[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


What is the difference between an Ogre and a Troll?
>>
Ogres are like onions, trolls are like garlic.
>>
>>92605442
the name
>>
>>92605442
Ogres are bullies and Trolls are predators. An Ogre will stomp into a village and demand every barrel of ale or else somebody's getting eaten, while a Troll will stalk the outskirts of that village and break into one of the huts at night to eat everyone.
>>
women want to fuck one but not the other
>>
>>92605442
Ogres move around, while trolls are content to take up residence under bridges and such.
>>
>>92605442
Big angry babies vs big angry guys who look kinda like what a scared woodsman would see if he was scared by a collection of branches and trees in the dark.
>>
>>92605442
Ogres can get a tan.
>>
>>92605509
They're both great with just about anything?
>>
>>92605442
It's something you have to get ogre, for sure.
>>
Ogres and trolls are two very different creatures. A better question would be what's the difference between an ogre and a giant
>>
>>92605442
Ogres are a dumber, meaner, smaller, more cannibalistic version of giants. Trolls are magical, malicious, elemental and really really like to hurt and eat people.
>>
File: 57.jpg (705 KB, 1920x1920)
705 KB
705 KB JPG
>>92605442
One suffers from an abundance of wrath, the other, envy.
>>
This is an Ogre
>>
File: 638063929586218907.png (304 KB, 723x1000)
304 KB
304 KB PNG
>>92606540
This is a troll
>>
>>92605442
Ogre do not know how to use the internet
>>
>>92606390
The main difference is the height, the giant is bigger.
In addition, there are types of giants that have elemental and sometimes divine powers.
>>
>>92605442
>What is the difference between an Ogre and a Troll?
Str + large health pool vs Dex + regeneration
>>
>>92606540
>>92606551
This is the only time that copying Warcraft is more beneficial than being traditional.
>>
>>92606533
based but unfortunately it is not the case in any game.
>>
>>92607025
>using official settings
hmm
>>
>>92607245
I'm just saying that it's a good idea that you came up with, but it's not a fact that it's part of the general culture.
>>
File: John_Bauer_1915.jpg (276 KB, 800x751)
276 KB
276 KB JPG
>>92605442
Depends on the setting.

In generic/classic fantasy terms, ogres are just big brutes, whereas trolls are big brutes that can regenerate. Their behavior is largely identical, but the latter is a lot meaner than the former - offset by the fact that trolls tend to be more reclusive and isolated, while ogres are more numerous and aggressive.

In terms of the folkloric inspiration behind them, there's much less to say. Trolls, of course, come from scandinavian folklore, but a troll is just a classification there: everything from a big ettin to an elflike huldra could be classified as a troll. See attached, they're all trolls. Yes, even the pretty lady. You could best typify them as reclusive pagan nature-spirits.

Ogres, on the other hand, are an even wider classification: Anything could be called an "ogre" if it was big, brutish, and ideally fed on manflesh. Indeed, like >>92606390 mentions, ogres and giants were often linked and giants could be described as ogrish.

Of course, when talking about roleplaying games one's depiction of trolls/ogres could reference either inspiration or neither of them, and indeed a setting might have one but not the other, or have them just be different subcategories of the same species.

So again, depends on the setting.
>>
>>92605442
ogres have layers
>>
>>92605442
One looks like your mum, the other looks like your dad
>>
File: myarm-37413694.png (82 KB, 512x334)
82 KB
82 KB PNG
Trolls are named after the first thing they tried to eat
>>
>>92605442
Ogres are hungry because they have the power of lard. Trolls are jackasses because they have the power of regeneration. Both fear the flame, one being walking fuel and the other because of cauterization.
>>
>>92605442
Trolls live under bridges, Ogres live in castles.
>>
>>92605612
I will not tolerate such vicious slander.
Trolls collect bridge tolls.
They are government employees and all-around respectable members of society.
>>
>>92605442
Ogres are just massive blobs of "ME WANT EAT YOU". Trolls are remnants of a long lost civilisations, they have a certain ancient wisdom to them even though they are also man-eating giants. Deep in the mountains you can still find the now abandoned troll castles hiding in the fog, built from massive stones and rubble, weathering the millenia and often confused with the mountains surrounding them. Meanwhile the most refined thing an ogre has ever done was breaking the branches off a felled tree to make a club, or shitting outside of his cave.
>>
>>92605442
Trolls are vicious predators.
Ogres are neanderthals
>>
>>92605442
The mods know what an ogre is.
>>
>>92605442
depends on the setting.
>>
>>92605442
>>92606390
obviously variable depending on setting but for a lot of my homebrew ones it generally goes as such;

Ogres are large brutish louts but are roughly equivalent to humans(and most other Demi-Human & Monstrous Humanoid races) in terms of intellectual potential, not often realized due to the rural isolation most Ogres live in but it's there(indeed some of the greatest magic users the world has ever seen have been Ogres), so an Ogre can potentially be reasoned with

Trolls are theoretically capable of reaching approximate human intelligence but most are essentially feral, about as smart as a Raven, Dolphin, or Chimpanzee, sometimes peaking at about equivalent to a human toddler

Giants are well weird, some are clearly hyper-intelligent, while others are almost as bestial as the average Troll
>>
>>92606390
Giants are wise and hold ancient secrets like runesinging.
>>
>>92605442
https://www.d20srd.org/srd/monsters/ogre.htm
https://www.d20srd.org/srd/monsters/troll.htm
any other retarded questions?
>>
>>92607010
Trolls literally have twice as much Str as Dex
>>
>>92605442
Both are mythological rendering of the nephilim, biblical giants. Nephils were described with words relating to cannibalism (ogre), turning into stone (trolls), and regeneration (modern entertainment trolls).
>>
>>92606390
Cultural legends. See >>92607539 and >>92611106
>>
File: Dick Kickem.jpg (9 KB, 225x225)
9 KB
9 KB JPG
>>92605442
Your face, your ass - what's the difference?
>>
>>92611604
one is for eating and the other is for shitting.
>>
>>92605442
ogres are really big people and trolls are just animals
>>
File: Ogre Thread.png (1.67 MB, 1401x6556)
1.67 MB
1.67 MB PNG
>>92605442
Ogres live in basements and like to watch mad max.
>>
File: cuddle session.jpg (516 KB, 1786x1469)
516 KB
516 KB JPG
>>92605442
The difference is that ogres have fat girthy cocks whole trolls have curved tapering cocks, what they have in common is that i want both to defile me :3
>>
File: 412.jpg (47 KB, 640x480)
47 KB
47 KB JPG
>>92617367
plausible
>>
>>92605442
ogres have layers, trolls don't
>>
>>92605831
Wait, so if a troll come up out the bridge, then he a ogre?
>>
Ogres are furless trolls.
>>
>>92605442
Both are big monsters, either gray, green or something. Both are violent and grotesque. Difference is Ogres are fat grotesque, and trolls are skinny grotesque.
>>
Basically just repeating others, but the important thing to me is that ogres are degenerate hillbillies with superficial trappings of civilization, while trolls are more savage. Ogres are like the dumbest civilized humanoids while trolls are more like the smartest of the feral monsters.

I prefer it when ogres use clubs and trolls use claws/teeth. But 3e Forgotten Realms had a troll fighter NPC that I liked, because he had unusually high int and unusually low str, he's using armor and a sword because he's the smartest weakest and most nerdy of the trolls.
>>
>>92617367
>>92617376
cringe and gay
>>
>>92625096
Perhaps, wouldn't stop me from putting on green fatsuit and plowing that bratty twink while All Star blasts in the background.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.