>winch editionPrevious: >>220089785
Winch it up.
Yet to be refuted.
>>220093384The wife should be Julie with the winch replacing the flower
/wg/ - winch general
Yasmín la Extraña De
I think this winch stuff is the type of thing that could tear this general apart
>>220093498or pull it together
>>220093498I am on team winch fuck team "sorry I got to go"
Okay, what are our bets on the lake of tears?>it's a literal lake in the forest, not far away, that they haven't found yet because they never explore shit>it's a ritual of some design that involves either the monster pit or some other weird place that isn't a lake (yet)>it's a magical portal that jumps in and out of existence>it's something super benign and overlooked (like the lake by colony house)>other
>>220093438Julie literally recoiled in disgust when Randall tried to get closer to her. He missed his shot last season and now she's in love with Sophia
>>220093498Go back from winch you came
>>220093498Hey hey heylook at mepull yourself together
>>220093498That's the best thing that's happened so far.
>>220093555He didn’t have the power of the winch back then
>>220093579>50 days since tabitha arrived
>>220093498All dissenters will have their day of winch
>>220093579what 40 years of winching does to a man
>I hope you like fromcake>*sits on your face*
>>220093555I think she just didn't want the pity act people tend to give to people with lost relatives, which isn't uncommon
>>220093659>Never changes clothes>Bathes in blood on occasion>Runs around the forest all night>Sleep in a hole all day>Eats nothing but raw meat and entrailsImagine the smell~
Do you reckon the monsters are cold to the touch?Like, theoretically, if you held their hand would it be warm or cold?
>>220093696they must have changes of clothes
>>220093720Windowcel said Jasmine's hands were warm
Jim wasn't not a simulation or hallucination. That was time traveler Jim I bet. Watch this explanationhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IYNOMT6_orQ
Do the monsters do literally anything except sleep and slowly walk around town, hoping to find someone to gore?
I wonder if Julie can die when she time travels. Also I don't know if this is anything but the monster that grabbed her didn't know she was time traveling
>>220093754>watch this retarded youtube grifter
>>220093659>Storywalk with a bro that stays out>End up in the forest in the night>Go to female froms and start hitting on them>They play along and let you fuck them, ready to torture and kill you when they’re done>Finish and then immediately bro winches you out>Get it for free without becoming the product
>>220093754Jim is dead though
>>220093754Ain't watching your shit ranjeet
>>220093754>literally an indian guylmao
>>220093754They call it story traveling and not time travel because I don't think you can change a story just weave around it.
This guy explains it betterhttps://youtu.be/ApmQpuYz6tk
>>220093760I always got the impression that they're bored so they go around scaring people. Sometimes killing to spice things up, but they can't kill them all because then they ran out of playthings.
>>220093831Stories are literally the easiest things to change though. I know the writers are just trying to be deep but stories have literally evolved until they barely resemble the original all acroos the real world.
.
>>220093792you goon too close to the sunpretty soon you're thinking the from cheerleader's ahegao is real so next time you bring your bro in with you to spitroast her because you'll just fuck the from into submission and skidaddle but then she reveals she was faking the whole time
>>220093893once a story is set you can't change it. You are thinking about making a new story which is not what I am talking about
>>220093778>Also I don't know if this is anything but the monster that grabbed her didn't know she was time travelingI think that’s significant. It’s still unclear how omniscient the monsters actually areI mean, they know your name and shit like that, they were aware of something Boyd said when during the day when they obviously weren’t around, and they were even able to predict where they should put Jim’s body for the kids to find him. But on the flip side, we know the townspeople used to hide before Boyd found the talismans, so obviously the monsters are either not completely omniscient or were intentionally letting them live. For Julie when one of them saw her, I wonder what the monster thought about her. MIY seemed aware of her storywalking and not really bothered by it, but that monster who assaulted her didn’t seem to realize she came from the future.
>>220093899Move marell down to goblina and move the man in yellow to wifey and you have a list, sir.
>>220093964>MIY seemed aware of her storywalking and not really bothered by itThat's because he's met her storywalking before.>but that monster who assaulted her didn’t seem to realize she came from the future.Why would she know that? Even if the monsters are able to remember and infer information like that, that incident took place on the literal first night Julie was in town so there's no way the monster could've met an earlier version of Julie.
>>220093930>Once a story is setNo such thing. For example take a look at the brothers grimm fairytales
>>220094058Yea people make new versions of them but each version is set
>>220094031No, it’s actually not from S1E01, it’s from S2 when Boyd was trying his "silver bullets"And again the monsters can know stuff Boyd said when they were sleeping or seemingly predict the future to know they will send the kids to where they put Jim’s corpse, they obviously have superhuman knowledge
>>220093899>forgetting best girl
>>220094114Who was she again? Astounding how easy it is to forget stuff from this show
>>220093498
>>220094079So the story is changing? Over time stories evolve, things change. If you want to go down this line of thinking. If I swap out a characters hair color, has the story changed or is it a totally new story?
>>220094152Just a random who got spawn killed. She’s notorious because the monsters left her to die without directly killing her so that humans would find her during the day and see her die
>>220094058hanel and gretel get abandoned by their parents they leave a trail of bread crumbs they walk into the woods and find the ginger bread house...the story is always the same more or less, same with little red riding hood or any other, hell lets take the most popular one right now the fucking snow queen one, you can make all the stupid disney songs you like but the story is what it is. Any attempt to change it fails. sooner or later the fairy tales with always come back to the source. he Only semi original fairy tale disney ever made was lion king, and now that one is set in stone, good luck ever altering the story and making anyone care.
>>220094152>>220094205>not knowing KellyFor shame. I bet you guys don't even remember Brian either
>>220094204>So the story is changing?No because what you are talking about is completely new stories
>>220091214S: Boyd, arab guyA: tebitas husband and randallB: noneC: chink guy and the assburger manF: the one-eyed coon, Boyds mutt son, uhh the rest
Entering the Gerson philosophical debates about storytelling and adaptations ft anons who don’t understand it’s just the show’s way of talking about deterministic time travel arc
You were wrong about stories. It's just that simple.
Winch of Justice
>>220094218Yes things can change while it still remains the same story. Thats exactly my point. The ending to the orinal version of snow white can have a totally different ending to the one we have in the modern day. Stories change, along with the time
>>220094262>no mention of jukebox chadthat is why you fail
Jukebox or Winch?
>>220094378>The ending to the orinal version of snow white can have a totally different ending to the one we have in the modern dayyup that's a completely new story
>>220094393you're talking about the season 5 finale right now, brobetter keep that to yourself
>>220094380It's not a man so no i do not fail. Go fuck yourself retard.
Does this show really make other networks seethe?
>>220094413It really isnt. If I change the color of snow whites eyes is it a new story? To use from as an example, if I change the entire population of fromsville is it the same story? Because thats exactly what happens across each iteration.
>>220094454Yes
>>220094454
>>220094462>It really isntIt is. Once the pen leaves the page the story is set. There is no patching a story to change it. That's creating a totally new story what you are describing
>>220093754There is just a lot of wack ass assumptions that have to be made on top of bad writing for that to be the case though>already established you can't significantly alter events that happen (fate plays a role in this, like Julie being the one to have always thrown the rope down to Boyd) said by both Ethan and MIYJulie for all intents and purposes is an observer. Notice how no one reacts to Julie except Martin (basically a ghost), Jim who was fated to die at that moment so might be an exception, the MIY, and the monster girl. No one in the RV heard Julie yelling even when the walked out of the RV and she was screaming her lungs out, Victor and Tabitha didn't hear her when she was calling out for them in the tunnels. So from what we know, the past cannot be altered in a significant way. That means Julie would not ever be able to alter Jim's actions. We never saw Jim go into the ruins or do any of that shit, we know exactly what he was doing most of the time since he was always busy trying to figure things out. How would Julie have then gone to a past Jim and then taught him how to do this and effectively change the past? How would this version of Jim suddenly know about the "Lake of Tears" in this place as if he had gained knowledge (if the ghost of Abby was really the voice in Sara's head during her outing with Boyd it would at least mean once you die you learn things about this place, that would be the only logical explanation for Jim knowing more than he did when he was alive)?Secondly>Julie is never seen going to the futureI mean maybe they will reveal she can later, but at this moment you have to assume Julie can not only change the past to make Jim into a time traveler like herself, but Jim can then go into the future and has clearly traveled around enough to know things about this place and then travel to meet Ethan. That's just so many leaps in assumptions based on information that contradicts what we know
>>220094454Imagine you're like apple or hbo or disney or some other retard, and you drop several hundred million dollars on a blockbuster event tv show. And to ensure its success, you wine and dine the critics to guarantee a 90%+ score. And then to be super safe you spend millions on paying shills to go market the show across social media.And the result is a tepid reception.And then some low budget mystery box shit that's barely even trying to be good gets much better ratings and organic growth just by being fun. And discussions for that show overshadow your super expensive and important show.Yeah. They spend a lot of time trying to attack these threads.
>>220094501So story is an analogy for time here? Because as I've previously stated, the entire populatipn of fromsville has changed. Does the man in yellow have complete control of time?
>>220094378but it doesn't you can try and tell a new story but it won't stick in the same way trying to change sleeping beauty or snow white or aladdin or any other one of the great fairy tales won't stick. sleeping beauty is cursed as is the kingdom and is woken by the prince. Aladdin gets the lamp, Snow White bites into the poison apple given by the evil stepmom. These are simple facts. You can try and tell new versions of the story but it never works. The story always will revert to the og version. The fairy tales the real ones never really change, which is why I'm giving disney the Lion King, that is a new fairy tale, and in the same fashion it cannot be altered. You can make as many "deconstructions" as you'd like it doesn't work because the story endures. I'm starting to come around on "its all a story" anons, thoery, but just because its a story doesn't make it not real.
>>220094513This is why time travel is dumb. Non stop grand father paradoxes. Does Julie change the past or was the "changed past" what the past was always supposed to be?
>>220094445>are you an idiothttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4wSyfE7ldhs
>>220094547No a story is something that is when it is written it is set. People may read it and say "wow this story is so cool but I wish it had x y z in it" that is now a new story independent of the story that inspired it that is set in stone and unchanged. What you are suggesting is like a parallel world of different From people whose circumstances are different but the current From people we watch are set in their story
>>220094539this, it is fucking hilarious how much this show makes them seethe
>>220094552>was the "changed past" what the past was always supposed to be?I would be okay if they actually foreshadowed it well with large portions of the story in previous seasons having Jim off doing something that no one knew or characters wondering where he is in subtle little moments. But no, he was always around, got a lot of screentime, always had some sort of issue to solve or project to work on or in the hospital. So if this Jim that talked to Ethan was actually a time traveler from the past, then what the fuck was the point of having Ethan mention storywalkers not being able to change events and then MIY confirming it in Ep 1 when he told her to her face that she can't change things?
>>220094595>What you are suggesting is like a parallel world of different From people whose circumstances are different but the current From people we watch are set in their storyKinda like the iteration before, where victor saw his entire town get killed? A different story you say?
>>220094641Counter point. The writing is so garbage in this show that consistency doesn't matter
>>220094378>The ending to the orinal version of snow white can have a totally different endingno it can't not in anyway that anyone would care about, if you alter the story too much then it isn't eh story and no-one cares and it will be forgotten where as the true story will endure
>>220094659It's not an iteration. What part of you can't patch a book once the ink is dry on the paper don't you understand?
anyone else disappointed we'll never find out what was the deal with pastor man?
>>220094666Storywalkers sounds dangerously close to dragon brake, I'm waiting for the writes to simply "fuck it this shit didn't happened" and retcon their own shit in between episodes or seasons.
Ok so I just watched 2 seasons of this.Should I continue? Or is this just another show where none of the writers have any goal in mind and the show will last as long and keep resetting back to status quo as viewership lasts and once it drops they will dump some half hearted finale.Also: is this just time travel or some loop shenanigans?Not particularly hating it but the repetitiveness of the arguing and soap opera style "character walks into scene, time to yell, drama, walk off, back to neutral" is already getting a bit old.
>>220094688What part of "this entire situation has occurred before with an entirely different set of people" dont you.
>>220094737we got khatris entire back story idk what more you'd want
>>220094737He's just chilling at the lake of tears resort and beach
>>220094775see? you don't even fucking know who I'm talking about because he died immediately.
>>220094767these aren't the questions you should be asking
>>220094737Yeah it was kinda fucked. Could MIY not just walked the road into town and then said something like "Oh my car broke down suddenly at the tree so I followed the road back to get some help, there is no cell service!"? I mean considering we've never seen anyone able to get back to the tree and the road just loops right back into town it's not like they would have no reason to believe him. Especially when no one had ever seen monsters in the day time and people would trust a big titted cute girl even without the sob story.
>>220094798What questions should I be asking?
>>220094767I'd recommend watching the rest but I gotta go.
>>220094767Season 5 is already stated to be the finale, this isn't network television where they have to pump out endless garbage anymore. The show is fun, keep watching even just for the memes.
>>220094774It didn't though. That is all part of one single story. Things didn't change the story just continued.
>>220094737>yfw he had an engineering degree and could create all sorts of useful tools if he hadn't died
>>220094829So tabitha and jade arent trapped in a loop of continously returning to try and fail the story?
>>220094767This general has become flooded by idiotic shitposters like you who don't like the show and only watch it because memes.Don't be one of them. If you don't like it, just stop watching it and leave us be. The show is never going to be anything other than what it is. Don't watch it hoping it turns into the Sopranos eventually
>>220094742I think the biggest argument against Jim walking based on what we have seen already is Father Khatri. They already established that hallucinations or whatever he was, is a thing and I doubt he was story walking too just to fuck with Boyd.
>>220094903Yes they are in a loop of a singular story you almost got it. So close.
Post Julie pits
>Ethan is 13>looks like a 9 year oldpoor kid will end up as a turbo manlet
>>220094955Each town they return to is a rerun of the same story. The same pattern of events keep repeating themselves. Hence the man in yellow saying "I love the next part this is were they tear themselves apart"
>>220095031At least Julie will take his virginity as good big sister
>>220095046Nope it's all the same story. 10, 100, 10000 loops it's all the same singular story.
>>220095031He won't.
Babymaking sex with the cute cop lady
>>220095094
>>220095031He noticeably looks much older this season. It's strange. They need to kill him or have some sort of explanation for why he's getting older
>>220095066if all the loops are a part of the same story, then this would imply theres an end. A story has got to have an end after all. Each loop being a retelling of the same story makes much more sense.
>>220094822>>220094904>memeswhat fucking memes you stupid jeets? ive been lurking in those generals past few days and only 2 things that were somewhat funny was nothingfuckinghappend.gif and jade driving into cave entranceyou are not funny and this constant bragging about le memes is beyond pathetic
>>220095241>then this would imply theres an endThey haven't reached it yet obviously > retelling of the same storynope all 1 singular story
>>220095243Hey, let's talk about this later okay?
>>220094808I would never trust a big-titted cute girl, they think they can get away with anything
>>220095292So the "story" is the exact same thing happening to different groups of people for who knows how long? Hell of a story that.
>>220095352Yup it is quite the hell of a singular story that's why we all watch it.
So do they come fully equipped when they shapeshift?
>>220095464encouraging dirty talk while titty fucking shall do
>>220095216He could also be a storywalker which can be used to explain why he suddenly looks older. The whole storywalker thing and being constantly reincarnated can be used to explain a lot of things in the show, mainly the "visions" of different people from different eras. The dude in the picture is obviously a version of Elgin with the missing eye and all.
>>220095094>>220095165>>220095464> sudden influx of extremely hot females while the hottest woman from the established group gets a lesbo shackle and ruins her hairwhat did they mean by this?
explain this shit
>>220095608Samantha Brown and Julia Doyle
>>220095582Did the addiction angle with the one lesbo ever go anywhere I can't remember now
>>220095667she went cold turkey after getting caught, had 2 rough nights and it looks like that genuinely cured her completely
>>220095568Holy shit, imagine the horror of being reincarnated as a fat retarded nigger.
>>220095667>>220095691rehab clinics hate this one simple trick
>>220095691I am just happy they read the room and stopped making dedicated episodes about them and their relationship.
obviously jim was looking around at something/someone when ethan encountered him, and this is different than any other ghosts we’ve seen before like katri, the bartender, or boyd’s wife, so what’s the deal? did julie bring him there to tell ethan about the lake of tears? was that real jim from the past? was it even jim/jim’s ghost at all, or an illusion created by some entity in the town?
>>220095820You're all reading way too much into this. It was just Ethan's subconscious mind saying a final farewell to his dad - he'll never be seen again.
>>220094114Is she ok?
YALL SHOULD USE A WINCH
>>220093384he should be the next James Bond.
Man I love this show. Nothing fucking happens and still I can't wait for the next episode.
>>220095959Why wouldn't she be?
>>220095959yeah, it's just make up effects
>>220093846they never run out. there is always a new cycle (or recycle) of idiots who cannot move a freaking tree.
>>220095820I think that Jim's soul is in a weird place because he was killed by the man in yellow.Think about it, the man in yellow is obviously not affected by the talismans and can kill people just by touching them. He could slaughter the entire town in one night if he wanted.But he chooses not to and, before now, has just been taunting them from afar. He's the wizard of some variety and by killing them, it ruins the game. So Jim is probably hanging out with the priest in some weird torture dungeon, similar to Martin
>>220096116what if someone happened to show up with a chainsaw and a winch and they were able to get around the tree and keep going?
>>220094114imaging doing her head hole...
What if I pretended that I was considering letting them in, and made them listen to me rant about linux, game lore, and whatever degenerate shit came to my mind instead night after night?
>>220093384Tuxedo Randall is real
this show's gonna have the dumbest fucking ending, isn't it
at the very start of the show everything was chill for the most part. they went quite awhile without an incident until some stupid kid opened a window. they use to have a bar, a diner, chickens and cows. seems like the more they try to get out the worse things get.
>>220096132what if a prison bus full of rapists and murderers encountered the tree in the road and now the town has a bunch of rapists and murderers in it.
>>220096453Season 1 and every season after feel like 2 completely different shows. These writers blow their wads in the 1st season then never plan past that. The whole colony house vs living in town divide was interesting and almost felt cult like and that was immediately abandoned. Donna and Boyd co-running things was interesting now she just is another character that does what he says
>>220096427can't be any worse than Lost
>>220096453Do we know how much time has passed since Boyd found the talismans and the first episode began? It seems like he only started solving the mysteries in the first season.
>>220096427I'm fairly sure that it's going to be some corny shit where the loop is broken by Julie storywalking back to the first episode, doing something that completely changes things and everything is sunshine and rainbows. Someone is going to be sacrificed so the Fromville curse is broken and the loop never happened. Que Sera Sera plays and we'll see a compilation of the freed people who don't remember what happened. Similar to Dark.
>>220096734I feel like the show will end with them all exiting that tree from the park when Tabitha was in the real world
My mouth, her penis
I bet this season ends with the MiY taking all of the town talismans and the Fromites start invading homes. Another big massacre like what happened to Victors group.
>>220096786god I love too big to hide
>>220096453>>220096529Honestly, I don’t miss those Colony House moments one bit. Sure, they helped flesh out some characters early on, but I’m glad it's over. With everything that they went through lately, that just wouldn’t make sense anymore. Things are way too heavy now for chill scenes.
>>220096895There is no internal conflict anymore between the people which makes it boring. I bet Acosta will die this season probably taking her own life when she finally gives up like they sort of started making her that character that maybe could have divided people but they aren't doing that anymore I think. I wish like a military grunt or high ranking US politician made their way to the town and really started causing issues
Can someone please explain to me what the worms were and how they killed a from
This show needs more episodes of them going deep in the woods thats where all the interesting shit happens
>>220096951They should have Elgis spite suicide and leave a bunch of public notes revealing fatimas corpseeating and killing and just say he was tortured for learning the truth about that.Randalls spite/distrust about being left behind also seemed to have vanished magically somehow.
I'm gathering a team of brave forest explorers to find a bunch of mcguffins and solve this thing for realYou in?
>>220097092Will there be snacks?
where all the town people this season? did the monsters kill most of them already?
>>220096951Almost all the people causing internal conflict died being assholes or got scared into submission by this point. MiY saying "this is when they tear themselves apart" should mean we see internal conflict ramp up again though, right?
>>220096951I think Acosta is just having a bad time accepting her new reality. Maybe because of her past experiences, as hinted in the show when she talks about 'hell' etc. Boyd acts like he's seen that behavior many times before. I believe Elgin is the one who's gonna somehow create another and even bigger mess.
>>220097092I don't have time right now, we'll talk later.*dies*
What the fuck is up with the Elgin-Odin connections between the Ravens and him losing an eye. Where are they going with that? The names even sound similiar
>>220097092Ready when you are.
>>220094114that's not Trudy
Genuinely I feel like it would be super easy to survive the froms. The hardest part would be farming
>>220097334Isn't the soil still fucked? Finding that random healthy vegetable patch was stupidly convenient, still not sure how that feeds the whole place for long but I guess I'm thinking too much
>>220097272i totally forgot about this guy. how did he end up in the ground?
>>220097398>still not sure how that feeds the whole place for long but I guess I'm thinking too muchKenny had a throwaway line in season 1 that animals like cows and chickens just show up in the woods somehow.
>>220096967we don’t know.
>>220097572True, but they lost a lot of those too didn't they?
>>220097398the fromians want to keep their playthings alive so food will always turn up
>>220096867Wot
>>220097145there were quite a few people standing around looking at the bloody bag hanging in the air in this episode.
>>220097476faraway tree teleport gone wrong
>>220096951>>220097198acosta will die sacrificing herself to save someone else. that will be her redemption that makes it so everyone will be sad she’s gone and we’ll spend a whole episode watching everyone cry. or, that’s kenny’s fate and acosta will be the new kenny next season and maybe ultimately the new boyd at the end of the series.
>>220097718yeah right the histrionic bitch who randomly fires guns into houses is gonna be in charge of keeping everyone alive literally over their dead bodies. no one would accept her authority.
>>220097775well she has a season and a half to earn people’s respect and also I would imagine a lot of people are gonna die now that the show is winding down.
>time travel introduced So they’re going to go back in time and save the children and then the froms will never have existed and the story will never have happened
julie? seggs
>>220098036Whatever happened, happene.They are just using this as a storytelling tool to fill in some of the gaps and answer questions without cheap flashbacks for characters that weren't even there, hopefully..
>>220098036You can't change a story that's already been told, Julie will grow to understand that but she will retrieve some trivia from one of her trips.Followed by great scene of her explaining Boyd that she time travels now.
>>220098110>>220098140You can’t change a story that’s already been told…………………… ……..until you can……..
>>220097647huge tatassqueeze 'emsuck 'embigger than her frame
>>220098110>>220098140>blindly trusting a shapeshifting demonngmi
>>220098311The question is, what is his favorite part?In my opinion it's getting ploughed as seedney sweeney lookalike and changing his face to original mid-way
how this general could be if that 1 angry guy who doesn't contribute anything but just replys to everyones posts calling them a faggot/foreigner/tourist/redditor just leaves and makes his own thread where he can call the fromsters ghouls all he wants
>>220098311Honestly Im just saying that whatever happened, happened thing from a meta narrative perspective. I just think they are using time travel to fill in the blanks a little bit, otherwise it would be really lame because Julie would be the only relevant character. I think its obvious Boyd will be the most important character in whatever the climax/conclusion is with the top billing and what not, otherwise if Julie is the chosen one and just fixes the whole plot on her own what is even the point of having the whole cast.
>>220093498haters will say its ai
>>220098418>20 minutes into virginal spelunking and she gives you this lookwwyd, I'd hold eye contact and finish inside.
>>220098530call him a fag and continue
The townspeople are such cucks letting someone like Boyd rule over them.Can't wait for a Fromster to turn him into chitlins.
>>220098458Fromsters? Ghouls? Do you mean "those things out in the woods?"
>>220098599I don't want to talk about it.
>>220098599Looks like a job for a winch
>>220098463well what’s the point of her time traveling if not to change something in the past, specifically to stop the ogs from sacrificing their children in the first place.
Sex with JulieSex with the yellow tranny
>>220098884Just to let the viewer see some lore probably
>>220093384If she (he) can cause strokes/heart attacks just by touching someone, why did she have to suffocate the priest?
>>220098932cooldown
>>220098932the heart attack she gave him in the car didn’t kill him, and clearly she couldn’t let him live.
>episode 2>already NOTHING IS HAPPENING
Severance vs. From in a nothing-happening-off
If they manage to find a reliable way to kill monsters will they kill all the women in the village so they can’t revive
>>220099049just impregnate them first
>>220099049That's how you get mpreg
>>220099040they’re both competing for second place behind pluribus.
>>220099040Severance is worse with the reset-to-status-quo rugpulls
>>220099082>MC is a dyke>Be surprised when nothing happens
>>220099119>christina walkenwould
They have running water? Fucking how. If there's a water tower, who fills it? Also for a water system to work, to have enough pressure to push the water around the town and up into houses and into faucets, it needs to be completely closed, without leaks. In that dilapidated, old town, there isn't a single place where rust or the elements ate through a pipe. All the valves and faucets operational.You know this show was made by Americans cause the town has three cops and no plumbers or electricians.
>>220099233It just works. Don't dig too deep into it, we know how that turns out.
>cast hyped episode 2 as the most shocking/exciting I can't believe I'm still watching this crap
>>220099233did you forget the electricity comes from nowhere, too?
How would YOU improve the show and make it more appealing to INTELLIGENT audience such as YOURSELF?
>>220099344I forgot they have electricity. what a retarded show. >inb4 in the Fromville timeloop the electricity and water are also looping>>220099418More naked tits and sex scenes.
>>220099119they all look like the average redditor
>>220099265>>220099344They also have the ambulance driving around, despite fuel expiring after 6 months.
>>220099418julie shower scenes
>>220099468kek
>>220099480the ambulance arrived like a week ago. and, given that fuel doesn’t keep very long, it actually makes sense to use it while you can. especially since the town nurse has a bum leg currently.
>>220099480That one can actually be explained. New vehicles show up regularly, they just siphon the gas from those. Plus not much time has passed in the show.
>>220099119petey looks like that main person from 30 rock, can't believe I forgot her name
>>220099519>the ambulance arrived like a week agothe woman cop has only been in From for a week? the pacing in this show is weird
Julie? Sorry, there's a new tiddy queen now.
OH SHIT FROM IS BACK what up from bros i missed last week and have to go to work tonight is gonna be HYPE HYPE HYPE
>>220099551the entire series has been like one month.
>>220099573two eps are out so far.
>>220099573that excitement will vanish real quick
>>220099233It's obvious these shows are made by sheltered nepo babies who don't know how the world works. I'm surprised they don't have a supermarket in Fromville that just magically restocks everything.
>>220097631They're supposedly still in the middle of a famine that was only partially solved by them finding a random abandoned spooky village with lots of crops growing.I'm about 70% sure the writers have forgotten about this though
>>220099649nah i love how fucking dumb this show is. its way better watching it along w this general and laughing at nothing ever happening.you just gotta embrace it, its peak desu
>knowledge comes at a costThe first lesson, facilitated by the serpent in the garden.>best part is where they turn against each otherCain and Abel.>drowned childrenRemember God's vengeance: the flood.
>his throat is suddenly intact>he has chest woundsso is it a mistake, or is there some significance that he was killed by throatrip and then when his children found him he had chest wounds and intact throat?
>>220093641kek
>>220100097Jim is gonna come back to life.
>>220100097Some anon was hypothesizing how that's not actually Jim
>>220100097chest wound was obviously made so they think it was the monsters in the woods.maybe the guy could fix the throat wound with some magik or it just wasn't showing clearly on the shot.the pose reminded me of the picture in 9th gate movie. or well i guess it's in tarot cards too. it's not same, like hands aren't bound for example. so i doubt has anything to do with anything. was just one of those "hey i think i've seen that somewhere" but then it wasn't same
>>220100035Ooh reddits not going to like this one
>>220093384The winch shit is getting old but I'm ngl I kek'd at this.
>>220100035>don't you think it's weird how there are no bibles in this town?
It's really astonishing that 4 seasons in, and NOTHING happened.
>>220100838Something happened. You watched it.
>>220100838It's really astonishing that you think repeating this endlessly will make us stop watching or liking the show.
>>220100838kek shills mad at From
we need to talk.
>The winch shit is getting old but I'm ngl I kek'd at this.
>>The winch shit is getting old but I'm ngl I kek'd at this.
>>220101035not now, I gotta go.
>>220100571You gotta go back
>>220100035kvno
>>220094767Well, the thing is that in season 3 and 4 is that i have to go
Why didn't they just winch the tree out of the way?
>>220100035if we see a rainbow then we’ll know the writers are based
what’s actually getting old is tabitha
>>220101558>>220101611Winch post do I believe mmmhmhmhmhm
>>220101266I dont go there, I was making a joke
>>220095351Because they can.
>>220098599Personally I call them woodies because thats where they live.
>Is this old kek'd at I getting winch but I'm shit ngl.
>>220098932Stroke? She (male) grabbed his dick. Poor pastor blew his load in seconds and lost control of the car.
>>220098599Credits depict them as "Nightmare Creatures"
>>Is this old kek'd at I getting winch but I'm shit ngl.
>>220101887I thought they lived in caves.
I call them Ethanies because they live in Ethan's head.
>>220102048Cavies isn't as pleasant on the ear. I just retconned them into living in the woods. Its not like it makes a difference anyway
>>220095608we live in a world where Alien:Earth is getting a second season and decent reviews, nothing surprises me
Thoughts on this?
>>220102383I can't remember who but someone arrived at night and still ended up driving in circles
>>220102530The ambulance arrived after dark? The bus too, no?
>>220102383Interesting theory. I kinda like it but don't believe that's whats going on just based on the fact fromsters actively try to coax Townspeople into letting them out or going outside.
>>220102550>>220102530I think their point was something else very simple is the answer and the monsters are guarding it. Maybe its something like going to the ruins at night or something
Why didn't the Man in Yellow just setup Fromville in India and endlessly deploy this strategy on horny jeets?
>>220102383thats pretty smart ngl but i highly doubt thats the angle and instead its about some stupid childish "le story is in ur head" and time travel cringe
>>220102550Ambulance, yes. The bus came in like an hour or two before night.
>>220102530Wait was that the ambulance? Does someone have a list of all the people who have arrived?>Jim and family>Jadegap>busgap>ambulanceAnd the ambulance never completed a loop.>>220102550The ambulance arrived after dark, or just at dusk. The bus arrived right before dark I think. Let me check
>xkcd getting in on the winchposting>https://xkcd.com/3218/
>>220093384How come is the biggest thing that happened to one of them - managing to leave the place and return with someone else - not like their most investigated thing? The hag literally managed to leave for the real world and they didn't keep on looking into the trees and shit?
>>220102805
>>220102805There's a resident "retard" in the town, Victor, who everyone knows knows more than he reveals. But he's developmentally stunted and trying to interrogate him is considered near impossible so they let him be.Tabitha is several times more retarded than him.
>>220093696Do they eat the organs? I always thought the creatures didn't eat and just tore people apart.
>>220102383People have been getting trapped in Fromville since at least the late 70s. They didn't start using the talismans until Boyd found them in like 2020. I doubt it's a ruse from the Fromsters.
>>220102880I'm pretty certain they just tear people apart.
>>220102666Literally who
>anti shills trying to ruin our comfy thread by spamming unfunny forced memes
>>220103074The fuck is an anti shill
>>220103120Shills post trying to get people to support/talk about something.Anti shills do the opposite. They're butthurt about how much attention this low budget show gets and trying to derail discussion so that we go talk about their critically acclaimed slop instead.
Report and move on
>>220103120Shills and antishills are formed in a virtual pair which cancel each other's charges. But when they form near the event horizon of a plot blackhole one of the pair is sucked in and the other is ejected creating either a shill or an antishill. It's called hawktuah's radiation.
>>220102383I mean Acosta was saying something along this line then Kristi told her to shut the fuck up
Kristi is weirdly cute.
>>220097272>>220097476>>220097689Boyd cursed him by saying "We don't have CONCRETE proof"
>Kristi is weirdly cute.
>>220103183no she wasn't she was just saying>UHHH REEEE I REFUSE TO UNDERSTAND ANYTHING AND BELIEVE ANYTHING ANYONE TELLS ME
>>220102642
>>220097476Took a page from Boyd's bookHe was stonewalling
>>220103290oh and also>I'M A GOOD PERSON I DONT DESERVE TO BE IN HELL LIKE THE REST OF YOU IM BUILT DIFFERENT
>>220103415>>220103415>>220103415
>>220103329>LIKE THE REST OF YOUThey are all desensitized zombies at this point, so I can concede this to her>IM BUILT DIFFERENTClearly yes
>>220103460i just enjoyed her making that argument because she literally killed someone and doesn't even seem to have remorse for it which is way worse than probably anything anyone else stuck there has done.
>>220103280that’s a man
