Quick rundown>We're making an anthology made up of a compilation of short pony clips.>No need to be high quality and flashy, but of course if you want to make something more ambitious like an animation please go ahead.>There is no need to volunteer to do the final editing. I can handle that myself. Thank you.How do I contribute?>Make pony related clips! It can be a PMV, YTP, Animation, or whatever.>Please render them in 1920x1080 resolution, 29.97 OR 23.976 FPS, and using progressive scanning.>Upload them to your preferred file hosting site and post them here with a title and the sources used or what it is parodying.Deadline?June 21st 11:59 PM PSTIf you have a high quality submission that you don’t want leaked to the internet early, please email to the address provided below. Submissions through the email will still be added to the spreadsheet.Email: ZWRpdGFub25tbHBAcHJvdG9uLm1lSpreadsheet: http://tinyurl com/3wrxtf53Resources>2021 anthology, submissions, and threads: https://derpy.me/DR3L8>2022 anthology, submissions, and threads: https://derpy.me/FCzOF>2023 submission spreadsheet: http://tinyurl com/ycxzeu68>MLP Episodes and Movies:MP4: DL from Heartshine (ensure you're on 1080p, it defaults to 480p) https://mlp.heartshine.gayMKV: DL from yayponies, iTunes Raw 1080p https://yp1.yayponies.no>Video editing software: Da Vinci Resolve (Be sure to download the free trial version. Latest versions support MKV.) https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/products/davinciresolve/>Audio Recording Software: Audacity https://www.audacityteam.org>Vocal Remover and Isolation https://vocalremover.org>Talknet (Visit the Pony Preservation Project thread)Some guidelines/restrictions:-No pornPretty self-explanatory. NSFW and suggestive submissions are welcomed of course, this just refers to straight up porn images and videos.-Anthro/barbies will be evaluated on a case by case basis>But this just means you’re going to sneak in furshit!Remember last year the problem with the Gurren Lagann submission? This does not mean I am going to allow any anthro or EQG. If it has merit, it will be considered. Anything explicitly or unironically anthro/EQG won’t be allowed. Calm down.-No politics or fandom dramaThis may be somewhat lenient depending on what the submission is, but we want to avoid too much /pol/ circlejerking or submissions that spend time bitching about Twitterfags or the like.>All submissions must be in 1080p and should keep their original aspect ratio. Letterbox them when needed. No portrait submissions.>No static image submissions.>Submission lengthKeep it brief. Anything longer than 1 minute will be evaluated on a case by case basis.>G5 inclusionlol. Is there even any content to use? If there are any submissions, they will be decided on a case-by-case basis.>AI generated videos-Evaluated on a case by case basis. If it has merit, it will be considered. If it’s just slop, it probably won’t make the final cut.
SUBMISSIONS ARE STILL OPEN UNTIL THE DEADLINEAnd a reminder! There will be a Wrap-Up Stream directly after the premiere with guest co-host Jhaller, creator of the original Ponies the Anthology series. Come join us for discussions on video editing, thoughts, and any questions you may have.
>>41173086>vtumors in first replyYou're trying very hard to meet your faggotry quota right off the bat, OP.
Reposting entry in new bread.Title: [GMOD] The Small Companion Horse: Antithology Editionhttps://pomf2.lain.la/f/6kyd9a75.mp4This is basically a remake of a video of mine from 4 years ago (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tFaSiSABF4Q) [Open]. I had an original idea, but it did not work out the way I thought it would, but I still wanted to make something for this and was already running out of time. This is a little bit closer to the inspiration (Doctor Lalve's Tiny Desk Engineer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e5v01iAfQvQ [Open]) of the original video with an added short "customer testimonial" section. I thought of making this a sequel to that original video at first, but then I realized it wouldn't make sense for those who never seen my videos before and feel out of place. So having something unique to the antithology is a better approach and I can make a sequel of it for next year!
ATTENTIONTO THE ANONS WHO SUBMITTED "INTERNET PONE" AND "RAINBOW DAESH" YOU NEED TO RESUBMIT YOUR CLIPS THEY HAVE NO AUDIO
>>41170204Finally Done!Title: Scootaloo is an Xboxhttps://files.catbox.moe/a3ic3v.mp4Pony version of https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MYSWcCyWrzI which is basically based on a scene from the Simpsons https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yD67ClenBEY
>>41173080Reposting since it was at the end of last thread I guess>>41172880Hopefully next year I'll have a better handle on things, I have an idea of something to make for the opening of the anti and several more clips.Can't wait to see this year's.
>>41173121I would absolutely recommend working on Anti submissions all year around, especially as ideas come to you. Build up a catalog to dump in the submission threads.
>>41173098I absolutely love your videos man, you perfectly capture Lalve's vibe
>>41173125that was my intent this year before I lost my job and stuff but I don't wanna drag down the thread with blogposting so I'll just say thanks to everyone who contributed and thank you for putting it together. I hope the project will return next year!
I have a few entries I've been meaning to bring upEntries 46 and 47>https://files.catbox.moe/07ezvw.mp4>https://files.catbox.moe/1earqy.mp4both of these have been on youtube now for 3 and months, respectively. Just previously made and shared videos submitted to the antihttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1NLdIwEPVdchttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8vsDWm_MzoUEntry 68>https://files.catbox.moe/693yn8.mp4at first I thought this was an original animation, but the only difference in this video from its reference material (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJDtjlMBK0E) is that the vocals were cut out, run through an ai to sound like rarity, then put back inIt doesn't break any rules or anything, but idk, just doesn't seem right to me
>>41173086When is the premiere again?
>>41173273Ah yeah, thank you for bringing these to my attention. Videos already on Youtube aren't really for the Anti. And just running a video through an AI converter is just really lazy.>>41173296June 28th, 9PM EDT
>>41173343>And just running a video through an AI converter is just really lazy.I mean using AI voices isn't what also 15.ai and PPP do? Where is the author of entry 68? Although the fact that the original is on youtube this one at least is changed to have Rarity voice isntead of some random guy
>>41173365> Where is the author of entry 68?we will never know since everyone is anonymous, duhand the author posted without any nickname
>>41173114WHY NOT ADD THE AUDIO YOURSELF YOU YELLING ARCHIVENIGGER?
>>41173401I mean if he posted here maybe he still lurks around. Still, mine was just an observation. IS up to the one putting everything together to decide
why is it called ANTIthology?I thought it is called Anthology, it is on JHaller's youtubeis there any lore behind the "ANTI" bit?
>>41173517something something JHaller's Anthology turned gaysomething something /mlp/ made "based and redpilled" version of it
>>41173517this one's just a little more "anty" 0c<
>entry 95: a tribute to minty root>https://files.catbox.moe/cms4nf.mp4this one seems a little out of place, mostly it's just really long and not really that transformative of the source material, as far as I can tellalso>longest clip in the antithology is a tribute to a namefag>a namefag that has nothing to do with the board nor the antithology
>>41173080>Deadline tonightGod dammit I thought the deadline was next week because I can't read and mentally switched it with the deadline for /mlp/con. Hopefully I can quickly scrounge something together.
>>41173549>2 minutes 30 secondsyeah nah man
>>41173517The regular Anthology went shit after few editions and JHaller (let say the main creator of the whole thing) basically gave up at some point./mlp/ people argued about making their own version and someone told JHaller about such concept who basically said "lmao you guys will never do something concrete", yet a lot of Anons made entries and the thing was called Anti-thology to mock him (but also because by being made on 4chan it can have a lot of things that the original can't have, such as racism, swearing and such). Notice that it was also 2021 so a lot of Anons had a LOT of free time since we were all locked up so that helped to make things more concrete.
Hopefully quality isnt too shit, TVpaint has been bugging out on this one for some reasonhttps://files.catbox.moe/dic38s.mp4parodying: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_yiQXPOO1Yo&thad a lot of fun with this one, one of the only perks of losing my job was getting enough time to animate again after months lol
What's it called when you "crop an outline" around a video so you can paste it over another video? I want to do that in Davinci but I don't know what the technique is called.
updated autopsy reporthttps://pomf2.lain.la/f/7af0mjo.mp4references:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBTmawSkibcTurnabout Stormfor maximum effect I'd recommend putting this one shortly after the other Turnabout Storm clip (but not immediately after)
>>41173578Masking?
>>41173273I'm against cutting stuff for effort reasons unless absolutely necessary, but #68 could go. The "popular video re-dubbed with AI" shtick is not worth 80 seconds.>>41173549It's a decently nice PMV-like video and I wouldn't mind seeing this some of kind of content in the anti, but I agree that it's far to long. Maybe if its author could cut it to ~30s?
>>41173585>I'm against cutting stuff for effort reasonssame, I have nothing against low effort clips, a lot of great clips are low effortMy problem with it is more that, being in the antithology and not being an obvious edit, it makes it seem like it's a wholly new animation created specifically for this. Like people who haven't seen or don't remember the original will just think it's new anti clip because the edit is so subtle. idk just doesn't sit right with meplus I think a lot of these animated lets play videos are only really funny if you're a fan of source material, and I never watched whoever was playing the game so it's not really doing anything for me
>>41173549Yeah I was on the fence about this one too. I'm inclined to include it because it does have some nice visuals, but it is just too long.
>>41173114>Premqueer doesn't support FLACWhat a piece of shit. Here:>Internet Ponehttps://files.catbox.moe/9feh7c.wav>Rainbow Daeshhttps://files.catbox.moe/b9i9wm.wav
>>41173561Keks. The style reminds me the Bambee animation by El-Cid
>>41173561I need a title, anon
>>41173611Fantastic, thank you!
Yo, I have a very last second submission. Crayon based melody.https://files.catbox.moe/spknkr.mp4Reference: This Anon post >>41173538
>>41173608The only reason I let it get drawn out so long is because of the song I included. There was nowhere to cut it that wouldn't sound weird and undermine the sound+visuals thing I was going for.Some anon said it would be good for including at the end of the anti given the length and I agree. If OP wants to trim it then that's cool with me since the blood would be off my hands, or just break it into multiple parts and spread them around. That would create a continuity of the song at least without it lasting forever.>>41173549Fuck you, Minty Root is cool, you are a faggot.
Also, I made this last minute>The Perfect Pear [unrated]https://files.catbox.moe/atctqp.mp4https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fRRHDXHSsM0
Deadline is here!Thanks to everyone who made soul entries and anti-thanks to everyone who made soulless ones.
>>41173791Lick my nuts nigga
12 hours till deadline
>>41173772https://files.catbox.moe/5pbw96.mp4In case you want the one where I deleted the unused clips 20 minutes down the timeline
>>41173758I never said he wasn't cool, just that this isn't really the place for a tribute vid imo
>>41173742
Is it possible for me, a total retard, to learn animation in time for next year?
>>41173852It's the calling him a namefag that really grinds my gears bucko. When you're that talented you deserve to be a namefag.
>>41173928Of course, Anon. I don't know shit about video editing and I learned to edit for the Antithology
when's the next antithology gonna happen? i was too unprepared for this one :(
>Ende Noihttps://pomf2.lain.la/f/0y3wpnxu.mp4Really rough but I haven't gotten the time to polish it up, better something than nothing I guess.Song: https://youtu.be/yRAwLxg8i2k
>>41174043Probably next year around this time
Newcomer guy again.Yeah, this one came out kinda sucky. I need better hardware/software."Horse's Tail"https://files.catbox.moe/xkp1z3.mp4Source: Rabbit Rampage (1955)Let me know if the MPEG-4 format doesn't work.
>>41174132It works!
So when's the premiere? Can't wait to see what all these anons made.
>>41173098based wapa submission
>>41173343>>41174175
>>41173928Yes, a little practice each day is key though but that'll get easier.And if self-learning is not your thing, a few classes involving practice can help you a lot.
>>41173814zigga*And perhaps later.
>>41173816Miscalculation from my part I guess.
>The ANT-itholagyhttps://pomf2.lain.la/f/vo6w97f.mp4Its ant ponies.
>Pony DDRhttps://files.catbox.moe/8zxjpk.mp4Reference: https://youtu.be/WXh7cGi5o0w?si=IRVqarKjR2rWL8u-
how to pronounce (oco)https://pomf2.lain.la/f/1st6km2c.mp4reference: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wGlBwW7f5HA
Ah shit. The 21st. Not the 27th. Oop
Title: Amethyst isn't BreadySource: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9HTT2ocfkoA (Amethyst screaming at bread)https://kissable.bluefast.horse/bvo09vy.mp4
how are we feeling on late submissions? I don't mine waiting and submitting next year but I can squeeze another one out during the weekend if editor anon will take it.
>>41174839If you can get them in over the weekend, I don't mind making exceptions.
>>41174850Cool.
>>41173080My humble and shitty submission. I'd feel bad if I didn't contribute at least something but I didn't have any great ideas. >Trixie's Phonecall>https://files.catbox.moe/lhxbce.mp4>Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5yVPnukbK6I
done. Hardware Store (Hardmare Store? I don't know...)https://files.catbox.moe/mgwfv4.mp4parodying: loose parody of https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1FwtC-1bpx0 which in turn is a parody of hardware store by weird al: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DFI6cV9slfIshorten it how you need.I tried.
>Title: Somehow Waifustealing feels good in a place like this>Source: https://pomf2.lain.la/f/8zrq79w.mp4Parody of: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KiEeIxZJ9x0&pp=ygUZbmljb2xlIGtpZG1hbiBhbWMgdGhlYXRyZQ%3D%3D
Christ I've wanted to make this dumb joke ever since I last rewatched Ghostbusters.Doggone it: https://files.catbox.moe/rjq7ym.mp4Parodying: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j__Sjj96a6I
Made it just in timeTitle: YOU, ME, WAWAhttps://files.catbox.moe/n4m5ah.mp4Source: https://youtu.be/3at_m1J1O4I
>>41173343>June 28th, 9PM EDTI need to wake up 4AM to watch that, whee! Fuck the time zones.
>>41175285
Congratulations everyone, we've set a new record for number of submissions for the Anti
>>41175718Hi OP, could I get a response why my submission >>41173742 is consider to not be included?
>>41175747No politics or fandom drama. We don't need to stir that pot.
>>41175756oh well, gonna think of something for the next year.
>>41175756Yeah i think that even it's just a silly shitpost, it can actually cause argument since JHaller is directly mentioned
>>41175718cool
wew
>>41176738>01:23thats rookie numbers, next years we should aim at getting two hours.
>>41176758Yeah, this isn't that bad. Just an hour, 23 minutes, 27 seconds, and 14.... oh.... oh no....
>>41174048based noi entry submitter
>>41175805Isn't shitting on Jhaller a tradition at this point tho? Or am I thinking of a different person
>>41173614The Ponesident goes to Dennys. Sorry, life happened lol
>>41177499Even so guidelines were made for a reason and avoiding any Drama or potential Drama is always the best option. Drama is also probably what caused the Pony Antology to become shit and then basically die out because then Anons will just opt the fuck out since they don't want to be associated with it, especially those with an easily recognizable style
>>41174850I was watching S05E15 and had to make a late submission for the latest viral slop that matched up with RD offering to clean Rarity's dress> Dashie hawk tuahshttps://files.catbox.moe/qqvfta.mp4
any last minute submissions?
Does anybody have a lead on the following clips:139 Worm158 Hoofynails4bits166 Rainbow Dash PresentsThey appear missing links in the doc.
>>41178221They were submitted through the email as attached files. No catbox links. I can make that a requirement for next year if we need to.
>>41178281Can we get a copy of them?
>>41178793I've updated the spreadsheet. They now have associated catbox links.
>>41178858Thanks.
Why'd you cut Super Numget? I like it.
>>41180004See >>41173273. It's not new.
>>41180014Ah. That's a shame.
I went through the clips marked as rejected, and I'd like to see some clarification on the three that have been stealthily cut without discussing or even mentioning it in the thread:>20. Welcome to Fuckin Appleoosa (https://files.catbox.moe/3b6t0e.mp4)>169. 2004 vs 2024 (https://files.catbox.moe/ip4ud6.mp4)>175. It's Still Over (https://pomf2.lain.la/f/xvk6eko.mp4)
>>41180030>Cutting clips without notifying the thread. I do not like how this year OP acts like it's his personal project.
>>41180078It IS my personal project, I'm the one who has to edit it.
>>41180099Okay dude, nice try.>>41180030>20There's nothing particularly interesting or funny about this clip.>169No politics. And it's not funny or original. I understand dunking on the gender nonsense, but even I'm getting bored of these jokes.>175No static image submissions
>>41180156Ahhh I messed up, used 720 for the>Dashie hawk tuahhere's 1080https://files.catbox.moe/t7hyim.mp4audio source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iMlwQ_w41EsThanks editor anon for the hard work
God I just really, really need to get fucked by a big black cock tonight like right now
>>41180364kinda weird bro
>>41180030The first one is a tough sell at 50 seconds, but the other two are fine, imo.
>>41180364OP what's wrong with you
>>41180802Well... he likes eqg and he wants to be fucked by black cocks. That's two things.
>>41180030Thx for the quick-check, I would not have noticed. I agree, if you're an Antithology hoster you have to notify people about changes, not really nice from this OP>>41180156> No politics> No static image submissionsare legit, according to the rules> There's nothing particularly interesting or funny about this clip.> And it's not funny or original.> I'm getting bored of these jokesare personal bias. We got it that these aren't funny for you, but at the same time very on-border NSFW jokes about genitalias, horse ass, sex are very original and funny for you
>>41180030>cut without discussing or even mentioning it in the thread>>41180078>OP acts like it's his personal project.>>41180858>if you're an Antithology hoster you have to notify people about changesAlright, sure, I should have been more transparent about what submissions are being omitted. That didn't cross my mind. I'm not making it my personal project, and I'm certainly not being "stealthy" about it either. I apologize, and I will be sure to post updates about those types of decisions in the future.>but at the same time very on-border NSFW jokes about genitalias, horse ass, sex are very original and funny for youWrong. There are quite a few submissions that I don't find funny or very original, but they are still in the Antithology because I know there are plenty of people that will enjoy them. I don't understand what point you're trying to get at.
>>41180364Based BBC enjoying editor
>>41180938You said you cut 20 because it wasn't funny or interesting. Your reasoning is literally entirely subjective to you. Given it doesn't break any rules, if that is the only reason then that's bullshit and you should put it back in. I think Calamity Applejack and Trixie Trixie is funny as shit. It's funnier than some other stuff that is still included. If you can arbitrarily say something gets cut because it's "not funny" you have basically given yourself the right to cut anything you want. I'd say you shouldn't take something out unless the board agrees but you saw how that went in the last thread. Unless it definitely breaks a rule don't cut it. It's bullshit and not fair, plain and simple.
>>41177577Fair enough. I just assumed given Jhaller made fun of us he was fair game, especially if it's a reference to him mocking the anti like in the first.
>>41180938>>41180966And if you make a sub that follows all guidelines but gets cut just because the op decides its not funny or interesting, why bother making shit if it can get tossed out on a whim?
>>41180966>>41180979Alright, I'll put it back in.
While we're on this subject of transparency, there are some clips that I am cutting short merely for brevity.21 https://files.catbox.moe/uiqq9c.mp4185 https://pomf2.lain.la/f/1st6km2c.mp4The gimmick of these clips gets old and stale long before they end. I for one don't care much for clips that overstay their welcome. I don't think they need to drag on for the entire duration of the original length. Are there any objections to this?
>>41181007Maybe for the numget one instead of cutting it you could add an exponential increase in speed. Or just plain speed it up so we get the full thing.Or, like has been said, release an uncut version of the anti a bit later so people get their curated version and an extended edition of sorts.
>>41181007numget is a forced meme that should be cut in its entirety.
>>41181028numget moment
>>41181007what the crap, man?!?!after all the talk with the applefried clip about how submissions shouldn't be edited without the creator's consent, you were seriously going to trim my clip without even telling anyone?!?not cool man. Please either include the whole clip as-is or just omit it altogether
>>41181109There is a difference between random anons changing other people's submissions on their behalf and me as the editor trimming certain clips for time.
>>41181109There'll be the full clip in the no EQG version.
>>41181129This IS the no EQG version.
>>41181140You are including a bunch of EQG, and there's been even more included since the last time I posted about it.
>>41181149[citation needed]
>>41181109>>41181120I still think applefried edit should be in, but trimming overlong clips has been a thing since the first anti.
>>41181151Clip 188 contains EQG for example. And there have been others added as well since the last list of EQG/Anthro/G5 made in the last thread.
>>41181169The images in that clip go by so fast I didn't even notice it. You must be some sort of turbo autist, bravo. And again>And there have been others added as well[citation needed]
>>41181174>The images in that clip go by so fast I didn't even notice iteither you're lying or you aren't paying enough attention to the clips that are submitted, neither of which is a great quality for an organizer of a project like thisgiven how many issues with clips have had to be pointed out to you, it's starting to make me suspicious of how selective you are with this stuff anyway
>>41181174Is this the famous "slippery slope" we've been hearing about?
>>41181217And you have straight up lied about what clips contain EQG. Furthermore you are acting like a tremendous faggot to get so worked up and offended over split seconds that serve as jokes and gags.
>>41181007>cutting short merely for brevity.>The gimmick of these clips gets old and stale long before they end>>41181120>me as the editor trimming certain clips for time. Objection! Since when has ANY anthology/antithology EVER cared about brevity? They always drag on, multiple clips or the whole thing. I'm serious, you think cutting 20 seconds is gonna make or break this entire project?And we've had clips in the past drag on(twikato, others that some people thought were shit but when it aired a bunch liked anyway, etc etc), that's just what you get with a project like thisThe intent/criteria for the antithology is simply for Anons to make stuff. It doesn't have to be PERFECT (funny how assblasted people get when they want it to be). If a submission is within the original time limit specified, there is absolutely no indication to cut it short/out based on how ONE individual personally feels about it.
>>41181236 see >>41181153Also, there is a difference between ONE submission being trimmed when the bit gets stale, and a COMPILATION of related clips being cut up and distributed throughout the runtime.
>>41181120I think you're getting kind of a big head. this is a BOARD project, you're an anon just like the rest of us>>41181153>I still think applefried edit should be insame honestly>but trimming overlong clips has been a thing since the first anti.-c-fine, whatever, I'm sure that's happened in the past, but still, I don't want my clip edited. So either keep the whole thing in as is or omit it entirelyor at least show the edit you want to make so the thread can decide which goes inbut just realize if you do that then it's kind of hypocritical not doing the same for the applefried clip (letting the thread decide which version goes in over the original creator, I mean)
>>41181227I'm not the anon that claimed there were more clips with EQG. You're just deflecting criticism like you usually do
>>41181248As you wish.>>41181251>>41181217>given how many issues with clips have had to be pointed out to youThe "issues" that have been brought up have been superfluous and downright nonsensical. It is silly to me to see people get worked up over jokes and blink-and-you-miss-it gags.
>>41181248>or at least show the edit you want to make so the thread can decide which goes inDeal. I've added a preview of the Anti to the spreadsheet.
>>41181338why not post it herehttps://mega.nz/file/iJs3ECjK#vNSWZ2Ti8vxk2HisFY6a17JqadFFwhVfSlu8f9uDYKM
>>41181341To prevent leaks like last year with "Sweet Victory", but go off I guess.
>>41181240The difference being, I object that it should be cut. I like it as it is.You're saying it should be cut because you don't like it. That's only ONLY reason. It fits the runtime rules already so what gives? Don't hyper focus on one example I brought up and ignore the entirety of what these projects have been.I want a better justification for removing something. If you can't give it then the clip should stay in.
>>41181373Are you still referring to "How to pronounce (oco)"?
>>41181393I'm referring to both on principle. The default for submissions should be: allowed. Unless you get multiple posters disagreeing with it.Your opinion of a submission should not hold more weight than anyone else's just because you're stitching them together. I haven't played LISA so I don't have personal attachment to the first one but it's under a minute. Both are. The how to pronounce one would make no sense if it were cut early, did you even watch the reference footage?
>>41181007>>41181393Personally, I'd much prefer to see 'How to pronounce (oco)' over any of my own submissions. If length is the only issue, would you be willing to compromise by removing some of my submissions instead? I can identify which ones I've made if you agree. I just don't want the anthology to be soured by this, and I'm willing to cut out my clips if it'll make everyone happy.
>>41181467>I'm referring to both on principle.Okay well I'm not seeking to cut those clips. I want to trim those clips. Do you understand the difference? Make them shorter. Because the gags of those clips get boring after 10 seconds. There's nothing new or interesting to be gained past that. It's the same gag with no variation. There's nothing being lost if they get trimmed down. >The how to pronounce one would make no sense if it were cut earlyIt makes no sense with the entire 45 second run time>did you even watch the reference footage?It doesn't matter. There are going to be plenty of people who won't know or even see the original reference material for every individual clip. And that's now how it works anyways. Every submission should be able to stand on its own merit without having to know the context behind it. I'm not saying the two clips in question DON'T stand on their own merit. I just think they could be more brief.>>41181502It's not the length of the Anti that's the issue, it's a matter of trimming individual clips down to a reasonable length so they don't overstay their welcome.
>>41181502I don't get why people are acting like we can't take one more time block, it's not like /mlp/con is overstuffed with panels.
>>41181516I haven't seen the original video, but I've heard the song before (who hasn't), and I find this submission funny. It's also obvious that more effort went into it compared to others (see: my submissions). If it were longer than a minute, I could understand, but it's only 40 seconds and a parody and not particularly lengthy. Personally, I'm not a fan of many jokes and references in the anthology, but would I say they should be removed? No. Someone worked hard, for nothing, during their own free time just to help make this project successful. And in this case, according to the sheet, it wasn't going to just be trimmed down either; it was to be removed entirely.
>>41181553The original contributor doesn't want it included at all if it's to be cut short. See >>41181248
>>41181565>or at least show the edit you want to make so the thread can decide which goes in
>>41181569>>41181341
>>41181571where is the edited clip in there? I couldn't find it
>>41181573I rendered the project after the oco contributor said he didn't want his clip included. Here is that section isolatedhttps://files.catbox.moe/26jxtp.mp4
>>41181583There's nothing left. Out of 45 seconds it's down to 15. It had an intentional slow buildup, leading to chaos as it went on, and now all that remains is the slow buildup. The pacing is off, the punchline is lost, and the best clips it builds up to are gone. All that work is just gone!
>>41181516If it isn't a problem of totally anti length, and it doesn't break the 1 min rule, then the only reason to intend to trim it is that it's not entertaining enough, but that's subjective, isn't it?It's the kind of decision that's to be voted on with a poll. The point of the transparency to make a post about the desicion being made is so that we get to have a say on it, no?
>>41181109How's blender as an editing software? I'm using kdenlive (yeah at this point it's way too late but I want to get something done anyways) and it seems OK but I'm wondering if blender with all the money behind it may be more useful.
>>41181611>>41181620Okay, I will reinstate both clips to their original full lengths
With stuff like this happening, I'm questioning why everyones videos arent just streamed as a queue of videos. Why is all the editing to make it into one video needed if things can be cut for whatever reason?
>>41181635NTA, but blender pretty much was able to do everything I would've wanted, especially with fine timings (for things like compiling animations that need to occur in line with the audio track) everything else I've tried just wasn't nearly as intuitive. I guess there's also the plus of having the ability to potentially integrate skills learned in this video editor with more things in the long term.
>>41181007I'd rather just keep both fully intact instead of having them butchered in some back alley like what happened to my clips last year.
>>41181652Now wait a minute: two years ago I also had to trim my entry because "it dragged for too long" according to the anon making the edit, while the whole short was under one minute and the original video had such length because it was based on a musical build-up, but now you can just complain and the trim is revoked? Whew lads, I wish I knew earlier. Maybe make it a rule that unless it's ovious that the clip is dragging for too long, the editior can't just decide to force to be shorter?I'm not mad to, since it was two fucking years ago, but just a little bothered so maybe next time we can avoid all this debacle
>>41182342I've always argued in favor of including more and cutting less, since the goal of this project is for anons to have fun making something and watching it together. It takes multiple people in thread to review submissions and debate them when quality/appropriateness is concerned, and I think I'm speaking for more than just myself when I say a lot of us don't watch submissions early anymore because we want to wait for the premiere. So you've got less people to tardwrangle each other if they don't want to be spoiled (including myself I'm retarded a lot of times too) I've also had several submissions cut out or down, it happens. Just have to move forward I guess.
>>41181583NTA but I prefer the original this one feels flat compared to the uncut one plus as other anons said, you shouldn't cut clips short if they're within the time limit except if there is a majority wanting that. this is a board project not a (you) project
>>41181652thank you!>>41181635it's pretty decent, I was able to do about 90% of what I wanted to really easily. Here and there I'd run into little roadbumps though, like the audio tools are pretty lacking. just the bare minimum for syncing stuff up I guess (and things like panning and volume, but don't expect anything like normalization or whatever). I literally looked up a tutorial for audio editing in blender and step one was to open the audio in audacity lmaoI was also surprised to find that there wasn't an easy way to chroma key. You can do it pretty easily in the 3d workspace place but for some reason the normal 3d/animation workspace doesn't connect as nicely to the video editing part as I thought it would (though maybe I'm just retarded)like to use the video editor to put text over a 3d animation, instead of just going into the video editor tab and dropping in text (which is how you add sound btw), I had to render out the 3d animation and then create another project that was just for overlay/post processing stuffbut yeah pretty much it has a weird curve where it's great for basic stuff, probably a pain for intermediate stuff, and then super powerful once you know how to use the tools in itI used blender for all my anti clips this year as an excuse/motivation to finally learn it. I've tried some of the donut tutorials but lost interest very quickly, but when actually trying to put together a video I have an idea for and interest in, one thing led to another and it was really easy to learn things step by step and figure out how everything workstldr: pretty good, lacks some tools unless you get deep into it (but getting deep into it is worth it anyway)>>41182625the original clip is already back in, we don't need to dwell on it anymore
>>41182263Which clips did you make? I know some loop-style videos were shortened but was there some more radical clipping happening too?
boop
>>41183234
How are people feeling about submission 162? https://pomf2.lain.la/f/6cq9i1ll.mp4In a previous thread we had some people chiming in with their disdain about AI videos of this caliber being included in last year's Antithology. I have no strong feelings one way or the other, but I know others feel strongly about this sort of thing.
>>41184060I would say this one is fine, as its a pisstake on all the current tiktok ai click bait videos.
>>41184060>some peoplepretty sure it was just one guy lol, I had never heard of anyone disliking solar tendies or ai voice stuff in the anti before then (or since)I agree with >>41184077, I think it's fine. Though I think it'd work better closer to the beginning of the anti
>>41184086I'll test that out. Thank you for the suggestion.
Every year I say to myself "I'll submit something next year, when I get good" and then before I know it, submissions for the next antithology are open, and I still don't know how to draw, or edit, or make anything cool.
>>41184060should be included for the 'awesom rainbow dash' line alone
>>41184116(.c.) why | tho? /|\ /\
>>41184060I'm fine with it if the objective is to make fun of it
>>41184089I watched the rough cut, but didn't the creator of the evil leponk submission say to cut it so it doesnt drag on?
>>41184096Start making it right now.
>>41184096I put off doing ideas I've had since Anti 2021 until now, most of them took me less than an hour to make. Just do it, Anon.
I know it's too late but I finished something. Feel free to ignore, I'll just submit it properly next year.Every Little Thing She Does Is Magichttps://files.catbox.moe/2kwym7.mp4Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aENX1Sf3fgQ>>41181851>>41182674Thanks, sounds like it'd be useful for animation stuff but not significantly superior otherwise. I haven't done any normalising or chroma keying but kdenlive seems to have functions for it.>>41184949>less than an hourHowEven this relatively simple one took me hours upon hours
why does the con schedule have two seperate versions of the anti? whole point of a grand premiere is to have everyone see it together.
>>41185257>whole point of a grand premiere is to have everyone see it togetherThe eqg pedos ruined any chance of that happening.
>>41185268I thought all the barbieshit was purged.
>>41185257Yeah, I don't like that I'm forced to choose between watching it with everyone (and let's be honest, the no-eqg edit will have like 10-20% of active viewers) or without eqg. I feel like the eqg in this is not significant enough to warrant the split, but at the same time it sucks that it's there.
>>41184747Oh did he? I forgor>>41185245I can still squeeze this in. You and one other anon have last minute submissions
>>41185607yeah, I think he said to cut it off like after the first three lines (at the end of "you make me happy")the original leponk one is still gonna be the same length, it's just the evil one that needs to be cut
Okay, the final cut of the Anti is rendering now. I just want to take this time to apologize to the Anons whose toes I've stepped on for the past few weeks. It was not my intention to ruin people's submissions, nor to make the Antithology my personal project. Truth be told this is my first time editing a large collabortive project of this scale. I've learned a lot about how to conduct myself when it comes to these sorts of projects. I know that clear communication is expected of me, and rules for submissions need to be more clear. If you guys can forgive me and be patient with me, I would love to come back next year as organizer/editor. Thank you all.
>>41185960It's okay. I think that when you have the imrpession something is dragging fro too long, just ask an opinion in the thread ans see what people say
>>41185960well played anon
>>41185960What's the final runtime? I'm curious how it compares to the "no eqg" version that the other anon is making.
>>411866181 hour 26 minutes
>>41185607Damn, thanks Anon, I appreciate it.>>41185960I haven't followed all the threads, but you seem to have done a decent job. And yeah, wanting to edit a clip for some reason isn't bad if the issue is really egregious in your opinion, but do run it by the thread before and generally err on the side of no edits because you might just not understand the intention. After all antithology is supposed to be less curated than anthology, that was kind of the point, but one and a half hours is starting to get real fucking long.I do wonder, how many people have had clips in both anthology projects? There's got to be some, right?
>>41186701MKog definitely has:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Hsw0aWOfMU
>>41186703Yep. Fo shohttps://youtu.be/N0CvN4mtm2Mhttps://youtu.be/MbtMYRwSbB4
>>41186703Mkog was only called later after Antithology 2 was done because before he was considered a no-no artist for some stupid reason. Also basically his entries are the only decent part in the Anthology they were put in
It seems I have posted my entry over month ago in the /mlp/con thread instead of the antithology thread like a retard.I don't have hopes of it getting in now since the antithology video is already rendered it seems but oh well, here they are anyway.https://pomf2.lain.la/f/q3t4nj8l.mp4 (1440x1080)https://pomf2.lain.la/f/5r9t2j1k.mp4 (1920x1080 w/ black bars)
>>41186703>>41186782Oh right.>>41187198>Also basically his entries are the only decent part in the Anthology they were put inDesu I never understood the "Anthology is shit now/Antithology is so much better" thing. Yeah the concept got a bit worn out after the first few but they're still fun to watch and the amount of clips I get has stayed about the same (not many and same goes for the antithologies lol).>>41187233>Editing the speech to make him say everyponynice
>>41187259Not the anon you're responding to, but the fact that new anthologies were like 50% eqg+g5 wasn't helping. They're free to do whatever they want, of course, but comparing that to the pony ones (where all content was pony, and thus for everyone rather than just the fans of one specific thing) is part of the reason why a bunch of anons are so vigilant about not letting any eqg into the anti.Also, and this is a personal reason for me, I prefer the old ones since I adore and almost idolize the older internet. Even if I don't get their joke, there's a good chance I'll eventually dig out what they were referencing and feel clever. Meanwhile I don't get almost all the "current meme" clips in contemporary anthologies and don't find them funny even when I do. This is a very "old man yelling at cloud" take, but it's true for me.
>>41185257I think people should man the fuck up and deal. I'll never like or watch EQG, but some people on the board have turned into such massive fucking pussies, and that they need a version specifically for them, to cater to their ultra autistic asses, to throw them a bone, is one of the worst things you can do. Because it means their legitimacy is great enough that they get their speshul version.>>41185960just do the one version OP, don't do two
>>41187278I suppose I've not purity spiraled enough for that, I don't like EqG and don't care much for G5, but I don't mind those parts of the anthologies and I also find the no EqG rule here stupid because art shouldn't be restricted and it's part of the franchise this board is for whether we like it or not (yeah yeah, FiM board etc. but it's ultimately part of pony and there are "people" here who like it so excluding them is stupid to me but whatever).For the older Internet part I get it although ultimately many of those old ones are also just contemporary memes or references, which makes me wonder if people will think similarly about current year an(ti)thologies in another decade or if current meme culture will always be considered stupid.>>41187369On the one hand, filters are for pussies, but on the other hand, that's what they're there for especially for easily triggered autists like we all are.
>>41187369>just do the one version OP, don't do twoThis. All you're gonna accomplish is balkanizing our viewerbase.
>>41187259>Anthology is shit now/Antithology is so much betterA lot of clips of the lastests Anthologies were extremely boring, unfunny or just there to waste your time. I don't care if they had EQG or not i recall i waited untill Mkog one appeared then stopped watching because i literally wanted to do anything else. A lot of those more creative either stopped working on pony stuff or were no longer interested so overall quality went down a lot
>>41187431The live action segments in the latest Anthology were dreadful
>>41187448I'm scared to even ask, but in which one?
>>41187431I haven't watched the latest one yet but since I've never gotten the majority of the clips I guess that reaction might just be lesser for me because that could apply to so many of them in any Anthology.
>>41187278>Meanwhile I don't get almost all the "current meme" clips in contemporary anthologies and don't find them funny even when I do.Last anthology I watched was few years ago and most of the stuff were just... boring. I still don't know half of the references they made in earlier anthologies but the clips were so well made that they were fun nonetheless. For some reason antis 2 and 3 have been solid diamond from start to finish and i really hope the high quality stays with this one too.
>>41187233Sorry anon, if you can hold it for next year we can include it then!
>>41185960will there be a premiere link on youtube?
>>41188177Most likely not. I uploaded it to Youtube and it is 100% blocked. I've uploaded it to Pony.tube. I also have a mirror uploaded to a MEGA drive. Links to both will be added to the spreadsheet after the premier.
>>41188190then where the fuck is it going to be premiering on
>>41188227>>41188224At /mlp/ con
>>41188227>>41188243Yup. Friday 9PM EDT. Cytube channel 1 for /mlp/con. Keep an eye on this thread, I'll be linking the cytube before the premier.
>>41188272I hope you only do the one singular showing, eqg anthro and all, and dont give in to the autists.
>>41188582OP isn't in charge of the second showing, that's some other guy from the previous thread doing his own thing. I don't think OP can really do much about it.
>>41188617Ah I see... well then won't the clips be all out of order and flow and their cut will be a completely different version to the original one?
>>41188633Yes
>>41188582I think what I'm going to do is during the Wrap Up stream I am going to ask the audience if they would be interested in seeing the two clips people have bitched about and were omitted out of the Anti. And then open a poll asking the audience if they would have been okay with those submissions being included.
>>41188654I think they will be okay with those, and that's irrelevant. I mean, have you seen the average /mlp/con goer? The con attracts a lot more casual fags than the board. Last year, quite a lot of them admitted to not using the board anymore. But that's why it's not substantial.The point of these antithologies has always been to celebrate what makes /mlp/, well, /mlp/. Trying to get congoers' permission to start adding eqg is pretty much the most direct way to subvert that. That was one of the reason drama/political submissions were banned after first year. This is really important; do not fuck this up, OP. I don't mind some thread drama, but this would be stepping over the line.
>>41188721Okay, so nix the poll. What about asking the people if they would be interested in seeing the omitted submissions?xhvtm
>>41188752you could make a poll before the premiere starts or, perhaps more appropriately, after it ends.
>>41188758or maybe even during the credits. also, the poll would have to be in cytube 1 of course.
>>41188763A poll during the con is probably a bad idea per >>41188721, but if you're going to do it, it should be in both cytubes unless you wish to skew the results in favor of eqg. And if it is to be at the end of the antithology, it should happen before the anti follow up panel. As the panel after that on cytube 1 is an eqg panel, and only eqg-fags would stay around for that.
>>41189104>behind-the-scenes panel>eqg
>>41189155I was referring to the panel after the behind the scenes panel. But there's a decent chance the behind the scenes will include that too considering OP.
Anyone planning to record the Antithology with live chat reaction?
>>41188752You should still do the poll if you end up showing the deleted clips, sounds like a nice idea and you don't have to follow it at all but getting opinions is always interesting. Also unlike the anthology itself the panel is yours, so you're less beholden to us faggots what you do there.>>41189483I think in past years someone has recorded the entire con anyways, so might not be necessary, no clue if they're doing it again this year though.
>>41189483>>41189489At least two anons in the con thread said they'd be recording, and one of them is the anon who recorded the entirety of last /mlp/con. It's never bad to have more backups, but it should be fine.
>>41189483i hope i have plans that came up unfortunately
bumpers
>>41190881such a cute cute mare rump
My internet is shit. Can I download the antithology in advance so I can watch it live with other anons? I think they allowed that last year.
>>41188190>after the premier.Why after? People with fourth world internet connections like myself won't be able to watch live, and occassionally cytube shits the bed. I swear that last year it was available for download prior to the showing. I don't see the logic of hiding the link until after the premiere. If people want to spoil it for themselves that's on them.
>>41191565Yeah that sounds fair to me. The links have now been added to the submission spreadsheet.>>41191487https://mega.nz/file/7MExiJTC#xr7W88-5aZm0hZgZmlL8lT21S03r_5LQknGAtYwduAE
>>41191589Thanks, I really appreciate it. I always download longer videos for cytube in case something goes wrong.
can someone please record the antithology i wont have the opportunity
>>41191845I will do what I can.
>>41191589Thanks m'nigga. My shift starts at the premiere so I appreciate this.
15 MINUTESGET IN HERE https://cytu be/r/mlp-con
Can someone upload a catbox of twilight saying the terry davis 'blackest gorilla niggers' quote?
>>41189483I completely missed most of the early chat reactions because I thought everyone would be on Cytube 2.
Guess my video didn’t make Final Cut, serves me right for half assing it10/10
Whoever did the y'all look lonely, great job!!Also, would be nice if I can download the clip.
The pony version of the anti was fantastic, compared to the furry/barbietroon version. + vastly better sound mixing+ better clip flow+ bonus clips
>>41192680Never mind. Found it.
Ok so I counted, there was 1 g% reference (3 if you include g% twilight and spike) and 1 eqg, and they were both taking the piss, so the other version was pointless, it was better edited/paced as well and the "no shit" version was 9 seconds longer.
>>41192671Which video was yours?
>>41192686AbsolutelyIrreparablyUnquestionablyUnironicallyOBSESSED
>>41192704Nah, the content was fine. The pony version of the anti was simply better edited and mixed, is all.
all my submissions are now on youtube! go wild.https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLuaT38OIqQPK8aYUsuLES5Ik0-C84BhMa&si=5hJ5buK1TTG8skCX
>>41192801>all the worst clips were made by one guyInteresting.
>>41192686Sad to see that the non-pony version was even aired on the con...i renember the bible proverb: the miserable will inherit the earthbecause the first people will, inevitably,be gone one day, no matter how great they were. every mortal will die one day
>>41192801>all the best clips were made by one guyBased.
Good job lads, was great fun. The top gear theme was great, the clips being short made it feel smoother than twikato, though I wonder how many times the different anthologies have done the banging stereo joke by now.>>41192686I thought the proper version had pretty good clip grouping, how was the other version better? Also, what bonus clips? The rejected ones?
>>41192980Just the one dunking on Zipperhttps://files.catbox.moe/p9n1wm.mp4
>>41192980Oh, and I think the editor of the "non-EQG" version included his own clips he never submitted to the thread
Fantastic anti, but I have to say that having two jokes from previous annis was a bit jarring, namely the Bateman walking with headphones clip and the Top Gear truck stereo clip. Probably just an oversight, but still.
https://mega.nz/file/sYZ03ACQ#CoRI3wcbYxR-J9cMiGuml7wHBIIfh4GPF6txj6-FSjwno impure content antithology with more efficient encoding to save disk space
>>41192801Oh so we can upload our clips now. Swank.
So did anyone record the chat reactions?
>>41193215Yes.
>>41193056thanks king, i hope you can do the actual antithology next year
>>41193220Thank you for answering my question. I appreciate your consideration. However, I must say I fear you have missed the point of my question. By inquiring if the chat reactions had been recorded I was also implying I would like to recieve the link to that video so I may also view it.
>>41193352It's gonna be a while. Usually around this time I start copying over data from the recording machines to start processing. However, this time around I have a new setup and a new issue to deal with. For whatever reason my gigabit switch is pretending it's a 100mb switch and so even copying over just the first day's data would take hours. Thankfully this doesn't seem like it affected the actual recordings. When Rock and Pone on channel 2 is done I'm going to try unplugging/replugging the switch to see if it fixes the problem. Really wish I would have spotted this before the con, but I guess there's only so much you can prep for. Keep an eye out on PonyTube. I'll be uploading it there when it's ready.
>>41193365I appreciate your work. I like to save the antithologies with all of (you) being funny in the chat.
>>41193365Try changing the switch port. Most likely a failed ethernet cable that needs replacement. You can force 1gb in your OS network settings but not good if your cable is bad.
>all this earape to whisper tier audioNot to shit on you OP, but how have you not noticed the problem with audio levels? Doesn't your video editor allows you to see those all those jumps in volume?
>>41193365>>41193395I got impatient and just did it. There's actually 3 switches in the room. I took the middle switch out of the equation and just plugged the end switch into my main 2.5G one. Don't know if there were actually any issues with the switches or if it was just the unplug/replug, but everything's working as it should now.
>>41173080>https://pony.tube/w/ohNxWumSJ35nJxYESLRp7cYO, here is recording of Antithology 04 with cytube chat. The final video is bit over 2GB if someone wish to download it.
>>41193519You're a hero. I'm beyond happy to see people liked my intro and other subs. Can't wait to spam next year too.
>>41193519Thank you for recording this! sad I missed it live but it's made me look forward to next year even more.The amount of original animation in this year's anti was really impressive, a lot of creative anons on this board.
>>41173549>>41173555>>41173608 Thanks for leaving it in. I'm feeling quite smug atm.
>>41193436Yeah, apologies for that. I tried getting the audio levels normalized, but with each pass I did it would fuck up some other parts. I plan on going back and fine tuning everything and reuploading the Anti with normalized audio levels.
I just assembled my collection of clips and there's 15 minutes of my stuff in the anti. If I start making shit for next year I bet I could make an hour's worth.
>>41193636Yeah, doing it en-mass is usually not a great idea as it will lower the quality a bit. Usually the video edition programs would either show you visually how loud the individual clips are and then you can edit them one by one until they are in a nice average level. This is a long process as you would need to go back and forth between different clips (or lurk up the sound volume levels and try to aim to not exceeded 95% maximum sound volume or go below 20% )
>>41193636Hopefully this should do it. If anyone else thinks there are certain parts that could use more fine tuning please let me know.https://pony.tube/w/5NiuBcpCKPaVWqFt8NJk4S
>>41192686I just rewatched it on my own, and yeah. Hopefully that editor anon does it again next year, or overtakes OP. It's just a straight upgrade.
I missed the eqg vs no eqg poll, does anyone have a screencap or at least remembers what it was and what the votes were?
>>41194021They voted no EQG
>>41194021Should "ironic" or "shitposty" eqg be allowed and the answer was 3/4ths in favor of "No". This is consistent with what other parts of the board vote, so it's probably legit.
>>41194051That wasn't the question pose, I don't think. I asked chat if they were interested in seeing the EQG related clips that were omitted from the Antithology.
>>41194044Thanks, that's honestly pretty surprising, but apparently good things still can happen in 2024.
>>41194021As the Anon said, about 2/3rds to 3/4ths voted against.
>noneqgfags overreact over minor bullshit>expect everyone to cater to their bullshit>screech when someone disagrees with them >treat even minor disagreements as a personal attacksThis is tranny behavior, noneqgfags are trannies
>>41194193I want to rescind my previous comment, I saw the deleted submissions and that was shit
I can't stop listening to Electric Avenuesend help
>>41194634It's an ear worm, that's for sure
>>41194634is good song
Nice antithology. It reminds me how much I love you faggots.
>>41193056Go fuck yourself.
>>41196463He literally made a better-edited version. That's the one I'm downloading, too.