What's the point of piano if you can program a midi or a piano roll to play it perfectly for you?t. someone who has played piano for years and has now realized this
>>80064595This is true for almost any instrument.
>>80064658Not true for string and wind instruments. Especially string instruments. Very hard to program them on midi and extremely expensive for a proper VST.
>>80064595If you were good at playing piano, you would know.
>>80064679Just tell him straight...
>>80064679This is my playing: https://voca.ro/17brU68XVLwTYou're really gonna call me bad?
>>80064716That was dogshit.
>>80064726The piece is 5 minutes long and you just typed that 3 minutes after my post. You're just being contrarian for the sake of it. I am asking real musicians here what they think. Not retards who goon to tranny porn and call it based. Fortnite is more your thing lil guy, go back
>>80064595Because it sounds like soulless trash (because it literally is) and if you were a decent musician, you would know that. But you seem to be someone who doesn't understand music. I'll also gladly post vocaroos of my playing if you believe I'm just some dude who has no idea.
>>80065476https://voca.ro/18kOSLlnOn3dreal piano or midi?
>>80064595learn to play a song on it and you will understand
>>80064595To impress young woman
https://youtu.be/TtCEFCxv6Z0?si=fA4loTzGoUG1APMdhttps://youtu.be/Nu48Z45ibxQ?si=uzqprrptbZ25EgYQ
>>80064595Women's vaginas get wet for physical activities like piano. They're vaginas get dry when thinking about technology.
Why play anything at all if you cant play it perfectly? Someone else is always just better than you. Just write the music and hand it to someone who wont fuck it up.
>>80066591Which one sounds better OP?
I play the piano at family gatherings and everyone loves it. On Christmas I played carols for my family and we all sang along to them. It brings people together.
>>80064595It's fun. That's literally it.>WHY DO PEOPLE LIFT WHEN MACHINES EXIST>WHY DO PEOPLE TRAIN MARTIAL ARTS WHEN GUNS EXIST>WHY DO PEOPLE COOK WHEN GOYSLOP EXISTSits fun. That has always been the answer.
>>80068004I don't seem to have fun playing the piano anymore. Guess i'll have to quit >>80066621I've heard synthesia VSTs that sound just as good as Rubinstein. You can program velocity in midi and all that "soul" shit. >>80066555>>80065476My Vocaroo, listen. >>80066570>>80066611I have impressed a few hotties with my skills, getting them all excited, but I still haven't gotten laid with it, so I don't really care to play anymore due to that.
>>80069294>I don't seem to have fun playing the piano anymore. Guess i'll have to quit nta but yeah if you're not having fun with a hobby then why continue? maybe lay off it and come back after a while and see if you enjoy it again.
>>80064672piano is a stringed instrument...
>>80070314no no no no no no no no no NO NO NO NO IT'S PERCUSSION YOU EVIL MAN D':
>>80064595>What's the point of piano if you can program a midi or a piano roll to play it perfectly for you?it depends what your goals aresuper serious musical performance is gonna be live anyway and need a real instrument
>>80069294>I've heard synthesia VSTs that sound just as good as RubinsteinShow me
>>80070489you can just program a midi file to match note velocity and tempo of a Rubinstein performance and run it on a grand piano which has an auto player.
>>80064595Programming "soul" is 100x more tedious and laborious than playing and recording a real instrument. I could only see someone legitimately preferring that route if they have years of experience in digital music production and zero experience playing real instruments, because to them it might feel more natural and easy
>>80064595Firstly, the same is true of sheet music and notation.ive made music using both input midi piano rolls and playing piano, bro, have you EVER actually made music with piano roll, inputing notes? shit takes forever.
>>80070314>erm acktually
>>80064595Too expensive I guesshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X1LWSB_cJwM
>>80070797>typing like a homosexual.
>>80071093A disklavier is cheaper than a Steinway Model D
>>80071276Yeah but too expensive for people to buy, and not many people would feel ok paying to listen to a machine play in a concert hall (and to play in said concert hall you would need the automated full size piano which is more expensive than the normal full size piano)
>>80071287Not many people are okay with Stockfish and Deep Blue either despite being better. Fuck the people. origiri
