[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1675316878822950.jpg (17 KB, 256x256)
17 KB
17 KB JPG
>tries to educate his audience on the dangers of war and authoritarianism
>accidentally raises an generation of authoritarian bootlickers by framing one as the all important "Chosen One" of his saga
Oops.
>>
Ah, yes. The space fantasy series known for its educational purposes.
You're mentally unwell, Ranjesh.
>>
File: 1751650795304569.jpg (217 KB, 1284x1350)
217 KB
217 KB JPG
>>217136805
>The space fantasy series known for its educational purposes
Yes.
>>
>>217136780
>makes pulpy sci-fi action-adventure movies
>lightly inspired by some real world events in history and contemporary politics at the time to get the story moving
>"these movies are for kids really"
>generations of insufferable retarded leftist consoomers wont shut the fuck up about how this is trans rights Antifa fuck drumpf propaganda
Please shut the fuck up please shut the fuck up. None of you even watched the movies, they are silly adventure movies with puppets and singing frogs and shit. Its really not at all that serious.
>>
i remember in one of the behind-the-scenes featurettes (honestly better than the films themselves, LotR style) he gives that whole
>nobody who is evil THINKS they're evil...
explanation.

i get it, and in-universe you could ask any of the baddies 'are you evil?' and they'd say 'no'. even when they're talking about 'the dark side' and 'unlimited power', they still believe they're the ones doing the right thing.

but really, the problem is that he has a noble-enough intention (saving Padmé) when it's also in a black-and-white fantasy world with objectively-evil dark magic. feels like the two don't mix. what if a Grey Jedi Demi-Sith used a Dark Side Power (lightning = bad, healing = good) to save innocent lives?
>>
>>217136868
And also >>217136836
>>
>>217136868
sufferable people don't use the word insufferable
>>
File: Poetics.jpg (57 KB, 647x1000)
57 KB
57 KB JPG
>>217136868
>None of you even watched the movies, they are silly adventure movies with puppets and singing frogs and shit. Its really not at all that serious.

congratulations, it went over your head. Lucas successfully combined Spectacle with Drama, Comedy, AND Satyr play. it's the filmic equivalent of a catchy pop song with complex melodies and profound lyrics.
>>
>>217136926
>Star Wars
>profound
In what universe are poop jokes and fart jokes profound
>>
>>217137011
And that's the problem with the prequels; Lucas made so many soulless and cash-grabby decisions, any/all message(s) he tried to tell were ultimately muddied.
>>
>>217136836
>Were inspired by, it means it's a documentary
Mentally unwell. Go take some ritalin, or whatever herbal remedy they sell in your country.
>>
>>217136805
>>217137141
see >>217136926
>>
>>217136780
Why he sold to disney. I wish he would make movies about Mara Jade
>>
File: Lucas_EU.jpg (76 KB, 1070x602)
76 KB
76 KB JPG
>>217137206
>>
>>217137269
Then why he created Ahsoka and Mara Jade?
>>
>>217136780
>dangers of war and authoritarianism
Why did he make war look cool then? George is kinda naive
>>
>>217137289
He did NOT create Mara Jade. Who told you he did?
>>
>>217137313
I think I saw a video about that. That he was consulting both Filoni and Zahn on their projects.
>>
File: Fucked.jpg (49 KB, 400x616)
49 KB
49 KB JPG
>>217136780
I still can’t get over the fact that broccoli heads love the prequels.
>>
>>217137312
>>217136868
>"these movies are for kids really"
t-b-f, he never was able to keep HIS OWN STORY straight.
>https://youtu.be/07wYdqUM1Hw
>>
File: iq.jpg (19 KB, 679x357)
19 KB
19 KB JPG
>>217136805
>>217136836
>>217136868
>>217136926
Very easily explained...
>>
>>217136780
I hate his hair that starts halfway down his fucking forehead, and I hate his cunty little beard that's only there to try and give him a discernible jawline.
>>
>>217136879
>nobody who is evil THINKS they're evil...
How can you say this and have Palpatine as your main villain
>>
>>217136805
Fantasy and sci fi are fables based around the author's thoughts about the world and the values they want to impart on the world. It's no different from ancient legends. Otherwise no one would care since they'd have literally nothing to do with anything.
>>
>>217137821
it's actually based as fuck that he was the cackling, evil guy underneath, and the morally-dubious, manipulative politician was the veneer.

all you people pretending 'shades of grey' stories are for mature, intelligent adults and good vs evil is fairytale children's stuff: Lucas CAN write the characters/stories you want, because he did. maybe Sheev once campaigned AGAINST a pro abortion bill, despite his Dark Side faith, in order to win over the popular vote in that system. at the end of the day, he still goes home to a castle made of skulls.
>>
>>217136879
>the behind-the-scenes featurettes
I hate the prequels with every fiber of my being, but this is what makes them fascinating. The BTS footage is an extensive up close and personal look at the process of a creative making a project that is, for better or worse, true to his vision. You see everything, the good and the bad and the nonsensical. We’d never get that kind of thing for any Disney project.
>>
>>217137915
something has gone deeply wrong if you can't even care DESPITE an author's worldview.

i like Harlan Ellison's stories, he was a crotchety old bastard and i doubt i'd agree with him on most issues. even as fiction, there's some of 'him' in there, so it's not as simple as 'separate the art from the artist'.

that said, they're really good stories. both as escapist fluff about robots, and allegories on whatever real-world issue was bothering him that week.
>>
>>217137364
Lucas famously dislikes Mara Jade, which got memed into him hating her (which George played along with in that sketch where he screams at Seth Green just for bringing her up).
>Zahn
George never collaborated with him, but he did like Zahn’s work, and used some of the elements of his stories (Coruscant, clone soldiers) when making the prequels. For a while, the official line from Lucasfilm was that the Thrawn trilogy was for all intents and purposes, the unofficial sequel trilogy.
>Filoni
This one is true. Filoni was as close to an equal partner that post-OT George ever permitted, and they worked together closely when running TCW.
>>
File: Behindthemagic.jpg (148 KB, 500x485)
148 KB
148 KB JPG
>>217138225
>You see everything, the good and the bad and the nonsensical. We’d never get that kind of thing for any Disney project.

it would be all sycophantic and positive now. even when you're starting from the premise '[franchise] is magical and important, this is for the fans!', the fans WANT to see the highs and the lows. we all know movie-making is a messy business. it's infantilising to pretend it was all wonderful and lovely and everyone was happy :-)))
(see also: any time Disney makes anything about Walt Disney)
>>
>>217138267
The intent is to impart values and worldviews, which is educational. Whether you agree or disagree with them is another topic. Star wars was clearly a simplistic model of Lucas's ideas about our own world in which militaristic authority are bad nazis and any form of resistance is moral and good. It's a shitty retarded narrative yet it was created to be educational. And it worked on a lot of people in conjunction with many other such narratives that came before and after star wars. Most Americans still believe that any imposition of authority is bad and people who fight back are automatically good.
>>
>>217137747
You can say a lot about george, but his hair is glorious
>>
>>217138351
i disagree, because i think they're clearly modelled after fairytales which are intentionally simplistic. in Star Wars you could have the Great and Wise King of Prosperia IV, even though we might think hereditary monarchies are bad.
(i wonder if Lucas actually got cold feet about this specific issue, Attack of the Clones goes out of its way to tell you Naboo's queens are elected and Padmé kept winning the elections, the fuck?)

>Most Americans still believe that any imposition of authority is bad and people who fight back are automatically good.
definitely, and sometimes this comes up in American media and it took me a while to realise how commonplace this belief is over there. they're not anarchists or something, they just view ANY state involvement as somehow a bad thing, the best state is an invisible one that does nothing.
but in Star Wars, it's made clear the Empire are actually evil. the scrappy rebels are Robin Hood and his Merry Men battling against the wicked Sheriff of Nottingham. they're not just inherently correct because the Empire has power/authority.
>>
>>217138351
>>217138505
It just makes you wonder then, how so many of these fans - even the ones who actually liked the prequels - ended up siding with authoritarianism (ie. Nick Fuentes and the like).
>>
>>217138505
TPM was already an anti-Republican/anti-big business in politics story, with the Trade Federation being lead by Newt Gingrich/Nute Gunray. AOTC was the first prequel created post-9/11, and so George decided to fully lean into the prequels political messaging, with a strong shift into an anti-Bush/anti-War on Terror story. For a story about a warmongering authoritarian enabling the crumbling of democracy, you can’t have one of your main good guys be a hereditary monarch.
>>
>>217138637
>a warmongering authoritarian enabling the crumbling of democracy
HINT HINT
>>
>>217136780
I know man, these retards and their boomer parents are out worshipping Maduro right now trying to get him released even though Venezuelan citizens are happy - how fucking brainwashed can you get. Yes Kings, Yes Tyrants, Yes Fentanyl.
>>
>>217138691
You're not fooling anyone anymore, Mr. Singh
>>
>>217138691
What happened to "America First" and "No More Wars"? Hmm?
>>
>>217137011
Everyone poops.
>>
File: S_Xvlj0Umpo.png (2.1 MB, 1680x1294)
2.1 MB
2.1 MB PNG
>>217138637
>>217138689
>>217136887
>>217136926
>>217138691
>democracy
>>
>>217136805
What makes you think you can’t learn anything from a movie, Rian?
>>
>>217138691
I swear to Christ it’s like we’ve time traveled back to 2003. Yes, Maduro was a piece of shit dictator who had it coming. So was Saddam. Yes, “running” Venezuela for an indeterminate amount of time is retarded. So was occupying Iraq.
>>
>>217138691
>>217138921
Except this time, there is no national emergency for OUR PoS dictator to use as an excuse to throw away countless lives and dollars beyond "MORE OIL".
>>
File: Spoiler Image (713 KB, 858x684)
713 KB
713 KB PNG
>>217136780
>>217136805
>>217136836
How does it feel to know that you failed to detect the real "St. Nicholas" in George's soap opera targeted at 12 year olds about Santa Claus' origin story?
Star Wars is a critique of Dune.
The Massassi as an outcrop of the Sith is George's portrayal of the Massylii as foreign allies of the Scythians.
The "Dark Jedi" are the Jews that happened to have Scythian origins and/or ideals.
Yes, you are in fact a lazy retard. And that is not George's fault.
>>
>>217138916
what have you learned from a movie
>>
>>217136780
Authoritarianism is good, actually
>>
>>217136780
Star Wars was Lucas’ answer to 70s bleakness. It was an optimistic throwback to his childhood serials from simpler and more optimistic times, with clearly defined good guys and bad guys, and evil is defeated in spectacular fashion by the end.

>The dangers of war

If anything, it says that war is sometimes the only solution to problems that are too big to vote your way out of.
>>
>>217137289
>licensing.
star wars was slapped on a bunch of shit between 83-99. some good, most bad. It kept the brand alive and allowed george to pick and choose from it when he did prequil shit. Like video game force powers
>>
>>217139284
83-99 is a fascinating period due to all the ways the EU contradicts what George would later establish in the prequels, married Jedi being the big one.
>>
>>217136780
>tries to educate his audience on the dangers of war and authoritarianism
Is that what you think he was doing?
>>
>>217136805
zoomers are mad at this post lol
>>
>>217136780
Yeah i have no idea how white guys could suck off Clinton, Obama and Biden like that.
>>
>>217139537
see >>217138731
>>
>>217139284
>>217139495
Lucassharts always brush off prequel criticism with "iT jUsT wAsN't WhAt YoU wAnTeD" when it was clear from 83-99 what the generally accepted details among fans and authors alike were just from watching the movies themselves and picking up on key details.
>>
>>217137367
You will never slay as much gash as prequel lovers. Stay mad
>>
>>217139688
Any gash who likes the prequels is one bad day away from castrating you in the dead of night because her Hayden Christensen body pillow commanded her to do it.
>>
>>217139141
>Authoritarianism is good, actually. No, I will not bother to defend my claim.
>>
>>217139657
Nah man, Empire would be so much better if Yoda told Luke to braid his hair into a stupid fucking rat tail.
>>
>>217139537
Your Dear Leader sucked off Clinton. What do you think that says?
>>
>>217139516
yes
>>217136887
>>
>>217138691
>>217139537
t.
>>
File: 1765657642988654.png (535 KB, 821x605)
535 KB
535 KB PNG
>>
>>217140931
>filename
>hidonist
>>
>>217141317
Sue me for being ONE letter off.
Also, >>217136887
>>
>>217141305
they are movies
they teach you nothing to begin with
holy fuck you reddit basedboys are such faggots

did the faggot propaganda teach you faggot propaganda shit? hell no, fucking die faggots
>>
>>217136780
I mean once you disregard the OT on its own and look at the entire 6-film saga while keeping in mind that there is no such thing as 'good guys', only elites and counter-elites, then the Empire doesn't sound too bad.
>>
>>217141605
>they are movies
>they teach you nothing to begin with

noooo we need movies and pop stars to teach boys 'positive male role models' because apparently we can't distinguish from fiction and reality any more...?
>>
>>217141681
see >>217136879
>>
>>217141681
>>217143014
also >>217138148
>>
>>217141605
see >>217137915 and >>217136926
>>
>>217141305
Why did they have the guy from SoM rather than Julie Andrews? HTF am I supposed to know who that is? Looks like the guy from It's a Wonderful Life.
>>
>>217143327
Don't forget >>217138637
>>
>>217136805
Star Wars is the Neon Genesis Evangelion of the west in regards to this, even fans should recognize the idea of pulp fiction ever being "educational" on purpose rather than as a byproduct as laughable.
>>217136868
This.
>>
>>217136879
Cringe redditisms
>>
>>217143529
>>217143327
>>
>>217143596
>>217143355
>>
File: 1745616931209399.jpg (48 KB, 527x582)
48 KB
48 KB JPG
>>
File: IMG_1581.jpg (397 KB, 3200x1680)
397 KB
397 KB JPG
Reminder that Lucas was the one who betrayed you first. It doesn’t matter of you believe he’s brilliant. You may think Kennedy and Johnson and Abrams are evil monsters, you may blame the shills and the shitty fan community. In the end, it was George who stabbed you in the back.
>>
Watch the plinkett reviews
>>
>>217136780
>"Fight against oppressive tyrants!"
>Ok I will!
>NO WAIT! NOT WHEN WE'RE THE TYRANTS! STOP IT CHUD!
>>
>>217144403
Did Barack or Joe impose economy-killing tariffs or invade another country for resources without provocation? Were either of them on Epstein's list? Hmm?
>>
>>217138911
>My allegiance is to the republic, TO DEMOCRACY!
>NO, NOT LIKE THAT! DAS IST RASISMUS!
>>
File: average -pol- poster.jpg (62 KB, 640x480)
62 KB
62 KB JPG
>>217144403
>>217144656
t.
>>
File: 1586783683283.jpg (64 KB, 800x600)
64 KB
64 KB JPG
This board is too proud and hard hearted to ever admit that they were wrong and apologize to George.
>>
>>217144782
see >>217144321
>>
>>217144782
uncs think they're on the team and think they can negotiate something lmao
>>
File: 1757114789454113.png (187 KB, 474x377)
187 KB
187 KB PNG
>>217144782
>The Mouse hardened the heart of Anon king of /tv/, and he shitposted the people of Lucas while the people of Lucas were going out defiantly
>>
>>217144782
No I'm not!
>>
>>217144954
/tv/ has no king.
>>
>>217144656
You will never be white.
>>
File: 381WSZ0.gif (1.87 MB, 500x281)
1.87 MB
1.87 MB GIF
>>217144522
>>
>>217144403
https://youtu.be/7ma8HFUE5nA
>>
>>217144522
>You have to defend Trump or else
Why?
>>
>>217145196
>>
>>217145251
>>217144772
>>217144522
Immediate seething and Trump spamming. Pozzers cannot take responsibility for their own political actions, their oppression, their hatred, their murders, their violence. The moment you start talking about their sins they pull up "what about Drumpf??" card. Can you even exist without your enemies? Pathetic.
>>
>>217145354
Discord troons have been spazzing ever since that favela monkey got snatched up.
>>
File: 1743538851705446.jpg (67 KB, 1024x761)
67 KB
67 KB JPG
>>217145354
Your emperor has no clothes. Sorry not sorry.
>>
>>217145354
>>217145387
>WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHH STOP SAYING MEAN THINGS ABOUT DEAR LEADER!!!!
Free speech, bitch.
>>
>>217145387
>>217145415
>>217145479
3 bots in a row. I hate Trump and I'm not even American. What's your defence now? Gonna go straight to denial?
>>
>>217145513
>anyone who hates Trump is a bot
Are you including yourself?
>>
>>217145513
>I'm not even American
then who cares what your opinion of the burger president is kek
>>
>>217145573
>>217145562
you derailing conversation from political murders and violent censorship committed by progressive left using your favorite boogie man
>>
>>217144522
> economy-killing tariffs
That’s subjective
>foreign policy
Barack leveled multiple civilian targets including hospitals and Joe fucked up the afghan withdrawal
>Epstein list
You mean the thing you didn’t care about until the media told you to last year? He was never at the island.
>>
>>217145642
There was no "conversation from political murders and violent censorship committed by progressive left" dumbass!
>>
>>217145705
>That’s subjective
No. No, it isn't. Of course, you'd know that if you actually lived here, Rajesh.
>He was never at the island
Then why did hold off on releasing the list for so long? Why was he always so panic-y whenever it was brought up? Hmm?
>>
>>217145705
>>217145354
https://youtu.be/4ur2kQIdykg
https://youtu.be/8orOvNaKcJE
>>
bump
>>
File: Peace President.gif (123 KB, 400x225)
123 KB
123 KB GIF
And now the orange fag is talking about invading even more countries.
>>
>>217136836
>suddenly makes claim in 2019, nearly 40 years after the movies actually came out
Weird how it took him this long to reveal such an amazing Truth Bomb. Totally doesn't reek of revisionist bullshit!
>>
>>217148785
He's been saying it for 20+ years.
>>
>>217145415
>screeching tranny drivel
Lol, don't care.
>>
>>217148838
>WAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHH YOU MUST LOVE DEAR LEADER OR YOU'RE AUTOMATICALLY A TRANNY!!!
>>
>>217148910
You ARE a tranny though. Nobody else is THIS obsessive and whiny over Trump in 2026.
>>
File: muh all art.jpg (59 KB, 711x630)
59 KB
59 KB JPG
>>217136836
>>
>>217144522
>economy-killing tariffs
Joe "killed the exonomy" WITHOUT Tariffs, kek!
>>
>>217148826
Oh, so more than 20 years after the movie was made & came out? Completely different then!
>>
>>217136780
Millenials think Anakin is a badass because they grew with Clone Wars.
>>
>>217145251
Advertise your political slop on YouTube elsewhere, faggot.
>>
>>217144403
Lmao look at the non-replies to this.
You really struck a nerve with the trannies.
>>
>>217148990
>Nobody else is THIS obsessive and whiny over Trump in 2026
Why? Not at all the first time Americans have hated their own president for being a total fuckup. If anything, still bitching about Biden like >>217149060, now THAT is pathetic.
>>
>>217141317
He cannot spell hedonist lmao
>>
>troons derailed ANOTHER thread into screeching about Trump
Why are they so obsessed? Why do they think EVERYONE wants to hear their constant, low-IQ bitching?
>>
>>217149149
See: >>217149169
>>
>>217149169
Why do YOU think everyone should love and defend that orange faggot? Why do you think it's only trannies who hate him?
>>
>>217144522
>IMMEDIATELY brings yo Trump out of nowhere
Lol why are trannies so predictable and fat?
>>
>>217149227
See: >>217148838
Nobody cares about your shrieking schizo-drivel, tranny. Get used to it.
>>
>>217149192
obsessed
>>
File: Mannequin Skywalker.jpg (71 KB, 2100x1178)
71 KB
71 KB JPG
>>217149089
>Millenials
Zoomers you mean. Millennials are the ones who saw Anakin for the faggot he is.
>>
It was bold when he showed 15 years of Bolshevist subversion, street battles and attempted coups against the Weimar Republic. Directed and funded by Stalin's Komintern. All while the guy massacred his own people. Known in Europe but covered up by the the NYTimes et al.
No, wait. They'd rather cut out their tongues than tell the whole story.
>>
OP here. To all the retards screeching about "MUH TRANNIES DERAILED THE THREAD WITH DRUMPF", this thread was obviously made with Drumpf and his dickriders in mind. Not my fault it flew over your shit brains, just like George's obvious messaging.
>>
File: 1767629743261357.png (15 KB, 1040x891)
15 KB
15 KB PNG
>>217149414
You're not OP.
>>
>but it's not authoritarian when my side does it!!

Lmao these trannies wanted to force people to kneel for blm and take away their kids if you don't let them mutilate their genitals. They're just mad because now they're the ones losing
>>
>>217149592
You can stop hiding behind "THE CHILDREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEN" now.
>>
>>217145300
But that literally is the point. Leftards, who literally did the same thing prior, are trying to sweep all the things they caused under the rug while screeching about Trump because they want to get back into power
>>
>>217149587
Proof?
>>
>>217149630
>17 year and 364 day olds are children
>>
>>217149656
Give me proof that you are OP first.
>>
>>217139128
Never shoot a man before throwing him out of a plane.
>>
>>217144522
The left is objectively worse
>>
>>217149060
>>217149644
I'm sorry that you thought "bringing down inflation" actually meant "lowering prices".
>>
>>217149717
and how well did that work out for him. shooting the fucker would of worked
>>
>>217149749
>it is in your interests to outsource your jobs to other countries and let the entire third world just walk into your country whenever they feel like it to take all the jobs left
>>
>>217149788
I mean, Trump has gone on record of approving H1 visas.
>>
>>217149808
>making high skilled immigrants pay to enter your country is the same as just letting the horde just walk in
>>
>>217149689
Well, how was this post NOT made with MAGAts in mind?
>>
>>217149689
Not that anon, but come tf on. It's literally the same "George Lucas is a Leftist! He said so in this interview! Trust me bruh!" thread. He's OP. End of story.
>>
>>217149847
>no you see it's ok to replace our jobs as long as you give the government money they will then send to Israel
>>
File: E632oDTVUAIIJ9c.png (472 KB, 694x409)
472 KB
472 KB PNG
>>217149847
>just letting the horde just walk in
Yes, that is literally the point of the poem etched on Lady Liberty.
>>
>>217149414
Don't bother talking sense to turd world bots.
>>
>>217136780
Star Wars and its consequences have been a disaster for the modern western world
>>
File: 1658718252450038.webm (2.79 MB, 1280x720)
2.79 MB
2.79 MB WEBM
>>217136780
>bootlickers
For people who spend all day screeching about media literacy you guys sure lack a grasp of irony.
>>
>>217150118
Excellent point. Palestine should let those poor jews in!



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.