Peter Sinfield Memorial Edition (1943-2024)https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukgraQ-xkp4What is Progressive Rock?>https://rateyourmusic.com/genre/progressive-rock/Good bands to start with?>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_progressive_rock_artistsObscure prog gems>https://rateyourmusic.com/list/antonbildern/a-secret-society-obscure-progressive-rock-albums/Previous >>124345966
>Weary from his journey>Birdman circled homewards>Gliding through the sunset>He very gently floated down>Down to the ground
>>124409538what are they drinking
>>124409687pure LSD
thoughts?
>>124409538Damn RIP to a legendim not a big lyrics fan myself but i always liked and appreciated Peter's way and style on writing themhis lyrics on "Cat Food" "Pictures of a City" "The Letters" "Ladies of the Road" and "Islands" are nothing short of amazing
>>124409538if Peter Sinfield is dead, who is still alive of the original King Crimson formation
>>124410108>>124409930
>>124410120Fripp...
>>124409931Penis?
>>124410108Ian MacDonald
I’ll never forget Fantano accidentally calling him Peter Seinfeld
>>124410689kek
Beneath the wind turned waveInfinite peaceIslands join hands'Neathe heaven's sea
>>124410134some of them do have penises yes, but some don't.
ITWOP is the best KC album, FUCK you if you disagree you fucking retarded piece of fucking shit i fucking HATE YOU.
>>124410986rude
post your favorite prog album and the anime girl you would smash into paste (sexually)>Larks'>Taiga
>>124411052>Taigaill never understand tsundere worshiping
>>124411052>Discipline
Well?https://youtu.be/-lIZ3MDrUV0?si=Y_9aLvbxTO3H02WF
>>124411246>zoomer crap album on the background>capesh*t shirt>long hair, glasses>chubbyI wont last 2 minutes watching this
>>124411246>>124411271That faggot identifies as non binary lmao
>>124411246Why would you ever make a video like thatDo people give a fuck about Fantano THAT much?
>>124411302He has been the most influential music critic on YouTube for over a decade
>>124410689What's the deal with cat food?
>>124411286They're just like me fr
>>124411246god i hope Fagtano hates prog, if he doesn't then i'll have to stop listening to it.
>>124411162i just like her huge tits
>>124411246He was banned from reviewing prog after he panned The Raven that Refused to Sing
>>124411052>Wish You Were Here(She would probably be the one smashing me into paste instead but it's fine)
>>124411314>He has been the most influential faggot for over a decadefixed
What's everyone's favorite progressive prog album?
>>124411588He only likes classic and critic approved prog like Zappa, King Crimson and Black MidiHe liked new Blood Incantation as well
>>124411858>black midi is progis this a meme?
>>124411905What else would they be?
>>124411922Shitcore
>>124411905>I don't like it, so it must not be progOk retard
>>124410108Seinfeld is dead?
>>124411052FUCK OFF
>>124411246Fantano hates prog because it's a complex white male genreReminder Fantano gave fucking Brat a 10
>>124411953they are not prog though, they're closer to jazz fusion if anything
>>124409931haircz?
>>124412855vlas
>>124412855>>124412956Flairck
>>124412731>>124411953they are Post-Prog
https://youtu.be/MVyrPFAl1cI?si=Z4WQmj9S68ce02oxHOLY SHIT
It was HIS band, guysNever forget that
Greeptards fuck offYou're not welcome here
>>124413713>doesn't play instruments>doesn't sing>It was HIS bandAnd people rag on Robert
>>124413727His lyrics were getting worse anyway. Haskell couldn’t contain his laughter when singing them, imagine what Wetton would’ve done.
>>124411953>>I don't like it, so it must not be progYes
>>124413947The band?
prog doesn't exist, the concept of "progressiveness," both in music and broadly, is often overly simplistic and naive; many people believe they understand how humanity, music, and art should develop, attempting to impose their vision rather than allowing it to develop organically. that said, I enjoy many bands labeled as "prog" or progressive rock/folk, so this doesn't necessarily pertain to the music itself, In fact, these bands often defy the narrow definitions of "prog". just call it what it is "experimental rock"
>>124414688mods delete the thread
>>124414688Prog exists. Proof:
>>124414819And now it doesn't. Poof!
>>124414688Sometimes
prog more like pog
>>124414885they should have left the cover like this
>>124414885Holy shit!
RIP Sinfeld
>>124415378fuck off we hate her here.
>>124415858AHHH I HATE HET SO MUCH
>>124415920any touhou prog?
>>124416062Yeshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UbqoImQZ-EY
>>124416062Flan is Prog
>>124415858i love her
>always shun this album in my mind because of Tom Sawyer>listen to it again on a whim>it's great
>>124417270>not liking tom sawyerdafuq is wrong with you
>>124411953I do the oppositeEvery time I find a top 40 hit I like I call it prog-influenced
>>124417297I don't hate it, but I have a bad habit of disliking songs if they get played in every piece of media. I end up feeling like I'm listening to wallpaper/advertisement music.Listening to Tom Sawyer again, it's alright, just not as adventurous as I like from Rush.>>124411858>new Blood IncantationPleb magnet of the year. It's some of the most poorly executed genre mad-libbing that I've listened to. It has good moments, but as complete songs, the two tracks are messes.>>124417343kek
>>124409538WAKE YOUR REASONS’ HOLLOW VOTEWEAR YOUR BLIZZARD SEASON COAT
>>124417675based, their best song from their best album.
>implying Rush is good>implying Rush isn't just discount Yes>implying my penis works
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k1LdAKkFhEMit is so over....
>>124417894i can't believe he did a Sieg Heil Salute and said "HH 1488" he's definitely getting cancelled tomorrow.
Hey, /prog/! It’s your boy from The Prog Corner, and I’m super excited to hang out with you all today! Let’s get into some juicy discussions about the latest prog releases!
>>124419803>latest prog releases!uuuugh... King Crimson?
>>124419816Yes
>>124419803>latest prog releasesuhhhhhhhhhh Steven Xbox and Cardiacs are releasing next year. Anything high profile from 2024?
>>124420264Uhh.... Tony Levin?
is Death Grips prog?
>>124417935where does he do that in the video? i can't find it, can i get a timestamp?
>>124416062magma
fagma lol
>>124409538https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8QYnsZ-8meU
>>124420388sometimes
>>124420464KEK
>>124420464Christian Wanker lol
No
Yes Sucks
i mean they fucking Suck, and not "early" Yes is not good either.
is the Shit i just took "prog"?
>>124422399if "YES" is considered prog, then then why not?
>>124422399
>zeuhl djentExpected to hate this because of the djent tag but it's surprisingly decent/goodhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ktcdu8A2H6c
>>124422399Yes, all shit is /prog/.Pic related
>>124422573>Expected to hate this because of the djent tagJannick-era Magma and Ruins/early Koenjihyakkei were practically proto-djent to begin with
>>124420388Yeshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xp96ZYJljAk
>>124422582We like Rael here
I FEEL SO SICK TODAY(I'M AFRAID TO BE HERE WITH YOU)YOU WANNA KILL SOMEBODY(I'M AFRAID TO BE HERE WITH YOU)
>>124422810my favorite Yes song
GET SO FUCKIN' DARK IN HERECOME-COME FUCK APART IN HEREI DIE IN THE PROCESSYOU DIE IN THE PROCESS
>>124422757>Kitard terrible opinion Truly clockwork
>>124423014Kita is best girl faggot
>>124422879Yes?
>>124422748>nigger screams for 7 minutes and 13 seconds>white cuck plays some synth and piano to make the recording legally count as music>???>success
>>124423609Sounds like an easy way to achieve success, why doesn't everyone do it?
>>124423609that's what my band is, but with the races reversed.
>>124423609Death Grips is literally /pol/ the band
are the Rumors true?
>>124423968Sometimes
>>124423968you mean the Steven Wilson thing? yeah that shit is sickening, i'm never listening to Porcupine Tree again.
>>124423968Ya it's /prog/
What do you niggas think of Renaissance
>>124423983Yeah, crazy how it's already been four women coming out with allegations too, he's really cooked
>>124425168Novella is my favorite followed by Prologue, Scheherazade (the song) is overrated because everyone creams themselves over 20 min epic no matter how disjointed it is.Also Live at Carnegie convinced me more to stop underestimating live releases than Great Deceiver. Not saying it's better, but it made a stronger argument.
>>124425168Jane Relf is a goddess who walks among men. The music is pretty good too
>>124425274dont believe it, he seems to much of a weirdo to even come up with something like that
>>124425987Don't believe it? It's all in the numbers
>>124425274still not as bad as the shit Bono (allegedly) has done.
>>124425168Good musically but Annie's voice gets stale real quick>A TRIP TO THE FAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH>BUT NOBODY WAS THAAAAAAAAAAAH>repeat 100 times
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fm1NFElYkoE
do I hear 21 21 21I'll give you 21 21 21
The other day I asked Chat GPY to give me a meme rundown on why Colors is such a beloved album. About five minutes later I asked it something about the heat death of the universe. I looked back at that tab like an hour later and asked it why my random access questions jumped from Colors to heat death. It gave me a track by track breakdown of how the albums themes mirror some of the emotions behind all of the questions I had about entropy and how probablilities work. I talked to a pile of code for like an hour about Colors and heat death.
>>124430052colors are gay
any good Prog to listen to during my parasite cleansing and fasting? i'm open to anything (other than prog metal), symphonic, folk, eclectic, avant whatever.
>>124430101Anything else?
there's something poetically sad about fripp potentially being the only remaining member of the court lineup both in the band and in life
>>124431116nah mike will outlive him 100%. Peter too
>>124431116god is saving the best for last.
>>124431116i just want the guy to turn his autism down a bit and write one last record in the way he approached the first 5 with a little bit of the new
>>124430514any color you like
>>124429959one of my top 3 Genesis songs, Tony is the man
>>124432154underrated
>>124431531Oh, how quaint that you would presume to dictate the artistic trajectory of Robert Fripp, a figure whose cerebral labyrinthine explorations far exceed the stagnant shores of nostalgia you cling to. Your lament for a return to his antiquated sonics reveals a woeful ignorance of the dynamism integral to genuine artistry. It’s rather amusing, really, that you conflate the pedestrian comforts of familiarity with the profound, often bewildering odyssey of true musical evolution. Perhaps it would serve you well to engage in a modicum of introspection rather than projecting your banal preferences onto a visionary unburdened by the shackles of your simplistic expectations.
The Dividing Line is kino.
>>124428652Yeah Pop was fucking awful.
>>124430393
>>124434753take the ass off the cover first
>>124434860
I believe in only two things, God and Fripp.
>>124434977You only posted one thing
>>124415286seething tarkuscel
>>124434733>*Gets removed from Genesis canon*BRAVO Mike
Progressive industrial?
>>124436541Peter gabriel's 3rd album perhaps? It's kind of proto-industrial and has some prog aspects
>>124436541https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GmHTKc8yd-A
>>124436469>gets rescued by Stevehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wYS-O3eFmrU
>>124436541Bob Dylan
>>124436469It wasn't his fault that the others had no material
>that time springsteen played proghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e3SqqtjmKV4
>that time prog played springsteenhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gvJ6o1PC4pA
>>124437638Maybe they shouldn't continued the moment Phil called it quits. Instead of fucking over the new guy.
>>124438725TIED UP LIKE A DOUCHE
>>124436541I can't believe 3 hours went by without anyone mentioning Thrak
>>124436469I blame Tony
>>124434627get back in toyah's sex dungeon, fripp
The new Fear of a Blank Planet documentary was uplodaded on the band's siteIt's on the FOABP (2024) folderhttps://porcupinetree.com/press/
>>124438967One of the rare moment where Tony wasn't as pricky as he usually isMike not saying a single word is a shame though
>>124440319get back into the grave, wetton
>>124440495>One of the rare moment where Tony wasn't as pricky as he usually isBut Ray said "That's what you'd expect from Tony"
>>124440495Steve also seemed to have the most bad to say against Mike rather than Tony.
>>124438967Virgin Tony Banks>wants to continue Genesis because he has nothing else to his name>apologizes to everyone he meetsChad Michael John Cloete Crawford Rutherford>refuses to elaborate>leaves
>>124438967>Maybe they shouldn't continued the moment Steve called it quits.ftfy
>>124440930BASED
John Frusciante can easily learn /prog/ songs in less than 24 hours. One of the many reasons he is the greatest guitarist of all time, objectively.>Could you tell us a random good memory you have working with John? >Dave Lee: "I'm glad you asked, Ivan. There's a story I remembered the other day. I've told Pedro I was going send it to him, so here it is. I grew up in the late 70's and was a huge fan of the band "Yes". At some point I came to know John was a fan as well. We discussed Yes occasionally, and while on a trip to Japan, John and I had discussed their album "Close to the Edge" and I had said how that album really meant a lot to me growing up. Particularly the song "Siberian Khatru". >Upon arrival in Tokyo, we had a day off to recover from jet lag. The next day at the venue, when the band showed up, I was notified that John was looking for me. My first thought was "Uh-oh. What did I do this time?" Well, he found me, and said he wanted me to follow him to the dressing room because he wanted to show me something. >He sits me down next to the little CD player in the dressing room and plugs his red Jaguar into the practice amp. He then takes out Yes' "Close to the Edge" CD and puts it in. Next he cue's up Siberian Khatru, and proceeds to play along note for note EXACTLY to the song. I mean exactly. Every single part of the 9 minute long epic. And if there was a part with no guitar, he'd play the keyboard parts on his guitar. He just sat there on the floor ripping perfectly through this very intricate song with a huge smile on his face. He even played the guitar fade out solo ending, all the way till it fades completely out. >And then I realized he wasn't smiling because he was "proud" or "showing off". He was smiling because he knew how much it meant to me. It was like a personal little gift, that he'd spent his whole day off preparing. And it did mean alot to me. ...still does." >Question by: - Ivan Roccon - Glasgow - Scotland
>>124441811holy shit its the guy obsessed with Frusciante's cum
>>124442257I just appreciate his musical endeavors.
https://youtu.be/Zg6svO2AQHw?si=0gdK7v3ZJXUng9Vm
>>124442526is that why you have semi naked pictures of him on your computer?
>>124436469Well Tony still talked about it in the latest interviewFunny how he mentioned Congo as an example of a bad song when it's the one people seem to like the most
>>124443322>Mariachi Slipknot>good
>make a cool 4-minute song>slap 9 minutes of filler onto itSteve Hogarth's Marillion and its consequences have been a disaster for the human racehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0NEBuW4oyXg
>>124443951Rock musicians play with their shirt off all the time, nothing homosexual about that at all. >>124446003It is good. John is good.
>>124446794Gazpacho are one of the best and most underrated modern prog bandsDream of Stone is even longer and better
Thoughts on the new Beardfish album?
>>124446923Overall I quite like the album but the acoustic unwinding part at 4 minute mark looks like a perfect place to wrap it up and the sad violin and sad piano do absolutely nothing to meMy favorite is Chequered Light Buildings, maybe it could be shorter but it's at least evenly distributed and the buildup is cool
>>124446994You might like their first 3 albums where all songs are standard 3-5 minutes long
>>124446994speaking of Gazpacho I got bamboozled thinking the vocalist pulled off a convincing female-sounding voice but there was actually a guest singerhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wl4lA9A5Z8w
>>124447005Yeah this is what I'm exploring now >>124447008
I remember when there were 2 tripfags on /mu/ who were obsessed with GazpachoThey don't post here anymore but they are still active on rym
>>124446837>It is good. John is good.don't care about him, but The Mars Volta are pretty bad, just the fact that Scaruffi gave Frances The Mute an 8/10 should tell you how bad they are.
lel
>>124447201why would the swedes do this?
>>124439253>I don't think Springsteen liked our Blinded by the Light, 'cos we sang 'wrapped up like a douche', and it wasn't written like that and I screwed it up completely. It sounded like 'douche' instead of 'deuce', 'cos of the technical process – a faulty azimuth due to tape-head angles, and it meant we couldn't remix it.>Warners in America said, 'You've got to change 'douche', 'cos the Southern Bible belt radio stations think it's about a vaginal douche, and they have problems with body parts down there.' We tried to change it to 'deuce' but then the rest of the track sounded horrible, so we had to leave it. We just said, 'If it's not a hit, it's not.'>But in the end, it was No.1 in America, and so many people came up to us after and said, 'You know why it made No. 1?... Everyone was talking about whether it was deuce or douche.' Apparently Springsteen thought we'd done it deliberately, which we hadn't, so if I ever saw him I'd avoid him and cringe away like a frightened little boy.
>I TALKKK TO THE WIIIIIND>MY WOOOORRRRDDS ARE ALL CARRIED AWAYYY
>>124447150What does Scaruffi's rating have to do with anything? I think he also gave Frusciante's Niandra LaDes an 8/10, which means he has good taste.
>>124447327I like how John sings ithttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8nMuA2y0kyA
>>124447424It seems that Scaruffi actually gave Niandra a 7.5/10, which is unfortunate.
>>124448314I knew the 70s were ASS
>>124448175pretty much anything above 6.5/10 from Scaruffi might as well be a 10
>>124448314What's some good Dutch prog?Except for Focus
>>124448414https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mqtUbtKT7zY
>>124448414https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KQR6jCWfI6o
>>124448394>>124448414Should I post the top 100 again?I did it like 2 years ago
>>124448314>bands with the most songs in the list>Marilliongarbage list
>>124448653Which other prog band has been consistently good for over 40 years
>>124447428This is the best live version
>>124448693King Crimson
>>124448653They counted a whole album as one song, I wouldn't trust these numbers anyway
>>124448781lol
>>124448693>goodthey are a shitty Genesis rip-off band, neo-prog is awful.
>>124450092What's so bad about ripping off good music
>>124450284Turning it into bad music Grendel is an absolute embarrassment to everyone involved
>>124450352how about something that isn't a B-side
>>124448693Magma probably.
>>124448693Gryphon
>>124446837>Rock musicians play with their shirt off all the time, nothing homosexual about that at all. https://desuarchive.org/mu/thread/124351009/#q124388797
>>124450092Only their early albums with Fish sound like Genesis, their Hogarth albums have a different more unique sound
Steve Rothery is underratedhttps://youtu.be/AfeJ4hhNNu0?si=rDNn8-y22K-b1kSm
>>124448693IQ, Gong, Camel, Hawkwind
>>124452364>Gong, Camel, HawkwindI didn't know they still made music
>>124448693Magma, Gong, My Band, Camel, King Crimson
mong, gamel, cockwind
>>124448693forgot rush lmfao>>124452383gong became it's own living entity instead of dying with its leader, kind of what fripp once dreamed for king crimson or yes tried (and failed) to do
wtf is zuehl
>>124452383Techincally Camel recorded an album in 2013 so the 40 year timeline checks outNot sure if "consistently good" applies though
hello grandfathers and great grandfathers i hope your catheter is replaced in a timely manner
>>124456865it's like nsbm but prog rock instead of black metal
>>124457031PLAY ME MY SONG
WHERE THE HELL IS BIGGLES?
>>124458533Sorry, only Buggles here
>>124456865noise rock
>>124458629Cursed lineup.
Reccomend some obscure hard prog.
>>124459554What's the difference between hard prog and heavy prog?
>>124459605No difference. Both hard prog and heavy prog are not mutually exclusive.
is it prog?
>>124456865the dog monster from ghostbusters
>>124459170BLESSED lineuphttps://youtu.be/vzxZzIiO84Y?si=8vgXPklMwoUp5Gsw
>>124459554
>>124438967If you're not fucking over the new guy are you even prog
>>124460931Damn, should've titled it "Chris Benoit.jpg"I'll go kill myself
>>124459990Dog?
>>124461199He's at it again
>>124456865bizarro prog rock opera jazz
>>124456865bizarro prog rock opera jizz
ICH LIEBE DEUTSCH MUSIKhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sQws9AJ-kCQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WBmVcKJSmYQhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQQ3X9gUbCIJourney being a prog band is one of the 20th centuries biggest memory holes.
>>124464447Contrarians like to pretend that this was the "real" Journey and that their label forced them to be corporate sellouts with Steve Perry, but honestly they were always an AOR band underneath all the prog trappings.
>>124464588How many AOR bands made 3 Prog albums and 7 minute instrumentals while looking like this?
Opinions on the new Opeth album
>>124466602neo prog is shitthats the general consensus here
Tony Banks lol
>>124467885That's him, that silly keyboardist
>>124468026>That awkwardness and inability to smile>That control freak attitude He's just like me frfr
firth of fifth has just surpassed supper's ready on the RYM chart (finally)
>>124468062smiling is pretty gay anyway, not as gay as dancing, but close.
>>124468582>Rymdiscord is that way, sir
>>124468895JUST LIKE THE MORNING SUNYOU MAKE ME GAYhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=320THk3elZg
>>1244666026/10they should've packed their bags and retired after morningrise
>>124470924has there ever been a band that did something like thisking crimson doesn't count
>>124464909>7 minute instrumentalsKenny G is proghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMi-tS-k358
>>124470992TRVKE
>30 minute epicmanowar is proghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X0AnLvPs6JE
>>124468582Is this their highest song?
>>124471053venom goes into the same list as manowar as unga bunga metal bands randomly shitting out prog>pioneers some of the most braindead proto-extreme metal of the 80s>randomly releases a 20 minute long prog epic concept track that according to the band was inspired by rush/pink floyd/genesis >album flops because people criticized the track length and they go back to playing standard shortform thrash metalhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nBB2deqwdIs
vander giraffe generator
>>124473575The post that saved /prog/
>>124471053>>124471361NWOBHM (which Manowar were not but still) genuinely had a better claim to prog rock's legacy than neo-prog or prog metal.
>>124471332yeah. i'm pretty sure their 3rd is dancing with the moonlit knight
>>124473642what? why? NWOBHM is almost like the anithesis of prog. it's short bursty songs that get in and get out.
>>124473642>>124473679NWOBHM has nothing in common with progressive rock besides being highly conceptual and having similar main melodies.
>>124473642>>124473679>NWOBHMis that like NSBM?
>its prog
>>124475272assuming you're not shitposting it's just the wave of british heavy metal ranging from the mid-late 70s to early 80s like judas priest and iron maiden and stuff (the wave that came after the first wave which was bands like black sabbath)
>>124476599>Lamb lies down on Bloatway higher than Moving pictures Disgusting
>>124473575vander giraffe generator
>>124476719why would you assume that?
>>124477216it's RYM so that means it's better
>>124477216Retard
>>124475272NWONSHM would be kino
>>124459554https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QFlH95rKAIc
one of their best songs, and it only came out in 2011.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0wweIx8KGjk
>>124479661>Jakszky lol
>>124480660did nothing wrong
>>124480937>*Ruins Crimson*
>>124481067>...but enough about robert fripp
>MoonchildSkip>ProvidenceSkip>Sheltering SkySkip
>>124481848>two of their best songs>one of their better live songsking crimson filters people much more efficiently than most. They were always careful to throw one track in that fucks with the pleb-eared
what is it about Moonchild that makes retards seethe so much? it's just a nice song, i don't get the hate for it.
