[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/vp/ - Pokémon


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1701136305540369.jpg (39 KB, 474x926)
39 KB
39 KB JPG
Why did Penny flop and not become the new Lillie/Marnie?

>gave her all eeveelutions
>le epik haxors
>bullied loser (relatable)
>transcoded
>forced zoomercore design
>>
>>56768576
He's ugly
>>
Genwar AND schizo thread btw
>>
>>56768576
to be fair, she didn't really flop, she just isn't as popular. she's more in a specific, niche crowd. (and flopping means they have low fans. not just low porn count.)

also it's probably because a lot of people nowadays would rather have eri or atticus, which, respectable honestly.
>>
File: 1697160452789896.gif (1.09 MB, 200x270)
1.09 MB
1.09 MB GIF
>>56768576
That's one retarded haircut jesus christ.
>>
>Character doesn't have a ton of porn therefore it's a flop
Do porn addict retards really?
>>
>>56768588
>to be fair, she didn't really flop, she just isn't as popular. she's more in a specific, niche crowd.
Very well said. I love Penny very much, but I'm aware that she's not for everyone. She still gets a lot of fanart.
>>
>>56768601
>porn is your only metric
retard
>>
>>56768601
yes
yes they do
>>
>>56768601
>no one said shit about porn
Meds.
>>
>>56768609
>>porn is your only metric
Yes anon that's what OP is implying
>>
>>56768601
Porn is the strongest indicator of popularity
More porn = More popularity
Less porn = less popularity
Simple as
>>
File: Frieza kek.png (329 KB, 720x404)
329 KB
329 KB PNG
>>56768611
>>56768615
>Out of nowhere
>When OP mentions lillie and marnie both nothingburger characters carried by porn and pedos
At the very least try to be more subtle next time OP
>>
>>56768617
where is he implying that?
>>
>>56768620
Meds, now.
>>
>>56768625
>Meds, now.
Yes that's what porn addicts deserve
>>
>>56768601
Schizopost
>>
>>56768629
Psycho reply
>>
>>56768576
Why are you answering your own question??
She's not hot. It's just that simple. It's not even all the idpol schizo babble, it's literally just cause she'd not a sexy loli, just a boring looking girl.
>>
>>56768640
legit
she's not even over-the-top neet like konata or over-the-top stinky like tomoko, she's kinda just.. there.
so ofc she'll not be as popular as the goth girl or the character you spend an entire game bonding with.

>CAPTCHA: WANG8
>>
>>56768576
>Why did Penny flop
Not sexualized enough for the gooner pedos
>>
>>56768576
>>56768640
This
The blackpill extends to fiction
LOOKS is the most important thing you can have. The halo effect can carry your entire life
If Nemona was ugly or a boy everyone would find her insufferable (those who arent attracted to her do)
>>
>>56768576
I forgot this character even exists
>>
>>56768576
She ended up making me sympathize with Team Star more. I'd bully her too.
>>
>>56768667
Explain how Gamefreak sexualizes Lillie and Marnie
>>
>>56768689
They didn't, anon is unironically a pedo gooner himself.
>>
>>56768689
they didn't (intentionally) but a lot of weirdo pedophiles find a lot of weirdo things attractive, like for some reason there's an entire fetish about a specific type of shorts? I don't understand that one.
>>
>>56768576
ugly tumblr loser
>>
>>56768689
Imagine being THIS naive
>>
>>56768749
this is why I said they didn't intentionally sexualise them in >>56768737. some people could see the crop top and assume it's horny because the internet is kinda fucked like that .-.
>>
>>56768749
You are a pedo if you think this is sexy.
>>
>>56768749
They knew what they were doing didn't they?
>>
>>56768753
Yeah bro they unintentionally gave her the sluttiest outfit and the ass-focused pose right
>>
The cope in this thread is incredible
>>
>>56768689
Marnie literally wears a dress that barely covers her thighs AND has peek holes in it that could easily grant you a view on her panties at the right angle.
And Lillie shows even more skin.
>>
>>56768824
>Marnie literally wears a dress that barely covers her thighs
Again, how is this sexy? Unless you just think fictionalized little children showing skin is hot then you're being the weirdo here.

>has peek holes in it that could easily grant you a view on her panties at the right angle.
This is just you projecting your horny fantasies.
>>
The amount of marniepedos deflecting in this thread is impressive
>>
>>56768863
man my point is proven more and more. a lot of weirdo pedophiles find a lot of weirdo things attractive
>>
>>56768576
Ugly.
>>
>>56768601
this is honestly the most funny double standard of zoomies on this board
>if a character don't gets drawn everyday is a woke character or ugly or a flop
>my literally who bitch from gen 2/3/4/5/6 that did'nt get get drawn in 10 years? is actually underrated and not a bland design.
>>
>>56768863
Anon literally look at her design. She wears a skimpy dress. Stop pretending to be retarded.
>>
>>56768576
>Why did Penny flop and not become the new Lillie/Marnie?
Lillie and Marnie were the only good female designs in their respective games after the female protagonist.
With SV Penny has far more competition than they ever did
Nemona
Miriam
Dendra
Carmine
Raifort
Eri
Mela
Lacey
Briar
Perrin

Penny was never going to win.
>>
File: 1714743627641908.png (122 KB, 329x781)
122 KB
122 KB PNG
>>56768952
What part of this is skimpy?
>>
>>56768954
>Nemona
>Miriam
>Dendra
>Carmine
>Raifort
>Eri
>Mela
>Lacey
>Briar
>Perrin

All of these are flops too. Only Iono approaches Lillie's level.
>>
>>56768954
Penny has almost of the double and triple the art of 90% that you have listed and she's drawn everyday, chuddies are just mad she was not designed to be a pedo bait like Lillie and Marnie and she's noticeable by her own merits.
>>
>>56768968
A good 70% of her thighs are exposed. Also the 3D model removed the cutouts and made them solid. They are transparent in the 2D art.
>>
File: 1707857752102797.png (846 KB, 800x2062)
846 KB
846 KB PNG
>>56769080
Again you are projecting your pedo fantasies. That is a perfectly normal amount of skin to be showing. But of course your porn rotten mind thinks otherwise. Rope yourself.
>>
>>56768576
She flopped? I liked he more than Marnie. Her little Mochi Mochi dance was really cute. She also has great chemistry with Nemona and Arven. Nemona is probably my favorite out of the group but that's just because I like her attitude and find he battle obsession amusing.
>>
>>56769090
I would not let my 12 year old daughter go outside like that but you do you.
>>
>>56769100
I pray that someone as sick minded as you never has children.
>>
>>56769119
How? I've read about what Typhlosion does to children. You can't trust Pokemona around you kids.
>>
>>56768576
Looks like a tranny
>>
File: 345.jpg (115 KB, 1169x786)
115 KB
115 KB JPG
>>56768576
Fuck Penny
>>
File: GD-YK8RbYAAeYsx.jpg (1.98 MB, 2322x3541)
1.98 MB
1.98 MB JPG
>>56768576
She's not as moe as Lillie/Marnie so she was never going to be as popular, but what I think killed her popularity the most is the fact that her in-game model kinda sucks. Most SV characters suffer from the game's awful semi-realistic artstyle and shading but she's probably the one who suffers the most. She looks a lot cuter in 2D.
>>
File: 1729864250696231.jpg (1.27 MB, 2432x2088)
1.27 MB
1.27 MB JPG
>>56768576
You forgot
>was the product of gay incest
>>
>>56769958
Nani the fuck?
>>
File: 1726541136999023.png (95 KB, 476x1220)
95 KB
95 KB PNG
>coomers think gamefreak is sexualizing lillie with this
>>
File: Spoiler Image (1.27 MB, 1226x1101)
1.27 MB
1.27 MB PNG
At least someone likes Penny...
>>
>>56768576
She's not supposed to be the new Lillie you nonce.
>But Lillie
Sun and Moon's main storyline literally orbit around her. Yes the player is discovering quirky knockoff Hawaii locales and taking the trials, but the game effective starts with he running away protecting Nebby and ends with her leaving to start her own independent journey in Kanto to unfuck her mom's jellyfish addiction. She's an uwu rich girl whose clueless about the world and you're forced to babysit and develop stockholm syndrome for, and if you aren't cynical then she's just generically cute enough for infinite shilling.
>but Marnie-
She's the shitty punk knockoff Lillie, like how several other aspects of Galar are just shitty versions of Alola that weren't thought out as deeply. She basically does nothing outside of give GF a reason to make some retards in paint stand around as roadblocks like Team Skull did, despite it making less sense that Yell is blocking off bridges n shit during a major sporting event. However since she's a cardboard cutout the game just kinda holds up once in a while she is also completely inoffensive, so people just latch onto her uwu pastel punk outfit and convince themselves she doesn't get mogged personality-wise by the shitass NPC who can't stop making chimeric affronts to god and paint chips.

Meanwhile Penny's entire thing is that she's some cringe shut in loser. She's only barely in the same role as "girl related to bad guys", and even then Kieran's school shooter arc and resolution is closer to Lillie's deuterologist shit despite being DLC.
>>
>>56768579
She*

https://youtu.be/XbP9GgiYyPo?feature=shared
>>
>>56768675
Dude if Nemona was a boy fujos would eat that character up and he'd be the most popular rival since Gladion. Like they already ate up Goh and he was a complete fucking non-character, Goku personality on a Spic boy would've been crack
>>
>>56771389
>he'd be the most popular rival
You have to be delusional to say this with how little women give a fuck about Hop and Hau and basically every friendly male rival besides Arven. She would be way less popular than as a girl.
>>
>>56768576
>>transcoded
Excuse me?
>>
>>56771413
That's literally just because Hau and Hop aren't cute
>>
>>56771439
Male Nemona would not look any better than Hau.
>>
>>56768576
Penny is only good because she's out of shape, stinky, and socially awkward
>>
>>56771479
>because she's out of shape
Nemona is the one who complains about the grand staircase at Mesagoza and gets winded in Area Zero. Penny easily scales both with no complaints.
>>
>>56768579
fpbp
>>
>>56771389
>>56771413
If Kieran was female half of /vp/ would've drowned in their own cum.
>>
>>56771672
No, I would still bully and cuck her.
>>
>>56771672
True but she wouldn't be as popular because of the hairstyle change in ID.
>>
>>56771727
And then goon to that.
>>56771758
He's still insanely popular for a male DLC character.
>>
>>56771672
Female Kieran would have never worked out, considering his character arc in the DLCs is an allegory for Inceldom
>>
nobody likes girls with short hair they look like a man
>>
>>56771784
>considering [schizo headcanon]
Meds
>>
>>56771779
So? Then people would still draw her with her old hair. Lillie also got a new style and everyone keeps drawing the other one anyway. It's the same with Kieran anyway.
>>
>>56768590
It could be so much better if it didn't look like ass in the game model. I genuinely can't get over it looking more like a headscarf than hair.
>>
>>56771784
People love femcel characters so she would work out perfectly.
>>
>>56768576
She's just lame
It's honestly disappointed to hear she is related to Peony/Rose
>>
>>56771806
Her reputation would be damaged hard by an ugly haircut and it would get blasted harder than with regular Kieran. It doesn't matter if people just choose to ignore it. It would leave a permanent mark.
>>
>>56771858
Highly doubt it. Marnies normal haircut is pretty ass too but no one cares. Kieran's new hair isn't even that bad just a slight downgrade.
>>
>>56772044
Female onion would objectively look way worse than Marnie's haircut if it looked anything like ID Kieran's.
>Kieran's new hair isn't even that bad
For a male character. The onion haircut is only accepted because he's male and it looks similar to some shounenshitter but if Kieran was female and had her hair changed to something similar, no one would allow it to slide especially for a character that was previously cute.
>>
>>56772194
Well he obviously wouldn't have gotten the same hair if he was a girl
>>
>that glaceon handjob animation
I’m warming up to her.
>>
>>56768576
Because she's boring as shit and her design is boring as shit, everything about her is so fucking boring
>>
>>56772432
I hope she lets the Sylveon knot her.
>>
>>56768576
That blue shit in her hair makes it look like she's wearing one of those old cooking bandanas Lenora wears, and the puffy eevee fur she has is stupid and clashes with her design hard
>>
>>56768620
Marnie is a nothing character but Lillie had a nice story about standing up to an abusive parent
>>
>>56768576
The other team star members are more interesting than her. You end up seeing them in school uniform but Pennys still looks the same. Maybe if she changed her stinky clothes it would be better.
>>
>>56771783
No.
>>
>>56768588
Eri is popular? Genuinely curious. I don't know much about the Paldea faves, but I find all of the Team Star leaders unpleasantly overdesigned personally
>>
>>56773068
The stinky clothes are part of her appeal though
>>
>>56775302
Very based. Penny's smell is part of why I love her so much.
>>
>>56768576
You know how the official art doesn't do the girls justice. Lillie has a stiff and basic stance and she looks silly looking all angry, meanwhile Marnie is even stiffer with the classic " one arm out" while standing like in many Japanese refsheets. Plenty of people called her bland when it came out. Now both have massive amounts of fanart, fucking coombait. Marnie who only have 1 episode in the anime still gets art.

I would like to say the same for Penny...but her appearance in-game, and in the anime, doesn't do her any favors. I'm sorry, there is just something fundamentally unappealing with her design for most people.
>>
File: 1722288002010633.jpg (667 KB, 1440x1440)
667 KB
667 KB JPG
>>56768576
Why would she? She spends the majority of the game behind your Rotom phone. It's kind of the entire point of her character.
>>
>>56775438
She spends so much time talking to you over the phone because you wouldn't be able to handle how bad she smells.

And maybe also because she masturbates while talking to you as well.
>>
>>56775454
Imagine.
>>
>>56775502
Imagine what? The smell or her masturbating?
>>
>>56775591
Both.
>>
>>56775699
Very based. I imagine Penny doesn't shower very often, so she smells pretty bad. She's also very porn addicted, so she masturbates a lot. She knows her way around her own body.

https://files.catbox.moe/u4egn2.png
https://files.catbox.moe/uyruv1.png
>>
>>56770134
Ignore him anon. 4chan's full of dinguses like that.
>>
>>56768576
>707 from mysmes but ugly femcel
She deserved to flop
>>
File: Penny stinks good.png (11 KB, 936x526)
11 KB
11 KB PNG
>>
>>56775945
cute pennor



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.