>here's your guild navigator brogood god denis is such a fucking PUSSY, zero risks taken
>>219090693I honestly don't mind the sarcophagus despite being very, very critical of DUNC. Although we should have the hint of a human inside, like eyes and shape of face obscured by the gas. The tomb and plugging into a heighlinger like we saw in the trailer is something I dig.Nonetheless, the movies have a shitty memecast, the music is pretty fucking poor because Zimmer is a hack, and there is an astounding lack of attention to detail and ethos that seems to encourage boringness everywhere - the sandworms, the fucking worms, are boring in DUNC
>>219090693Hollywood loves "realistic" fantasy
>>219090780the most unforgivable part for me is how fucking beige arrakis is. we got one cool orange part at the start of part 2 and that's it
>>219090863I agree, or the fact it doesn't actually feel hot. We see plenty of scenes of Atreides at Arrakeen without stillsuit and it doesn't FEEL hot at all - no sense that prolonged exposure to the desert without stillsuits will be very fucking bad for Paul or Jessica (and of course the stillsuits themselves are disgustingly shit) or the totally boring lighting of le final battle in DUNC 2. Not sunrise or sunset? Not even saving the eclipse for then?
>>219090780>Although we should have the hint of a human inside, like eyes and shape of face obscured by the gas. The tomb and plugging into a heighlinger like we saw in the trailer is something I dig.Will also add, this sacrophagus Edric? I imagine when he's executed it's you break the 'glass' as gas leaves the container and you essentially pull a shrivelled, mummy-like human with the Eye of Ibad from it. Denis the frog needs to give us more than simply the sarcophagus floating around, so I should say my forebearance with nu-Navigators is also linked to my own imagination
>>219090926I guess Mr. House's true body in New Vegas isn't far off when I am thinking.
STFU you faggot
>>219091001>copies Avatar
>>219091001i actually really like the moviesi just think denis is a pussy and plays it too safe
>>219090693every Denis movie is like thisits the most bland shit in the world, there's no spice, no characterDenis is like the opposite of an auteurhow the fuck do you get to direct Dune and make the most bland shit in the world
>>219091001The DUNC movies needed someone for James Cameron to make the world feel believable. So far pretty much only the spice harvesters have any thought put into them. This shot feels like it's just a bunch of cosplayers standing around because Denis doesn't give a shit, but James is a world builder and would have made it feel like a real team with proper tech and prep for a mission.
>>219091088sicario is his best work desu
>>219090693>zero risks taken>>219091088i think he knows deep down and thats why he's not going to make any more after 3 which is essentially Messiah, and he's said that he's>leaving the door openbecause he doesnt want to try putting Leto on screen
>>219090926>>219090995Based. Powerful as fuck in some way but physically frail is a trope I love.
>>219091125I suggested Peter Weir due to M&C showing he's good a autistic attention to detail and large casts with authentic feeling dialogue
>>219091088>there's no spiceHe had one fucking job.
>>219091001Why aren't they looking for wormsign from a thopter? Fucking retarded.
>>219090926>>219090995>>219090863DUNC 3 Hayt is also boring. His eyes aren't offputting at all and have a separation of iris, pupil, and whites and if there is one character who is going to be close to bald/lacking in hair, ought to be the newly grown Duncan ghola.But Denis Duncan is a waste, to be honest. Oscar Isaac would have been much more fitting for the role than Momoa and more to the point, his death was such Hollywood slop. The death of Uncas from The Last of the Mohicans would have been my inspiration for the death of a man outnumbered by Sardaukar
>>219092233Technically Gholas should have metal eyes.
>>219091125Yeah my thoughts exactlyAll of DUNC looks like someone just fed Dune prompts in to an AI for the concept art and then sent that sloppa straight to the prop and CGI teams with no further comment.
>>219090893Totally agreed. I hate the DUNC stilsuits and feel like they misunderstood the whole idea. They thought "oh they just wear some weird outfit. Toss some rubber scraps together and call it good". They don't get how fucking extremely hot it is and how they're conserving every ounce of moisture. And to go with that, they don't make it appear hot either.
>>219092323That's what I am getting at, should have had a metallic look throughout, no or barely perceptible pupil-iris-whites division
>>219092473I almost suspect it's for the bitter, it would be so much worse if the stillsuits, the worms, the score, etc. were all 10/10 but we still had to put up with a shitty memecast consisting of jokers like Chalamet, Zendaya, Momoa, etc. Better to have unambigious contempt vs. such mixed feelings
>>219090693also why are the trees behind them so small? looks like they were just brought there from a shop
>>219092562Possible this is Arrakis in the process of terraforming, so the trees would all be fairly new
>>219092593doesn't that happen with paul's son worm emperor? or does paul start it
>>219092660Paul starts it I believe, but I don't think he makes a whole lot of progress during his time. Mainly just Arrakeen.
>>219092660>>219092789Paul starts itThat's in the plot of Dune Messiah; there are already plenty of fremen pining for the good old days when Arrakis was a murderous shithole where you had to murder people for the water in their body.
>>219090693It reflects the ongoing decline of Canada
Dune is such a shitshow of a book. Jodorowsky is right that the story should be raped and turned into something else entirely. Meanwhile Villeuneve is like "oh this is totally serious and cool so we are not going to give them nothing and they fill in with imagination"
>>219090693More like penis villeneuve
>>219090693that's not a guild navigator tho
>>219091001seeing this in a theatre while very high and having just finished the book was a ride
>>219091001>2 hour long movie>only the first 5 minutes are good
>>219094236SAY THAT TO HIS FACE NOT ONLINE
>>219091182Sucarui was his last top tier movie. Everything else has been bad (Arrival) to mid (BR2049) to merely decent (DUNC 1&2)
>>219090780It should be a giant glass box with a midwit fishman rolling around in cloud of gas popping pills whenever he gets nervous or btfo by the other conspirators.
>>219095229I know. I'm only saying I dig the take of a sarcophagus with a Mr. House-esque shrivelled up mummified human inside. I do give DUNC credit when it is due, it's only very rarely that I do that because it leaves so much to be desired
>>219094236penis vanillanova
>>219090693you are just mad because you are upset
>>219094349Is it or is it not.
>>219097393what IS a guild navigator really? can we really say? or is it just a social construct we made up to put people into groups? is anyone really can be a guild navigator? maybe we all guild navigators if you think about it.
>>219090693DV claims to be a fan of 2001, but his promo tells you exactly what to think while 2001 led you to asking the big questions.
yeah he's very decent technical director, but unimaginative. Any director with a hint of aesthetics would never have cast that ugly nigger in the first place. His pragmatism gets the job done but is boring
this board is just /v/ for movies now. everything is just low quality bait
>>219097867>wahh someone disagreed with me
>>219097477I identify as a Guild Navigator.
>>219090780>I honestly don't mind the sarcophagus despitewell you shouldit's jj abrams "mystery box" tier
I love how it triggers you dumb incels
>>219097477Woah maybe the guild navigator was fucking you in the ass this whole time bro!
>>219100274UwU
>>219097867>now
denis navigator is too safelynch's navigator was too much
>>219090693>ugly fish guy who lives in a pod and is used by a corporation for his big brain skillsholy shit, he's LITERALLY me
>>219101213i like this, just make the gases a bit more foggy to cover up the cgi
>>219101213Miniseries was just right?
Reminder that they NEVER addressed why shields are not used in the films, it's just left in the open. No reason is given why lasers are not given to every soldier.
If Penis plays it safe, how come he imagined Sardaukar as crazy methheads being anointed with the blood of their upside-down crucified brethren while grooving to Mongolian throat singing? Checkmate Lunchians.
>>219090693>no Leto II (I)>no psychic spice>stoneburner i just white light silence EEEEEEEEEEE tinnitus bomb>no idea wtf is going in with alia>no guild, ixians, tleilax, mentats, >>219092843I don't think it's totally shit, but Jodorowsky's would've been the adaptation we need. That or Cameron like people said. It's literally just bland desert scenes which completely missed Herbert's idea for the world which came from the fucking PNW
The Spicediver edit of dune (which you can watch below) absolutely mogs dunc https://archive.org/details/dune-1984-alternative-edition-redux-fanedit-mkv-flac-subs
>>219104583looks like my mom's vagina
>>219090926he's canadian, if he was a true frog his dune wouldn't have been so shit
>>219094236Villeneuve been REAL quiet since this post dropped.
>>219101296it remains unsurpassed
