[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 20240716_111535.jpg (2.68 MB, 4000x3000)
2.68 MB
2.68 MB JPG
What was the last actual, physical, published, written by someone who actually did some research, work on a historical subject that you read, /his/?
jewtube, wikipedia, et. al. need not apply.
This board is dead anyways, so I'm killing a Gervais shitpost thread to see if any of you faggots actually know how to read.
>>
File: IMG_6359.jpg (542 KB, 638x880)
542 KB
542 KB JPG
/his/ doesn’t read.
Pic related is the last book I read. I thought it was well done. Now I’m moving on to a book on Slovakia; I’m excited to start it later today.
>>
>>17414286
Based and comfy-pilled.
Currently reading picrel. They just don't make writers like Mapp these days.
>>
>>17414267
I highly recommend Lockley!
>>
File: IMG_4580.jpg (92 KB, 680x1000)
92 KB
92 KB JPG
>>17414267
I don’t read books all my historical knowledge comes from Crash course
>>
>>17414499
The average /his/tard, unironically
>>
>>17414267
Rabbi Marc Lee Raphael is impressive. His sources were systematically rounded up by jewish congregations, and the remaining copies restricted to private libraries. He might be the Rosetta Stone of trans-Atlantic slave studies, given how many primary sources and great secondary research was redacted. Same reason many of the same groups have been trying to take down Wayback Machine and archive.org
>>
>>17414267
David Irving's work (if it survives the censorship bonfires of the 21st century) will be regarded as exceptional for uncovering original sources in government archives and interviews of historical individuals.
>>
File: file.png (499 KB, 666x1000)
499 KB
499 KB PNG
>Origins of the Late War by George Lunt
Best Civil War research, most of it from original sources, written immediately after the war by a man who lived through it. Very much like modern investigative journalism, but written by someone with encyclopedic knowledge of political "inside baseball" at the time. Given the author's sympathies, sort of a minority report countering the victor's narrative.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Lunt
>>
File: file.png (315 KB, 620x871)
315 KB
315 KB PNG
One of the best sources of Colonial Era history, especially for understanding how private capital rode "stealth" on top of government policy. Author served in various governments, so knew where the "bodies were buried" and filled his longer works with a lot of valuable original source materials. Another great work by JA Hobson is "Imperialism: A Study" where he breaks down "rentier capitalism" in the context of colonial policy, showing how loan capital and stock manipulation drove many significant events (especially wars) in colonial history.
>>
Currently reading. Very complete and erudite.
>>
Great source for understanding how unregulated colonial banking cartels drove the slave economy, and exploited both sides for profit during the American Civil War. Also great source for understanding politics during the Jacksonian era, especially the struggle to reduce the power of the banking cartels. Relevant to understand the emergence of the Federal Reserve later, and the transformation of politics during the 20th century.
>>
File: file.png (1.95 MB, 756x1000)
1.95 MB
1.95 MB PNG
Great work on Umayyad Era (caliphate of Cordoba) Spain.
>>
>>17414267
I forget the journal, but it was about how animal trials were used in medieval France and England.
>>
File: file.png (2.44 MB, 1445x1445)
2.44 MB
2.44 MB PNG
Picrel should be required reading here
>>
>>17414677
>complete and unabridged in one volume
What the fuck is wrong with you?
>>
>>17414677
>should be required reading
>The Conquest of Mexico and the Conquest of Peru
I can’t think of a topic that interests me less. Why should I bother?
>>
>>17414267
Hitler's War
>>
>>17414596
>No, it wasn't really about slaves! Ignore all the Southern screaming about slavery please, they didn't mean it.
>The war is the North's fault because it just is ok? They should have left the poor South, who never did anything and had no agency, alone.
>Freeing the slaves was bad for them. Look at how badly they're doing! Dealing with violence and famine from planters trying to force them back into a servile state. This is obviously the North's fault.
Lmao. Lunt was a hardcore copperhead and perpetual slave power supporter, both before and after the war. He wrote his book as a blatantly revisionist polemic against his political enemies in the North. You're being taken 150 year old propaganda.
>>
>>17414680
>complaining about not-the-work
Buy both volumes if you prefer, wtf is your problem

>>17414682
>can’t think of a topic that interests me less.
Why reply to something you don't care about?>Why should I bother?
You shouldn't, you obvious don't read.

>>17414720
>LAWL LAWL LAW
>HE WAS BADTHINK WRONGTHINK LAWL
so was everyone at the time you fucking tool, you don't study history to find ideological validation.
go back >>>/r/eddit
>>
>>17414724
I was the first reply to this thread. You said it should required reading, so explain why. Stop getting so defensive.
>>
>>17414726
>You said it should required reading, so explain why
It's well written and thorough. You said you're not interested, I'm not here to fucking evangelize you to become interested. Neck yourself you cancerous tourist.
>>
>>17414729
Take a 15 minute break, breathe in and out, and then maybe you can try coming back and explaining why everyone is required to read your favorite book.
>>
>>17414724
>HE WAS BADTHINK WRONGTHINK LAWL
Why are you so emotionally invested in this? Your pic is also totally irrelevant to the matter at hand. Your inability to make any counterargument just shows that you don't actually know anything about the context and reasoning behind the book and just took it at face value as an honest account. Your complaint about idealogical validation is hilarious when that's clearly the whole reason you got taken by the book.
>>
>>17414762
>Why are you so emotionally invested in this?
>>17414753
>Take a 15 minute break
I'm not in love with you, I just told you to fuck off. Just fuck off, farm (you)'s for dopamine withdrawal elsewhere.
>>
>>17414772
Anon, calm down. You're spazzing out for no reason.
>>
>>17414753
>explain why everyone is required to read your favorite book
He said that it was well written and thorough.
>>
>>17414823
If I came in here and threw up a book saying it needs to be read by everyone here, required reading, I would give more justification than “it’s well written and thorough.” I have read well written and thorough books that I wouldn’t recommend.
>>
File: IMG_3567.jpg (299 KB, 1650x2531)
299 KB
299 KB JPG
This and Crisis in Byzantium. If you want 700 pages on the nitty gritty of Nazi administration and thought process throughout the war, I recommend Hitler's Empire. The 700 pages seem daunting, but Mazower's writing style is very succinct and enjoyable. Crisis in Byzantium is about the historical development of theology in the Greek Church during and after the Latin occupation of Constantinople and how it shaped relations with the Roman Church. While it is shorter than Mazower's 700 pages, it is a bit of a slow read. Though the amount of research poured into it is more than evident.
>>
File: The War of the Fists.jpg (1.35 MB, 2689x3822)
1.35 MB
1.35 MB JPG
I'm currently reading pic related
>>
>>17414267
>high IQ
>can't even post a picture the right way up
>>
>>17414898
Holy based

>>17414930
Not my fault the Indonesian goat weaving forum is like this.
>>
>>17414267
Arian's the Campaigns of Alexander.
>>17414286
pop history
>>
File: file.jpg (95 KB, 658x1000)
95 KB
95 KB JPG
>>
>>17414889
Can confirm as a comfy read.
>>
File: gordon-ramsay.jpg (88 KB, 1092x1092)
88 KB
88 KB JPG
>>17414267
>The Cooking Gene
Based culinary Darwinist
>>
>>17414949
>pop history
I guess it is a little bit, but it wasn’t that bad.
>>
>>17414976
all im saying is that we should just continue to keep englishmen, nordics, and fucking midwesterners out of the kitchen before they give us a half-frozen half-melted literal fish dog-food cheese sloppa meal
>>
In the middle of Reading Polybius right now
>>
File: cooking_gene.png (469 KB, 738x415)
469 KB
469 KB PNG
>>17414976
>>17414987
It's actually an exploratory "memoir" by a gay negro who converted to Judaism kek
Decent read. He does his best to track down his ancestry (including, of course, the white mas'suh that knocked up one of his grandmothers) and gives some good food descriptors/recipes.
>>
>>17415014
>greater than Napoleon
BASED
Nappy just fucked up the backwaters of western Europe and a decrepit Spain. The last clown from a century of actual Greats.
Marlborough >>> everyone else >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the Corsican autist
>>
Most recent read. Good shit.
>>
>>17415135
What's the thesis of this book?
>>
>>17415415
That Jefferson wasn't "le shining beacon of liberty" the way he's been mythologized as. Dude was highkey the "monarchist" that he painted Washington and Adams as through his network of yes men that wrote letters/newspaper pieces for him.
>>
>>17415425
>men that wrote letters/newspaper pieces for him.
oy gevalt, it's like a meshuggenah 18th century hitlah ova here
>>
>>17415426
>embargoes the entire east coast and tanks the economy because this will somehow spite Britain
>"h-hey Thomas, I-I uh... I don't think it's working..." - Gallatin
>"fuck you" - Jefferson
Fuck off /pol/tranny
>>
>>17415439
And then he, what, sent his goons to arrest gallatin and throw him in prison, tar and feather him,?
>>
>>17415448
>to arrest his own Secretary of the Treasury
No seriously, fuck off you >>>/pol/tranny
>>
>>17414267
>so I'm killing a Gervais shitpost thread to see if any of you faggots actually know how to read.
BASED
>>
>>17415461
This seems to be a very personal matter judging by how upset you're getting
>>
File: IMG_0826.jpg (585 KB, 1290x1328)
585 KB
585 KB JPG
Good overview but obviously not too In depth
>>
What's a good book on the GDR?
>>
File: images.jpg (13 KB, 182x277)
13 KB
13 KB JPG
Currently reading this book on Central Asia, read a book on the Golden Horde just before. I'll go back to reading the Romans after this, I plan to read Appian, Plutarch and other sources of the Late Republic I've yet to read yet.
>>17415014
Polybius is pretty fun, I'd put him up there with Thucydides. Having such a self aware and analytical ancient writer is something you won't really get again.
>>
>>17414823
They're triggered someone used the phrase "required reading" because anons say that on /pol/ to emphasize something is important or significant to their worldview. Used elsewhere, the phrase probably indicates that something is a good example of historical work, or significant academically. Seems to be the case here, since Prescott is famous for his use of personal correspondence and giving equal weight to indigenous accounts. Nothing obviously chud-like about the work from what I can tell.
>>
>>17414267
The last book I finished was The Little Ice Age by Brian Fagan. It is a great environmental history book about the 1300s to 1800s. Very well done.
I am currently reading Brand Luther by Andrew Pettegree. Which fuses the history of religion, printing, and capitalism into an interesting read.
>>
File: th-4227810210.jpg (40 KB, 474x710)
40 KB
40 KB JPG
>>17414267
This bad boy by Richard "Big Dick" Carrier.
>>
>>17415426
Kek
>>
>>17415841
Based

>>17415931
Faggot alert
>>
>>17414267
Turchin and cliodynamics journal.
>>
File: IMG_1587.jpg (101 KB, 1600x2383)
101 KB
101 KB JPG
>>17414267
I completed this entire book the other day. Basic overview m

>presocratics

Primitive and backwards attempts at philosophy. He disregards them as substantial philosophers wholesale.

>Socrates

First true philosopher who tied ethics to physics creating metaphysics.

>Plato

Invented dialectics and politics.

>Neoplatonists and other assorted post Platonists

These all vary in quality but generally they all have the same goal of attaining pleasure in the individual even if their beliefs on spirit and physics are contradictory (Epicureans and stoics for example are very similar outside of the physical beliefs on reality).
>>
>>17417876
Based high-IQ anon
>>
>>17418020
That post is like the most general overview of the book possible. I suggest reading it for yourself because he really goes far more in depth than that. I was impressed with how he would know the exact minutiae offhand (these were lectures) of random obscure philosophers like Aristippus the hedonist.
>>
>>17418049
>I was impressed with how
Historical autists were a different breed, unironically.
>>
Kino read
>>
>>17416996
It’s 2025 and the 2nd America civil war still hasn’t begun
>>
is libgen finally kill?
>>
>>17418431
Try the .gs one desu.
>>
I'm slowly going through the Cambridge History of China right now.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.