[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • Additional supported file types are: PDF
  • Roll dice with "dice+numberdfaces" in the options field (without quotes).

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


If you like them lewd I don't wanna hear it.
Just a little inb4 because I know you fuckers.
>>
File: 1531861396022.jpg (360 KB, 1280x1600)
360 KB
360 KB JPG
>>94531269
Currently using them as an ancient and defeated race from before the epoch of man. Real tall, more towards unique domains and responsibilities like classic greek titans.
One living but detached head in a powerful witch's basement the players know about and want to get at.
Another potentially passed out and grown over as a snoring hill but turning in its sleep/waking up due to a recent large magical war.
>>
>>94531269
I like my Giants to be big hulking rape monsters with enormous cocks.
Futanari, of course
>>
>>94531331
>he has a 16th century icelandic christian magic-rune for wayfinding on his head
lol
>>
File: DF62zE5XgAA5uIW.jpg (229 KB, 735x829)
229 KB
229 KB JPG
>>94531269
>How do you like your giants?
Decapitated
>>
I like them being fairly intelligent and not falling for the false dichotomy of if you're big and strong you must also be dumb.
>>
Pretty basic and all and all. Split into several different varieties. Frost and Fire giants are opposed and, depending on the setting, mythic quasi-deitie sort of creatures. Cloud/sky giants tend to be rare and roughly analogous to giants because I like the whole 'fought a war over the world before the age of men,' cliche. "Just normal giants," tend to be a bit less than twice the height of a man, grey skin tones, nomadic cultures often enough. Usually all but the cloud giants have horns of some kind as a distinguishing feature, but don't do it for every setting.

Players tend to only deal with the smallest kind, and with women. I often represent them as patriarchal and with a superiority complex. Doing cooperative 'adventuring' and managing trade and diplomacy with smaller folk is woman's work. Same as managing slaves of smaller races at home. This attitude falls off as you get to more individually powerful races of giant.
>>
Big, mean, and clever.
>>
>>94531905
Yes, well done, you've posted it again. Now fuck off and let people talk about giants, often used in traditional games.
>>
>>94531269
I like them as precursor races, with a few individuals left roaming, the rest trapped in some magical prison (usually in the sky). They range from idiots to geniuses, just like people, but they're all partial to the taste of human bones (the smarter ones prefer to boil their victims first so they can get the clean bones).
>>
>>94531269
I like my giants actually fuckin giant. I wanna fe fi foe and crush people to death with a tree trunk one handed.
>>
My current campaign is all about giants. The players are exploring a vast untamed taiga in the north that ancient maps leave blank and just call "zigantia" or "the land of giants" in modern tongue.
The story, unbeknownst to the players, is that there were 8 rephaim, giants of divine heritage, that fought for the right to ascend to godhood there in prehistoric times. whole civlilizations rose and fell at their whims and conflicts. In the end there were no victors.
The giants that remain there are terribly degenerated and in the worst cases utterly muted into hideous monsters.
>>
File: frys.jpg (118 KB, 1024x1024)
118 KB
118 KB JPG
ice-giants are real
>>
>>94531269
i dunno what about you???
>>
giants are woke
that is why they always announce theyr pronounc when they enter a room
FE FI FO FUM
THESE ARE ALL MY PRO-NUNS
>>
>>94531453
I was under the impression those were older than that but incorporated by christian proselytizing. Not a scandiweeb though. Just read Mouth of the Whale by coincidence (was in the laundry bookshelf), which was an interesting portrayal of mixed pagan magical thinking, hedge wizard magic and early modernism in an isolated island.
>>
>>94532838
>absolutely mind broken since may 2024
>>
>>94531269
In which games?
>>
>>94532270
There is no talk. Only anons posting opinions on stuff that does not matter. No replies. No discussion. It's empty.
>>
>>94531269
>How do you like your giants?
Tiny.
>>
>>94534339
Some giant balls too, forgot about those
>>
File: image4.jpg (357 KB, 1356x2048)
357 KB
357 KB JPG
>>
File: image5.jpg (61 KB, 678x906)
61 KB
61 KB JPG
>>
File: image1.png (1.19 MB, 831x1027)
1.19 MB
1.19 MB PNG
>>
File: dnaljsbgdljasbgd.jpg (496 KB, 1193x1675)
496 KB
496 KB JPG
>>
File: image3.png (473 KB, 498x635)
473 KB
473 KB PNG
>>
File: image24.png (1.73 MB, 1387x1217)
1.73 MB
1.73 MB PNG
>>
File: image7.png (692 KB, 800x795)
692 KB
692 KB PNG
>>
File: image8.jpg (211 KB, 948x1600)
211 KB
211 KB JPG
>>
File: image9.png (642 KB, 900x1180)
642 KB
642 KB PNG
>>
File: image29.jpg (336 KB, 1200x834)
336 KB
336 KB JPG
>>
File: dasdafvwe.jpg (154 KB, 811x979)
154 KB
154 KB JPG
>>
File: image40.jpg (89 KB, 735x1024)
89 KB
89 KB JPG
>>
File: image33.png (392 KB, 536x822)
392 KB
392 KB PNG
>>
File: image41.jpg (47 KB, 510x784)
47 KB
47 KB JPG
>>
File: image34.jpg (91 KB, 665x419)
91 KB
91 KB JPG
>>
File: image19.jpg (364 KB, 707x1000)
364 KB
364 KB JPG
>>
File: image43.jpg (425 KB, 1387x1572)
425 KB
425 KB JPG
>>
File: image48.jpg (58 KB, 700x501)
58 KB
58 KB JPG
>>
File: image21.jpg (310 KB, 779x974)
310 KB
310 KB JPG
>>
File: image30.jpg (1.31 MB, 1039x1600)
1.31 MB
1.31 MB JPG
>>
File: image51.jpg (815 KB, 1149x1500)
815 KB
815 KB JPG
>>
File: juahodugosad.png (3.43 MB, 1181x1575)
3.43 MB
3.43 MB PNG
>>
File: fenrir.jpg (56 KB, 400x328)
56 KB
56 KB JPG
>>94531269
>Among the inhabitants of the Plane of Ysgard, fensirs are commonly called trolls, despite the fact that the two kinds of creatures are completely unrelated. Fensirs are giants—albiet cultured and intelligent ones that desire only to be left alone. The two different kinds of fensirs are normal ones (males and females) and the dreaded rakkas—female fensirs that undergo a hideous transofrmation that turns them into gigantic brutes that rampage around the countryside.
>3.0 MM2
>>
File: image46.jpg (533 KB, 1384x1038)
533 KB
533 KB JPG
>>
File: image15.jpg (568 KB, 1131x1600)
568 KB
568 KB JPG
>>
File: image45.jpg (660 KB, 1337x1575)
660 KB
660 KB JPG
>>
File: image13.jpg (106 KB, 800x1029)
106 KB
106 KB JPG
>>
File: image50.jpg (378 KB, 1383x1039)
378 KB
378 KB JPG
>>
File: image26.jpg (78 KB, 454x816)
78 KB
78 KB JPG
>>
File: image37.jpg (75 KB, 583x982)
75 KB
75 KB JPG
>>
File: image47.jpg (501 KB, 1575x1239)
501 KB
501 KB JPG
>>
File: image18.jpg (306 KB, 777x1575)
306 KB
306 KB JPG
>>
>>94534241
You're confusion "talk" with "conversation". The former needs no replies.
>>
>>94531453
It's not the Helm of Terror?
>>
>>94531331
>>94532286
These, but they built things and taught people.
Then they left. Where did they go? Elsewhere.
They travelled to other realities through elf-mounds, giant's circles and caves. Someday, they may return.
>>
>>
>>94531269
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: .Fire Giant King.jpg (99 KB, 700x901)
99 KB
99 KB JPG
>>
File: giant (1).jpg (120 KB, 800x850)
120 KB
120 KB JPG
>>94547973
>>
File: giant (12).jpg (44 KB, 405x582)
44 KB
44 KB JPG
>>94547977
>>
File: giant.png (360 KB, 662x476)
360 KB
360 KB PNG
>>94547981
>>
>>94531269
You've heard of giants, haven't you lad?
Tall, towering men and women, so tall that their heads scrape the clouds... but their feet are planted firmly on the earth.
Their ambitions go no further than that. Remember this well boy. Though the sky is far above our heads, unlike the giants, he strive to reach even heigher than the clouds. Giants never look up. They're always staring down, at the earth, at us. But humans, aye, humans, we stare up. Not at the giants, but at the stars. The stars that we shall one day, sail among, to travel, to trade, and conquer. But even when we are so far above the giants that we would be a mere twinkling in their glassy eyes, we will never look down. We shall look up, up lad, for above the stars we've conquered shall be the stars we've yet to conquer. Then that will be our destiny.
Aye lad, remember these words well, and when the time comes. Pass them on.
>>
File: 4drUC2S.jpg (352 KB, 1100x1555)
352 KB
352 KB JPG
>>
>>94531453
That's not vegvisir.
Also, vegvisir is a stave and not a rune.
Also also, the earliest attestation of vegvisir are from the 19th century, not 16th century.
Pseud.
>>
File: giant (5).jpg (1.61 MB, 2126x1163)
1.61 MB
1.61 MB JPG
>>94548434
>>
File: giant (9).jpg (165 KB, 1584x2880)
165 KB
165 KB JPG
>>94551307
>>
File: giant (10).jpg (86 KB, 490x693)
86 KB
86 KB JPG
>>94554093
>>
File: 1729474479847273.jpg (63 KB, 540x508)
63 KB
63 KB JPG
>>94531269
They're my favorite monster, but in play they're just a sack of hit points and their size doesn't play in at all.I tried to run them as shadow of the colossus-monsters able to be climbed on and able to be tripped to gain + to hit their weakpoints but it just became convoluted and didn't work well. Frequently I get visions of giants sieging a castle or the like and get inspired but then I remember they're just shit.
>>
File: eZEYncW.jpg (57 KB, 579x800)
57 KB
57 KB JPG
>>
>>94550645
dumb frogposter
>>
>>94534241
>Only anons posting opinions on stuff that does not matter.
It matters to me and everyone discussing it
>No replies.
Wrong
>No discussion.
Wrong
>It's empty
To you, go back to whatever general or political bait thread you got lost on your way to, subhuman swine. Sorry but some of us like to discuss fantasy on the board that was originally made for scifi and fantasy lore fags
>>
>>94531269
Went to another dimension for some unspecified reason. Only one of each kind stayed behind in a self-imposed exile.
>>
I actually prefer the bog standard fantasy depiction of them. 3-4 times the size of a man, tribalistic/prehistoric tech level and culture.
Balancing out their size with lower intelligence just feels intuitive and right to me.

I don't really need a forced spin on them.
>>
File: snoke.png (1.28 MB, 1200x680)
1.28 MB
1.28 MB PNG
I remember when I saw Force Awakened, at the scenes introducing Snoke before it showed to just be a hologram, I thought he was actually a giant and thought that seemed like a fucking cool concept, like does he have a lightsaber with a 20-foot-long blade, what's fighting him going to look like
>>
>>94559999
nice digits, pseud
>>
>>94560243
I know! Fuck those shyster shylocks for all this mystery box baiting.
>>
>>94531269
Big loveable, forrest gumps to their teammates and absolute scary fuckers to fight against.
>>
File: Huge Cat Fight.jpg (121 KB, 828x1242)
121 KB
121 KB JPG
>>
File: giant (4).jpg (431 KB, 1280x1600)
431 KB
431 KB JPG
>>94555701
>>
>>94559999
Holy BTFO, quads of truth
>>
>>94551307
>half a boat as a helmet
>weilding an anchor
>the other boat half is a bracer

Be still, my aching heart.
>>
File: 0 (599).jpg (353 KB, 1920x1080)
353 KB
353 KB JPG
>>94563353
>>
File: 79xpNYA.jpg (417 KB, 1920x2452)
417 KB
417 KB JPG
>>
File: 109783489734.jpg (264 KB, 1024x1016)
264 KB
264 KB JPG
>>94531269
I like all giants. Both the big, bumbling, comic relief grunts working for the big bads and the impossibly skilled and wise titans mentioned in myths. Whether they’re ugly, big nosed brutes or just "humans, but really tall and beautiful."

They’re just infinitely cooler than dragons imo. Also, yes. I do like lewd giants.
>>
File: G04H6tz.jpg (776 KB, 1920x1641)
776 KB
776 KB JPG
>>
File: zdZ5cCL.jpg (331 KB, 848x1200)
331 KB
331 KB JPG
>>
File: taGBgIP.jpg (311 KB, 1920x1222)
311 KB
311 KB JPG
>>
File: 1320961574541.jpg (2.22 MB, 1600x1070)
2.22 MB
2.22 MB JPG
>>94560186
So, something like this?
>>
File: giant.jpg (96 KB, 640x896)
96 KB
96 KB JPG
>>94568622
>>
File: iIEKG8h.jpg (152 KB, 1920x1260)
152 KB
152 KB JPG
>>
File: 0 (1).png (1.7 MB, 966x1143)
1.7 MB
1.7 MB PNG
>>94575548
>>
File: FemaleFrostGiant.jpg (257 KB, 1400x933)
257 KB
257 KB JPG
>>94531269
People but bigger
>>
>>94531269
In what game?
>>
>>94579211
Pick one, retard.
>>
File: 0 (209).jpg (118 KB, 1200x675)
118 KB
118 KB JPG
>>94579149
>>
File: 1467393461752.jpg (65 KB, 640x463)
65 KB
65 KB JPG
Couple of giant dum-dums.
>>
File: 0 (1407).jpg (477 KB, 1920x1080)
477 KB
477 KB JPG
>>94580227
>>
>>94548476
Bump for interest.
>>
File: 0 (1666).jpg (205 KB, 1280x699)
205 KB
205 KB JPG
>>94584725
>>
File: 0 (1735).jpg (55 KB, 800x570)
55 KB
55 KB JPG
>>94589664
>>
File: giant (7).jpg (504 KB, 1920x1080)
504 KB
504 KB JPG
>>94590549
>>
File: 4099964053838.jpg (198 KB, 1155x1155)
198 KB
198 KB JPG
>>94555864
>Frequently I get visions of giants sieging a castle
>>
File: OV1DGnQ.jpg (124 KB, 474x639)
124 KB
124 KB JPG
>>
File: JcIX0t3.png (1.2 MB, 1080x1375)
1.2 MB
1.2 MB PNG
Green man and wild men are almost always gigantic in stories.
>>
File: Giant_BY_Shabazik.jpg (444 KB, 1125x1200)
444 KB
444 KB JPG
>>
File: Giant_BY_GeraldBrom.jpg (258 KB, 939x1200)
258 KB
258 KB JPG
>>
File: GiantSlingers.png (2.17 MB, 1280x720)
2.17 MB
2.17 MB PNG
>>94555864
Have some slingers, then.
>>
File: 1569880380070.jpg (99 KB, 1024x768)
99 KB
99 KB JPG
>>
File: 1569657850378.jpg (54 KB, 400x555)
54 KB
54 KB JPG
More Ice-giants.
>>
File: 1569268142047.jpg (71 KB, 416x590)
71 KB
71 KB JPG
Man-eaters
>>
File: 1569231266051.jpg (17 KB, 280x408)
17 KB
17 KB JPG
Adversaries
>>
File: troll-1745.png (1.56 MB, 851x1104)
1.56 MB
1.56 MB PNG
>>94564811
You might like this one then.
>>
File: giant.jpg (168 KB, 517x855)
168 KB
168 KB JPG
>>94531269
they shouldn't just be "exactly the same as a regular person just 15 to 100 feet tall" cause that's fucking boring, they should have some weirdness to them, especially if it's in the vein of having physiology adapted to their larger size
>>
>>94591904
best one yet. slings are awesome and giants using them are basically just trebuchets with more mobility
>>
File: Battle_Cartman.png (712 KB, 675x1026)
712 KB
712 KB PNG
>>94531269
sizeshifters are a neat concept. id love to see a attack on titan style world with meat mechas but more medieval

also pieck is peak waifu
>>
File: 0 (4).png (89 KB, 239x222)
89 KB
89 KB PNG
>>94591276
>>
File: 0 (537).jpg (295 KB, 1197x834)
295 KB
295 KB JPG
>>94595783
>>
File: 0 (853).jpg (220 KB, 796x1000)
220 KB
220 KB JPG
>>94598216
>>
>>94531269
a good Giant is a Diet God
>>
File: Titan-Mooreberos.jpg (217 KB, 617x616)
217 KB
217 KB JPG
>>94599608
Based and Titan-pilled.
>>
File: Sea-Giant-Celts.jpg (69 KB, 467x617)
69 KB
69 KB JPG
>>94599608
Or maybe something more loosely defined as "near-god"?
>>
File: 1604498180409.jpg (208 KB, 916x675)
208 KB
208 KB JPG
>>94594573
If you think this is boring...
>>
>>94594573
>>94603037
...you're gonna end up with giants like this.
More of an elemental horror in my opinion, but you do you.
>>
File: thatsapenis.png (3.01 MB, 1920x1370)
3.01 MB
3.01 MB PNG
>>94603052
>>
File: titan (2).png (446 KB, 722x454)
446 KB
446 KB PNG
>>94603052
Disney's Hercules came out when I was a kid, and ever since then I've seen Titans as elemental giants.
>>
>>94603080
Indeed, he's no Ouranos.
Why on earth would you want to save jpeg as a png?
>>
File: 0 (12).jpg (346 KB, 1476x879)
346 KB
346 KB JPG
>>94603052
>>
File: bbJEiEy.jpg (86 KB, 900x665)
86 KB
86 KB JPG
>>
File: 0 (300).jpg (114 KB, 1200x635)
114 KB
114 KB JPG
>>94599413
>>
>>94594803
holy shit titanslop has jumped the shark
>>
File: 0 (302).jpg (220 KB, 1208x758)
220 KB
220 KB JPG
>>94609651
>>
File: 05pBJe1.jpg (416 KB, 1920x1920)
416 KB
416 KB JPG
>>
File: Lu594Bv.jpg (496 KB, 1920x1280)
496 KB
496 KB JPG
>>
File: 0 (653).jpg (127 KB, 800x1100)
127 KB
127 KB JPG
>>94611860
>>
What are some good mechanics for dealing with interactions between creatures of wildly different scales? Like, not just in combat, but also just in general.
>>
>>94611034
aot has been finished for a while anon. any shark jumping is in the past. the pictured cart titan was present in season 2 already iirc
>>
File: 0 (475).jpg (54 KB, 540x720)
54 KB
54 KB JPG
>>94613290
>>
File: drVqs8f.jpg (328 KB, 1200x780)
328 KB
328 KB JPG
>>
>>94531269
Dead but not yet gone, and serving as parts of the landscape. Can be communicated with if you possess the proper knowledge to temporarily bring them back from their eternal slumber.
>>
File: file.png (457 KB, 625x625)
457 KB
457 KB PNG
>>94531269
Nearly extinct and absurdly powerful
If giants had banded together they could have crushed the world, but now they are too few and too scattered
>>
>>94618478
>get to the top of a big canyon, cliff, or mountain
>wait for the wall titans to get close
>use a glider to go straight over them with ease
>survived the rumbling
>>
>>94560243
Great, now that you said this I can't stop wanting this. A fight scene against a giant lightsaber wielder would've been kino.
>>
In my world, I tend to make Giants somewhat like Nordic Giants and Greek Titans. However like Dragons, their race though see as powerful and wise. Is rare and isn't strong enough to fully control anything but small parts of land. As they tend to live mostly alone or in a small groups rather then group up with other families and make settlements.
>>
>>94532791
would
>>
>>94613290
Looks more like a troll than a giant
>>
File: Wood Giant.jpg (2.09 MB, 3797x4339)
2.09 MB
2.09 MB JPG
>>
>>94622754
And so you begin on your journey to learning they stem from the same sources in folklore...
>>
File: TzP93OC.jpg (125 KB, 1000x1225)
125 KB
125 KB JPG
>>
>>94531269
I like to use the more social giants in d&d (ie stone, fire,ice) as sort of a respected yet excluded part of major metropolises that I have included in games.
For example a capital city once had an enclave of stone giants living in a walled section near the main keep, they very rarely left this area but were supported by the duke and some of the merchant class in exchange for being on a sort of military retainer. They didnt share any cultural allegiance to the rest of the city, just lived in what amounted to a luxury reservation, with some traders having deals with their crafters for giant made goods.
Have thought about trying to implement a similar thing with fire giants in a new game.
>>
File: zVbXWNn.jpg (620 KB, 1920x2359)
620 KB
620 KB JPG
>>
File: NrNSDJL.jpg (1.68 MB, 1920x2754)
1.68 MB
1.68 MB JPG
>>
File: 0 (744).jpg (368 KB, 650x975)
368 KB
368 KB JPG
>>94616251
>>
File: AC4Zfzg.jpg (320 KB, 1310x1750)
320 KB
320 KB JPG
>>
File: lftKzDF.jpg (949 KB, 1920x1292)
949 KB
949 KB JPG
>>
>>94623728
Same areas would be better description: they come from same folklore, but are distinct entites in that folklore.
At least in nordic folklore I'm familiar with.
>>
File: giphy-downsized.gif (1.74 MB, 384x280)
1.74 MB
1.74 MB GIF
>>94531269
>Half these pictures

If the fucking creature isn't bigger than a barn, it's some kind of Ogre or troll, or similiar at best.

A "Giant" most be taller than 5-6 story building.
>>
>>94623728
Akchually...
>Giant
from Hellenic cthonic mythological creatures noted as large
>Troll
from a Nordic adjective referring to something magical or otherworldy, be it a person, an object, an animal or a mythological creature
So not even remotely the same thing in the sources, let alone from the same sources.
>inb4 ettins
Not all trolls are ettins and not all ettins are trolls. But 'ettin' does mean 'consumer', which could be seen in a cthonic (entropic) context.
>>
>>94628624
>cthonic (entropic)
You must be 18 or over to post on this site
>>
>>94628673
>I'm baffled by words that I didn't get from MTV, so therefore you're a child
If the children you're chatting with know Greek and understand Hellenic mythology, they're feds, anon. Well educated feds, but feds nonetheless.
Direct yourself to the myth of Persephone if you want an easy way to see the link between cthonic and entropic concepts in the Hellenistic world.
>>
>>94629192
Nice projection, retard
Chthonic (with an h, retard) refers to being underground. It has nothing to do with entropy, and neither does hades for that matter.
>>
>>94629202
>death and decay has nothing to do with entropy
ok bro
>>
>>94628508
If you look in a bit deeper, you'll find they were originally synonymous. Angrboda was often described as both.

>>94628624
>Akchually..
You need to be right to use that. Giants = jotun = trolls. Feel free to look it up.
>>
>>94630647
>look it up
Gladly. Name the original source that makes it explicit that there is 100% overlap between Hellenic gigantes, Nordic ettins and Nordic troll-things/beings (you won't).
Stop relying on shit translations and fantastical interpretations, anon.
>>
>>94631058
Why are you bringing Greek giants in?
>>
>>94631423
https://letmegooglethat.com/?q=what+is+the+etymology+of+the+word+giant
>>
>>94632067
So you're completely unaware of giants in Norse folklore?
>>
>>94630647
Jötnar = Jotunn = Jotuni = Jatuli = ~Giant =/= Troll,
Sometimes trolls could be giant-sized, but Jötnar and Troll are still two distinct entities in nordic folklore.

If you had truly red - or heard - the folklore you'd know this.
>>
>>94633417
Or, as seems to be apparent, you've not actually "red" enough of Norse folklore and myth to know anything more than a really superficial level, and that's put you well outside of this particular topic. Good luck on your journey to learn more, though. I've started with some simple basics for you to begin with, they'll help clear up your confusion as to the related nature of trolls and jotuns.
>https://www.academia.edu/1259123/
>https://archive.org/details/dictionaryofnort0000sime
>https://www.academia.edu/1348105
>https://archive.org/details/icelandicfolktal0000simp
>https://www.jstor.org/stable/1260141
>>
>>94633225
>goalpost moving
So no source then?
>giants
By definition, all Gigantes are Hellenic chthonic proto-gods, not Nordic at all. If you just mean "a supernaturally large being", that's fine, but you'd still be hilariously wrong to say that all trolls are ettins and that both are enormous. So once again: primary source please?
>>
>>94633609
No goalpost moving at all. The discussion is that in Norse folklore, trolls and giants are synonymous. You're getting confused because you're incapable of following extremely blatant context. So here, go educate yourself like the other anon: >>94633528
>>
>>94633528
>no primary sources
>only translations of opinions
>on post-christianization folklore
Oh wow you've got us convinced about pre-christian Nordic mythology anon!
You probably speak many Nordic languages right?
>>
>>94633633
>No goalpost moving at all.
Still no source? Just take the L man.
>The discussion is that in Norse folklore, trolls and giants are synonymous.
You're already forgetting your own retarded claims. >>94630647 Probably for the best.
I'll follow your lead and forget your braying too.
>>
>94633528
Mmhmm.
First source clearly delineates differences between Thursar, Jötnar, Risi and Tröll.
Second is a dictionary, not a source.
Third is source why Trolls and magic are intertwined, and why we have trolling in the language today.
Fourth source is cut short.
Fifth source might have something to support your theory that Jötnar = Tröll. Care to cite it with actual citation?
You will not, because you are defenitely not a giant.
>>
Holy samefag, Batman. I guess you've gotten a little hurt over this.

>>94633667
>no primary sources
Sorry, did you want me to tell you to read the Prose Edda? I didn't realise you were THIS unqualified to talk on this.
>only translations of opinions
While you have... nothing?
>on post-christianization folklore
Oof, painful to try to dance away from admitting I was right, with such a despearate gambit.

>>94633708
>Still no source? Just take the L man.
I gave you 5. Are you blind as well as ignorant?
>You're already forgetting your own retarded claims. >>94630647 (You) Probably for the best.
Amazingly dishonest for you to not link to >>94623728. You're the retard that tried to shoehorn Greek giants into what is very clearly a discussion on Norse giants.

>>94633763
That's just sad, man.
>First source clearly delineates differences between Thursar, Jötnar, Risi and Tröll.
Wow, you really are just a liar. Page 185: "This seems to be a big, stupid and ugly race, that may in turn be called “riser”, “jotnar” and “troll”, without any special need of sub-categorisation."
>Second is a dictionary, not a source.
A professor of Scandinavian mythology, having written multiple volumes of translated Norse myth, uses the primary source in his work but isn't a source, because YOU say. So glad to have your input!
>Third is source why Trolls and magic are intertwined, and why we have trolling in the language today.
Page 44: "“In medieval Iceland, the word Troll can have the same meaning as in the post-medieval Icelandic folktales, i.e. it can be synonymous with jotunn or mountain-dweller…”"
>Fourth source is cut short.
And? Try actually reading it. Page 77: "In Iceland, the word ‘troll’ always denotes a giant..."
>Fifth source might have something to support your theory that Jötnar = Tröll. Care to cite it with actual citation?
Yep, like the other 4 you didn't read.

You're a desperate, lying, little idiot.
>>
File: muhsamefag.png (28 KB, 196x435)
28 KB
28 KB PNG
>>94633894
>did you want me to tell you to read the Prose Edda?
Yes, that's how sources work. And nowhere in the Prose Edda does it say all "Giants = jotun = trolls".
>While you have... nothing?
One cannot prove a negative sweetie. You made a claim. Prove it or tuck tail.

>inb4 post-medieval Iceland is representative of all Nordic mythology
uh huh

You're literally the 'let me tell you about your country' amerimutt meme kek. You know only burgerspeak, and you've never seen a jættestue in your life. Rend og hop.
>>
>>94635727
>Yes, that's how sources work. And nowhere in the Prose Edda does it say all "Giants = jotun = trolls".
Okay, so you want me to tell you to read an entire collection of stories and poems that you've never even heard of before but still think you can comment on, despite you being unable to even understand the 5 extremely simple sources I've already given. Your hubris is as great as your ignorance.
>One cannot prove a negative sweetie. You made a claim. Prove it or tuck tail.
Saying "trolls and giants are different" is not a negative, "sweetie". Provide sources, because so far you're behind by 5.
>>inb4 post-medieval Iceland is representative of all Nordic mythology
Yep, confirmed for not knowing what the Prose Edda is. I'm English, by the way. Good luck learning about Norse mythology, you've very clearly got a long way to go.
>>
>>94636924
>I'm a foreigner, by the way
Tydeligvis.
>still no source
Ak og ve.
>>
>>94637678
>Tydeligvis.
Ah, I see now, you're embarrassed that you got schooled on what you consider "your" culture's myths. It explains a lot.
>Ak og ve.
I know, right? I've so far given you 5 different sources, and directed you to enjoy the Prose Edda that you've never read (even heard of before). You've given... nothing. Sad.

Know when you're outclassed, boy.
>>
>>94531269
weird thread
>>
>94633894
“Identifying the Ogre: The Legendary Saga Giants,” Fornaldarsagaerne, myter og virkelighed: studier i de oldislandske fornaldarsögur Norðurlanda.
Ármann Jakobsson
p.186
"Gudbrandur Vigúlfsson noted: "In popular Icelandic usage risi denotes size, jötunn strenght, thurs lack of intelligence...""
Later in the same page, Motz distnguishes four categories: jotunn, tröll, thurs and risi.

Dictionary of northern mythology,
written in Vienna in 1950s by a German, with an original title of Lexicon of German Mythology.

Needs no further comment.

“The Trollish Acts of Þorgrímr the Witch: The Meanings of Troll and Ergi in Medieval Iceland,” Saga-Book 32 (2008),
Ármann Jakobsson,
p. 44
"In Hjálmthérs saga ok Ölvis and in Bösa saga, for example, trolls are listed along with elves, norns and mountain-giants..."

Clear distinction of troll and giant.

Icelandic folktales and legends,
edited by Jacqueline Simpson
seems nice, but ultimately a pop-folkloristic book. I'm sure it's a nice read, though.

Giants in Folklore and Mythology: A New Approach in Folklore, Vol. 93, No. 1
p. 70
Lotte Motz:
"This present study... aims to affirm following points:
I. Folklore giants and Eddic giants are indeed related
II. Size is not their most basic quality..."

Size not being essential to giant? Right, this is unforseen level of academic cope.


Ármann Jakobsson seems to be arguing that troll was being used as an adjective and was being associated with malicious supernatural deeds and beings - not a category of being neccesarily in itself.

Thanks for the sources, I'm sure their references make for nice reading later.

So, do you prefer to be called thurs or troll?
>>
>>94638593
Oh look, the lying coward is back.
>"In popular Icelandic usage..."
Irrelevant.
>written in Vienna in 1950s by a German, with an original title of Lexicon of German Mythology.
By someone with more expertise in this than you.
>Later in the same page, Motz distnguishes four categories: jotunn, tröll, thurs and risi.
Let me actually quote what you're once again lying about:
>“The unknown fourteenth-century author of Barðar saga argued for a clear distinction between nice “riser” and nasty “troll”. […] In clearly distinguishing between “riser”, “jotnar” and troll, Barðar saga is unfortunately less typical than Hjdlmther’s saga. […] The author of Barðar saga is something of a rebel when he makes a conscious attempt to distinguish between “riser” and “troll”, and uses “thurs" as a pejorative term.”
Again, the "distinction" you're lying about was by a single author and is notably atypical and clearly implies that if a distinction is necessary, THERE WAS NO DISTINCTION BEFORE. You probably won't get that.
>Clear distinction of troll and giant.
*Mountain-giant, since your reading comprehension is awful.
>seems nice, but ultimately a pop-folkloristic book. I'm sure it's a nice read, though.
Dismissed because once again, it proves my point and you can't refute it.
>Size not being essential to giant? Right, this is unforseen level of academic cope.
It would certainly be unforeseen to layman, but all it does is reveal your lack of knowledge in this topic. To those of us who have studied this, the debate regarding the size of jotun is extremely well known and requires context to discuss.
>Thanks for the sources, I'm sure their references make for nice reading later.
I highly doubt you'll ever read them. Not that it matters, the field of study for Norse mythology isn't actually impacted by your refusal to accept established facts.
>>
File: Madworld Little Eddie.png (149 KB, 850x900)
149 KB
149 KB PNG
Like a few other anons have said, it's pretty boring if they're just humans but really big. They should have some inhuman proportions and faces, I think skyrim really nails it well.
>>94535853
>>94535861
Not quite a man but big, not quite an elf but big, while also close enough to both that it doesn't look like a troll or ogre. They have their own style going on
>>
File: dunhuang-chen-18.jpg (501 KB, 1920x2806)
501 KB
501 KB JPG
>>94531269
>>
File: 0 (2067).jpg (541 KB, 1600x872)
541 KB
541 KB JPG
>>94627272
>>
File: 0 (2080).jpg (177 KB, 900x736)
177 KB
177 KB JPG
>>94645044
>>
File: 0 (14).jpg (398 KB, 1188x1800)
398 KB
398 KB JPG
>>94647040
>>
File: 0 (1964).jpg (240 KB, 1144x1179)
240 KB
240 KB JPG
>>94649751
>>
After defeating and imprisoning his sister, the goddess of dragons, the god of mankind was seduced by her. Their children were the first Hill Giants -- hideous, hateful creatures with long hair, serpentine heads, and scaly yet hairy skin. They can only be killed by mortals and are immune to the power of the god of mankind and their many half-siblings -- instead of killing them, the gods imprisoned them in the physical realm, where they rape and/or eat any mortal foolish enough to be near them unprepared.
Some of the giants, who attempted to rape the goddess of earth, where captured and tortured, magically transforming them into savage yet loyal servants of the gods. The goddess of earth created the prideful and alcoholic Stone Giants; the god of water created the sadistic and cruel Frost Giants; the god of fire created the deadly and powerful Fire Giants; and the god of wind created the greedy and reclusive Cloud Giants. One might find the rare Frost or Cloud Giant who does not wish harm upon mortals, but all other types are inherently evil.
>>
This is how I giant.
>>
The giant gave me a sword forged from great ambition.
The knicks and kinks only seem to sharpen the blade.
>>
File: 0 (1815).jpg (139 KB, 900x658)
139 KB
139 KB JPG
>>94650629
>>
Normal giants bore me. I want my giants to be so giant that their corpses become landscapes.
>>
>>94629372
>>death and decay has nothing to do with entropy
Being spent, exhausted or immobile and incapable of movement is not linked to death to Ancient Greeks, because many unliving and undying beings are such (Aristotle's God for example). Also, strictly speaking, they might not have understood death as inertia given that expansion and compression were the most basic forms of motion.
>>
>>94532791
SVALBARD
V
A
L
A
R
D
>>
I played a one shot once where we had to kill 3 giants. I had to climb up the giants leg hair and cut open his ball bag. That was the only weak spot that didn’t require a full days climb and wouldn’t be immediately swatted with a fist.
Split the dudes ball bag wide open and rode down his descending testicle to his shin, where I was unable to grasp his leg hairs because of torrents of blood and fell to my death. I left early that session and never played with those guys again.
I hated that game.
>>
File: minishcap3.png (294 KB, 1407x938)
294 KB
294 KB PNG
>>94531269
Everybody is always talking about giants as monster encounters in the wild. I don't think they have anything in particular over other giant monsters in that department.
What I think makes the most interesting aspect of a giant is his lair. Fighting giant vermin under the floor boards, scaling a giant dresser, raiding a giant pantry. These are the things that turn simple farmboys into seasoned adventurers!
>>
File: 0 (821).jpg (74 KB, 564x704)
74 KB
74 KB JPG
>>94652924
>>
>>94531269
Giants in my setting are sort of a rare mutation which can crop up in a child regardless of race. They start out normal sized as a baby but quickly grow, usually reaching about three to four meters in height. Despite this massive size they are characterized as being absurdly strong, fast, tough, smart, and basically are instant folk or even national heroes who lead their communities to victory, so usually your child being a giant is seen as good omen (or just a warning shit's gonna go down and they'll be needed for it). Giants are actually one of the few things that can consistently go toe-toe with dragons and have an even odds of winning.

Unfortunately, around the time of their twenty fourth year, they start to experience gradual decline in mind and personality, becoming dumber and more brutish and basically becoming the stereotypical barbaric savage by the time they're in their early thirties. Most Giants try to go out of their way to be killed in action beforehand, or alternatively end up running off into the wilderness where they transform and grow in size in semi-peace.
>>
File: 0 (1894).jpg (442 KB, 1252x1772)
442 KB
442 KB JPG
>>94658415
>>
>>94535452

Skyrim?
>>
>>94662067
Yes.
>>
>>94653564
>missed the point again
Hades is the land of the dead, an explicitly chthonic place. You're just being an obstinate faggot and deleting people pointing out your retardation.
>>
File: 1634712916970.jpg (203 KB, 1380x1725)
203 KB
203 KB JPG
>>94531269
Female
and misanthropic
>>
>>94670203
Why are you suggesting he has an issue associating Hades with chthonic? He very clearly takes issue with you claiming both are entropic.
>deleting people
What? We can't do that here, you're probably thinking of reddit.
>>
>>94658573
This does not seem conducive to the end goal of making the heroes fight on top of a giant dining table, wielding giant silverware.
>>
good thread
>>
>>94651567
That's how I ogre.
>>
>>94658573
So do giants still vary in height proportionally amongst each other depending on their race, i.e. halfling giants are half the size of human giants?
>>
>>94677918
A bit, but not really as much, as mentioned, in their prime they tend to be three to four meters tall, but that's still a heck of a range. Once they kind of get over that hill and start to degenerate though, signs of their parentage increasingly vanish as they grow huge and monstrous.

>>94671038
It is proper size for them to pick up cannons and use them as small arms.
>>
>>94678181
>but that's still a heck of a range.
Yeah but less than what their non-giant kin have.
>>
File: 0 (1919).jpg (325 KB, 1161x869)
325 KB
325 KB JPG
>>94659696
>>
>>94670370
i have to say anon, some people might misconstrue this as lewd
>>
File: 0 (1887).jpg (89 KB, 748x480)
89 KB
89 KB JPG
>>94681527
>>
File: 0 (2073).jpg (104 KB, 1087x735)
104 KB
104 KB JPG
>>94682784
>>
File: 0 (1868).jpg (89 KB, 529x399)
89 KB
89 KB JPG
>>94683864
>>
File: 0 (1816).jpg (827 KB, 916x992)
827 KB
827 KB JPG
>>94685569
>>
File: 0 (1807).jpg (65 KB, 580x392)
65 KB
65 KB JPG
>>94688447
>>
File: 0 (1766).jpg (84 KB, 499x750)
84 KB
84 KB JPG
>>94689743
>>
File: 0 (1688).jpg (92 KB, 600x900)
92 KB
92 KB JPG
>>94690760
>>
File: 0 (1341).jpg (66 KB, 616x462)
66 KB
66 KB JPG
>>94693059
>>
>>94531269
I like them lewd and I don't care what you want. Fuck you.
>>
File: 0 (1397).jpg (394 KB, 936x1248)
394 KB
394 KB JPG
>>94695934
>>
>>94534241
Just because you head is empty does not mean there no discussion of games.
>>
File: 0 (499).jpg (50 KB, 688x960)
50 KB
50 KB JPG
>>94699847
>>
>>94699962
I preferred the "discussion" on trolls.
>>
File: 0 (138).png (543 KB, 500x500)
543 KB
543 KB PNG
>>94703327
>>
>>94531269
My favorites are dwarf giants, basically they are bearded mid-sized men who build structures out of hardened clay and wood and fight with standard armaments like spears and swords.
>>
File: 1642123077235.jpg (75 KB, 976x850)
75 KB
75 KB JPG
>>94706938
>>
>>94706938
... so neanderthals.
>>
File: 0 (291).jpg (164 KB, 857x877)
164 KB
164 KB JPG
>>94706794
>>
>>94531269
Yeah
>>
File: 0 (135).jpg (87 KB, 1000x667)
87 KB
87 KB JPG
>>94710431
>>
File: 0 (636).jpg (305 KB, 905x1280)
305 KB
305 KB JPG
>>94715775
>>
File: 0 (1791).jpg (90 KB, 620x400)
90 KB
90 KB JPG
>>94717288
>>
File: 0 (945).jpg (55 KB, 823x1011)
55 KB
55 KB JPG
>>94719332
>>
>>94713670
Yeah, what?
>>
>>94532851
The silence to this post was pleasing.
>>
>>94531331
Considering how many cultures have myths of giants as a precursor race, it fits the mythic trope.
>>
>>94564811
...Why did you have to choose those words?
>>
>>94736086
It just means he loves the aesthetic.
>>
>>94736749
I know, but given the artist's heart ripping in half it was a painful thing to read.
>>
>>94739130
>the artist's heart ripping in half
>Miura died due to acute aortic dissection
Why lie?
>>
>>94739799
I exaggerated slightly.

Man literally died of a broken heart while making the saddest chapter.
>>
>>94740011
>Man literally died of a broken heart
You're doing it again.
>>
>>94655365
Svalbard has no trees, though.
>>
>>94532697
>The giants that remain there are terribly degenerated and in the worst cases utterly muted into hideous monsters.
This is something I like to do with giants, there's a lot of myth and folklore about monsters descending from giants/gods, it feels like something that should be explored more.
>>
>>94531487
I do the same with them being intelligent, but I have them slow in their thinking. Not slow like stupid, I mean literally slow, so they can scheme and strategise like a human could, just taking ten times as long. You can't outsmart a giant, but you can speedsmart them.
>>
>>94539672
If you follow C.S. Lewis' vision of them, they'll wake up from under the hills of the land to help destroy the world.
>>
>>94531269
I am immensely proud that this thread has lasted over a month, and it's not even mine.
>>
>>94753611
Maybe they like to think everything from every viewpoint. Every possibility etc., so they just don't answer fast "yeah" even for casual questions. Maybe they just dislike fast conversation, it needs to be worth it to say it out loud or something, kinda like ent speech. It would take them loooong time to insult you, but it would practically make even narcissist to die from shame and self-hatred.
>>
>>94531269
in my setting, giants are a subspecies of humanity, and the theme i always had for stuff with them is that they are "human in excess". theyre more jolly and more sad, brighter and cunning, yet stupid and foolhardy, and so much longer lived yet eager to squander the years. not all giants are TERRIBLY large, but the tallest are probably one to three chains tall. theyre built like humans in proportion, so they need to eat a lot. however, giants are a lot more magical than humans in general, so many have means to magically feed themselves (either by summoning feasts for themselves or using their navel chakra to convert magical energy to calories)

far after the ancestors of man and giant alike faded from history, but before man's advances as the leading race under the sun, giants created a mighty empire, and laid the foundations for those to follow them. the elder giants wrote many of the earliest research on magic, alchemy, and spirituality; some even communed with the gods themselves. as for the younger giants, however, many grew brazen, content in that which their forefathers had created, yet absent of the skill or wisdom with which they had done it. they looked upon the other races, lesser in size, strength, and wit - and decided that it was naturally their inherent duty to lead them. they proclaimed themselves the new gods of the world, and for their hubris the other races lashed out. a bitter war broke out, with the gods taking part in mortal matters for the last time to force peace among them.

in the end, the giants were magically banished to the northern continent of thule, where the elders still live in quiet isolation, and the youngsters try time and time again to seize control of all they believe theirs.
>>
>>94759738
I was thinking more playing on the concept of size-speed ratio. Smaller things tend to be able to react much faster than humans, mice, flies, even cats, so presumably we appear much slower to them. By comparison, we would then be the mice/flies/cats of giants, seeing them slower as well. They react and move slower to us, but to them we just seem irritatingly quick. It would help explain why "giant-slayers" could be a thing.
>>
>>94761610
It seems to be a common trope that huge things end up in some frozen landscape, and I suppose it has something to do with mammoths, and polar bears, and elephant seals being huge, and the cold conditions help with heat management. But the largest land animals are elephants and live in hot Africa and India, and largest birds are ostriches again in hot climates.

So surely giants would make sense also as living in some huge sinkhole or unreachable plateau in a tropical climate? Something like the old The Lost World book does with dinosaurs.
>>
>>94560171
The unspecified reason needs to be made less mysterious, it's too vague. At the very least, we need to know if they left willing, or were driven into exile.
>>
>>94531269
I like them as body horror undead boss fights. Sadly I can't really find a body horror giant miniature to represent them on the tabletop roleplay games.
So I may have to commission a 3D STL designer if I can find one.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.