Red at 50 editionWhat is Progressive Rock?>https://rateyourmusic.com/genre/progressive-rock/Good albums to start with?>https://www.musicgenretree.org/essential_prog.pngObscure prog gems>https://rateyourmusic.com/list/antonbildern/a-secret-society-obscure-progressive-rock-albums/Prev: >>123867205
WOO!
Why Red? Why not Blue?
happy birthday red. I normally talk shit on this album but for one thread we will have peace
>>123908070how do you do this shadow effect, I want to have some fun
Got the album on now, looking forward to Providence :)
>>123907616What's next for King Crimson? Scarlet? Salmon? Marine Blue;
>>123907616Seventh for LISTEN TO OMEGAhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mLIpchKHmbE
>>123908568Sorry bud, I'm ALPHA and I adjust my listening preferences accordingly
>>123908557>Scarlet
https://youtu.be/0FP5kyPiyKE?si=qWioME7NtmdGPIVAI want to sexually abuse myself in his light. I want to amputate my body if it meant that Fripp was given energy, I want to partake in blood rituals of the Necronomicon if it meant that Fripp would be rejuvenated. I would charge at any army, even a horde of violent savages if Fripp gave me the command. His instructions are my orders. His sadness is my depression. His pain is my agony. He is everything. Fripp is everything and nothing else matters.
pog rock
prog rok
playing starless on bass, when you're really in the zone, is like a musical orgasm
what was the last album that made go like pic related after you were done with it
>>123909120people in this gen were gassing it up 2 years ago, i should've given it a shot much earlier
>>123907616only great metal album
take the Bernard Paganotti pillwhat a monstrous bassisthttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jXIift_AIyc
prog cock
why does mike always look horny in pictures
>>123909120for me it was Area's first albumjust heard it a couple days ago and my god, i finally found the equal to Banco whitin italian prog
>>123909290Between Jannick, Paganotti and Bussonnet, who was Magma's best bassist? They're all incredible in their own ways but I feel like Jannick overshadows the other two in online discussions while Bussonet's really underrated considering he's the bassist who's been with Magma the longest
>>123907616>hate the splashing sound effect on "one more red nightmare" studio version>the larks gang never played the song live together>the KC live versions are good but one has to do all sorts of mental gymnastics to put up with Jakko's gay ass voice and style of singing >the only version close enough to match the original band's energy is the "exposed" version where they remove the drums entirely and even though its a nice breath of fresh air the song isnt the same without Broof>this is the reality we live inreally hope they release all the recording sessions for Red at some point like they did with Larks so i can make a try at mixing their shit
Everything PF released after Atom Heart Mother is terrible (except for WYWH)
euros really do carry this general huh
>>123910143jannick and its not even a questionhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mXWYO_9B2xI
Reminder In the Hot Seat is worse than Love Beach
>>123909867>showing his bush to KateReminder Pete tapped that.
>>123910258i'm brazilian
does anyone else think this part of domino sounds like meg sucking on her binky?https://youtu.be/b4vNMtCvIHE?t=503
>>123910602What was it like capping off Invisible Touch? Throwing It All Away must have been a tough track to follow
>>123907776there was blue, it got scrapped kek
>>123907616I used to put my red vinyl on every morning before going to the gym i love you red
>>123909867It's all the coke he was doing back then.
>>123910258americans were never good at progcan't think of any relevant prog band
>>123910602show me some brazilian prog
>>123910254i wouldnt say DSOTM, The Wall or Animals are terrible, just extremely overrated (specially the later 2)
>>123910602basão>>123912677nta buthttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-Jpa7nBKe6o
>>123910602>>123913075Third brazilian here. Someday anons will realize we're 80% of entire 4chan.
>>123912677https://youtu.be/gtEagOeHftU?si=Fj3nGrj4yca8r9ij
I feel Stevie Wonder should be included in /prog/ solely from his impeccable way of writing his jazz-influenced chord progressions no matter how sappy the songs are.But heh just my two cents.
Is Ryo prog?
>>123907616The best live performance of Starless on YT got Fripped and nobody has ever complained or reuploaded.
>>123914484All of the Kessokus but Kita are Prog
>>123914336I feel Paul McCartney should be included in /prog/
rog prock
>>123914663He is prog.He made Phil seethe forever.
>>123914336no
>>123914484sometimes
>>123914484no
Has anyone had mystical experiences listening to prog?
>>123915942I have with John Coltrane so I think it's only a matter of time before I do with Magma considering everything Vander does is a devoted mystical experience to Trane
>>123914621Kita is the most fuckable though
>>123915942i was listening to gong and i swear on the holy bible i saw a gnome in the corner of my eye flip me the bird and disappear behind a box
>>123916658The Gnome in question.
>>123916138John Coltrane cured my atheism
>>123916658
Acknowledge Hawkwind.
>>123916658Gong is certainly the most psychedelic music out there. I've seen some shit listening to them before. Interesting that others have shared this experience.
>>123909131Flying Microtonal Banana is better.
>>123907776I prefer purple myself.
>>123916658>>123916873Can I get a redpill on Gong? I recall a post here a month or two ago saying Gong was the only prog band that scared them.
>>123917044That was me. I don't know, I find Gong almost indescribable. It's like hard bop meets psychedelia. Something about Daevid Allen's vocals is also pretty interesting. Master Builder is my favorite, but when I was younger and first heard it, I was terrified.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yelK7E81slM
>>123917108Holy fuck that song goes hard.
>>123916138John Coltrane cured my autism
>>123917108Gong's music is steeped in the Occult, "Daevid" is a genuine Wizard.
>>123908568Bbb b b based
>>123917360He really is.
>>123914336No, because FUCK Stevie for putting in so much of that damn fucking grating harmonica sound all the time.He blew it.
>>123917406harmonica is a pleb filter
>>123914591Oh there were complaints
>>123917406His harmonica is the sound of angels singing. You wouldn’t get it.
>>123917414>>123917427The fuck is wrong with you abominations
>>123917406>He blew it.well yeah, that's what you do with a harmonica
>>123917446>filtered by a simple harmonica>calls us "abominations">ohh noo le harsh sounds hurts muh ears
>>123914336prog soul is /prog/
>>123916733This I believe>>123917155This I doubt
>>123914336>>123917622Stevie Wonder and progressive soul in general is based, but this is progressive ROCK general. go make your own thread.But I will say there are some Stevie Wonder tracks that really do sound like prog rock at times, particularly softer stuff like a Camel or Hawkwind balladhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fy4fMlLj_B8https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6T5q7BzpEe4
>>123909290wtf is he related to the singers himiko and antoine paganotti? talented family
>>123917446I like harsh dissonance in my prog what are you going to do about it, pussè?
>>123917730Yeah. He's their father.They're not the only children of Magma members who eventually joined Magma either.Jimmy Top (Jannick Top's son) is Magma's current bassistAnd I think Vander's daughter's one of their vocalists too.
Ever listened to MAN, from Wales?https://youtu.be/VPPJGY4jT3A
>>123918399>MAN>not from the Isle of Man or at least Manchester
does your shadow ever talk to you?
>>123918808yes, it tells me scores on wikipedia are low
It's prog
>>123907616>Red at 50 editionHave they done anything special for the anniversary?
>>123919024yes, Robert resurrected Wetton and McDonald and they are going on a tour to play itBruford refused to participate though
>>123918940and?
>>123918940Sometimes.
>>123909131Try Polygondwanaland next
>creates the most boring prog in you're pathELP are technically good but incredibly boring.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aa3kCZRKj4YRenaissance are underrated IMO, they have some really long songs and a bit of a folk style, but some parts of their songs never fail to give me chills. Like a beautiful but indescribable feeling that creeps into my mind.
>>123919128except they are not and tarkus is great
>>123919138They are boring, it's the most by-the-books prog band ever.Tarkus and Trilogy are good, not great.
>>123919147That's only because the books were written about ELP
>>123919161doesn't even make sense as they were formed in 1970I agree they are good but they just don't experiment at all which makes them boring.
>>123919171LEAD THE BATTLEFIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEELD AND LEEEET ME SEEEEEEEEEEEEE
I like prog rock, 80s music and maximalist art pop like Peter Gabriel, Tears for Fears, and Susumu Hirasawa, what is some other stuff in this vein? Should I try out Phil Collins Genesis?
>>123919171If ELP doesn't experiment at all, what other bands from that era did? ELP's first couple albums were inspired heavily by cut tracks from In the Court of the Crimson King, but went in a very different direction from that band. Tarkus was quite experimental for 1971, to the point where ELP earned a reputation for being self-indulgent and "masturbatory" in their exploration of styles. Hell, the first song after the Tarkus suite in the album is some kind of ragtime, not my style for sure, but they were trying some new, eclectic things. I can't vouch for all their work, but Trilogy and Tarkus are some landmark albums in Prog history.
>>123919147>the most by-the-books prog bandmars volta or tool
>>123917562got em, kek
>>123919247Yes,KC,GG.I will concede that Tarkus actually did some new things, but it feels extremely safe in what it does. >>123919266>derivative bands are derivative obviouslyinnovation stopped after the mid '80s.
>>123919307>derivative bandsMost new attempts at recapturing the style of 70s prog fail miserably. Steven Wilson's Luminol is one of the only contemporary songs to hit that prog rock sweet spot for me. (And I honestly think its because he convinced Alan Parsons to be his audio engineer for this album)https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IVC8Vtev3-Q
I'm getting the Red 50th anniversary shit because I'm still mad I didn't get the '80s releases when they came out. $50 isn't too bad.
>>123919244Yeah try it out. Idk why you would need to ask
>>123919432>Most new attempts at recapturing the style of 70s prog fail miserablyIndeed.Red especially.I honesty think Änglagård did it the best with Hybris.
>>123919147>Tarkus and Trilogy are goodi agree but, those aren't even their best albums, their best is Brain Salad Surgery
>>123919551>Brain Salad SurgeryIt's like Moody Blues split into VDGG and ELP and ELP got left with the short end of the stick.
>>123916853Acknowledged
>>123916853Hawknoledge Ackwind
>Emerson, Lake & Palmer7.5/10, Great songs nothing amazing though, pretty good debut.>Tarkus6/10, The title track of "Tarkus" is a standout, easily one of the best pieces in the progressive rock genre, blending intricate musicianship with compelling themes. Unfortunately, the rest of the album doesn't quite maintain that level of quality, the rest of the album ranges from just "pretty good" to "wow, this is garbage">Pictures at an Exhibition8/10, fantastic take on classical music, with ELP's bold reinterpretations (AKA Butchering) adding a unique and exhilarating flair. The way they transform these classic pieces into something fresh and exciting is a true marvel, making this album a thrilling listen. Its energetic arrangements and virtuosic performance >Trilogy7.5/10, Trilogy showcases ELP's signature blend of complex compositions and rich melodies, delivering a strong overall experience. While some tracks shine with impressive musicality and innovation, others feel a bit more conventional. Overall, the album strikes a fine balance between high-energy rock and symphonic elegance>Brain Salad Surgery9/10, Brain Salad Surgery is a remarkable album that really showcases ELP's creativity and musicianship. The blend of rock and orchestral elements creates a unique sound that's both ambitious and engaging. With standout tracks and a few bold experiments, it captures the band's essence beautifully, their best album by far.>Works Vol. 1 & 24.5/10, A mixed bag with some standout tracks, but overall it's more mediocre than memorable.>Love Beach4/10, attempts a more commercial sound but fails to resonate.
>>123919775no
>>123919775Agreed
i think works vol 1 has some of their best tracks, even after the pretentious startpirates is one of their best (after trilogy) and greg's side is great too
>>123919830Its a mixed bag, they were not thinking straight
>>123919844yeah, that's why i said>has some of their best tracksi usually take trilogy or tarkus over it anyways
>>123919117Its the best thing they ever did.
>>123919887last time I checked nursery cryme wasnt the best one
>>123919775sometimes
>>123919147>it's the most by-the-books prog band ever.Nonsense sentenceNone of the major prog bands sounded similar. How do you be a "by the books prog band"
>>123919989>None of the major prog bands sounded similarblatantly false
>Kobaïa8.5/10, Kobaïa is Magma's groundbreaking debut, introducing their unique Zeuhl sound with intricate rhythms and ethereal vocals. While its experimental nature may be polarizingthe band's remarkable musicianship and vision.>2 (AKA 1001° Centigrades)8/10, released in 1971, amplifies the band's Zeuhl sound with intricate rhythms and a fusion of jazz, rock, and choral elements.>Mëkanïk Dëstruktïẁ Kömmandöh 10/10, Mëkanïk Dëstruktïẁ Kömmandöh by Magma is a mesmerizing masterpiece that exemplifies the band's unique fusion of progressive rock, classical and jazz, elevating the concept of music to an art form. With its intricate rhythms, powerful vocals, and immersive soundscapes, the album transports listeners into a cosmic journey through the enigmatic language of Zeuhl. it's not not only sonically challenging but also emotionally, and spiritually profound, showcasing the band's virtuosity and vision. This ambitious work deserves a 10/10 for its innovative approach and lasting influence on the progressive music landscape.>Ẁurdah Ïtah7.5/10, Released in 1974 as the soundtrack for Tristan et Iseult, this album explores Magma's distinct Zeuhl sound. It’s filled with intricate rhythms and haunting vocals while capturing the essence of the Theusz Hamtaahk Trilogy.>Köhntarkösz9/10, stands as a remarkable entry in Magma's catalog, rich with complex rhythms and powerful vocals. As part of the Köhntarkösz cycle, the album showcases the band's signature blend of complex rhythms, powerful vocals, and an avant-garde approach that captivates listeners.>Live/Hhaï10/10, is an extraordinary testament to Magma's live prowess and creativity, The standout track "Hhaï" is an unforgettable track that takes you on a mesmerizing spiritual journey. The energy and creativity Magma brings to the stage are palpable, and the rich rhythmic layers and emotional intensity make this one of their all-time great releases. It absolutely deserves a perfect 10/10.
>>123919171>don't experiment at all What? You had a point, but you ruined it
>>123919294>>123917562I’m glad he did, perfect witty reply to the setup
>>123920261I won't mind saying I'm wrong; what new thing did they do?
>>123919307What’s also obvious is you listening to 70/71 music with your modern ears and taste
>>123917414gimme some prog with harmonica
>>123919464Bested by Astra / Birth
>>123919147Unironically, this is the only album I enjoy from beginning to end of theirs. I don't get the hate, sure it has problems, but those issues are present in any of their earlier albums
>>123919775based Pictures enjoyer
>>123920303https://youtu.be/WF6d6CKlZpY?si=rygztq-Dj-4qLzvS
>>123919830In theory yes, but no.Pirates is a mess and a waste >>123920292Now you’re saying new, that’s not the same thing at all
>>123920584>Now you’re saying new, that’s not the same thing at allI would argue it is in the context of prog
>>123920584don't care, i enjoyed it a lot and thought it was worth it, orchestral rock is great
also bro they were the new prog, this is 70 right after Crimson, Yes and Genesis haven’t really took off yet… and they keep trying things, switching things up.I’m no fan of the saloon style, and don’t really think that counts, though.Overall I find ELP to be prog only for prog fans because it’s often so cringe and aged so poorly, but when their bad taste got out of the way for a few moments and they were good, they were really good.But yes it is baffling to consider they were quite likely the biggest prog band for years.>>123920600Well that’s dumb.Also related debate, ‘new’ doesn’t mean good, new can SUCK so bad, so often. The pursuit of novelty for itself is a fool's errand
>>123920628Orchestral rock list?Caravan & orchestra 74Deep purple & orchestra 69William Sheller - Lux Aeterna Shawn Phillips - 2nd Contribution + some songs on Collaboration Uriah Heep (72?) Salisbury …Who am I forgetting
>>123914484Ryo cant play bass like 2011 could
>>123920687The second half is an orchestral performance of The Snow Goose
I have to make a confession: I've never really cared for the title track of Red. It's just okay.
>>123920687
>>123920687Procol Harum live with Edmonton Orchestra
>>123920687Yes Magnification
>>123920894>>123920968 oh don’t know that one >>123920987>>123920998>>123921010Nice. Oh yeah The Nice, they have some too…also Pink Floyd Atom Heart Mother i guess Led Zep Kashmir? maybe stretching it too far
>>123919024they are releasing a 50th anniversary edition of Red with a bunch of stuff if thats what you mean with "special"heres the link if you want to check it out:https://www.dgmlive.com/news/new-release-date-eed-50th-anniversary-edition
Would you want to hang out at a ball game with Geddy Lee?
Acknowledge Kansas
So Greep is the new Prog King?
>>123921985i have more faith in Muse to come out with a good prog album than geordie greep
>>123920687ELP live in Montreal, '77 I think
>>123919171>they didn't experiment so that means they weren't goodAside from the fact that you are completely wrong, what an absolutely retarded merit to base whether a band is good or not
>>123919307>it feels extremely safe in what it doesBecause that album is over FIFTY (50) years old, dude. When it came out, this stuff was absolutely insane for the time
>>123921985lol
>>123921975I acknowledge that they sucked.
Acknowledge Chicago
>>123922682What the fuck are you talking about? By that time you had Stockhausen, you had Cage, you had free form jazz etc. ELP is extremely tame in comparison.
>Aerosol Grey Machine8/10>The Least We Can Do Is Wave to Each Other 8/10>H to He, Who Am the Only One 9/10>Pawn Hearts9.5/10>Godbluff6.5/10>Still Life7.5/10>World Record6/10>The Quiet Zone/The Pleasure Dome 7/10>Vital 7/10>Present 5/10>Real Time8/10>Trisector5/10>A Grounding in Numbers6/10>ALT4/10>After the Flood: At the BBC 1968-19778/10>Do Not Disturb3/10
>>123923817the least we can do is wave to eachother is not better than godbluff. besides that this is pretty much good
>>123923996>the least we can do is wave to eachother is not better than godbluffbut it is
>>123924004it's good but it doesn't have a song as good as Arrow
>>123923817What's with the 5/10 for Present?
>>123924077nothing on Godbluff clicks for me, i don't get the praise for that album.>>123924178none of their studio albums after The Quiet Zone do much for me. they have their moments but nothing close to their first 4 albums.
>>123923584Which is the one who shot himself in the head being stupid?
>Gentle Giant8/10>Acquiring The Taste9/10>Three Friends7.5/10>Octopus8.5/10>In A Glass House8.5/10>The Power And The Glory8.5/10>Free Hand5/10>In'terview 5/10>Playing The Fool9/10>The Missing Piece6/10>Giant for a Day!4.5/10>Civilian3/10>Out Of The Woods8/10>King Biscuit Flower Hour8/10>Live at the Bicentennial 1776–19767.5/10
>Yes7/10>Time And A Word7/10>The Yes Album7.5/10>Fragile8/10>Close To The Edge8.5/10>Yessongs9/10>Tales from Topographic Oceans8/10>Relayer7/10>Going for the One4/10>Tormato5/10>Drama5/10>901256/10don't even bother with any of their other albums
>>123924281>His last words were, "What do you think I'm gonna do? Blow my brains out?"
>>123924194Your ratings are terrible anyways, and you have no justification for them. Opinion discarded.
>>123924668why are you so angry? my ratings are objective, whether you like it or not, i don't need any justifications for my scores, you probably just have bad taste.
>>123921985pretentious isn't equivalent to prog
>>123924681>ObjectiveDescribe how exactly
>>123924549>Gentle Giant9.5/10>Acquiring The Taste10/10>Three Friends11/10>Octopus10/10>In A Glass House9/10>The Power And The Glory9/10>Free Hand10/10>In'terview7/10>The Missing Piece6/10>Giant for a Day!2/10>Civilian5/10
>>123922936Peak of the genre, not even close
>>123923817Pawn Hearts > Still Life > H to He > Godbluff > The Least > Aerosol Machine > World Record > Present > Quiet Zone
>>123923638Please stop embarrassing yourself-future you
>>123922282Based
>>123924681What an idiotic thing to say. Your ratings are subjective and that would be a more than acceptable defense, but… eh
Gong - You? More like Gong - (You) amirite?
Top 3 prog songs? Top 3 non-prog songs?
>>123927292>proghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OfR6_V91fG8https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XJLKenVrv7Yhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eks6KcV2ufg>non-proghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRU-c0SBbyUhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MbldM7JEIeEhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BxuxhERiwQM
>>123927326For me, it's Supper's Ready.
>>123907616>RedBased as fuck edition.
>>123926689You should say that to yourself if you believe what ELP was doing to be "absolutely insane".
>>123926786Your gong
>>123924681you want to be smart so bad
>>123927433Based Harper appreciator.
post your favorite /prog/ album covers
>>123927931
>>123927931this >>123920968 and picrel
>>123928291
>>123927862My magnum gong
>>123925145>>123926705>>123927887>what is irony?
>>123928517My gong is bricked up.
>>123928868oh, so you want to be funny so bad. that's even worse.
>>123927931not prog but also Wasnatch - Front to Back
>>123929167not really, i didn't put that much thought into it.
>>123927931Low hanging fruit but prime Floyd has the best album covers of all time. Except Meddle, what the fuck was that
>>123929644It’s an ear, bro
>>123927858You are confusing the many people who indulge in conversing with you despite obvious reasons not to bother
>>123929666You too are making the same mistake. You had replied to my only post in the thread at that point.
>>123929655I know but its a terrible album cover
>>123921975Sneed
>>123927896I love Jessica Harper so much it’s unreal!
is there any Prog Rock with country influence? what about Prog Rock with gospel influence?
>>123930730>extremely small breastsbased
>>123920303https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LfSJZCkMc9A
>>123930730What's she playing, anons?
>>123930957>Jessica Harper – Roundabout.jpgWonderwall
>>123909290You should have posted this, the bass sounds like Godzilla.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VXENYJuD338
>>123931165are they contractually obligated to wear the magmachu medallions
>>123923817>Godbluff, Still Life and World Record that lowkys idiot
>>123926254lemmings is weak tho
>>123931165Fuck man I love zeuhl basslines so muchhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u4hvrGHuE-o
>>123930872Strawbs started out as a bluegrass band and a few of their tracks feature Cousins on banjo.Doug Pinnick from King's X uses gospel flourishes in his vocals.
>>123930957A guitar
>>123918808
What does /prog/ think of this?
>>123928291disgusting and also not prog
>>123930904Hey, they deserve love too.>>123930957In my head she’s playing an acoustic cover of Roundabout but Wonderwall would also be kino.
Let's play the impossible game.Explain why you hate Black Midi in good faith without bringing up points that can be applied to your favourite 70s bands.
I am now relistening to Red because of this thread
>>123932937>Let's play the impossible game.>If you dare insult my favorite band I will say "no u" ad nauseam.
>>123932983I would never listen to Black Midi so I have nothing to compare it to.
>>123932966
>>123933010zoomer king crimson with a touch of frank zappa
>>123932983>someone makes fun of your favorite band's album art>get so assblasted you make a passive aggressive post phrased in such a way that you can dismiss any and all criticism as "bad faith" or claim it applies to another band (doesn't actually make that criticism any less valid btw)>"s-s-struck a nerve, did I?" he says, weeping and changing his diaperwhy are black midi fans so insecure? for what it's worth, I actually like hellfire's album art
>>123933028>zoomer king crimson with a touch of frank zappamore like arctic monkeys with a bit of miles davis
>>123932983>The Geat Deceiver is the exact same thing as Shit Midilmao, please show me a song from that shit band that support your deluded claims that they are comparable with KC
>>123933028iirc the head of rough trade literally said that black midi gave him the same feeling of seeing the original king crimson in 1969
>>123933026?
Black Midi is shit, but they are still better than shit like Marillion, at least Black Midi try to be original, still the only good modern prog bands are Swans and Motorpsycho.
>>123920303prog status is debatable, but Polygondwanaland and laminated denim by king gizzard have songs that use harmonica
>>123929167It seems he just made a controversial opinion then sarcasticly said it was objective. not really a big premeditated ironic joke, just sarcasm in response to criticism
>>123933249
an accordion is sort of like a giant harmonicahttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KTI-N6mfdHs
I’m updating Harper’s wiki since she’s an actual musician.>>123933363Polygondwanaland is fantastic and I’d recommend it to any prog fan looking for something modern. 2017 was a stellar year for King Gizzard.
>>123933293nu swans are terrible
>>123933623i like the new albums, but their 80s and 90s output is much better, specifically Children Of God, Soundtracks, and Swans Are Dead.
>>123933208Really?
>>123933606>I’m updating Harper’s wikiwhat about her wikifeet?
>>123927931Is Canada prog?
>>123933992Sometimeshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LfSJZCkMc9A
>>123934072>>123934072Everything this dude does is prog yes
Stick Men
>>123934205Even this?
>>123933623fuck off scaruffi
>>123927326already said my prog in the previous threads, here's my nonproghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_gcykT0WqT8https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p4atQSktICEhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IxsUGOQm6qQ
>>123934344Scaruffi dislikes nu-Swans? I'm glad he can see through the hype.
Holy shit the BEAT show in Richmond was nuts. Vai's gotten a lot better at the Fripp picking since the first shows if those early videos are any indication. Engineering could have used some work though, model man was too much of a wall of sound for my liking.
if black midi isn't mediocre then why is there MID in the name?
>>123931225i always felt Godbluff was slightly overrated, nothing close to as good as their first 4 albums, either way, i still like it, and i gave it a 6.5/10 which, overall is still a good score for an album, that said i probably should have given it a 7/10 at least. Still Life is a great album, but i felt like their first 4 were still better so i gave it 0.5 points less than the first 2 albums, World Record is decent, it has a decent 6/10.
>>123934735Scaruffi is very based. He also saw right through Radiohead and is a huge fan of Robert Wyatt, so I can pardon any of his occasional shortcomings.
Adrian Belew
>>123935251i disagree with him about post-reunion Swans, i prefer late 80's - late 90's Swans, but The Seer and The Glowing Man are great albums, The Beggar is pretty good too.
John Wetton
>>123935501sometimes
Tony Levin
>>123935251he also rates Astral Weeks and Lorca 9/10, extremely based.
Geoff Downes
>>123935501What the heck?!
Trevor Horn
is this worth it for ~$200?
>>123935567I'm not a Van Morrison fan, but Lorca is great.
>>123935287Lol
Robert Fripp
Peter Gabriel
Mike Ratledge
>>123936094lol
Do you guys allow prog metal in here? /metal/ is full of drug addicts and raging alcoholics.
>>123936295I listened to the first two minutes and I didn't like it.
>>123936295no, but you are welcome if you get a better taste in music
>>123936104FUCKING KEK
>>123916175> be autistic trve aryan> life in NY is le hard> CHRIST IS LE KING> simp at roastie> 'ur freak boi'> hurr durr im boutta dedwhat do neal morse mean by this?
>>123933981Kek I’ve never even checked that shit.
>>123927931i never knew this was a hated album cover
>>123937859It's only hated by nerds and incels.Fantastic album, by the way.
>>123935691It's a nice box
>>123936295Yeah but 99.9% of prog metal is looked down upon here. Be prepare to be ignored completely or shat on.
Thoughts? What did I think of it?
>>123938479Please don’t say
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZqF9Vt612w>decided to give Greep's solo album a chance>he still does the auctioneer-style singingfuck off man
>>123938925He sounds retarded in his regular, normal speak too.https://youtu.be/9XbHp54a6QU?t=146
>>123938683Why not?
>>123937801so do you agree that Kita is the most fuckable or not?
>>1239384798/10, their best album by far. seriously i don't know how a band as shitty as The Who made this album.
>>123939336I agree. I'm not really a big The Who fan, but I do like concept/rock opera albums, and I've put this off for awhile.
>>123934735>>123935251scaruffi is a fucking hack who jerks off bargain bin jazz rock far too often
>>123937859how did you not know that, it looks like utter dogshit
Phil Collins
>>123938479You thought it was not as good as Quad and it's not prog
>>123939988>bargain bin jazz rockSuch as? I've got my gripes with Scaruffi, but they're certainly not about his jazz rock taste.
>>123935976>bitches, leave
>>123940173>Makes Fripp eternally seethe
>>123940173slowly up, then slowly down
Rick Wakeman
Giles, Giles and Fripp
>>123940199i doubt he thinks much about it, it's pretty insignificant compared to even the worst King Crimson album.
>>123940322>t. Robert
>>123940347yes, i am Robert Fripp, how did you know?
Someone make the next edition Bill Bruford, please. He’s my favorite drummer.
what do we think of Curved Air?
New bread:>>123941130>>123941130>>123941130
