Freak Show is the only good season of AHS.
I only ever saw Asylum but it was pretty decent
>>198572586Coven shits over any season.
>>198572586I stopped watching when the aliens put an alien baby up the gay dude's butt.
>>198572586All AHS seasons suffer from the twin problems of completely falling apart thematically during the 2nd half of the season, and being really really fucking gay. Just the tone, vocabulary, and ambiance of most seasons is aggressively gay and I can't even quite put my finger on it beyond several of the actors being really flamboyant about it.Anyhow, I felt Asylum was really the only unequivocably good season, Hotel worked but less as a horror and more pure gonzo. Murder House was at least thematically pretty coherent but was too bleak for it's own good IMO.Apocalypse probably had the absolute best first half and the absolute biggest letdown in the 2nd half.
>>198572586AHS is shite. I always wanted to get into it because I like horror shows but it's always so tonally inconsistent and the plot is always all over the place where the climax of something would happen and then the next 2 episodes would be boring as fuck
>>198572673>Lah lah laaaalah laaalah
>>198572673if you enjoy feminist fantasy drama with a side of nobody being able to permadie. Unless they decide to for...reasons.
>>198572586Only good one was Murder House. After its success FX stopped giving a fuck about what they did and unfortunately the later seasons lacked coherence because of it.
>>198572586>two sarah paulsonsfuck no
>1984>Asylum>Freak Show>Murder House>Hotel>Coven>Apocalypse>ElectionPOWERGAP>The rest>Stories
>>198572888>>1984BASEDhttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=k9g14iaqt3s&pp=ygUOYWhzIDE5ODQgaW50cm8%3D
Roanokes the good one and that double feature season was bizarre as fuck, dont know if it was good tho. Witch season is funny because of the downs girl.AHS always has an interesting premise but goddamn they always shit the bed after a couple episodes and take weird turns.
Seasons without ghosts are better than the ones with them. Their ghost logic/rules are retarded.
>>198573007Roanoke is literal trash
>>198573255I remember enjoying that everyone other than the angry black lady died. Its been awhile since I watched it however, so my memory is fuzzy on the actual plot.
>>198572586Why is that lady so popular? She made some time magazine "totally best goys ever" list and then she did some shit with the united nations or whatever. Anyways every time I see her I say, "oh it's that pinkerton teacher lady from deadwood" and then I change the channel.
>>198572586>Murder houseLegitimately good>AsylumLegitimately good>CovenNot bad, a little aimless at times. A little too grrl power-y>Freak ShowHighs and lows. Really had fun with the freak concept but didn't always seem to know where go with it>HotelSome good episodes and performances in general, and Gaga's ass was nice but you definitely feel what >>198572746 was talking about by the end. Didn't love it, didn't hate it>RoanokeDidn't see, no opinion>CultFrankly had no interest in seeing the show get political. Actively avoided>ApocalyseGreat concept and one or two good episodes then goes right down the shitter. Even by this series' low standards the ending is a complete fucking joke and a slap in the face. Nearly gave up on the show at this point>1984Bascially just a sarcastic riff on 80's slasher films but that's not a bad thing. If was just as campy as it should have been and didn't have a shit ending. One of the better seasons and a complete shock after the bag of ass that was Apocalypse>Double FeatureFirst half is actually pretty good and was nice to see /ourguy Macaluay actually doing stuff. Plus having fewer episodes meant the story didn't feel like it had so much filler in it. Second half is shit >NYC Gave up after the first few epsiodes. It's always been a gay show but a gay season was just too much. It's like it kinda forgot to have a point outside of the gayness. Maybe it got better later but I kind of doubt it>DelicateSuch a blatant Rosemary's baby ripoff that they just went ahead and overtly incorporated it into the plot but like with 1984 I'm not sure being derivative is necessarily bad. Waiting for the terrible ending but I don't hate it so far
>>198573735Cult was fucking hilarious the main villain is a /pol/cel and Sarah Paulson plays a far left huffington post lesbian and the entire series is him tormenting her
>>198572746I opened the thread to talk about the second season (Asylum) and then I saw your post.It's crazy because I really loved the first 2 or 3 episodes of Asylum, but I dropped when crazy Santa Claus appeared and killed that priest.I really don't know what is wrong with the writers of this show.
>>198573912Wait really? That’s sound hilarious.
>>198573912Me:>yeah I really wasn't interested in election year propaganda piece made by gay men who work for jews that predictably stereotypes and villifies all non-liberalsYou:>the main villain is a /pol/cel
>>198574353One of the characters called out 4chan by name. Can't believe /pol/ had Hollywood writers seething that much about a fucking pink shitposting board.
>>198574238Not him, but I actually really liked that season. It was far more nuanced than most people give credit, but I get why the majority of people hated it.
>>198574437They'd just seen Trump win the most unfathomable victory in modern political history. People were showing up to Clinton rallies and shouting "Pepe" at her. They were fucking shookI think we're still too close to it to fully grasp what a fucking insane ride Trump's presidency was. That election night on /pol was something else. Meme magic was real for a minute there
>>198574238Yeah there are some unintentionally hilarious sceneshttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fBs7C5yDNxI&pp=ygUaYW1lcmljYW4gaG9ycm9yIHN0b3J5IGN1bHQ%3Db>>198574353it vilifies both terminally online far right autists and mentally insane far left snowflake faggots. people obsessed with politics are fucking cringeworthy and most scenes are just dunking on one side or the other
>>198572746well the flamboyance is part of the appeal, it's like Jon Waters stuff
>>198572888Cult is better than Apocalypse, it's honestly so deranged it's very funny
I liked Coven but it was single-handedly carried by Kathy Bates and the season was still quite flawed.
>>198575121>VILE NEGRESS
I legit thought AHS ended with Roanoke and there's twice as many seasons now, crazyanywayCoven > Freakshow > Hotel > Murder House > Asylumnot sure what everybody see in Asylum and why is Coven considered so low
>>198572586I like the one where Ariana Grande types: Dr. Pavel, I'm CIA you don't get to bring friends I'm a BIG GUY 4U eoifvh0aishfposifhpasiofhpiouashfpiashfpiasdfipasvijaspijvniw0uhr029yur123ur9283r093q8hf0u93wefhpiascnpijascnpiads
>>198572586I've only seen Asylum and Hotel, and both were excellent.
>>198575291>why is Coven considered so lowI understand that the show is meant to be schlocky teen girl horror, but if I wanted to watch a CW after school show, I would watch the fucking CW.
>>198572586The first part of double feature was pretty good. I liked the new england deserted beach town vibes. Also they were clearly alluding to adrenchrome
>>198574863KINO
Do they write the show a single episode at a time? It feels like they're completely winging it and the show becomes incoherent halfway through a season.
Freakshow > Asylum > Roanoke > Coven > Hotel > First half of the double feature > Cult I don't like the others at all, but I haven't seen the newest one and I don't want to. I hate Kardashians.
>>198572586>Murder House very good>Asylumawesome>Covengood>Freak Showvery good>Cultbad, the politics stuff was funny at times but the season is largely shit>Asylummeta garbageHave not watched the rest.
>>198575748meant Apocalypse for the second Asylum
>>198572586That's Asylum, the only one with actual horror and not so much drama/glamor.Or Roanoke actually which is 100% horror but the doc part is way better than the "real" one>>198572673>female led witch shitYeah no
>>198575772Apocalypse is complete trash. I've never seen anyone say they like it beyond the first couple episodes.
>>198573735I would watch Roanoke, it's actually the one that's most consistently horror out of the whole series, with barely any dramashit
>>198575935There's def drama in the second half though but nowhere near as bad as the others.
/tv/ is a Scream Queens board.
>>198577658honestly when i started the thread, i expected to just get called a faggot & then it'd die.
