We all agree Cody going back to WWE was Tony’s biggest fumble? Even over the Punk fiasco?
>>16732042Punk was avoidable. Cody had to go.
Punk is what sealed the deal for WWE. Not Cody Lispy Smoke n Mirror Rhodes
>>16732042Nah. Dwayne's new fabarit, "Sweet cheeks" Ethan Page is Tony's biggest fumble when it's all said and done
>>16732042Cody was their biggest could’ve been star going by how he’s been in WWE but it’s hard to say if they would’ve ever been able to do the tard wrangling WWE obviously has been doing with Cody too. I don’t think Tony had the balls to tell Cody he’s going heel & challenging for the title.
Punk was very bad for AEW but Cody is worse because him leaving gave WWE a new top babyface. How different things could be right now if Cody stayed and got what he wanted.
>>16732089Ethan Page has tits
>>16732136this is an underrated aspect because the defacto top babyface in wwe before cody was fucking matt riddle
>>16732149and now it's Roman
>>16732042It was akin to stepping off the ledge
>>16732042Tony's biggest fumble was not asking his dad to buy WWE for him before TKO>>16732042>>16732042
>>16732042nah he wasnt over with the fans before he left. letting cody book himself into a corner was the mistake. he did massive damage to himself by giving indie jobbers title defenses and other codyverse shit. maybe if they never hired brandi and do something where he goes back on never going after the world belt (or never do that shit at all) he could have had this run in aew. him leaving or staying at the time he did leave wouldnt have changed anything
>>16732042Nah Cody was a cancer that needed to go.The Codyverse was shit.Crying about his dad was shit.Brandi was hot but shit.It was best for everyone.
>>16732089Why would Tony let so many shitters do whatever dime repellent schtick they want but never let Ethan Page be the bonafide star he so clearly is?
yeah i reckon, but its the fans fault, never shouldve booed him for no fucking reason
>>16732155You have to be there for the shows, events, interviews, media etc. to be the top babyface.
The lack of replies to your bait thread should tell you all you need to know
>>16732242Roman has cancer. please understand
>>16732042Wouldn't he be WWE's biggest fumble then? He quit because they made him Stardust. The version of him they have now was what he became in AEW. They at least built him into something
>>16732187Yeah but then if he forced the issue he could’ve gotten Collision & we get to nickname it Saturday Night CODEllision
>>16732042Him leaving objectively started the decline of AEW and they simply cannot argue any differently without being bitter and disingenuous
>>16732509He had it when he was a full timer too. Maybe it got worse, I don't know but genuinely, you can't be the top guy if you're not there to make all the shows.
>>16732209>For no reasonBut Cody himself said he was a meta heel, the booing was justified then
