For anyone who remembers my What If? storytimes from last year, don't worry - I've pared things down to the stuff that's ACTUALLY SoP-worthy
>FIGHT CLUB 2>>#1-3>>144621227>MORRISON/MILLAR JUDGE DREDD>>144632783>WARRIOR>>Ashcan>>144634801>NASH>>Preview>>144634921
Also, please be aware that 4chan is being real fucking retarded for some reason, so things may not progress as smoothly as I wish.
>>144635370I thought the original What If was generally well regarded, no?
>>144635441No run is completely perfect. Besides, this was the inspiration for Jason Aaron's run on Thor, which should be justification by itself.
>>144635460>Besides, this was the inspiration for Jason Aaron's run on ThorAh, right.Carry on then
Now, let us move swiftly onto What If? v2
You'd better get used to all the Wolverwank - it was a real mainstay in What If? as Spider-Man getting killed.
>>144635642Who doesn't love a good old bit of Wolverwank?
>>144635370Your storytimes last year weren't even that bad. So far this year you'd posted actual shit. Now you're back to posting stuff that is nowhere near SoP worthy.
>>144635441Minifig has highly questionable judgement about what is or is not Storytime of Pain caliber.
>>144635893Not doing your case any favors. This issue is better than it has any right to be given the creative team.
>>144635914>Jim Valentino>Rob LiefeldYeah, you'd think this shit would be a fucking disaster. It's really not.There's very little of the early What If? v2 that's actually BAD.Now the post-DeFalco chunk of the run on the other hand... You might have a case there. (Though to be fair this applies to Marvel in general.)
Now, the first story in this issue is one of the best What If?s ever told...
... good job I'm only covering the second one, then!
>>144636220Is this the only where Reed smacks a hoe?
>>144635421At least th art is good
>>144636466Now you're getting into some actually bad comics.
>>144635421You know? Thordis would have been the ideal Marvel's version of Wonder Woman.
>>144636469Who tf is shard??
>>144636765Lmfao
This might be the stupidest ending to any issue of What If?, and that's saying something
>>144635642To be fair, Wolverine dies a lot in What ifs too. I'd dare say he and Spider-Man are tied in how many times.
>>144635914Liefeld drew feet!?
>>144636964I'm as shocked as you are.
>>144636964In all seriousness, the inker probably did it for him.
>>144637085Oh dear god...
Well, so much for v2.
We limp now towards v3, which was mostly Bendis stories iirc
God, the fucking ego on this bald prick.
Anyway, time for 00s Claremont at his most mediocre.
>>144635393pretty solid choices so far.
>>144637866I'd like to think I learned a few lessons from my overzealousness last year...
>>144637279>v3OK, now we're into actual proper shit.
Good news: I've only got one more What If? thread for this week.Bad news: I still have one more What If? thread for this week.>>144638204
>>144635997He did the thing!
>>144637251The base concept matches, but the execution was awful.
Bad timing. Or maybe good timing, I'm not sure.
