Nebraska is booming right now

File: 1702966385795.jpg (72 KB, 679x638)

72 KB JPG

>>96785824
>tq
crying

>>96785824
>TQ
I'm not waiting for the next UW to come out. I'm only here to feel better about quitting the hobby I cared about for so many years dying a slow painful death. I'm waiting for my other friends to jump ship so we can spend our social time playing better games.

Most influential sets.

>>96785844
There are a lot of pig farms in Nebraska

>>96785844
I thought the meme state was ohio

File: MaroInfluenced.png (471 KB, 1135x464)

471 KB PNG

>>96785971

>tq
I'm not waiting. MTG is dead now. Even the nu-MTG non-UB sets will be slop as they have been in the past couple years.

File: MODERN RC.jpg (1.48 MB, 1920x1080)

1.48 MB JPG

amulet chads cannot stop winning

>>96786033
Looks like a garbage format.

>>96786033
Amulet will get banned before MH4 drops, screencap this

>>96786083
Why would it get banned? It's not totalizing, it's a perfectly fair enabler card.

>>96786033
Damn that's a lot of Amulet
It used to be unpopular bc its hard to pilot

>>96786083
Amulet is the most balanced deck in the game, it always has a place in the meta without going too nuts, only losing a few pieces like field of the dead and summer bloom in bans when it gets a bit too good. It has been relevant for over a decade which is basically unheard of, besides maybe Tron. But the tron of a decade ago is entirely different from it is today, amulet titan has a developed shell that will never change

>>96786033
this is way less belcher players than what I was expecting, the deck is really good

>>96786083
amulet will never get banned, people are too stupid to play the deck enough for it to be a real problem

>>96785999
>Top 10 (except number 6)
fantasy with slight of Magi-tech (3 and 7)
>Top 11-20 (except 17 that has lots of Magi-tech)
fantasy with slight of Magi-tech (14 and 17)

Also Maro: Lets go full Scy-fy and modern day Earth!!!!

I hate Titan. I want it banned. Same with Goryos

>>96785999
how in the fuck is Neon Dynasty that high

File: m11-192-primeval-titan.jpg (247 KB, 672x936)

247 KB JPG

>>96786250
you can ban amulet of vigor, I do not mind one bit but leave my boy alone, I can still play traditional titanshift with him

>>96786255
sales

>>96785824
>tq
playing mill in modern
i did a few spiderman drafts but they were pretty meh so i probably wont draft again until avatar or whatever is next

>>96786255
You are right, that should be original Kamigawa. That said, I'd guess that it's the one where they didn't get burned at the stake for doing something completely and utterly disconnected from fantasy, proving that yes, they CAN in fact sell you a Star Trek crossover.

>>96785999
Is this real? this shit cannot be real. what a dogshit list. Maro is too retarded for words someone kill this nigger with a bag of hammers please

>>96786403
Original Kamigawa was a total failure outside of 2 cards relevant in constructed. Epic is the worst keyword of all time. The Kamigawa flip cards were awful. Bushido was bad. It was a weak set over all. The draft environment was shit. It sold like ass.

It only developed a cult fan base from people that started mtg long after it came out and flopped because set: Japan

Neon Dynasty succeeded by catering to the newfags with set: Japan but also meaningfully advancing snd changing the setting for oldheads, having a decent draft environment and having many mechanically interesting and powerful cards for constructed and the slop format.

>>96786572
It was also the set where they started taking the multiverse concept seriously, instead of making Dominaria Continent #1488. It was a vital step on the design side to how Magic was built going forth. Ravnica, Innistrad, Mirrodin, Theros, and all the rest all owe their existence to Kamigawa being the block that set out to build a plane.

>>96786572
You speak the truth, also the arcane gimmick was terrible.
I think neon dynasty was just a forgettable set overall because it was such a mid era of magic where things came and went so quickly. (a continuing problem today) It was a decent set, I really enjoyed the drafts. But to be the 6th most influential set for him is crazy

>>96786603
Rath
Mercadia
Phyrexia

>>96786603
>It was also the set where they started taking the multiverse concept seriously, instead of making Dominaria Continent #1488
I don't hate Kamigawa but wasn't that Mirrodin?

Kaminawabunga, my name is LSV-Sama.

I'm a 27 year old American Piggie (Magic the Gathering fan for you gaijins). I preorder Secret Lairs and Universe Beyond products, and spend my days perfecting my shuffling art and playing superior game modes. (Commander)

I train with my foiled deck every day, this superior weapon can cut clean through steel because it is curved over a thousand times, and is vastly superior to any other weapon on earth. I earned my sword Magic Judge two years ago, and I have been getting better every day.

I speak Nebraskan accent fluently, both American and the Oink dialect, and I write fluently as well. I know everything about Nebraska history and their farming code, which I follow 100%

When I get my Nebraska citizenship, I am moving to Aurora to attend a prestigious pig farm to learn more about their magnificent culture.

I own several Commander decks, which I bring to my locals. I want to get used to playing them before I move to Nebraska, so I can fit in easier. I bow to WotC and oink as often as I can, but rarely does anyone manage to respond.

Wish me luck in Nebraska!

play

premodern.

>>96786662
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=__7NUrkFirA

>>96785824
>So what you're doing while waiting for the next universes within set to come out?
Build a cube to play with my friends. I want to support classic archetypes of aggro, combo, and control decks, with some tempo, and some big ramp for green. Not sure what else to add, I hate token spam and current year busted midrange creatures.

TEENAGE MUTANT SLOP ENJOYERS
TEENAGE MUTANT SLOP ENJOYERS
TEENAGE MUTANT SLOP ENJOYERS
IS THAT A NEW UB SET? TIME TO BUY!

This is the future you chose.

>>96786626
>>96786630
I fucked my shit up slightly, Mirrodin was before Kamigawa. That being said, all four of those are still directly within the overall "scope" of Dominaria. The existence of the first three is entirely about their relationship to Dominaria, with Mirrodin being the result of a Dominaria planeswaker going off to make his own blackjack-and-hookers gig in much the same way as Yawgmoth. Kamigawa was the first time that they completely separated a plane from existing in context of Dominaria and explored a strong inspirational vision completely independently of it. Without the Kami, you can't have the gheists of Innistrad or the Nyxborn of Theros, because you're still unconsciously working in that box of how death and undeath work on Dominaria and its local area.

>>96785824
How can we accelerate the enshittification of magic fast enough that there is still a playerbase elft to rebuild it after it inevitably rock bottoms? I'm talking 12 sets a year, instants getting a rules change to not target legendary creatures, wotc printing a 2 mana 5/5 with flying, vigilance, haste, lifelink, ward - ante your mortgage, and "when this creature enters, exile target opponents magic the gathering collection. Each card costs X to return where X is the WoTC approved value. All proceeds are directly deposited into MaRos bank account"

When this creature dies, create five hundred treasure tokens and make a suggestion for the next months monopoly theme

>>96786774
>playerbase elft to rebuild it after it inevitably rock bottoms
The only people who will be there to rebuild it are the reason it went to shit in the first place who don't have the sense to quit. And whoever is in charge of Magic when it is revived will make the product for those who killed the game, exactly as it was now or before it died. Anybody who has the game mind when rebuilding Magic has to fight through these people - do you really expect us to succeed when we can't fucking succeed now with the full attention of the half-alive players?

Magic only survives as a paper game because OTHER games make the LGS model possible. But that business model is fucked because board games are no longer in vogue, tabletop RPG is fucked because it takes so much effort, Warhammer is still fine, but card games have so much of their money moving through TCGPlayer rather than stores.

File: Screenshot 2025-10-19 010319.png (446 KB, 942x619)

446 KB PNG

Not blocking was fucking nuts

File: sok-5-cowed-by-wisdom.png (1.65 MB, 745x1040)

1.65 MB PNG

>>96786765
you are a scholar anon

also CHKx3 is a good draft format even if it's the set most built around damage on the stack

>>96786572
>Kamigawa flip cards were awful
Watch your whore mouth buddy, flip cards are badass and INFINITELY better than the travesty that is two sided cards

>>96785824
quitting mtg

File: superiority.png (150 KB, 680x384)

150 KB PNG

>>96785824
>Two threads in a row
>Early bakes
>Not Boom in Nebraska edition
>Not Esper (WUG) edition
The shills are working O V E R T I M E

>>96786765
To piggyback off what you're saying, Mirrodin was still connected to Dominarian events in that Memnarch was the Mirari before Karn put him in time-out for ruining Otaria. Same with Kamigawa in a sense because it provided a backstory for the Umezawa line whose decendant would be responsible for Bolas getting killed off the first time.
Really, the first plane that was entirely separated from Dominaria's affairs was Ravnica, because Azor was the only related planeswalker and he had no particular connection to Dominaria.

File: 1739463993813505.jpg (785 KB, 4000x3000)

785 KB JPG

I played Winota today.

>>96787094
see you tomorrow

Why do compfags whine about every fucking think that doesn't cater to their mental illness. Seriously half the complaints before universes beyond were still about the state the Standard Meta is in.

Cowabunga!

Cowabummer.

>>96787249
: (

File: incredulous baseball man.png (299 KB, 500x375)

299 KB PNG

>>96786908
>not blocking with nully-d against an incoming swifty

>>96787157
And to return the piggyback, the other set with huge implications is of course Lorwyn, which would formalize the story structure of "5-10 members of the ensemble cast go to a new plane, meet the locals, and get up to trouble". That episodic structure would be the narrative backbone of the game all the way up to the 4-part pseudo-block climax of DMU/BRO/ONE/MOM.

Of course, then everything went to shit, but it's interesting to look back and see just how much of Magic's way of doing things formed right in that late '04-late '07 window.

Rat Demon Guide
2B
Creature - Rat Demon
When this creature enters, each opponent discards a card and you lose life equal to the amount of cards discarded this way.
Exile this creature from your hand: add B
1/1

>>96787218
Anon, it's not even compfags.
The game is unplayable even casually, and making any rules or ban lists, turns the game into a pseudo competitive scene.
Of course people are always going to gravitate towards having the most optimal decks, but when the optimal decks are pure bloated solitaire cancer, don't need to wonder why people complain.

It's pure design issues.

>>96787308
Honestly I blame over optimization. Any misplay from a deck us internalized as "Hmm, better tighten it up" to the point after a year you ship of theseus it so much you're theme is gone in favor of response.

>>96787319
Just think about this
When's the last time you saw any game mechanic or designs in any game released in the last decade, have any real downsides?
The broader audience doesn't like actually playing games, hence why game design is approached with a mentality of optimizing everything and turning everything into low risk-high reward.

>>96787181
How dare you play foreign cards without a proper translated card near by?!
How will your opponent know what your cards do? Are they supposed to search the internet for the correct text?!

JUDGE !!!!
>>96787296
overpower. Spirit guides just need the pitch add mana ability to be good.

File: IMG_4927.jpg (171 KB, 1179x772)

171 KB JPG

Every single reply to this is “I LOVE COMPANION!” if you wanted a metric for how intelligent MaRo’s ballwashers are.

>>96787375
>I promise you there are players who adore Companion.
Yeah Maro, and some people enjoy cannibalism, or rubbing one out while scuba diving in septic tanks.
Fuck, I hate these demonic, amoral idiots. These avatars of absolute abject evil who constantly assert, at every opportunity, that actually there are no standards and actually if one person enjoys something than it is good.

Educating yourself so you can discern quality is a virtue, Mark. What we mean when we say "everybody hates Companions" is "Everybody whose opinion matters"
These people are beyond stupid. I can't even begin to conceive of how such a rotten, idiotic world view manifested in this world.

>>96786255
It did 2 things:
1. It prove that failed planes can revitalized to be successful .
2. It was the first set to try to balance two themes rather than focusing on one the traditionalist Kamigawa and the Neo Kamigawa.

File: IMG_4928.jpg (132 KB, 1008x501)

132 KB JPG

>>96787393
They tell on themselves

>>96787094
Same. I actually have been thinking about it seriously for a while, then the pig slop meme happened and the announcement for the set next year... I self reflected a lot and said you know what, Im tired of supporting this game because of the sunken cost fallacy. I do not want to be a pig because honestly, I was.

My main playgroup broke up last year anyways. I'm keeping a few old school decks and cards I like and the rest was just put up for sale this week. I've already got a guy who wants all my modern staples. I really hope wizards goes under. maybe if it improves I will come back in the future. But I've had enough "this set isn't for you" to realize it's actually "this game isn't for you"

>yo this shit is bad
>umm akshually i like it so its not
like who do these niggas think they are?

>>96787375
he is unfortunately not wrong

>>96787406
>They tell on themselves
It's crazy. Truly, have some dignity people. When something is universally reviled by all people who have good taste, at least have the dignity to not say you enjoy it in public.
the fuck is wrong with these people? How do you get like this?

>"eating shit is bad for you"
>"No, it's not! I happen to enjoy it!"

>>96787094
>>96787408
I started dumping my more valuable cards at an LGS for shit returns last year, which I regret now because I set up a TCG shop to get rid of the stuff they wouldn’t take and the margins are way better even if it is more effort on my part. I’m slowly selling off every card I own, saying goodbye to the ones I have good memories of as I mail them off to new homes (probably in commander decks, but whatcha gonna do).
I’ve gone from something like 10k cards to 2k and sales are dwindling as my more popular cards are almost all depleted. At this point I might just dump them on Facebook marketplace for free to purge myself of the cross of nostalgia and juvenility.

>>96787415
The only people who liked companion and had a semi-decent reason for doing so were limited players who enjoyed the exercise of making a deckbuilding constriction work in draft. But anyone who has to play constructed in any capacity should remember how atrocious the whole thing was and continues to be.

>>96787411
>>96787418
The worst part is, never once do any of these people have any ability to articulate why they think it is worthwhile. Not once, ever.

>>96787411
People thinking liking things most people dislike is a valid substitute for having a personality: contrarian

File: 1733737349140182.jpg (745 KB, 3377x4096)

745 KB JPG

>>96787415
The let people enjoy things attitude.

File: boros cycles.jpg (142 KB, 920x613)

142 KB JPG

>>96787425
>The only people who liked companion and had a semi-decent reason for doing so were limited players who enjoyed the exercise of making a deckbuilding constriction work in draft.
Sure but those people are soundly refuted by the fact that Companion was featured in easily one of the worst limited formats of all time, obliterating any hope for said interesting aspect of the mechanic to FLOURISH.

File: no-i-dont-think-3440416251.gif (2.11 MB, 640x362)

2.11 MB GIF

>>96787430
>let people enjoy things

>>96787432
Ironically the cycling matters cards were a lot more fun in jank constructed than limited

>>96786255
It's possibly the best limited format ever from a Standard set.

File: MontBlanc.png (311 KB, 458x423)

311 KB PNG

>>96787418
It's actually Mont-Blanc aux marrons you cultured philistine.

>>96787425
Likely true. I had a blast opening a Lurrus in a chaos draft and making a dumb WBG "oops all 2-drops" deck or seeing a Zirda in the wild.
But once you get to constructed they're pure cancer

>>96786255
>how in the fuck is Neon Dynasty that high
It opened the floodgates for the total ruination of the game's lore.
Bad influence is still influence.

>>96787421
That's great man, don't have any regrets, I know I won't. Once I made the decision a weight was lifted and now I can enjoy laughing at this game from the outside, and eventually forgetting about it entirely. Don't even replace it with another card game, just play vidya, DnD, or board games with the boys for social nights. Card games are such a crazy money sink. You could pay 40 bucks for a good board game and get many nights of fun out of it. I recommend dominion.

>>96786255
it was honestly a pretty fun set even if it did shit all over the flavour of the original kamigawa

File: 1610285878114.png (310 KB, 501x621)

310 KB PNG

>>96787426
They don't because they are cattle.
And starting to articulate why they like thing might out them as the shallow slop eating pigs they are.

>>96787453
Before I finished your post I thought to myself “board games? I could sure go for some dominion.”
Then I got to the end, lol.

>>96787374
Needs to be better to get commander play

>>96787459
What's your favorite expansion? Mine is Renaissance

>>96787430
People really need to understand that enjoying something doesn't automatically make it good.

File: 1746821763968192.png (956 KB, 1632x971)

956 KB PNG

>fatguys are back
>it's Commander content
god damnit

>>96787467
I've been in that relationship with magic for YEARS before finally deciding to quit now. "I know this game kinda sucks but *insert bad excuse*, I can't quit"

File: 1742220118681554.jpg (143 KB, 1280x1280)

143 KB JPG

>>96787467
Things don't need to be good for you to enjoy them, but I agree.

>>96787467
You'd have better results trying to teach a monkey how rocket engines work.
Ego is a helluva drug

>>96787467
Of course, by the same token something being bad doesn't necessarily mean you won't enjoy it.

>>96787489
And by the same token, something bad being enjoyed doesn't mean it is not allowed to be criticized or that the critic hates whatever they are criticizing

>>96787478
>before finally deciding to quit now
Based, good on you.

>>96787489
The point is that one must respect the quality of things. If you enjoy something that sucks ass (As everyone does, for many things.) then at least have the good character to not assert your love for it equals it being of quality.

That solipsistic selfish "My own taste is the sole arbiter of quality", the rejection of transcendental truths, is a mind plague predicated on the sin of pride.

Look, i enjoy big anime titties as much as the next guy, but you ain't catching me defending it against any slop accusations.
It is slop.

>>96787466
I have way too much nostalgia for intrigue for no good reason because it was the first one I bought. More objectively I’d probably go with prosperity or adventures.

File: IMG_4929.jpg (467 KB, 1179x1012)

467 KB JPG

>>96787553

>>96787553
This analogy doesn’t even make any sense because McDonald’s has been doing cross brand promotions since before anyone here was born.
And also the food has almost always been the DEFINITION of slop.

I honestly don't understand the inane vitriol against food analogies, or actually any analogy in general.
The thing about an analogy is that it should explain something as understandably as possible, and what is humanities most common denominator? Food.

Hating food analogies is like a Glorbontian from planet Phukemeaz saying Urterguus are Plotromp accessories.

File: 1617915011881.gif (822 KB, 256x256)

822 KB GIF

>>96787553
>compares MtG to actual slop to defend it against the chuds who call MtG slop

>>96787553
>Mmm, boots!

File: slop.gif (3.72 MB, 359x202)

3.72 MB GIF

Maro here, it's patriotic to consume slop! I am an American and I eat slop! Buy UBs! Haha!

>>96786033
amulet titan is truly the most green deck to ever green

>>96785824
I have almost $2.2k worth of singles, how the hell do I go about selling off my collection that isn't one card at a time?

>>96788086
Some site allow you to sell in bulk.

damn that ouroboroid deck with the simic spiderman dude is annoying as fuck

>>96788086
dump it all at an lgs and get 40% of that value
or sell one card at a time the stuff that is worth more than 50 bucks and dump the rest at your lgs for 40% of the market value

I only buy cards with the mindset that it's all wasted money i won't be making back...
i always make my money back but i dont sell

BeyBlade UB when?

>Introduce Play Boosters with above normal rate of rares per pack in hopes that players will accept the greed-fuelled switch over.
>Secretly and quietly over time reduce the number of Rares in a Play Booster set by set, so nobody notices that you always intended to scam them.
You don't hate them enough.

>>96787181
based winota chad

File: 1760111698161251.jpg (95 KB, 750x1000)

95 KB JPG

Can the damage done by this UB shitfest repaired somehow? Is still possible to save this fucking game?

>>96788156
The game (minus commander of course) will be dead in three years time but the collectors buying ubshit will go on for as long as wotc keeps churning out product profitably. We may see the rise of one or two new community formats that wizards will try to get their grubby hands on. Pretty sure the game is unsalvageable considering they have shown no signs of wanting to change their current course.

>>96788156
>Can the damage done by this UB shitfest repaired somehow?
lol

>Is still possible to save this fucking game?
lmao

>>96788129
I returneed to magic after 15 years because some of my friends play commander. I come from an era where you used you money to buy cards and play not to make money out of it.

That said what I am seeing today with Magic is what I have seen yesterday with GW. Corporation are greedy as fuck. What people have to understand is that even if Magic start to sell like shit WOTC would need at least 2 years to show you some change. Production and release schedule are a thing.

For now I am just enjoying play commander with my playgroup as I can totaly skip set without worries, but if you play 60 card standard you just better leave the boat now.

Biggest problem is that I don't see valid alternative to Magic as the other TCG are just asian stuff.

File: rothus.png (1.26 MB, 593x827)

1.26 MB PNG

>>96788132
Once Duel Masters UB gets out of the way.

File: duema might actually have(...).png (2.02 MB, 1950x1359)

2.02 MB PNG

>Duema UB
Might unironically save MtG
which would be extremely ironic

Duel Masters UB would have any creature double as a land by being played upside down

>>96788319
WotC invented this but worse with MDFCs.

File: the chin.jpg (594 KB, 850x500)

594 KB JPG

>>96786255
Here the reason

>>96788298
>cool art
It looks like shit. Generic anime shit.

>>96788298
Akira references became so cringe
>>96788454
NTR

File: 1644002526419.png (4.03 MB, 1920x1433)

4.03 MB PNG

>>96788454
moshi moshi

>>96788466
I watched Akira when the memes where being spammed around and how everyone was talking about that movie like it was the second coming of Christ.
Holy shit it was mid.
Akira is to normies what dragonball is to blacks.

File: gatling.png (1.23 MB, 589x827)

1.23 MB PNG

>>96788298
It would highlight the early sets of Duel Masters, mostly the ones featured in the animated series whenever the franchise was localized first time.

File: zjpc7altrah81.png (581 KB, 982x542)

581 KB PNG

>>96788466
>NTR
It was also the pants

File: 13323497029.png (213 KB, 392x399)

213 KB PNG

>>96788482

File: enhance.png (32 KB, 530x940)

32 KB PNG

>>96788491

>>96787406
This retard confused Companion with Partner.
And you retards didn't notice

File: pneo-238s-tamiyo-compleat(...).jpg (175 KB, 672x936)

175 KB JPG

only pw card i know i actually don't hate and seems balanced

>>96788515
by "seems balanced" you mean "unplayable", right?

What happened to Emrakul possessing Tamiyo

File: rna-186-kaya-orzhov-usurper.jpg (173 KB, 672x936)

173 KB JPG

For me it's the og Kaya.

>>96788609
kino card against mono red

>>96788554
yes, when every card is "unplayable" for modern metapigs that just want to cum all over the table, the game is saved

>>96788609
I really hate Kaya but this card is so well designed. Shame it's unplayable.

>>96788513
I noticed

>>96788156
Theoretically standard can be saved post ub rotation
Eternal formats are fucked between mh3 and ub
Hey maybe blocks will make a comeback and we can do block constructed again, though with mythics that sounds expensive

>>96788606
She did it for a single moment to seal herself away, it wasn't a constant 'thing'.

File: war-150-arlinn-voice-of-t(...).jpg (158 KB, 672x936)

158 KB JPG

>>96788647
no, really, that card has never seen any play outside of standard, and even then it was very mediocre
if it's just a matter of posting shitty unplayable planeswalkers, WAR is full of those

>>96788609
>og
U having a giggle m8?

>>96788695
>>>/tg/edhg

Trying to tweak my first cube. I just made 5 mono color decks and slapped them together. I had W go-wide fliers with a lifegain theme, U tempo, B control, R aggro with some burn, and G was just ludicrous amounts of ramp into huge creatures. The result was decent to play but the drafting felt really railroaded into specific deck archetypes. I also used almost not rares or mythics, so it's 99% peasant. But pretty each card for a color felt so focused that drafting amounted to "okay cool I've got 3 blue cards and 5 black cards now, guess I'm making UB control" and the like.

I need suggestions on making it less boring and more variable.

File: war-228-ashiok-dream-render.jpg (148 KB, 672x936)

148 KB JPG

this guy is pretty cool

File: kaya.jpg (329 KB, 1471x940)

329 KB JPG

>>96788652
>Shame it's unplayable.
retard

>>96788722
>guy

File: 1750831491823538.jpg (142 KB, 672x936)

142 KB JPG

>>96788734
Jace isn't trans yet.

>>96788710
Conspiracy isnt edh and even if it was it still wouldnt be the og
Wewlad

>>96788737
Fractured anus will have genderswaps of all the javetice league because wacky universes or whatever
Hopefully they do garruk too, shed be cute

File: kaya le kaya.png (166 KB, 1343x739)

166 KB PNG

>>96788753
cool cool now compare with
>>96788728

File: IMG_0569.jpg (753 KB, 1179x1660)

753 KB JPG

>>96788772
The comparison is both meaningless and incorrect

>>96788693
You don't get it, do you? Games with lots of game pieces should 99% be "mediocre".
True card games shine when most of the cards are unplayable unsynergetic jank because if they aren't; you just get the current autopilot, selfsynergetic slop that wins on t2

>>96788647
Unironically this.
Ban everything from Rav 3 forward and start over from a sane power level.

>>96787598
You're making the fundamental error of assuming that ">food analogy" has anything to do with good-faith argument. Food analogies are common because everyone eats, and if there's anything that the modern shitposter adores it's a meaningless phrase they can trot out when encountering common stimulus. I blame Dora the Explorer having kids tell her where Swiper is.

>>96788734
askers?

>>96787598
>>96788951
Analogy in general is the flaccid backbone of many a poorly intentioned argument. Every propagandist under the sun craves a simplistic message that the the 99 iq havers can wrap their shrunken frontal lobes around. Food anagly is where logical arguments go to die. "To explain my idea, instead of showing you how it actually works, let me compare it to a food that you're eating. That's right, my idea is just like not eating this food. Isn't that so profound" but it's not. If something isbtrue, it can be explained in cold hard facts without resorting to analogies.

Of course, the inhabitants of the internet are largely retarded and thus take these analogies as the gospel truth.

>>96788951
>and if there's anything that the modern shitposter adores it's a meaningless phrase they can trot out when encountering common stimulus
It's called a "thought-terminating cliche", i.e. a canned argument that's used to justify not thinking about the details of a topic. Whether it's logically-consistent or even applicable to an objection is irrelevant, the point is that it's an excuse for people to blindly assume they are correct.
This shit dates back at least to ancient China, and is common anywhere a dogma is enforced by some sort of power.

File: unh-43-question-elemental.jpg (283 KB, 672x936)

283 KB JPG

>>96788959

>>96788981
Analogies serve to simplify things, not to be used as stand-ins for arguments.
>just explain the thing
Sure, and when you explain the thing, you're just going to get the internet equivalent of the fluoride stare; "uhm i dont understand what you're saying so ur a schizo"
This is also an analogry.

>>96786238
There's been a rise in the popularity of izzet prowess and, in my personal opinion at least, blue belcher has a tough matchup against that. It's actually a pretty shitty matchup in terms of gameplay, since both decks don't have super great ways to interact with one another so it often ends up just being two dudes goldfishing their decks and it just so happens that prowess goldfishes one turn faster than belcher.

>>96785999
>even though innistrad, ravnica, and invasion are the most influential sets lets get away from their design and balancing principals to instead just spam more broken and uncreative slop

>>96789124
Well, you see Mark personally likes SciFi and Marvel, and now nobody is left to stop him.

>>96788728
>>96788789
>>96788609
>edh
Not MTG. Take it back to the pig-pen thread

File: G3oQHHpW0AAOyC_.jpg (1.48 MB, 1920x1080)

1.48 MB JPG

>>96786033
day 2

>>96788298
This is really not a great example because even with the overused Akira references the art on the right is much better than the one on the left and it's not even close.

File: lizwhat.gif (1.18 MB, 296x296)

1.18 MB GIF

>>96787553
>eating food is a hobby now

File: 1363796093926.jpg (124 KB, 398x398)

124 KB JPG

Anything can be a hobby.

>>96789329
Ah yes. The only way that slop which broke standard can be balanced is if there is more broken auto-play slop in the format. Still two izzet auto-play slop decks in the top 2 in spite of that.

>>96789441
I am fairly sure you cannot elaborate on your statement without using meaningless and wrongly used buzzwords

>>96789329
God Modern sucks fucking ass man

>>96789329
amuletGODs i kneel

>>96789749
If you have any sort of appreciation for artistry and technical detail you can easily tell that right is a way more impressive illustration. Left is decent but pretty bland and indulgent modern anime art, I'll grant that it shows more care for detailed shading than most gacha-core slop you see these days but it's still nowhere near as impressive as the other art.

https://scryfall.com/search?q=art%253Achild+art%253Agirl&unique=art

>>96790002
>nothing but meaningless buzzwords
Wow, it's like i predicted the future.

(you)s are worthless, Anon. And it makes you pathetic just to try and get them like you do.

>>96790084
Just stick to your little slop, kid.

>insults
man, i should have written that prediction too

File: WE WUZ ELFZ.jpg (101 KB, 488x680)

101 KB JPG

DAS RITE!

File: WE WUZ KANGZ.jpg (146 KB, 1600x800)

146 KB JPG

AYO GIBS ME DAT

File: Major Teroh.jpg (215 KB, 672x936)

215 KB JPG

Old MTG had so much soul. Nu MTG is nothing but slop. Anyone could tell it was going downhill hard when they started printing those Pokemon borders instead of the true MTG borders.

>>96790227
tolkien lived in South Africa watching innocent people get necklaced, making Aragorn black is the exact opposite of the moral of Lord of the Rings

>>96787553
At least with McDonalds, you can still get their regular menu. Their cross-over menu items do not replace the entire menu. They do not stop selling the Big Mac for two years while only selling the Street Fighter menu. The Big Mac is not objectively being replaced by the cross-over menu.

>>96785824
These threads are getting slower... how many people do you think got tired of being pigs and actually quit the game? Probably a lot more than any wizards survey would admit

File: pepe fact.png (63 KB, 220x221)

63 KB PNG

>>96789329
>based archetypes
Amulet Titan
Prowess
Energy
Belcher

>reddit archetypes
Blink
Affinity
Tron

File: 1727635919174713.jpg (1.28 MB, 3072x2048)

1.28 MB JPG

I've been having fun in casuals with friends or at my lgs with these decks but I haven't been following the actual meta in a while.

https://www.mtggoldfish.com/deck/7095760#paper

https://www.mtggoldfish.com/deck/6921180#paper

https://www.mtggoldfish.com/deck/6908136#paper

https://www.mtggoldfish.com/deck/6859613#paper

>>96790364
I can only speak for me and the shop where I usually go. Things seem the same, only spooderman is being less bought/played than any other set I remember. Even the stupid hat sets like the ravnica detectives and the hot wheels one sold like hot cakes by comparison, and there were a lot of limited being played. But the people is more or less the same volume, only they mostly ignore the current set.

File: 1758910966013849m.jpg (109 KB, 1024x576)

109 KB JPG

>>96790364
The end is near. And we still have to see the worse, i mean next year we have in quickly succession TMNT, Pic related and Star Trek

File: KANG OF DA RANG.png (634 KB, 646x902)

634 KB PNG

janny can't handle banter so he deletes posts instead of growing a spine

>>96790468
Same, limited play didn't seem to take a huge hit, people just started asking for other sets to be drafted instead of SPM. A store owner I know told me he considered SPM to be a flop but even then they managed to move most of their stock, at least enough to not lose money with it.

>>96790578
From left to right:
>Movie that bombed
>Canonically dead since phase 3 ended
>Show that bombed
>Last movie bombed
>Last movie bombed
>Canonically dead since phase 3, but saw success in a Deadpool movie
>Has yet to feature in even one good movie despite repeated attempts
>Movie bombed
>TV show fell off hard, movie bombed
>Movie bombed
Damn the MCU really never recovered after phase 4.

>>96790597
>spamming decade-old pastas apropos of nothing
>banter
spend your deck budget on a better sense of humor instead.

File: 1752444108768471.jpg (67 KB, 640x1136)

67 KB JPG

>>96790630
Bomb? Like draft bombs? Sounds like a perfect match for MtG!

File: I AM A PIG AND I EAT SLOP.jpg (623 KB, 4096x2650)

623 KB JPG

>>96790641
found the piggy who can't handle banter so he reports to janny

>>96788298
You can tell this image was made by a Filipino

>>96790653
Nigger, you couldn't even change the repost filename to Return of Da KANG. You just suck.

I AM A PIG AND I EAT SLOP

>>96790666
>OINK OINK OINK OINK
I'm sorry piggy. I don't understand you. Write in English please.

>>96790630
Infinity War felt like too much of a conclusion, most people jumped off afterwards because it felt the stakes couldn't get higher. "Perpetual" stories like comics and wrestling often have that problem. I don't think they mind that much since every once in a while they still have a big hit doing like a billion dollars but it's clear that their hits are getting rarer.

>>96790691
Time travel fundamentally breaks stories. You get to use it to have fun ONCE, and then everything afterwords will be stupid forever.

File: 1602285803179.jpg (1.05 MB, 1467x1080)

1.05 MB JPG

>>96788481
Akira came out during a time period where anime didn't have huge cultural relevance in the west and high-budget adult animation was fairly rare. It and Ninja Scroll made burgers much more aware of the merits of Japanese animation and basically created a market for it. Its actual plot is mediocre but the animation is gorgeous and that's what people remember about it.
Ninja Scroll is sick as fuck btw, watch it

modern is shit.

>>96790870
I'm rooting for broodscale

>>96791005
we know

>>96789329
It's very weird that Modern is objectively the best 60 card format with decent deck diversity (Pioneer doesn't count since they basically decided Pioneer was dead)

File: rav-208-glimpse-the-unthi(...).jpg (68 KB, 616x452)

68 KB JPG

>>96790870
mill sisters... we didnt make it........

>>96790238
>Wotc being right wing chuds replacing a Latin icon with a generic north american

There's probably someone in Wizard's C-suite who's currently thinking
>But how much more money would we have made if Ice Till Explorer was Laura Croft? Or what if Psychic Frog was Hypnotoad?
And on some level they are completely right to think like that.

ancient tomb float 2
-1 sol ring float 2, 3 total
-2 grim monolith float 3, 4 total
-2 time vault, 2 remaining
-1 manifold key -1 activate target time vault
all with force of will backup

File: IMG_4934.jpg (1.03 MB, 1179x1532)

1.03 MB JPG

It’s easy to hate MaRo. But do you have the courage to hate Hasbro?

>>96791233
Dude we told you not to bring shit like that next time you do this we're playing with Jamie instead

>>96790691
>Infinity War felt like too much of a conclusion, most people jumped off afterwards because it felt the stakes couldn't get higher.
Compare and contrast Otaria arc where wotc had just finished Urza's wild ride and killed off Yawgmoth at the cost of just about everything. Instead of trying to escalate further, they deescalated by making stuff about gladiator mages fighting each other which had a whimsical appeal that had been absent for a very long time.

>>96791255
vintage is a 2 player format

>>96791236
I don't even hate Maro. I hate Hasbro.

>>96791236
Fuck both.
And COCKS too.

File: 1644082887584.jpg (224 KB, 1472x2048)

224 KB JPG

bnuuy

>>96791236
>unsleeved cards
>rules reminder cards
>upside down lands
>open drinks
>cards directly on a rough wooden surface

>>96791260
Yeah and Odyssey was a flop too so take from that what you will.

File: 1760369699161649.jpg (9 KB, 202x249)

9 KB JPG

>>96791236
The format of choice of evil suits destroying this game? CUMMANDER.

Color me surprised. And then this subhumans will tell the rest to no compare them to pigs and respect those “players” that enjoy this game “in a different way”, suck my balls.

File: IMG_0163.png (1.24 MB, 1792x828)

1.24 MB PNG

top 8

>>96791535
my prediction:
>blink beats blink
>affinity beats amulet
>esper beats energy
>prowess beats prowess

>blink beats affinity
>prowess beats energy

>prowess beats blink

>>96791568
Personally I'm betting on Goryo's going to the finals (I think the matchup with energy and prowess is good) against amulet titan and amulet titans wins.

File: retard.jpg (695 KB, 3000x3000)

695 KB JPG

>>96791568
>>esper beats energy
>>prowess beats energy

>>96791236
Just think about. Those guys could get any cards printed they wanted for personal used. Cocks could have even bullied Nosewater into giving him some lotuses to play with. But instead they're playing exclusively with slop printed in the last five years. And on top of that they aren't even using sleeves to make shuffling easier.

>>96791604
both of those decks have a positive matchup against energy, I genuinely have no idea what you're trying to say here

>>96791604
>>96791684
oh, I now see that I wrote "energy" instead of "esper" in the semi-finals, I am indeed a retard

I'm not following modern closely but I could've sworn that izzet decks with murktide and DRC were out of fashion and now they have two in top 8.

>>96791786
They're cori steel cutter decks lol. Imagine the deck that raped standard back on May/ June but with modern level cantrips and interaction

>>96791236
Are Cock's lands tapped or untapped?

>>96791867
>https://vocaroo.com/1ihc21gJLBh1

>>96791684
esper beats energy then forfeits the tournament so energy gets a free seat in the semis

>>96791859
I always forget that EI is still legal in modern.

>>96791786
>but I could've sworn that izzet decks with murktide and DRC were out of fashion and now they have two in top 8.
they are two completely different izzet decks
the deck you're familar with had ragavan, counterspell and murktide in the main
the deck in the top 8 doesn't have any of those cards in the main, it's izzet prowess

Jesus Goryo's getting brutalized.

>>96791568
well you’re wrong so far
the esperKEK just got btfo by the energyGOD epic style

File: Screenshot 2025-10-19 185710.png (1.02 MB, 1279x709)

1.02 MB PNG

kinda sad amulet waifu didn't make it

Amuletsissies are in for a rude awakening

>>96791867
tapped 45 degrees like arena

just ban amulet already

I'm 14-6 in the legacy leagues I've played today
I can feel a 5-0 coming soon

>>96792295
good luck buddy, beat those digusting UB reanimator players

File: 1686114727231143.png (748 KB, 729x1015)

748 KB PNG

>>96790578
>It's so uninteresting everyone forgets that we're also getting the Hobbit.

File: file.png (422 KB, 980x442)

422 KB PNG

>>96792303
I think delver is a worse match up for me, or maybe I've just played enough games against reanimator that I can guess what to fight over and know how to board better.

File: Elf.jpg (98 KB, 488x680)

98 KB JPG

>>96792397
They'll probably give frodo a lip disc.

File: mh2-137-obsidian-charmaw.jpg (164 KB, 672x936)

164 KB JPG

>>96792123
*rapes amuletCHUDs*

>>96792437
Obsidian GOATmaw does it again.

File: 1759406536327209.jpg (44 KB, 474x474)

44 KB JPG

If a magic card doesn't have this on the back side of it. Then it's not a real magic card.

File: Screenshot 2025-10-19 at (...).png (13 KB, 650x223)

13 KB PNG

Am I deranged for finding this a little insulting? You can whore out the game to an IP you don't even bother knowing anything about?

>>96792565
maro doesn't design every set, just most of them

>>96792565
Do you think Maro is in charge of anything?

>>96792112
Hilarious that the dude has the more fag looking hands here

>>96792530
They all have to have a nick on the top middle?

File: magicplayers.jpg (105 KB, 640x480)

105 KB JPG

>tq
literally this:

>>96792698
Handling complaints. Also Un-set rules.

>>96792742
Yeah but he only designs unsets. He doesn't decide if or when they come out.

>>96792565
He's not leading the set, so why's it matter? He tends to be at least partially involved in every set's design to a greater or lesser extent, but just as a designer alone his contribution is still useful, surely.

>>96790630
It's a good thing they're not basing this set off the movies, then.

Modern has largely balanced out in to a healthy state post MH3 how will MH4 blow up the format

>>96785999
How the FUCK is Alara not on this list? It fucking DEFINED the colors of its shards! We STILL use Jund, Bant, etc for those colors.

>>96792934
>modern has balanced out into a healthy state
>paper play needs you to track like three different storm counts because Ral Zarek was formatted by James Joyce

>>96792949
I said largely, storm will be storm. It does have to be said that it's really easy to hate Ruby storm to death though

>>96792934
we won't know until we get at least a hint about the main themes of MH4

>>96792934
Modern is trash right now so who cares how much trash will become in the future? Just look at this >>96791535 is a hell.

>>96791236
>>96791351
It's hard to hate them when the play like such chads, but then I remember it's commander and they only do it because they are rich and know nothing about magic. Fuck hasbro and every stain on humanity in this picture.

What are those piles of cardboard with the planeswalker symbol on the back though? Official C-suite proxies?

>>96793078
its the life marker that comes with precons

>>96793023
Blink and Energy are just normal midrange decks. Affinity is just straightforward beatdown. Amulet Titan is just doing the normal Amulet Titan things.
The only deck there that I would call problematic is Prowess because Prowess has the potential to consistently OTK the opponent turn 3
Compared to even a few months ago, this isn't a bad state. Multitude of strategies and not that many non-games. It's better than anything under MH2 which was YEARS of modern.

File: ice-324-jester-s-cap.png (1.96 MB, 745x1040)

1.96 MB PNG

>>96793091
kek that's pretty good too

File: MH4th impact soon.jpg (388 KB, 1920x814)

388 KB JPG

>>96792934
>Modern has largely balanced out in to a healthy state post MH3
I'd say it's in a similar state as all the non-rotating formats. Which is to say it's stabilized because it's all but dead
>how will MH4 blow up the format
In ways we can't even comprehend.

File: 1730863015703166.jpg (63 KB, 380x531)

63 KB JPG

So why aren't you guys playing Sorcery again?

>>96790459
these look fun. I've always had a soft spot for maverick. I can't really say much though I don't play the format and this place is mostly modern

File: 1243244.jpg (140 KB, 672x936)

140 KB JPG

your thoughts on Secret Lair?

>>96793281
Get the hammer you fucking animal fucking animal, but also unironically the best UB implementation WotC ever did.
>fantasy
>silver border
>charity