Top: SoulBottom: Soulless
Both are soulless 3Dslop
>Charizard is no longer permanently airborneThat makes it soul by default.
>>55777053Zard and Blastoise are both improvements. Venusaur needs the bottom fangs back.
>shiny plastic toys le GOOD>actual texture and definition to details le BADAlright XYgote. Run along and pretend you're Calem again, there's a good lad.
>>55777076>Wanting "muh realism">In an anime styled gameSV is the ugliest game in the entire series.
>>55777053>SWSHIT >Soul Galartroon detected
>>55777080I-IS THAT A LITTLE BIT OF TEXTURE?AIIIIIIIIIIIIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE MOM IM SCARED THE FUNNY CARTOON CRITTER LOOKS SO REAL AND SCARY
>>55777087It just looks out of place. Honestly if they want to overhaul the models they should lean harder into the Sugimori style and go for a sort of watercolour cel-shading.
>>55777053Gen 6 era really liked giving mons tard faces. Venusaur and Charizard look a lot better with their mouths closed and their eyes given more detail.
I always weirdly found the old Venusaur model cute and the new face ruins that :/
>>55777053Both are soulless. Bring back the pre-gen 6 models.
>>55777106>Pre-gen6>ModelsAnon you're either a spriteshitter or are advocating for actual N64 models and I don't know which is worse.
>>55777053blastoise looks worse
>>55777053>XY*FART*
>>55777066>NOOOO YOU CANT JUST MAKE THE FLYING CREATURE FLY
>>55777116Nostalgia's a cunt of a drug that makes people say retarded shit, what's new?
And so it keeps going
>>55777138Nice cope SwShitter
>>55777152Say that without crying next time. Galargods rule this board.
>>55777116Spinoff games always had better 3DEven the gen 6 spinoff games had better 3D graphics than XY
>>55777062based fpbp
>>55777138I mean, they're right. Each generation is worse than the previous. Things just keep getting worse than we even thought possible
>>55777080anime sucks go get your Naruto DVDs and shove them up your ass
>>55777198Except the gamecube when compared to Game Freak's own 3DS and Switch games, but let me guess, you're an authentic hoennbab, thus can't actually look at the past objectively.
>>55777211>He says on a board dedicated to discussing anime-styled games on a website originally created to discuss anime, owned by a Japanese manWhere do you think we are?
>>55777053>ITT: galarva and paldeggs arguing over which one of shitty generations is "good"Now let's see the models in motion.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B-1OHHSYP2o&t=14
>>55777053The top look more washed out and thats a bad thing
>>55777231these look worse than what’s in SV.
>>55777208Maybe because "worse" per autistic manbaby standards is good for kids/casuals?I mean, series saw an increase in overall sales since they joined the big boys on Home hardware, as well as the games themselves finally evolving away from the rehash formula finally but that doesn't fit the manbaby definition of "a good pogeymans gaem" as they're basing THAT opinion off a moment in time that is now lost to all but who were the demographic for it of the era. And as Game Freak displayed MANY times, they'd rather create those moments for ALL new players, instead of trying to pander to an extreme minority (in this case 27-32 yo's, who MAY have possibly played Ruby or Sapphire as children. Much easier to shill at kids and know you're hitting the mark).
>>55777094that requires them to know what theyre doing and they dont hire new people. all the people there had to learn how to 3d and cellshading is apparently hard because muh topology.
>>55777186Galarfags don't even rule their own region, they're too busy choking kantochad dick
>>55777053the bottom's models (with textures) and, the top's shading and lightingsomeone needs to experiment to see how that would look
>>55777247Kanto doesn't even have a good modern way to play it.>Original games are unplayable janky oldslop>FRLG are close but lack modern QOL features, are spriteshit and have outdated lore like America existing>LGPE don't have proper wild encountersMeanwhile Galar got the best games in the entire series.
>>55777259Funny way to spell Hisui and Paldea.I mean, I appreciate SS for its evolution of the series too, but it's in no way "the best game in the series" unless you're going to modify that by adding "in my own opinion".
>>55777273>HisuiJust Sinnoh in the past, also sidegame.>PaldeaDoesn't even work properly and is also ugly as fuck.
>>55777053Charizard looks better without derping around in the airVenusaur, only thing is his eyes, I'm way too used to everything having sticker eyes instead of real definitionBlastoise is most affected, I figured his arms always being forward in majority of his appearances was due to his shell limiting his arm movement doesn't help that it looks like his right arm is clipping into his shell
>Meanwhile Galar got the best games in the entire series
>>55777259Explain how gen 1 is unplayable without sounding like a fucking turbo zoomer
>>55777335>oomerismsBut I'll bite.>Blatant errors re: type interactions>Glitches out the wazoo>Pathetically limited item space>Hideously ugly (some of the sprites are fucking vomit-inducing)>Ear-grating musicIt's outdated and obsolete in every single way. Embodiment of oldslop. FRLG shits all over it in every way, and THAT game is outdated as fuck too (no phys/spec split, no EXP share, etc). At least it isn't physically painful to play thanks to that horrible Nokia tier soundtrack and deformed sprites.
>>55777358your birth year begins with a 2 doesn't it
>>557773671996 actually.
>>55777372Trying too hard there kid.
>>55777377>27 year old>"kid"Rich coming from an -oomerism spouting newfag/tourist.
>>55777053The models are improved, the lighting is a downgrade. I don’t understand why they’re trying for more realism instead of sticking with an anime aesthetic
>>55777053Honestly that bottom Charizard kinda captures his art pretty well
>>55777358>>Blatant errors re: type interactionsOh no psychic is immune to lick, a move you'd never use anyway.>>Glitches out the wazooUnlike SV, you actually have to intentionally glitch the game.>>Pathetically limited item spaceI'll agree with this one.>>Hideously ugly (some of the sprites are fucking vomit-inducing)They're not pretty I'll give you that but if being ugly makes the game unplayable how in the actual fuck can you play nupokemon when that also looks horrid?>>Ear-grating musicThe music is fine, FRLG are the games that fucked with almost every track and made them worse.
The new models have more detail, but the color and shading in SV is just ugly.Also Charizard looks silly just standing still now. It’s supposed to be a flying lizard. Why did anyone complain this.
>>55777402>They're not pretty I'll give you that but if being ugly makes the game unplayable how in the actual fuck can you play nupokemon when that also looks horrid?Gen 8 (AKA the only gen that matters seeing as Gen 9 shat the bed) looks great though.>The music is fine, FRLG are the games that fucked with almost every track and made them worse.Blatantly false, FRLG sounds great, meanwhile OG Viridian Forest sets my teeth on edge and OG Lavender Town was so bad it gave kids headaches in the JP release and had to be altered for the Western version.Oldslop belongs in the trash.
>>55777416Gen 8 looks fucking horrible though.FRLG sounds like they put the music through a filter. It's not terrible but it's absolutely not better than the original tracks. Gen 1 still sounds good to this day.
>>55777467>Gen 8 looks fucking horrible though.Wrong.>FRLG sounds like they put the music through a filter. It's not terrible but it's absolutely not better than the original tracks.Wrong.>Gen 1 still sounds good to this day.Absolutely not. Gen 1 sounds absolutely awful.
>>55777053Galar is the epitome of soulless
>>55777382I didn't originally reply to you kid.If you're going to sperg out like a child, don't be surprised when people call you one.The fact you got triggered enough to age yourself in front of Arceus and us all here just proves your fucking immaturity kid.
>>55777492You're either younger than me yourself and LARPing as a millennial or you're terminally retarded.
>>55777476I can just say your whole post is wrong too, faggot.It's obvious we're not going to change each others minds here. Good for you if you actually enjoy nupokemon somehow, but I sure as fuck don't and would much rather play the old games again.
>>55777516I accept your concession, oldslop eater.
>>55777053both are recycled 3D slop but i'd prefer SwSh's style over SV's every time>>55777116bro did not just forget Battle Revolution
>>55777501Neither. Project harder why don't you?
>>55777516Pity you faggots just *can't* "play the old games" and let the rest the world play the newer ones though. Always gotta throw in your incel opinions where they clearly don't matter.
>>55777402frlg made them better
>>55777525Literally every 3D series ever recycles models because there's no point in making new ones unless the character's design changed.
>>55777525anon BR recycles stadium models
>>55777080Back in my day, Charizard had texture.
>>55777053Both are soulless because only humans have souls.
>>55777116>advocating for actual N64 modelsJust like Game Freak?
>>55777129>>55777403charizard flys in battle but isnt permanently airborne so that makes sv better by defaultlets not even mention the better textures or that venusaur and blastoise actually use their vines/canons in their attack animations now
>>55777123This, hgss sprite was the last time Blastoise looked great. Really needs the pop of color and to not have it's arms melting down.
>>55777875>2024 main Pokemon game has less quality than a render from the fucking 90s
>>55777053Mfw live long enough for someone to start defending the 3ds models god dammit
>>55777875That looks like shit.
>>55777999> charizard flys in battle but isnt permanently airborne sooo…like XY?
>>55779520not at all because it actually stands on the ground in the main game and not a side mode where they dont have to animate it movingit also just looks better but that goes without saying
>>55777138Nah, you are wrong. I think Pokemon ZA is going to be good. Meanwhile, SS and SV are both still shit.
>>55779822>amie doesn’t count as the main game because…um…it just doesn’t ok?>the flying pokemon looks better not flying because…um…it just doesn’t ok?
