[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/sci/ - Science & Math


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: europa.png (265 KB, 614x448)
265 KB
265 KB PNG
The surface is a radioactive wasteland, but could life actually exist underneath the ice? If so, what might it look like? Is 'muh liquid water' just cope?
>>
>>16543773
believe in religion and you'll come to realize that spiritual lifeforms already exist everywhere in the universe
>>
>>16543774
Go tell /x/ all about it my friend
>>
>>16543775
im gonna guess you believe your grandparents were monkeys and that you are a tiny meat machine in the skull
>>
>>16543778
Legit question: why are you on the science and math board if you’re just gonna spew whatever the DMT entities told you? You hippies are 100x more cringe than any fedora-tipper
>>
>>16543779
because science is about knowledge, and im delivering you knowledge
>>
>>16543786
Science is about what you can prove, and ‘I took 200mg of DMT’ isn’t a source. The question asked was specifically about Europa and the possibility of life there, which you answered with something completely irrelevant. Fuck off with your hippie bullshit back to /x/
>>
>>16543792
>Science is about what you can prove
Correct, and to prove something you need to observe something first.
The fact that people can observe spiritual beings during DMT trips prove that they're real.
>>
>>16543799
You're retarded.
>>
>>16543799
You know why they call DMT a ‘hallucinogen’, right?

The funniest thing is, I’m a God fearing Christian. Online atheists are as annoying to me as everyone else. What annoys me even more, however, are pseudo-philosophers who think they’re privy to divine knowledge that they did nothing to earn except the 20 bucks it cost them to buy whatever drugs it is they took. God alone decides his prophets, not you.

The only ‘spiritual entity’ I care for is the Lord. I’m telling you guys take it back to /x/ because they would lap it right up.

I’m here for scientific knowledge, not for some drug-addled heathen to tell me about ‘duh spirits, man.’
>>
>>16543799
For as-yet-unexplained reasons, DMT can cause a lot of people to have similar hallucinations. It doesn't prove anything is real.
Some people have tried to study and test the beings they encounter during DMT trips, and found that they can't provide any information that the person didn't already know. Whatever is going on there, it's happening within a single person's mind, not connecting them to a spirit realm or whatever.
>>
>>16543817
You believe in God, yet you deny the existence of spiritual beings, that makes you hypocritical at best, bigoted at worst.
>>16543810
An insult is not an argument, go somewhere else, maybe someone will humor your back-and-forth tantrums.
>>
>>16543819
Here's something, you can't measure dreams with scientific tools nor capture them in a video, does that make them nonexistent? Think.
>>
>>16543822
>you believe in God, yet you deny the existence of vague ‘spiritual lifeforms’ that ‘exist everywhere in the universe’ which clearly is not a reference to the Biblical God

Even ignoring the obvious retardation in your argument here, I have consciously decided not to engage in a discussion about how real these ‘lifeforms’ are, because, like I said, that’s a discussion better suited for /x/. I have made it very clear that I don’t care for any of it here, because this is completely irrelevant to what this thread, and by extension this board, is about.
>>
>>16543833
>N-no i don't want to argue, i just think you're an idiot alright?
That's pathetic behavior, not that I would expect anything less from you though.
Have a nice day mr.holier than thou
>>
>>16543839
See, you finally get it. I don’t want or need to argue with heathens such as yourself. Now that you’re going, someone might actually talk about Europa.

Have a blessed day, and repent.
>>
>>16543823
No, but you can remember the things that happen in dreams and deduce whether or not they included information that wasn't already in your mind.
With a larger sample size of DMT trippers reporting on their experiences, it would probably become pretty clear that they are not connecting to anything outside of themselves.
Some % of DMT users also report seeing completely unique things that have nothing to do with the "elves" or anything in common with other people's trips
>>
>>16543773
>the surface is a radioactive wasteland
What. Sir, those are glaciers.
>>
File: Blue LED diagram.jpg (80 KB, 1334x688)
80 KB
80 KB JPG
>>16543792
>Science is about what we can prove
Holy shit you're retarded.
99% of actual science is trying to demonstrate something everyone else is claiming to be impossible to actually be possible.
>>
>>16544079
Frozen oceans and glaciers aren't the same thing.
>>
>>16544188
In other words, proving shit. Retard.
>>
File: venting.2018[1].jpg (2.25 MB, 2560x1920)
2.25 MB
2.25 MB JPG
>>16543773
>could life actually exist underneath the ice?

If Europa does in fact have a liquid ocean 10-12 miles below the ice, and geothermal activity caused by its' orbit with Jupiter, than there's a distinct possibility Europa could have life around its' hydrothermal vents.

>what might it look like?

Colourful chemoautotrophic bacteria, worms, tubes, tube-worms, shrimp, crabs, bivalves, *maybe* fish, but that's a big maybe.
Hydrothermal vents can be quite rich in life.
>>
>>16543773
It's certainly worth sending a probe to find out.
>>
File: 1706671824069.png (80 KB, 320x280)
80 KB
80 KB PNG
>>16544412
We'd just end up seeding it with invasive tardigrades.
>>
File: 1693684548568984.jpg (287 KB, 1200x906)
287 KB
287 KB JPG
>>16544576
the radiation on the surface will sterilize anything reaching landing on it. Pointless anyway as good luck piercing the ice sheet with current proves and their extremely limited weights

>>16544367
>multicellular life on europa
yeah that aint going to happen. even on earth it took most of its existence for single cells to reach that power level. and earth is a cosmic garden of eden

maybe, if extremely lucky, some very simplistic single cells by the thermal vents. other unknown is also the acidity of the oceanic water which is another hazard for any fledgling life
>>
>>16544367
i don't think there's any reason to assume true multicellular life. as amazing as earth is, it still took billions of years to get there.
>>
>>16544702
>the radiation on the surface will sterilize anything reaching landing on it
Pretty sure spores can easily survive that
>>
>>16543773
giant squids or octopus most likely
>>
>>16545033
>it still took billions of years to get there
How much time has the hypotetical life on Europa had?
>>
>>16543773
The short answer is we have no idea and will need to go there and check.
I think the odds are low seeing nearly all life on earth is dependant on the sun but it's not impossible geothermal vents are providing energy to a Europan ecosystem.
>>
Europa alien here. Fuck off, we are full. We don't need or want your smelly jeets.
>>
>>16545992
The life we know uses the sun because the sun is available to it. That's like saying life can't survive without grass, because you grew up on a farm all the cows eat grass.

The deepest core samples ever drilled still show endoliths living in them. Life is fucking everywhere, and just evolves to take advantage of whatever is around. There is probably life on Mars, on the moon, on Europa, on Jupiter, on Pluto, and on dust in interstellar space.
>>
this board is so fucking gone, just look at this thread
>>
>>16543773
>If so, what might it look like?
Most likely, unicellular/colonial anaerobes. Complex life on earth didn't start showing up until the end of the oxygen holocaust (~500mya, cambrian), once there was plenty of high energy poison gas to exploit for energy
>>
>>16546265
What is wrong with this thread? This is a pretty good thread.
>>
>>16545033
Europa is the same age as Earth. Life there has had just as long to evolve.
>>
>>16546241
If there's life on the moon, where is it, and why haven't we detected it yet?
>>
>>16543773
It's possible, but a 'bit' too cold, so they'd need to have something to keep them warm.
There may be in Venus.
>>
>>16546397
We know next to nothing about Europa. We have never landed there.
>>
>>16543773
>Could there be actual life here?
Yes. Life may have developed on Europa near "Europa"-thermal vents at the bottom of its ocean(s) underneath the ice.
>>
not a chance. Our definition of life is anthrocentric and a fluke chemical reaction unique to our planet
>>
>>16546777
>>16546270
>>16545992
>>16545033
>>16544702

This is all, of course, assuming that life has to be made from scratch on every planet. That might not be the case.
NASA's Europa Clipper could arrive on Europa in the next 4 years, drill a big hole, find hypothetical life, take samples, and that life may end up being (very) distinctly related to life on Earth.

Spermatogenesis might be the canon, at least in our own system. Every Martian, Venusian, Terran, and Europan, might all share the same First Universal Ancestral Cells. We don't know, but I'm sure as shit excited to find out (it's on my personal bucket list of "questions I want Science to answer before I die").
>>
>>16546804
Europa Clipper doesn't have a drill.
>>
>>16546241
My point is there were vast areas of earth where life could start and have readily available energy from the sun.
On Europa life would need to form in what is likely a tiny percentage of the surface where active vents provide energy.
>>
>>16547142
The sun is most likely hostile towards abiogenesis. Its very hard to evolve to make use of it. Hydrothermal vents are a better tutorial zone.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.