So let's say a Soul Eater remake is actually announced later this year for a target spring 2028 release to celebrate the original anime's 20th anniversary. The real question is...who should make it?Should they go back to Bones or stay with David Pro?
you could've just posted in the other thread
>>287276983science saru
>>287276983previous thread >>287234471
>>287276983Full respect for DaviPro, but I vote for Bones. They proved themselves last time.
>>287276983>Should they go back to Bones or stay with David Pro?Mappa or Ufotable. I prefer Mappa since Ufotable will probably make a movie of each arc.
>>287278162>M*ppa No, God no.
>>287276983Fuck off. You already made this thread. >>287242799
>>287278061>>287277070FOOL the last thread already ended on the greatest post>>287277797
>>287278162>CrappaFuck off
>>287277089Hell yeah, their psychedelic art style and crazyness fits perfectly with Soul Eater.
>>287276983MAKA CUTE
>>287278162Mappa and all of the garbage shonen they animate deserve each other. SNK, CSM, JJK, etc all a match made in heaven.
>>287277089tpbp
>>287278473The problem is that they would probably cut the anime into 4 seasons of 12 episodes each.
>>287278884So? The original Soul Eater anime was only like 50 episodes. That comes out to around the same length.
>>287278162
>>287278884Hmm, that wouldn't be so bad, splitting it into seasons would end up increasing the hype. I'd only change the number of episodes to 13.>1st season with 13 episodes ending with the Asura's awakening>2nd season with 13 episodes ending with the Arachne's defeat>3rd season with 13 episodes ending with Stein and Marie kicking Justin's ass>4th and final season with 13 episodes adapting the moon war.
>>287279425Someone please contact Science Saru NOW!
>>287279425>52 episodes for 25 volumesAre you insane? This needs around 70 episodes.
>>287279518Yeah, without a doubt a production committee will approve 70 episodes for a Soul Eater remake, sure. It's not going to happen and you know it. Just make a few cuts here and there and everything will be fine.
>While the Fire Force series acts as prequel and the Soul Eater series taking place in the "distant future", the latter series features instances, information, and events (World War I, election of President Kennedy, existence of ancient Egyptians, etc.) that suggests both a prehistory, ancient history, and world history similar to the real world. How this is the case is unknown due to the former series' setting taking place around 250 years in the future compared to the real world and latter series chronologically taking place after.How can this be explained?
>>287280825>not the same WW I>not the same Kennedy>not the same EgyptiansAt no point in the series do they refer to this president Kennedy as JFK, he wasn't even killed. As for the Egyptians and ancient stuff, a lot could have happened in those more than 800 years.
>>287276983Fuck a remake, just go watch the original
>>287281062I've already watched it and now I want a remake. Fuck you.
>>287281055Another possibility is that ShinrabanshÅ-Man brought back or reincarnated the souls of everyone who lived before the great cataclysm. I mean, Shinra had god-like powers, creating crazy creatures and even messing with space and time.
>>287280825>World War I, election of President Kennedy,When? This is simply explained by Shinra recreating the entire world up to this point, this would include the other continents, like Egypt that used to exist, but now clearly don't follow the same rules our mummies do. Following the 3D > FF > Shinra's memory path of creation the animals got
WARNING DO NOT OPEN
>>287281062I want to see animated the rest of the manga and there's no point on rewatching the original one.
>>287281249>>287281055>>287280825First time I read it I assumed Shinra re-created Earth from the start, like before dinosaurs, and evaluated it by fast forwarding in time. This is how I understood his statement of recreating it an unknown number of times before he landed on version that works for his goal.
>>287281062Retard. The original Soul Eater only adapted a 1/3rd of the manga and then went anime original. People don't want a remake because the original anime is old or they think it looks bad. You're getting mad about a series you've obviously never watched or read. And since you're probably going to say:>But then they should just do what Blue Exorcist did and ignore the anime original stuff and continue from the canon content!Well, look what good that did for Blue Exorcist. It was dead as fuck and got zero traction despite it being a really popular work back in the day. So little of Soul Eater was adapted that you might as well start over from scratch, which will help bring in a new audience.
>>287281325
>>287281298>>287281325>>287281521VICTORYANDGLORYhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bugPnuKjQD4
>>287281805
>>287276983David Pro is the best so why change it? Also I love Soul Eater as much as the next guy but the quality of the anime is only really god tier for the first 3 episodes, I think David Pro could stay consistent for a longer time.
>>287276983.........Pink Pineapple
i must say, shinrabansho-man looked really fucking cool in the anime.
>>287282623Thanks, man. That means a lot.
>>287279518So three double cour seasons? Easy peasy>>287279670If they approved Ranma, I don't see why not. The real question is will it be garbage that cuts everything out like the Ranma remake?
>>287244115I never got a name...
>>287280825All the same stuff happened just at different times
>>287281514They should indeed do what Blue Exorcist did if they're going to do anything at all. Especially because there's almost no way it would look nearly as good as the original. I mean just look at the OP would never be and to animate something like that.
>>287276983How did it so effortlessly beat out every other nu-Shonen?? All Ohkubo really had to do was be a half decent writer it seems
>>287283244Ohkubo and his works don't have the same cultural impact as Rumiko Takahashi's classics. That's why I find it hard to believe any production committee would care about Soul Eater in that way.
>>287276983a collaboration between both
>>287278162>mappa If your not talking about CSM reze quality, you have really low standards. Not to mention that you like waiting 5 or 6 years between a season and another
>>287280825We don't know the time scale between FF and SE. Could be 10000 years for all we know. It's AT LEAST a thousand
>>287279518Eh FMA had 27 volumes with 64 episodes. At most you do 60 episodes. You could totally do 52 if you speed up lesser fights
>>287287853So how do you explain history repeating itself with the same people? Did Shira mess with space-time or something?
>>287278896the original soul eater anime only adapted 1/3 of the manga and then went into an anime original ending.
>>287288934Japanese view on reincarnation/samsara
>>287288934They are not the same people or historical events, for Death's sake
>>287284379Taiki Konno I believe.
>>287276983why do the kids of Shinra look very different from him and a carbon copy of 1. Inca and 2. Arthur? His genes are that weak?
>>287276983David.
>>287276983>you will get your remake >it's made together with netflix
I've heard people say the manga ending is shit and that the anime original ending is way better. Is that cope or true? I remember people saying the same shit about FMA before Brotherhood.
>>287280825Shinra saw the world before the Great Cataclysm and included elements from it in the Soul Eater world, ezpz
>>287291350if anything, it is the opposite.
>>287276983Anyone who remembers Fire Force S1 and Stone Ocean should know that David Production is not to be trusted.
>>287292985I thought S1 was good. I remember it being faithful to the manga and the sound design on Shinra's jet boosts was really good. I also liked Stone Ocean but I'm an anime-only for that
>>287293037FF S1 had some of the most schizophrenic editing I have ever seen in a mainstream series. The dude chiefly responsible basically got fired over it. The Stone Ocean anime was a fucking slideshow, someone post the godawful webm of Made in Powerpoint.
>>287281325Goddammit why didn't you warn me
>>287292985Stone ocean was like that because of netflix.
>>287278162I'm so tired of Studio MAPPA animating every big shounen. Can we please just let other studios flex for a change. Is that really so much to ask for? I would also like the staff to be forced to kill themselves just to make a good product. It was nice being able to watch Mob Psycho 100 S3 knowing that it's quality was not paid for by kuroshi bullshit.
>>287291350Not even close. That was just a troll. The anime original ending made me die of cringe. It makes absolutely no sense and ties up 0 loose ends. It's literally just your average power of friendship ass-pull bullshit ending.
>>287291350The ending in both is bad, but the fight against Asura in both is good, especially in the manga.
>>287276983i didnt hop into the original thread, so i want to say that it was a great rideeven though FF had a lot of quality and goofy animations, they delivered in the most important partsit was fun
>>287295180i want madhouse to animate soul eater remake
Descendant of Arthur or Haumea?
Over 10,000 years of PURE African DNA.How did he do it?
I never got why people say the ending of the manga sucks too, at what point does it start becoming bad? Do people not like the moon war and final fight? Is it just people not liking the boob stuff in the last chapter?
>>287296134Haumea, Arthur's descendant is Mifune.
>>287296756The moon war and the final fight are great, what's bad is the way it all ends. Ohkubo rushed everything so that the manga would end as quickly as possible.
>>287290002Anon... I meant the catbox, not the anime illustrator.
>>287301083That's just the genga I believe, there's no artist source. https://gelbooru.com/index.php?page=post&s=view&id=7269510
It would be pretty baller if the team making YAIBA at WIT Studios did a full Soul Eater adaptation, but beggars can't be choosers.
>>287301820Whoa, I wasn't expecting it to be actual production stuff.Thanks, I will try to look more into it.I actually thought it was some draw anon or something.
>>287281325Fuck you.
>>287281325Ah, poor guy, I like him.
>>287276983>real question is...who should make it?>Should they go back to Bones or stay with David Pro?Don't care as long as the ost remains unchanged
Why do people take some of the things Inca said at face value? I think is kind of obvious she is interested in him on a romantic level. She basically wants for him to chase her all the time, and at some point she told him they would fall in love
>>287303713It would be great if they kept the same art style too, but that's practically impossible. As long as it's something close to FF and nothing like SE NOT, it's fine I guess...
>>287276983A reminder that Black*Star was the first honored onehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h8JQMTkYxoU
>>287284455>Especially because there's almost no way it would look nearly as good as the originalso also like Blue Exorcist in that regard
