>Andor5/5>Ahsoka2/5>Kenobi3/5>Mandalorian4/5>Book of Boba Fett0/5Why is it all so mid?
>>215288687
>>215288687None, except Andor, is above a 2/5 at best.
>>215288738Kennedy has a solid record of having produced some solid movies, so I don't know just how much of the blame is on her.
>>215288771Mando was good for it's first season and parts of two, Kenobi had some good moments between him and Vader, those are their only redeeming qualities.
>>215288777She absolutely does not, at best she has a solid record of not being able to stop Spielberg or other big names from doing what they wanted and injecting her own shit, yet.The minute she got the reigns she somehow tanked the single most successful scifi property of all time.
>>215288687Skeleton crew would be good for kids. The pirate planet was cool.
>>215288687Its probably the best universe to make content in. Tragic it got jeeted. This should be a cautionary tail against female and basedjack writers. Their minds can't properly engage in fantasy and roleplaying so they end up inserting normal modern people into their fantasy setting destroying the experience. The redditor must completely relate to everyone except the villains who have to be personified as their modern political opponents.
Andor is a made me want to sleepAcolyte was top tierDidn't watch skeleton crewKenobi was meh and felt like it cheapened Vader and obiMandalorian was okayI liked boba Fett better than mandalorian
>>215288687Writing is for child like mid american mind, and it's simple.
>>215288867>Acolyte was top tierFirst time i've heard anyone say this, is this a troll or are you serious? I haven't seen the show.
>>215288687Kenobi was dogshit and was literally a guaranteed money printer. And somehow it was horrible.
>>215288985It was so obvious they just took a movie scrip and added bullshit fluff to stretch it across six episodes.
>>215288687I dont want the same story again and againLone wolf raises younginPlease...andor was different enough
Wait but what happened to the Jabba Feet show?
>>215288973>I haven't seen the show.Just watch it instead of listening to chuds on youtube
>>215288832Skeleton Crew isn't completely unwatchable, but it's incredibly too "kiddie". Even though it's Goonies but Star Wars, the characters don't really gel together and neither does the journey. Ironically it's too grand of a story to be saddled with 4 dumb kids as your main cast.
>>215288687If you have any modicum of taste at all, drop those points by three each to find the real ratings
>>215288818>Star Wars>Sci FiEven though I know you are not a Jeet you deserve to be treated like one
I haven't watched any of these except Mandalorian.>Mandalorian Season 18/10Few parts were somewhat silly, the seven samurai episode for example was extremely lame. But otherwise almost perfect. It was very good for a Star Wars show.>Mandalorian Season 27/10Only slightly worse than Season 1. Some episodes were 10/10, but the episode introduction of Boba Fett was garbage. And the episode introduction of Bo Katan was also garbage. The ending was extremely nice.>Mandalorian Season 2.5 (The two Mando Episodes that bizarrely aired on Boba Fetts show)8/10Back to the basics. Bringing attention to everything he's done so far, laying groundwork for him basically being Mandalore reborn.>Mandalorian Season 32/10It's so obvious someone else took over. Someone up the top who decided to do the old switcheroo after they built up a male character to great fame, who then gives everything he has to someone else, usually a woman. Everything that had been done beforehand was thrown away to make Bo Katan this gay as fuck mythical figure. Half of the episodes Mando either doesn't do anything or needs to be saved by Bo Katan. He is made retarded so she can flourish. The other half of the episodes aren't even about him at all. He becomes a side character in his own show with one of the episodes being this weird filler about some random dyke woman no one cares about. I should also note that Season 2 ending was almost perfect and that they shouldn't have went back on that ending without good reason or simply not done the ending like that in the first place. Just Disney yet again taking a male space and ruining it.I imagine the movie is going to be more of the same of Season 3 sloppa.
>>215291615I was actually glad Bo Katan was there because the Mandalore shit was gay. Mando worked best as a Bounty Hunter going on adventures, this grand plan with the Empire and taking back Mandalore was boring as fuck and I would have been pissed if Mando became "the one".
>AndorBoring. Not entirely awful and I can see the appeal. But it was boring.>AcolyteHilariously bad. Even if you ignore all the feminist slop bullshit. It's hilariously poorly written.>Skeleton CrewA really, really shit version of Treasure Planet mixed with The Goonies but with none of the fun. Ending killed any hope of it being good.>KenobiShits on the original vision of the original movies.>MandalorianAbsolutely top tier until Season 3 then dramatically falls into being almost as bad as The Acolyte. >Boba FettAs bad as Acolyte. This is what Acolyte would be without the Feminist Sloppa. It's still fucking awful, just not as obviously bad and doesn't use progressive politics as a shield. It has some of the worst bits of writing, acting, choreography I've ever seen. Five second fights with 30 cuts. A fat old man barely able to move properly so they cut a billion times a second. Weird fucking choreography. Just awful all around.
>>215291650I do agree with you partially. My main issue is that it should have never been laid as groundwork in the beginning. We even had an episode of him learning how to use the Sword. There was nothing else it could have been only for it to be taken by someone else. Just all around shit.
>>215291715Look I would have loved if they gave Bo Katan her own show and left all that shit out of Mandalorian entirely.However I am aware that Disney is a soulless corporation and of course they aren't going to take risks, they're going to backdoor pilot a new thing off their most popular show. Same thing they did with Boba Fett and why the best episodes of Boba Fett were the ones with Mando. I just wish it didn't take an entire fucking season to do.
>>215288687Andor season 2 was boring as shit
Disney is not a real company anymore. They promoted all the HR women to executives and Larry Fink bankrolls their failure to brainwash the youth with cultural marxism.
>>215288777If you got to work with Spielberg and Lucas during their primes, anyone would have been "great producers on solid movies".
>>215288687>Andor5/5>Acolyte4/5>Mando season 14/5>mando season 2 3 pure slop>Assoka2/5>Bookabooba1/5
>>215288687Ahsoka is better than Kenobi,Even Boba Fett is better than Kenobi.
>>215291938>shit is better than shit>even shit is better than shitNot saying much. All of it is terrible.
>>215288687>andor>5/5
>>215288973Acolyte Is trash, that guy Is probably a soiboy>>215288867You have shit taste
>>215288973Acolyte was original, it had soul put into it, it had a cringe episode.
>>215291923>Acolyte 4/5Jesus Christ what awful taste.
>>215292009I value originality, you value slop.
>>215288777Giving bj and getting coffee does not make you a good producer plus she knows where the bodies are buried
>>215288687Reminder all nu wars is faggot shit
>>215288777Checked and it's obvious what happened: she was a woman burning with resentment after spending 40 years watching men create. She thought> finally, a woman is in charge, and now things can be done the right wayShe proceeded to create a Star Wars writers room that was 100% women and POC. They took a picture of Luke Skywalker and pinned him on a board with a large red X over him. No further plot was required, and the result speak for themselves in the sequel trilogy.The Mandalorian S01 was good, which inspired Kennedy to inject lots of female characters. Instead of letting it end with the epic Luke reveal in S02, Kennedy ordered baby Grogu back, since that was the primary female appeal of the show.When things started going south, she went back to the old hits like Kenobi and Boba Fet and let DEI hires fuck them up, too.There was a hail Mary pass to Felony, who dropped the ball. Finally the lesbian destroyed Star Wars for good with Acolyte.By the time some good stuff came down the pipe, like Andor and Skeletron Crew, nobody cared anymore.She was in charge of all of that. She set the direction. Who else was there to blame? Imagine losing 10 wars, one after the other, and not blaming the leadership.
>Andor 5/5This is 3/5 at best. Bunch of faggots giving grandiose speeches like it's some BBC prestige drama.
