>>215161593>this is not art>but it will be the death of art>because it is not artNice
>>215161593>semitic seething intensifies We're right above target
We’ve already established that slick, glossy AI has no appeal but choppy, absurdist AI humor can fit into web culture.
>>215161593matt walsh with a surprisingly good take for once
>>215161593George NO!
>>215161593pshh pshhh go back to work matt walsh go back to work do not criticize is ray el yes ben shapiro yes saar
>>21516159390% of film made by human are souless
>>215161593>even chuds are turning on ai nowya love to see it
>>215161593Miller hasn't made anything of note in years, he's completely washed. Michael Bay, a true artist and auteur, has already debunked AI slop.
>>215161593what if your prompt is an articulation of your feelings, and the AI is simply depicting the prompt?
>>215161593Since when did matt walsh give a shit about liberal "soul" and cinema slop? Oh wait he's a Jew worshiper of course.
>>215161593I am constantly looking for sci fi and alien movies and rarely do any good movies get made since hollywood jews have been shilling cape shit instead.Even when a good sci fi premise is made its often mixed in with some shitty romance sub plot.Look at arrival, top tier first contact movie shoved in with some dead baby shit as an example.Give me AI so I can make a kino of my own with prompts and i will be much more entertained than the cancer the hollywood jew makes.
>>215161687AI is the only thing that’s been able to make me laugh in years, surprisingly >>215161593>meanwhile artists: (I just think this looks good but idk I’ll just tell people it’s symbolic if they ask)
>>215161593I take AI over any woke slop
>you're not a director if you had someone else operate the camera
>>215161749Basically, he's right. If its not somewhere in the training data then its not coming out. AI just mashes what exists, maybe good enough for generic popcorn slop but will never be at the limits of innovation. It can replace Bay though. Probably Matt Walsh too since hes a generic boomer
People forget that Walsh is a successful filmmaker himselfAI couldn't capture the soul of kino like his
>>21516173099% nowaday btw
The only people that will get replaced by AI are the ones that had no real merit to begin with, and that's why there are so many angry people.Also making fake things ubiquitous just makes real things more valuable.
I'm here for the cognitive dissonance from people who hate AI but suck this boomer's dick>People will tell AI "make a movie in the style of James Cameron, make a movie in the style of Zack Snyder." But "Make a movie in the style of Ridley Scott, or make a movie in the style of Stanley Kubrick," that's always been the prompt that goes on inside my own head.>Cameron is on the board of directors at AI company Stable Diffusion
>>215161687I like AI body horror
>>215161593First time I've seen a MIGAoid be anti-AI. Usually these fags lap that shit up.
>>215161852Might actually be good. Not needing to appeal to the lowest common denominator might mean movies can be told at a higher level. It might make the artists go up their own ass more, but it also means more decent work? Hopefully
2024 and 2025 even moreso have been truly abysmal for film. The good movies are just alright; we're definitely past the point of masterpieces being created.In other words, have AI take over because it's at least improving, unlike hollywood which is just decaying.
>>215161879You are either brown or a fat woman so why would I care?
>MUH ART MUH SOULI do not give a fuck. Not a single solitary shit. I just want to see MLK in Family Guy
>soulless art is not artexactly, but does he think the vast majority of the stuff being currently produced by Hollywood is art?If AI slop looks cooler and more entertaining than Hollywood slop, I'll watch the former, even if it's made by a machine.
>>215161977YawnAnything new?
>>215161749>Dumbass boomer who never made a single fucking noteworthy thing with artistic merit preaches to the choir for Reddit brownie points and X points and 4chan YAAAAASSS (You)'s and is scared of being replaced thus losing his cashcowReal artists like Lynch embraced AITRVTH NVKE
>>215161593This is like the same arguments people made about machines and cars.The car will never replace the horse!
>>215162190and this is the part where people ignore that cars were hand cranked in those days and pretend our forefathers had Challengers with V8s from the get go so the replacement made le perfect sense
>>215161593Quantify soulless or admit your argument is based on feefees
>>215162254>feelings…bad!ok NPC
>>215161593>>215161695>>215161835What is soul
I'm not pro-AI, I just want hollywood to fall
>>215161749michael bay is basically an LLM so he knows what he is talking about
>>215161593>Fatt Walsh betting against MillerMiller is right. AI has the ability to democratize filmmaking, making story the center of the art.
>>215162158There is a difference between using AI as a TOOL like David Lynch says here and outright making an entire movie using AI prompts and stitching together the clips. The former is useful for brainstorming ideas, creating concept art, editorial practices, etc. The latter is inhuman worthless slop with no effort. And guess what, the average goycattle retard (including most /tv/ users) support the latter instead of the former because they don't have the creative capacity to even use AI as a helper. People are so devoid of will today they just don't want to do anything at all. That's the real crisis that emerges from AI, an increasing loss of will that translates into a competency crisis, decline in fertility and literacy, etc.
>>215162281
>>215161730Thats because theyre films by committee. May as well be AI.
>>215161749Is AI even capable of making anything as bad and soulless as the script for a Transformers movie?
>>215162293>he thinks the democratization of art is a good thing>he thinks storytelling will somehow be advanced by stripping away all thought and just using technical means for production/tv/ is utterly pathetic and knows nothing about art at all
Since the 60s we were forced to accept that completely blank canvases, Campbell's soup cans and a banana taped to a wall are all art. If they are art, then anything a human uses an AI to make is art, as the human would have as much input as they would making some prestige contemporary gallery piece that is a pile of beans that is a metaphor for sexual assault or something
>>215161593When I use AI, I just ask AI questions and read the answers that it compiles. It's sort of like Wikipedia in a way, but sources compiled and generated by AI. I don't ask AI to make Art or movies or anything of that sort. In fact, I just opened Tubi and went through their catalogue of films, new and old, that they have at the moment. I plan on watching a few of them, especially the horror films, since it is October. Tubi has some zombie films(Night of the Liing Dead, Day of the Dead, Return of the Living Dead 2,3 and Necropolis) and John Carpenter(Vampires, in the Mouth of Madness) films at the moment. They even have Dagon and 30 Days of Night.Earlier today, I asked AI about how the Byzantine-Romans were freeing Christians who were enslaved by Muslims. I also asked AI to generate a list of Horror and Gothic stories written before 1925 so that I have something other than H.P. Lovecraft to read this October. AI is good for asking about fiction books and can also list sources or books about history. No need to ask AI to create stories or make AI Art when there is an abundance of that stuff still around.
>>215162332Fuck off with your strawmanning faggotry.Someone with a script and no funds can make a movie and you can't stop them you gigantic horse's ass
>>215161593>REEEE NO SOULThen I guess I’m a soulles husk because I don’t fucking care.>>215161861This applies even more strongly to AAA vidya.
>>215162309>There is a difference between using AI as a TOOL like David Lynch says here and outright making an entire movie using AI promptsStop playing Jewish word games. I'm not even going to continue because it's apparent to anyone without a hateboner for AI that Lynch was all for it. He was obviously still alive when image and video gen was around and wasn't senile which is why he brought up the phone to pencil comparison
>>215162332Gatekeeping homo jew
>>215161593Why does everyone pretend like we're actually going to invent Skynet? It's fairly obvious that AI is going to hit a ceiling in the next few years and all that it'll be able to do is generate movies. Then the bubble will pop and we get a huge recession considering these bullshit tech companies are the driving force of the global economy right now. The pinnacle of this technology will be creating an Attack of the 50 Foot Woman giantess porn remake with Jenna Ortega while you use ChatGPT to write your work emails. sorry to break it to you
wack
>>215161695Not sure if leftoid or groyper....
>>215162394Congrats, you can "make" a dogshit movie with minimal effort that no one will watch. Might as well devote your life to painting a masterpiece portrait by hand that no one will see. Art is useless if it's not public, if it makes no impact on anyone or any culture. That's the whole appeal of going to the movies, reading classic books and watching the best films, etc. And I guarantee whatever slop that Google helps create for you won't be worth anything
>>215162452>Art is useless if it's not public, if it makes no impact on anyone or any culture.This is the faggiest thing I've ever read
>>215162452Sounds like you failed at life and are a bitter little faggot lol
>>215161593Remembered that Erasmus from the Dune prequels tried to make Art. So I asked AI about it.
>>215161621>Kike Walsh>celeblmao
>>215162539Freaking hell.
>>215162491>>215162524AI leads to automation. Automation leads to the end of culture, borders, unique identity, etc. Those things lead to communism. All AI jeets are literally communists who don't realize it.
>>215162568AhahahaHope to see your sorry ass in the gulag then, comrade
>>215161593Shit take from Walsh. If I write a script then prompt an AI how to generate and render it, that absolutely is art. Its like saying photos arent art because the machine generates them.
>>215161593matt walsh is such a performative faggotart will never die because humans always want to fuckand art is a way to build up your fuck valuesimple as
>>215162244It's funny that you think you made some kind of rebuttal. Even the most rudimentary version of the car replaced the horse as you just pointed out.
>>215162649Except it took decades for automobiles to effectively replace horses due to numerous factors. I think you're just dumb bro?
>>215161695He forgot to mention that corporate checklists and focus groups are soulless and that's where AI is learning how to make films in the first place.
>>215162629>If I write a scriptYou won't.
>>215161593Retarded grifter.
>>215161593If someone made a movie out of prompting he would be sifting through thousands of possible shots and discarding most. Individuality and creativity would come through in that process.There would be an ocean of shit, but there is no reason someone couldn't make something great.
>>215162452>Might as well devote your life to painting a masterpiece portrait by hand that no one will see. Art is useless if it's not publicHard disagree. The point of the artistic process is that you get a kick out of creating. Fuck all those people who aren't worthy of seeing or hearing my result. If you create to share with others, then you're a fucking narcissist who seeks validation. I've been making my music for two decades by now because I enjoy the process, any other reason for creating is inherently sinful.
>>215162709This is why a lot of AI sloppa has a piss filter now. So much of the Ghibli shit got fed back into it that it tainted the whole thing.
>>215162394>Someone with a script and no funds can make a movieNobody is going to watch his AI movie, they're just going to ask for the prompt so they can make their own version with the same button press.
>>215161593Based Miller.
The videogame The Movies came out in 2005 or 2006 and somehow it wasn't the death of filmmaking, even though anyone could create movies on his own computer now.
For an AI slop thread there's like only 2 AI slips in this whole thread... Is that the best we can do as 4chan these days?
>>215162539>the Dune prequelsRemove yourself.
>>215162873No, the piss filter is simply because it's how ChatGPT/Sora generates.
>>215161635now you understand the argument about why trannies are women
Now is a good time to start redpilling normalfags about ALADDIN, the "Asset, Liability, Debt and Derivative Investment Network."
>>215162717>Except it took decades for automobiles to effectively replace horsesNo it didn't.
>>215163072>>215162709>>215162430Why the fuck are you less sentient than a GPT prompt? All you ever do is spam one word and dump the same gay ass folderI know that of course this is the part where you absolutely btfo me by really switching things up and making the exact same godamn post again, but honestly the last thing this shithole board needs is ANOTHER boring fucking ritual posting asshole like the Sarah Gadon guy or the ice cream guy, just shut the fuck up dude
>>215161593getting exactly what you desire is never good for art. lotharios don't write love songs
>>215163143>das right niggas roads built for cars just magically popped up out of nowhere i aint bullshittin ya and people could afford $2000 jalopys >Posts a model from the 20s proving my pointPoint is AI is only a few years old, cars were introduced in the 1890s and were initially seen as a novelty luxury item.
>>215161593What is an AI?
AI is useful for creating concept art, but isung it to create actual stuff just creates slop. There's no craft and no effort.
>a prompt isn't filmmakingYou can prompt one thing at a time and combine them later if you need to have cumbersome effort in your definition of art. The value of sucking insider cock is still going to zero.
AI is the Antichrist. I tried using it and I just felt disgusted with myself. There's something about this technology that just feels unnatural. The images look uncanny but not in an obvious way. There's just a lack of soul to it. I don't think we're used to seeing this kind of imagery.
AI won.
>>215161593I thought this guy was based and redpilled when did he turn into a retarded faggot?
>>215163616This is gonna piss his fans off because he was peak sovl or something but the one thing I felt the instant I started seeing AI generated pictures was that they somehow look like the pictures David Dees used to makeAnd that was a very specific feeling because fucking nothing looks like the pictures David Dees used to make
>>215163333They used the same excuse for Google Stadia, or VR glasses. Or NFTs. Problem is the whole AI is a marketing buzzword. LLM is not AI in any way, its a glorified search engine. Its as intelligent as you pushing Ctrl+F on your keyboard when you're looking for (You)s
>>215163701
>>215163616>I don't think we're used to seeing this kind of imagery.We aren't, but kids who are 15 have seen this kind of imagery for essentially their entire life, starting with how smartphones started to process photos almost 10 years ago already.You look at "4K remasters" of James Cameron's movies and they look unnatural to you, but they look Just Fine to the upcoming generation and in fact better than the original footage (to their eyes).
>>215163710>If I name a bunch of failed completely unrelated tech thingys I’m right I think!I think I’m arguing with a fat woman at this point
>>215163732James Cameron himself confirmed that he personally reviewed and approved every frame of those remasters and anyone who criticizes them is "a basement-dwelling incel"Are you really gonna question James Cameron?
>>215161593AI is a tool. Just like this guy.
>>215163775Of course I will.I also ~question~ (call out) Armin van Buuren when he shows a very incorrect technique in his """masterclass""" video that actually introduces a specific audible problem.
>>215163720based as fuark
>>215161687>We’ve already established that slick, glossy AI has no appealLmao, according to who?
>>215162309>There's a difference if I want there to be.OK, faggot, whatever.
>>215162332>stripping away all thought and just using technical means for productionBut AI Film-Creation is literally the OPPOSITE of that: It eliminates the gatekeeping of the originally expensive, resource-heavy technical means for production, allowing for a creator's pure creativity to manifest as images.Sounds like YOU are the one that "knows nothing about Art", dipshit.
>>215161593https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite
>>215163616>Me scared of new technology :(OK, grandpa, that's fine. Go back to your Cave-Painting or whatever. We'll handle things instead.
MOD RUNNING AMUCK BECAUSE I DIDNT DENOUNCE A.I
>>215161635FPBPHollywood is fucked because it can't understand that AI is their competition, not something they can just get rid of.If they want to be better than other forms of entertainment, they have to step it up or die.
>>215164071Honestly it's nice to see ritual spammers get banned every once in a while
>>215161593Are there really people here who unironically follow Matt Walsh for his opinions? Are you faggots 40+ years old???
>>215163616you used something designed to hide its flaws and please addicts enough to get big investment, there is no gen AI yet released that was created to create art as it's first and only guiding principal.
>>215161635he's right though. its an amalgamation of what has been fed into it, but it cannot create something new that it has no concept of.
>>215164128How did it know what Will Smith eating spaghetti looked like when Will Smith was never filmed eating spaghetti before he learned of the AI meme?
>>215164095I only posted once in here and nothing I've ever posted before.
>>215164128But enough about Quentin Tarantino!
>>215161593Its a fucking tool like anything else faggots
>>215164158Just to indulge you, here's every post that got banned ITTBy the way, even though I bitched at the retard I didn't actually report him. I know that's pointless, you can't get rid of anybody from this shithole. But man he gets on my nerves.
>>215164152> its an amalgamation of what has been fed into it
>>215161695Its because he's a loud mouth grifting faggot like everyone else who would be negatively effected by AI.Like you and your gay breadtubers.
>>215161593Art has already died because the CIA pushed shit like Jackson Pollack as 'art' when it's anything but. Classical art has been dead for quite some time and film making is the worst it's ever been so if AI can improve on what we currently are subjected to then I'm all for it.
>>215164128You're aware that human art is also an amalgamation of what's been fed into it. That's what influence is all about.Every artist worth a shit has learned through studying other peoples' works. All artists train on external data.
>>215162332Maybe you retards shouldn't have used interest free loans and government grants to produce absolute trash for the past few decades.
>>215161861Is he wrong? People won't go see a superhero movie if you lower the quality, so you have to cut the cost to make a profit.
>>215162403AAA vidya benefits massively from smaller teams.
>>215163182Its fucking perplexing how these people are bitching about AI when they act like dumb spambots from over a decade ago.Like, we reached the bottom of the barrel in terms of discourse and creativity YEARS ago and they want to draw the line at AI?Give me a fucking break.
>Movies in the future will be a director working with a small group of tech nerds feeding the AI into making a movie>There's nothing these hacks in hollywood can do about it
>>215161593All art is soulless in the current year.
>>215164437And they'll have to be better and more entertaining than the average autist with the same budget.It's gonna be a wild ride.
>>215161593>"Sora, take the movie Tron Ares and remove Jared Leto. Also fix the story."At the point AI could do that then it's definitely filmmaking.
i cant even understand why people are exited about AI beyond language stuff and repetitive tasks, the AI bubble cant burst soon enough, i want altman and peter thiel to be raped by bums just to afford a hot cup of coffee
>>215164546>the AI bubble cant burst soon enough
>>215161593Dude’s basically describing the last 15 years of Hollywood
the internet is just becoming one big facebook now it's over
>anti-art
>>215161635What part of that sentiment was too complicated for you, pajeet?
>>215164733Blud, did you really post a jak? Is this your best argument? A fucking jak? Are you soi or something?
>>215161593Oh the ironing. Pretty much everything we got in the past 10 years was soulless garbage, so there's pretty much no difference other than AI prompters have the guts to type "make the women hot with huge tits".
what is a human?
>>215163616>AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH. THE ANTI CHRIST. IM GOING INSANE
>>215161593>left wing director is pro-AI, right wing documrntarian in anti-AIHuh?
>>215163616Cameras steal your soul!
>>215161593nooooo the pope says you can't use crossbows because the bolts dont have heckin souls compared to longbowarinos!!!!! its illegal!!!!!!!
Daily reminder than nothing can stop technology once it's emerged. We know you can use machines to generate images, sound, and video that's nigh-indistinguishable from human craftsmanship, therefore it's here forever.Get a job.
>>215161593>a camera has no feeling, no thought, no soul, so what it spits out will be souless and meaninglessHe's a grifter=just saying what his fans think/want to hear... If human soul is a thing then AI is a reflection of it anyway.
>>215165022Funniest part. Generative AI is a human invention and it's legitimately genius.It didn't just fucking grow out of nowhere and invade. It's human ingenuity in action.These fucking pearlclutchers are even more obnoxious than vegans.
>>215162332trvkelooking at all the content posted online, there hasn't been a greater democratization of art, yet the majority of what is posted is garbage. everyone who is into some type of artistic product, whether music, movies or video games is longing for some past period where creation was less democratic and required more hardship.
>>215161789That's not what directors do you idiot
>>215162332Fries.Bag.Now.
>>215161593Weird I saw an interview where George Miller called AI "slop" verbatim just a week or two ago.
>>215165292He had a bad impression by seeing bad shit, and then realized it can also make good shit. Many such cases.
>>215165301I think the journalist is just cherry picking things to spin a narrative
I think it's inevitable, but they will probably reach some kind of agreement first. I just haven't seen anything AI made that was good. Yes I know Will Smith eating spaghetti looks better now than three years ago, but everything I see especially things with audio look and sound unnatural and static, sometimes having very obvious errors. Will it ever be actually unironically good? Probably, but who knows how long it will take and who knows if the public will have access to it. I am also not sure if the people that like AI so much have the skill to create good stories. Most of what I've seen is just wacky stuff like "Elvis and Tupac playing basketball together" or "here's how a live action version of Evangelion would look" or just fake trailer channels from India. Or that one channel, also Indian, that made an AI movie about the Oct 7th attack. So I wonder, what's the endgame for them? Live action versions of anime shows? Men in Black but with Elvis and Tupac? Little Mermaid but with Francesca Capaldi? Seems pointless and hacky and even worse than Hollywood because at least every now and then a new movie comes out and it's actually good, like Eddington.
>>215165357>I just haven't seen anything AI made that was good.It's not hard to find, especially with later advancements.Unless of course you don't want to actually find anything. Then it would be exceptionally hard to find.
>>215165371I don't really care, I'm skeptical but not anti AI. Can you please provide a couple links?
>>215165460https://www.youtube.com/shorts/wMTYYcpbbpchttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SA6fUs3dsRU
>>215161593no one is saying hollywood is going to prompt a whole movie. they are going to have ai do bits of slow work quickly. make a backdrop picture that would have taken 4 guys 2 months to do for Star Wars. that sort of stuff. or get scene variations when scriptwriting and choose one to work on. much later on have AI actors in the shots instead of real people. directors are not putting themselves out of a job.
>>215165543>directors are not putting themselves out of a jobI'll be doing that.
>companies replace people with AI>start churning out workslop that's actually making outputs worse>absolutely everyone with a three digit IQ can tell AI art and AI written text apartAI so far has only revolutionized porn.
>>215165584It'll also only replace porn.Actual art will coexist with AI generations easily, but porn "artists" are already permanently out of a job. Good riddance.
>>215161593When you type 3+2 in a calculator, it's the calculator doing the calculus, not you. Same with AI.
Seems like all of you are so retarded that you think all movies using AI will be made up of single prompts making random slop videos with audio.Ever heard of nuance? All filmmakers, cg artists , audio mixers, everyone on the tech side, will use whatever tool gives them the best result at each separate step for every separate shot. They always have. And they can tell slop from nonslop better than you.
>>215165680I'll go even further: creative people will use things, AI included, creatively.
>>215162452>Art is useless if it's not public
>>215163701>>215163720David Dees what?
>>215161593I disagree with some of Matt Walsh takes. This isn't one of them. What he fails to consider is that PC can just continue to generate scenes until the creator is satisfied with how it looks.
>>215165751Interesting that there's ultimately a human element. Not so soulless after all.
>>215165584>>215165627>AI so far has only revolutionized porn.>It'll also only replace porn.Porn sites have already added separate filters for them because they were flooded with absolute shit. Pixiv has separate AI filter you can click on the Options menu. Sadpanda AI galleries get consistently downvoted because the retarded prompters dump all the results instead of only choosing the few good ones. The only 4-5 star AI galleries use 3D model methods mixed with an AI filter.Rule34video made a separate site for the AI porn and the most popular clips there are lucky to get 300 views at most. Meanwhile when the new 3D animation of Tracer fucking Mercy in the ass with giant futa cock gets released in the old site, it gets thousands of views instantly.
>>215165766>look at these several-months-behind chinks!lolAs for whatever you typed I'm happy for you or sorry it happened.
what the flippity floppity flizzilwotsit does matt walsh know about art KEK!
>>215165766They put those filters in because career pornfags know they're fucked and want to kiss their asses. Don't kid yourself.AI porn, especially very recent examples, are increasingly great. It'll plateau only when it's fully indistinguishable from the real thing.
>>215165766>Sadpanda AI galleries get consistently downvoted because the retarded prompters dump all the results instead of only choosing the few good ones.>these troons on the loli site hate it!I'm not convinced.
>>215165810>People don't visit the AI porn site because the artists would get upset.Now thats a pajeet cope if I've ever seen one.
>>215165834rule34 has an optional AI filter that's off by default. Nobody gives a shit and your porn "art" career is over whether you like it or not.It's over.
>>215165851>Nobody gives a shitThats right, nobody gives a shit about AI porn. Glad you agree.
>>215165834>pajeet copeOh no, it's one of these troons. You weren't fooling anybody with Superman and you aren't fooling anybody here.Somebody post the graph that shows that troons especially hate generative AI
>>215161593>chuds agree>disco elysium commies agreeMan, everyone hates AI slop
>>215165859In other words they fap to it because porn, unlike art, is only designed to stimulate one thing.You don't need to spend hours drawing up anime tits when you can just gen them. No one will ever see the use of porn "artists" ever again.
>>215165861Show your hand, nigger.
don't care, gonna make celebrity porn
>>215165875>In other words they fap to itThats the thing. They don't. Rule34video made an entirely separate site for AI porn and nobody visits it. People fap to 3D porn instead in the old site. I'm sorry but you have to work in your shit-smeared kebab stall a bit longer.
>>215165896>Thats the thing. They don't.That's because they also host the same video on the main site.
>>215165903>That's because they also host the same video on the main site.No they don't. Just told you they made a separate site because there was too much shitty AI porn flooding the 3D site.
I'm surprised at how little AI has been used in political smear campaigns yet
>>215165947Meanwhile the site people actually go to gives you 250 pages of results.Redundancy is bound to be unpopular.
>>215165973That would get people sued. Universal and Disney are already suing some AI sites for allowing people to prompt Donald Duck and Mickey Mouse.
>>215165982>results are the same thing as popularity.Holy shit I'm talking to a genuine brown mouth-breather retard here. Also you see that Filter AI posts-button? Why do you think they put that there if people love AI porn so much?
>>215161593What is a director or a producer if not a meatbag AI?
>>215161593I haven’t watched his movies, but I doubt there is any ‘soul’ in them. So what exactly would be the difference if there wasn’t soul in future movies? I haven’t seen much soul from movies in general for over a decade now. I’ll also point out that he is on the shaky ground of claiming there is such a thing as a human soul, and that machines can’t be the tools for crafting products, despite having done so for decades now. Your car was made by humans using machines, and robots. Your appliances, computer parts, cell phones, medications, clothing, etc. Does he complain when he buys something made by a machine? Or is his fear extremely narrow to just his own industry, where his cash flow comes from? He’s afraid of a future where anyone willing to compete could make a movie, because he’s afraid he isn’t talented, he’s simply protected by the gate keeping. He’s afraid of a future where he can’t profit. When you read from nay sayers like him, remember, it is a selfish view from someone that is fearful and greedy. Not someone that cares about ‘art’.
>>215161749I'm pro AI and agree with that quote
>>215161593When will these people accept using AI as a tool to help?
>>215166052So far it helps ripping green screen with slightly less manual cropping but thats about it.
>>215164546The AI bubble will only burst for its non useful functionsWhich I’m sorry to say is not the art side of things, you’re going to have to prepare
>>215166080Wrong, it could easily be used as interpolation between animation frames to halve workIt also does lighting way better than most CG I’ve seen in recent years, which is dogshit and always makes everything look fake and clash
the entire conversation concerning Ai and the inevitable single prompt film misses the mark entirely. Still doesnt change the fact that marketing STILL rules this industry.Moreover, anyone in media adjacent to filmmaking with Matts is full of a cope. The groundbreaking part about LLMs is creating synthetic likeness. And the ease of censoring and editing per market release in real time. LLMs are the single largest disrupter in storytelling since the camera
>>215166052Ai, LLM has been writing scripts since disney panicked about TFA not meeting internal expectations. Why do you think TLJ took a 180
>>215167137lol, you really think that?No, that’s “human” millennial writingMy generation is terrible at writing because they’re all ideologically captured
>>215167246RJ is genx, there isnt a single millenial involved in the ST. And yes i 100% believe Disney is not only willing to us a LLM with star wars and market research, Disney is a top 5 company on planet earth to advance computing or to hide nefarious reasons to advance computing. Wouldnt doubt if Tron Ares is a test ground for literal fake news in a few decades
>>215161593>the AI has no feeling, no thought, no soulDo you? Does anyone in Hollywood?
>>215161635>X has the capacity to destroy Y, therefore they are the same thingThe idiot buffoon really thought he was cooking with this one.
>>215164128 neither can people
>>215161593love the squealing
>>215161663Exactly. Some poeple are obviously feeling the threat of anyone at home with any story to tell being able to make movies to tell that story without content and narrative controls from (((THE SYSTEM))).
ok writerfags who ruined films in 08 by striking. Riddle me this, if there are only 3 types of stories to tell and no idea under the sun is original, why shouldnt we give the LLMs a chance to tell a story of executive committee based filmmaking? I see no reason why the market wont welcome the chance with open arms
>AI has no feeling, no thought, no souljust like modern film makers
AI will only make movies worse because less thought will go into it. They're bad enough already.
>>215161593>computer generate me a 3h long live action version of the entire DBZ Cell arc. Make all the men muscular and all the women hot, blood and gore to the max of course.
ai will simply reveal the true nature of humans, we don't give a shit about "art" and simply want boobs and entertainment
>>215167408Ironically, I trust an LLM to at least thematically and narratively connect the dots. More effort than Hollywood does.
>(new tech) isn't real art!man i hate this episode, why do they keep recycling this plot? its like the 8th time already>(thing i don't like and/or understand) is demonic!nevermind, i'm done with this shit
How is ai slop different from this week shitty horror release or another marvel shit?
>>215167451looks like non-subversive media is back on the menu boys.
>>215167451>vibrant behind the scenes>Some intern ruins the color grading in postEvery time
>>215161593Hollywood movies don't have soul though.
>>215161593>artfags got madI’d be seething too. Basically we don’t need you anymore.
>>215161866AI could probably actually do the I'M GOING INSAAAAANE visuals of Lovecraft. It's complety obscene and surreal in how grotesque it can be.
>chuds defend ai art because all they want is a fully white cast where the women are hot and dress like sluts. bonus points if it's a version of something they enjoyed as kids (the good ol' days)>lefties hate ai art because the vast majority of them are talentless and if people start being able to male their own movies the public won't be forced to watch their terrible takes on beloved properties Discussing about the soul or if democratizing art is good is pointless because both sides really don't give a fuck about art, they just want their perfect utopia where everything is like THEY want it to be
>>215161593I thought chuds loved AI sloppa
>>215167537>eating the company's food while workingI hope they got fired and live on the street now, filthy animals
>>215167537this is taking jobs, you could just hire local cats for this
>>215167594It was probably something the customer didnt want! Leave the hard working kittens alone! They have it bad enough already working for mcdonalds!
>>215167451>AI BTS of an AI movieyo dawg
>>215167519i think you'll find one side more tolerant of the other side existing and doing their own thing. sure start with what should have been greenlit in the last comic era but they don't have to end there, the audience is demanding entertainment first they will accept surprise once the ship rights itself.
>>215167594ya don't get high on your own supply
Fact is that almost 100% of all movies will be AI movies a decade from now, including all the biggest movies. Left-wingers can seethe all they want but it's a fact. No one will want to watch their left-wing propaganda, which is why they seethe so much. The same is true for music btw.
>>215161593a director is not making a film, the crew is
>>215167506AI NOOOOOOO
>>215162288Seriously. Like, do you poofter artistes not grasp that the whole point of an LLM is to mimic the way humans learn and create? There *is* no magic, no "soul", no ineffable mystique at play when you create, just a lump of cells randomly combining and recombining arrangements of states until one of those arrangements triggers a dopamine response. Your "style" is just a recombination of elements of the styles you were exposed to as you learned to draw/paint/write/film things, as those styles were semi-random composites of the styles their creators were exposed to, and on and on back into the mists of time when Ug and Bug noticed that if you scratched *this* rock against *that* one it made pretty colours and drew a crude sketch of an auroch on a cave wall.I also greatly enjoy the deep ignorance in artist types, sitting there with a furious expression, spittle flecking their screen as they bash out another manifesto against the evils of AI with absolutely zero self-awareness, completely unaware that you could take a transcript of their diatribe and find & replace "AI" with "TV", "radio", "movies", or "photography" and each time it would read nigh identically to similar whingefests by previous generations of poofters railing against a new tool or medium of expression that threatened their business model.Your forefathers couldn't stop the "moving pictures" from making theatre into a niche irrelevance anymore than mine could stop the textile mills from taking their weaving jobs or the assembly robot their career in the auto industry. Just know that there are huge swathes of the public out there who are gleefully revelling in your unseflaware misery, every post you make whinging about this is like meat and drink to those of us who you and your ilk mockingly told >lol lern to code you relic
>>215167683Yes anon, directors direct the film, which is a form of making itCrazy, I know
>>215161593Almost all films are already soulless
>>215161593I disagree with his central anti ai luddite thesis, I would argue that GPT 5 thinking high & pro have more feeling, thought, and "soul" than majority of the humans I've come across in my life and currently I'm increasingly finding myself turning to these models over humans for cases like art, entertainment, education, advice, work, accessibility, creative exploration, and etc. If anything, the world in which I can craft and tailor any type of game, comic, tv series, and movie to my personal preferences would be nothing short of utopia for me. But this is all moot because the pro and anti AI factions don't have to conflict with each other. Like if Matt Walsh and his ilk don't want to consume ai made content then just don't fucking consume it. No one is putting a gun to his head and forcing him to use something like Sora 2, he's free to only consume human made slop if that's what he wants. Now if his real objective is to force pro AI people like me who don't give a shit about the "human soul" from having the option to opt out with AI than there is going to be a problem.
>>215167699Splendid jiggle physics
