[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1743980213367257.png (335 KB, 939x899)
335 KB
335 KB PNG
Is Alsace-Lorraine French or German?
>>
It's Lotharingian
>>
all of europe is german land
>>
>>18241609
German
>>
>>18241609
French

And that isn't even the Alsace-Lorraine claimed By Germany. The original one didn't include most of Lorraine the way your pic does.
>>
It's only french until the next war pierre.
>>
>>18241668
And when is the next war germnigger?
>>
>>18241682
Once we get nukes. Don't you worry.
>>
>>18241609
>Strasbourg

It is French in the same manner as Donbas is Ukrainian. Difference is we (Germans) lost our war.
>>
>>18241703
>Once we get nukes. Don't you worry
I will not. Since that will never happened.
>>
>>18241616
Fpbp
>>
File: Lotharinga.png (315 KB, 1200x841)
315 KB
315 KB PNG
>>18241609

>Historically?
Lotharingian.

>Culturally?
Lorraine is French and Alsace is German.
>>
>>18241682
Britain and France are collapsing while Germany is remilitarizing. Look at what's in front of you.
>>
>>18241609
I've lived in both Alsace and Lorraine and both are heavily frenchified nowadays but in Alsace there's still a small amount of people who speak alsatian, especially in the countryside and interestingly many of those who don't speak it have an alsatian accent somehow (they tend to pronounce the "h" for exemple which french speakers usually don't do) , and there are attempts to save alsatian through german language tv programs for exemple.
Meanwhile in Lorraine I've never encountered a single franconian speaker, despite having lived for years in Thionville as a cross border worker in Luxembourg, where franconian is supposed to be spoken, there's honestly nothing german left there except some except some german soundint last names like Müller or Schneider
>>
>>18241609
FYI the region shown is a very modern invention that came from reorganization of French department borders, it's not the historic "Alsace Lorraine" you're probably thinking of.
Anyways, they're overwhelmingly French now and German dialects there are dying out. They also don't really have fond memories of the German Empire era since it was essentially a Prussian occupation and within Germany itself other non-Prussians were already kinda miffed at the idea of being ruled by Prussia (Bavaria's pride is already well known, but "Zwangspreußen" like the Rheinlanders also had some lingering resentment, hence Adenauer's famous disdain for anything east of the Elbe)
>>
>>18241904
Is French-Germanic tension the most kino rivalry to exist in modern time?
I just noticed EU's HQ & Capitals are located at this french-germanic cultural borders: From Brussels-Luxembourg-Strasbourg-Switzerland

I can even imagine that the Romance vs. Germanic vs. Slavic (led by France, Germany, Russia respectively) is European three kingdoms (in this case, Britain is Japan)
>>
>>18241609
Frankish, so Dutch.
>>
>>18241609
>Is Alsace-Lorraine French or German?
Yes
>>
>>18241616
Based early medieval enjoyer
>>
>>18241609
I dunno but its an interesting area
>>
>>18241663
This is a kike
>>18241609
If you think Alsatian, a Germanic dialect, is French, a Latin language, then you’re jewish
>>
>>18241682
This is a jew trying to get white goys to kill eachother.
>>18241904
This is a complete lie from a yid.
>>
i heard alsace is more like switzerland
>>
>>18241992
who cares about dialects, the Alsatians didn't want to be part of Germany
>>
>>18241996
>You're Jewish if you know historic borders and understand French administrative regions
Americans literally think geography is Jewish magic hahahahaha
Also
>Yid
Yiddish is a German dialect so yeah following your logic Jews are also Germans!
>>
>>18241996
>He thinks Jews are needed to get white people to kill each other.
There is nothing more than European than killing each other over stupid shit.
>>
>>18241996
I'm just a german who takes the bants too far. The french francicized the alsatians, they did not kill them, so it's not really worth fighting a war over. But the french have to be reminded that their current borders are the result of unprovoked wars of agression so they don't get too self-righteous over WW2.
>>
>>18241609
>>18241616
Burgundian clay
>>
>>18241904
>essentially a Prussian/Rhinelanders territory*
Fixed
>>
>>18241779
>>18241682
>>18241960
>low countries
>>18242762
>>
>>18242272
>>18242097
You’re a retarded kike, Alsatians served in the Wehrmacht by the hundreds of thousands. Get wrecked yid
>>
>>18242994
Trvke and factual
>>
>>18242994
they were conscripted, they didn't have much of a choice
>>
File: amenbrother.jpg (78 KB, 460x568)
78 KB
78 KB JPG
>>18241644
>>18241640
>>18241616
real
>>
>>18241609
Sounds pretty French to me desu



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.