S3 has been good, but not as funny as s2. I don't get why people complain about s2, it's the most consistently hilarious of the three seasons.S3 has impressive animation, but the jokes are light in some of the episodes, and then other jokes are ones they'd literally make fun of on oneyplays. Why is Alan gay now?
>>216041962I really don't like how they changed Mr. Boss from an enigmatic weirdo to just some dudebro
1 > 2 > 3It's just downhill
season 2 seemed like they run out of ideas
>>216041972his personality is that he's inconsistent and switches personalities every episode
>>216041987The Halloween episodes are getting better Atleast
It has never been funny.
>>216041962The fanbase is quickly becoming Rick and morty tier weird considering how alt right the oneyplays crew is
i gave up in season 2 when it seemed like every joke was just "dude look how wacky and strange this animation is bet you weren't expecting a live action character maybe the next one will be rotoscoped haha"
Lots of the time they're just showing off detailed laborious animation to "impress" the viewer but the story and jokes aren't there to back it up. Show feels like a Williams Street demo reel now
>>216041972>>216041998Mr boss is whatever they need him to be for the plot. They're just doing a lot of "we love current game" like south Park started doing a few years ago
>>216042013S1 was the best Halloween ep, s2 was ok but still funny, s3 was only funny when the witch was talking.>>216042076If you look at Twitter and reddit, OP have always had a strangley large amount of Troon fans, which is strange considering how much they slur, and Dave is basically openly RW.
Yeah 2 > 1 > 3Silly Samuel has to be the worst ep so far, rest of season 3 has been meh-good
>>216042076>alt rightIt’s another “my parasocial buddies believe in everything I do.” Post
>>216041962>why is Alan gayHe was just licking some crumbs off the boss.Nah but in all seriousness why does anyone even care? Alan isn’t really much of a character to begin with. Same with Glep.
>>216042281That’s not evidence they literally are tho
>>216042415>the man Oneyplays himself. Best friends with a gay trannyfucker, tranny that made TADC, Ding Dong and Julian who are a gay coupleI coyld go on, the character designer for Squim is a troon as well. >inb4 y-yeah but just because i vehemently hate trannies doesn’t mean that they can’t be alt right!
>>216042380Because its gross degeneracy
>>216042472Pussy
>>216041962I feel like this show has worn off its novelty. Dropping the full season at once was a great surprise but now they're milking it. I have watched the first 2 episodes of S03 and have torrented the rest.Somehow it's giving me World Peace feelings, I see how it could be great, why people would laugh, but I just don't laugh at/with it. Maybe it's just not made for me.
>>216042447Doesn’t matter I know what they are they use slurs
>>216042472Let me guess, you jerk off every night
>>216041962>I don't get why people complain about s2, it's the most consistently hilariousAnnnd anything you say has no value now.
>>216042046Then why are you here bozo?
>>216042076>alt rightWhat is that, some sort of indie bookstore?
Smiling friends always brings out the seething schizos for some reason.
>>216041962I disagree. Every episode I'm usually at least smiling through it, with at least one moment that makes me laugh out loud. It's been that way for me since season 1. That's pretty good for only 10-12 minutes of runtime.
Hello, I really hope Mr Frog hasn't been written out for good
>>216042606>redditor
>>216042447>tranny that made TADCHaving him on an art show once doesnt make them "best friends"
>>216043238Origionally they said they never wanted any returning side characters. Be glad he got 3 episodes
>>216041962I dunno dude, Glep getting his shit rocked by those kids was a whole season's worth of gigakino.
The halloween episode was great and honestly most of the secondary plots have been better than the main ones. I almost feel like the show would be better if they abandoned the main premise like ATHF did, it’s still one of my favorite shows and the only adult cartoon I’ve enjoyed in years
S2 was shit, 3 is miles better
>>216043777Too far Respect your betters young man
>>216043861>plotfagging thislol
report eceleb threads as off topic
S1 > S3 (so far) > S2I thought that this was the shared opinion
>>216042472And him sucking Charlie's nose and thinking mole man's penis was "delicious" is fine?
>>216043356I should’ve worded that better but they clearly aren’t alt rightAlso Chris is on TADC>inb4 ok you can work with troons and be buddies but you can also be alt right!!Dude get a life, they aren’t and does that make them any less funny or change your opinion on their output? It shouldn’t if you aren’t a parasocial retard
>>216042472>THE TV MADE ME DO IT!!!
>>216044002Huh? I’m saying it would be better if they didn’t have to do the same structure for almost every episode>introduce wacky character>have to make wacky character smileThe Halloween episode was the loosest with it and it was the best. All the b plots that don’t follow the structure have been better
>>216042472Tell me you are a newfag and never seen a sickanimation video in your life
>>216044019I don't share this opinion.2>1>3
>>216044228I can't even see plot
What was his fucking problem? Can we discuss?
>>216042472>its gross degeneracyLmaohttps://youtu.be/WmOUDf8ufbQ?si=eSw1Lv-VhMDKmGDs
>>2160419872 had mostly dogshit episodes tho that pretty much were all built around one gag. Like the aliens that partied, and the Rotten snowman, the demon wife episode
>>216043977Zombie simpsons isn't a better of anything. Even the "bootleg simpsons" are more seen more fondly than that.Seriously, fucking family guy seems to be more closely watched and still spawns memes. Same for American dad.Can't recall last anyone talking about the simpsons without either talking just about the older episodes or the topic being how the fuck it is still alive
The show's great. The proof is that there's no consensus whatsoever about what's actually good or bad about it. Asking which eps are best or worst will get you wildly varying answers from everybody. It's like asking what's the best or worst Tarantino movie. I learned quickly about this show that other people's opinions are meaningless.
>>216043777I was surprised they actually went against the simpsons like this. I feel like every show besides family guy is afraid to criticize it because of the legacy. But this was almost more cutting than family guy’s criticisms or parodies. Saying it’s old and lame and just copying lame trends.
>>216044705Hawk Tuah man!
>>216044705The last time people seriously discussed it was when they did a Death Note parody that was actually pretty good... I think Simpsons should just make like 3-4 Treehouse of Horrors a year because those are the only episodes they put effort in now.
>>216044738It really is just good
>>216044772No they need to keep Simpsons running until I have a kid old enough to watch it with
>>216043385I'd argue Frog isn't a side character because the show was supposed to be his show. He was the first character they came up with. But they definitely have been bringing side characters back regularly anyway, like DJ Spit and Charlie's doctor, so the promise is moot.
>>216044797you can watch old episodes, they cast is rotting away, even ned flanders doesn’t sound right anymore
>>216042046>My entire personality is not liking the things you like.Not counting your mom and people you talk to on reddit/discord, how many close friends do you have?
>>216042472Proof?
>>216044825FuckIf I had my shit together my kid would be 10 right now
>>216044228>introduce wacky character>have to make wacky character smileLiterally the premise of the show.>Wouldn't it be better if Batman didn't have to fight villains and we could just watch him do his laundry or something?I think it's hilarious that someone would complain THIS show is too narratively rigid, wtf lmao
GEDDAUDDA MAH HEHD MEHN
>>216044859Retards keep insisting on wanting the show to be like ATHF for..... Some fucking reason?
>>2160419871 > 3 > 2
>>216044875You have a small head
>>216042076The mole man episode was Zach explicitly telling these types to fuck off and get a life
>>216044764It's only because Simpsons took the first shot with their "Screaming Friends" parody. But I think they only did THAT because they mistakenly thought the "mmm, cooked shrimp" guy was a dig at them to start with.
>>216044859Yes, I’m saying the characters not being forced to do the same plot would be better because the episodes that don’t just do the same structure or are loose with it have been better
>>216041962>Why is Alan gay nowyou are a retard if you think these character grow and have arcs and arent just doing shit thats funny for an episode
>>216044764It was retaliation for the Simpsons taking a cheap lazy swing at themhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jmuGQXwAjFw
TEXT NO TOI REALLY, REALLY DON'T WANT SMORMU.
>>216042076>considering how alt right the oneyplays crew islmao youre retarded have you been under a rock since the middle of sleepycabin 10 fucking years ago?
The fanbase for this show has become a heady mix of >parasocial oneyplays autists that sperg out when you insult their surrogate friends>politics brainrot autists that think the show is left/right-coded and therefore worthy of praise>terminally online autists that clap and shout whenever their favorite internet thing is referencedIts also why you basically hear nothing about this show in the real world, no one normal watches it. Ask your co-workers if they've heard of Smiling Friends tomorrow.
who was Allan cosplaying as?
>>216044972>shows are only good if the unwashed masses discuss them around the watercoolergay. also i dont have a job so joke's on you.
>>216044904That those episodes exist in the first place is proof that whatever you think the problem is doesn't even exist. They're already doing what you're saying they should.
Mr Boss threatening him over the phone was gold.
>>216042586>they use slursdoes that make you alt right? have you worked any manual labor job in your life? bet you havent noticed that regular people have started saying retard and wigger again and shit.
>>216044975It was some character Mole Man had a poster of. Just their generic Sailor Moon character.
>>216044972This girl I worked with at a convenience store loved the show and she'd always quote it. She didn't even know what Oneyplays is and wasn't really into internet culture shit.
>>216042264Mr frogs ep was my least favorite but yeah silly Samuel was mediocre, severely underused Connor o'malley
>>216042076>oneyplays, who are my friends, believe the same as me!!!did you know you literally are this character? can you tell that one funny tomar being murderous joke again? got the whole discord laughing last time, anon
Mr. Boss playing Monkey Ball and having a Steam account is a jump the shark moment.
>>216044972Normies watch because it's on HBO Max.
>>216042472>le degeneracy devs vult mein bröthers!!!!this nigga wouldnt have handled 90s cartoons and cod lobbies lmao
>>216044291>thinking 2 was the best
>>216045036I dunno why but the 3 Weird Willies was my favorite>I'm Weird Willy #1 I'm the alpha of the group>WHAT DO YOU THINK KIDDIES ISN'T HE WEEEEIRD>WHERE DO YOU THINK YOU'RE GOING>Silly Samuel pushes them and they fall dramatically
>>216044764Is it really "going against the simpsons" it's so absurd until pims line is guess
>actually debating the loreI'll never understand you people. I don't even want to.
>>216044851I'm having one next month, cant wait. Been waiting 5 years for this
>>216044972So what?
>>216044851Mine would be in college.Yay, abortion!!sob
>>216045005I’m saying it could be cool if they ditched the premise more because they have this season and it worked. The plot with Mr Boss and Allan with the inspector was way better than the Silly Samuel stuff that felt like just going through the motions
>>216044972You should see what other show's fanbases are like. Hell, is there any thing as a "healthy" fanbases? The word fanatic is right there in the name
>>216045049But he's playing games on his gaming laptop in the pilot...
>>216045003Never said it's popularity was indicative of its quality but that it appeals to a specific type of internet dwelling cretin which hinders it's general appeal. I'd imagine they'd be merching the hell out of the show if they were confident it'd sell
>>216045188>I'm saying it would be cool if they did the thing they're already doingdude
>>216045209Why do you think they're cretins?
>>216045125>lisa with the fascism sign>parodying the screaming friends thing with bart using an ipad>bart saying a dated tiktok meme phraseI’m not saying it’s like South Park attacking Family Guy, but most shows like this never make fun of the simpsons genuinely at all besides family guy. It’s always showing admiration
>>216045209Yeah, normies never use the internet, or obscure websites like YouTube and Twitter
>>216045222You’re retarded
>>216044413What about this jackass
>>216044947YOU VOTED AND WE LISTENEDTHIS CANNOT BE UNDONESMORMU IS HERE TO STAAAAAAAY
>>216042619Because I wasted 30 minutes of my life watching the first 3 episodes.
I have been enjoying this season way more than the previous. The animation gimmicks are all well done and the plots are decent.
>>216045310That’s Chris O’neill
>>216045357I think the tone is more balanced this time around. S2 felt like too much a lot of the time. This one continues the more manic style but paces it out better.
>>216045259He is fat, therefore wrong.
>>216044972>Ask your co-workersIs not a sign of anything. My coworkers are all in their 30s-50s
>>216045125Yes, very clearly. Lisa being an obnoxious activist and how out of place modern stories seem is a direct shot against the writing.
What was the reference in the new episode where Mr. Boss starts like rubbing his arms vigorously and rocking his head forward while making weird sounds?
Season 3 has just been pic related for me. I know the funny thing is happening, but I'm not laughing.
it's pretty good, it's definitely more entertaining than trying to listen to an oneyplays with cory anyway
>>216044972>The fanbase for this show has become a heady mix of>>parasocial oneyplays autists that sperg out when you insult their surrogate friends>>politics brainrot autists that think the show is left/right-coded and therefore worthy of praise>>terminally online autists that clap and shout whenever their favorite internet thing is referenced>Its also why you basically hear nothing about this show in the real world, no one normal watches it. Ask your co-workers if they've heard of Smiling Friends tomorrow.S1 was all good.S2 had 3 good episodes. I wasnt impressed by s3e1, so I didn't bother. The snowman episode from s2 was the first episode i noticed using "realistic dialogue" that's irrelevant to the plot as filler, and it just made me think "why don't i just watch family guy?"I kind of hope smiling friends crashes and burns so Zach still return to OneyPlays again.
>>216045480It’s an autism thing
>>216045608You know before they created family guy nobody on Earth actually could have conversations? Family guy invented that. We’d just grunt and go ooga. Family Guy was basically an irl monolith moment for humanity if you think about it
>>216045480Fake autistic people on tiktok
>>216045608>>216045646Dr Katz and Home Movies are what did the whole super realistic improv dialogue thing first anyway
It’s funny that the new episode tries making fun of the simpsons. Smiling friends will never be as culturally relevant as peak simpsons. Enjoy this slop show enjoyed by the terminally online after it gets cancelled Zach enjoyed by all the people you laugh at on oneyplays.
>>216045688>duuude it was culturally relevant in the 90s maaan Ok? That was almost 40 years ago grandpa
>>216045688Simpsons is super shit now so that point is irrelevant. You can't rest on your laurels forever. It just becomes pathetic at a certain point.
>>216045672Those shows features actual comedians that riffed and improvised good jokes and not just "its funny cuz its le realistic muttering" bullshit. To compare the two is wholly disingenuous
>>216045716>>216045706and it has more staying power than any smiling friends episode. They’re one and done no one rewatches it. Let me know when they make a movie.
>>216045733Why is everyone in this thread so antagonistic?
>>216045775I just want more out of the show. The first season was solid but it seems like theyve used up all the jokes they had and just rely on wacky bullshit intercut with realistic reactions. After 3 seasons its old.
>>216045745Nobody likes the Simpsons anymore. And the movie wasn't really that good.
>>216045745Sneed is the only relevant thing about it anymore.
>>216044847The bible
>>216041972I made this exact comment on a different thread this morning, you plagiarizing faggot
Season two is the best because it has Allan's adventure episode(best episode in the series thus far).
>>216047527cool it changpt
3>1>>>2They've won me back, 3 has been the most consistent and feels the most authentic to the creators' humour which attracted me to the series in the first place. I think it's succeeding because they've clearly abandoned the series concept. Season 2 was odd, there was some good episodes but it felt a lot more like a typical adult swim creation.Only problem with 3 is that they are already starting to overdo bits and rehash earlier jokes.I hope it gets cancelled soon before it gets ugly but that's not going to happen with it's popularity peaking.
>>216042472This, and FUCK them for not loving Israel and Trump
It feels like the hype died after the infamous mr boss & allan cookie scene.
HAWK TUAH, MAN.
>>216048069The iconic boss and Alan cookie scene
Silly Samuel was kinda mid, he wasn't very funny or interesting. I liked the building inspector subplot though.The mr frog episode started off decent, but really went downhill when it tried to be serious with the family drama and inner self peace shit.Mole man was funny and the subplot was nice, the end line of Allan saying the penis looked delicious over shadowed the episodeHalloween episode wasn't really that funny, but the visuals were amazing.The cabin episode was ok, the mother nature plot was a bit underwhelming, and the infamous Allan Mr Boss gay shit broke the internet.Squim was so annoying and unfunny that he nearly made me turn the episode off, Charlie's subplot was mid.
>>216044904Not really though. A lot of season 2’s episodes deviated from the “make someone smile” plot and those were shit. Not because of that or anything, they just weren’t good>Dudebro aliens(literally the only funny moment is the flat earth bit)>Mr. Boss’ demonic wife(literally the only funny moment is leepic Nostalgia Critic reference)>SpamtopiaThe last one I mentioned was just ok.
Season 2 is so much betterGwimbly is the peak of the seriesJimble kinda sucks, but has some good jokesThe allan episode is good, a bit overrated imo, too "lol random" for me.the Boss finds love is kino and just as good as GwimblyBrothers egg is really funny and overlooked.Alien episode starts off good but gets really dumb and unfunny.Spamtopia was decent, the subplot is kinda meh.Rotten the snowman is ok, I love the bill nye joke so much though.
>>216048154Squim is the second best episode.
>>216048154>Halloween episode wasn't really that funnyMr boss choking the witch and then getting ran over by a million cars is probably the hardest I've laughed watching the show.
>>216047954Nah fuck Israel.I don't need the show to be political, I just need it to not be fucking gay
>>216048280Not really convinced by saying most of them are shit or just ok. For season 2 it felt like they built an episode around one funny bit they thought up
>>216048280>Gwimbly is the peak of the seriesAgreedI love spamtopia because it's peak newgrounds/what I grew up with on there.Still love the Alan episode.
>>216045049Yeah, they should have just made him a boomer who likes playing tic tac toe or stick ball. This makes him feel like a surrogate for the audience to project onto.
>>216048379>>216045049Pretty sure they showed him playing vidya in one of the first episodes
>>216048396>>216048379Twas the pilot actually. He was on a gaming laptop with a headset
season 3 has been great
>>216042472nobody show this prude faggot ren and stimpy, he'd faint
>>216042447>crippling e-celeb obsessionKill yourselves.
>>216044413Bosnian homer
>>216045027It's funny the only time I hear people talk about eceleb faggots is on this website.
>>216048514>uses f-slur>is ok with faggotry in his goyslop
>>216048621the through-line is that both are funny
the red one's voice actor's voice is so fucking stupid and annoying it makes me hate the whole show
>>216042085Season 3 is that but 10x worse for it. I don't mind season 3 but it's really starting to bother me now. I'm all for supporting up and coming animators but every guest animator pushes their work way too hard like their life depends on it (I guess it does, it's their big break). It pulls me out of the story.
>>216041987>>216044884Season 3 is actual my favorite season so far. Mole ManSilly SamCampingHawk tuah episodes were all great.
>>216048696I’d rather have this than shitty rigged puppet animations that have been the thing for over a decade now thanks to R&M and laziness in general. Jesus Christ I couldn’t even watch the new season of KOTH because every character’s movement was so stilted >Character says something, strikes a pose>they are stuck on that pose until they say something else to strike another pose
The Boss cussing out Charlie after seeing him logged onto Steam has been my favorite part so far
>>216045310Literally a caricature of Chris
>>216043777Why are the Simpsons green?
3 > 1 > 2all r great tho
>>216049035First 3 epsiodes were dud for me but Halloween, Camping, and Return of Squim were great, better than season 2 episodes.
>>216041962GWIM RETURNS > MOLE MAN >>> MR. FROG REDUX > SILLY SAMUAL > CABIN MOTHER NATURE > PSYCHO PIM Genuinelly a bad season aside from Gwim, Gwim fucking sent me bro>>216041987This.
>>216042076>alt rightwhat are you talking about schizooneyplays have exactly the same audience as Jerma, which is socially awkward teenagers who watch internet videos and draw furry porn instead of socializing in school. MAYBE they have a little drop of oldfag newgrounds people compared to Jerma.
It’s my favorite season so far
>>216043977>>216044764smiling friends' legacy is internet animation and newgrounds, they have nothing to share or do with simpsons and almost everything in smiling friends is in one way or another a reference to that - simpsons writers don't understand it, so their joke was out of touch and was fairly called out by zach and michael
1>3>2 so far
>>216043777Don’t have a hawk tuah, man
>>216049273I didn't even know this joke existed until Smiling Friends brought attention to it. That's how much no one fucking cares about the Simpsons anymore
>>216043777Holy fucking based, fucking Liza, fuck Simpsons and fuck Matt Groening
>>216049273>Screaming FriendsBased Simpsons calling out smiling friends for what it is. That eight second clip proves they understand the core essence of its humor and perfectly encapsulated the mindset of the average fan.It was also done in good fun, whereas Zach and co fired back as petty one-upmanship. In fact they will continue to rag on The Simpsons in the future as they have so far, like a little puppy barking to get attention, while The Simpsons will never stoop so low as to reference SF again.
>>216049540Modern Simpsons can't sink any lower, no one watches it except for zoomer brownoids
>>216049273Classic simpsons not even trying to match up with what they're trying to mock.
>>216049674i think you mean millennial brownoids, no one gen z gives a fuck about simpsons
>>216049674Boomers who still pay for cable you mean
>>216044738>bestpilot>worstaliens
1 > 2 = 3Best seasonal episodes are pilot, Brother's Egg and Mole Man.
>>216049835you know its on Hulu right
BLART! WHAT THE DEVIL ARE YOU DOING ON THAT CONFOUNDED COMPUTER TABLET DEVICE?
The scientist walking out the door with the parasite going >you are so FUCKED, you have no idea how fucked you aremade me lol
>>216051334or not scientist, doctor or whatever
>le front facing charlieyes we get it zach his nose looks like a smiley face. you can stop now
>>216051313Simpsons unironically btfo by this one.
