Who did it better?Post-Halloween Edition
And here's a template
Yugioh 100%
>>56824662pokemon didall the others are funny pumpking guysYugioh is just a head
>>56824662SMT > Pokemon > Yu-gi-oh > Dragon Quest >= Digimon >Yokai Watch
>>56824662Pumpking in Duelists of the Rose is really fucking funny.
YGO > Pokemon > the rest
>>56824662digimon
yugioh has a different card that's just a better version of smt's pumpkin
>>56825807Yeah I was about to say why choose Pumpking when Ghostrick Lantern mogs him in every way possible
>>56826311What it be
>>56826318Huh?
>>56826311Pokemon by far. It's not "just Frankenstein's monster" like the others, nor is it a fairly generic reptile like Monster Hunter's.
>>56826311Type Null isn't a FrankensteinIt's a chimera
>>56826346Pokémon? No? go fuck yourself.
>>56826384It's both. It's also a griffin. Pokemon can be based on multiple things.
>>56826311There's a better Medabot example https://medarot.meowcorp.us/wiki/Grazie
>>56826396Pokemon doesn't have a succubus, anon
>>56826387SkullGreymon's my favoriteBut I have to give it to YKW, if only cause it's literally the original Gashadokuro painting with a Gachapon machine
>>56826698skullbaluchimon
>>56826719Not really a dog, and how could I pass on the chance of making a morbid labramon joke?Otherwise, I would have gone with Helloogarmon.
>>56826719That's based on an ancient dino rhino
>>56826441SMT's Oni was always been one of the series' best designs in my opinion. Simple, recognizable, but with enough going on to not be generic or forgettable. The rich blue festival wear instead of the usual tigerskin loincloth gives him a strong identity.
Ah this thread is back, nice.
>>56826397>Pokemon can be based on multiple things.It's almost as if it's a chimera.
>>56826359>a fairly generic reptile like Monster Hunter'sBrother that's a gorilla
use to Hatterene for Witch >>56826318and Mismaggius as witch hat Ghost >>56826375
>>56826441Pheromosa and Salazzle
>>56829241Those are both pretty big stretches
>>56826387would Duskull not be better skeleton representation
>>56829288well take a vampiress
>>56829345canon boobs
>>56824662as usual, the only good ones are pokemon, SMT, and yugioh.
>>56829288Is it though? Salandit and Salazzle use their pheromones and sensual movements to mind control men into being their sex slaves.
>>56829458I know. Still feels like a stretch because all it really has in common with succubi is the seduction aspect. If I had to argue any Pokemon as being a succubus, I would probably have to go with Jynx. It's not too far off from the classical portrayal of a succubus, being often depicted as old and hideous. It also has the sleep association as well as the seduction thing. Still feels like a stretch though.
>>56829912I prefer the rotted tree dragon
>>56830022Entmon is actually one of my favorite Digimon. Cherrymon is just more fitting for the image. I used Entmon for my fly/mosquito one.
>>56830175That's a bit of an odd choice, but I guess it could fit in the fly category since it's both the decaying tree beast and the bugs within that allow it to move
>>56830269Digimon doesn't really have any other fitting flies with Flymon being more of a wasp.
>>56830761why does the yokai watch one have a cock cage on???
>>56830781It's a bell. It's supposed to represent the tanuki's balls.
>>56826698I think the closest for MonHun would be Odogaron? Still not dead, but it's the closest.
>>56830879it looks like a caged dong just hanging out tho
>>56824662Digimon>>56826298DQ>>56826300Pokemon>>56826306Pokemon>>56826311SMT>>56826318Yugioh
>>56826300>Dracumon>Venom Vamdemon>Neo Vamdemon>Belial Vamdemon>Sangloupmon>Vamdemon X>Matadrmon>GranDracmon>BastemonIt's surprising the only lady vampire Digimon is Bastemon
>>56826346There is like five different SMT Liliths and she's not even the best one.
>>56832872She's the most recent and one of the more (if not the most) plot-relevant Liliths. It made the most sense more me to use her over any other Lilith or any of SMT's other succubi.
>>56829715>Dusknoir doesn’t have a signature scythe attackGayfreak logic
>>56824673You'd have a point if it was Pumpkaboo instead of Gourgeist, who is less memorable than many of the others despite being more "interesting".
For most of these Yugioh wins. The classic Yugioh card ardwork is just the best.especially for sexo Dark Magician Girl But the newer ones after GX aren't that great and another franchises overwhelm these
>>56830957Only because you are obsessed with that.Everyone else sees a bell.
>>56835781better one for Yugioh
>>56835972Seems more like an Orochi than a hydra
>>56836629Some Susanoos to go with them
I remember the past thread had a mermaid and puppet charts too
>>56838264I have a mermaid one. Any ideas for new charts?
>>56838319>Cthulhu or similar eldritch creatures>Angels>Shadows>Bats>Knights>Samurais>Robots
>>56838348Who does the Pokemon shoe belong to?
>>56838348I think leprechaun works better for SMT's shoe>>56838359Chinpokomon
>>56838334
>>56838393>ChinpokomonNow that's cheating>>56838417Thank you!
>>56838334knights
>>56838334bats
>>56838334a Cthulhu/Lovecraft oneNot many to work with, but uh...
>>56824673TPBPPumpkaboo gigamogs, Gourgeist is also cool. No wonder all the others fell off while Pokemon is going strong.
>>56838548>>56838553Thanks!>>56838578Shin Megami Tensei... Such a freudian seriesWell, if we go by the broader definition of eldritch abominations, i guess Giratina would fit? Or maybe Guzzlord
https://rentry.org/vqqz8dpfHere's my picks for each one posted ITT so far, this was the easiest way to post them
>>56838548Digimon has many knights, is Craniamon your favorite?
Any Hanako-san (Toiletta) one?
>>56838831I don't normally pick by favorites, but by what was most fitting for the theme and franchise. I figured one of the Royal Knights should be chosen. Out of them Gallantmon, Lord Knightmon, and Craniumon seemed the most and equally knightly to me. I then picked Craniumon because it is in fact my favorite knight digimon
>>56830761I always loved how the SMT one is contorting its genitals into a one-eyed monster. It's a perfect mix of Kaneko's love of penis and the legends surrounding them being masters of transformation.
>>56838942More than I expected, but less than I hoped
>>56837294Anyone have the HD image of the Turtle of Yokai Watch?
>>56824662Idk point of this thread digimon always is going to mog everything
>>56839831In a snowman one SMT would winIn a slimen one DQ would win
>>56840234
>>56838319What about making one for Groudon?
>>56841393So, Behemoth?
>>56839022Pokemon
>>56841792
>>56836902Lugia would be our Susanoo, god of storms, while Ho-Oh would be our Amaterasu goddess of the sun.
>>56838334>>56842337
>>56841792She looks very similar. But that girl was only societed with caves and killing people but not toilets.
>>56842338Angewomon and DMG are top tier waifus.
>>56824662Pumpkaboo wins hard against all of them
>>56838608How dare you use such a cool image to spout such crap? Gourgeist is easily the weakest design there after yet-another-jibanyan and the rest are just as- if not cooler- than Pumpkaboo.
>>56842338>>56842457
>>56842461See >>56842464. I understand finding the DQ and YGO monsters a bit generic (one in execution and the other in concept) but you have to be daft to not appreciate the SMT and Digimon designs.
I like how there's an obvious difference in artistic direction between old and new Digimon
>>56843132The same with Yugioh.
>>56844666that's not Garudathat's Rey Mysterio
>>56826490Dusclops isn't a mummy, it's a paper lantern. It's based on Chochin Obake
We need a ninja chart
>>56826490>Cofagrigus literally has the Mummy ability >Nah Dusclops cuz reasonsFuck you
>>56824662Shin Megami Tensei's version is demonstrably the most iconic and I fluential of these
>>56826311>>56826384Yeah a better fit for Frankenstein is Mewtwo if we really want to nail the idea.
>>56826384The helmet with the square jaw and giant bolts on the side of the head is obviously supposed to invoke Frankenstein's monster to at least some extent>>56847962Mewtwo has absolutely nothing in common with Frankenstein's monster design or concept wise beyond both being experiments made in a lab
>>56844723>>56847880good points
>>56824665But hardly any Pokémon appeared in Emerald Adventure
>>56848289I really don't understand why and how that was chosen for Pokemon's logo. Here's a more recent chart.
>>56849264From Yo-kai watch
>>56824662Yu-Gi-Oh the GOAT.
Crazy how superior Digimon and Yu-Gi-Oh are to Pokemon.
Samurai chart?
Proper Digimon logo (from the original Digital Monster v-pet)
>>56849264>>56849301the only loser here SMT... also why? though
If you remove the 真・, this is a proper Megami Tensei logo (misaligned 転 unlike SMT IV or Strange Journey, red like the earlier logos, represents all of Megaten unlike SMT).
Remove the デュエルモンスターズ, and this becomes the closest thing to a proper Yu-Gi-Oh! logo.
>>56849677
>>56829979these are all terriblethe generic ayy blowns all of those
This would be a good Medarot logo, would be better if it was transparent.
>>56850044>>56850076>>56850089>>56850138no need to be pedantic about it, the point of a logo is being recognizable
>>56850168Exactly what I have been thinking. In fact, it made me realize I should have changed to a localized logo for Yokai Watch a while ago.
Is there any reason telefang has been left out? Too niche?
>>56850101Thank you!
>>56850253>Too niche?That plus as far as I'm aware. It's an actual dead franchise. Even the deadest franchises in these charts at least have a running app game or card game. Also a big factor is lack of official art for most of its monsters. Right now if I were to add another franchise to these, it sits behind Monster Rancher and Palworld. Still has some pretty great designs though.
>>56850388I think Achillesmon fits better here
>>56850478sure, I'm not that familiar with newer pets
>>56847841
>>56852108Thanks!(I've never seen this Medabot before, only knew about the blue one)
>>56850101>>56852108Felynes in different armor sets feel like a bit of cop out for MonHun when the franchise does have actual samurai and ninja-themed monsters (Magnamalo and Nargacuga)
>>56850101>>56852108>palico armorsets instead of the actual monsters that are supposed to be those conceptshuh?
>>56852169>>56852177Lynians are monsters
>>56852169>>56852177Ah, thanks for letting me know. Monster Hunter is the franchise here I am least familiar with so it's a but of a blind spot with me.
palico is cheating?y/n
>>56852289I'd argue it's fine if there are no better options
>>56852289it's like making an image for 'devils' and putting cynthia in her giratina outfit under pokemon
c-c-cheating?
>>56852550A better one for Medarot
>>56852611cool
>>56852653surely there's a money themed yugioh monster that actually exists, right?
>>56853013
Joan of Arc Pokemon when?
>>56853013More of a mimic, but there’s man-eating treasure chest
>>56852653Slightly more fitting monster for Dragon Quest
>>56853013Is gold okay?
>>56855585I hate UnimonWe could have had a cool or elegant unicorn but we got that ugly sumbitch
>>56856271Funny, I llike Unimon for that exact reason. Instead of making the usual majestic unicorn like everyone else, Digimon made a battle-scarred carnivorous cycloptic cyborg unicorn and I love them for that.
>>56856359I grew up with The Last Unicorn on repeat and posters of knights and dragons and unicorns on the wallI am incapable of doing anything but hate his ugly ass
It's insane how much better the art direction of Digimon and Yu-Gi-Oh are. If only they had better games, anime and marketing teams.
>>56856987I'd be happy if Digimon just released all their art in high quality
>>56855587Wouldn't Xerneas fit the Kirin role better?
>>56827425Spectrobes and it's not even close
>>56842338Who's even the blond bitch in yugioh?I mean in your pic
>>56855099missed oppoturnity to add brachy
>>56860148Protecting Spirit Loagaeth. I mostly picked her at random because Yugioh has a ton of angels. I was going to use Guardian Angel Joan before I realized I could make a whole Joan of Arc chart.
>>56858907monster hunter has inagami
>>56860355The funny thing about Chamelemon is that these dudes are cybernetically enhanced to also have chameleon camo skin
>>56853840
>>56860494I can kinda see it, but it seems like a bit of a stretch. Is there anything besides fanart that connects Gardevoir to Joan of Arc?
>>56860652is that thomas edison?
>>56860673No, it's T. Energison.
