[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


This bitch ending up with Ron instead of Harry was the weirdest most random twist ever
>>
>>215476092
JK Rowling is explicitly anti-mudblood, only a loser like Ron would settle for Hermione.
>>
>>215476107
she might be a mudblood but she's a girlboss too...
>>
She was an uggo nerd bitch in the books. That’s one reason Rowling was upset with the casting.
>>
>>215476092
>Useless Ron ended up with a KRUM widow
This series promoted retroactive cuckoldry
>>
File: FB_IMG_1761380466679.jpg (124 KB, 1210x1503)
124 KB
124 KB JPG
>>215476156
ZAYM! so ginny mogs Hermione in the books?
>>
>>215476256
Apparently she's supposed to be rly likable in the books
Movie ginny is like the most non character wallflower ever made
>>
>>215476414
I read through the entire series 5 times as a kid, and I don't remember shit about her.
>>
>>215476156
>uggo

So that's why Rowling was okay with Hermione being portrayed by a black actress . . .
>>
No it makes perfect sense

They would all go their separate ways after hogwarts if this didn't happen

Since Harry married Ginny, Ron is basically his brother-in-law and Hermione his sister-in-law

They'd be lifetime family unironically
>>
File: 1760100010853607.jpg (838 KB, 2328x2311)
838 KB
838 KB JPG
>>215476092
Harry x Luna is the only way it should've ended.

>>215476414
Supposedly. She has only a prominent role in the second, then becomes a non-character until the 6th where half the book is her fucking other guys until Harry goes for her.
>>
>>215476256
>The protagonist ends up with a BLACKED hoe, and this is somehow presented as a happy desirable outcome
This series was a piece of feminist propaganda made to pass off degrading humiliation rituals as desirable to little boys.
>>
>>215476576
Evanna Lynch was cute in the movie, but Luna was an autistic weirdo who probably smelled bad.
>>
>>215476576
Luna my childhood crush :3
>>
ginny was rowlings self-insert
>>
>>215476092
i want to fugg ron
>>
>>215476092
she split with ron few years after cursed child events according to J R
>>
It makes more sense in the books, which despite still being shit, are better at characterization. Ron is much cooler and braver in the books and Hermione is a nerd that Harry isn't attracted to.
>>
>>215476623
>Lynch read the Harry Potter series for the first time at age eight and became a fan,[6][7][8] reading and writing fan fiction about the series[6] and sending letters to the author, J. K. Rowling.[1] She was educated at Cartown National School in Termonfeckin until June 2004 and then moved to Our Lady's College in Drogheda,[2][7] where her father was the deputy principal.[9][10] In 2008, she studied speculative fiction and drama at the Centre for the Talented Youth of Ireland, a summer school for gifted teens, in Glasnevin.[11][12] While on the Harry Potter film set, Lynch was tutored for at least three hours a day.[13] In September 2010, she attended the Institute of Education to repeat her Leaving Certificate.[14]

Lynch developed an eating disorder at age eleven. She was hospitalised several times for anorexia, and stated that the Harry Potter novels were the only thing that could distract from her condition. During this period, she often wrote to Rowling, stating that "her books and her kindness really made me want to live again."[15] Rowling wrote then-11-year-old Lynch "incredible, wise letters" back.[16]

That's rly wholesome desu, I wonder if she turned against Rowling for the terf thing
>>
>>215476735
IIRC Lynch wasn't one of the people who turned against Rowling
>>
>>215476092
Harry and Ron not ending up together was the cop-out of the century.
>>
>>215476092
Apparently it makes more sense in the books. The characters were butchered for the movie by the script writer who was a pedo and had a hard-on for Emma.
>>
>>215476092
Emma in this pic looks similar to Ellie from the last of us
>>
>>215476788
this
>>
>>215476801
It doesn't. The entire epilogue is a fanfic-tier asspull.
>>
>>215476788
twentieth post best post
>>
>>215476801
>Apparently it makes more sense in the books.
I would say it makes less sense in the books. From what I remember the movies don't have Ron and Hermione arguing and bickering all the time and Ron being a insensitive asshole towards Hermione every year.
>>
>>215476801
I haven't read the books since they came out but as far as I can remember it was just randomly thrown in at the end.
>>
>>215476823
>>215476857
It does make more sense in the books, and you also get Harry's inner thoughts showing he isn't attracted to her at all.

>bickering all the time and

like a couple does
>>
>>215476256
Based Redhead Lover Harry.
>>
>>215476092
The series would have worked better, if Hermione was thrown into a volcano at the end, possibly while being clutched by an ecstatic gremlin-like creature.
>>
>>215476585
Rowling is a total prude, there is no way that anybody has sex at Hogwarts
>>
>>215476881
>>bickering all the time and
>like a couple does
A bad couple.
>>
>>215476092
>brave, powerful, literally the savior of the wizarding world
>his friend who is slightly taller
Gee, I wonder which one a woman would pick in the real world...
>>
>>215476933
Like Ginny wasn't famous for taking black cocks under the Quidditch bleachers
>>
>>215476933
It was implied. She wasn't going to write explicit smut in a book series aimed at children. The parents wouldn't have bought it for their kids if that was the case.
>>
>>215476953
Popular doesn't mean slut
>>
>>215476092
>most random twist
It was a very obvious endgame in the books
>>
>>215476998
In what world?
>>
>>215477020
in any world nigger lots of popular girls enjoy the social attention but not sex with randoms meanwhile lots of shut in girls can be mega whores in contrast
>>
>>215477007
Nothing obvious about it, she was a snobbish intruder only marginally useful and a drama generator, with a chip on her shoulder and a rotten attitude. She was like the antithesis of Molly Weasley. She had more chemistry with Draco fucking Malfoy than she did with Ron, who by his own admission thought she was legitimately psycho.
>>
>>215477055
Yeah, but imagine the bush. Wood berry my face in her English crumpet
>>
>>215476722
that shit is not canon. That and fantastic beasts is just proof that authors should be legally prevented from touching their own works after the primary work is finished.
>>
>>215477120
Exactly what a coomer would think, and that wasn't Ron. Shit endgame built on lies is shit.
>>
>>215477169
>and that wasn't Ron
Ron was a massive coomer. Remember how he acted around Fleur?
>>
>>215477169
>>215477222
>>215477055
We do have a saying in my country that goes like whoever fights the most actually loves each other
Tsundere type shit
>>
>>215476256
Ginny is unironically one of the prettiest girl in Hogwarts. There's a line where the Slytherin students in Harry's year talk about her in HBP
>“Potter, precious Potter, obviously he wanted a look at ‘the Chosen One,’” sneered Malfoy, “but that Weasley girl! What’s so special about her?”
>“A lot of boys like her,” said Pansy, watching Malfoy out of the corner of her eyes for his reaction. “Even you think she’s good-looking, don’t you, Blaise, and we all know how hard you are to please!”
>>
>>215477222
Didn't that bitch roofie him?
>>
>>215477255
it's boomer bullshit like that which end up having abusive nonsensical families that hate each other
>>
>>215477330
You're thinking about romilda vane
>>
>>215477281
Coalburning garbage
>>
>>215476465
Remember when Rowling was the peak Tumblrite Wokie before Troons all freaked out on her for saying Biological Women exist?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qwS6o9KyuZc
>>
>>215476780
She's just a fence sitter. She supports trans people but are too afraid to speak out against Rowling

>Speaking to The Telegraph in February 2023, Evanna said: 'I think it’s important that J.K. Rowling has been amplifying the voices of de-transitioners' - those who regret changing gender and want to reverse the process.
>She later admitted that she was naive not to expect an online backlash for supporting Rowling and told MailOnline in 2023: ‘It was a big wake-up call,’.
>The author first waded into the trans debate in 2020 when she criticised an article's use of the phrase 'people who menstruate' and then wrote a personal essay defending her opinions on sex and gender.
>Following the controversial tweet, Evanna wrote an impassioned defence of the woman she refers to as a 'mentor', saying: 'I won’t be helping to marginalise trans women and men further'.
>'I think it’s irresponsible to discuss such a delicate topic over Twitter through fragmented thoughts and I wish Jo wouldn’t … That said, as a friend and admirer of Jo I can’t forget what a generous and loving person she is.'
>>
>>215477344
proof for this claim??
>>
>>215476092
She's a bossy, know-it-all girl with an attitude, he's a bumbling dork. They're perfect for each. Plently of couples like that in real life
>>
>>215477255
Depends what kind of fighting, as long as it's playful. Some people who fight just hate each other and would just make broken families.
>>215477340
Yeah boomers are fucked.
>>
>>215477368
>she criticised an article's use of the phrase 'people who menstruate' and then wrote a personal essay defending her opinions on sex and gender.
That wasn't the first, the big first attack on Rowling was when she tweeted
>“Dress however you please. Call yourself whatever you like… But force women out of their jobs for stating that sex is real?"
That literally non-controversial statement in any sane persons eyes basically her sticking her head in a african bee nest.
>>
>>215477387
not a coomer btw just curious
being the popular girl doesn't equate to being fuckin blacked
>>
>>215477399
Dean Thomas was literally tonguing her in one of the books
>>
File: 1760266795213251.jpg (149 KB, 903x1313)
149 KB
149 KB JPG
>>215476092
>>
>>215477397
>sticking her head in a african bee nest
Like Ginny, but in reverse.
>>
>>215476092
also noticeable is the time hermoine spends with the weasley family, like starting from book4, she stays with her family for at most 1 week at the start of the holidays then spends the rest of the time with the weasleys

the only time starting book4 the trio is separated for a longer duration is when hermoine goes home for christmas holidays in book6

you can say almost that she married into the weasley family, her inclusion in the family feels quite natural
>>
>>215477410
Was he black in the book tho? Post proof
>>
>>215477410
Dean Thomas appearance was never described in the books
>>
>>215477426
Ok you are brown, go back to your porn addict discord.
>>
>>215477440
Not as brown as Ginny's first six lays.
>>
>>215477430
>>215477432
It was never described in the UK editions, but in the American versions they explicitly made him black.
>>
>>215477430
>>215477432
*In one of the movies
He was definitely black in those
>>
>>215477459
Anon said books, now you're back tracking. You lose sir.
>>215477453
American version? Not canon.
>>
Americans even raceswap in book translations? damn
>>
>>215477511
The US publishing industry is mad woke, it's almost unreal.
>>
>>215476092
iirc jk originally meant for that to be the case but changed her mind dunno when dunno why
>>
>>215476092
>weirdest most random twist ever

zero twist, not random
her and harry were just friends
this was very clear by the time of the wizard tournament
>>
>>215476092
Harry never really liked Hermione. That was clear once he was forced to hang out with her without Ron. He found her annoying and nagging
>>
>>215477055
If it was real life she would be secretly horny for Draco.
>>
>>215477397
The train of progression has no brakes, and once it passes the line you won't cross you are now on the other side. You are with them.
>>
>>215476585
>>The protagonist ends up with a BLACKED hoe, and this is somehow presented as a happy desirable outcome
She was ready to settle down.
>>
>>215476982
The magical school literally cockblocks the kids in the book
>>
DON'T CALL HER BITCH YOU SCUMBAG
>>
>>215478233
It's a figure of speech bwo chill
>>
>>215478368
aight, my bad cuh
>>
>>215477393
giwtwm (taking orders from the girl)
but if it comes to cuck shit I'd snap and dropkick the bitch
>>
>>215476092
Harry should have ended up with Cho Chang
>>
File: 1740435265535441.jpg (387 KB, 1580x1700)
387 KB
387 KB JPG
Why is Emma so popular with so many men?
>>
>>215476092
I wonder why she made the decision.

Being charitable I do actually agree that Harry and Hermione did not really have that kind of chemistry. I can see Rowling saying to herself "this just isn't happening, there's no spark here".

But her solution was to basically double the problem by creating two couples that have no spark or chemistry. I mean at least Ron and Hermione have a certain opposites attract, tsundere logic to it(which might have worked if she spent more time developing that romance and showing it to the audience instead of just suddenly announcing it happened) but then Ginny is just absolutely fucking nothing. Who the fuck is Ginny? Her whole character was being shy but mostly just not being around.

I think there might be a woman brain worm here of thinking its cute for two guys to become brother in laws, like oh, they were such good friends and now they're family. Radical failure to appreciate how most males would react to their best friend dating their sister. They would not just be a bit peeved.
>>
>>215479564
Harry should have ended with Luna.
Hermione should have ended with Draco.
>>
>>215476092
What "twist"? There is literally zero romantic interaction between Harry and Hermione for the entire book series.
>>
>>215477428
I like the idea that Harry was the third wheel for like the whole series but he's such a narcissist he doesn't notice so it doesn't come across in his POV.

The one fan fiction that might actually be good is just an abridged version of the entire series where you see Harry's friends kinda talking shit about him behind his back, and showing that Ron and Hermione's body language was way different than Harry noticed, like she's constantly grabbing Ron when she gets scared and they keep having these private conversations and clamming up when he shows up. "Did you see that shit where he tried to buy everything in the Trolley? What was that about"
>>
>>215477453
>American versions they explicitly made him black
Just looked it up and JR claims she made him black in the UK version too but it got cut by an editor. He even had a backstory in which his father left the family when he was young.
>>
>>215476092
She wanted them all to end up related so she had to be with Ron while Harry ended with Ginny
>>
>>215476938
well yeah they're in highschool
>>
>>215476092
Alpha fux, Beta bux
>>
>>215479834
ginny actually has a personality in the books
>>
File: 1635002752810.jpg (144 KB, 935x1539)
144 KB
144 KB JPG
crazy how this is still accurate almost a decade later
>>
>>215479608
First waifu
sexy British accent
>>
>>215480232
What's wrong with LotR?
>>
>>215476092
Not really
>>
>>215476092
I always thought it was weird that Naruto and Sakura never ended up together too.
>>
>>215476092
Rowling fucked up and everybody knows it.
Also Harry should have shacked up with Luna.
>>
>>215476092
yeah, she herself said she regretted foring the ron/hermione thing as it didn't feel natural and hermione should have ended with harry
>>
>>215480319
Um I'll have you know the Pink Ranger from Power Rangers was the first waifu.
>>
File: 1760476274487846.jpg (583 KB, 1000x668)
583 KB
583 KB JPG
>This bitch ending up with Ron instead of Harry was the weirdest most random twist ever
>>
Ron was way cooler in the books and definitely could have gotten her.
A whole bunch of Hermione's "girl boss" lines and scenes from the movies were literally Ron's lines in the books.
>>
>>215476156
she had a glow up in Goblet of Fire and became hot
>>
>>215482077
Ron was the best character in the books, funny, awesome, coolest best friend ever. Sad how they turned him into a useless retard in the movies



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.