If you here held at gunpoint and told to erase one from existence, which would it be and why is it left?
>>146097990Right obviously. Less black people in the left one.
>>146097990easily right, the only interesting thing about the entire show was the lube man and thats like 10 seconds long
nice try nigger
>>146097992If you want to unnecessary blacks out of your fiction, you might as well bail out of Warner Brothers entirely, because that is their idiom now.Both of these works are completely unnecessary sequel-shit as WB is famous for crapping out.Nobody flogs a good thing to death quite as enthusiastically as WB(D).
>>146097990I would keep them both and erase the original Watchmen graphic novel.
Both are awful. Nothing Watchmen should exist other than the original.
>>146098460Looks like a porn comic
>>146097990I would still say both even threated at gunpoint
>>146097990Left turned Alan Scott gay, so left
>>146098460>Nothing Watchmen should exist other than the originalWhat about picrel?
>>146098525>Tom KingErase it
>>146097990Doomsday clock shit but at least US vs Russia and Middle East proxy war aged better than HBO watchmen BLM propaganda.
>>146098653>US vs Russia and Middle East proxy war aged betterNo it didn't. In the comic, Putin is portrayed as a reasonable guy.
>>146098662>No it didn't. In the comic, Putin is portrayed as a reasonable guy.>Being pissed over American superheroes accidentally nuking Moscow is reasonable
>>146098662a reasonabls guy rhat would offer multiple peace agreements even if his globohomo enemy keeps refusing all of them and insisting on war?Damn how unrealistic
>>146097990>destroys integrity of the original book>vs some dumb tv series au about dr blackhattan the kkk and lubemanI got some good keks on /tv/ from blackhattan so Left
>>146098690Retards incoming!Retards incoming!
>>146098755>lived an amazing, fulfilling life and was beloved by his large network of extended family and friendsHe was an incel, anon. A proto-incel, if you will.
>>146097990Because Watchmen is a comic book so I don't care about some spin off tv series based on it. A sort of sequel crossover with the larger DCU thing though? Indefensible.
>>146098787He probably was in the 60s (don't blame him, I wouldn't have wanted to be friends with Stan), but based on everything that came out after his death, had a fairly active social life privately in his later years.
>>146097990Right
>>146098693post some screencaps, I just finished reading the original a few days ago
>>146097990hbo watchmen had some kino episodes with the white guy who had that silver mask.Doomsday clock was shit all around
>>146097990>implying that I want either to exist
>>146097990Right. At least left brought the JSA back.
>>146097990Doomsday Clock was definitely more retarded. The show might have sucked as well but at least he had some decent acting for some characters, good cinematography, and a great soundtrack. Doomsday Clock is largely unremarkable and has to be one of the most shameless whoring of the franchise imaginable. Lindelof is pretentious as shit and missed the mark completely but at least he made a genuine creative attempt with the show. Johns is just a hack.
>>146099824It brought back the JSA and LOS but they were all terrible and mockeries of what they once were.
>>146097990Right. Doomsday Clock was pleb filter.
>>146100252You mean it filtered plebs into liking it?
>>146097990Only one?Can't i get rid of both?
>>146097990Right. Left at least works as a sign to never pick up Johns' comics.
>>146097992Based
>>146097990Because right is set in the Watchmen movieverse. Left is a comic and appears to be canon. It isnt but it cant be overlooked or forgotten like the HBO series.Even i thought left was less dumb and ideology driven.
>>146102227>Because right is set in the Watchmen movieverse.It's not
>>146098525That's a dope cover. Is it any good?
>>146102227are any of before watchmen good?
>>146097990Right, at least silly superhero stories are more pleasing than whatever the HBO series was.
Watchmen has always been and always will be mid slop for psudes
>>146102454>psudesHoly kek
>>146102434Not at all but there's one guy who who can barely form coherent sentences that thinks it's good for some retarded reason. For most people it actively worsens the story and characterization of anything it covers, the story is improved by not reading them.
>>146100209>The show might have sucked as well but at least he had some decent acting for some charactersIn the pre-Damian Lindelhof script, the main character was looking at glass and the main plot was a war on terror shit with Dr Manhattan worshipping Jihadists. This is why Red Scare and pirate Jenny did nothing but the first episode set them up to be important.
>>146097990I guess the right one
>>146102447>>146103326>In the pre-Damian Lindelhof script, the main character was looking at glass and the main plot was a war on terror shit with Dr Manhattan worshipping JihadistsRetarded. But I’ll take that over HBO watchmen unironically comparing racism to nuclear war. Even Alan Moore called out HBO watchmen for race baiting bad writing.
>>146103524he did?
>>146103326So they basically we either get the hilariously out of touch race stuff or they pull another V for Vendetta movie trying to shoe-horn in war on terror bullshit
>>146098525I'd rather keep the trash Watchmen show that Tom King's Rorschach comic.>>146102384That cover is the only good part.
>>146102227ftfy
>>146097990The television show is genuinely one of the most offensively bad live action “comic book” projects ever. As much as I hate doomsday clock the lindeloff show is putrid.
>>146098525Maybe the only watchman addendum worse than the HBO show.
>>146098755I don’t think I’ve ever fully agreed with a post quite like I do this one. Have a good rest of your evening anon.
>>146100209>decent acting for some characters, good cinematography, and a great soundtrack.I’m not even just being a nitpicky dick when I say it genuinely had none of this.
Left easily.
>>146102434Silk spectre and minutemen
>>146106132How so? I thought it was terrible in terms of writing and the MC and Blackhattan sucked ass but it had some qualities that were worthy of kudos. Irons was fun even though Ozymandias was completely out of character, Looking Glass' actor did good even if he was wholly unoriginal. The show looked nice, as retarded as the writing was for the flashback episode it had a lot of great shots. I like Trent Reznor so the soundtrack was my jam.
>>146106493Fuck do you mean how so? The shit looked like a high schooler filmed it from a script written by high schoolers making fan fiction. I disagree on the music but you can enjoy what you like. I just don’t think it fit at all.
