I remember a flag tier list, and the author said any flag with text or images on it is automatically F tier. But because there are so many - he decided to more tiers below F tier: F-S, F-A, F-B, F-C, F-D and F-F just for them. Those can be your EQG tiers.

>>41844032
The best general was /mwf/

File: 1731606346719884.png (1.26 MB, 1140x832)

1.26 MB PNG

>>41844032
I'd actually put the shimfags and fishfags in C or B. They seem alright.

File: generaltierlist.png (1.26 MB, 1140x834)

1.26 MB PNG

Sure why not

File: Capture.png (818 KB, 1264x529)

818 KB PNG

almost all of them are pointless image dump generals, shitty fetishes, and aislop

File: sure.png (149 KB, 493x429)

149 KB PNG

S tier: promoting creativity is based
/preg/: honestly surprised this is even allowed, and it's not something I care to see
/tfhg/: dead game please put this general out of its misery already
/filly/: would be great if it contained foalposting to one thread but it doesn't even accomplish that, so what good does it even do?
/ai/: it offends my sensibilities and is basically the opposite of s tier

everything else I don't have strong enough feelings on to rank

>>41844032
not going to make a tierlist but the general icons are pretty cute!

File: 448.png (1.26 MB, 1140x830)

1.26 MB PNG

I am somewhat biased
Some of the circlejerk generals can be alright sometimes

>>41844097
>>41844192
What's wrong with Pony Gaming? Isn't it just a place for horsefuckers to talk about games and play with each other?

>>41844032
Why does every other pony have a /general /except twilight, are all the Twilight slide threads the stand in?

genuinely embarrassing thread
this board is dogshit

>>41844202
She's second to last in the list, use your eyes my little retard.

>>41844205
MLP post tier list
F tier: incessant whining

>>41844206
That's only a picture of twilight. So I will assume it's all twilight slide threads out of a general.

>>41844198
Oh shit I thought /mlpg/ was the mlp general
High B tier then

>>41844217
Yeah, OP fucked up. I think /mlp/ is supposed to be MLP General.

>>41844032
You forgot /nmp/, the SSS tier general. /cyoa/ is missing too.

Did you just Ctrl+F for '/' or something?

File: generals tier list.png (1.29 MB, 1140x830)

1.29 MB PNG

Missing /both/ and the snake pony general. I would put them in S.

The mind control thread sucks. How do we fix it?

>>41844404
Control the minds of the people posting in it, obviously.

/bale/ and /create/ have squarely sat on the throne for a long time.

>>41844422
And yet they pale in comparison of /tempo/ a shitty soulless rebrand will never be the same

>>41844032
Where does tierlist general fit in?

People rate their favorite ponies general and the content creation generals as their favorite. No surprise there.

>>41844430
Why did a simple name change intended to make the purpose of the thread more understandable piss so many people off
This sounds very autistic

File: Tier list.png (1.26 MB, 1140x920)

1.26 MB PNG

>>41844032
Perhaps I just like to draw ponies

>>41844422
nowadays almost nothing gets done anymore in /create/ besides from the aggies and the occasional singular update/new thing posted once a week. it’s a bit disheartening that it’s essentially turned into a bumpfest.

>>41844449
It was forced by an outsider, purp the faggot who was behind /bale/s name and needed it to be more accessible and understandable for normalfag people who were too retarded to know what /tempo/ was (hurr durr it's music?) There was never a chance it would ever be anything other than a soulless rebrand.

File: general tier list.png (1.71 MB, 1262x1011)

1.71 MB PNG

/ra/ is lucky I don't put them lower. They're practically a fetish general at this point.

>>41844481
So autism, got it

>>41844032
Here is my modest proposal to better /mlp/. We need to get rid of all generals:
>OPG/PTFG
Discord Troons ERP generals. Need to go.
>TF2
Gay ERP general. Need to go.
>EAW/TFHG
Offboarders and dead games. Need to go.
>All single character generals (sun, moon, aj, glim, rd...)
Only post a shitty image bump when >10. Need to go.
>Flutterape, RGRE, AIE, My Little Progress
Just corpses at this point. All the good ideas and greens have been made. Need to go.
>Fimfic
Very gay circlejerk. Need to go.
>PPP/CHAG/AI 'ART'
AISlop. Need to go.
>Mindcontrol, Casual sex, Submission, Pregnancy...
Fetish threads. Need to go.
>/Create/
Sold its soul with a shitty rebrand. Need to go.
>CYOA
Dead. Nobody care. Need to go.
>jdb/canterslut
Fetish threads and EQG. Need to go. Other EQG generals too.
>merch
Consoom the thread. Need to go.
>/mppp/
No Woona. Need to go.
>etc.
Only then, like a phoenix rising from the ashes, can /mlp/ start anew on solid ground.

>>41844124
seems about right

File: 2862270.png (73 KB, 1280x720)

73 KB PNG

>>41844986
never not based

>>41844836
good one

>>41844836
Not bad.
Though why is /chag/ in active with problems?

File: Chart.png (1.32 MB, 1888x786)

1.32 MB PNG

/DFB/ isn't in here. You may imagine it alongside /neet/. Fetish threads are low and mane six generals are in B tier.

>>41844454
we draw a lot in opg come visit sometime

>>41845013
/fimfic/ is in here because it's mostly a homosexual circlejerk that sometimes remembers it's supposed to be about fics, mostly on weekends
/chag/ is in here because even if it's funny, the whole big models meta must be one of the most retarded sagas on this website

>>41844032
>using an AI image for mind control thread has instead of the OP pic
Literally why, F tier list.

>>41844449
>>41844481
I didn't know it was purp, but still doesn't change that I never posted to the thread out of principle ever since the shitty forced rebrand myself, from the creative name to the normal trash, even when I completed anything larger that would fit in there, yea.
Ironically I have similar feelings towards /bale/, which I feel the draw thread could have fit it, but fags decided that a new thread and a new theme was needed. Unlike Tempo, that wasn't an hostile takeover, and moreover it morphed to become it's own thing instead of a draw thread to new artists that it started like, so I'm fine with it

File: firefox_IkN5tTzlNj.png (1.09 MB, 1550x496)

1.09 MB PNG

Also sorted from left to right within each row between themselves. Leftmost could be almost be considered to fit on the row above, while rightmost the row below.

>>41845052
What do you have against the pedos

File: toothpaste.png (529 KB, 773x842)

529 KB PNG

>>41845054
>Victim complex
But also, I like grown mares. Anything wrong with that in turn, Anon?

Hopefully this shows the state of the board, and people's preferences to the different threads

>>41844032
wheres /jdb/ not even an anon that uses it, just wanted to see how many would put it in F tier.

Ehem.

>S Tier:
Threads I like.
>F Tier:
Threads YOU like.

That is all, thank you.

>>41845153
But what if I like the threads you like?

>>41844032
Honestly, I don't even know if I can rate shit at this point because there's multiple generals that I really liked that have gone to utter shit. For example, I wanna be the little pony, but /ptfg/ in its current state is a festering discordtranny bumpfest.
Most of the generals that I don't have strong feelings on I also don't visit a lot, and given how many of the generals I used to love have gone down the drain I really don't feel like I can possibly rate a thread I don't even browse. I just can't know if it's actually good, or just a nice-looking concept with cute OPs but hiding a cesspit of faggotry inside it.

>>41845152
Read the OP
>eqg generals omitted

>>41844430
>mfw I accidentally caused the final straw that broke /tempo/'s back

>>41845057
Yes. fillies are objectively hotter.

>>41845159
Then you are literally me

File: 562209.jpg (456 KB, 600x926)

456 KB JPG

>>41845152
>>41845160
EqG would just be bloat on F tier desu so I agree with OP.
I miss cute humanizations, but that trashfire just killed all of those for monster high shit

I see everyone love opg

Why the fuck is spanking even a general?

>>41845950
We have a lot of fetish generals

>>41845950
Cause fetishes.

File: 1860568.png (31 KB, 800x878)

31 KB PNG

Milky should be unbanned or all fetish generals should be banished to /trash/.

File: 1614123949594.png (29 KB, 176x156)

29 KB PNG

>>41844032
>no /vst/ thread
fuck you

>>41844836
I wouldn't know how to differentiate the bumping generals since they’re all the same. I guess you rank them based on your favorite ponies.

File: 1728869718176903.png (2 MB, 2241x2704)

2 MB PNG

>>41845966
/pnk/ deserves to be rated higher than other bumpfests because Ponktober results in a lot of great art.

Make an objective list of waifu generals

>>41844467
There's plenty being done, maybe not 500 projects, but a handful of new stuff per thread for sure. The recap posts were a good thing to show that, but 4chan's been detecting them as spam since they implemented new anti-spam meassures

>>41846024
It’s 9 quotes per post now. Just split them into several recap posts.

File: Superior taste.png (1.26 MB, 1140x830)

1.26 MB PNG

Ranked from left to right. Also counted most of the mare specific generals as one.

>>41844032
>no /plone/
remove yourself from the earth this instant

>>41846080
It's dead, nigga

>>>/mlp/rules/3
>3. Topics must be show-related. When discussing people, they must be associated with the show and not the fandom.

>>41846106
erm pushes up glasses hiro said we're allowed 1 thread to talk about the state of the board

>>41846106
Are you going to do something about it?

>>41846106
You will never be a janny.

>>41844533
purp's autism, correct.

>>41846080
Search /plone/ right now, sperg

>>41846094
>>41846133
but include /latex/ for their first thread in months. was it even ever a general? or did they just call it one for no reason?

>>41846069
What a sad "I can only like what /mlp/ tells me to like" list.

>>41846154
https://desuarchive.org/mlp/search/subject/latex/
Chances are OP just looked at what was alive on the board when he made the list.
He missed nmp too, probably because there’s no /.

>>41846178
Most of my As were everyone else's Cs or lower, schizo

>>41845981
/pnk/ and /dash/ are the top 2. /pnk/ has Ponktober and /dash/ has thread recaps. I guess /glim/ also has thread recaps but that one brapfag brings down the whole general by at least 1 tier. I don’t know how to rate the rest. They’re basically the same.

>>41845981
twi general lower than the rest because of the sheer amount of >wings

File: 1711108716747811.jpg (87 KB, 908x718)

87 KB JPG

S tier: /WILDMANES/
Z tier: the rest of /mlp/

>>41846185
>nmp
>alive

File: tierlsit.png (738 KB, 1313x507)

738 KB PNG

Didn't rank waifu generals because that'd be very mean to the waifuchads.

File: my-image.png (1.27 MB, 1140x1012)

1.27 MB PNG

>>41844032
>not making F tier and lower just for /ptfg/ and the like
If there was F tier, I would put /ptfg/, /afg/, /optimal/, /opg/ and /sim/ too. Actually, scratch that, I would put them, but /sim/ below F-tier as they don't deserve even that.

>>41846294
It’s here. I’m not judging its state or quality, that’s what the tier list is for.

>>41846301
Right, I forgot about the stallion general, it goes into F tier too.

>>41846301
You can create your own tiers, nigga

>>41846301
Just add another tier yourself dawg

File: 1737064160780.gif (360 KB, 378x400)

360 KB GIF

>mfw I got bored of ptfg and started to draw thanks to bale

>>41846404
Were you in /ptfg/ for Pony in Equestria stuff or for literal transformation shit?

>>41846416
Yes.

>>41846492
Then die.

>>41846298
>Making a "disgusting" fetish tier and not putting Slavery
>Yet puting kinderquestria, pure hearted mares who don't know better; mmp, literally pony but bigger; and mindcontrol, which is literally /slave/ with less steps despit that one going elsewhere
I have questions, but I don't know If I want answers...

>>41846495
No.

>>41846515
>>Yet puting kinderquestria, pure hearted mares who don't know better
/kinder/ is cute as a concept, but there's tons of stories that end up going lewd, making it pretty much pedo. Even worse than filly and loli stuff, because that is mostly about the looks of the character, but here it is about the behavior which is exactly what real pedos like about a child.

File: my-image.png (1.26 MB, 1140x982)

1.26 MB PNG

>>41844032 here is my contribution to this thread.

>>41846515
I can tell you never went to /slave/. Fetish posts where mostly on submission is mandatory. Slave focused more on how actually horrible life as a slave would be. Its biggest sin was being filled with hero complex greens, where anon saved all the ponies from slavery

>>41844032
I'm pretty impressed with how well /kinder/ seems to be doing in the rankings despite having a green dry spell lately.
>>41846523
Majority of the stories there are sfw though, I literally made the paste down for the thread and read roughly half the greens there. Don't forget that the thread is also merged with anon in pone prison as well which is not obligated to have kinder themes. There's also a ton of variety in how the ponies act and behave too depending entirely on the writer and the subject of the green.

>>41846515
>>41846631
Shit, I think I halucinated a post. I didn't mean to reply to you but I lost the actual post I wanted to respond to. Apologies

>>41846631
I'd like /slave/ if it was somewhat like a magical familiar thing, set wholly in Equestria and without humans. Or something like serfs and landlords, obviously also set in Equestria without humans.

>/trix/ consistently rated decent
thanks guys, we try to keep it nice

>>41844032
are you an aj fag?
unrelated, I had to turn off my filters to see this threads

>>41846650
nothing stopping you from writing stuff like that and steering the thread, you'd be amazed at what one writefag can do to direct weeks of conversation on a slow board

>>41846867
>nothing stopping you
Besides ability to write I guess?

>>41846863
what gave you that idea?

>>41846876
>>41846863
shit, meant to reply to:
>>41844097

>>41846883
/aj/ is pretty good because it often has lewds that go undetected for weeks.

>>41846883
Which one is a reply to >>41844097?

>>41846872
the only thing stopping you is you.
You know what you like, read it and rewrite it til its good to you and you'll be your harshest critic

>>41846872
No one is born knowing

File: my movie.png (1.11 MB, 1140x828)

1.11 MB PNG

Very biased rating. I don't use most of the threads under B tier. Even then I don't frequent a lot of the B ones very often.

>>41846976
Why /fimfic/ in D?

>>41846981
>I don't use most of the threads under B tier
NTA but if I had to guess, he doesn't use that thread

File: csre.png (1.02 MB, 1598x488)

1.02 MB PNG

perspective from a /ptfg/ fag to mix it up
+ sorted left to right within the rows themselves

The most shocking thing of this for me is learning that very few people hate /chag/. I guess it's not going out of its way to bother people, I just figured anti-AI sentiment would come for it as well.

>>41845950
Autism.

>>41847016
It's probably because it's mostly just artists that seethe about AI.

>>41847030
This, nobody's grifting the fandom making voice clips

>>41847016
>roleplaying with highly customizable AI mares
>freedom from god awful fandom VAs
Textgen and voice synthesis are way more appealing than image generation. If someone seethes about the former two uses of AI, they're probably a tourist just parroting twitter opinions.

>>41847032
Neither is anyone by making AI fanart. They simply don't care because it doesn't affect them.

>>41846981
They're a faggot circlejerk constantly seething about aie.

>>41847045
no, but artists are and that's why they're so mad at the AI guys. They can make excuses but at the end of the day they're mad I don't have to spend $20 to commission a shitpost image of my wife anymore

>>41847047
But /aie/ IS shit. Not even a /fimfic/ regular. The whole concept of humans in Equestria and isekai in general is simply dumb.

i only ranked /ai/ low because the one time i looked in there they were talking about monetisation and shitting on traditional artists and it left a bad taste in my mouth. nothing inherently against ai art it's just that the culture in that specific thread seemed odd to me

>>41847050
As a pro-AI person, I can say /ai/ is a pretty bad thread. Mostly shitflinging from both sides, a lot of shitty Bing gens, hardly any discussion of workflow involved or sharing of prompts, or at least sharing of quality gens.

File: 6461338.jpg (269 KB, 1600x1250)

269 KB JPG

>>41847049

>>41847059
And you will never go to Equestria either. Seethe on, /nmp/.

>>41847059
Begone self-insert tranny

>>41847053
I have to agree with this, I got zero help when I was starting because people were only interested in shit talking and posting their own gens

>>41847062
>>41847077
Go cry about it in your discord server tftroons

>>41847090
Stick to your chatbots loser

>>41847049
i don't care how you feel about it. I will continue to enjoy my comedic asshole anon stories AND my vague wish fulfillment. For me, Anon is a character first and foremost and a self insert some of the time.

>>41847128
>i don't care how you feel about it.
He says, in the thread asking people their feelings about generals.

>>41847137
he should've posted his chart instead of whining to me then.

File: 1713183801111.png (3.82 MB, 2550x3300)

3.82 MB PNG

>>41847045
>Neither is anyone making ai fan"""art"""

>>41847162
>t. Sandeep

>>41847162
Are you mad that you had to slash your coomission prices?

>>41847164
>>41847171
>aijeets projecting and sidestepping like usual

>>41847171
you can also tell that this was written, or at least prompted, by a native Hindi speaker because of the grammar errors that they make. They're rarer than they usually are which is why I think they ran it through chatGPT but there are a few tells, probably where the "author" was unhappy with the wording that was presented and applied their own grammatically incorrect fixes

>>41847173
Not really. The fact someone is competing with you with new tools is not "grifting", it's simply competition. Something you were in dire need of.

>>41847182
>Yes sars it's not grifting when we do it bloody bitch bastard

>>41847182
now they'll say its not competition because AI art is "worse" while simultaneously crying about it even though its definitely not competition they swear

>>41847189
It's not competition to them, because it's shit and not even art and... it just needs to be banned okay!!?

>one single casual comment about AI
>the thread immediately derails into obnoxious bullshit
wew

>>41847196
It's just a classic case of aijeets playing the victim

>>41847195
its not even the rare jeet trying to pass off AI art as real commissions, every artist I've actually talked to is seething that random anons like me won't have to pay them $20 and wait a week to get a sketch tier piece of work, it raises the bar enough that most pony artists are cut out of making money off of anyone who can afford a high end GPU

File: 10073.jpg (152 KB, 1000x772)

152 KB JPG

>Rip Mares With Flares

>>41847128
>vague wish fulfillment
>vague

>>41847213
I want to CUM in TWILIGHT SPARKLE'S PURPLE UNICORN HORSEPUSSY

>>41847218
So just say wish fulfillment you pussy, this is why AiE is shitwater

>>41847224
But your autogynephiliac wish fulfilment is good?Sure pal.

>>41847234
It is not black and white no matter how much you cry and stamp your feet. I'm not even a tf fag

im a tf fag

>>41847246
>i-i-it's not a *SNIFFLE* pwease stop bullying me
Silence homo.

>make thread about generals
>it devolves into shitflinging about generals
are you happy OP?

Why are hiecels so fragile?

File: 1727857041056763.png (49 KB, 952x252)

49 KB PNG

Why are people against hie so petty?

File: 2922968.jpg (1.25 MB, 2359x1896)

1.25 MB JPG

>>41844032
Where's /ggf/?

>>41847269
You did the exact same thing on BLM pics and had a tism episode fracturing derpi

File: 1711136217353585.png (155 KB, 375x554)

155 KB PNG

>41847363
>non sequitur
>also not even what the drama was about
I will not be engaging with you further, you dishonest cunt. I encourage other Anons to not take this bait as well.

>>41847367
>le smug nothing
I accept your concession avatar tranny

Obvious tftranny raid is obvious. Thread started out with nothing but them being rated at the bottom of tier lists, now a mysterious group of people is shitting on /aie/.

>>41847395
>It-its a raid!
Pathetic.

>>41847459
You have a discord server in your thread OP. It's not a very outlandish possibility.

>>41847463
>You, you, you
Swing and a miss, miss

>>41847468
>sniveling tftranny projection
I must have hit the nail on the head.

>>41847472
Doubling down on your own cock isn't a healthy mindset, but not surprising

>>41847492
>stop pointing out my general's bad behavior!!!
Be less obvious next time.

>>41847494
>NONO NO YOU ARE ON THE BAD POOPIE HEAD TEAM AND I DONT CARE WHAT YOU SAY
Actual toddlers are more intelligent than you.

>>41847500
>immediately gets assblasted when the general known for discord circlejerking is called out for a pathetically obvious raid
My bad, upon reexamination you're clearly just a concerned fence sitter, carry on.

why can't i like both threads

>>41847503
I will call out the mental cripples like yourself and you can cry about it.

>>41847508
Yeah yeah, whatever. Don't miss ERP hour with your xisters tonight!

>>41847520
>Nothing but bot-like replies regurgitating boogeyman over and over.
Mental.
Cripple.

>>41847541
>Nothing but bot like replies with meaningless asshurt insults over and over
See, I can do it too.

>>41847550
>NO U!

>>41847571
>r-retard! t-tranny! s-schizo! d-double retard!
You're actually doing exactly what I described, though. You seem awfully worked up over me pointing out your little raid.

>>41847575
You seem upset that you're merely getting your own medicine. All anyone needs to do is scroll up to see the start of your tantrum throwing ad homs.

>>41847584
You started throwing around tranny and retard insults damn near immediately. I did no such thing.

File: my most viewed.png (1.26 MB, 1140x830)

1.26 MB PNG

from S to C are my most commonly browsed generals. I op /kinder/ and /bale/ so naturally they are my most browsed generals. I tenderly care for my generals, I give them the love and care they need to live and make sure to bake fresh bread in a timely manner.
A tier is threads I always check out on a compulsion. I always peruse the waifu generals they are excellent for farming pics of the mane six plus the princesses, and popular bg amres. also love me anonfilly she a cute so I lurk there a lot.
I like harvesting images from the B tier groups, I mindlessly lurk these threads with the sole exception being the rarest of comments on /snow/.
D tier are fetish threads and threads I never visit.

>>41847586
Scratch that, I did no such thing until the xister remark, which came way after I realized you were just spewing mindless asshurt and had no real argument.

File: 1707654843121844.jpg (305 KB, 1280x720)

305 KB JPG

>>41847206
They live on in our hearts and throats.

>>41847594
>Blatantly lying
Sad

>>41847657
Whatever you say. I still know what you are and why you're so upset.

File: 1942012.png (151 KB, 1000x750)

151 KB PNG

>>41845963
F-tier, never any above. It's basically a barbie[REDACTED] thread, with all that it entails.
Vinyl deserves a better general.

>>41847206
F for faggots tier.

>>41847103
Chatbots are an /aie/ exclusive thing now? /chag/ is the closest you'll get to ever becoming a pony

>>41847213
yeah, because sometimes it's not very present or takes a backseat to other aspects of a story. I don't know what idea of me you have in your head but im not sorry for liking what you don't.
>>41847218
please cease replying for me.

>>41847047
Anon belongs in greens, not in fics.

>>41847047
>>41845027
I truly don't understand the circlejerk accusation. What the fuck?
We don't stick together because we're arrogant; we do it because, as some of the last enthusiasts of well-crafted proseᅳwith grammar that hasn't gone feral and themes that stretch beyond "Anon Fuck ponies"ᅳwe're practically an endangered species.
It's not about superiority; it's about holding ourselves to a standard that, frankly, not everyone on this board can appreciate. Think of us as keepers of a fading art, an ancient guild dedicated to maintaining the flame of complex characters and coherent storylines. Without our little circle, huddled around our flickering candles of literary nuance, that flame would be snuffed out by a wave of greentexts and dime-a-dozen HiE retarded tropes.
So no, it's not hubris when we come together to encourage each other. It's survival. It's duty. And if someone has to stand as the last defenders of FIMfiction's soul, well, we're willing to make that sacrifice.

>>41848198
>It's not about superiority;
Proceeds to describe how your an 'endangered species' that are high class because you have 'standards'.
>Hie Aie bad in Fimfiction, we don't deign to read it
Actually retarded. Of course you're a circlejerk.

>>41847005
Unsurprisingly you have horrible taste.

>>41848198
Okay yeah, like the Glimmerfag said, that is simply elitism. I'm fine with it, but don't deny the air of superiority.

>>41847851
I'm the dude that said /aie/ is shit. I'm sorry, it's really just my opinion, I don't care if you like it, that's no skin off my back. You like what you like, I'm just saying I think the idea of humans (and non-mythical creatures in general) in MLP isn't the best kind of material. Like >>41848150 said, fine for wish fulfillment greens, but it's not high art.

kek what a fucking retarded dramafest this dumb thread is

>>41848310
It's fun.

>>41848312
it just makes everyone here look incredibly gay

>>41848314
Can't beat the master (You)

File: 516753.png (788 KB, 1280x575)

788 KB PNG

>>41848150
that's fine, you can believe that. I have no problem with it but the anons letting it live rent free in their heads are annoying.
>inb4 your side does it too.
I realize that, it's not what I'm discussing right now though.
>>41848198
You can include anon in a story and have it be good, you lot act like it's impossible and conflate anything involving anon with coomer fantasies. it's there sure, but it's disingenuous to act like that's all there is and to dismiss an entire character over it.
>>41848304
humans are fine for me. My greivances are moreso with people projecting human concepts and values onto the ponies themselves, that almost always lowers the quality of whatever it's in. Stuff like saying pinkie or rarity are sluts or that fluttershy's into weird kinks because she's quiet and shy. Twi and aj are victims of it too. Not the best examples but the only ones I can think of right now. These extrapolations of their personalities are based off purely human experiences and behaviors. They hold no value other than to insert a fetish or make a pony look bad.
>>41848314
Where do you think we are?

>>41848304
The HIE genre is not for the faint of heart. It’s not just about sending humans into the world of Equestria; it’s about transcending the boundaries of fiction itself. Just as you wouldn't expect to stumble upon a Shakespearean play in a high school drama class, or find the nuances of a Tolstoy novel in a community book club, you simply cannot expect a mere fanfic writer to grasp and master the profound depths and soul-stirring complexities of the HIE genre. It's the apex of storytelling. Too intricate, too delicate, too soulful for most to comprehend, let alone capture in writing. The problem isn’t with the genre. The issue lies in its towering grandeur, which is just too monumental for the average writer. We don't lack good HIE stories; we lack the literary giants to pen them.

File: pinkie-scrutiny.png (158 KB, 250x500)

158 KB PNG

>>41848343
Hey I've seen this copypasta before

>>41848198
>All these Anons responding to a pasta

>>41848405
A pasta that, I'm assuming, only sees usage in a general I tend to avoid.

>>41848415
You should notice something's off just by reading it.
>It’s not about superiority
>describes why they are superior
>not a circlejerk
>without our little circle, huddled around our flickering candles of literary nuance

>>41848198
>Think of us as keepers of a fading art

Of what? Posting bait?

>>41848424
im gonna be honest, I barely skimmed through that post before replying to it. seems I made the right call considering how useless it was.

>>41845014
>/DFB/
lmao, I don't know how that shit became a general, the first two threads were just a shitpost I've made, I'm not even into bat ponies

>>41848466
There were already /bat/ threads and raceplay seemed to be in season so why not a temporary rebrand?

>>41844032
Why would anyone visit generals for things they're not interested in??? Like I don't give a shit about some fanfic AU or some fetish or don't waifu a certain character, why would I browse their generals?

>>41848538
anons with too much time on their hands LOVE getting riled up over irrelevant shit

>>41848538
You don't. Because you have bad taste.

>>41848551
>not being interested in everything ever = having bad taste
????

>>41848534
>the cancer killing the board

>>41848593
>Not liking everything means you have a preference in things.
>You're not me so you must like different things.
>Any taste that is not mine is bad.
>Therefore you must have a bad taste.
As shrimple as that.

File: my-image.png (1.27 MB, 1140x1014)

1.27 MB PNG

>>41844032
Not much keeps me coming back anymore, if it weren't for the occasional funny random thread that pops up I would get bored of the few generals I care for eventually

>>41848964
>Actually has a "No opinion" ranking rather than putting everything he doesn't know straight into F.

You're okay, Dashfag.

File: 1735801825752.jpg (14 KB, 256x256)

14 KB JPG

>>41844032
now that the dust has settled...
is it time to admit this was the best general/consistent shill post?
like a rekt thread before newfags ruined them all. or an episode of degrassi. it had it all. child rape, autism, at least three felony convictions, multiple board project killing scandals (did you like pony asmr? the mlp plays? they killed 'em), more child rape! thanks based d*scord troons!

>>41848981
Well it's not very fair to rate other people's threads so poorly if I just don't have a strong opinion of them is it? The only generals listed that I actively dislike are fetish threads or threads that suck despite being about something I would otherwise be interested in. I don't care to participate in /eaw/ but it's not something I think needs to change or be removed because it simply doesn't interest me.

I know you can make the argument that threads take up space in the catalog, but the threads I would criticize for that aren't listed.

>>41848994
>utterly defective retard saves thumbnails
pottery

>>41849006
it's not a thumbnail, it's the only version available to me, after a long and extensive search

>>41847016
>/chag/ keeps to themselves and posts funny or sexy logs
>botmakers put 10x effort in than a promptmonkey
>simple lovemaking with ai mares unity
>artists sometimes use it as inspiration
>they welcome the artists and promote them

>shartist general actively shits up every thread they can with autistic spam
>believes they are morally superior, and better than artists
>will derail any thread over aislop like this one
>'effort' consists of copying booru tags and rolling dice
>they seethe about artists and want to be them
So shocking

>>41848534
Bait

>>41844032
Woah, two of the threads are represented by my art. I have finally made it.

>>41849661
Based.

>>41848538
I like to visit other mane 6 generals to hang with other waifufags.

>>41849661
Based.

So /opg/ and /ptfg/ are the most hated?

>>41849793
Probably, especially /opg/.

File: 1716427594404798.png (344 KB, 1140x465)

344 KB PNG

>>41844032
Everything else is barely even a general

>>41849894
>RGRE on S
Based
>Latex on top of create
wtf
>Everything else is barely even a general
I'm going to assume you just don't go on the generals you didn't rank, and that's alright

File: brick booty perturbed car(...).png (561 KB, 1216x1061)

561 KB PNG

>>41844032
uhhhhhhh wait where is /bbg/?

>>41849935
>I'm going to assume you just don't go on the generals you didn't rank, and that's alright
Real. They're all dead or recycling posts sadly. /create/ is too small to be taking up a thread.

>>41844032
Peak:
>Create, ai art, draw, merch, shitpost threads
Mid:
>Greentext threads, fetish threads, social threads like gmod server
Low:
Trainers

>>41849961
It was embarassing

>>41846617
based as usual

>>41849961
forced meme from the same type of "people" responsible for numget

Can normal anons just "come up" a whole new general, instead of following established ones?

>>41851440
Why have i been seeing esls EVERYWHERE lately?