[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/tv/ - Television & Film


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: seen everything.jpg (43 KB, 1024x576)
43 KB
43 KB JPG
Already Seen Everything Edition

Previously on /trek/: >>214133009
>>
star trek sex with shran
>>
>>214140540
Seems to be a lot of /trek/ threads recently. What's with the sudden uptake after it seemingly being dead?
>>
File: 1744239597718617.png (180 KB, 450x470)
180 KB
180 KB PNG
Uuuh is that bad if I like Strange New Worlds? Just finished watching the latest episode, it was fun. I eagerly look forward new episodes each week.
>>
>>214140576
>Uuuh is that bad if I like Strange New Worlds?
Yes.
>>
>>214140571
One of the old ritualposters returned.
>>
>>214140571
a line was drawn this far no further
>>
File: Dinner Tonight.webm (2.11 MB, 720x542)
2.11 MB
2.11 MB WEBM
>>214133288
>>
>>214140576
Theme your reac pics.
>>
File: 546903412147676.png (398 KB, 528x522)
398 KB
398 KB PNG
>>214140576
>>
>it was fun
Yeah, that sounds about right. That's a SNW fan if I've ever heard one right there.
>>
>>214140571
jeri ryan's leak
>>
Damn y'all have been busy. Last thread I remember seeing was Sex With Shran edition. Suddenly you go all the way through big hat edition too?
>>
File: 1755489810438584m.jpg (53 KB, 1024x735)
53 KB
53 KB JPG
friendly reminder not to talk to it or acknowledge its presence at all
>>
File: ds9 vile.jpg (43 KB, 500x378)
43 KB
43 KB JPG
>>214140673
well said, words to live by
>>
>>214140673
Leninism
>>
>>214140576
No, you just see typical 4chan contrarians and the occasional schizo is all. Now if you said you liked Discovery...
>>
File: 1718987965690277.jpg (8 KB, 250x250)
8 KB
8 KB JPG
>>214140624
This Peepo is from holo Las Vegas
>>
>>214140673
Indeed, my honored Gul. It shall be so.
>>
>>214140540
If a Federation race was culturally nudist then would they be permitted to join Starfleet and as part of their culture be nude on duty?
>>
>>214140719
>:(
>>
Made it to VOY: Endgame. Fare thee well Berman Trek. I just have Nemesis after this and then in my trek it's on to nuTrek. Fortunately the streaming era comes to my rescue, there aren't many total episodes left after this. Then, I'm done for a while.
>>
>>214140768
No. Bajorans aren't supposed to wear their earrings either, Picard lets Ro wear it as a treat.

So maybe he'd cut some boob holes out of a nudist's uniform or something once they became a trusted subordinate.
>>
>>214140768
Probably not, due to uniform regulation. Unless the captain was based enough to allow it anyway...
See TNG Ensign Ro as a direct analogy
>>
>>214140793
so you're skipping ENT?
>>
>>214140768
I remember an episode of Sliders where the end-gag was they ended up on a naked planet.
>>
>>214140793
How'd you like S4-S7 VOY?
>>
>>214140806
Why was Worf allowed to wear his fancy sash?
>>
>>214140806
>>214140818
Human supremacy in the Federation once again rears its ugly head.
>>
>>214140823
No it's chronological by stardate order. I started with Enterprise many many seasons ago.
>>
>>214140846
because Picard is a Klingaboo
>>
>>214140846
Probably not strictly against uniform code. I imagine "jewelry" was policed more tightly as a working hazard more than an extra piece of fabric.
>>
>>214140829
>How'd you like S4-S7 VOY?
Needed more Chakotay episodes. Otherwise, it's all fine Trek. Lots of good sci fi premises.
>>
File: Gorn.jpg (605 KB, 1822x1440)
605 KB
605 KB JPG
>>214140571
The Gorn Community has returned!
>>
VOY S1-7 needed more Beltran acting
>>
>>214140890
I would've liked some more Akoocheemoya too but they made him totally boring after that Hamalke guy got exposed

They should've just doubled down on the goofy fake indian shit imo
>>
>>214140823
>>214140865
Also I already watched STD seasons 1 and 2 before watching TOS, so I don't have as much of that crap to watch anyway
>>
File: warf.jpg (55 KB, 406x720)
55 KB
55 KB JPG
>>214140905
They have NO HONOR
>>
>>214140904
>Arguably, it's even worse than Star Trek discovery.
while I generally agree with the rest of your post, nah. Discovery is still worse because even as flawed as BSG is, it still looks fucking great. The space combat is gorgeous, the portrayal of the ships, and there is at least a spectre of military discipline in how the characters interact on the bridge.

Basically, BSG still feels military (up until towards the end) for a long time in a way that STD always just felt like a super hero vehicle
>>
>>214140931
I don't see why all his episodes needed to be Indian episodes. I just liked him as a character. Honestly I was looking forward to Seven but then they just overused her a little too much. However like I said, I think seasons 4-7 did a nice job. I'm not as harsh on Voyager as some people are
>>
>>214140865
what an incredibly dumb thing to do, well godspeed anon, I wish you the very best of luck
>>
>>214140571
shitposters' bans are up
>>
>>214140965
he's not a genuine poster he's just in it for the (you) don't bother.
>>
What even are the rules the UFP outlines for Starfleet personnel?
>>
>>214140965
Not this anon, but wanted to add that the miniseries and first episode were also some of the best television I had ever seen. It was mostly a gradual decline from there, and especially in the last half. Whereas I don't think I've enjoyed any of DIS. Admittedly there is the very rare decent plotline but the show can't help but to shoehorn stupid shit into every episode.
>>
>>214140994
Nah it was fun watching Enterprise first. Lots of little hints of things to come. Ferengi, Brent Spiner imagining robots, it actually works pretty damn well as an introduction.
>>
>>214141017
There's been a rise in (You) farming lately.
>>
>>214140975
Well, the boxing episode fucking sucked. He had a few opportunities and they were just bad. Plus, there was a lot going on behind the scenes with Beltran.

They kind of kneecapped what was interesting about his character in episode 2 of the show by just making Starfleet and Maquis get along magically. He went from the leader of the Maquis to the "you've got to follow the rules!" guy who was busting Paris' balls on the holodeck for gambling rations.
He just becomes "first officer man" after that and kind of generic outside of the indian stuff which is the only thing that remains to set him apart.
>>
I like how Janeway doesn't trust Janeway. It's very Janeway of her. Overall that's my review of Voyager, Janeway is actually a really great captain.
>>
>>214140965
>still feels military (up until towards the end) for a long time in a way that STD always just felt like a super hero vehicle
Exactly this. I wouldn't trust any of the STD cast to be able to operate a toaster, let alone a starship
>>
>>214141098
Janeway is bestway, if you're Insaneway, she knows what shes doing never trust Janeway especially if you are Janeway, who knows what that crazy bitch will do.
>>
File: 1745730744627529.jpg (224 KB, 1920x1080)
224 KB
224 KB JPG
>>214141098
The whole "Insaneway" thing has always been exaggerated. It's VOY's 'Kirk is a manwhore,' ie the common mass misconception people seem to have about the show.

There are like 5-6 episodes where she is "Insaneway" at best and I think the show has what, 176 episodes? Some of the episodes aren't even her because she's under alien influence, or it's a duplicate or an alternate version like: Course Oblivion and Living Witness
>>
>>214140553
on the grass
>>
>>214141097
That's the beauty of Voyager though. One bad episode doesn't really ruin a character. He has a cool episode just before the finale where he ends up meeting a native tribe with Seven. It's a really nicely done episode. There's some lines here and there that he's an anthropologist, and they use that a tiny bit.
>>
>>214140354
Then make a request! I have all episodes from all series, plus the movies.
>>
>>214141181
I agree. She's a very good captain. She tends to follow the rules and does a good job as a leader of the crew.
>>
>>214141206
VOY shines on rewatches because as great as DS9 is, you start to know the major story beats a little too well after a while but VOY being almost entirely episodic kind of retains its freshness episode-to-episode. Having said that, I love rewatching them both.
>>
File: STTOS: Ken and Barbie.jpg (45 KB, 396x450)
45 KB
45 KB JPG
Do you have one of these yet? You're not a real Trekkie unless you do!
>>
Voyager was litty
>>
>>214141181
how many times must we go through this? its not her competely irrational insane moments its the episode to episode whee she switches back and forth on what her stance is, who knows what her stance is? does she even have one? the insaneway meme is very misunderstood by nufaggots like yourself. Having said that...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2c7cHdPKCE
and what you nu-fags really don't seem to understand is that we love Insaneway
>>
>>214140768
Lwaxana Troi was nude in one episode. Thankfully they didn't show anything too revolting. That lady is scary. Someone needs to tell Majel she's not young and cute anymore.
>>
>>214141336
Lwaxana wasn't Starfleet
>>
>>214141098
Part of me thinks it would have been more interesting if Janeway was the Commander who had to step up to be Captain with the actual Captain of Voyager being killed in the first episode. So a sort of idea that she feels out of her depth in position, made worse by the situation Voyager is in. I suppose this is part of a wider issue I have that a lot of Voyager seems sort of wasted. The critique has been made by many before, but it seems to squander what the premise should set up by just really being no different to the cruise like feel the Enterprise in TNG has despite the completely different circumstances. Obviously it could go to far the other way to become grimdark or even grimderp at the worst level, but is a grading it could have worked with towards something that was not effectively doing the cruise-like feel and everything resetting. Now sure part of the direction they did go is going to be reflective of the TV at the time and what the network executives want, but I am not really sure how much of a defence that is on a creative level regarding the show itself being judged.
>>
>>214140940
Who is your shrink? Must be great for you to still be here
>>
File: voy insaneway 3.jpg (18 KB, 378x510)
18 KB
18 KB JPG
>>214141231
>She tends to follow the rules
damn straight never ever broken the prime directive that lass, maybe bent it a time or two, and by bent I mean shattered splintered and used for fire wood
>>
>>214141325
That's not at all true though and I've seen that video many times. It uses the 5-6 episodes I'm talking about and pretty much nothing else.

The episode-to-episode inconsistency is barely a thing at all because there just aren't enough Insaneway episodes to take away from her consistently being a competent captain.
I say it's like the 'Kirk is a manwhore' thing because that's what it is: a common misconception by people who don't know much about the show.

I'm sure you've watched it, anon, but it was maybe once or twice with a shrug because you decided you didn't much care for it, the same way people can "watch TOS" and then think Kirk was anything but a highly academic and serious-minded captain.
>>
>>214141305
This episode sounds cringe on paper but it's actually kino. UPN basically forced it on the writers as blatant cross promotion for the WWF but instead they not so subtly took the piss out of it.
>>
>>214141416
> its the episode to episode where she switches back and forth on what her stance is
anon I am rewatching voy right now and have watched it many many times, and yes she is constantly shifting her stance depending on the episode yes it is true, if you really just finished voyager idk how you missed it.
>>
>>214141364
She was on the Enterprise as a guest of Starfleet. That means she has to abide by Starfleet regulations. She was also a Federation citizen.
>>
>>214141364
She's a federation ambassador
>>
>>214141416
>>214141472
Additionally, I will admit that the reason Insaneway has some staying power as a thing is that the 5-6 episodes where she is truly Insaneway are typically BIG EPISODES, like pivotal story episodes. The pilot, Scorpion with the first Borg interaction, Equinox which is another two-parter. That's 3 two-parters where she is inconsistent with her normal character, so I think that is kind of why people focus on her poorly written episodes and ignore the good that counterbalances it.

It's like the news: bad news sells newspapers and gets clicks, nobody gives a shit about good news.

And I'm not the guy who just finished a rewatch, I'm in S6 of my VOY watchthrough right now but it's kind of been delayed by other things.
>>
File: 1745977518185899m.jpg (60 KB, 1024x553)
60 KB
60 KB JPG
>>
>>214141416
Idk how else to say this without being insulting, you are a fucking moron.
>>
>>214140576
Next: Flatulence.
>>
>>214141502
Well, you could start by making some detailed counterpoints instead of acting like I'm a nu trek faggot and tossing ad homns at me. Pretty disrespectful, anon.
>>
>>214141492
The bullshit Riker Ex Machina at the end of Picard S1 reminded me so much of this scene
>>
>>214141336
they cut the scene with her smearing her grilled cheese across the science station
>>
>>214141491
no they are every episode every single one, without fail, I might even doa big write up on the countless times janeway flipflops on her supposed "principles" once i've finished my current rewatch. All the "well it was only during the first 2 seasons" "well it was only a few big episodes" doesn't cut it, Not even a little bit, literally episode to episode, you know what I will for the first time, be prepared it will take some time but after I finish Voy I am on to my ENT rewatch, so I'll multitask. The Many Crimes of Janeway and her Crew of Schizos will be coming...in a few months.
>>
>>214141593
>every episode
Yeah, you've definitely got some comprehension issues, anon. I look forward to your rambling manifesto so I can tear it to pieces with acerbic cross-examination.

Prepare your bootyhole.
>>
File: 1756424219420999.jpg (61 KB, 320x240)
61 KB
61 KB JPG
>>
>>214141514
>Janeway hater
Thats exactly whats annoying me I don't hate Janeway at all, or Voy, but I can laugh at the things that crew of psychos got up to. The definitive Insaneway the Mad Captain of the Delta Quadrant compilation will be coming. Give me time.
>>
File: voy insaneway 5.gif (1.03 MB, 450x342)
1.03 MB
1.03 MB GIF
>>214141622
see you in a few months for now I'm on s6 so many great insaneway episodes to come
>>
>>214141718
The only major one I recall that's still in front of me in S6 is the series finale. Time traveling Janeway is full Insaneway, no two ways about it.
>>
>>214141474
>>214141483
>Starfleet
>on duty
Starfleet is not the Federation. This is like saying "oh yeah since our ambassador in Germany has waist-length hair, our Marines can wear it that way too." No the military has its own dress code to abide by that diplomatic officials don't. Also I don't fully remember the episode, but I don't think she was ever nude when acting in her official capacity anyway?
>>
File: pepe sisko.jpg (135 KB, 500x328)
135 KB
135 KB JPG
thinkin about...making a fanedit of my favorite character. would that be too gay? too cringe?
>>
>>214141781
Which character?
>>
>>214141523
ok the ocean planet, the french faggots planet, the back in time apocalypse planet, the swarm space, the hirogen relay, the krenim space...these are the minor everyday sort of issues not the Big ones.
>>
>>214141808
weyoun
>>
>>214141748
you need to keep the prime directive in mind and then look at things in a more critical light, trust me it won't take away from your enjoyment quite the opposite, it makes things so much more entertaining.
>>
>>214140571
SNW marketing
>>
>>214140571
>What's with the sudden uptake after it seemingly being dead?
Phase II of The Plan, codenamed "Xon," to watch Star Trek, requires active participating in this thread to monitor, collect intelligence on, and counter certain Interlopers.
Also, what would Starfleet uniforms look like to di- and tetrachromats?
>>
I haven't seen every episode of TOS, TAS or VOY. Only TNG, DS9 and ENT.
>>
>>214141781
Depends on what character. Why dont you TELL US :)
>>
File: 1749438636121390.png (182 KB, 285x502)
182 KB
182 KB PNG
>>214141862
>>214141862
I genuinely don't care about the Prime Directive being broken, though. That does not constitute insanity, so if that's the direction you're going, well, I can just counter when other beloved captains broke it.

It's about when, where, why, how severely, and if it's justified. A captain acting insane or wildly straying from Starfleet principles is one thing, breaking the Prime Directive is another.

If you're really going to do this, you need to catalog how many times EACH captain has broken the Prime Directive, whether you personally believe it was justified or not, and then we can discuss them comparatively.
If that's your angle, there's going to be a lot to it. But it would be interesting for the thread to talk about.
>>
>>214141305
litty based
>>
File: Kim.jpg (21 KB, 303x404)
21 KB
21 KB JPG
>>214141808
Harry Kim to this song.
>https://youtu.be/bb2OSQLnn6A?si=Y9H4abhSe6g8mHEl
>>
>>214141980
>I genuinely don't care about the Prime Directive being broken
lol how very Janeway of you, but she does care, at least when it suits her, 1/2 those episodes I named were ones when she says she is either holding to or breaking the prime directive, so if thats the argument you are going for then you've already failed. This is the entire reason for Insaneway she changes her mind episode to episode. I can't believe you don't get that. Oh and btw that img you posted its called "the Trial of Captain Kirk" its a fun comic all his supposed violations of the prime directive are put on trial, even the gangsters from piece of the action show up they give McCoy his communicator back its funny, whole thing is good fun you should read it sometime. Doesn't excuse Janeways actions her stance or "I never broke the prime directive" bullshit she told Ransom.
>>
File: Schaub-2015-Kirk.jpg (82 KB, 650x430)
82 KB
82 KB JPG
>https://youtu.be/s4yBHgC4_Xs?si=pv-jL731EHbu-YZJ
>>
File: 175621296148539502.gif (624 KB, 220x165)
624 KB
624 KB GIF
>>214142132
>?si=Y9H4abhSe6g8mHEl
>>
>>214142167
Isn't that guy a rapist or something?
>>
File: 1756057907488026.jpg (66 KB, 604x285)
66 KB
66 KB JPG
>>214142194
Aren't you?
>>
File: ds9-palesisko-1280x964.jpg (73 KB, 1280x964)
73 KB
73 KB JPG
>>214142228
I allow my thread personalities a little rape, as a treat.
>>
>>214141894
There are only a few seasons of TOS so its easy to finish it all even in like a month
>>
>>214142228
Kevin R. Nash doesn't count
>>
File: 1756527914461668m.jpg (94 KB, 772x1024)
94 KB
94 KB JPG
>>
>>214142157
All of the great captains broke the Prime Directive 5+ times, though, and nobody calls them insane.

Whether or not a captain has violated the Prime Directive is just autistic pedantry rather than an honest argument. Violating the Prime Directive is not inherently wrong, nor is it inherently right. Picard violated it at least 9 times, Kirk at least 6, Sisko at least 5, and Janeway at least 6 times and there are not soft violations, these are hard violations. Granted, only 5 or 6 of Picard's are shown on screen but Seti says he's violated it 9 times in The Drumhead and Picard does not deny it because the obvious implication is that we, the audience, know that his violations were justified.

We just watched Sisko violate it in The Circle in the DS9 Watchalong the other night when he ignored Starfleet orders to evacuate the station and directly involved himself in the Bajoran coup.
It's just not that simple, anon. Ethical issues are not like math problems that can be solved so cleanly and without debate or nuance taken into consideration.
>>
File: 1551246385581.png (10 KB, 574x540)
10 KB
10 KB PNG
>>214142267
>>
File: voy torpedos.gif (2.95 MB, 540x350)
2.95 MB
2.95 MB GIF
>>214142335
Idk what to tell you but I'll try, you don't understand the Prime Directive you are incredibly defensive of Insaneway, you don't even understand how that term came about, and you won't even address the episdoes I named likly because you don't even remember them, and if as you said you just watched Voy then that is seriously weird, in short, I will make a total write up of all of Janeways many many violations her many many changes in personality episode to episode and her and her crews complete lack of consistency at a later time. No I will not be doing a total write up on all the captains or crew just voyager, no I do not care if that upsets you. Now then by all means continue to defend insaneway she sure needs it.
>>
>>214142538
NTA but when did Janeway break the Prime Directive?
>>
>>214142550
see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2c7cHdPKCE [Embed]
just for starters
>>
>>214142538
The fact that your posts are just one giant paragraph of word salad really says it all, anon. But I look forward to continuing to humiliate you as you insist on moving ahead with this. I will be using other captains and their violations as examples, however, so you should probably take that into consideration as you scratch out your Benny-esque manifesto on your lovely white walls.

Good luck! We're all rooting for you!
>>
>>214141492
in the expanded universe, somehow this guy became special forces and commanded the Enterprise-E
>>
>>214142598
Okay thanks for informing me that you're a total joke with no actual argument.
>>
What went wrong with Star Trek Discovery?
>>
>>214140576
What do you like about it? How many episodes have you rewatched?
>>
>>214142614
anon I am not going to double space like some reddit faggot, if it turns into more the a paragraph I'll space like a normal person, that post wasn't that, but thanks for once again proving my point, you really don't have a come back at all, the best you can do it try and pick on my posting style. Lol.
>>
>>214142661
He hasn't watched any. It's all about the (You)s.
>>
>>214142550
Big discussion of that here: https://www.sffchronicles.com/threads/24470/
>>
File: 1726694761401804.jpg (523 KB, 987x741)
523 KB
523 KB JPG
>>214142335
>>214142538
The prime directive is a meaningless plot device. It's importance and rigidity is always dependent on what kind of conflict the writer wants to inject into the story. It has never been treated with any consistency in the entire history of the franchise. Arguing about it is pointless.
>>
>>214142625
lol you genuinely have no idea what you are trying to post about do you? that vid is 2 and 1/2 mins+ you replayed in 20 seconds you idiot child.
>>
>>214142723
nope its the core one you ignore that then things get really silly, like Voy did
>>
>>214142724
Calm down, the both of you.
>>
>>214142638
just about everything, except doug jones
>>
>>214142760
idiots are annoying
>>
>>214142767
poor doug, feel bad for him, hope he got a ton of cash for it. He deserved better.
>>
>>214142774
/trek/ is a trial of patience.
>>
According to chatGPT, just doing a blind pass out of curiosity as I read this argument:

Kirk: 4 clear on screen violations
>Miri - vaccinating children after plague
>Return of the Archons - destroying mind-control computer
>Patterns of Force - intervention in Naziland created by Fed historian
>Private Little War - arming aliens for proxy war with Klingons
TNG - 9 stated violations, 5 on screen
>Pen Pals - pre-warp civilization saved
>Who Watches the Watchers - direct cultural contamination
>Justice - saves Wesley from death penalty
>Homeward - relocation of Boraal II inhabitants
Sisko - 6 or 7 strong violations
>Captive Pursuit
>the Circle
>all Emissary role episodes, Accession, Rapture, etc
>Sacrifice of Angels - asks for Prophet intervention
>For the Uniform - lol
>The Die is Cast - defies orders to rescue Odo and attacks Dominion ships sparking open war
>Pale Moonlight
Janeway - Six clear violations
>False Profits - creates her own false prophet to counter Ferengi contamination
>Scorpion - makes a deal with a Borg, shares tech
>Demon - "Voyager crew's DNA exposure accelerates a pre‑sentient species' evolution. Though debated, most agree it constitutes a direct violation. " (don't agree with this one at all)
>Killing Game - gives tech
>Dragon's Teeth - revives Vaadwaur
>Voyager Conspiracy - ?Fed tech used to build subspace catapult
It exclusives Omega Directive as the Directive overrides the Prime Directive and allows itt o be countermanded, and Endgame for time travel.
>>
>>214142812
true I'll stop now insaneway should be in a penal colony
>>
File: bf.png (506 KB, 707x701)
506 KB
506 KB PNG
Do you own any trek gear?
>>
>>214142829
damn AI is stupid, Jneway also gave federation weapons away
>>
>>214142869
That's mentioned though under Scorpion, actually most of her violations are dissemination of Fed tech
>>
>>214142723
Finally, somebody who gets it. I'm the first anon you're quoting there and I completely agree. Like I said, quibbling over the Prime Directive is just autistic pedantry. All that matters is if it was justified or not.
>>
Barclay sex crimes?
>>
Damn. It was hard to watch Dater’s autistic ass get played like a fiddle in this episode. This is the type of experience that turns naive young men into incels. I’m glad Riker gave him the “ya gotta get back up on the saddle” pep talk at the end to steer him right. I’d be upset too if I missed out on this Yareltoe.
>>
File: 1756319567909064.gif (1.63 MB, 480x360)
1.63 MB
1.63 MB GIF
Remember the episode where Archer goes off on Trip for teaching the Cogenitor how to read?

If you think the Prime Directive is some unassailable principle and that total non-interference is always the right decision NO MATTER THE SITUATION, you must agree with good ol' retarded Archer in that episode. Sure, it's pre-Prime Directive but he is basically defending its principles. ENT has more than one dumb episode like this.
>>
>>214142987
that wasn't even a Prime Directive thing. Archer was just genuinely mad that they wouldn't be able to use their sex slave to get knocked up
>>
>>214142987
It's not set in stone.
>>
>>214142987
using Archer as an example of reason is never the right move
>>
>>214142921
Peeing on girls like R. Kelly.
>>
>>214142921
Barclay has never had sex with a real woman.
>>
This is embarrassing.
>>
Sisko is definitely the single biggest violator of the Prime Directive. Constantly meddled in the politics of alien worlds, embraced being a religious figure to aliens, bombed planets, hunted down innocents and even participated in an political assassination. The guy's a fucking menace.
>>
>>214143062
Many anons relate to Barclay.
>>
>>214143119
My aunt counts doesn't she?
>>
>>214143103
you don't understand what the PD is
>>
>>214143158
Do go on.
>>
prime directive was only relevant during the “we have to re-use other show’s sets” era of TOS where they had to go to a roman world or a nazi world or a gangster world or a cowboy world

by TNG it is just retarded and a complete afterthought
>>
>>214143103
>embraced being a religious figure to aliens
He knew it was vital to getting Bajor into the Federation and Starfleet was pragmatic enough to begrudgingly accept it. Besides, not taking ownership of your interference and walking away from it is probably just as bad as interfering in the first place, accidentally creating a prophet figure and then metaphorically killing it. That's where Picard's militant atheism in Who Watches The Watchers went wrong.
>>
>>214143216
nope
>>
>>214143046
Good thing I'm doing the opposite and using a scenario where he was explicitly wrong and treated a crewman like shit over it?
>>
>>214143216
Not true. Pen Pals is a great TNG episode just because it shows a case where the crew is 100% justified in violating the Prime Directive
>>
archer was justified
>>
The most "Insaneway" moment of Voyager isn't even one where she violates the Prime Directive which just further shows how dumb the latter is to use as a measuring stick.

It's in Equinox where she is threatening the crewman of that ship with being left to the aliens they've been using for fuel. She opens portals and leaves the room. Chakotay has to confront her in the hall and basically shout her back down to reality, in which case she eventually relents. She doesn't break the Prime Directive here, she just goes right up to the line and stops, but it's definitely her most unhinged moment of the entire series.

Again, the entire premise of this argument is that you can't ignore 170 episodes of a character acting as a rational captain, point to 6 where she's a completely different person due to bad writing (typically from an outside script) and then say she's "Insaneway."
>>
>>214142638
Brian Fuller either left or was ousted, and someone incompetent tried to fill in the gaps. Probably Kurtzmann
>>
>>214143470
>you can't ignore 170 episodes of a character acting as a rational captain, point to 6 where she's a completely different person due to bad writing (typically from an outside script) and then say she's "Insaneway."
Of course I can, it's funny
>>
>>214143518
True. You can do that, I should say, but not if you're trying to make a serious argument.
>>
>>214143045
then why is it called the PRIME directive
>>
>>214143577
>the virgin PRIME Directive
>the chad OMEGA Directive which allows for the Prime Directive to be broken
Poor little Prime boy
>>
Now I'm watching Star Trek Nemesis. I really want to watch it with an open mind, maybe it's not as bad as I remember?
>>
>>214143594
I sincerely doubt the violations of the Prime Directive by all the Star Trek captains can be traced to the Omega Directive. Even by the standards of 4chan retards, that was really bad.
>>
>>214143748
I haven't seen it in forever but I remember it being fucking retarded
>>
>>214143748
Its proto-nutrek
>>
>>214143748
it was cool as a kid, but it gets exponentially worse the older you get
>>
>>214142495
Hay guuuiss itz Gaynan
>>
>>214143748
I saw the Plinkett reviews before I ever watched Star Trek so I always imagine the Remans on vacation in the pool playing volleyball like in that photoshop he did.
>>
>>214143748
it's boring and depressing
>>
>>214143235
>he knew he could use it to manipulate alien politics in favor of the federation and that's good because
Wow okay you're retarded
>>
File: Tom_and_Kes.jpg (47 KB, 692x480)
47 KB
47 KB JPG
Me and my wife (she is 4 (four) years old)
>>
>>214144013
You can tell she's an alien because she doesn't have eyebrows
>>
>>214144135
>>starfleet knew they could use it to manipulate alien politics in favor of the federation and that's good because*
ftfy
>>
File: kira.png (361 KB, 1000x1000)
361 KB
361 KB PNG
Is this a reference to something that happened in an episode, or just a silly meme?
>>
File: 1748733792746820.jpg (307 KB, 1008x1011)
307 KB
307 KB JPG
>>214144647
>QUAAAAAAAAAARK!
>You made Kira fat!
>Oh... Oh by the Link, I'm gonna... I'm gonna GOOOOOOOOOOOO
>>
File: hologooner.webm (437 KB, 1280x974)
437 KB
437 KB WEBM
>>214144647
Tiron specifically requested an inflation mode in his custom program. that and the related scenes were cut
>>
This Nemesis movie sucks. I'd rather be watching First Contact and I can't even believe I'm saying that. There's an hour left. This is so booooring
>>
>>214144647
Another Evangelion reference?
>>
File: Gul-Dukat.jpg (54 KB, 640x480)
54 KB
54 KB JPG
Is Dukat an Architect? Or does he have a lame fetish like NTR or feet?
>>
>>214144786
Nemesis, First Contact, or The Motionless Picture?
>>
>>214144843
i don't think he has a specific fetish unless you want to count liking Bajorans. i think he's just horny as fuck. he has 7 legitimate children and god knows how many bastards.
>>
File: 1753411659090017.jpg (244 KB, 512x512)
244 KB
244 KB JPG
>>214144843
Hes based
>>
File: Pike.jpg (271 KB, 1600x900)
271 KB
271 KB JPG
He's taken his proper place on the Mt. Rushmore of Star Trek Captains now!
>>
>>214140576
>Uuuh is that bad if I like Strange New Worlds? Just finished watching the latest episode, it was fun. I eagerly look forward new episodes each week.
Many Cats here Fucking LOVE Strange New Worlds. They are at war with themselves to not admit it though.
>>
>>214144959
>no new episode
>didn't do anything noteworthy in any of the last ones
yeah I'm thinkin' uhhh automated spambot
>>
>>214145056
yeah I'm thinkin' you suck cocks. Plural.
>>
>>214144959
The Mount Rushmore of Star Trek Captains goes
>Kirk
>Picard
>Sisko
>Kirk again fuck Insaneway
>>
>>214144986
But if their philosophy makes them suffer, then why do they continue to hold it? That is not logical.
>>
File: 1753407819650768m.jpg (58 KB, 1024x960)
58 KB
58 KB JPG
>>214145153
Pretty much yeah
>>
File: 1755919858120546.jpg (60 KB, 590x483)
60 KB
60 KB JPG
>>
File: yWcgUt8Y9wpJtRbSYZqwjn.jpg (92 KB, 1280x720)
92 KB
92 KB JPG
What does Morn do? Like what is his job? Why is he on the station?
>>
>>214145264
he's insanely wealthy so he doesn't have to work. he just likes to hang out. and join violent mobs as they arise.
>>
File: 1754449235427509.png (306 KB, 1000x1000)
306 KB
306 KB PNG
>>214145285
He keeps Quark employed
>>
I thought he was a smuggler or something
>>
>>214145237
rock, it, man
>>
>>214145285
Nobody has to work because post-scarcity. Morn is there to keep the makeup team busy.
>>
>>214145354
>in the future, nobody *has* to work
>meanwhile today, they literally make things up to force people to keep working
I want off Mr. Bones' Wild Ride
>>
File: 1756168656699686.jpg (129 KB, 615x434)
129 KB
129 KB JPG
My favorite Captain because he is trained to run the ship and prepared for any scenario
>>
File: ECH.jpg (94 KB, 460x506)
94 KB
94 KB JPG
>>214145503
Sorry, wrong Pic
>>
File: 1756340293093241.jpg (255 KB, 1024x1013)
255 KB
255 KB JPG
>>214144959
Why do people subject themselves to this nutrek crap?
>>
>>214145503
>Prepared for any scenario
>Nearly gets humanity genocided by Q, loses his security chief and frees his second officer’s evil twin all in his first year
>>
File: 1508226745005.gif (1.93 MB, 500x281)
1.93 MB
1.93 MB GIF
>>214145556
>people
We dont
>>
>>214145539
Oh, that pun has /layers/
>>
Morn joining the mob trying to kill Odo was so funny
>>
>>214145648
Fucking shifters
Cant trust them
Dont let them in your country
>>
>>214145153
Wrong

It's obviously
>Kirk
>Picard
>Sisko
> Jellico
>>
File: 1743677051709979.jpg (29 KB, 661x165)
29 KB
29 KB JPG
>>
>>214145729
One of my favorites, so many great moments
>>
>>214144843
>NTR
I'm convinced he's into netori
>>
File: siskos.jpg (643 KB, 1200x1090)
643 KB
643 KB JPG
>>214144959
cool dad pike is the best because cool dads are the best
>>
File: 1583546348014.png (304 KB, 576x432)
304 KB
304 KB PNG
>>214144843
>Or does he have a lame fetish like NTR

>"Return to Grace" DS9, Episode 4x14
>DUKAT: Lately, when my mind wanders, I find myself thinking more and more about Gul Marratt. Do you know him? Very dashing. One of Cardassia's rising stars. Graduate of the Cardassian Military Academy, smooth-talking junior member of the Detepa Council, and like your friend Shakaar, quite a lady's man. Especially with other officer's wives.
>KIRA: Including yours?
>DUKAT: Mmm. A year ago he wouldn't have dared, but now? I think the first thing I do when I'm returned to power is to demote him. Assign him to the Cardassian Embassy on Breen. I hear it's bitter cold on Breen. And we Cardassians do despise the cold.
>>
File: dainty run.webm (424 KB, 960x720)
424 KB
424 KB WEBM
this is such a good and memorable episode beloved by all but the "bplot" and hamfisted racism bullshit is so cringe and not believable. also the newlywed thing seems kind of tacked on too. what could they have done instead?
>>
>>214145899
The racism subplot is key to the story and pure kino. The wedding thing was just fluff that they could've dropped entirely.

Firmly establishing that Spock is "one of the good ones" is important for the audience, particularly the predominantly white audience of 1966.
>>
>>214145877
>oh my God Kira's here with me I have her all to myself as a captive audience hahaha what should I talk about to make her love me? how about the guy who's probably getting KEKING ME RIGHT NOW that'll melt her panties

his mind is truly an enigma
>>
>>214145940
That's cause he's half human, like Obama was half white, which maximized mass appeal.
>>
>>214146014
Still gotta let the audience know it's okay to like the yellow devil-eared non-white guy
>>
>>214145940
no. Stiles is a monkey retard and acted in a way that is not believable of a Starfleet officer on the bridge. being alarmed kr skeptical INITIALLY would have been one thing but he literally chimps out at his superior officier for no fucking reason except apparently having PTSD. fuck off. that shit was STUPID
>>
>>214146032
here's what I think they needed for it to work for me:
instead of a scene of him of him and Kirk talking about how his family was killed by Romulans or whatever, show a scene of him already being cold towards and not trustful of Spock. and then you can explain that since his family was killed by Romulans he just has a thing against xenos in general. going from just treating Spock as a normal person to bring a bigoted freak just because he physically resembles a Romulan is too dumb for me.
>>
>>214146239
being*
>>
>>214145556
After all the seething ITT, I decided to watch SNW 101. I thought it was very good! Maybe the series gets worse from here, but it sure had a strong beginning! Can any of the oldtrek geezers tell me why I'm supposed to hate it? And I mean actual details, not "argle bargle nuTrek bad REEEEE!!!"
>>
>>214146334
Can any of the oldtrek geezers tell me why I'm supposed to hate it?
No, they can't. Most of them have not actually seen a single minute of the series.
>>
File: 1755970682707384.png (318 KB, 769x768)
318 KB
318 KB PNG
is anybody buying this?
>>
>>214146413
Not even a little bit
>>
File: AA1CICVu.jpg (40 KB, 734x435)
40 KB
40 KB JPG
>>
File: Quark_as_Lumba.jpg (25 KB, 340x260)
25 KB
25 KB JPG
>>214146413
It is about as convincing as Quark in drag.
>>
>>214146397
Still, I'm giving them a chance. Handling conflict with reason is preferable to a mob-style melee. At least, that's what Trek tries to teach us.
>>
>>214146479
He convinced the sluggo cola magnate just fine
>>
>>214146494
The Sluggo guy was just a goddamn degenerate
>>
>>214146479
he was convincing though
>>
File: hqdefault.jpg (13 KB, 456x360)
13 KB
13 KB JPG
>>214146502
Takes one to know one.
>>
show me a female Ferengi that's not Moogie and not nutrek. has there been one?
>>
>>214146599
Yes, one of the early FErengi episodes. The next one in the watchalong I think even, where there's a female waiter pretending to be a man who gives Quark good advice
>>
>>214146599
There is a reverse trap.
>>
>>214146641
I mean. they are pretty androgynous so yes I would argue "Lumba" is a convincing female
>>
>>214146750
Well that one is specifically setting out to look like a man

I've never looked up the actress.. I'm afraid to
>>
So, no oldtrek geezers have a reason I was supposed to hate SNW 101? (Just the non-reply replies which, I'm assuming, are implying that I samefagged. For the record, I didn't. Seems like projection on their part.) I'm 10 minutes into SNW 102 and still, nothing particularly offputting, except for the dyke haircut on the helmsperson.
>>
File: nu trek fucking sucks.png (131 KB, 900x574)
131 KB
131 KB PNG
>>
Bad haircuts are just a Star Trek staple THOUGH
>>
File: 1747968109704324m.jpg (70 KB, 1024x766)
70 KB
70 KB JPG
>>214146786
it's really a moot point I guess. Bashir can convincingly alter people to look like totally difference species so of course there's no reason he couldn't make Quark a convincing female. if we go by Moogie we know that the females don't have long hair or any other obvious distinguish sex characteristic besides like what, smaller ears? easily altered. Brunt would have been fooled too if he didn't already know better.
>>
File: Hélène Udy.jpg (82 KB, 576x864)
82 KB
82 KB JPG
>>214146786
Fear not, fearful one. You should be willing to seek out new life and new civilizations. Have you learned nothing from Trek?
>>
File: tguvzy6uomb61.jpg (126 KB, 960x720)
126 KB
126 KB JPG
>watch this thing you know you will hate so you can tell me why you hate it
>>
>>214146902
So, no reason given to hate SNW, just irrational prejudice. So very not in the spirit of Trek. It's like you learned nothing from all those hours watching oldtrek.
>>
hes sick of getting banned I guess lmao. the new ruse is being "on topic"
>>
>>214146985
Could be worse
>>
i saw 30mins of wrath of khan. it looked neat. and khan looked nothing like i imagined. i need to watch the movies ;s
>>
File: 1748369126666315m.jpg (112 KB, 1024x576)
112 KB
112 KB JPG
>>214146938
Armin Shimerman is a very great actor in any role hes done
>>
>>214147207
what else should I watch him in?
>>
>>214145172
It must be because they don't actually like SNW, so they're not suffering in the first place
>>
File: SNW 101: World War 3.webm (3.61 MB, 1280x528)
3.61 MB
3.61 MB WEBM
>>214147004
Irrational prejudice. Check. They talked about people like you in Star Trek. You were the sort of people that hurled us into World War 3. Here, have a free webm.
>>
>>214147224
He was Kramer's caddy in Seinfeld.
>>
File: 1755963089797403.png (7 KB, 437x695)
7 KB
7 KB PNG
>>214147319
>here have a free turd of dogshit
>>
File: liar for ants.gif (72 KB, 263x200)
72 KB
72 KB GIF
>>214146413
it's all so tiresome
>>
>>214147337
ok I'm not gonna watch Seinfeld to see him in some NOTHING role. what else?
>>
File: 1578777838613.jpg (213 KB, 800x714)
213 KB
213 KB JPG
>>
>>214147079
>being on-topic is a "ruse"
Do you even realize how insane you sound right now?
>>214147268
But they hate it although they've never seen it. After somehow powering the first two seasons of Discovery (which featured Starfleet officers crying on a regular basis... I mean, really?!), I assumed I would hate SNW, but tonight, I decided to give it a try anyway, and so far, I don't hate it.
>>
>>214147379
Bro loves his history
>>
File: 1736796755166614.jpg (59 KB, 923x692)
59 KB
59 KB JPG
>>214147004
I want to kill Relena at her birthday party
>>
>>214147372
Billy & Mandy
Psychonauts
Lots of sitcoms
>>
>>214147224
he was the principal in Buffy, unfortunately I think he gets got pretty early on
>>
File: 1756084535584025.jpg (37 KB, 552x672)
37 KB
37 KB JPG
>>
File: 1754261989429152.jpg (106 KB, 1000x750)
106 KB
106 KB JPG
>>214147389
>Do you even realize how insane you sound right now?
Do you realize an actual newfag would have no idea what I'm talking about and not even noticed my post let alone respond to it? you suck at this
>>
File: images.jpg (8 KB, 246x205)
8 KB
8 KB JPG
>>214147438
>That doesn't really work, does it?
>>
File: 1579113848059.png (2.02 MB, 1080x1605)
2.02 MB
2.02 MB PNG
>>214147399
The cast were all pretty well read. Not retards like nutrek.
>>
>>214147438
I can see his neckbeard even though he shaved. idk who this incel is but he is an insult to Spock
>>
>>214147319
I wonder why they didn't show literally any footage of the Mostly Peaceful Protests, y'know, the ones that involved mass looting, shooting, and arson? Also, why are clearly starfleet-pattern shuttles dropping nukes in these historical films? Wouldn't they be more contemporary aircraft?
>>
>>214147389
>But they hate it although they've never seen it
You wouldn't know this if you were actually a newfag as you claim, you trolling faggot.
>>
>>214147347
I guess all I can do is continue to minister to the least of my brothers. Because you oldtrek geezers certainly are the least.
>>214147457
What's to understand? It doesn't take any background to realize that, by claiming on-topic is a ruse, that you've lost any meaningful contact with reality. I'd like to say it's fascinating to get a glimpse into your insanity, but it really isn't. Pretty mid.
>you suck at this
Epic non-self-awareness, epic projection.
>>
>You were the sort of people that hurled us into World War 3
...heroes?
>>
File: 1680855813132204.gif (966 KB, 245x180)
966 KB
966 KB GIF
>>
>>
File: your god.jpg (165 KB, 1024x1024)
165 KB
165 KB JPG
>>214147539
Wait, when did I claim that? Link to the post.
>>214147634
You are truly deranged. If you want to kill yourselves, could you do it without taking the rest of us with you? We don't think we're going to meet your God.
>>
File: 1748997549012061.webm (936 KB, 960x720)
936 KB
936 KB WEBM
when I was a newfag here about 6 months ago all I did is talk about trek I was watching and post webmemes I made because I love trek. and I still do that to this very day! no one ever gave me any pushback or told me to fuck off. gee I wonder why that is
>>
>taking the schizo bait
Are you guys that bored?
>>
>>214147724
It's a three day weekend.
>>
File: Spoiler Image (564 KB, 800x430)
564 KB
564 KB GIF
>>214147718
>>
>>214147724
lil bit
>>
>>214147319
>nuke new york, washington during biden era
>leads to utopian sci-fi paradise
What did they mean by this?
>>
Gul Skrain Dukat
>>
>>214147372
Seinfeld is good though, watch it anyway
>>
>>214147823
Skrain Dukat is such a gross name. can we brainstorm a better one?
>>
His first name is Gul.
>>
>>214147860
Gulliver. Gulliver Dukat.
>>
>>214147860
>>214147878
Gul Gil Dukat
>>
>>214147878
that's a human name. not buying it
>>
>>214147860
It's Skrain actually.
>>
>>214147723
You think I care if a bunch of mentally-diminished troglodytes give me pushback or tell me to fuck off? I can't even comprehend the desire to be such a conformist. Maybe you can explain it.
>>
File: 1753104828093072.gif (2.54 MB, 480x270)
2.54 MB
2.54 MB GIF
>>214147916
idk why you replied to me I have nothing to do with whatever you're talking about. sorry!
>>
You can't strain the Skrain.
>>
>>214147952
I get why Zyial was so important to him. She is almost a perfect metaphor for his relationship to Bajor. It just makes me think about the rest of his family that he talks about but is never shown.
>>
>>214147945
You claimed to be a newfag that didn't get pushback or got told to fuck off. I was hoping you could provide illumination. That wasn't obvious?
>>
Enabren Tain is the most aesthetically pleasing Cardie name. That I know of anyway
>>
>>214147991
everything about him is obvious if you have ever encountered a malignant narcissist. I have fought with people about him on here before that genuinely belive he cares about anything but himself and its so interesting
>>
>>214148000
weeoo weeoo weeoo
>>
File: 1755404054850540.png (29 KB, 550x550)
29 KB
29 KB PNG
>>214148000
yeah when I was a newfag I didn't notice you. but it's been a few months and now I'm the person warning others to ignore you. i'll tell you my superpower that you lack. it's called actually liking star trek.
>>
>>214148032
My favorite Dukat moment is when he is trying to flirt with Kira while DS9 is in a self-destruct sequence.
>>
>>214148102
NO I HATE STAR TREK BECAUSE IT TAKES ITSELF TOO SERIOUSLY! I NEED QUIPS! I NEED MEME DIALOGUE! I NEED THE CHARACTERS TELLING ME HOW DUMB THE SHOW I'M WATCHING IS!
>>
>>214148102
I like Trek. I'm liking SNW 102 at the moment. I'm halfway through and there's a messianic vibe and some esoteric religious content, which I'm a big fan of. There's not enough of that in sci-fi. Why don't you think I like Trek? I literally like more Trek than the seething oldtrek geezers.
>>
>>214148172
I'M A ONE DIMENSIONAL STEREOTYPE! THERE'S NO COMPLEXITY TO MY CHARACTER! IF I SAY SOMETHING, YOU'RE FULLY JUSTIFIED IN INTERPRETING IT IN A RIDICULOUSLY NARROW WAY AND THEN BLOWING IT OUT OF PROPORTION! IT'S PERFECTLY OK TO ACT DECISIVELY BASED ON INCOMPLETE AND IMPRECISE INFORMATION!
Hey, you're right, this is fun!
>>
This is why DS9 is the best
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_s-nDssQRtI
>>
>Skrain! Skrain! Oh Prophets, Skraaaain! - Kira's Mom
>>
Dukat is literally me (except I never had the opportunity to genocide a planet)
>>
>>214148241
But enough about nuTrek
>>
File: 1752896873966620.webm (2 MB, 1456x1092)
2 MB
2 MB WEBM
>>
File: 1748290230443484.jpg (226 KB, 1440x1178)
226 KB
226 KB JPG
Give me one of these and I am content.
>>
>>214148341
I want to see a diagram like that of DS9
>>
>>214148341
Wow is there really that much space in the runabouts?
>>
Nw thread soon
>>
>>214148283
How can you possess so much narrow-minded prejudice and yet be a fan of Star Trek, which stands for the exact opposite of that? That must take a lot of work.
>>
File: Danube_class,_aft_section.jpg (803 KB, 1434x1080)
803 KB
803 KB JPG
>>214148382
Yeah bro they're awesome
>>
>>214147836
Adolf
>>
>>214148001
Enamored Taint is my favorite fat cardie
>>
>>214147836
Donald
>>
>>214147836
Jeffrey
>>
NEW THREAD
>>214148501
>>214148501
>>214148501
>>214148501
NEW THREAD
>>
>>214148461
there is no "narrow minded prejudice" here. the criticism and disdain is legitimate. and that's why you can do nothing other than constantly get banned
>>
>>214148260
"If I had been there Bajor would have turned out different." -Dukat
>>
>>214147991
>the rest of his family that he talks about but is never shown.
This just makes me think about if he is talking about Cardassia because they value the state above all else.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.