/tv/ - Frank Herbert after seeing Star Wars "Lucas plagiarized Dune" - Television & Film


08/21/20	New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17	New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16	New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]

Anonymous
Frank Herbert after seeing Sta(...) 04/03/26(Fri)07:44:32 No.219279278

File: writer-of-dune-says-star-(...).png (187 KB, 640x492)

187 KB PNG

Frank Herbert after seeing Star Wars "Lucas plagiarized Dune" Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)07:44:32 No.219279278

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)07:45:24 No.219279288

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)07:45:24 No.219279288

>>219279278
To quote Bruce Dickinson, Frank Herbert was a cunt.

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)07:45:34 No.219279291

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)07:45:34 No.219279291

>>219279278
He's right. Star Wars is cultural poison.

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)07:46:28 No.219279304

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)07:46:28 No.219279304

>dude like *hits spice* what if everyone was disingenuous about everything and it was all fake and gay
Bravo Frank.

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)07:46:42 No.219279308

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)07:46:42 No.219279308

>man who only watched dune
>hmm i getting dune vibes from this movie

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)07:49:02 No.219279332

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)07:49:02 No.219279332

>>219279278
Then why didnt he sure Lucas? When you are sure that someone ripped you off, you sue. But if you are just talking shit and have doubts you will win a court case because your arguement is weak....well, that sounds like what happened here.

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)07:52:26 No.219279370

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)07:52:26 No.219279370

File: colonel_te_lawrence.jpg (27 KB, 576x552)

27 KB JPG

>>219279278
>Thomas Lawrence after reading Dune "Herbert plagiarized Seven Pillars of Wisdom"

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)07:53:56 No.219279389

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)07:53:56 No.219279389

File: IMG_2798.jpg (27 KB, 500x370)

27 KB JPG

>>219279278
I was rrrrraping Frank Herbert, raping like this.

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)08:02:07 No.219279507

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)08:02:07 No.219279507

>Some of the action in the book-and in the movie-takes place on a sandy, desolate planet inhabited by nomadic scavengers who are pursued by enormous sand creatures.
>enormous sand creatures
Was there anything like it in Star Wars, especially in the first edition??? Did he just make shit up?

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)08:08:35 No.219279597

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)08:08:35 No.219279597

File: il_fullxfull.6363951505_d6uo.jpg (63 KB, 1039x685)

63 KB JPG

>>219279507

You can see this skeleton

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)08:27:02 No.219279855

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)08:27:02 No.219279855

>>219279597
And where is "pursuing" scene?

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)08:40:58 No.219280028

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)08:40:58 No.219280028

>>219279278
>something gets extremely popular
>has-beens try to sue with no basis
many such cases

you didn't invent deserts, big dog

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)08:45:26 No.219280095

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)08:45:26 No.219280095

>>219280028
In 1977 Herbert was more famous than Lucas

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)08:54:14 No.219280244

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)08:54:14 No.219280244

File: dynch.png (2.03 MB, 2178x1866)

2.03 MB PNG

It's pretty undeniable that Star Wars lifts a bunch of ideas from Dune. The Bene Jedi science-magic antichrist stuff and the emperor that sees the future for instance.

Regarding 'plagiarism' i respect artists like Michael Moorcock who is too antagonistic towards copyright to get his panties in a bunch over the witcher ripping him off.

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)08:59:43 No.219280337

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)08:59:43 No.219280337

>>219279278
More people plagiarized star wars than dune
It's a fact

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)09:00:50 No.219280356

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)09:00:50 No.219280356

>>219280337
And that's a good thing.

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)09:01:30 No.219280366

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)09:01:30 No.219280366

>*tastes sand*
>"It's chicken salt!"

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)09:01:37 No.219280368

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)09:01:37 No.219280368

>>219279278
Frank also ripped off another book while writing Dune.

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)09:03:02 No.219280391

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)09:03:02 No.219280391

>>219279278
Dune page 1:
>The main character opened his eyes. He had a dream where he was a prophet and led the sand people to victory. Actually it wasn't a dream. It was the truth and it is going to happen in the next 1,000 pages. Yes this is how the book ends, there is no tension, I'm literally telling you this kid is going to be the king of sand people and he won't die because he is already having prophetic visions of shit I'm gonna write about in 900 pages time.

truly dogshit author.

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)09:09:47 No.219280502

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)09:09:47 No.219280502

File: GEG.jpg (144 KB, 800x450)

144 KB JPG

>>219279389
GEM

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)09:12:29 No.219280538

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)09:12:29 No.219280538

>>219280368
what book

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)09:33:22 No.219280868

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)09:33:22 No.219280868

>>219280538
Duuune

Anonymous
04/03/26(Fri)09:43:43 No.219281026

Anonymous 04/03/26(Fri)09:43:43 No.219281026

File: 748x1024.jpg (147 KB, 748x1024)

147 KB JPG

>>219280538

Name
Spoiler?	[Spoiler?]
Options
Comment
Verification	4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File	[Spoiler?]
Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.