Was this a good combat scene?
No. The Matrix one where Agent Smith gets throated over and over by Neo is better.
it was cool in 2000
>>218192440They made a whole video game just for this scene
>>218192440No
Ultra kino
I mean one dude taking on like ten is always gonna be ridiculous but does it look believable? Yeah, there are only a couple of moments where I think the gang would have acted differently, but then you go on /gif/ rekt and fight threads and see trained boxers in street brawls doing similar shit, keeping distance, making sure no-one gets behind him etc, so yeah, a trained and disciplined fighter probably can handle ten retards that don't know how to fight as long as he doesn't get swarmed.A fighter can 1v1 ten consecutive dyels and normies.A fighter can't 1v10
>>218192440https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NnESWtnURrQ
>>218192875the issue is that he learned to fight just by watching tv for 10 years
>>218192959Yeah I know, that's retarded, but he moves like a fairly decent boxer so suspension of disbelief etc
repeatedly watching it you can see the mistakes.choreographing 30 guys for one fight scene is basically impossible though, and doing everything in a single take even more so. Hollywood sucks because they would have used about 900 jump cuts for the entire scene, so I give the gooks massive credit.so yes, it's a very good fight scene.
>>218192959It's a manga adaptation....
>>218192440Uh yeah. Thanks for reminding me of it actually it's missing from my "great fight scenes" playlist on youtube. Spike Lee's remake version is fucking awful though.
Its horrendous chink slop.Its frustrating that people actually think it's even remotely realistic.
>>218192440the goodest
>>218192875I've seen a guy do it and i know there are other people who canpolska gurom
>>218192440My favorite one by far, even with the little mistakes towards the end.
>>218192440i can never watch these asian fight scenes without paying attention to the guys standing on the sidelines while the protag "heroically and epically" fights them all one at a time when they could just all rush him and end it in 3 seconds.
Pure unadulterated kino
>>218192440The quieter music does a good job of drawing focus onto the scene. It's oddly calm for a fight scene and the impressiveness comes more from how long he manages to stay fighting. I love films where the protagonist takes as much abuse as he deals out. Overall It strikes a good balance between entertainment and realism for me. Obviously it's exaggerated and upon rewatch you can see a couple moments where the thugs don't capitalize on openings.>>218195585It's slightly more justifiable here since it's in such a narrow hallway. Only two or three guys can face him at a time.
>>218192468
>>218192959This is what you have a problem with in the movie with mind control hypnosis
>>218192875>>218193534>>218195692nah it's a shit scene. there are guys constantly standing around watching other guys fight and you can see them pulling their punches/hesitating to swing their weapons even when the protag isn't facing them and he's busy fighting someone on the other side. and when the protag pushes one guy they all fall back with him like they're fucking cascading dominoes lmao.it's laughably and comically bad.
>>218195737>>218195755>>218195765which kinos
>>218195774Meals on WheelsPolice Story
>>218192440We having a fight scene thread? Cool what about this one? Should I hate it? Too many cuts?https://youtu.be/n3L8UVTe6Ak?si=klS-gX0i1ko2Y9jn
>>218192440This is absolutely dogshit. The gooks are an embarrassing pretentious race of lowlifes. The Chinese are way beyond those freaks when it comes to combat scenes and cinema in general
>>218195761>>218195845take your meds
>>218195787>The candelabraEvery fucking time man. It's so fucking cool.
>>218195737>>218195755>>218195765Overchoreographed crap, what makes OP cool is grounded it is. You don't see the best in the world fighting like that in real life... Actually, they'd kick the ass of a guy fighting like that.
Wanna talk "uncoordinated" fight scenes? This is my favorite.https://youtu.be/0kqn9qQZdOs?si=Qm2hrRvJq_s0J645
>>218195906>He knows nothing about the legitimacy of Benny "The Jet" Urquidez https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZgGTP5Cevrs
>>218195906>what makes OP coolBut it isn’t cool, you’re just a teenage gay male
>>218195585>>218195761>Why are they standing back?Because they're afraid, retard. These kinds of scenes only work in cases where the baddies are cowardly/intimidated
>>218192959He was also straight up punching solid concrete for ten years. That combined with his iron will is something unbreakable
>>218192440It looks cool when you're focussed on the action, but it's really fucking stupid when you watch the guys standing 4-5 feet away just doing fucking nothing
Can't pan the Chan
>>218192440>Was this a good combat scene?Yes. It accurately portrays upper-body strength of average asian male.
>>218195906OP is overchoreographed and not grounded. It's worse because it's so obviously choreographed yet trying to be gritty and real and doing the one-take thing. It becomes less authentic, not more, because it's pretending it's not stylized when it is. Jackie fights are obviously stylized, rhythmic, and audience-pleasing foremost and no one is expected to believe that's how fights go down in real life.
>>218192440yea it looks great.i like the remake too.
>>218192959Read a book and join a Tae Kwon Do class.>>218198134It's a movie. You do not punch a wall in real life because you can break your hands.
>>218192440There's probably an argument to be made that it's the best one ever filmed.
>>218192440No this is a good combat scene.
>>218192697was just thinking about sifu
>>218200570I need an edit of American Psycho where this happens after the ATM demands to be fed a stray cat
>>218200570this is my favorite so-bad-its-good movie
>>218200570
>>218200872Gun Kata bing silly but trucking cool and the story being almost 1:1 Fahrenheit 451 does help a lot
>>218198050Unless you have a knife or a bladed weapon you're gonna get dogpiled. Niggers have perfected this ancient strategy yet the supposedly intelligent oriental cannot figure it out.
I liked the training montage more but yhe hallway was innovative. The remake was so by the numbers that it had to be some money laundering scam. Poor lizzie.
>>218200897Where did the writer get their maths
>>218195755Both Benny and Jackie decided during shooting this scene to not pull punches and just see who could take more. Great fight scene.
>>218192440At the time it was
>>218195761>and when the protag pushes one guy they all fall back with him like they're fucking cascading dominoes lmao.Because theyre standing in a narrow hallway
>>218195702This fucking hurts IRL
>>218192440I have gook fatigue.
>>218192440Anyone watching action movies and analysing the realism needs to get their checked because you're a fucking moron. You want realism? Go watch street fights or police bodycams on YouTube.
>>218202983fpbp
>>218192440no it's pretty gay and shit like this has been gay since the early 00's
As sooas you start looking at anyone in particular you start thinking>why is he doing that? Why would he do that?
>>218192959You can just do that
It's fucking shit, one stab with one of those sticks and he's down
>>218192440Usually not one against 50.
>>218202061AI
>>218202983This. It needs to believable, not realistic
>>218192440
>>218192959We can assume he at least had some military experience given that service in korea is mandatory
>>218192440yeah, it's great
>>218192440No.
I always liked this fight from Jack Reacher.
You want a good fight scene? I'll give you a good fight scene.
>>218207667kino
>>218207691
>>218207700>it's the comic relief episode
>>218207891The ending was pretty crazy. I forget if it revealed that Xena is actually Ares daughter or not.
>>218195906Hate zoomers like you wouldnt believe.
I liked the musical episode.
>>218192959you can just do things
>>218192959I've been watching tv for even longer than that I could fuck him up.
>>218200558Not bad, not bad at all.
>>218202983I can't watch street fights or body cam videos on YouTube, I can't watch YouTube on my laptop because the internet can't work during a power outage.
