpg (270 KB, 960x540)
270 KB JPG
>Magia Record anime flopped
>Scene 0 flopped
>Exedra flopped
>Kaiten bombed
Shaft needs to play their trump card. Only she can save this franchise.
>>
>>290489049
It depends on how Homua's portrayed. Doesn't change the fact Homura's new world was falling at the seams instead of being perfect, Madoka seems to never change her mind, and that Homura is abandoned on a bench in the end.
>>
>the movie was bad
Well I guess it makes me less anxious for indepth spoilers. I don't even think being a Sayakafag will redeem this movie for me. Feels sad to think another franchise I liked is in a state beyond repair.
>>
>>290488988
Its likely they didnt found a way to extend the plot so they ended up with something that was only possible for movie format (besides the fact Aniplex likes money).

If they are doing more, i hope they´ll do the 2nd cour format or at least 1, i believe they were testing the 2nd cour idea with the Magia Reco anime but after the troubled production that happened they scrapped the idea.
>>
>>290489039
>hopes the series never ends
AIEEEEEEE
>>
>>290489039
KIMETSU NO YAIBA already talked about this cancerous mentality
>>
File: HELp9znaIAAzp1H.jpg (303 KB, 1451x2048)
303 KB JPG
>>290489079
No, i'm saying if they were going to make this type of this it should've been two cours and a series
This MOVIE should've been about Madoka, Homura and Sayaka (just like the original series), it should've have been about Fucking Walpy, Homura and a bunch of literal whos
I'm not saying it's good but fuck they could've executed it so much better from the sounds of it
>>
>>290489096
>Madoka seems to never change her mind, and that Homura is abandoned on a bench in the end.
So basically Madoka has Homura feelings in the ass cause it would be better if they ruled together than this shit.
>>
>>290489079
The movie expands pretty heavily on the lore of the original anime, but it seems like so much of its story is taking from the Wraith arc and the fucking PSP game of all places.
>>
>>290489050
>he isn't a stranger to doing something like what I described
This is why it's kind of obvious whatever he wrote in 2015 went through re-writes over the years,
>>
>>290489080
>Saar the movie that came out a few hours ago is a flop because western discord trannies who thought it was gonna be about their yuri doujins are mad or something
>>
File: 1773847567658068.gif (66 KB, 350x350)
66 KB GIF
Stop doomposting
>>
File: file.png (730 KB, 1000x563)
730 KB PNG
SO LET ME GET THIS STRAIGHT.
I GET THIS GAY?
>>
>>290489023
I mean, fair I do think Homura also fucked that up and it was something Madoka should've had agency in, but it tried to engage with the fact Madoka was meant to be a person beyond the LoC and had the whole question of "did Madoka really want this? Is she really happy?"

All of that, including Homura's own thing? Gone.
>>
>>290489135
Keep in mind we're just reading the script instead of seeing it play out on screen, the execution might actually be better than we think.
>>
>>290489096
That ending sounds totally retarded.
Probably we will need to look into the symbolism of it, it's probably another flower scene type situation where literally everyone is confused and hung up on some really obvious things.
>>
>>290489096
>Madoka seems to never change her mind, and that Homura is abandoned on a bench in the end.
What a shit show man,
>>290489109
Apparently there's a lot of Sayaka in the film. She and Homura do a lot
>>
>>290486643
Waiting for camrip. If I was able to wait for this movie then waiting for rip is a piece of cake.
>>
>>290489150
But both of these characters are straight
>>
>>290489109
>the movie was bad
Nah, the movie is fine, the real problem is that it wasn't a definite ending.
>>
Should I rewatch the series, which I haven't seen in at least 5 years, or watch the recap movies for the first time?
>>
File: file.png (739 KB, 1280x720)
739 KB PNG
so you're saying this homu is a jobber?
>>
A lot of nips are pretty mad that Homura is a massive jobber and that Devil Homu felt really weak and got her ass kicked basically the whole movie. There are actually a lot of complaints about this, I didn't expect nip Megukafags to be such huge powerlevel autists.
>>
>>290488956
replace with shinobu and you have the perfect post
>>
>>290489157
Exactly. Getting so tired of these "i knu itd suc haha" posts. Watch the execution and then see if it holds up.
>>
>>290489096
>Friendzones you
>Leaves you on a random fucking bench while your asleep and then runs away forever
The less they want to explore Madoka as a character the more of a cunt she seems
>>
>>290488427
Rebellion ending felt incomplete so not fair to say if is good or bad ending imo. But Rebellion is good in general.
>>
>>290489152
It can't "engage" with the idea of a person deserving to have their own happiness by having another person FORCING it on them, dude. That's very clearly the wrong thing to do. And lest ye forget, in the original series Madoka made the choice after 11 episodes of pondering over it, looking at the history of all magical girls and Homura, and then making that wish. Madoka actively chose to be God, and Homura forcefully replaced it with her own wish to be together instead.
>>
>>290489162
Sayaka getting featured a lot isn't enough to redeem a shit plot and dumb OCs nobody cares about stealing other characters' screentime.
>>
File: EndMadoka.jpg (238 KB, 850x1194)
238 KB JPG
>>290489190
Her whole character is jobbing. Every time she tries to do something Madoka has to bail her ass out.
>>
File: 1661585860384.webm (2.79 MB, 852x480)
2.79 MB
2.79 MB WEBM
>>290488341
We all know he was busy playing with his puppets (based).
>>
>>290489150
Sayaka is literally explciitly shown to be straight, more than virtually any anime character is
>>
>>290489215
Cope, Homura did nothing wrong is canon now.
>>
>>290488609
Well, that explains why my books disappeared in strange ways, why cybernetic attacks happen so often, it seems I have been always on the list, I bet is that rat Inugami
>>
>>290489220
Selema plays the role of the villain, who did you want to take that role? Seems like the movie really wants to sanitize the main characters, Homura included.
>>
>>290489190
>failed each and every time loop
always was
>>
>>290489202
Good she didn't impregnate Homura with their daughter and then fucked off.
>>
>>290489227
Sad that this would have been a perfect 10/10 had the last season not been forced to shoehorn so much to account for S5 getting canned. Still think it's incredible though.
>>
Anyone can post recent interviews about Urobuchi, Shinbo or Doroinu?
>>
File: G5_H5N7bQAA1kix.jpg (367 KB, 1491x2048)
367 KB JPG
>>290489157
I'm just doomposting because I'm pissy Homura didn't get her happy ending, and instead essentially got sucked off and then thrown to the curb at the 11th hour.
Fuck Homura SHOULD have ate shit throughout this movie only to get the best ending possible at the end. Instead it seems that no one but the crazy psycho who wants to kill everyone has a problem with what she did, which doesn't make sense considering who everyone else are as people.
Like fuck man, I agree with Homura but she should've gotten some pushback from SOME of the characters
>>
>>290489187
If it was "fine" the same way Magia Record is claimed to be by Madoka fans who could stomach the whole thing, it's shit by normal standards.
>>
>>290489236
Madoka doesn't seem to think so
>>
>>290489191
>Devil Homu felt really weak and got her ass kicked basically the whole movie
Fuck. That’s legitimately the plausible thing I was fearing the most. I fucking hate it when franchises are inconsistent about power level stuff
Maybe it’s because I used to be a powerlevelfag but seriously, when a character is on this scale, it’s unforgivable. I hope nips are retarded and context actually explains it because no other meguca should be able to even touch Homucifer or Madokami
>>
>>290489096
>>290489202
just like my toxic yuri
>>
>>290489262
Urobuchi isn't even part of the press tour. That's how fucking done he is with this.
>>
>>290489227
how did that end?
heard it ended a while ago
>>
>>290489253
Nothing can be a 10/10.
>>
>>290489191
Devil Homu was always explicitly a parasite that just used MadoGod's power, no surprise she's a jobber.
>>
>>290489202
It’s not friendzoning when Homura never had romantic feelings for her. Imagine being surprised by something people kept telling you for a decade and half turning out to be true
>>
>>290489215
Dude you are misunderstanding me. I'm not arguing for Homura being right. I am saying it was bringing up a lot of questions to be asked of Madoka. I do agree she made a definitive decision in EP12 but we could've had that explored further as well as her depth as Ultimate Madoka upon reawakening in Kaiten complete with her agency, thus leading to a conversation with Demon Homura. Or so I hoped.
>>
>>290486643
Madoka will be back in Doomsday??
>>
File: file.png (509 KB, 735x665)
509 KB PNG
>>290489150
They hated each other in the series so much that I should have seen it coming. Yuri always does that.

[Two girls hate each other ferociously]
[Turn the page and they're making out and dry scissoring]
>>
File: 1570091012940.jpg (56 KB, 644x937)
56 KB JPG
>>290489080
Reminder that Oriko did nothing wrong
>>
>>290489322
I get it, I'm just saying Rebellion never intentionally brought up those questions in the first place. I will say I am also disappointed Madoka isn't explored as a character in Kaiten, even if I don't think Madoka's wrong about her choice.
>>
>>290489297
H e was never a good writer. Madoka was never good.
>>
File: HGs6xukbIAAwYCp.jpg (193 KB, 2048x2048)
193 KB JPG
>>290489188
Just watch the series
>>290489236
>>290489270
Homura was right but the rest of the characters should've had an IDEOLOGICAL conflict with Homura about martyrdom, happiness and what she did in Rebellion.
Madoka can and should admit that her behaviour was self destructive and hurt those around her and HOMURA should admit that her own self-hatred is also a bad thing
I really hope the movie is better than what I think it is just based on what I've heard
>>
Honestly if that bench ending is actually true, then madoka only has herself to blame whatever the hell kyubey does after to screw things up again, as no doubt that rat will go back into upgrading his crowbar
>>
>>290489241
>Selema plays the role of the villain, who did you want to take that role?
That answer's obvious, the character who turned herself into some devil incarnate for the sake of her obsession and trapped everyone in a new world by taking a God hostage. I'd argue it would've been simpler to write a Rebellion sequel that plays expectations straight and actually focuses on Madoka trying to regain her memories/powers while ideologically clashing with Homura. There are plenty of ways they could have had magical girls who were Homu sympathizers or Wraiths/Witches going out of control in Homura's world or whatever to extend the plot as necessary too.
>>
to be fair
my first impression of PMMM is that it wasn't meant to be a multimedia franchise
felt like it's similar to anime who supposed to have definite endings, like guren lagann or code geass
>>
>>290489168
There won't be any.
>>
>>290489270
Madoka has no say in anything, okay? Everyone in the Holy Quintet has agreed with Homur so she's gotta agree with them okay?
>>
>>290489241
>who did you want to take that role?
homu
>>
File: HOtpB9raIAE7lT9.jpg (103 KB, 862x651)
103 KB JPG
>>290489310
>"You, my best friend, are my ultimate best friend"
>Leaves you on a random bench and abandons you forever
The fuck is her problem?
>>
File: madoka_76.jpg (73 KB, 850x655)
73 KB JPG
>>290489096
>Madoka seems to never change her mind
Thats the Madoka i know, i loved that part of her. Hope is true.
>>
Was the 40 minute scene of nagisa working the pole necessary
>>
>>290489395
She doesn't want to corrupt Homura with her gayness.
>>
I hope you will actually wait for a proper release to torrent not for an ugly camrip. If the plot is meh at least you might as well watch it for the animation.
>>
File: file.png (496 KB, 1416x738)
496 KB PNG
I WON
>>
>>290489378
Sure seems she had a say on that bench
>>
>>290489412
>Was the 40 minute scene of nagisa working the pole necessary
Was at least Mami watching?
>>
>>290489365
Absolutely, you can see it from how out of all the spinoffs shooting out their ass only TDS was good, and even then TDS was still superfluous and not needed for the story and characters to feel complete. Madoka Magica as a concept is just not meant to last beyond 12 eps.
>>
>>290489354
What I liked about Rebellion, despite thinking it was pretty unnecessary, was that Homura and Madoka weren't wrong or right but clearly operated from out of synch value systems.
And that put Homuras wishes at odds with (what we think are) Madokas wishes.
I don't really need Homura to be vindicated, I just needed her and Madoka to have a moment to understand what caused this. And it seems the movie doesn't have that. Very disappointing.
>>
>>290489459
>TDS was good
stopped reading there
>>
File: 1786882059845013.png (46 KB, 916x300)
46 KB PNG
>>290489191
I'm ready for the downscale. These spoilers definitely don't sound like 2-A.
>>
>>290489437
Winners
>Kyubeyfags
>Homusayafags
>Nagisafags
Losers
>Everyone else
Undecided
>Homurafags
>>
What's the explanation for Homura randomly losing to some random magical girls? It literally shouldn't even be a fight, she's on a completely different level of existence compared to them. Fucking hate asspulls like this
>>
File: kyubey_32.png (205 KB, 439x510)
205 KB PNG
>>290489480
>Kyubeyfags
Hope is true. And is KyubeyChad not kyubeyfag.
>>
>>290489495
She will forever be a glasses wearing loser no matter how chuuni she gets, it's time for Homurafags to remember who the character really is
>>
File: 1730645759778.png (437 KB, 879x712)
437 KB PNG
>"no way fag"
homu...
>>
>>290489150
>>290489190
Creepy Homu is beautiful.
>>
>>290489495
The people doing the rewrites couldn't think of anything better
>>
>>290489188
Eatch the Funcutfags one.
>>
File: HIxFJJlbsAASwG0.jpg (476 KB, 1447x2046)
476 KB JPG
>>290489460
Absofuckinglutely
Rebellion's ending set up a plot between two people who obviously weren't evil, who were both very similar to each other, and who disagreed with each other
Kaiten doesn't explore any of that. I think Homura did nothing (to the others) wrong but she sure as she did a lot of harm to herself. Same as Madoka. Kaiten should've explored this and the fact that both of them are self-destructive and inadvertently harm those they love
Instead it seems like everyone agrees with Homura, Homura fucks off to be with Madoka in the LoC, and then Madoka abandons her on a park bench.
I sound more pissed than I am, and I am hopefully that it actually works in the new movie, but I really do not like what I've heard
>>
>>290487638
>>290489495
>>
>>290489495
When you're running phone scams full time you forget how to fight
>>
>>290489190
>all that posturing in Rebellion
>btfo IMMEDIATELY in the next movie
lmao she only got to intimidate Sayaka that one time and that's it huh
>>
>>290489080
I've said this before, Oriko would've been the perfect antagonist for a 'we need to hold Homura accountable for her actions in Rebellion' sequel.
>>
>>290489557
https://nyaa.si/view/1106971
>>
It's been a while since I watched Madoka. The whole problem is that there always have to be magical girls who generate curses to stave off heat death of the universe because of entropy or whatever right? But since Madoka and later Homura became gods or whatever can't they just delete the current universe and create a new one with different laws of physics?
>>
>>290486643
Will this movie finally get devilmura to get doujins
It’s insane how she has literally nothing, at least as far as what has been scanned goes
>>
File: file.png (388 KB, 804x798)
388 KB PNG
>>
>>290489599
It's funny to think people were talking about Sayaka jobbing before we got the spoilers.

Homura is up there now.
>>
>>290489613
So that's Wasu right
>>
>>290489348
It won't work, give up already https://youtu.be/gPIjhBsWPN4

Seeing the future doesn't matter when you have your 3letter fanclub tailing you
>>
>>290489459
TDS was good at first, then it stopped being a prequel and became alternate timeline fanfic slop and became shit as a result
>>
>>290489606
> subbed in English and Finnish.
Disgusting.
>>
>>290489637
It's the only good alternate timeline fanfic slop
>>
I don't understand why this movie exists. Rebellion was a perfect conclusion
>Madoka gets to live her happy life same with the rest of the girls
>Homura runs shit and gets to enjoy Madoka being happy
>Kyubey is a raped slave
>>
I haven't seen a single review that doesn't say that Green Chink is a completely pointless and wasted character.
>>
>>290489666
Maybe, but it should still have stayed a prequel. The only reason why it didn’t do so is because they thought it would sell more with Homura on the cover
>>
>>290489676
Same reason Rebellion exists despite the series having a perfect ending.
>>
Yeah this is horseshit. Pretty obvious that there's some faggot jap with hateboner for Homura on the team. I'm done, this movie isn't canon.
>>
>>290489680
Where do you see reviews?
>>
>>290489711
Nips posting spoilers here:
https://fusetter.com/feed/explore/149309
Just keep browsing the tags and shit.
>>
>>290487056
Where is the midget?
What they have against the midget?
>>
>>290489706
>series having a perfect ending.
But it didn't. Madoka and Homura were both miserable. It works much better if their roles are switched
>>
File: 100-Day_Countdown_(10).jpg (200 KB, 1040x700)
200 KB JPG
>>290489680
Literally no one took me seriously when I said they would end being Vegeta and Nappa. I also feel weird for having getting right around 90% of the movie's plot somehow.
>>
File: file.png (916 KB, 1432x600)
916 KB PNG
so i guess this is the scene where devilhomu got btfo?
>>
File: Screenshot (291).png (636 KB, 1225x663)
636 KB PNG
>>290489630
Yeah
Seems like it
>>
>>290489695
I thought Mami killing herself was a good enough finale for her character to excuse the Homura going through it again ending.
>>
>>290489710
The whole team loves Homura, they simply don’t share your objectively wrong headcanon about her motivations
>>
File: HOnR6nNbIAAuoLf.jpg (1002 KB, 2000x3000)
1002 KB JPG
>>290489747
If only Kaiten would've focused on that instead of Walpurgisnacht for some reason
>>
>>290489747
lol no, Madoka and Homura were fine in the original series until Rebellion retconned it. They would only be miserable if they were switched like you want them to be.
>>
>>290488812
>anime girl likes toast again
Anime is saved.
>>
I just want Sayaka to have a happy ending man
>>
>>290489758
>>290486760
dibs on wasu
>>
>>290489564
>abandons her on a park bench
The abandoned part is pure headcanon. Its just a story continues scene.
>>
>>290489613
Any explanation yet for why she took Homura's appearance?
>>
>>290489758
>some other random girl got gay with Madoka instead of Homura
this is why HomuSaya is real, because they're both cucks
>>
>>290489768
>The whole team loves Homura
No they don't, they don't understand her at very least.
She needs to get hyped up to save Madoka from the LoC and then gets abandoned by Madoka anyway
This feels like a humiliation ritual more than anything, which they somehow managed to fucking pull off while having no one question the morality of what Homura did.
I'm a Homurafag because I like seeing her strive and survive in bad situations (the entire original series, last fight of Rebellion), Homura getting sucked off only to be kicked in the head is the exact opposite of how her character should've been treated
>>
File: 1771517819950989.png (71 KB, 736x575)
71 KB PNG
>>290489747
>>290489807
Good thing their roles will keep switching so everyone gets their turn to be satisfied.
>>
>>290489332
I feel like this is perhaps the most disapointing possible way this could possibly go.
It's just the avengers now.
No ideological conflict, just a cartoon villain who gets defeated by the avengers and now with Madoka its just like: What about the world?
What about Homura?

It could however also be that there is something that everyone is missing.
>>
File: file.png (127 KB, 363x262)
127 KB PNG
>>290489758
>literally just fox-eye homu
that's just cheating
loved her design
>>
>>290489637
So, Wasu and Margaret are the same?
>>
>>290487393
>homura can't use her devil powers as she is outside the universe
Immense downscale
>>
>>290489749
She's not even Nappa, at least Nappa gets to die as a villain. She just suddenly becomes their new BFF when Seleme goes evil.
>>
File: HH5gw-AaMAAVMj_.jpg (753 KB, 2490x3000)
753 KB JPG
>>290489827
Until we get movie 5 anything would be
Madoka might just work the LoC like a job
Madoka might have abandoned Homura forever in some sort of LoC dream
We can't say because it's ambiguous, which leads to the obvious assumption of the worst possible scenario.
>>290489893
Yeah apparently that's what's going on
>>
>>290489892
If these 2 are ancient witches then how come they look like current school girls.
>>
>>290489827
>"I’ll always be with you"
>fades away
yeah, and dad's going to come back any minute now with his cigs
>>
>>290489893
Kinda like Toaru's movie...
>>
>>290487668
That was never true, the verse capped at universal.
>>
>>290489495
Homura likes girls, so she gets distracted in combat and ends up losing.
>>
File: HAXF4n7acAEZusg.jpg (791 KB, 1024x1600)
791 KB JPG
>>290489920
Japanese genetics are STRONG
>>
>>290489920
She looks like Homura for plot reasons then goes back to Margaret when Madoka says her real name.
>>
>>290489758
>>290489892
Why does he look so much like Homura? Is there a reason?
>>
>>290489935
Multiversal because Madoka's wish made her go across multiple timelines, thus multiple universes (infinite)
>>
>>290489871
>gets abandoned by Madoka
Thank you for proving my point
I wonder how you will react when you actually see the movie and see how Homura doesn’t have a problem with that
Almost as if lack of physical proximity with Madoka was never the problem
>>
>>290489191
>I didn't expect nip Megukafags to be such huge powerlevel autists.
If what you are saying is true and not like 5 twitter people complain. You should know magical girl fans are extremely respectful of power levels.
>>
>>290489956
themes and such
>>
>Listens to Sayaka once
>Gets taken by Madoka and Fucking dies
Urobuhchi wouldn't have it any other way
>>
File: tokyo ghoul loss.jpg (585 KB, 1115x1600)
585 KB JPG
Pic related but Homura.
>>
>>290489965
Doesn't she just go in the past?
>>
>>290489956
Yes, this part is actually explained in the movie. Walpurgis' backstory and characterization are the universally praised parts of the movie by nips.
>>
Are the redesigns explained in any capacity?
>>
File: 1579584767523.jpg (213 KB, 685x968)
213 KB JPG
>jobbed to a rando
NO THIS CAN'T BE HAPPENING
I'M IN CHARGE HERE
>>
>>290489992
Pretty sure she also goes to those who will also be witches. Any magical girl at the verge of becoming a witch. Sounds like future to me
>>
>>290488146
It should have ended with Rebellion actually, that was a perfect happy ending
>>
>>290489970
>Homura doesn't have a problem with that
Madoka does it while Homura is sleeping, right?
Fuckin Homura doesn't even know what's happening, and even if she does do you honestly think it would be okay for her to be left alone without her best friend while Madoka is out there suffering as (the now compromised by Kyubey) law of Cycles?
>>
>>290490033
But isn't the future still part of the same timeline?
>>
>>290489956
She doesnt remember her name. As soon as her memories come back to her she transforms into Margeret.
>>
>>290489807
The original series ends with Homura making a last stand against the wraiths in the desert. It directly lead to Rebellion.
>>
>>290489807
>>290489747
I mean the point of S1's ending was that it was the "best" outcome Madoka could've given all yhe magical girls with the amount of power she had. The whole system was fucked and tragic, Madoka's actions were portrayed as a sacrifice for a reason and Homura's acceptance of it while at the end being a soldier that marched on for her was also Homura making the best of Madoka's sacrifice. Madoka was quite clearly never conceived to have anything more than a bittersweet ending. Even Rebellion's ending sort of changing S1's ending was fine because it was a direct answer to it where Homura due to witching out/her own universal importance decided she wanted to change Madoka's sacrifice against Madoka's will. The problem is that Kaiten doesn't seem to address what was set up as a pretty straightforward clash of ideals by not even letting Homura be the real villain for Madoka to fight against (literally and/or ideologically).
>>
>>290489919
>Madoka might have abandoned Homura forever in some sort of LoC dream
Considering the phone ringing clearly not. They're just too cowardly to have more sequels without MadoHomu so they can't give them a conclusion yet.
No wonder butcher washed his hands of this shitshow.
>>
Is Urobutcher working on the next movie or will it be someone else?
>>
File: HLVsTTaa8AAtf8N.jpg (198 KB, 992x1008)
198 KB JPG
They should've just made a Walpurgisnacht movie
Focus on all the shit people seem to actually enjoy, set up Choka and Selma, have a bit of the LoC here and there. Do everything so that they could (if they want to, which they evidently did for some reason) introduce this shit into the Rebellion sequel without spending so much time on it.
Fuckin hell
>>
>>290490075
>No wonder butcher washed his hands of this shitshow.
Where? Also I don't think the butcher's writing is flawless, I've read stuff of his that I thought was mediocre and contrived
>>
>>290490059
There are multiple timelines as seen with what Homura does when going back in time. There is a timeline where Mami gets eaten by Charlotte, there is a timeline where she doesn't. There is a timeline where Madoka turns into a witch, there is the kne where Homura kills her. It just keeps branching out
>>
>>290490082
Someone else. Assuming there will even be another one.
>>
>>290490064
>implying the spinoff was even written before this
>>
>>290490082
If Uro actually wrote it, and if it really is this bad, than I fucking hope not.
I still don't think he did anyway, I hope he didn't
>>
>>290490108
Yes but the anime doesn't show you Madoka going into those timelines as well.
>>
>>290489459
>>290489637
Everyone mixing up the drama cd, the one thats actually is good, with its pseudo manga adaption that add a alternate timeline filler plot with nonsense drama
>>
>Madoka and Homura talk it out
>qb is deleted permanently
>they both fuck off to some pocket universe and live a happy married god life together for all eternity while the rest of the world can deal with their own problems
There, fixed everything. Of course it's not going to happen because they enjoy milking this misery porn slop.
>>
>>290490133
Nigger, >>290490107. He is not perfect, this would not be his first time writing meh stuff.
>>
>>290490069
Madoka's actions were never portrayed as a sacrifice, it was a triumphant moment for her and all magical girls with a big cheery music and all that jazz, with the only slight bittersweetness coming from having to be forgotten, but the show provides closure by letting Homura remember and talk it out with Madoka's little bro with a smile. All in all the original show portrays the ending as a good one, you're misremembering it as some super dour or ambiguous gray ending when it was not.
>>
File: GHuVu_gbYAAJ81z.jpg (241 KB, 1600x1259)
241 KB JPG
>>290490075
>They're just too cowardly to have more sequels without MadoHomu so they can't give them a conclusion yet.
Yeah
Now instead of having a good ambiguous ending (Rebellion) we get to argue if Madoka abandoned Homura or not until they get off their asses in 20 years and make Kaiten 2, now with cyan Kyouko
>>
>>290486942
Homura is now back to being a regular human in the real world and Madoka erased her memories harder this time so she doesn't fuck shit up like a retard again (she has the ribbon in her hair again but it's no longer Madoka's).
>>
>>290490108
There aren't multiple timelines. In the canon of the anime at least. Every time Homura goes back in time she deletes the old "timeline" and the karmic destiny of that timeline gets tied to her, which is why she has so much power as a witch.
>>
>>290490136
Why would they need to though? Think the show made it pretty clear what her wish did. Although regarding Madoka's witch form which seems to be the Witch of Despair (that thing with the planet as its eye) isn't actually dead but we dont know if they will explore more on that creature in the future
>>
>>290490193
>"Homura, get a job"
Bravo Urobuchi
>>
So this movie is literally Rebellion but with Madoka's and Homura's roles switched? Wow, is the next movie gonna be about Homura rebelling against Madoka again? How brave
>>
>>290490170
I'm aware of that but even then this doesn't seem to be something he'd usually write.
Regardless I hope whoever writes the next one focuses on the actual characters instead of literal who's who don't even do anything in the new movie
>>
>>290490181
Meanwhile Sayaka literally dies and has to watch her childhood best friend and love interest get stolen away as she fades away in everyone's memory
>>
>>290490159
Of course it’s not gonna happen because they know Madoka and Homura are straight
>>
so, do i have to turn off the internet until 2028?
>>
Homura is a cute jobber! Jobbing against random magical girls she just met! Jobber jobber jobber!
>>
Does it really ends with Madoka abandoning powerless Homura on some bench and fucking off? This just seem evil and mean spirited
>>
File: HCKTBEuawAANvsf.jpg (408 KB, 1024x1280)
408 KB JPG
>>290490193
Somehow that sounds worse than what I thought
I can't wait for Chouka and Sayaka to force her to remember everything so she can save Madoka from Kyubey, again, in 13 years tme
>>
>>290490243
She gets closure with Kyosuke and thanks Madoka for letting her see his violin performance, letting her remember what her wish was a magical girl, and that it was right even if Sayaka died and turned into a witch. Stop willfully misinterpreting things.
>>
>>290489437
That’s all I want from the movie honestly
>>
>>290489637
>TDS was good at first,
The past that was good was "Farewell story", the prequel, was already in CD drama 3.
>then it stopped being a prequel and became alternate timeline fanfic slop and became shit as a result
That part is what is new of TDS and is slop
>>
>>290490270
>many people who made fanart of that scene thought it was homura
kek
>>
>>290490198
Episode 11
>>
>>290490264
I think it's meant to be in the LoC which makes it less cunty, but if that's what happens than I can almost get Madoka's reasoning
Homura is the only one who can stop her from being a retard. So making her be unable to stop her does follow a train of logic
It won't work anyway since the last scene shows that Kyubey intends to fuck with the LoC again, and Homura is Homura, but it was a nice effort somewhat if your goal was to get Homura to stop caring about you.
>>
File: evilretard.jpg (67 KB, 1884x815)
67 KB JPG
Why is she so powerful it takes all the other magical girls teaming up to take her down?
>>
No kissu?
>>
is this the new song?
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BDUItFbK_U4
>>
>>290490323
plot
>>
>>290490243
Have people just memoryholed the fact Sayaka's whole meltdown was the realisation she never actually cared about him, and just eanted someone to be dependent on her? Which made her realise she is a bit of a shitty human being and she only gets peace when she accepts that her feelings never came from a place of love?
Sayaka had a full closure good ending.
>>
>>290490323
Apparently she puts on a Kyuubi-themed costume and that makes her super powerful for some reason.
>>
>>290490323
Furries are powerful
>>
>>290490318
1. That agrees with what I said.
2. Kyuubey is not an infallible source of information.
>>
Homura realizes that she needs a child
>>
>>290487152
No because the ending and what actual happens to Madoka is vague sequelhook bullshit. It's not "up to interpretation" like people are coping, it's "lol lmao keep following for the answer in the next series / movie / whatever."
>>
Fucking Homura should stop caring about her. ANYONE else, would be a better friend to her. Even her 4 year old brother and fucking Oriko would be better friends for her
>"I'm your best friend, Homura"
>Abandons you for like the third time (which is guaranteed not to work more so than any other time before)
Really?
>>
>entire movie is just 2 hour long Homura humiliation ritual because we hate her and her fans lmao
>also Madoka is now a bitch who doesn't give a shit about her friends and abandons them btw lmao fuck you
Who wrote this shit? I'm getting TLOU2 and Last Jedi vibes from this. Talk about a disaster
>>
>>290490256
Nah it’ll probably just be another 8 to 9 months before it hits foreign theaters.
>>
>>290490021
Pink is brain
Purple is soul
Despair started in 9/11

The magi are fucked up in the mind. It hurts whenever they try to control you, like being blown away by a magnetic field and losing consciousness.

https://youtu.be/kWCDA09XFT0
>>
>>290490387
Agrees with what? You said there aren't multiple timelines. Literal proof right there saying otherwise
Also your argument devolved to "Kyuubey doesn't know more than me"
>>
>>290490347
Dude Madohomu is dead.
Like, it might be dead dead as a ship. Not in the canon sense (it wasn't canon anyway) but in the sense of people wanting to ship it.
>>
>>290490366
They've memoryholed it because what you said never happened. Sayaka gets closure, but not because of your out of nowhere interpretation.
>>
>>290490006
…nothing?
Wait, they actually mean something right? Like they’re alternative versions of the characters or something? Surely they’re not supposed to be permanent retcons right?
>>
>>290490399
>Abandons you for like the nth time
just like the madoka franchise
>>
>>290490435
Its literally said outright
>>
>>290490426
What are you talking about? It's coming out next month in the USA.
>>
The nip comments are saying Homura gives up on Madoka but Sayaka and the others convince her to go after her, and that's where the ending scene comes in with Homura's new form splitting them again. The implication they're thinking is the two powers are working together in both the afterlife and mortal realm now.
>>
>>290490399
Yeah, this desu. Madoka is honestly just a shit person at this point. Homu deserves better
>>
>>290490435
Sayaka realising she only wanted someone who couldn't exist without her is what sends her into a spin. Thats not even interpretation, thats the literal text.
>>
You niggas are seriously unironically thinking they don't want to do a sequel? There's a mid-credits scene that shows QB going "just as planned" and regaining control.
>>
File: GygjlcHa4AAxCYm.jpg (429 KB, 1431x2048)
429 KB JPG
I'm going to believe Homura didn't just get episode 12'd again because that feels like character assassination of Madoka
Homura is just stuck in the LoC somewhere to be abandoned forever, that is somehow the better ending for her
>>
>>290490442
Anon are you blind? Just read>>290487393, if it doesn’t mention them then they are probably not explained. No one itt has actually seen the movie.
>>
So we agree that this movie isn't canon yes?
>>
I'm Japanese.
I just finished watching the movie.
I really want you guys to watch it too.
You'll end up in a world of nothingness, just like me.
>>
>redesigns just to sell merch
>kyoko and mami are magically cured of their trauma
>>
Did we really need an Arceus meteor moment for Devilmura
I expected better from this franchise
>>
>>290490478
>The implication they're thinking is the two powers are working together in both the afterlife and mortal realm now.
Which is where we had been at the end of the anime
>>
Lmao this is what y'all waiting over a decade for? Yurifags lose once again
>>
>>290490455
Oh really, I hadn’t seen any news on it, I’ll be glad if that’s fully true.
>>
>>290490490
Even if they want, they don’t have the resources for it right now. Probably in decades.
>>
>>290490507
I don’t really consider Rebellion canon either so yes, not that I don’t like it
>>
>>290490478
>Homura gives up on Madoka but Sayaka and the others convince her to go after her
Out of character bullshit. Did Urobuchi write this while high?
>>
>>290490366
No, her breakdown was because she kept comparing herself to an ideal she could never possibly reach, and her inability to cope with her new reality. The original comment is retarded and doesn't understand her, but neither do you.
>>
>>290490366
Yuritrannies really are comically retarded lmao
>>
File: HHnBbmUbUAAhlLC.jpg (175 KB, 1448x2048)
175 KB JPG
>>290490478
>The implication they're thinking is the two powers are working together in both the afterlife and mortal realm now.
That would be nice. I hope this is the case instead of Homura being abandoned or locked in the LoC
>>290490507
I will wait to pass my judgement after I've seen it but this doesn't seem to be a good movie
Fuckin skipping the good part of Homura's conflict, giving her it on a sliver plater, and then shooting her in the head for no reason at the end
Fuck I hope we are all missing something
>>
>>290490435
What are you talking about? Sayaka even says that realising Hitomi loves him more selfless than she did was what broke her.
>>
>>290490520
Wrong because Madoka was alone. The whole arc of this film is Sayaka, Mami, and Kyouko convincing Homura she isn't evil and had a point, but rather should have just worked things out with everyone instead of becoming a chuuni devil. The cliffhanger portion is "what the fuck did she do" and "oh shit Kyubey can fuck with the afterlife now," nobody is saying anything about Homura being abandoned or losing her powers.
>>
>>290490454
>>290490485
I mean that's not what happens in the scene where she's watching Kyosuke's performance as a ghost
>>
>>290490565
And the best part is she suffers for it
The one time she trusts Sayaka and she fucking gets abandoned again
>>
>>290490546
Co-produced by Cloverworks or some shit.
>>
>The "we had this movie already written 12 years ago" stuff was real
>because this isn't anywhere near the end but a midpoint infodump meant to bridge to more movies
>everything would have been fine if it had actually come out when it should have
>>
shipfags aside. If I'm a lorefag, will I be satisfied?
>>
>>290490428
The "timelines" are now just "karmic destiny power" inside Homura and Madoka.
>>
>>290490567
Her meltdown over her zombie body only comes in the wake of realising 'what' she gave it up for. Which was a guy who didn't love her and she didn't love either. Again explicitly pointing out Hitomi helped him while her own feelings was purely selfish self-gratification, which is precisely what made her realise she isn't the hero of justice she liked to be.
>>
Maybe instead of being emotional and judging an entire movie based on badly translated hearsay we should wait until we watch it ourselves? :)
>>
File: HCSwT1FbsAApUhu.jpg (237 KB, 1536x2048)
237 KB JPG
>>290490633
Yeah
Walpurgis lore is the highlight of the movie apparently
>>
>>290490633
The Walpurgis/wraith/witch lore is the part of the movie everyone praises.
>>
>>290490633
Only is you like literal who glup shittos from the gacha effortlessly beating homura and everything being reset to the tv series again
>>
>>290490633
lorefags probably won the most out of everyone
>>
>>290490660
I’ll watch it.
>>
>>290490633
There is a lot of lore. It doesn't seem very good, but the movie is basically a lore dump.
>>
>Yuritroons are now trying to pretend Sayaka never loved Kyosuke
>All the while claiming officially deconfirmed yuriships are canon
OH NONONONONO
>>
>>290490660
It's fun to shitpost tho
>>
JUST FUCKING KILL QB ALREADY HOLY FUCK
JUST ERASE THEM FROM EXISTENCE HOW FUCKING HARD COULD IT BE JESUS CHRIST
>>
>>290490660
Being reasonable was never an option
>>
>>290490687
Tbh I hope the fight is cool. Mamis vs Homura type of cool.
>>
>>290490633
You (alongside waifufags) are the target audience and this movie proves it
Literally nothing for shiptards AGAIN HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
>>
>>290490660
No, I've known the movie will be mediocre for 10 yesrs. The shitposting before is the only fun part. The rest will be just schizo refugees screaming about trannies for another decade.
>>
Butcher only made 2 tweets about this movie so far. One claiming he wrote the script 15 years ago and one tweet yesterday saying it's coming out today. That should've already been a bad sign since the start. And most of the video promotions for this movie, including the seiyuu interview last year where they were literally telling you how to feel about Kyubey and Homura's actions, and that Homura is lowkey the true protagonist instead of Madoka, should've massively lowered your expectations. Then they have the OP by the people who sang the Exedra OP instead of ClariS and there is no part in this OP nor the new song "Links" from ClariS about this series that was a motif except from Connect. And then they reveal that the Revue Starlight movie director worked on this movie and featured an awful scream by Yuuki Aoi in the latest trailer, as well as basically showing that the 2 new literalwhos defeated Akuma Homura. I didn't want to be correct about this. I really fucking don't. Fuck everything.
>>
>>290490658
This is just an inaccurate reading into her mindset. She more decides that she isn't worthy of his love or attention because she's decided that she's selfish, which she does because she's set an impossible standard of selflessness for herself. Her idolization of Mami as an ideal feeds into it, and she never gets to learn that Mami is also lonely and needs attention like anyone else.

She literally could have taken back her wish to heal him and still didn't, because the closure for her is realizing that she can be selfless after all and can allow Kyousuke to be with Hitomi, even if that hurts her.
>>
Selema is not a literal who, she comes straight from the PSP game.
>>
>>290490691
>It doesn't seem very good
why? what happened
>>
>lol u love Homura? Fuck you here are our cool gacha ocs beating her up and mogging her while Madoka abandons her forever lol lmao fuck you
Very cool. Did Naughty Dog write this?
>>
>>290490534
He's coping, there isn't an official release date.
>>
>>290488244
>since he seems to have some part of the LoC now
I don't know why people keep saying this. Qb doesn't have the LoC (which is still Madokami and may be regular Madoka again too). What he has is the Witch library, meaning he can go and turn girls who would become witches into witches with the books (and has knowledge of their lives). Entirely different thing, and clearly setting him up as a villain who manipulates girls with his knowledge and maybe makes them witch out.
>>
>>290490784
>>290490784
>>290490784
>>
>>290490759
> Revue Starlight movie
I thought that one was kino though
>>
>>290490759
>some unc who barely uses twitter is barely using twitter
>this means movie is bad
>>
>>290490767
>because the closure for her is realizing that she can be selfless after all
Thats the only accurate part of this post. The rest is bewildering mental rewriting of what she actually says. Even the Mami part is only partially true, because its more confirmation bias than being actually fed by it.
>>
>>290490778
>this is just like my snoy capeshit!
Go back
>>
>a lot of nips are comparing it to the last 2 Rebuild movies
OH NO NO NO NO NO NO
>>
>>290490759
Did you really expect him to tweet heavily about something he worked on 15 years ago?
>>
>>290490799
>general fagging
Kill yourself, this thread isn’t even over
>>
>>290490703
But he has all my saves anon
>>
>>290488340
>apparently he did the scenario for it and then the guy who did Magireco actually wrote it
Putting aside the Magireco part, someone else doing the actual writing while Uro does the scenario is a good thing; he's more talented as an ideas guy than in execution (see the Godzilla movies).
>>
>>290490759
> And then they reveal that the Revue Starlight movie director worked on this movie
This is the one good part. That movie was really good.
>>
>>290490829
>Madoka telling smelly neet Homura to integrate into society like an adult
GOOD
>>
>>290490812
>>290490832
Butcher uses Twitter pretty often, newfag. Also he's clearly not involved much with whatever monstrosity they cooked up in this past decade. His first tweet about Kaiten being a detached clarification that he finished the script 15 years ago was basically a declaration that he wants nothing to do with the final product desu.
>>
>SAAR SAYAKA DOESN’T LOVE KYOSUKE EVEN THOUGH SHE LITERALLY CRIES UPON SEEING HIM WITH HITOMI AT THE END OF REBELLION
>>
>>290490518
>>290490518
And that's why One must enjoy every fap session, the world could end anytime

https://youtu.be/btEnsQjUb1A
>>
>>290490828
>d-don't criticize my badly written fanfic movie made to shit on the fans!
Kill yourself
>>
>>290490889
>the only thing that matters is what surface level reaction happens
>sayaka can only cry for the reason is say
Explain why Sayaka didn't cry when she saw Hitomi and Kyousuke together at the start of the movie.
>>
>>290490193
Nooo what the fuck rebellion was perfect ai yo what is this
>>
>>290488427
The series is a clear cut ending except when you realise the last scene is Homura witching out which starts Rebellion, but Rebellion literally ends with Madoka nearly freaking out again and Homura going "I guess we'll have to fight again eventually." One of them begs a sequel a lot more than the other; Rebellion just isn't written as a satisfying stopping point because it goes out of its way to tell you the new equilibrium is very fragile.
>>
>>290490922
Explain why she did at the end
>>
>>290490767
>She more decides that she isn't worthy of his love or attention because she's decided that she's selfish
This is complete bullshit and completly misses the whole point of Sayaka's arc. That she is not perfect, but its okay to not be perfect.
>>
File: HLC3vbyXEAAcPf6.jpg (207 KB, 1672x941)
207 KB JPG
I don't want to hate this movie but I just don't like the ending
It seems purposely confusing, maybe in practice it isn't but I just don't like it
>>
>>290490926
Except Homura effortlessly stops Madoka's freak out
>>
>>290490888
>butcher can not write bad stuff
Maybe you are the newfag, he is nowhere close to being a perfect writer
>>
>>290488447
>Homura doesn't abandon her friends
Like she didn't abandon Mami to her death in the series
Or didn't try to kill Sayaka and then abandon her to witching out in the series
Or didn't abandon Kyouko to die against Sayaka in the series
>>
>>290490914
>It’s made to shit on the fans because it doesn’t pander to my retarded headcanons about this franchise
lmao
>>
>>290490934
NTA because she is happy for the people she cares about. Not that you'd understand empathy you psycho.
>>
>>290490922
Because it was a fake world and she knew it, nothing had any impact.
At the end it was real and she was back into reality as well.
>>
>>290490960
>effortlessly stops it
Madoka's power activated the minute she walked close to her, and Homura gets a fucking "it's over" face even if she stopped it, it was clear her control was never going to last.
>>
Maybe the 5th movie will fix it
>>
>>290490944
>That she is not perfect, but its okay to not be perfect.
That's literally what I said, I'm explaining her mindset in the middle of a mental breakdown. It's the other anon who called her a shitty person.
>>
>>290490995
You’re clearly coping if you think she was crying out of happiness lmfao
>>
>>290490971
That is not what I'm saying though. His behaviour so far all seems to imply that the final product has been changed without his consent and he doesn't gaf anymore, is my point
>>
>>290490934
>instant side step
Honestly funny.

She cried at the end because she had just lost a a major fight against Homura, she was losing her memories, she had been dead for months and is finally alive again, she finally got to see them in person again.

There is a ton of emotional depth to that scene, and you boiling it down to "durr she cry cuz cucked!" is stupid.

>>290491022
It objectively was not fake world, and we see both the real Kyousuke and the real Hitomi being brought into it by Homura's familiars.
>>
>>290491039
in 2050
>>
Can someone slap the shit out of Madoka to make her realise that the whole martyr thing isn't good?
Please?
>>
>>290490993
>n-no u see Madoka is actually supposed to be a massive cunt who hates Homura, her being a good person is a headcanon!
>also it perfectly makes sense that a godlike being lost to some literally who shitters b-because of some plot contrivance that I just made up!
Grt your mouth off Shaft's cock
>>
>>290491056
Unless you have actual concrete proof then this is schizo bullshit.
>>
>>290490973
They're not her friends.
>>
>>290491077
no, homu
>>
>>290491061
It was a fake world. She says herself it felt like a dream.
>>
>>290490973
>Like she didn't abandon Mami to her death in the series
Didn't Mami tie her up? Homura was the one who suggested that she deal with Charlotte instead of Mami.
>>
>>290490520
No, Homura was still human then.
>>
File: 1723208174948845.jpg (110 KB, 707x1000)
110 KB JPG
>>290490953
It was designed exactly like that
>>
I think this all could be fixed if Homu just raped Madoka into submission
>>
>>290491143
She's too much of a jobber to do that
>>
>>290491143
Only true post in this thread
>>
>>290491134
It was the real Hitomi and Kyousuke. I like how you just ignored that part. As see Homura's familiars literally carrying Hitomi and Kyousuke into that world.
>>
>>290491143
I feel like Homu would have done so already if Madoka was a guy
At this point the only thing preventing her from doing so is her heterosexuality
>>
>>290491143
Unironically fucking true at this point
Whatever that can get Madoka to stop being retarded is a good thing
>>
>>290491174
It was, but Sayaka wasn’t part of that world so she was ok with it
Her feeling sad that Kyosuke was taken is part of her becoming human and bound to the material world again
>>
>>290491227
She saw the real Kyouske and the real Hitomi together. You're wrong.

>Her feeling sad that Kyosuke was taken is part of her becoming human and bound to the material world again
Baseless conjecture.
>>
>yurifags arguing that Sayaka doesn't actually like Kyosuke
>Sayakafags arguing that she isn't a shit
Its really like its 2011 all over again
>>
>>290488970
Clearly the Symphogear movie will be good though, right?
>>
Why is Madoka so shit? She ruined the whole movie.
>>
>>290491344
She abandoned Homura again
>>
>>290491143
Madoka did nothing wrong.
>>
>>290491261
Retard, she was only temporarily back and she knew it, she was dead. At the end it was the revelation that she would have to live an entire lifespan as part of a universe where Kyosuke is with Hitomi. You’re really low iq for not seeing the difference
Meanwhile she has never expressed that kind of feelings for any female character, and neither did any other female character in the series. You will ignore this part even though you could very easily answer it by denying being a yuritroon but you won’t. YWNBAW
>>
>>290491465
I'm not going to bother humoring you anymore. Just going to remind you that you are the sole "anti yuri" shitposter on the site.
>>
>>290491490
You won’t find a single female poster on a Madoka thread
>>
>>290489275
>no other meguca should be able to even touch Homucifer or Madokami
Homura splitting Madokami in Rebellion was already bullshit and it's time to admit it.
>>
>>290491512
>It was ACK all along
Oh kek, that’s explains it LMAO
>"Anti Crack Kun"
>Hates and denies the only PMHQ ship that isn’t crack
Geeeeg
>>
>>290491565
Why did you reply just to announce you were correctly identified?

You can't be reasoned with you because you'll never admit you're wrong about anything and all you ever say is baseless conjecture.
>>
>>290491039
Here we go again.
>>
Ok but am I allowed to have sex with Wasu? She is kinda beautiful and sexually atractive.
>>
>>290491600
Ironic
>>
File: FChgZ9TVUAEP0z3.jpg (414 KB, 2728x1852)
414 KB JPG
>Magia Record was full of HomuSaya content
>Magia Record anime had loads of HomuSaya content
>now Kaiten makes their relationship the main focus, ends with them closest among the quintet
>HomuSaya artists all over twitter celebrating and in disbelief
Were you an early adopter of the OTP?
>>
File: Nietzsche.png (429 KB, 953x567)
429 KB PNG
>>290489460
>>
>>290491703
>>290491683
Crazy how both of these posts are by the same person.
>>
>>290489828
She's obsessing over Madoka.
>>
File: HFIUXWbacAA7cTi.jpg (324 KB, 1448x2048)
324 KB JPG
>>290491609
Sure man
Sure
>>
Homura just needs a good dicking
>>
>>290491815
>>290491834
>>290491854
Thanks for always making yourself look so mentally unstable.
>>
>>290490108
This is insanely retarded because it means Homura is going after a different Madoka each time, which is both insane for her to do since it's not the same person she wanted to save, who stays dead, and also makes it impossible for the whole "Madoka is so powerful because Homura wound time around her" stuff.
>>
>>290490323
Cunny strong
>>
>>290492017
The grip....



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.