[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 20251209_143644.jpg (861 KB, 1920x820)
861 KB
861 KB JPG
>Aragorn Will Be Recast in 'Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum' (EXCLUSIVE) - (via @KnightEdgeMedia)

>Today, we at Knight Edge Media have learned exclusively that the character of Aragorn will be recast with a younger actor in the upcoming Lord of the Rings spin-off film, The Hunt for Gollum

Who should be cast as Aragorn?
>>
>>216494173
maybe aaron taylor johnson
>>
>>216494173
Idris Elba
>>
>>216494173
Paul Dano
>>
>>216494173
A heckin' black trans woman, I honestly hold these opinions and am not just desperate for (you)s
>>
>>216494359
Dude stfu fag
>>
>>216494253
Too short
>>216494324
Too old
>>216494333
No juice
>>
>>216494173
Aragorn didn't even know Gollum existed. Not in the books, not in the movies.
>>
>>216494173
great
they will cast zendaya and she will be the lost daughter of Arathorn and true heir of gondor or some shit like that.
>>
Why didn't Viggo return?
>>
File: kino out of ten.jpg (42 KB, 554x554)
42 KB
42 KB JPG
>>216494173
>>
>>216494439
older than gandalf
>>
File: 2156534488.png (2.57 MB, 1792x1344)
2.57 MB
2.57 MB PNG
>>216494173
>Who should be cast as Aragorn?
None other than Viggo Mortensen (using additional de-ageing).
>>
>>216494432
>eyo we was Numenoreans and shiiiiiet, Isildur was really an orc
>>
>>216494518
They tried that with Indiana Jones. The problem is a 60 year old man sounds very different from a 25 year old man and the human ear notices right away
>>
>>216494630
Old people move like old people.
>>
>>216494518
there is an story about aragorn as king elessar in his last days ruling gondor.
they could show him telling the stories about the war of the ring to his grandchildren or whatever.
but its not going to happen.
>>
>>216494485
Damn, you're right. Viggo is older now than Ian was when they filmed LOTR.
>>
>>216494630
Yeah, voicing may be the main issue with it. What >>216494658 pointed out is also valid (see The Irishman), yet most of it can be mitigated with body-doubles.
The de-aging itself may also take relatively less effort, not only due to newer techniques - compared with previously attempt like in Rogue One - but also since at the time of the LOTR all main actors did lifecasts of their faces, preserving how they'd looked. Viggo's voice would be a challenge though.
>>
>>216494173
>The Hunt for Gollum
But we already know they won't find him.
Wait did anyone even tried to find him to begin with? Iirc only Bilbo met him and no one cared until Frodo crossed his path.
>>
>>216494173
why the fuck are they making shit about fucking Gallom

I cannot express my thorough disinterest for this character into words
>>
>>216494173
>let's turn the short children's novel into an epic CGI slop trilogy
>let's not adapt Tolkien's writings, but instead some fanfic nonsense with diversity quotas and ugly british actors as elves
>what should we do next? Oh yes, let's turn Aragorn's one line about hunting Gollum into a three hour blockbuster
Whoever is in charge of this IP needs to be shot into outer space
>>
Steve from stranger things
>>
>>216494173

Because that always works great.
>>
>>216494173
They already did a Gollum video game and it sucked monkey ass
>>
>>216495679
Obi Wan.
>>
>>216495534
>>let's not adapt Tolkien's writings
Exactly. Lets not. Just think of what could be
>The Teleri, a tribe of dark skinned fishermen, wronged by white supremacist mad man, Feanor and his MMEGA cult
>Luthien, a heckin’ smart and strong woman who dunks on Morgoth (there is no Beren in the adaptation)
>Elrond: The Early Years - three hours of homoerotic tension between him and Glorfindel
Confining Hollywood to only making fanfiction is the best outcome because it doesnt bastardize anything Tolkien actually wrote and normal people can safely dismiss it.
>>
>>216495977
>Elrond: The Early Years - three hours of homoerotic tension between him and Glorfindel
Am I an irredeemable letterboxdfag if this actually piqued my interest?
>>
>>216495976

Han Solo.
>>
>>216494173
Ke Huy Quan
>>
>>216495381
Gandalf tried to find Gollum.
>>
File: IMG_1427.jpg (338 KB, 651x540)
338 KB
338 KB JPG
>>216494173
>>216494518
wait wtf the original cast isn’t in this? not interested, dropped
>>
File: ozNCDjnT61B7zgm7.gif (3.77 MB, 600x338)
3.77 MB
3.77 MB GIF
>>216495534
Yes, exactly. Death of the author.
>>
>>216496491
Everyone is in except Virgo.
>>
>>216494518
He doesn't want to be in it, that's why they're recasting him
>>
>>216497152
Based. He knows it's shit after the Hobbit disaster.
>>
>>216496979
Cool. It's been a while since we got some Christopher Lee kino
>>
File: 1761130082785447.jpg (92 KB, 736x736)
92 KB
92 KB JPG
>>216497188
Everyone liked the Hobbit movies except contrarians in the internet. They did 900m each for a reason.
>>
>>216494413
Nice try, but you fail.
>>
>>216497247
Don't care. They are objectively bad.
>>
>>216495534
>let's turn Aragorn's one line about hunting Gollum into a three hour blockbuster
I read somewhere that this could be multiple movies, there is some sort of war going on and they are going to cover that too.
>>
>>216495977
>there is no Beren in the adaptation
kek
>>
>>216495483
easiest member berries since he's CG, everyone else in the cast looks too old now to play the same character
>>
>>216496979
????????? Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa???????
What the FUCK is that faggot doing??????????
>>
>>216497247
Not really. Me and my dad watched the first one and hated it, never even bothered with the others. Everyone I knew hated it too. Maybe if you were in middle school they liked it but adults knew it was shit.
>>
>>216497247
the reason is they were still coasting off the sterling reputation of the LotR trilogy
>>
>>216497220
kek
>>
Goddamn they sure want to milk dry that franchise
>>
>>216494173
>>216494518
>>216497706

LMAO I read this as “Aragorn will be racist” my bad
>>
>>216497706
Mostly directing movies now
>>
>>216495483
Agreed gollum is annoying. Hopefully he's barely in it because they can't find him. If he just shows up for one or two encounters like in the hobbit that would be ideal
>>
File: 1739132572058498.png (55 KB, 265x370)
55 KB
55 KB PNG
>>216494324
Pretty sure they were originally intending to use a black but changed their minds now that its obvious no one is paying to see that kind of shit anymore.
>>
>>216497621
The first one was pretty good except for some bad dwarf depictions. It had the adventurous feeling of the book. The second one was stretched to make a third and that's why it sucked after that.
>>
>>216494173
Clearly a perfect role to launch John Boyega's big comeback.
>>
>>216494333
Worst actor in SAG btw
>>
>>216494173
The only good Tolkien adaptation is Fellowship of the Ring. This will suck like most of the others. Christopher Tolkien was right about literally everything and the Jackson franchise is spiritually vapid and cynical Hollywood action movies for 14 year old boys
>>
>>216499186
The Hobbit 1977 is pretty good for a made-for-tv Rankin Bass film
>>
File: 1763511165595206.png (232 KB, 692x523)
232 KB
232 KB PNG
>Gollum game flops so horribly it's delisted and is likely to be lost media
>Why not make a movie too?
>>
they keep milking it huh
>>
>>216499467
I like the animated LotR in part because it's only the first two books but mostly for the rotoscoping kino
>>
File: 1677501182140371.png (1.29 MB, 747x885)
1.29 MB
1.29 MB PNG
W E
>>
>>216495381
The internet says Gandalf asked Aragorn to look for gollum and that they knew gollum was following the fellowship, but I don’t see where that’s written down anywhere.
>>
>>216499186
The 1981 BBC radio adaptation was quite good
>>
>>216494395
No, this isn't your safe space cunt.
>>
>>216496929
>Death of the author.
The clarion cry of the midwit.
>>
>when Gollum finds the ring again and he starts flossing while repeating "Oppa Gollum Style"
>>
>>216495483
gollum is the emotional heart of LOTR and easily the most well-rendered character in the books. He's empathetic because of how well Tolkien understood Grendel and he poured a lot of that into the character. He's the bridge that keeps everything from being black and white, good vs. evil.
It comes across in LOTR, but only because of Tolkien's sensitivity as a writer. It'll be a mess working from an original script.
>>
>>216501444
Maybe if Amazon was making it but I think Peter Jackson is.
>>
>>216502263
Lol at best Jackson will have a producing credit. Hes not directing anything but documentaries anymore
>>
>>216494333
Austin Butler would be better
>>
>>216494173
Stuart Townsend
>>
File: really.jpg (69 KB, 286x290)
69 KB
69 KB JPG
>>216494173
Really scraping the bottom of the barrel aren't they? Making a whole film out of Aragorn tracking down Gollum. Something that was barely expounded on even in the book.
>>
>>216494173
This shit is going to flop so hard
Even normies are angry that this even exists
>>
>>216494173
BLACKEST
BANTUEST
BIG LIPPED
SPEARCHUCKING
RED LIPPED
APE-LIKE
>>
>>216494173
Elliot Page.
>>
>>216494173
Literally any black guy will do
>>
>>216499944
>aragorn is a nog
>arwen is still white

Kek
>>
>>216500582
Very good. I just finished the audiobooks of them (get a library card Anons!).
>>
>>216494333
Classic
>>
>>216494173
A Black Tranny to honor Tolkien
>>
Doesn't it make more sense to make stories from the Silmarillion? Or maybe children of Hurin.

Or is there a rights issue? Who leads the Tolkien estate these days?
>>
File: 731cchxy69ha1.jpg (29 KB, 672x541)
29 KB
29 KB JPG
>>216494173
Stuart Townsend. It's time to redeem himself.
>>
>>216504651
Nobody has the rights to adapt the Silmarillion or CoH.
>>
>>216494173
Lizzo
>>
>>216494173
FUCK
>>
>>216494173
This movie could be cools as a sort of high fantasy Jeremiah Johnson but you just know they'll fuck it up.
>>
>>216499607
They have two other movies planned after this.
>>
>>216494173
>Some utter garbage that will have nothing to do with Tolkien's actual work and will at best be marginally superior to the Rings of Power which isn't hard to pull off at all
>Also Aragorn will probably be black
Oh. I can't wait...
>>
>>216497621
The M4 book edit is good. It's the only way I watch The Hobbit now
The intermission is a shit idea and I've seen plenty of people agreeing online. He reworked the edit last year and still kept the fucking intermission, and I don't understand his attachment to it.
>>
>>216494413
Actually, Gandalf mentions Aragorn searching for Gollum in the books.
Too bad it's one line and they're making an entire movie of it.
>>
>>216506432
I've seen the Maple Books edit and liked it.
>>
>>216506462
He doesn't even find Gollum until he gives up and starts his (almost 10 year) journey back which he then runs into him randomly, captures him and hands him off to Legolas (Gollum escapes shortly after)
For the movie they have to fill that entire 10 years or condense it and god knows how they'll fuck it. Maybe Aragon will run into some female elf woman warrior. Or make friends with an Orc. Or who knows what other stupid shit they'll shove in.
>>
Who will play Aragorn's female cousin that constantly saves his ass in every situation and provides him with the inspiration for his speech in Return of the King?
>>
>>216504840
kek
>>
>>216506432
>M4 book edit
Yeah that makes it watchable. The last act with the battle of the five armies is still trash though. No editing can fix that.
>>
File: 1765292559468752.jpg (158 KB, 1080x985)
158 KB
158 KB JPG
>>216494333
>>
>>216506733
Not even the Maple Films edit could fix that. Battle is unsalvageable film. Even Peter Jackson knew it before he made it.
>>
>Wasn't into LotR at the time
>The Hobbit comes out
>Eventually go and see one in the cinema
>It's The Battle of Five Armies
>Three hours of a giant, pointless fight between various dudes in armor
I regret going to it so much. I missed out on the amazing experience of seeing the original trilogy on the big screen but got subjected to THAT instead.
>>
File: IMG_4489.jpg (494 KB, 750x911)
494 KB
494 KB JPG
Ok if Viggo isn’t in that kind of sucks but what about all the other side-jackasses like the guy from LOST? Are they in? What do they look like these days if Viggo is too haggard to reprise his role?
>>
Please be black
I want to see the world fucking burn
>>
>>216506578
>>216508421
Peter Jackson is making this, they’re probably going to get a vaguely similar guy to pretend to be Aragorn. It will be Hobbit tier at worst, it’s not going to be some creepy AI-written kikefest like Amazon.
>>
wtf is this shit? who asked for this shit?
>>
>>216508454
Yeah, being The Hobbit tier is the best we can hope for. It'll be a stain on the franchise, but not the spit in the face of Tolkien that Rings of Power was.
>>
>>216494173
A black man, just like Snape
>>
>>216494173
hopefully they find someone who can sell a coherent tax policy
>>
>>216494518
He wouldn't do it, he's got to much artistic integrity.
>>216498016
Same.
>>
>>216494173
I had assumed they were already shooting. Christ it takes forever for these retards to make things these days.
>>
>>216494173
I'm mad as all hell they're doing this.
It won't have a scrap of Tolkien's DNA in there, so it's going to be hacks trying to ape his style, which will never work, especially in our current climate. I get why they're doing it - LotR was that one trilogy that did almost everything right and people love it for a reason, so of course they want to recapture that magic. But it won't work, and it's stupid to even try.
Heh, captcha was NGG0R.
>>
>>216494413
Retard

>>216506462
>one line
Actually, Gandalf goes into a good amount of detail about it.
>>
>>216499999
The story is told by Gandalf at the council of Elrond.
>>
it's going to be anal juice
>>
>>216494173
They're going to replace him with a nigger.
>>
I wish they'd leave the franchise alone. Just make lego sets of LOTR and leave it alone.
>>
>>216508891
>Actually, Gandalf goes into a good amount of detail about it.
Fair point, but not enough detail that we can get a whole movie about it.
>>
>>216494173
Aragorn is an 87 year old man during the time when these events happen.
>>
>>216494173
some gay nigger
>>
>>216494173
Daniel Day-Lewis. He will de-age himself because he's just that committed to the role. Another easy Oscar!
>>
>>216508970
Tolkien hated racist shits like you btw
>>
>>216509186
Yeah and he lived to be 210 so he's not even middle aged.
>>
>>216509270
But not as much as he hated darkies. Proof? They are all evil, base creatures in his works.
>>
>>216509270
Actually he didnt
>>
>>216494173
Leo Suter, I'd guess.
>>
>>216509326
But how will they make Aragorn lose his shirt for every scene?
>>
>>216509296
>>216509313

The only romance is his book is about two characters with two different races.
Tolkien hated any kind of prejudice.
>>
>>216509407
Elves are just nordics, ie. better and more pure than the other whites.
>>
>>216509407
The world you created inside your head isnt real
>>
>>216497247
Strange definition of "everyone" you have there.
>>
>>216509353
If there's a will, there's a way. BTW, i heard that this guy is going to be the new Bond and i called bull but he looks completely different clean shaven so it could work. only in 2025 would a tall English chad like him be relegated to a BBC detective show as his most recent work.
>>
>>216495483
Andy Serkis is very easy to work with
>>
File: 1752016900311623.png (1.59 MB, 1280x853)
1.59 MB
1.59 MB PNG
This casting was the definition of perfection and it will never be topped by any film ever again.
>>
>>216509418
They are still different races.
>>
>>216509493
Imagine it was made today
>Timothée Chalamet as Frodo
>Zendaya as Arwen
>Anya Taylor-Joy as Lady Galadriel
>The Rock as Gimli
>Pedro Pascal with a fake beard as Gandalf
>BTS as "Elves"
>>
>>216509493
Where's the dwarf guy
>>
>>216509711
far left
>>
>>216509493
Yeah, even if we live to see things getting better, even if a more skilled director gets the project, a remake of the original trilogy will never live up to what we got.
Every single actor was perfect for their role, and clearly gave a massive shit about doing the work justice.
>>
>>216497247
The first one was ok, but the others sucked balls, and the high framerate horseshit made everything look extra fake.
>>
>>216494333
>autistic screaming
he'd actually be a good Gollum
>>
>>216508395
Apparently at least Serkis (duh), McKellen, Wood, Bean and Bloom are in.
>>
Gollum is by far the worst thing about the Lord of the Rings movies. Andy Serkis fucking sucks
>>
>>216510312
That's a bit harsh, but I must admit the audible version of the book is pretty bad. Serkis is great but he can't sing for shit and some of the voices he does is terrible. I will always compare his Tom Bombadil to those episodes of Keeping Up Appearances where Hyacinth sings at Emmett, who clearly fucking hates it.
>>
>>216510312
He's alright, but he was overused for "remember the hobbits are still doing their thing!" scenes in between the actual fun action stuff and epic speeches in Rohan and Gondor.
>>
File: 1759083295235.jpg (199 KB, 936x774)
199 KB
199 KB JPG
this guy? Obviously dyeing his hair
>>
>>216494432
Hopefully they rewrite the story and have Sauron replace all elves and white men and show how the last ones are degraded and raped before they're thrown into Mount Doom.
>>
>>216510660
He's old now and looks like shit, swedes in general age terribly.
>>
>>216494173
I thought it said aragorn will be racist in Lord of the Rings lol
>>
>>216495381
>Gandalf, during the 17 years he was researching the Ring and doing other stuff, caught Gollum, interrogated him, and then let him go
>Gollum is then captured by Mordor, tortured in Barad-Dur by Sauron himself, where he gives up the names "Shire, Baggins," then is released
>Learning of this, Gandalf hires Aragorn to hunt Gollum, who finds him and hands him over to the elves of Mirkwood
>Sauron attacks Mirkwood as a feint so Gollum can escape

This is basically the entirety of the story as told in the book, and the movie doesn't even really mention any of it besides briefly showing Gollum being tortured. Hackson and Serkis want to stretch this out into a 3 hour movie lol
>>
>>216495260
They should use the same mo-cap from Gollum to to both Gandalf and Aragorn, that would not only keep the same actors but also make Gollum look less fake.

This is gonna be a disaster anyway, just like >>216495483
>>
File: hes-surely-not-gay.jpg (291 KB, 828x1224)
291 KB
291 KB JPG
>>216495977
>Elrond: The Early Years - three hours of homoerotic tension between him and Glorfindel
Ngl this sounds like kino
>>
>>216494173
Damn, they're really going to scrape the arse out of this barrel aren't they?
>>
>>216511243
why did sauron want gollum to escape mirkwood?
>>
>>216511622
They fucked
>>
>>216494630
They have voice de-aging too, but they didn't use it with Indy for whatever reason
>>
>>216494173
It will definitely do as good as the Gollum video game!
>>
>>216508970
Why do they always give them white people hair?
>>
>>216509493

Gimli is actually the tallest. Never noticed he was tall in the Sliders show, just remembered him as the physics nerd.
>>
>>216494173
Jazz from I am Jazz.
>>
>>216509493
>LotR is the ultimate manlet fantasy

We bow to no one
>>
>>216511880
>Never noticed he was tall in the Sliders show
How, he was the largest of the cast by far.
>>
File: 1738671038282.jpg (31 KB, 478x640)
31 KB
31 KB JPG
>>216494173
Scott eastwood
>>
>>216494439
He's like 80 years old now
>>
>>216509270
you will go to hell for speaking ill of the dead, let alone twisting their words and work for your own benefit
>>
Chris Hemsworth boom
>>
>>216511622
Sauron had no direct leads on the location of the Ring after Frodo left the Shire. Gollum is a wild card that would never give up his hunt for the Ring, so Sauron believed that Gollum being loose would eventually lead him to it. He had no compulsions sending a few hundred orcs into a suicide mission just on the offhand chance Gollum could aid him in finding the Ring
>>
>>216512160
Very handsome but unfortunately a charisma black hole. He should stick to rom-coms
>>
>>216509647
>The Rock as Gimli
it would have to be dinklage or he'd shut the production down
>>
>>216494518

They can still use Viggo as an older, maybe close to his death Elessar and he thinks back when he was on the hunt for Gollum.
>>
>>216494173
Obviously Timothee
>>
>>216509647
>Anya Taylor-Joy as Lady Galadriel
lol no, Florence Pig
>>
File: file.png (481 KB, 498x702)
481 KB
481 KB PNG
>>216514836
I love that cute little piggy like you wouldn't believe.
>>
File: edit_1765112805945.jpg (231 KB, 1600x2097)
231 KB
231 KB JPG
>>216494173
me, with no doubt
>>
>>216514954
>Easterling soldier #37
>>
>>216494173
bad decision, viggo would bring a billy for them at least now its joever.
>>
>>216515044
thanks god at least ain't orc
>>
shan't be watching this slop, i bet they won't even use forced perspective
>>
File: img_2_1765225477427.jpg (342 KB, 1080x1004)
342 KB
342 KB JPG
>>216494253
Kickass was his first and only good movie and even then he was an annoying little bitch in it. Fuck off.
>>
>>216494253
fuck no. stop.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.