>>16290905
AEW by a mile. I watched TNA in it;s glory days 2004-2008 and it never reached the heights of AEW in 2021/22

>>16290905
TNA and it isn't close

>>16290905
TNA by a country mile, they have stories that actually make sense.

>>16290905
Sting's run in AEW was way better than his run in TNA

>>16290905
WWE

>>16290905
I prefer AEW, but I respect TNA more for being so good despite so little resources while AEW wastes gorillons of dollars.

>>16290905
AEW. That said I have not watched TNA since like 2006 or 2007.

>>16290905
I get it's the cool thing to shit on but AEW and it's not even close. TNA had some amazing years back around 2005-2009 or so but even those were littered with some of the most what the fuck booking choices and creative. It's far from perfect but AEW does a solid job in its place as the secondary promotion

>>16290905
TNA. aew is really boring and has shit matches.

>>16290905
TNA's highs of course shit all over AEW, but their lows are really really bad.
A consolewarrior might post the sparkler incident, but the point is that on average AEW isn't a total fucking embarassment creatively it's just boring.

>>16290905
TNA is okay. Storylines make sense and everything. Not everyone's good on the mic though.

>>16291333
Even the sparkler incident wasn't as bad as some of the shit TNA did. Like the electrified steel cage match.

Scott Steiner’s antics in TNA are more entertaining than anything I’ve seen from AEW.

>>16291333
>on average AEW isn't a total fucking embarassment creatively
it actually is.

TNA easily. AEW had a chance to be a top 2 contender and Tony blew it.

>>16291435
Fair enough I only watched it for like 4 or 5 months. I just found myself disillusioned with the way they used guys with potential. Which I suppose was my issue with TNA except they also were running Russoriffic nonsensical feuds.

>ITT: a bunch of people who have never watched TNA, and railed on it for YEARS now suddenly pretend to like it to "spite" AEW
saddo shit

>>16291582
it doesn't have to be great or liked to be better than aew.
people didn't just start hatewatching things in 2019 lil brother

>>16291582
says the guy who never watched nujamal, ecw, wcw, aaa, cmll, etc but somehow is the biggest fan of them all and knows all of their past and future wrestlers.

>>16291582
I started watching TNA when it started crossing over with NXT.

>>16290905
Rare case of double Jannetty

>>16291409
At least the sparkler thing was a mistake and not the planned outcome

>>16291460
>except they also were running Russoriffic nonsensical feuds
AEW dived into Russo-esque feuds during 2023 and never crawled out of it. That's the actual reason the ratings tanked

TNA had much better talent and was a very serious show compared to the absolute clown show that was and kinda still is AEW

>>16290905
TNA

>>16290905
TNA, also TNA has lasted longer than WCW and ECW combined at this point and will be here after AEW falls into oblivion. Anyone who says otherwise is trolling or just never watched the kino that is TNA.

>>16291662
KEK

Russo and Jarrett TNA sucked but it was never boring. Good or bad (mostly bad), there was always something to talk about when that show ended. There were usually also a million different things happening so something was interesting enough to get a reaction out of you.

There's not as much to talk about with AEW. The matches are good or bad and that's it. The investment in various wrestlers isn't there. They don't have the big shocking or surprising moments. There's not a lot of storylines that you have to follow each week.

>>16290911
fpbp

>>16291333
TNA's highest peak isn't even close to AEW's opening night.

>>16291689
>LOLTNA
>serious

>>16293457
You shriek over "dangerous" AEW spots like every other week, ya rockspider.

>>16290905
NWATNA

>>16291608
so you've watched for like 4 weeks lol

>>16293457
>There's not as much to talk about with AEW
and yet you never shut up about it, curious

>>16290905
AEW is the better promotion as an average but TNA was more entertaining. TNA slop was entertaining in a car crash way. AEW is owned by a billionaire and has essentially an unlimited budget so it's just sort of sad.
Hardy/Jericho is a good example. The warping stuff was mental and stupid but a good type of stupid. B Movie type stupid. If AEW had more bad stuff but it was B movie bad then at least it's endearing. Now it's just tedious.
AEWs highs are higher than TNAs though, when AEW was good, although it wasn't my preferred style of wrestling, people really enjoyed it. Almost nobody really enjoys AEW any more, they seem to be watching in case something good happens rather than because something good happens. Ironically, the thing that slowly drained WWE.

>>16290922
>>16291406
Name 3

>>16295462
Main Event Mafia
Aces and Eights
Broken Matt Hardy

>>16295466
>newest story is from the fucking Obama years
>and it was Matt being some intentionally ridiculous weirdo

>>16295429
I love how the Panda years of TNA have gotten retconned, as if they didn't have stupid amounts of money then.

>Aces & 8s

lmao

>>16290905
This one got him punching the wall again