They only put these stupid fucking things in the movies to sell toys, right?
There were toys of this?
They were in the book.
Which star wars is this?
>>201707149if you would just care to read the book my dear /tv/ zoomer scholar...
>>201707149>My KING! They have giant elephants! Should we simply keep our distance and use our arrows to hurt and confuse these giant monstrosities?>Oh…. You want us to charge into them and get stomped… oh… alright.
>>201707685i doubt hed ever fought olyphants before so a strategy to fight em had never been devised
>>201707149They didn't sell toys of that
>>201707685>keep your distanceThe job was to keep them from entering the city they would have plowed through them if they just stood there in the moment devising a plan.
>>201707685And it worked, dumb nigger
>>201707149That's the only reason things are put in movies
>>201707806Theoden is supposed to be a semi-competent commander. Any damn fool knows that you shouldn’t attack a more powerful beast head on when you can outmanoeuvre them and hit them from afar.>>201707876Ah yes… the city that was already breached and full of narrow streets… yeah…
>>201707685>>201708326How will they keep distance when they are charging at them at full speed and will reach them under a minute?
>>201707208people don't like fantastical things in fantastical filmsthat's why lotr is so devoid of real magic....
>>201708448Moving might help (cue laugh track)
>>201707149>toysThey're called miniatures.
Grey as a mouse,Big as a house,Nose like a snake,I make the earth shake,As I tramp through the grass;Trees crack as I pass.With horns in my mouthI walk in the South,Flapping big ears.Beyond count of yearsI stump round and round,Never lie on the ground,Not even to die.Oliphaunt am I,Biggest of all,Huge, old, and tall.If ever you'd meet meYou wouldn't forget me.If you never do,You won't think I'm true;But old Oliphaunt am I,And I never lie.
>>201707149I was almost the perfect target market age group for these films being born in 1988 and I don't remember any toy merchandise for this stuff unless you include Games Workshop launching a TT LOTR game like Warhammer
>>201708748>that's why lotr is so devoid of real magic....That was in the novels too.
>>201709393yes they werethere's some magical elements in the booksmost of it was cut from the movies...
>>201710297The premise of an ethereal being putting his power into a ring, wizards casting magic and Balrogs existing invalidates that notion. You want to see TES or DND levels of magic when both of those settings owe their existence to Tolkien.
>>201707806This is one of the funniest things i've read today. Like imagine a hunter who had fought a lion but then encounters a really big bear.>wtf what do i do now... it's just incomprehensible... where do i even begin?! i need to fight and lose to it many times before i can think of a way to deal with this...LOL
>>201708748>that's why lotr is so devoid of real magic....i thought that was because magic was getting weaker over time and by the time the events of hobbit/lotr came around it was super diminished.
>>201707278Revenge of the Jedi
>>201709276>mfw got Helm's Deep Aragorn and my brothers got knight Pippin and Merry
Well, I don't know.What's so bad about these animals?
>>201712048They're elephants.
>>201708748>No wozards casting le fire ball and le evin neon colors therefore no magic Retard with shit taste.
>>201712064Yes, elephants have been used in wars for a long time in the real world.And?
>>201707149Olyphants were cool.
>>201709214MODS DELETE THIS GORE
Why didn't the Rohirrim just enter the city instead and fight them from the walls?
>>201712495It's hard to get that many horses into narrow stone streets in an organized way.
>>201709152>miniature of a giant elephant
>>201712409>>201707208they were in the book but were they supposed to be that big? I thought olyphants were just maybe a little bigger than regular elephants. Those things are like 100 feet tall
>>201712516probably a lot harder for elephants
>>201709276There were action figures for the first film that I remember, but they were also pretty shitty. It was also around when Yugioh was just starting in the US and that apparently caused a slump in toy sales because of kids wanting cards more than toys, so maybe they didn't make as many for the second or third films.
>>201712551The biggest African elephant ever recorded stood at 13 feet tall. The ones in the movie are around 45 or 50 feet. They're supposed to be extremely massive going by Sam's poem >>201709214. And there are creatures that are even bigger in Middle Earth. Mostly the dragons.
>>201712566Imagine all of the elephants trying to fit through the gates of Gondor.
>>201712645I can't even imagine one of them. I honestly don't know what role they would have played in the battle of the Rohirrim didn't show up, and they didn't know the Rohirrim were showing up.
>>201707149>but if we changed them to rhino's, no one would noticeMark Rosewater said calmly
>>201712667>>201712645if they're that big couldn't they help break down the walls? Just have the elephant headbutt the wall
>>201712713No lol. Those are big, thick fucking walls.
>>201710297>one of the main characters is a wizard who regularly uses magic>>201708748I really like how they did the magic in warcraft movie
>>201707685Yeah, it was really weird that the king that just lead an army screaming "DEATH!" lead a second death charge...
>>201712632Yeah, they're massive for a hobbit
>>201710895it's three movies of bunch of retards walking into a fucking volcanoit ain't magical at all..
>>201713616
>>201713661none of that happens in the movies...
>>201713732https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y2fwe0rnHak
>>201713732>t. didn't watch the movie
>>201713616This is what happens when you become such a gay hipster for so long that you become contrarianism poisoned and have to deconstruct anything you see.
>>201713748balrog did not have a sword like >>201713661depicted hereit's a lie.....none of it is true.
>>201713797https://youtu.be/1tNWTJxLMXs?t=65
>>201707685>simply
>>201713839the sword was curved in the art...it's a fucking. it's phony. it's all phony bullshit
>>201711992I got orc disguise Sam and my brother got Eomer
>>201713907don't you think you're putting in a little too much effort to look like an idiot right now?
>>201707149Toybiz made everything BUT oliphaunts.
>>201712736Yeah and those big, thick fucking elephants
>>201712667Tactical reserve
>>201707685>>201707806>>201707876>>201708448>>201713131>>201713876I swear this is the new "eagles, ring, mt doom" argument.>Be Theoden>lead cavalry based army>Movement is key to success for cavalry>About to be "hammer and anviled" between giant elephants, orcs and the walls of Minas Tirith>Men are beginning to panic>have seconds to rally them and make a decision>decide to charge at them in order to get behind the giant elephants and out of the deathtrapTheoden made the right call and I'm tired of people saying it was a bad tactic.
>>201712632>Giant dragonsHNNNGGG
>>201709152what a terrible paintjob
If you could keep your horses from breaking it was a good tactic against elephants historically.Elephants are intelligent cowards and you can break their morale if they think they are going to get hurt. And once they do they turn on their own infantry and break the line to get away. Romans would do it on foot.
>>201712551They're large enough to have tiny men up on their neck, and war towers.>To his astonishment and terror, and lasting delight, Sam saw a vast shape crash out of the trees and come careering down the slope. Big as a house, much bigger than a house, it looked to him, a grey-clad moving hill. Fear and wonder, maybe, enlarged him in the hobbit’s eyes, but the Mûmak of Harad was indeed a beast of vast bulk, and the like of him does not walk now in Middle-earth; his kin that live still in latter days are but memories of his girth and majesty. On he came, straight towards the watchers, and then swerved aside in the nick of time, passing only a few yards away, rocking the ground beneath their feet: his great legs like trees, enormous sail-like ears spread out, long snout upraised like a huge serpent about to strike, his small red eyes raging. His upturned hornlike tusks were bound with bands of gold and dripped with blood. His trappings of scarlet and gold flapped about him in wild tatters. The ruins of what seemed a very war-tower lay upon his heaving back, smashed in his furious passage through the woods; and high upon his neck still desperately clung a tiny figure – the body of a mighty warrior, a giant among the Swertings.
>>201711670That and all the wizards had limiters on them from god so they would not wreck shit
>>201714052should have just gone around