We all have so many valid complaints about how BJJ is run. List how you would design your BJJ academy, addressing the each problem you have created a solution for. I'll start with my ideas:24 hour access to blue belts and up.Separated area for advanced members to train during fundamental class times so the entire place is not off limits. Can also be used by members who prefer to stretch or run their own warmups so they don't feel pressured to do difficult warmups when injured, old, etc.Zero class time used for discussing IBJJF rules and point systems. Offer a dedicated seminar class outside of regular class hours for this if you even want to focus on competition.Be proactive in making sure members are appropriately matched for drills. A 200lb 40 year old man and a 115lb 20 year old girl who have never met are not appropriate. Not due to sex or age, but body type, and everyone deserves a productive class where they have an appropriate body to work with.No stripe White belts are not allowed to interrupt to ask questions. But Blue belts are tasked with helping them and addressing them during drills. Can ask individually after class. This sucks up so much time and annoys seasoned members who just want to drill the move.Adhere strictly to the old school system of promotion roughly based on years in and objective progress unless someone is a phenom for which early promotions can be justified by competition results. If a student is especially anxious and capable perhaps go to a few regional open mats with them and see how they fare against higher belts. Never promote based on being the big fish in a small pond.
no brazilian cultural memorabilia anywhere, no gracie slop pictures on the walls, no brazil flag, no portuguese terms for movesno use of the word "professor" for the instructor. He's not a professor of anything, he barely has a GEDno gi, if you want to wear a gi you can go to the biweekly judo class and learn a real sport with itno retarded PE class group callisthenic warmups wasting everyones timeno static repping, this isn't aikido class. all drills are to be done live with resistanceno under belts asking questions of upper belts, they're customers trying to work out too and it's not their job to teach you anythingno upper belts "showing stuff" to white belts without getting the OK from the instructor first. If you want to teach fill out a job application otherwise stay in your laneno laying on your side while the teacher is talking, it's disrespectful. If you're too tired sit up straight then go homeand god help you if you're a white belt and you get in the way of competition prep like what happened the other day when this kid is sitting on our side of the mat talking to someone on the bench and does a back roll to "show him something he saw online" and crashed heads with one of the guys mid roll prepping for a quintet competition our gym is participating in. I just about blew my topmost important of all, members do not ever wash the fucking mats! they're paying money for a clean facility, it's not their job to clean up after class. The owner needs to get off his lazy ass and pick up a mop himself.I don't know, thats just off the top of my head but I'm sure there's more
>>220494>>220496no wonder your martial art is dying.You guys cant agree on anything and are always in fighting like a bunch of women in their period.You cant just be chill and relaxed like judoka. always have to act like you just got out if prison. No wonder you guys always get beat by judoka. Too insecure to come up with a system that benefits everyone. No wonder you have to charge exuberant prices to people who have no idea that there are cheaper and much more effective martial arts around the corner.matter of fact ignorance is the only reason bjj is still relevant.>People hear from influencer that bjj is really good>go to class>get ass kicked day one>"wow this js really good">$200 a month for classes>wow this must be normal>has no idea about other martial arts outside of BJJ>thinks bjj is an unstoppable force because their professor with a horrible win loss ratio says so.>meanwhile the judo school around the corner charges like $50/month
>>220499>meanwhile the judo school around the corner charges like $50/monthand you learn everything bjj teaches you without the fucking gay gatekeeping of "you arent ready yet"
>>220499Bjj = dyingJudo = already dead and buriedYou can only charge $50 a month or less and work on a volunteer basis because that's all its worth
>>220504how's the transition coming along?
>>220506>can't take anyone down because it's not winter in Minnesota and your attacker doesn't have a double weave wool coat on>gets touched 3/4 of an inch below the waist line>AGH AH NOO I DONT KNOW WHAT TO DO KANO SENSEI HELP MEEEE>panics and rolls over into a turtle desperately waiting for someone to call mate and save you>get choked and offer no more resistance than just gritting your teeth as hard as you can and hoping his arms get tired before you pass outquite the grappling art you have there, I can see why it's so popular
>>220507>made up shit because he cant come up with a realistic scenario in which judo loseskekclassic, sounds like someone needs to take a hot shower to warm up
>>220508>cant come up with a realistic scenario in which judo losesyou lost in that there's no less than 5 threads on this board discussion various aspects of bjj and the judo thread hasn't managed to hit bump limit in over 2 months and hasn't been posted in for 3 daysthat's why you're coming in to shit up someone elses topic
>>220509sounds like the shower wasnt hot enough
>>220509>he has to have more than one thread to feel relevant
>>220510oh are you the guy that has been trying to convince people for a week now that running in circles is a good use of their training time (which they're paying for) maybe that's why nobody is going to your judo classes>>220511funny I don't see many bjj schools clamoring to find a judo black belt to teach classes. It's always the judo places that can't pay their rent so they're starting bjj classes to get people in the door
>>220512>funny I don't see many bjj schools clamoring to find a judo black belt to teach classesbecause they dont need to if they can just teach you to scoot on your ass.What kind of logic are you using?I think you need estrogen blockers
>>220513so we're in agreement, judo has no value and there's no point in learning it
>>220496You sound like a massive faggot
>>220514>t. too afraid to fight a judoka>>220516most bjj fighters are
>>220494>Competent instructor>Actual structured curriculum>Lots of sparring>No elitism and sucking off higher belts
>>220518>most bjj fighters areNo, BJJ fighters are homosexual. Not every homosexual is a faggot and not every faggot is a homosexualThat anon seems to be both thoughever
>>220520>No, BJJ fighters are homosexual
>>220496>no brazilian cultural memorabilia anywhere, no gracie slop pictures on the walls, no brazil flag, no portuguese terms for movesI don't have any reason to disagree here. The lineage stuff has gotten way out of hand.>no use of the word "professor" for the instructor. He's not a professor of anything, he barely has a GEDI have a masters. But the whole professor thing is ridiculous.>no gi, if you want to wear a gi you can go to the biweekly judo class and learn a real sport with itKYS>no retarded PE class group callisthenic warmups wasting everyones timeAgree>no static repping, this isn't aikido class. all drills are to be done live with resistanceActually mentally retarded>no under belts asking questions of upper belts, they're customers trying to work out too and it's not their job to teach you anythingThey're going to ask regardless. But the owner should never encourage much less require upper belts to pair with lower belts. I have been victim of this many times and it makes me incredibly angry. I did not sacrifice whatever else I could be doing to help someone else's clients.>no upper belts "showing stuff" to white belts without getting the OK from the instructor first. If you want to teach fill out a job application otherwise stay in your lanePurple and above showing White is ok. Cuts down on dumb questions.>no laying on your side while the teacher is talking, it's disrespectful. If you're too tired sit up straight then go homeBut I thought you hated all that?
>and god help you if you're a white belt and you get in the way of competition prep like what happened the other day when this kid is sitting on our side of the mat talking to someone on the bench and does a back roll to "show him something he saw online" and crashed heads with one of the guys mid roll prepping for a quintet competition our gym is participating in. I just about blew my topComp prep should be limited to people signed up to compete>most important of all, members do not ever wash the fucking mats! they're paying money for a clean facility, it's not their job to clean up after class. The owner needs to get off his lazy ass and pick up a mop himself.If someone seeks to be enslaved let them choose their own path
>>220524>But I thought you hated all that? It's a far cry fromm requiring people to blow smoke up someone's ass to having the common decency to sit up and listen attentively when they're speaking Allowing people to lay on the mat like it's a couch is one of those little cancers That turns into people having side conversations or hanging out in the locker room when class is supposed to have started, or going to the bathroom and leaving their partner waiting The mat is for training use the space correctly or get off of it
>>220504The fuck you talking about? Judo has been an internationally renown grappling art since the 1950s. I respect BJJ and it's growing ever more popular but judo has way more practitioners and it still has stacked competitions.My only criticism with BJJ is too many Indians not enough chiefs, they lack a real international governing body like Judo has with the IJF or Sambo with FIAS.
>>220528The IBJJF tries to be that, but no one likes themBut the way it is now works I think. No governing body, every tournament has similar but somewhat different rules that you have to read up on before competingMy only problem with this is that there is no curriculum and objective standards for progression, belts are mostly vibe based. It works, but I like having some structure and a concrete objective to work towards, rather than a vague "just git gud", true as it may be
>>220530 This is done purposely, Remaining nebulous is by design, So this Mexican dude in California can come up with all the 10th planet stuff, and a kiwi in New York City can develop entire leg lock system nobody has ever seen before, And this lanky white Hawaiian kid can invent all of these revolutionary lapel guards And the Brazilians can sit back and take credit for all of it because they never defined what bjj actually is
>>220530the ibjjf is completely absent from the sport and diesnt regulate anythingwhat the fuck are you talking aboutthey're literally just a figure headthey do so little for the sport aside from tournaments they may as well not even exist.
>>220535They are the arbiters of da rulezWhy is passing to side control good? Ibjjf said soWhy are hooks good? Same reasonWhy can't you heel hook in the gi? You guessed itHow come people only pull guard and don't learn takedowns? Ibjjf says its only worth 2 points so it's a waste of timeWhether you participate in their tournament or not they are the defacto rules all the gyms follow
>>220494>>220512i like how everytime this faggot makes a thread it's just him getting shit on for his dumb ideas
>>220537I didn't make the thread, you quoted 2 different peopleHave fun running in circles tho, really gonna accelerate your grappling for sure. Just keep at it! Eventually you'll get that blue belt
>>220539you're really annoyingnot in a good way you come off as an insecure faggot. No wonder bjj is dyingno one wants to be around this.
>>220539and i dont even train bjj.I think bjj is fucking stupid as a defense system and as a sport
IBJJF have an increasing stranglehold due to belt recognition and the huge focus on competition. Now you have to be an accredited two stripe black to promote to black. Once upon time a black belt was it. You were your own man. Now if you don’t get all that paperwork it makes your school look ghetto and students may be upset their belt doesn’t “count.” It’s awful. Plus they lowered the required time spent at a belt before promotion below what it had historically been accepted as (10 years for black unless you make some objective case). Now it’s like 7? Absolute shit. I saw people I brought to their first class when I was purple get black belts before me because they stayed at a newer school that desperately wanted to look legit and fast tracked every guy they could get away with it for with ZERO comp wins to back it up. It undermines the entire integrity of the black bet. There should be some regulation but IBJJF do it all wrong.
>>220542that's a lot of words to say the ibjjf does nothing
>>220541So you came into a thread about bjj gyms for...reasons
>>220544i came in to talk about how much bjj sucks and how much of a faggot you arebjj fighters can do shit>get beaten by wrestlers>get beaten by judoka>get one tapped by boxersyour sport is a joke and you're a faggot
>>220545>cancant*
>>220545I don't think I'm the one that sounds insecure and annoying around here
>>220547kek
>>220572bjjfags... it's overi'm starting judo
>>220572This is in my area. I was shocked to see this troonthing wearing a black belt so I looked into it and the first thought that came to my mind was OF COURSE he's one of Gina's students.Gina sucks, is a cunt, has her gay little leftist school Uptown Minneapolis, and requires students to address her as Ma'am. I've been at a few events where "males" from her academy were present and their presence always made me queasy. The Minneapolis BJJ scene in general is full blown AIDS but they really carry the standard high. The only surprising thing about this is it is located in Northfield, which is pretty rural. Royce Gracie used to train a filthy rich Native guy there one on one who opened a Royce academy in Shakopee. Mostly a kids program. But still he did it out of passion cause that dude does not need a single dollar. I feel like he probably should have opened in Northfield instead to protect the local children from this predator. There is no way Northfield has enough queers to keep this place financially viable and they must drive in from the city.
>>220582>There is no way Northfield has enough queers to keep this place financially viableAre there any other martial arts gyms? Maybe people just don't care or put up with the queer stuff so that they have a place to train. And who knows, maybe this person is a decent coach
>>220583Try to remember what Minneapolis is. The entire woke revolution blew off here from George Floyd. When the weather is nice enough to be outside I see a new tranny almost every single day. Very unsettling place if you are not a sick freak. There are dozens of schools much closer and they are not full of trannies. It's safer to assume they all commute to be at this place.
>>220583Taps sig.
>>220584I meant people from Northfield, anon. There seem to be two BJJ gyms in that city, so not many choices if you don't want to commuteAnd fwiw, if you ignore the "1 star because gay" reviews (which is about half of them), most seem to praise the instructor. So probably a decent teacher but also a terminal activist
>>220582>The Minneapolis BJJ scene in general is full blown AIDS but they really carry the standard highnot high enoughin judo it's either blue or white gi or you cant do judo
>>220494>>220496Man you guys make so happy I switched to a mma gym when I was still a one strip.No one cares about anything but have fun and getting better.None of the bs about rules and RESPECT
>>220536ThisI am waiting till they drop the names and just have submission grappling. It doesn't matter to me if the move I use is bjj judo or wrestling as long as it works.
>>220587As if those aren’t from every gag they know. Come on anon. Use your brain.
>>220542Do people actually care about belts? My impulse is that belt progression systems are for kids. I don't really care if I ever get a different color belt.
>>220763Without a hekkin belterino how am I supposed to make people respect my authority?
>>220582HOLY SHIT LMAO YOU'RE SO FUCKING RIGHT.Where do you train? I even made a list of all the BJJ schools in Minneapolis & ranked them by how shit they are & hers was at the bottom of the list. Her school didn't even have a 24% win rate. Shit was ATROCIOUS. I left minneapolis after shitting all over The Cellar & making their instructor's look like a fucking retards heel hooking & toe holding them every roll. The BJJ scene in Minneapolis is actually cancer.I made this in 2022 btw. Don't even get me started on how shit Akagi is. Holy fuck.
>>220494A boxing gym. Your meme martial art is only good for getting stabbed
>>220763belts mean fuck all in bjj considering sandbagging is a common occurence in the sport
>>220496Half of this is bullshit, the other half is very relatable
>>220820I think largely the claims of sandbagging comes from the skill level of the average practitioner getting lower every year, so anyone looking half way competent get accused of sand bagging
>>220829Idk, you sometimes hear about people competing at WB despite having photos of podiums from 5 years ago or something ridiculous like that. Some people just don't care how they get that medal
>>220829Look at daisy fresh they get so much hate for sand bagging but they will promote anyone who comes in and passes there test.Heath just has old school standards that aren't about money or making parents happy there kid got a black belt.>>220833>WBI am sorry but all I can think of is westside barbell, what do you mean?
>>220838>[color][object]
>>220839Ah fair gotta ya
>>220770Yes the scene has terminal cancer but not every school sucks. That Team Sakuta ranking is SouthSide. The dude who runs that is completely insane. Like in a sort of impressive way. It took him years to get an affiliation because the locals he was under got him blacklisted. I don't recall the initial drama. But then he went rogue for a while and his whole merchandise campaign was #unaffiliated. Wore it like a badge of honor and created this intensely competitive school that won all the local white and blue belt matches since they could not do IBJJF. Then he shacked up with one of his female students and all the cucks hate him 2x for that. He is driven by pure spite. I have no idea how his upper belts fare but any home grown ones should just be getting to the purple level if I recall the timeline correctly.M-Theory has a lot of Worlds and Pans gold on the wall. Of course Greg Nelson's Academy is legit, both are Sauer. Alliance is run by a holster sniffing douchebag manlet no one outside of that cult can stand being in the same room with. And there are spots of light here and there at other places but mostly it's all about the business aspect now. I can't think of anywhere that has more than 40 students that is not family focused at this point and personally I don't like sharing an academy with children due to germs, that their parents often train after kids class and the children wander around, etc. Most of the GFTeam places are kid-heavy.The Cellar was known for BJJ a looooong time ago when Marcelo Nunes was the instructor. And believe me you would not have an easy time with that man. He teaches at Zenith HQ now I think. Now i's more of a Muy Thai place. Everyone who was any good left when Marcelo left, and the few who hung on left a couple years ago.
>>220770Part 2The Gracia Humaita school is the passion project of some unbelievably rich Native guy who did like all of this training personally with Royce so to see them on the board is odd because I thought they were kind of self defensy. To see him beating out GFT by even 1% is pretty funny because GFT have a load of affiliates and the main guy is from Brazil and I believe the highest ranking black belt in MN.Akagi is probably better now than it was then. But there is a definite attitude issue there. I kind of liked the head instructor but everyone around him have bad vibes.
>>220820Well to me the main issue is that belts are given by individual dojos/gyms and rely on the judgment of the people there, so a belt is not a hard reliable metric. Like if someone tells me something is 2 yards long, I know exactly how long that is. If someone tells me they're a brown belt, I don't know precisely what that means.And just to be clear, I don't think it's worth drilling down on further. I'm not saying the system should be fixed or even could be, it just is what it is and if people like that fine but I can't imagine taking it that seriously. Skill should be fairly obvious even when you lose and lack of skill fairly obvious even if you win. If you know you know.
Oh i got it>dump the BJJ entirely>turn it into a boxing/kickboxing/muay thai gymIts perfect now
>>220852i think there needs to be more accrediation for rank because from what i can tell from irl and here on 4chan it's really pick and choose >oh jm a blue beltand then they either shit test you or they scower social media attempting to find a photo of you with your instructor wearing your blue belt
>>220855like there are some schools in judo that will not let you train there unless you're willing to retest for your belt or you have a piece of paper that says you are who you say you are.You can have all the social media proof you wanf if you arent accredited you cant train there
>>220855I've only ever gone to one place so I haven't had that problem yet, but that's a thought I hate.>I'm a brown belt>OH YEAH PROVE ITI'd probably just tell them my old place didn't have belts, I don't need that shit in my life.The main problem I'd see with accreditation is that then you have to have standards for what means what that applies to at least most gyms, which means you need everyone or just about everyone to agree on and comply with those standards, and you need enforcement/inspection mechanisms to make sure the rules are followed which would cost money. Which I don't know if IBJJF has the capacity to do that? Or motive to try. It would be nice though, because then that black belt would be like a degree you can take with you anywhere. Like being in the Seals or having a purple heart or something.
Redpill me on bathsalts ben
>>220857This is why if you are serious about it you find a way to get your black from someone beyond reproach like a coral belt, or some luminary like Mendes, Galvao, Danaher, etc. And even then it can be a crap shoot cause sometimes guys get old, have kids, and care more about the money and start awarding black belts to all sorts of undeserving cretins to keep their income going and people hear about it and see it on IG. I moved a lot and never had a close relationship with any coach nor did any individual influence my BJJ in any serious way so when it was time for me I found a coral belt who offered a test as long as you could convince him it was the best path for you. And it was not easy or simple. It had around 140 combinations you had to design and demonstrate. Imagine having to come up with 6 COMBINATION escapes from north south. It took months to design, more to memorize, and this was after I had been training for well over a decade already. When I saw every shit brown belt I used to smash get awarded black belts on Christmas regardless of their skill from the school I left a month prior I was so sick of the bullshit that I didn't want to spend another X amount of years having to impress some new guy I don't give a fuck about and spend a boatload of money and attend classes constantly I was bored to death attending so I went that route and the coral belt agreed given my history. And I am glad I did. I'm not beholden to any local asshole.
>>220859You could just go to a globetrotters camp and ask to be testedYou can be promoted if all black belts there unanimously agree
>>220861That doesn't go down the way you think it does and I think IBJJF stopped recognizing those promotions.
>>220864It was purely political, some bullshit reason about how the head of the organization doesn't verify the promotions as though heads of checkmat or gracie barra are personally signing off on every promotion that happens within the affiliationThe reason is they didn't like that globetrotters was giving people a way to participate in ibjjf tournaments without having to pay ibjjf fees to get their gym chartered since globetrotters doesn't charge anything to be in the associationBut anyway, that only matters if you care about their certification which I don't. I have no interest in participating in their tournamentsThere are many other high status organizations that allow people to participate without annual fees
>>220858He's unstoppable when he's on bath salts.
>>220865>It was purely politicalAs is almost every black belt promotion.