[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/sp/ - Sports


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: IMG_7066.jpg (440 KB, 960x434)
440 KB
440 KB JPG
What is one controversial sports opinion you have that 99.9% of people would consider borderline retarded but you firmly hold on to it?
>>
>>150483609
You're retarded
>>
I'm convinced 1995 FC Nantes was the best European team this year and would have beat Ajax in the CL final.
>>
>>150483609
Higuian at napoles was ronaldo narazio prime level.
He could drible against everybody alone
>>
>>150483609
Yes, higuain is much bigger than Suarez I'd say at least 15 kgs bigger
>>
Maybe not 99.9% but I think virtually all blabla about tactics in football is made up bullshit. Most matches are decided entirely by who has the better players, who has the better matchday form and who gets more refball in their favor. All the guardiola autism is useless and he would have basically the same success with just vaguely telling them to do their best on the pitch.
>>
>>150488834
the Vamos strategy
>>
>>150488834
PSG had a better players with Verrati, Messi, Neymar and Mbappé so nah
>>
>>150492989
No chemistry
>>
>>150483609
A tragedy at a sports venue was possibly a planned sacrifice of human life under a large owl
>>
>>150492989
Verrati was a paperweight and the front three didn't help pressing/defending so no
>>
>>150488834
It's like this, it really is.
>>
>>150492989
the defense was also worse, so was the coach, Galtier doesnt show any sort of energy for wanting his team to do well just to get the job done for a paycheck.
Luis Enrique actually looks and sounds interested in having a winning team, and the midfield is much more functional its not just Verrati now, and the forwards actually press and do more than just waiting for the ball.
>>
Kits are one of the most important things in football
Most teams peak in their best kit and win nothing in their bad ones
>>
Pumping ball after ball into the box is a good strategy
>>
>>150494004
proper englishman
>>
>>150494049
>english
It's arteta nuevo mate
>>
>>150483609
That the NFL is "guided"
>>
4 4 fucking 2
>>
>>150493953
Cardiff were forced by Cardiff to play in red once upon a time. It wasn't the same. It really fcuked things up for them even more than usual. The kits, colours and badges and shit play their part
>>
>>150483609
Grealish will be for Moyes what Cantona was for Ferguson
>>
File: astroturf.png (492 KB, 1079x1165)
492 KB
492 KB PNG
>>150494122
This used to be controversial but the NFL tipped its hand the past few seasons with the Mahomes slurping and anyone who's not a Cheifs fan knows some of their games were sus as fuck (and Chiefs fans know it too, they just won't admit it).

Between years of blatantly favorable calls, the Taylor Swift hype machine and that Buffalo game with its incredibly dubious 4th down call, the jig was pretty much up. Even the normies were tweeting #rigged and the league had to backtrack and let the Chiefs lose fair and square for once just to reassure the public that it wasn't all scripted. But we all know how it was supposed to go. Calling it off at the last minute doesn't erase all the shit they were pulling right up to that point. And I feel compelled to point out this is the second time the Chiefs have gone in as heavy favorites and got absolutely blown the fuck out. If you happened to know that those games would be officiated fairly and that the Chiefs would lose as a result there was a lot of money to be made.
>>
>>150494550
That is interesting. Good noticing with your last points about them getting whipped with a fair ref
>>
>>150483609
They should give all the faux states independency so the World Cup could be a 256 team elimination tournament.
>>
Football should be a non contact sport
>>
>>150494550
Good post. Right before the Owl started, I started to realize they were going to pull the plug on the hype train and do the whole SEE SEE IT'S REAL thing. The games are real but the manipulation is so blatant to anyone who's watched it for decades.
>>
>>150496505
>Owl
Which owl?
>>
>>150483609
Basketball should be played in sets like volleyball, that way you'd have the 4th quarter excitement more times per game.
>>
League format is boring as fuck and embraced it killed Brazilian football.
>>
>>150497199
How would change the Brazilian comp and still provide a champ worthy of the name? I'm not against smaller leagues if it can be done nicely
>>
>>150488834
You are indeed retarded. Most players if you just don’t tell them anything they’ll either do nothing if they’re thick or they’ll work against what their teammates are doing and you get chaosball, you might have one player who tells the others what to do if you’re lucky he’ll have a good plan
>>
>>150483609
all major pro sports are rigged in some way or another
>>
>>150488834
Doesn't explain why Guardiola's teams don't have personal flair and everyone plays in a system, like they're part of a machine.

That's why he doesn't have dribblers.
>>
>>150493865
>>150492989
Verrati was made of glass desu
great player when he's not injured but he ended up missing like half of his possible matches at PSG due to injuries
>>
>>150496808
59
>>
>>150488834
Argentina didn't have the best players for the 2022 World Cup but they dominated every single game.

If it was about the best players, Brazil wouldn't have lost to Croatia, or Belgium.
>>
That VAR is a good thing and it's working fine
>>
Super League would have saved football
the monopoly needs to ripped from the hands of UEFA and FIFA
>>
Non constant scoring makes football boring for 90% of the time.
>>
File: voley-argentina-bronce.jpg (229 KB, 1013x675)
229 KB
229 KB JPG
Volleyball is a fun a and based sport that gets hate cuz manlets can't play
>inb4 the libero
Average height 180 cm, nice try!
Manlet rage at a sport that demands being tall and able to jump high. Also having fast reflexes.
And many won't admit it, but they resent being hit by the ball constantly, pussies!
>>
File: ctf.jpg (25 KB, 569x428)
25 KB
25 KB JPG
>>150483609
As an american who is disgusted by so, so many important soccer games having to resort to penalty kick shootouts because otherwise they could play forever without anyone ever scoring, I say you play whatever stoppage time there is without the offsides rule.

Yes, it would result in chaos and probably a lot of "cheap" game-winning goals, but is that any cheesier than just lining people up for point blank shots at the goal with no defenders and the whole thing being decided by the goalkeeper guessing right once or twice? Penalty kicks are an incredibly contrived way to end the game. Out of necessity, because it's so hard to score otherwise. But if the whole problem is that it's so hard to score why not give everyone a few minutes with a more offense-friendly ruleset at the very end of games? Just let people go nuts with no restrictions and end games with goals during actual play instead of people taking turns kicking a dead ball.

And the best part is this only opens the door to more games ending with goals, it doesn't guarantee any actually do. If no one scores during the offsides-free stoppage time at the end of OT you'd still have to go with penalty kicks. So this doesn't take away that aspect of the game, just makes it so like 80% of games don't end in ties or shootouts. Best of both worlds. And before

>stupid fucking american doesn't understand the beautiful game
Give me actual arguments why this wouldn't work instead of just the "that's the way it's always been so nothing can ever be different" mentality
>>
>>150498123
Fuck no, the American system is super retarded.
>Your team doesn't get punished for playing like absolute SHIT, they'll be back for the next competition no matter what.
>Your players are selected by a fucking draft
>Fans become brainless customers
>>
>>150483609
Barça wasn't a big European club before 2006.
Everything they dis before 1992 was meme tier and they got carried to an UCL final in both 1992 and 1994 by their manager and the competition format,. Just like marseille.
>>
>>150483609
France isn't a serious footballing nation.
>>
>>150498185
Agree.
At least in hockey it somewhat resembles actual gameplay IE a fastbreak
>>
Basketball is a sport designed for low iq people, designed to make scoring as easy as possible.
Even hardcore basketball fans will admit that a team not being able to score on 7 of every 10 possessions is a shitty team that needs to die.
I repeat
>unless you score on almost all of your ball possessions you are playing badly
Guaranteed scoring system that makes that the average point differential on a match is always 10 or 12 pts.
Average pts per game is on a 60 years high, they tried to give defense a break in the 90s and early 2000s and the people hated it. So now they turned it back to foul fishing and defense cucking.

A basketball game that ends 100-90 is the same as a football games that ends 1-0.
>>
>>150498340
>Basketball is a sport designed for low iq people, designed to make scoring as easy as possible.

I don't think that is particularly unpopular. The sport was designed as winter exercise so they wanted people mindlessly running up and down the court non-stop. Once it got more organized coaches tried to stop that but then rules were added to defeat the coaching shenanigans
>>
>>150498340
the problem with your metaphor is that a made field goal in basketball doesn't really count the same as a goal in football. in football a goal is a game-changing event that is massively celebrated, in basketball it's a back-and-forth and an eb-and-flow kind of game where it's about consistently delivering for 40-48 minutes, especially in the final 5 minutes where actions are magnified because there is less time for the opposing team

its just a different kind of "scoring" like in football
>>
>>150483609
that all england needed to do was build a team around glen hoddle first, and then copy that template for le tiss, and we'd have at least 2 more world cups by now
>>
They should eliminate the shot clock in basketball and open up the rules to allow for more aggressive contact.
>>
File: furious.jpg (72 KB, 1000x488)
72 KB
72 KB JPG
>>150498340
That wasn't the intent, at least at the beginning. Ironically, basketball almost went under as a spectator sport because in the pre-shot clock era teams would just hold the ball forever and wait out the clock when they had the lead. It wasn't good defense, just nonexistent offense. The shot clock forcing teams to actually try and score saved the sport.

But yeah, it's gone hard in the other direction and it creates this sort of inherent statflation that's great for marketing above-average players as "all-time greats." I mean, in a sport where both teams score 50 times a game, how impressive is scoring, really? What's the difference between actually being good and just shooting a lot? Somebody's going to score 20-30 points in any given game by deafult. It's a statistical certainty because even shit teams score in the 90's and it's not because 9 guys have 10 points each. But whenever someone does this routine thing we act like it's an accomplishment and that they're great instead of just average.

This sort of non-impactful faux productivity is how guys like Bradley Beal make like $400 million despite never actually accomplishing anything or being good in a way that actually makes their team better. No sport has more fake "superstars" than basketball.
>>
>>150498254
They're too smart to be obsessed with le football
>>
>>150498671
Every other club in London seethed about Hoddle. Why did they hate him and spurs so much? Scandalous. Le Tissier was kino almost every match. What a waste of both talents. If there was ever a spurs player that didn't play for spurs it was le tissier.
>>
Super Bowl 43 was rigged for the Pittsburgh Steelers over the Arizona Cardinals, and the famous Harrison pick6 had at least 3 personal fouls on PIT (2 holding, 1 clipping iirc) that would have negated the whole thing.
>>
>>150498340
>Basketball is a sport designed for low iq people
Basketball isn't, but NBA "basketball" isn't even a sport - it's WWE-level "sports entertainment" to sell merch to monkeys.
>>
Curry is better than lebron and a goat candidate
The game is about shooting the ball
>>
Pelé is the goat
>>
Australians should apologize to lumumba. He was unfarily treated
>>
>>150483609
I would rather watch men’s volleyball than women’s volleyball
>>
T10 cricket is enjoyable
>>
>>150488834
this right here is what separates true football knowers from couch midwits
football is 70% tactics 30% physicality, star players are useless if they can't do a basic pass + run to space and much less if they can't coordinate a good marking
you need to play footy to understand this
>>
>>150483609
A-Rod is the greatest baseball player ever
>>
>>150501488
HH
>>
>>150492989
>Verrati
just not that good
>Messi
very old by that point, far too late to adapt to another European league
>Neymar
he's famous for being overrated
>Mbappe
their one good YOUNG player, but he continues to be a flat track bully at Real
>>
A manager is only as good as his connections. That's why so many ex-footballers from top clubs get management jobs - club owners hope they have connections to bring in good or promising players. Coaching can be done by the coaches, tactics are just whatever the latest fad is. It's all connections. Some top players however failed to make connections like Wayne Rooney, but Harry Redknapp went as far as he did because of his connections. When Redknapp's connections left football, his managerial career ended. If an ex-player becomes a manager but fails right away, they were simply not a good people person. Rooney, Gary Neville, Steven Gerrard all failed in that respect. They were footballers for ~20 years but failed to make connections.
>>
>>150498060
You're not necessarily wrong but Brazil's failure had more to do with the absence of cajones in Brazilian "men" than with tactics. We weren't beaten tactically, we choked like fags.
Argentina won in part because of Scaloni's work, indeed, but largely because of morale and dedication. But you're right to say having the best players doesn't mean you'll always win.
>>
>>150500852
>men's volleyball
Is this real?
>>
File: Connecion.mp4 (1.54 MB, 480x854)
1.54 MB
1.54 MB MP4
>>150502064
>connections
Too right, Arteta has all kinds of connections and he's survived so far
>>
>>150483609
This might actually be the shittiest opinion I've ever heard. Not even the most deranged and autistic Real Madrid fan and Barcelona hater would say this
>>
Titles dont matter. Teams are big according to their geographical location and fanbase numbers. Thus Arsenal will always be a bigger club than say, Ajax or Porto
>>
>>150483609
>Higuain better than Suárez at any point of their careers
You're right, that's one fucking retarded opinion. Here's mine and I don't care if you disagree, some olympic events like shooting and archery and the like should include men and women in a single competition, not to prove any kind of point or because there aren't any potential inherent advantages between the sexes, but rather because the program inflation is absolutely ridiculous and a lot of events should be cut where they could.
>>
>>150492989
>with Verrati, Messi, Neymar and Mbappé so nah
Verrati spent more time injured than playing with them, and so did Neymar. Also, I will always maintain that Messi & Mbappé was an underrated duo, but that PSG midfield and defense were utter dogshite. Having three superior players upfront that were rarely available all that once =/ having a better team.
>>
>>150504328
>ajax
Where do you start and finish with ajax? Not too sure about that but arsenal aren't given enough credit by know nuffins desu
>>
>>150483609
The final WBC showdown between Ohtani and Trout was an overrated foregone conclusion after Mookie Betts sucked the air out of the whole stadium.
>>
>>150498060
>dominated every single game
what are you smoking my man
>>
>>150498254
I don't see how it's controversial. The league almost went bankrupt and died several times in the last seasons because nobody wanted to pay more than 20€/month to watch it on tv.
>>
>>150497480
Like it was until 2002. One leg only and a playoff with the best 8 teams.

Or even better 2 groups of 10 plays 2 legs and the first 4 of each group go do playoff.

>but you will not play against Indio FC from Amazon.

Who cares?
>>
>>150496992
Agreed
>>
>>150498185
They got rid of the golden goal rule (first team to score during 30 minutes of additional play wins) which helped to encourage teams to keep attacking during extra time. Now, they play the 30 minutes regardless, so they just sit deep, defend and pray for penalties most of the time.
>>
File: _91408619_.jpg (54 KB, 976x850)
54 KB
54 KB JPG
>>150499807
>They're too smart
>>
File: jose.jpg (388 KB, 1926x1227)
388 KB
388 KB JPG
>>150483609
Footy should return to the old days when youngsters couldnt leave their home country asap.
Old champions league format was way better than what we have now, because it was actually champions vs champions and not "big countries have 4 teams each and the rest fight for scraps".
There should be a stricter limit for foreign players to encourage homegrown talent, and you shouldnt be able to "naturalize" someone that easily.
>>
I don’t think the majority of “top” players would have even got a look in ten or fifteen years ago. This isn’t me boomerposting about guys that played before matches were televised, but the current crop of “world class” players are evidently not very good at football. They’re all completely lacking in skill, flair and talent. They can run about loads for long periods of time and that’s about it

Also I think most of the Olympic events should be scrapped. The Conference League, Europa League and all second string cups that top teams can compete for (EFL Cup) should go with them
>>
>>150483792
>won the league with 16 draws
kek
>>
>>150507581
Good post.

>>150508079
>The Conference League, Europa League and all second string cups that top teams can compete for (EFL Cup) should go with them
Why?
>>
File: Alex Meier.jpg (361 KB, 2100x1519)
361 KB
361 KB JPG
Disregard Klose, this is the best german striker of the last 20 years.
>>
>>150488834
That's truly retarded cause what you think is matchday form or refball is tactics getting the best out of players and surpressing the opponents
>>
>>150493953
Germany switched to red away shirts under Klinsmann because statistically teams with red kits are more successful. Back in the day Bayern always used to lose away to Kaiserslautern so they started to play in Brazil colors against them to break the curse.
>>
>>150501217
>star players are useless if they can't do a basic pass + run to space

thats not tactics....
>>
>>150507546
>They got rid of the golden goal rule (first team to score during 30 minutes of additional play wins) which helped to encourage teams to keep attacking during extra time.

it actually just made them play super defensive as one goal conceded and theyre out
>>
>>150483609
all of my opinions are based and objectively correct
50-60% of people disagree with everything i say but that's because 50-60% of people are retarded



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.