[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • Roll dice with "dice+numberdfaces" in the options field (without quotes).

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


Janitor applications are now being accepted. Click here to apply.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: inr-91-thing-in-the-ice.png (1.03 MB, 745x1040)
1.03 MB
1.03 MB PNG
Previous Thread: >>96571483

>Most recent bracket system update
https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/commander-brackets-beta-update-april-22-2025

>Outline article introducing the bracket system
https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/introducing-commander-brackets-beta

>Current banlist
https://magic.wizards.com/en/banned-restricted-list#commander-banned

>Former Commander website, where you can learn the basics, and read the format philosophy laid down by the rules committee
https://mtgcommander.net

>Statistically see what everyone else puts in their commander decks based on what is posted to the internet
https://www.edhrec.com

>Learn about PDH, Commander's budget pauper format
https://pdhhomebase.com/
https://www.pdhrec.com/

>Deck list site: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck strategy and card choices
https://www.archidekt.com
https://www.moxfield.com
https://www.tappedout.net

>Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen color identity
https://managathering.com

>Card search
https://scryfall.com

>Make custom cards
https://magicseteditor.boards.net
https://mtg.design
https://mtgcardsmith.com

>Proxy a deck or a cube for cheap
https://pastebin.com/9Xj1xLdM

>How to proxy using any printer
https://mtgprint.cardtrader.com

>Precons
https://magicprecons.com

TQ: What is your pet creature card?
>>
File: silversmote ghoul.jpg (172 KB, 672x936)
172 KB
172 KB JPG
>>96585655
he cute.
>>
>>96585655
>TQ
>>
File: Jedit.jpg (120 KB, 488x680)
120 KB
120 KB JPG
>>96585655
>TQ: What is your pet creature card?
>>
>>96585655
>>
File: 1560700432462.jpg (68 KB, 685x800)
68 KB
68 KB JPG
>>96585663
>>96585667
>>
File: jmp-169-rhystic-study.jpg (107 KB, 488x680)
107 KB
107 KB JPG
>>96585655
>TQ
>>
>>96585655
He always surprises my table.
>>
>>96585655
He works great as a discard payoff and nobody ever sees it coming.
>>
>selling at 30 on tcgplayer
>you can just buy the welcome deck for 20 on tcgplayer
>>
>>96585655
TQ:
>>
File: ltr-95-mirkwood-bats.jpg (93 KB, 672x936)
93 KB
93 KB JPG
>>96585655
This works great in my Elas Il-Kor aristocrats deck.
>>
File: image.png (7.37 MB, 3976x2121)
7.37 MB
7.37 MB PNG
>Ugin can thrust his fat knot into Bolas, getting them stuck together because he's too deep inside Bolas, causing Bolas to have offspring
WTF Magic is based!?
>>
>>96585705
why are you gay
>>
>>96585713
No, Ugin and Bolas are gay.
>>
cutting cards is the least fun part of this game
>>
>>96585763
Driving 30 minutes to have your time wasted by turn 1 onions ring turn 2 rhystic study is the worst part.
>>
>>96585769
>closest shop is 30 minutes
Sad
>>
>>96585769
That's why my one group has both of these banned. So that we have the chance to see turn 4 or 5.
>>
>>96585775
If turn 1 sol ring leads to consistent turn 4 wins then the issue is you guys are playing decks that are too powerful even without sol ring.
>>
>>
>>96585688
The lengths people will go to to not have shitty bulk
>>
>>96585788
I don't get what this post means or how it relates to a card being 30 dollars.
>>
>>96585792
Then im afraid you are very slow.
>>
>>96585795
I think you're just not being descriptive enough in your sentences, leaving them open to interpretation instead of getting your point across.
This seems to be due to a need to meme.
>>
File: Turtle_questions.jpg (413 KB, 1080x1233)
413 KB
413 KB JPG
Should I use shiny or matte adhesive paper for my proxies?
I collected a ton of those infographic cards that come with bundles last friday and wanna put them to good use.
Also is the rumour that the first UB set of '26 is TMNT true?
>>
>>96585779
They're fairly powerful, yes. That's why we put deck rectrictions in place. Fast mana cards just contributed a lot to the speed of the game. Otherwise a few card draw cards, field of the dead and extra turns are banned.
>>
>>96585800
No its painfully straightforward and has nothing to do with memes.
>>
>>96585800
NTA but I hope this is bait because otherwise you are indeed very slow holy shit
>>
It is funny how utterly miserable Spider-Man has made this general. Based Spidey
>>
File: 1744625597518093.jpg (172 KB, 1290x919)
172 KB
172 KB JPG
>>
>>96585860
Based
>>
File: images.jpg (48 KB, 378x529)
48 KB
48 KB JPG
>>96585655
>TQ: What is your pet creature card?
Apparently this young las. Mate pointed out she keeps showing up in my decks and I didn't even really realise.
>>
Does MPC not accept paypal anymore? Their payment processor doesn't accept my card.
>>
File: 1697288532238712.gif (2.03 MB, 300x380)
2.03 MB
2.03 MB GIF
https://moxfield.com/decks/T7xECaELREChl2Jj7WAfAg

how did I do? Another anon suggested I use lylah or Balmor for a creature and token based izzet deck .
>>96585655
>tq
probably charmbeaker devils or electrostatic infantry. Exalted flamer is just too expensive
>>
man most spells with a kicker cost suck
>>
>>96585705
Gay Bolas anon continues being unfathomably based.
>>
File: Faggot, Lord of Bullshit.png (4 MB, 2010x2814)
4 MB
4 MB PNG
rate my card
>>
>>96585960
Ironically a far better card in green decks cheat it in with Chord of Calling, Finale of Devastation, or Invasion of Ikoria. Would basically not be played in straight Izzet but would be a huge Temur+ enabler.
>>
>>96585655
Even won with it once, but it's so slow... I play it in my graveyard lands deck because if I animate my lands and they die I can still Splendid Reclamation and it might be even better if that happens
>>
>>96585960
Every cascade deck would want this
>>
Do you guys think the soul stone is gonna retain that $80 price tag?
>>
>>96586015
I like him with Yedora out so they just come back automatically.
>>
>>96586053
Oh that's pretty neat
>>
>>96586053
he cute
>>
>>96584200
Updated Burakos did pretty well tonight. I didnt draw too many of my new additions but Sevinne's Reclamation in particular felt super impactful. Fetching 2 3-CMC creatures from the yard felt pretty value. Angel of Indemnity was able to recur Aura of Silence which is a big piece for me against a particular opponent.

So Im still a Mirkwood Bats Andy but hey victory demands no explanation
>>
>>96585792
You really don't get what he meant by that? He means people would rather spend the extra ten dollars to just get the card alone rather than pay the twenty and get stuck with the garbage cards that also come in the Welcome Decks.
>>
I have a question, does "dealing damage" includes only to a player, or just blocking a 1/1 and killing it is enough to make her lose hexproof?
>>
>>96586295
>just blocking a 1/1 and killing it is enough to make her lose hexproof?
Yep, dealing combat damage is dealing damage.
Also check out this unrelated Uncommon from 2025.
>>
>>96586295
Damage is damage, no matter what source it is.
>>
>>96586299
Wrong colors but cool stuff, thanks for the answer
>>
>>96585663
this but unironically
>>
>be me
>pretty meh about spiderman
>LGS selling spiderman collector boosters for $38
>Decide fuck it I'll buy 2 since they're MSRP priced rn
>End up pulling a Foiled Soul Stone and comic Foiled Eddie Brock
Why did I use all my luck on Spiderslop??? why can't God let me pull ancient tomb from EOE instead??
>>
File: ddh-4-wild-nacatl.jpg (270 KB, 672x936)
270 KB
270 KB JPG
>>96585655
>TQ
>>
>>96586365
>muh spiderslop
>proceeds to buy not only one but to collector boosters
you deserved two duds. Also you can easily trade in a foil soul stone for an ancient tomb, you performative fuck
>>
>>96586365
Foil soul stone is like 125
>>
File: 1739656333529.jpg (24 KB, 300x400)
24 KB
24 KB JPG
>>96585655
>TQ
>>
File: OIP-1768197338.jpg (41 KB, 322x450)
41 KB
41 KB JPG
>>96585655
>TQ
>>
File: mmq-189-flailing-soldier.png (1.77 MB, 745x1040)
1.77 MB
1.77 MB PNG
>>96585655
This guy always gets people talking T1
>>
How much effort is it for you to play EDH? For me it's
Option A: Meet with regular playgroup once a week an hour from me. Sometimes it gets cancelled because the guy who hosts has other things to do.
Option B: Go to commander night of the local bar. People there are either fat neckbeards or pink-haired women.
Option C: Try to organize with other people over whatsapp to play. Fails half of the time because someone suddenly has to watch their kids or someone who had agreed earlier no longer responds
>>
>>96586520
pretty easy for me to get as many games in as I want in week since I'm a jobless student with no real responsibility
I guarantee get at least 1 dedicated commander day every friday with my girlfriend and her coworker and her coworkers boyfriend
but I live next 2 game stores that are both 1 mile away from house that the loser autists swap back and forth from cause one game store is open on the days the other is closed and vice versa so if I desperately wanted to play EDH on a Tuesday at noon I could play with those mongrels and then to top it off the college I go to has a MTG club that has 20 students show up regularly every Thursday in the college library that usually play from 2-10pm so yeah it's really easy
>>
File: KarumonixTheRatKing.jpg (515 KB, 919x1280)
515 KB
515 KB JPG
>>96585655
>TQ
He really kinda sucks but I like rats but not Marrow Gnawer or Ashcoat
>>
>>96586520
Pretty easy. My preferred LGS has dedicated EDH nights Wednesday and Friday, and there usually neckbeards there open to close playing most weekdays. I do shift work, so there are weeks where I work both of those nights, but I will usually have at least one of them off per week. If I am working both, the neckbeards are generally pretty chill and accepting of me so I can get pick up games with them in any bracket from 2-4.
Having said that, I only really like to play one night a week, as I have other interests and I like the feeling throughout the working week of looking forward to going to MtG which tends to go away if I am no-life'ing the LGS outside of work.
>>
>>96586594
>if I am no-life'ing the LGS outside of work
So you are, or were at some point, one of those neckbeards?
>>
>>96586591
I really wish there was a decent rat general, flavour-wise. I loved the rb pied piper guy but he also sucks
>>
What are the most reddit tribe in the game?
>>
>>96586673
The one you don't like! Congratulations anon! You figured out the algorithm! "Reddit" means "Thing I don't like"!
>>
>>96586673
eldrazi
>>
>>96585832
Spidey will be forgotten in a week and they'll all move onto to crying about Avatar.
>>
>>96585662
>zombie vampire
sovl
>>
File: phylactery-lich.jpg (142 KB, 672x936)
142 KB
142 KB JPG
>>96585655
>tq
I like liches and undead in general
>>
File: Untitled.png (177 KB, 365x254)
177 KB
177 KB PNG
>use umbral collar zealot to sacrifice cryogen relic
cryogen's relic effect will trigger first before the zealot's, right?
>>
>>96586520
I try five minutes to a friend's house every week for 6 hours or so of gaming.
If I really wanted to I could go to any of my three LGS's for commander nights too but then I have to play in rando pods with potentially stinky autists that get tilted when you path their gooner-alt-art commander
>>
>>96587317
You pay costs before the effect happens so Cryogen would go to the GY first, so yes.
>>
>>96586857
>he doesn't have an Eldrazi deck with Zhulodok to get all the free shit
>he doesn't have an Eldrazi deck with Ulalek that has all the gamechangers jammed into it
>>
>>96586673
elves
>>
File: images (14).jpg (35 KB, 378x529)
35 KB
35 KB JPG
>TQ
I love this lil nigga like you wouldn't believe.
>>
>>96585705
How do you respond to someone doing this setup without sounding mad?
>>
>>96587476
No why would I? Both of those are weak decks.
>>
>>96585769
>>
>>96587611
Ah yes my 4 mana answer to a turn 2 setup. Why didn't I think of that before?
>>
>>96587601
>he hates having fun
Eldrazi with all the big boys is the ultimate Timmy fantasy. Hell with the right setup it can be a fairly viable 3.
>>
>>96587630
wild growth + elvish spirit guide or carpet of flowers bitch
>>
>>96587643
>Just have a bunch of relatively specific cards in your starting hand in case someone has a rhystic study start
cEDH is saved! Rhystic Study is basically useless now! Btw are you paying for that fade from history?
>>
>>96587642
Eldrazi are incredibly boring to play with anon im sorry.
>>
>>96587702
I dunno man, the startup is dull, but once you got Zhulodok out with cascade spam, I find it stupid fun.
>>
>>96587630
>everyone has such a strong start
>everyone except me heh 1 mana per turn thats what I say!
Why do people come here and larp about their pods? No you arent playing above cedh level on your Friday nights.
>>
File: s-l500.jpg (62 KB, 359x500)
62 KB
62 KB JPG
tq sucks
>NEW TQ - CLAIM YOUR MTGWAIFU EDISH!!
>>
>>96587700
>wild growth
>specific
>>
>>96585763
Agreed, but sacrifice's must be made. Anyone with a big collection usually has 200 cards they wanna use set aside but need to cut 101 of them. It hurts a little
>>
>>96587717
>1/3 opponents are more likely to have a strong start than the 1/1 me
Yes anon that's how math works.
>>
>>96587717
If you can have 4 mana consistently on t2, then you're more likely to be cheating than a good deck builder.
>>
>>96586365
Sell ASAP. Or store credit
>>
I recommend Bracket 2 for playing for fun with people you know. Having no GCs keeps the game a lot healthier, and makes it possible for people to test out an unaltered precon or EDHrec deck and still be able to keep up.
>>
>>96587795
This is an astoundingly dumb post. Please stop trying to be smart.
>>
>>96587843
>me and my friends are babbygamers who need to be cuddled
No thanks me and my friends will play what we want and have fun regardless.
>>
Thirty (30) starting life is objectively superior to fourty (40)
>>
>>96587859
cramming fast mana, tutors, and efficient draw engines like rhystic into every deck is playing magic with a handicap. no thought required to get the resources you need to perform actions.
>>
>>96587611

What does any of that have to do with bears?
>>
>>96586520
Monday night at 1 store, all of Saturday at the other. The latter has a discord people use to find players on other days
>>
>>96587843
Bracket 2 is fucking slop. So long as the game changer is comprised of
>cards that are sometimes good (Seedborn Muse, Crop Rotation, Aura Shards, fucking Opposition Agent???
and
>cards that should literally be banned
I'm not going to respect it. The tutor restriction also doesn't make the gameplay "fairer" so much as it skews the game toward certain strategies (value piles and green ramp become god).
>>
>>96587579
Joke about it but make your intention's known as to why
>>
>>96587746
I wanna stab her wound if you know what I mean
>>
>>96586365
Nice LARP
>>
>>96587867
I dont know why youre saying that anon. You and your friends are just children and prefer training wheels. Which is fine, dont try and make some grand statement out of it.
>>
File: file.png (976 KB, 672x936)
976 KB
976 KB PNG
>>96585655
>TQ: What is your pet creature card?
It's incredibly amusing how this little fucker just completely shuts everyone down. No one will even attack anymore
>>
>>96587977
My word I wish I played in the pods you guys play in. Gotta be new players. Great card though
>>
>>96588002
Nah, we've been playing for almost a decade and we all have 5+ decks each. We just don't play with any tryhard bullshit cards. We play to have fun, not to stomp on each other
>>
>>96588046
Yeah i didnt need you to go into defense mode. You guys are bad if no one will attack cause one creature might die, having such an attachment to your creatures is a hallmark of new/inexperienced players.
>>
>>96588053
>insinuates we're all shitty newbies
>Yeah i didnt need you to go into defense mode
Go touch grass.
>>
>>96587851
Anon is it more likely one player gets an abnormally fast start, or two players get an abnormally fast start?
If the former is true, assuming all players are using decks with an equal chance of a fast start, is it more likely you will get it, or a random one of your three opponents?
>>
>"YOURE NOT LETTING ME PLAY THE GAME ANON!"
How do you respond without soubding mad?
>>
>>96588061
I insinuated you are all new or inexperienced. You are free to attach any additional value judgments but dont accuse me of that lmao
>>
>>96588166
break down crying into a sobbing mess
>>
>>96588166
look him dead in the eyes and play a second counterspell just to underline the point
>>
>>96588166
"You're right, I'm not."
My friend and I played a casual game against some retard on Jodah last month, and he got mad when we kept killing his commander. I pointed out he just wins the game if we let Jodah stick, but he wouldn't listen.
>>
>>96588176
I find it incredibly amusing when anyone that runs an extremely kill on sight commander gets mad when their commander gets removed. The fuck did you think you were signing up for??
>>
>>96588106
>hes still going with his awful math
Lmao. Ill give you one post to tell me why its bad before you stop getting free yous from your retarded bait
>>
File: file.png (490 KB, 627x425)
490 KB
490 KB PNG
>make the angel, phase it out after combat damage but before combat phase ends
So it'll come back next turn, but will it get exiled at the end of *next* turn's combat, or any proceeding turn's combat? Or does Geist's trigger only talk about the current turn's combat phase?
>>
>>96588166
i would let them play the game and then when they inevitably combo off or shit out their library in a turn i could point this out to them but people like that usually dont have the self awareness to realize that point
>>
>>96588166
>The best way to play Magic is to stop your opponents playing Magic.
>>
>>96588191
geist says "exile that token at the end of combat", so I reckon at the end of any combat phase. Like, in general at the end of combat. If it said "at the end of this combat phase" then yeah it would remain forever
>>
>>96588223
I thought so too because magic is very literal but in some rules fuckery that should surprise no one it is not the case here!
>>
File: file.png (1.04 MB, 672x936)
1.04 MB
1.04 MB PNG
>>96588223
Yeah that's how I took it, too. So is there no way to permanently keep his angels? You're not sacrificing them so something like this can't help you
>>
>>96588229
There's a red phoenix or some shit that really will work that way if you want to do those shenanigans. I can't remember what it's called though.

Also mardu now just has something that will do equivalent if you play tokens that sac themselves >>96588235
>>
>>96588191
>>96588223
The "Exile that token at end of combat" ability from Geist of Saint Traft won't exile the token if the token is phased out at the time it would exile that token (C.R. 101.3, 702.26b). Once the ability triggers, it won't trigger again, even in future end of combat steps (C.R. 603.7b).
>>
>>96588191
You have to let the exile trigger go on the stack then phase out in response. It's like Obeka.
>>
>>96588223
>>96588229
>>96588235
Sorry I (middle poster) wasnt clear. I thought it would work that way, that Geist would provide a delayed trigger every combat. He does not, if you phase it, you keep it permanently.
>>
>>96588255
Don't listen to this guy this is an entirely unnecessary step.
>>
>>96588256
>>96588252
I see, neat
>>
>>96588252
neat
>>
>>96588183
This. I learned the hard way since my first commander deck was Kaalia. I've had the deck for almost 2 years, and I've only been able to attack with her like 3 times. On the bright side, this is also how I learned to focus on deck synergy so I can still win even if my commander gets nuked multiple times.
>>
>>96586673
Dog, Cat, Horse, Squirrel
>>
>>96585688
>Spiderman
>Flying
>Gaining life somehow makes things indestructible

How the fuck does this fit Spiderman in any way
>>
>>96585688
>spider
>flying
what fucking bullshit, should've been reach
>>
>>96588373
Are you retarded?
>flying
Webs.
>gaining life makes things indestructible
Spiderman swooped down from his webs to pick you up and save you from danger. Why you making me defend this dogshit set. Pick better criticisms.
>>
File: choosing is agony.png (1.49 MB, 1352x468)
1.49 MB
1.49 MB PNG
I can't decide which art I want.
Like they are all good for different reasons and its all so cheap like moonrune versio being most expensive at couple bucks. I guess I will just buy a playset on 4 different arts.
>>
File: 9dWV6cX.jpg (19 KB, 480x480)
19 KB
19 KB JPG
>>96588338
>dog, cat
its a fantasy game, why did they errated it from "hound"? and cats should be "feline".
dog and cat simply takes the immersion away, what ever was left of it anyway.
>>
>>96588380
>webs equal flying
>Gaining life somehow equates to "picking people up when you're in danger"

nigger fuck out of here
>>
>>96588391
cant go wrong with the OG.
>>
>>96588402
Sort of my issue with it - you have a fantastical setting filled with all these different weird and wonderful creatures, and some people are all
>nuhhh i wanna make a heckin' pupperino deck
I love animals, but the pandering is embarrassing.
>>
>>96588391
Older is always better.
>>
>>96588405
Yes web slinging equals flying. These arent a normal spiders webs that it lives in... spider man uses these to quasi fly around new york.
>gaining life and buffing a creature somehow not analogous to saving victims
You are genuinely retarded and there is no other explanation
>>
>>96588402
>>96588425
The pseudo intellectualism in this thread is astounding
>>
>>96588466
Nah, sorry we don't like your heckin' retarded silly pupperino slop - there are way too many cards that are just
>Dude, it's a cute little dog XD
which is more of an issue with modern art design more than anything. I can understand why they changed 'Hound' to 'Dog'
>it's to save ink
>>
File: BalanByHepari.jpg (886 KB, 2640x3712)
886 KB
886 KB JPG
>>96587746
My first deck, my first love. I don't care if she's animeslop I can't hear you over my Shroud 13/13 with Double Strike that can't be blocked.
>>
>>96588391
weeb or og
>>
File: 1669667800344632.png (126 KB, 370x349)
126 KB
126 KB PNG
>Gradually learning a bit of MtG as an outsider
>Love wizards up and down
>Adore traditional Black Mage design
>Read about FF crossover
>Vivi was added
>Now extremely interested in MtG
>Discover Vivi is apparently broken and most certainly going to be banned, and that standard is unplayable due to him
I was so excited, I wish he wasn't broken
>>
They should print a card that's just Reanimate for a planeswalker instead of a creature.
>>
>>96588504
Vivi is planned to be banned in Standard so he's probably going to be fine on EDH/Commander format.
>>
File: 1636063789650.jpg (48 KB, 802x936)
48 KB
48 KB JPG
>>96588519
There couldn't have been a worse fate for my boy
Broken at birth, banned to obscurity, and never to return in a playable state
I don't know much of EDH or commander. I just know Standard always looked the most fun and appealing to me. Knowing the format is currently in shambles is rather crushing
>>
>>96588504
>>96588534
UB piggies out.
If crossovers were required to get you in to Magic, then they will be required to keep you in Magic. As soon as characters you don't know are printed in future sets you will lose interest and leave.
A commander deck is pretty consistently $50-$100. Save your money- or go spend it on retarded shit like posters and figurines since all you want to do is collect shit with characters you know on it
>>
>>96588534
>I don't know much of EDH or commander. I just know Standard always looked the most fun and appealing to me
You're in the EDH thread. All other formats go here >>96587040
>>
>>96587746
I want to peel her out of her armor and lick her sweaty tummy.
>>
>>96588534
I haven't been keeping up with the Pioneer meta lately, but when Vivi gets banned in Standard he can probably find a home there if not in Modern.
>>
just found out overwhelming forces is only 1 opponent and ive been cheating for like 10 years
oops lol
>>
>>96588600
To be fair lots of old cards say a single opponent actually target all opponents.
>>
File: mmq-195-kris-mage.jpg (235 KB, 672x936)
235 KB
235 KB JPG
>>96587746
I've just always liked the art
>>
>>96588575
why are elves so hot
>>
>>96588610
And it's not even consistent errata. The Rack and Pauper's Cage both had the same wording, but Rack gets one opponent while Cage gets them all.
>>
File: wth-7-aura-of-silence.jpg (223 KB, 672x936)
223 KB
223 KB JPG
>>96588610
>To be fair lots of old cards say a single opponent actually target all opponents.
speaking of, this is probably my pet card cause I have a signed by artist copy and Im kind of surprised people sleep on this thing. Its not bad at all
>>
>>96588466
holy reddit
>>
>>96588600
>ching chong set has the coolest imperial seal
>it's eight fucking hundred dollars
JUST DO A REPRINT FOR FUCK'S SAKE
>>
>>96588817
they already did
>>
>>96588817
Just get the one with Queen Marchesa (long may she reign) flavor text.
>>
File: 1652006151038.jpg (95 KB, 1021x1024)
95 KB
95 KB JPG
How is the bracket system? I've thought about playing again now that my friend can't bring his totally 6 power level for real guys I wont win in 3 turns for real this time.
>>
>>96588847
Barely function but far better than what we had before.
>>
File: all-88a-elvish-ranger.jpg (286 KB, 672x936)
286 KB
286 KB JPG
>>96587746
>>
>>96588847
about as meaningless as power levels were
>>
>>96588847
If you let him get away with that before it will still happen cause he will still just lie. Rules only work when people are willing to follow/enforce them.
>>
has anyone ran this? Ive never seen this card anywhere but it seems quite powerful. You can keep chain sac'ing creatures and manifesting more
>>
>>96588900
>has anyone ran this?
*run
>>
>>96588890
I called his ass out every time that's why I stopped playing with him. So do people lie about which cards they have in their decks? What do they expect to happen when everyone is playing a tier 3 games and they whip out a tier 4 or 5 card?
>>
>>96588900
>You can keep chain sac'ing creatures and manifesting more
Only if you keep modifying them. Skull Clamp maybe? But they're 2/2s and Skull Clamp only gives them -1 toughness

If you can find something that puts +1/+1 on anything that enters and then have Viscera Seer or Umbral Collar Zealot as your sac outlet, then yeah burn your entire library, but it's a lot of board set up and any piece of the engine getting hit puts an end to it
>>
>>96588900
>manifest
>seeing play
lmao
>>
File: 1718815633992065.png (34 KB, 407x374)
34 KB
34 KB PNG
>got second place twice today

Hurts more than being last tbqh familia-senpai
>>
>>96588949
If you're playing this format to win, you're doing it wrong.
>>
>>96588950
Nope, this format is for rewarding victories instead of cheap victories. If you ain't playing aiming to try to win, then you better of not even playing
>>
Returning to MTG after a 5 year hiatus, picked up this guy's deck. It's a really fun deck to play but definitely needs some juice. I want to cut all the non-token sfuff and go all in on mardu go wide/aristocrats.

What would you add to improve it? Right now I got got cruel celebrant, blood artist, vein ripper and chance for glory added in.
>>
>>96588950
if you arent trying to win why are you even playing
>>
>>96588917
Whats funny is I encountered this at work when writing a google doc for a technical thing. Then I asked Chat GPT about it and it was like ya the participle of run is still run. I guess Im a conscientious objector at this point because Im an EFL and in my expert opinion as a language autist, "ran" sounds better and is overall more consistent.

>>96588943
>Only if you keep modifying them. Skull Clamp maybe? But they're 2/2s and Skull Clamp only gives them -1 toughness
>If you can find something that puts +1/+1 on anything that enters and then have Viscera Seer or Umbral Collar Zealot as your sac outlet, then yeah burn your entire library, but it's a lot of board set up and any piece of the engine getting hit puts an end to it
I run skullclamp in everything. But yes anything that puts counters on entry. It feels not hard at all to get value out of this thing. If you are running aristocrats there are plenty of great sac outlets. I did swap UCZ into my deck last night and I expect great things from it. Viscera Seer is another classic that would be great with this card.

>>96588947
>>manifest
>>seeing play
>lmao
I guess but what is wrong with manifest exactly? Its in many ways "draw a card" or "mill" if you consider maybe you want to just get your deck into the GY.
>>
File: serious format.png (381 KB, 675x1008)
381 KB
381 KB PNG
>>96588957
>If you ain't playing aiming to try to win, then you better of not even playing
U
>>
>>96589024
>in my expert opinion as a language autist, "ran" sounds better and is overall more consistent.
ChatGPT says
>The correct sentence is:

>"Has anyone run this?"

>Why it's correct:
>"Has" is a helping verb (present perfect tense).
>The past participle of "run" is "run" (not "ran").

>Why "Has anyone ran this?" is incorrect:
>"Ran" is the simple past tense, not the past participle.
>You need the past participle after "has", "have", or "had".
>Quick comparison:
>Tense Correct Form Example
>Simple Past ran "He ran yesterday."
>Present Perfect has run "He has run every day this week."
>>
>>96589059
>retard uses chat GPT
>>
>>96589096
>a truth once repeated by an AI becomes a lie!!!!!
Prove it wrong or accept defeat
>>
>>96588830
>>96588833
I want the EXACT art and text, not the lame new ones.
>>
>>96589059
>asking abominable intelligence to think for you
>>
>>96588630
They just are.
>>
>>96589024
>I guess but what is wrong with manifest exactly? Its in many ways "draw a card" or "mill" if you consider maybe you want to just get your deck into the GY.
Your deck is more than 1/3 lands so the majority of the time you're just going to be hitting shit you can't manifest. And a 2/2 body isn't great. It doesn't even interact with other things like buffs for tokens etc.

They rereleased like 6 versions of manifest trying to make it not shit.
Manifest dread is one of the better ones because you can choose what is manifested. But you've put down a 2/2 do-nothing with no ability and no protection.
If you get your legendary sac chain off, it will be the best thing manifest has ever done but it's a big IF
>>
>>96589142
See >>96589109
Also I did think for myself and then I was told by someone else that I'm wrong. Could I go fucking google the past tenses of "run"? Sure. How would that be any better than an AI? Go ahead and tell me. Especially when I can get AI to address the exact sentence in question rather than an approximation of it.

You anti-AI fags are so performative, you don't even know why you're against it.
>>
>>96589024
>"ran" sounds better and is overall more consistent.
it sounds WRONG because it is WRONG
fake language autist
>>
>>96589109
>>96589227
>Gay Autist with maladaptive behavior let's AI think for him
>>
What are some reliable Naya Treasure/Food/Clue generators?
>>
File: IMG_3744.jpg (90 KB, 764x752)
90 KB
90 KB JPG
>turn 6
>have guildpact, moonlit on arcane, play infinite guildline
>make 10 signets
>gets out of control, draw 20 cards next turn on attack

https://moxfield.com/decks/ZsmwWi_5REOaCUL6FlvvkA

This deck cant be overpowered? Its a fucking meme deck, but I’m getting. Shamed against Conrad and green goblin
>>
>>96589249
>I see that actually you gave your opinion without AI first
>I can see that the AI agrees you were right
>I can't explain how AI was wrong
>I can't explain why it was wrong to consult AI
>but I CAN act smug about it
Got it.
>>
>>96585705
Why is Bolas gay?
>>
>>96585705
Why is this even possible
>>
>>96589265
>Gets called out for being an autist, proves that he is indeed a cheeked up on the spectrum.
>>
>>96589303
Make up whatever delusions you want you performative faggot, anything to avoid admitting you were wrong
>>
>>96588566
>N-NO! YOU'RE PLAYING THE GAME WRONG!!!
Uh oh melty!
Don't yuck someone's yum, mmkay?
>>
>>96588931
Cunts playing with strangers may lie that brazenly, but usually what happens within more established pods is that there will be one retard that goes out of his way to bend the bracket rules in order to play certain "not a GC guyss" cards or almost-infinite combos and say it's fine because WOTC didn't specifically mention them even though the rules are clear about intent superceding everything else.
>>
>>96589199
>If you get your legendary sac chain off, it will be the best thing manifest has ever done but it's a big IF
Ya I guess the chain is
Warren Soul Trader + Guardian of the Forgotten + Clamp/Counter-Giver

That way you sac, get a treasure + a 2/2 manifest, equip the clamp, sac, repeat and you just go. Then you'd need Elas-Il-Kor or something to take advantage so it is teetering on being a rube-goldberg machine. It doesnt have to be though, there are ways to get the value without assembling exodia
>>
>>96589325
>Don't yuck someone's yum
Makes my skin crawl every time
>>
File: wood elves.png (2.28 MB, 1344x936)
2.28 MB
2.28 MB PNG
which Guay wood elves to buy? I'm a modern frame enjoyer but the og wood elves art is superior
>>
The more I play EDH with randoms the more convinced I become that a lot of people who play EDH don't actually enjoy Magic at all and would be happier playing a boardgame or sonething instead
>>
>>96589400
well I think modern frame SUCKS and retro frame ROCKS
>>
>>96589417
edh in general is only worth playing with friends
>>
>>96588847
Its shit.
>>
>>96589251
Have my super secret tech for him
>>
>>96589417
You have it right on the money
A psychological profile WotC didn't originally codify, but I'm sure they're aware of now is "Guy who doesn't really want to be there but all his closest friends play magic". I call these players: "Sarah".
>>
>>96589251
Probably too expensive, but I like this thing.
>>
Why are planeswalkers illegal as commanders?
>>
>>96589528
Because they just are, okay?!!?!
>>
>>96589251
>>96589504
You can use my favorite robot man in conjunction with basically anything to get a ton of tokens. And yes he makes nine tokens if you tap with transmutation font.
>>
>>96589538
And fuck I forgot the pic.
>>
>>96589417
>The more I play EDH with randoms the more convinced I become that a lot of people who play EDH don't actually enjoy Magic at all and would be happier playing a boardgame or sonething instead
I feel like Im lucky. There are some bozos at my LGS but mostly they cant into threat assessment. Or they dont understand card advantage etc.

But most of the people I play with are
1) Not trannies
2) Play at least mostly seriously and without drama/politics even if they are prone to making bad misplays
3) Seem to enjoy the game even if that is because of flavor, social aspect, w/e

Im inclined to think all the anons here bitching about people at the LGS are actually the problem
>>
>>96589538
>And yes he makes nine tokens if you tap with transmutation font.
no he doesn't, transmutation font makes ONE token. Roboman would make three tokens as normal.
and he does nothing if you make a blood token
>>
>>96586365
Update here: Went to an LGS with the cards seeing if anyone wanted to trade for them the store was gonna offer me 65% store credit until a guy with a venom tattoo overheard what I had and traded me his Revised TAIGA from his cEDH deck for both of them The shop owner was kind enough to inspect the taiga to see if it was real it passed the green dot test and light test so yeah that's how my days going first ever true dual I've ever owned going in my gruul deck
>>
>>96589651
zamn
>>
>>96589651
Genuinely a terrible trade on his part what a retard. Good for you
>>
>>96589651
>trading highly playable RL cards for nu-slop day if release
Holy crap you found the perfect idiot, GJ anon. Only thing I'd trade my RL stuff for is more RL stuff.
>>
>>96588969
Can I interest you in our lord savior Zurgo Stormrender?
>>
>>96589747
Seems based, ill chuck him in
>>
>>96589787
They go pretty well together as it turns out. Most Caesar decks are gonna be happy to have him, and most zurgo decks are happy to have Caesar
>>
>need ~80 commons and uncommons across 3 decks, all from the last 5 years
>gone through dozens of shops all with 20k+ cards in stock, they have near zero of them
Is TCGplayer just fucking dead, then?? It's blowing my mind how I can't find a single shop with more than 5 cards that I need. And I'm not gonna use their broken "mass entry" tool because I refuse to pay $50 in shipping
>>
>>96589787
Caesar pairs well with the neck beard warrior Isshin Two heavens I would honestly buy the FF art of Isshin cause his original art looks like he's protecting his waifus honor
>>
>>96589804
For mass commons /uncommons I go to card kingdom. Like .10 more per card but easier shipping
>>
>>96589747
Based Zurgo enjoyer

>>96588969
Heres my Zurgo list if you want ideas
This list is pushed as fuck and obviously pretty stompy. But its also fairly optimized (minus busted mana rocks and tutors).



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.