>several lines are spoken that were never spoken in the books>characters look completely different from their book counterpart>several scenes take place that never happened in the booksAnd all of this can be seen from just the teaser. Yet, people and anons still claim that the reason this garbage is being made is to make it more "book accurate", what a fucking lie.
>>218942151Hogwarts Legacy proved people want more out of the Wizarding world that what JK shat out 30 years ago
>>218942222because she was a shit writer and never expanded on it. the world she created is insane. you could spend days just considering the implications of the inventory of Weasley's Wizarding Wheezes
>>218942151Somehow, even this had more soul.
>>218942151make ten more threads reeing about it. they’ll surely change it.
No anon you missed the memo we actually like it because trannys hate it. keep up!
>>218942593The wizarding world undergoing its own industrial revolution would be prime kino material but no one is capable or willing to explore such routes. They just want to rehash the same generic plot structure, just like Star Wars.
>>218943006Hogwarts Legacy explored it a bit. The goblins were rising up against the wizards because their tech started to rival magic and they were tired of being second class citizens
>>218942593I just tell myself the wizards have illogical brains. Industrialized magic simply cannot work because magic is powered by quirk chungus
>>218942151In regards to harry potter, “book accuracy” means “hermione is brown.”
This is why most authors don't explore magic systems and their implications. The few I've seen:>Terry Pratchett intentionally focused on the absurdities, to emphasise the danger of magic>Tolkien made Arda so that magic was fading and was once much stronger in the world>Ursula le Guinn linked magic directly to language, and the True-Names of things, which can change with time and different parts of the world.JK Rowliing probably should have read Pratchett and le Guinn, before constructing a world heavily dependent on 'say word, make whoosh things happen'. Without restrictions, the Time-Turner alone should have up-ended everything that happened after book 3, and they gave it to Hermoine just to have more classes(with the side-effect of her ageing faster relative to her class-mates).
>>218943735It was a children's book her husband wrote, it's unironically not that serious anon.
>>218942151It was never suppose to be “book accurate”The only ones calling “book accurate” were literal Shills and SJWs doing damage control for the DEI Potter show.One of the people working on the show openly said that they didn’t read the books
>>218942222Hogwarts Legacy was fotm trash.>>218942593You can have fun spending days in your autistic headcanon, that's never what Harry Potter was about. You seriously think the books would have been better if Rowling had spent chapters autistically explaining the inner workings of spells or some shit?
>>218943735The time turner is a borderline nuke, it's a monkey's paw. Hermione was smart enough to understand this. They didn't use it to stop Voldemort because even messing with time going back a few days can have implications that are impossible to predict, let alone going back decades. For instance, the time turner creating the self-fulfilling loop that was the entire climax of Prisoner of Azkaban, they created a bootstrap paradox. That was just going back days. It basically was not an option. Or you could just headcanon that the horcruxes can create immortality that even defies past events being changed, Dragon Ball Super logic.
>>218945847Call it trash or whatever else you want, most players disagreed and it broke a 14 year streak of either a CoD or a Rockstar title being the top selling game of the year. It showed there is strong demand for more of the HP universe, all these years later
