What is Progressive Rock?>https://rateyourmusic.com/genre/progressive-rock/>>https://www.progarchives.com/Progressive-rock.asp#definitionGood albums to start with?>https://www.musicgenretree.org/essential_prog.png (embed)Obscure prog gems>https://rateyourmusic.com/list/antonbildern/a-secret-society-obscure-progressive-rock-albums/prev thread - >>128949020Bones edition https://youtu.be/ZyyYzddxxVY?si=ITKCGFIms2iGnINU
SUPERTRAMP
Prognime
>>129046332I don’t miss ged’s pony tail era
Ged didn't have a lot of choice if he wanted to be taken seriously as a rockstar.Any shorter and his "ethnic features" would dominate.
Listen to the many works of Anthony Phillips.
>>129047980Based knowerNot really though. He's a slop master with a few pieces of kino sprinkled throughout
>>129047781>GET A SKILLwow, thank you for your amazing words of wisdom sam>*donates on patreon*
>>129048167Which works of his did you enjoy?
>take a look at me now
>>129048364https://youtu.be/gb-sOCk6BP4?si=qBb73r6GTkNYoSXnwinning?
>>129048496Phil forfeits
>>129048519... not like this
>>129048343first 2 solo albums are great, like a continuation of Trespass, a glimpse of a Genesis that could have been. Other than that i can't vouch for much.(not the anon you asked, though)
>>129047980Solo work his carried hard by his buddies much like Hackett.
>>129049019>Hacketthackett's solo discog is weird because you'll get cool stuff like voyage of the acolyte, followed by the most hippie new age shit of all time. he's one of those artists with a huge discog but like a good portion makes you forget the guy played in fucking genesis
>>129048364Looking like the old man from The Musical Box kek
my 16 yo daughter came to me yesterday and made me listen to a song she discovered by Comus, I think her musical horizon just leaped past mine
>>129048519>>129048605have you seen him in the drum interview with his son? he can barely get behind a kit, he's gone
>>129049357Fuck….https://youtu.be/FAbAR1Eu6UE?si=B1cZnyt5tIdhzJ7M
>>129049477...yeah... but hey, he had a good run, the lovable goof. i hope he gets to enjoy his extra time, and it's not all suffering now
A couple days ago, somebody uploaded a copy of Manfred Mann Chapter Three's unreleased third album on Youtube. I know bootleg copies existed, but I had never been able to get my hands on one. https://youtu.be/09iBV0jWROA?si=RQZHuyDKL0lmRe4m
>>129046749If only there weren't some songs on there with very terrible vocals.
thoughts on Camel? Snow Goose isn't bad
>>129050804more bad songs than good, pretty overrated
>>129049351Is she single?
>>129050804Moonmadness and mirage are kino
>>129050747which ones? >>129050804goose has great moments but also flute abuse, with happy little gnome passages that go too far.mirage and moonmadness are better, i find
I feel like Nolan Potter and all his works are severely underrated in terms of modern prog.
>>129048364>I'm just a lawnmower you can tell me by the way I walk
dominion by IQ
>>129053310better than resistance, but that's not saying much
6 years ago
>>129053833Most overrated drummer ever.
>>129053833That picture is from way longer ago than that.
bump
>>129053833What would he think of the cheapest Rush tickets for selling for $400 + fees?
Gabriel released Live at Womad '82 this year, which means there's hope that Six of the Best gets an official release in the near future.
>>129057183>6 of the best >Not 7 of the best >Tony doing whatever he can to pretend Hackett gets nothing
I really like The construkction of light, why did people hate it?
>>129057506Hackett was late because he was flying in straight from a a South American tour.
>>129057088He'd say the tickets are a scarce good and are properly priced such that there is no shortage of tickets.
>>129057707Kek, was he the reason the band wrote Anthem? I thought that was all 'ee
>>129046332do y'all consider the Mars Volta prog? Frances the Mute is an all time best for me but I don't hear it talked about so much anymore
Acknowledge Kansas
Thoughts on Time Machine Modulus?
>>129058169actually pretty good, not cringe at all
>>129058169*takes a drag & fixes my shades* Time Machine Modulus? haven't heard that name in years...
>>129057088He was Jewish
>>129058394(not true, by the way)
>construKCtion of light>prozaKC blues>fraKCturedget it? because their initials are KCgood one, fripp you massive retard
>>129059259ClassiKc choons though
>>129058169fun, but they're coasting on the one vid. the EP from around that time is ok. they had a "live album" that was supposed to be released a few years ago that never happened and i hate em for it
>>129059174Well Geddy is
does anybody here like Camel?
>>129057088Somehing about trees or something
>>129059644Moonmadness is in my top 5 albums of all time and Rain Dances is an underrated masterpiece.
>>129059644the animal?
White people when Koenjihyakkei comes on
>>129057811Shit band
>>129060347I actually dance in my computer room to some of koenjihyakkei's and ruins' bass grooves
>The Yes>The Genesis>The King Crimsons>The Jethro Tulls>The Van Der Graaf Generators>The Camels>The Renaissance>The Soft Machines>The Gryphons>The Rushes>The Caravans>The Gongs
>>129061303The Camels sound like a one hit wonder 60s band
>>129059644i'd gladly take a fat shit on every camel member for the hell they released upon the world.
>>129061444what hell??
>>129049315>I've been waiting here for so long>And all this time had passed me by>It doesn't seem to matter now...
>>129057811Absolutely but with a lot more post-hardcore and noise rock influences
>>129061752their mediocre music which has hoodwinked a lot of people
>>129060468Why
TOUCH METOUCH ME
>>129057811Of course they're prog. Or at least they were. Haven't kept up.
>>129064102I am also a fan of the ending to musical box.
>>129064102https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uNfcerx_b-k
STEAM
>>129066384STAND BACK
>Do you think you will ever perform on stage with Roger again?>Absolutely not. I tend to steer clear of people who actively support genocidal and autocratic dictators like Putin and Maduro. Nothing would make me share a stage with someone who thinks such treatment of women and the LGBT community is OK. On the other hand, I’d love to be back on stage with Rick Wright, who was one of the gentlest and most musically gifted people I’ve ever known.Same interview immediately after>Can you get Kate Bush back on stage soon? >Kate Bush is the only person who can get Kate Bush back on stage. I think the shows she did in 2014 at the Hammersmith Apollo were some of the best I’ve ever seen. We went several nights. I’ve tried persuading her recently, actually. Gently.
Where do I go with Mike after Tubular Bells, Ommadawn and Distant Earth?
So what's the difference between jazz rock fusion and prog?
Which song makes you go like this?
>>129069074His entire discography front to back.
>>129069196TURTLES HAVE A SHORT LEGS NOT FOR WALKINGVery groovy and actually fun, unlike 99%.99999% of prog
>>129069196https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YGsq3ya1-8Yhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7-lFr5N8KOchttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=42DCB0pfmN0
Is Porcupine Tree actually good and THAT LINE just ruined their reputation, or are they always cringe?
>>129069681They went through like 4 distinct era so if you don't like prog metal you can check their psychedelic or alternative albums
Is this prog?https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9mjcdoE6KGw
>>129069074Hergest Ridge, Return to Ommadawn, and Amarok.
>>129069074He has gone with a lot of styles but I also enjoy his pop albums like Crises
>>129069074Incantationshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g9lRRLzyHZ4
>>129069196https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yfprrYtvzRIhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T9BD3JS2DRIhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nOrYTBaT1z0
>>129069975>song off Attahk that makes you dance>isn't Liriik Neconomicus Kanht
>>129046332Alex looks like young Donald Trump in this photo
>>129053329a time of shadow by dead heroes club
>>129069681Cringe as always
I'M WHEELS
Why does moo hate Steve Wilson?
>>129071062he's moving wheels
>>129069076one is black, the other one is white
>>129069076Fusion that leans more heavily on the rock side is closer to prog than jazz. The most famous fusion bands tend to be in that camp.
>>129071904TRVKE
>>129071904YE YE YEAH
>>129048364>musical busybody who worked himself half to death for decades>crippling back problems from a lifetime of sitting on the world's smallest drum stool>wrecked his body inside and out from raging alcoholism after multiple divorcesIt's amazing he's still with us
>>129071062He's not cool to be approved by hipster critics
>>129072110Coa?
>>129072468at least he gave us lily
>>129071062My xbox has provided more fulfilling experiences than any fucking Porcupine Tree album
>>129073366Bros...
>>129046332Anyone have any opinions on Camel?
BILLYBILLY DON'T YOU LOSE MY NUMBER
>>129074262I like them but they're not one of my all time favorites. I kind of have the same relation to them as with Gentle Giant where their music is often pretty and technically impressive but doesn't have a lot below the surface to invest in.
>>129074251THE RIVEROFCONSTANT CHANGE
>prog is intricate, complex, dense and honest music made by rich white men>genre is lambasted by criticsHmmmm my almonds, they're activating...
OUYAIS A GOD TO ME
>>129075399not even gay, but roine is a hottie
>>129075399Neal Morse looking like he wants to share with you some very good news!
>>129074251That's what you get for not saving that guy from drowning you sick bastard
>54 years later>still the best 'rog epichow did they do it?https://youtu.be/szJq1lwnkNw
Is it just me or is this actually kinda kino?
>>129076951>rog epichttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OF4rw3LOfqY
>>129077360If only they kept the coda to Deception of the Thrush.
>>129077360Great album
>>129077503Musically, Echoes is almost entirely the work of Dave and Rick.
>>129057088I'm getting in for free because I know people.
>>129053833Holy shit I swear that was only 3 years ago or so. Fuckin hell
>>129078605cool. i guess i hate dave and rick
Atom Heart Mother is goodbut see some live clips with poor Dave trying to sing that high being a choir all by himself and you understand why they ended up hating it
hmmmm https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ws3EAdMpEVA
>>129080800Roger...
>>129081005Huh?
let's gooooohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2lUC8Gimxz8
>>129068052>Gently
>>129075752OUR LORD AND SAVIOR JESUS CHRISTIS A GOD TO ME
>>129081378Yes. He walked her home gently.
>>129069896my man
What in the fuck is this?https://youtu.be/603u2rRcGFY
>>129081686something i'd expect /tvpol/ to make. i have no idea how geddy signed off on it
>>129082262self-deprecating humor is the #1 ashkenazi pastime
>>129078605OK here's a real rog epichttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cY_0Ypdab0s
>>129077360It seems to be one that fans either love or hate
>>129082581>rog epic >90% of the song is Dave solo wanking
>>129082581Again, musically more Dave and Rick than Roger.
>>129078605>>129082677>>129083541>what are lyricsinb4 they don't matter
>>129083633they don't matter
>>129083633they don't matter for those 2 songs.Now if you said the rog epic was >All of the Wall I'd agree with you
I just don't get Tull
>>129080912is this zheul?
Fhttps://www.loudersound.com/bands-artists/terry-sullivan-renaissance-rip
I THINK DAVE IS A GOOD GUITAR PLAYERThe Division Bell is genuinely fantastic musically, it's an almost trance like comfy experienceThe lyrics are fucking abysmal, predictable, woeful, ugly and some other mean words, except for maybe High Hopes which his wife wrote, but the actual musicianship is pretty good
>>129084849I’m going to listen to Turn of the Cards and pour one out for him.
>>129084849All gone now except for Annie.
>>129046332Now that the dust has settled: Were Camel really that good?
anyone ever listen to RAHMANN?
>>129069196YYZ, but all the other songs too.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LdpMpfp-J_I
>>129083633They don't in 99% of cases. Unless they're incredibly cringe (Flower Kings, Neal Morse) or incredibly great (Peter Hammill, Peter Sinfield), they just need to sound good. Lyrics can only change a song +/- 1/10.
>>129090426i downloaded them, maybe after you posted about them some other time. didn't get to listen much though
