[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/lit/ - Literature


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


unpopular opinion: Dune is weird and gay
>>
>He shook his head from side to side
>>
Threatening to kill your gf if she cucks you; isn't this super based and redpilled and trad, my fellow 4chan giga-chads?
>>
>>23299495
>Dune is weird and gay
No, because if it was it might actually be worth reading.
>>
does anybody still read books or do all you fags just scan them for shit to be upset about
>>
>>23299640
Who told you we read?
>>
>>23299640
I bet that image is copy-pasted from /tv/. Scanning a book for shit to be upset about is probably too high effort for /lit/ these days.
>>
>>23299495
considering he didnt give a shit about her, what exactly is wrong with this?
>>
>>23299495
if i was paul i would fuck her along with chani and also i would have a harem of concubines.
>>
>>23299749
paul was a good boy
>>
I will now read your book.
>>
>>23299749
typical plebian mindset
>>
>>23299495
Why would anyone even include that kind of shit in their novel
>>
>>23299495
Holy based. I didn't know he was an antinatalist chad. I will now read your book.
>>
>>23299495
That's why I like it.
>>
Apparently Tolkien thought it was pure trash not worth his time.
>>
File: 1713426439959438s.jpg (6 KB, 250x200)
6 KB
6 KB JPG
>>23299517
>>He shook his head from side to side
>>
>>23299495
>weird and gay
jokes on you, I'm into that shit
>>
Almost every genre fiction author was either a coomer or assumed their readers were, which means we are going to endure this sort of concern trolling with every writer who gets a modern adaptation.
>>
>>23299495
Committing to the used goods brown girl while refusing to breed the perfect eugenic concubine is just woke nonsense.
>>
>>23299495
is all the prose this wooden and shitty?
>>
>>23299495
not an opinion, a fact. Frank Herbert is a total freak.

In God Emperor, a religious cultist lady has an orgasm and collapses after seeing a reincarnated Duncan Idaho climb a mountain.
>>
>>23301946
not an opinion, a fact. Frank Herbert is based.

In Heretics, a religious cultist lady gets reverse mind raped and becomes the slave of a reincarnated Duncan Idaho after he gives her that good d.
>>
>>23299517
>He rotated his cranium back and forth along the transerve plane.
>>
>>23299495
Herbert was a homophobe
>>
>>23300248
Asimov wasn't
>>
And since you've read the book, I'm sure you can explain what makes it weird and gay, right?
Or did you just see the word Cuckold and got triggered to post it here?
>>
>Genre fiction is puerile filth
Wow, who could have guessed?
>>
>>23302626
>repeating leftshit lies
Stop believing shit you read online
>>
File: lgbt pride.png (917 KB, 768x1024)
917 KB
917 KB PNG
>>23302626
So?
Maybe it's not fear, just disgust, faggot.
>>
>>23302626
Wtf I love Herbert now.
It doesn't surprise me anyway since Herbert is fixated on bloodlines, reproduction, heredity and vitalism, all of which is negated by homosexuality which is sterile and nihilistic in essence.
>>
>>23299517
Paul Muad'Jeet Atreides confirmed
>>
File: asimov.png (2.34 MB, 1140x1854)
2.34 MB
2.34 MB PNG
>>23302639
Anon, I'm so sorry you had to find out this way
>>
>>23300210
he was right
>>
>>23302626
nah, he was just really, REALLY into femdom
>>
>>23301384
Chani was used goods?
>>
>>23302746
Dude, read any chapter with Baron Vladimir Harkonnen. The villain is a big homo, and there's no way that's accidental.
>>
>>23302626
He was right
>>
>>23299860
What does your wife’s son think about it?
>>
>>23303438
Cry harder faggot.
>>
>>23303581
I don't get it. I'm also against trannies and shoes. Am I supposed to be triggered by the fact that you haven't read Dune while pretending you have?
>>
>>23302723
Most people outside your polycule would consider cuckholdry inherently weird and gay.
>>
>>23303615
So do I, but having actually read the book I know the context of those handful of lines and calling it cuckholdry is honestly almost a bit of a stretch
>>
>>23303581
>4000% more trannies
>lifestyle becoming more socially acceptable means more people will openly admit to it
Wow, big numbers scare me.
>>
>>23299495
Non dedignum, fecisti; nam si ego digna hac contumelia sum maxume, at tu indignus, qui faceres, tamen.
>>
File: 1560090760027.jpg (99 KB, 1024x986)
99 KB
99 KB JPG
>>23299517
>>
>>23299889
No, he's a committed race mixxer.
>>
Dune is YA fiction. It's one of the first baby books that graduated into being exclusively for neckbeard man children. It's the Harry Potter of the 60s.
>>
>>23305160
This.
>>
>>23300210
I will never understand why some people are so desperate to imagine Tolkien as some final arbiter of quality literature. He was notable for being the first to do some things during an era in which modern literature was still in its infancy. As far as the actual content and prose of his works is concerned he is, as the kids would say, pretty mid.
>>
>>23303438
paraphrasing "The point if the baron is to say that homosexuals have a harder time developing mature sensibilities and getting rid of dangerous deviances because society doesn't foster them through puberty like it does straight people."

herbert is literally an ally, you RETARD
>>
>>23303628
Social contageon is a proven phenomenon
>>
>>23302753
the 33 percent of pedophiles simply comes from the fact that 33 percent of children molested are male, therefor their molesters must be gay. that's not really a fair conclusion as the sexes children aren't even easy to tell a apart visually. it's like if 33% of dogs raped by humans were male. it would not follow that the men who raped those dogs were attracted to adult human males and not attracted to adult human females. i am not going to read the rest of your pamphlet.
>>23299522
yeah but he's saying she CAN cuck him, as long as it doesn't lead to a baby. granted, a political marriage isnot like a relationship you or i will ever have. paul is with her solely for practical reasons. he has no feelings for her.
>>
>>23305345
you don't thing a space baron gets fostered through puberty?
>>
>>23305655
Anon he's not saying she can cuck him. He's saying she isn't capable of cucking him, because he doesn't consider her his mate.

It's literally just.
>"lol" said the messiah, "lmao".
>>
>>23305660
Do you have a point?
>>
>>23299495
>CONTEXT

In its time for its time, Herbert is unspeakably based FOR A BOOMER. he pioneered mushroom propagation techniques, for instance

DUNE was prescient for its time and anticipated a plethora of AI type challenges we are now confronting head one. IF nothing else he is a front runner in an irredeemably shitlib genre (postwar-genre at any rate. the turn of the century through interwar period was far further ahead in its anticipations and creative visions)
>>
>>23302883
Asimov is the singularly worst dialogue I had ever read until glancing over Chuck Wendig's inaugural Disney Nu-Canon Star Wars novel. It's that bad, and a shame so many foundational speculative conepts original from the goofy literal archetypal boomer coomer incel fuck.
>>
>>23299495
His marriage to Irulan isn't real. It's a political sham to give him legitimacy as the emperor. Chani is his real woman.
>>
>>23299749
Then you would probably end up creating children who would eventually cause political problems for you.
>>
>>23305896
Good, may the best win.
>>
>>23305820
>anticipated a plethora of AI type challenges we are now confronting head on
Isn't that half of sci-fi/cyberpunk though?
>>
>>23305896
More importantly it would play into the hands of the Bene Gesserit, giving them someone with Paul's Genes they can control
>>
>>23305936
He should have genocided the Bene Gesserit.
>>
>>23305160
>>23305163
Shameless samefag
>>
>>23299640
Are you new here?
>>
>>23300210
Based Tolkien Trad Chad

>>23305225
Cringe virgin onions cuck zoomer
>>
>>23299495
her literally says that if she has a child from that or isn’t discreet about it that he will strangle her to death. the marriage is a sham marriage anyway which is also explained in the book

0/10
>>
>>23302626
based if true, though nowadays anything short of taking it up the ass is considered homophobic
>>
File: GFlZBQNacAAxi0G.jpg (67 KB, 509x694)
67 KB
67 KB JPG
>on the day of the rahmadan
>the orange catholic bible
>zensunni philosophy
When did you realise Herbert was a hack?
>>
This done shook me, I cann’t lie



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.