Gearhead thread but for /tg/Part of why I like to play ttrpg's is the analog aspect. I prefer to keep all digital things out of the experience. No laptops, ipads, phones at the table. Well, an exception can be made for googling something quick, but other than that, keep that shit in your pocket.I like to do my gm prep, world building, drawing maps, in notebooks. npc and character sheets etc.on paper.I really like MUJI stationery. Their notebooks are really nice, and their pens and pencils are amazing.I recently found some hex paper notebooks on amazon. That was really nice to use to draw some hex maps.Do you have any neat stationery or other analog "gear" that you really like? Could you share some of your cool items or showcase your note taking system or maps or whatever?
>>97835016It's really just about making it fun for yourself than anything else. Personally, my favorite pencils are pic-related. They're very pretty and mad of incense cedar.
>>97834954These "Statty's noteboards" are pretty handy for traveling GM's. It has 1 inch hexes/squares on the other side which is great for gaming. Can be wiped and the thing fits in a pocket folded.But in home games I love the Chessex Megamat. It is huge, and lays flat easily. The surface is pleasant to the touch. It is basically as big as my whole table, but it is fine, the character sheets and all the tools can just lay on top of it. Wet erase is also kind of better than dry erase in some ways.
>>97835036>better than dry erase in some ways.Like not getting all over my hands as I touch the table, ways. I agree.
>>97809050Go here. jetpens.comAll the paper and pens and pencils. Refill inks and stationary designed to last. Worthwhile if you don't have a Michael's hobby store (much cheaper high quality notebooks compared to everywhere else) or a Walker's Office supply (bulk discounts).
>>97835064Or penboutique if you wanna get all fancy. Jetpens has more of the funky jajpanese stuff, but penboutique has more of the high-end stuff.
Tree 2 Edition>2024 PHB Scanhttps://files.catbox.moe/g8oo9h.pdf>Cropped and rotated, but more artifactyMjAyNCBQSEIsIE5vIFRodW1icywgT0NSZWQsIEFub24ncyBCb29rbWFya3MgdHJhbnNmZXJyZWQgb3Zlci4gCgpodHRwczovL2Vhc3l1cGxvYWQuaW8vd2Fvcm9h>2024 DMGhttps://files.catbox.moe/fd04pq.pdf>2024 Monster Manualhttps://files.catbox.moe/atd38s.pdf (D&D beyond version)https://pomf2.lain.la/f/1en5qwum.pdf (scan)Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>97834738>Does anyone know any house rules which maintain that low level feel of needing to improvise, rather than relying on your class features? Obviously, you can just restrict players to like level one or two, but then there’s very little progression.Idk maybe make enemies vastly stronger, like +5 to AC and saves always, 2-5 x HP, 2 x damage, but have improvised solutions be vastly more effective too, for example toppling a large statue on a troll straight up automatically kills it, a charging beast has 0 chance of avoiding a pit trap and if it's deep enough it's stuck there with no chance of escape, direct ballista hits instakill huge and smaller targets etc. Ideally you should just look for a different system instead.
>>97834738If you and your party like playing at low levels, you could always attack the problem by just keeping them from leveling up as ofte. Cut the exp to 1/4 of what's listed, or if you run milestone leveling make the milestone harder to reach.
I've got a hankering to play a shaman-like character in 5.5e. More or less I'd draw upon nature spirits to do magic for me. It sounds like I'd be rolling a Warlock, but would I be better off dipping into Druid, taking the Guide background, or working with my DM to homebrew something, whether it be an entire class or subclass of Warlock?
What are some item ideas or mechanic changes or anything to give players something to do while unconscious but stable?>magic sword that fights after death>playing pets or summons>choice to keep rolling d20s to get 1 hp on 20 but risk haunt to start making death saves if 1>becoming stable just heals to 1 hp
>>97834991There is the Vestige Warlock from Unearthed Arcana, which does explicitly summon a spirit. It also gets access to a Cleric domain as extra spells, and while it does just list the 2024 domains, it wouldn't be a huge stretch to use the Nature or Tempest spell list from 2014.The damage types are a little off, being Fire, Necrotic, and Radiant. But you could likely swap that to Fire, Poison, and Thunder and end up with a similar overall effectiveness. And likewise the final feature is to upcast a Summon spell, but again swapping it for Summon Beast/Elemental also would probably be fine. Add on the Guide background for a bit more Druid magic and take Pact of the Chain so you can have another 'nature spirit' of some variety and it's shaping up pretty well with minimal tweaks.
Hello elegan/tg/gentlemen,Bit of an odd question, but, I am travelling from USA to Europe and I will visit over there a friend of mine who is into /tg/ stuff and lives over there now. We have a rule of not bringing gifts to eachother, but nonetheless I wanted to bring something, maybe not in excess of 10$. What could I bring him? Preferably something that he cannot get in Europe or is more expensive there. Any ideas?Thanks in advanceTL;DR cheap stuff /tg/ related which is more expensive or had to get in Europe than the USApic unrelated
You're an American. Bring him a gun
Anything that is popular enough is also available in Europe. Assuming you have enough prep time, look around /awg/ for the manufacturers list. There are some indie mini makers that don’t sell across the pond (or the shipping costs are insane). For example, I found this old school manufacturer that I had shipped to my ex-gf uncle’s and I picked it up when we visited last summer.
>>97833049Pro Acryl paints maybe? Those are made in USA if I recall correctly.But then again they're liquid so maybe they'll get stopped during your molestation by the TSA at the airport. A good reaper miniature you think he will like possibly?I'm not sure beyond that.
>>97833049>We have a rule of not bringing gifts to eachother, >but nonetheless I wanted to bring somethingDon't. Really. You're just going to make it weird.
>>97833049>What could I bring him?Wishes of health, good luck and happiness, you rule-breaking faggot.
Bedsheet Ghost EditionTell us about your horror settings, games, etc. Share inspirational art, prompts, etc.>List of games:Call of Cthulhu, Chill, Cold and Dark, Degenesis, Delta Green, Don't Rest Your Head, Dread, Esoterrorists/Fear Itself+Book of Unremitting Horror, Fall of Delta Green, GORE, Into The Shadows, KULT, Little Fears, Mothership RPG, Nemesis (free on Arc Dream's website), Nights Black Agents, Silent Legions (Mostly for the tables), Stalker: The SciFi RPG, Symbaroum, Ten Candles, Trail of Cthulhu, Unisystem (All Flesh Must Be Eaten, Witchcraft, Conspiracy X, etc.), Unknown Armies, The Whispering Vault, Vaesen>Inspirational stuff:Caitlin R Kiernan, Castlevania, Carnacki the Ghost-Finder, Doom Watch, Fear & Hunger, George Romero, Ghostwatch, House of Leaves, I Am In Eskew, John Carpenter, Kolchak the Nightstalker, Laird Barron, John Langan, M.R. James, Nick Cutter, Old Gods of Appalachia, Quatermass, Ramsey Campbell, Remedy Series (Alan Wake, Control), SCP Foundation, Scarfolk Council, Shaun Hutson, Silent Hill, Stand Still Stay Silent, The Evil Dead, The Magnus Archives, The Secret World, The Stone Tapes, Anatomy, Thomas Ligotti, Twin Peaks, Vault of Evil forums, toomuchhorrorfictionOther News:Dust & Blood released for Cthulhu by Gaslighthttps://www.chaosium.com/blogout-now-for-cthulhu-by-gaslight-dust-blood/Current Book Club Topic:Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
Book Club starter questions:>What works?>What's cool about it?>Why is it so effective?>What is the best part of it in your opinion?>Thoughts on the characters?>Is the villain effective?>If you had to pick a moment that really scared you, which would it be?>Is there anything you feel could have been expanded upon?>What would you change?>Would you use it as inspiration for a game?
I am playing old CoC starting with 2E, I play solitaire TTRPGs because everyone is a fucking retard who wants social lube and "good" times doing things for laughs rather than trying to roleplay or seriously do anything.I finished the Haunted House with relative ease, my characters didn't figure out the sunlight, but we dealt with everything without death or going insane. Which makes sense as its the tutorial.However, the 2nd scenario is very confusing. How is anyone supposed to "win" in this scenario? There is no clear way to stop the ritual. The rules are clusterfuck of a mess, which is fine as long as there is a way to win. Combat is a no go because of the Mi-Go's super high armor. The only thing I can think of is that you are supposed to run away to tell the authorities and fuck outta there and say "it's someone else's problem" which actually will result in the certain doom of the town at the hand of Ithaqua because they are doing the ritual every night with a 28% chance of success to cause a massive blizzard and snow to kill all the town, then set up a mining camp there. My characters thought that the hillbilly was key to stopping the ritual and killed him in combat, but afterwards died to all the Mi-Go's hunting them down, carrying them into the atmosphere and all meeting their death through lung explosion.Is this common in CoC? Is this how most of the scenarios and stories are?
>>97834275My main question here is how did anyone manage to beat this scenario successfully.
How does horror work in a TTRPG?
Ran The Necropolis out of Gateways of Terror for my group last night. Two players were going to miss our Horror on the Orient Express session, so I did it instead. Had a 75% casualty rate, but the last character made it out. I had to beef up the monster, however, as our Solider player nearly killed it in the first round of combat with an impale on their gun (they did 14 damage out of 17 health). I made it so their gun did half damage instead, though they still ended up bringing it down to 2 HP before they got killed. Rather disappointingly, none of them even attempted to sneak past the monster and get into the room it emerged from, so they never found its heart. Instead, it died due to the tomb caving in after the exit was dynamited by the last surviving PC. We had a good time, but it’s definitely a con scenario, and a much more combat-focused one at that. I feel like of the three scenarios in the book, it’s the one least suited to people who have never played an investigative horror game before. The lethality might put them off it if they’re not used to that kind of thing.
A Midsummer Night's Dream EditionPreviously on /slop/: >>97789009▶ Thread Task: William Shakespeare.▶ Generatorshttps://bing.com/images/create/https://sora.chatgpt.com/https://gemini.google/overview/image-generation/https://perchance.org/ai-text-to-image-generatorhttps://civitai.com/Curious about local genning? Check out /g/'s stable diffusion OP or ask one of our friendly locals.Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>“Age cannot wither her, nor custom stale her infinite variety.”
>>97828814>>97829683>>97829052Nice. Remind me of those surprise hot illustrations that you would find in tabletop RPG magazines>>97829460>>97829646I get it that it can seem like the slop machines are taking over, but they can only do derivative, repetitive stuff with small variations and only after a lot of trial and error. An actual person will always do it better, but it will take a while to get there, and the long road of learning can be disheartening, but it is also fun and fulfilling. You can also combine your skills with the slop. It produces the best results.
TOOOOOOOT Edition>Previously, in the Mortal Realms>>97828345>Official AoS website:https://www.ageofsigmar.com>Downloads, Rules Errata, and FAQs:https://www.warhammer-community.com/warhammer-age-of-sigmar-downloads/>Toolshttps://runebrush.pa-sy.com/warscroll/>Anvil of Apotheosis hero creator:Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>97834884The Corpse God is on his Golden Throne and all the faithful knows he's still alive and holding back the darkness.
>>97834795I prefer the idea that the mouth guard piece of a heraldors deathmask helmet is separate, and strapped to their jaw so that it can open just enough when the heraldor wants to doot the horn.
>>97834889Abraxia claims to be in direct contact with archaon and is leading his forces per his instructions but she could be coping and covering for him.
Do you guys think Bel'akor's new kingdom will get unique models and rules or will it just be a sub faction in S2D?
>>97834916I wouldn't be opposed to archaon's underlings trying to usurp him, sounds fun>>97834935I mean he kind of already has unique models and rules *as* a subfaction within S2D currently. But no I don't expect him to become his own faction if that's what you're asking.>inb4 the autarchy belongs to belakor
Hey /tg/ I have a problem. One of my players is a genuine incel. He's 27 and I'm pretty sure he's never had sex. He definitely hasn't gotten laid in a while. He's not really ugly just kinda weird and awkward. I feel bad for him. But he is taking his extreme thirst out in the game. >every time his character, a human eldritch knight, comes back from our adventures he always tries to play up the angle of "we saved the town, where are the girls to suck my dick as thanks?">he constantly talks about how his character is 6 foot 2 (he's 5 foot 8 irl)>he talks out of his ass a lot about medieval times and says that peasant girls were way healthier than modern women.>says how farmers would be begging to marry their lithe 17 year old daughters to him>he talks about medieval demographics and criticizes the DMa works building (which is actually kinda shit to be fair) >you can just tell how excited he is talking about how there should be a dozen villages between these two cities on the map, like he is stopping just short of talking about how many nubile virgin farm girls are there for his fighter to fuckWe tried talking to him about it but he twisted it around to make the rest of us sound like we were fucking gay or something. Also his character is too important to the story to kick him, and running him as an NPC would suck the fun out of it since there's be a lot of the DM just roleplaying with himself while the rest of us watch. So....any advice? Its not worth ruining the game over by kicking him, and nothing is so blatant to be a clear social violation, but the dude is just oozing incel energy and I feel like I should subtly suggest to the DM something that will set his head on straight, and possibly help cure his mindset. Any ideas?
>>97834928This. Positive change starts with you, and this guy clearly hasn't developed his sexual and social skills in a normal healthy way, the only course of action is to lay him down by the fire, caress his manly body, make him moan and perspire. When you make him your wife this will solve the incel problem, and you can solve other table problems by talking about it as a couple.
>>97834944> When you make him your wifeProbably the other way around since OP sounds like a bitch.
>>97834948Incels definitionally don't make the first move. You go to war with the army you have.
Have the party wizard force-fem him.
>>97835024Not a bad idea.
It's Da PDF Share Thread!STEP 0:<----- That image is not a PDF, it's an image, at least for now. Check the 4plebs link below to find the PDF.PLEASE READ DA FAQ BEFORE REQUESTING OR SHARING.It will answer 99% of your questions about this thread. If you haven't read it, we will know.STEP 1:Please exhibit good manners. Threads start sliding off the board after a certain number of posts. More posts wasted on being rude means fewer posts available for sharing.STEP 2:Request, share, stay awesome!Previous thread:>>97757836Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>97834660The Red Book doesn't appear to be in there, but i appreciate those ones too, thank you.
>>97834796Oh, you're right. I downloaded it recently, and just assumed it was that one when I searched for it in the previous threads. Hered/MYRgJr
>>97834812much thanks
>>97834394Thanks bro
Are there any of the pdf´s in this bundle in circulation here?https://www.drivethrurpg.com/de/product/474244/mythos-chronicles-ultimate-5e-bundle
>produce indie module>send it to a few youtubers who review modules and have a decent reputation for independent thought>hey, I've seen some of this guy's videos and he has never once mentioned being paid>send free copy>get email from his agent quoting a price for a reviewWhy are they all like this?
>>97833048Why haven't you posted the proof he asked for? If you're not lying it would be super easy to shut him up by posting a link.
>>97833283took you long enough to reply again trooniefor a second I thought you weren't still mad :)
Do you think he gets back-pain?Do you think he calls them>"the girls"
>>97833382fucking yuck
>>97833283She has none, and thus she deflects.
▶Previous thread: >>97697376▶Official Key Downloads, FAQs and Erratahttps://www.warhammer-community.com/en-gb/downloads/kill-team/▶Official GW KT app:https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.gamesworkshop.kt3https://apps.apple.com/us/app/kill-team-the-app/id6479447973▶Rules and Resources[Missing in Action]▶Team Summaries for Dummies[Missing in Action]Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>97834093>>97834120You done champ? You feel good now?
>>97834139I'm a proud Aryan male and I wish nothing more than for pissreal to be nuked off the face of the earth>>97831823Although playing killteam one of my war dogs will do for now
>>97833130The last time we left making threads with oldfags, the general was dead for half a year and was missing everything from the OP.
>>97831823>TQThey make me feel cautiously optimistic. The fact that it's a whole expansion based on asymmetric narrative scenarios gives me hope that the designers will get away from sucking tourneyfag cock someday.>>97832072My kid isn't even a year old. When he is old enough I'll probably start him on something straightforward like Warcry first.
Anyone got an updated table of all the teams and the way they play/boxes
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-K7lXvGbc_A>"This Rule INSTANTLY Makes D&D More IMMERSIVE">look inside>"reinvent secret checks (in the style seemingly popularized by Pathfinder 2e, without mentioning Pathfinder 2e), roll these secret checks for players, deceive players on low rolls for secret checks (especially le ebin natural 1s, which should be critical failures!)">524k views as the very first video of the channel>pinned comment: "Well, that's it folks. This guy's peaked D&Dtube. Sam, this is a spectacular video, you should be incredibly proud of the work you've put in here. It's amazing, informative, and incredibly watchable! From your writing, to presentation style, your editing, camera work, AND LIGHTING! You're cooking!"I am so very, very mystified by the broader RPG community at times.
>>97829226https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fIvPWwtnOjEGoodness. This follow-up video earnestly, unironically posits that most D&D characters are bad because they are allegedly like Superman. Supposedly, the way to make a "great" D&D character is to deliberately give them a dumped ability score at 6, then constantly attempt tasks using that score, leaning into the failure to highlight the character's flaws.This video and the "le ebin flubbed secret checks" video seem tailor-made to appeal to the crowd who loves to watch other people play D&D and fumble.
>>97832551It's called roleplaying and not metagaming lil nigga
>>97832527NTA, but the only /tg/ related discord I'm aware of is the sup/tg/ one and that place is fucking gay they have a "no hate speech" clause. Doesn't sound very normal to me, unless your definition of normal involves power-injecting soi into your veins.
>>97833917It's actually called being bad at the game, because if you fuck up rolls, you wind up losing far more often than you win, which fucking sucks for most people, including most people on here.
>>97829226You should write a long-winded post on reddit about this, that might help these poor sodden fools see the error of their ways
"What the fuck?! 'You guys' let the thread die with no link to the new thread" EditionHere is a thread to discuss trading card games other than the big three.>Build Divide>Force of Will>Final Fantasy TCG>DBZ CCG>Wixoss>Keyforge>Gundam>Legend of the 5 Rings (L5R)>Digimon>Flesh and Blood>Gate Ruler>Battle SpiritsComment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>97834559>all the top meta decks are demonsKinda sussy.
>>97834806NFTendie is desperate to get others to agree that QR codes aren't fuck ugly and ruined any possible chance of that "game" (I've yet to see a single person ever play it) ever having a positive public reception.
>>97834289The artwork is such a turnoff
>>97830777>>97832899cards cost what they cost because of other aspects of the game. if the game makes players hungry for more cards then getting more cards will be "OP" (or expensive, if its balanced). like >>97833096 in mtg you only get 1 card per turn when you could easily use 3 or more, so draw is extremely valuable. if one deck could just draw more they would prettymuch always win.in games that just give you more draw, or some equivalent like SWU, draw tends to be less good. in netrunner you can draw up to 4 per turn with no help so things like Diesel can exist and be balanced. Ashes is at the extreme end where you usually cant use everything you draw after round 1, and you will see most of your deck, so both draw and tutoring are on the weaker side.piccy is some exampls of cards that look similar (one shot pay X to draw 3) but are very different valuation because of the system theyre in.
>>97834922no altered was a stupid shit cashgrab TCG with phygital dick cheese. basically just last year's version of riftbound or cyberpunk, but using a gimmick as the hype generator instead of a B-tier IP.hubworld is a niche LCG with an original setting that probably wont even be sold in stores. there about as far apart as any two acg games could be.
Disc 1 Final Boss editionPrevious >>97787403>Basics Pastebinhttps://pastebin.com/GWjTU9Uv>Anon's Locals Survival Guidehttps://pastebin.com/xXp5jShL>Fanmade PC simhttps://pastebin.com/u6aKrBSg>Official Mobile sim (Release Date TBA)https://www.digimon-alysion.com/en/Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>97834876It's just an bunch of important sounding gibberish. Maybe as a parody of pretentious card game advice, maybe as an attempt to troll, the guy who wrote it probably doesn’t really know himself.
oh great the DCGO only guy schizo posting about imperial was not a one time thingI think I need to leave this thread for a while because this guy just keeps shitting it up
>>97834966If Siren or Ceres has tamer suspension it will just really fuck with other TS decks (can't use Asuna, Hiroko, promo rookies etc as none will instantly remove him). Though if Ceres is kinda weaksauce Venusmon pairs nicely with him
>>97834798Simple effect. Feels underwhelming for a Olympos top end. Maybe Ceresmon is the star of the deck.
>>97834975https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wtRdkqFDZZ8thats an island, son.
>What is Exalted?An epic high-flying role-playing game about reborn god-heroes in a world that turned on them.Start here:http://theonyxpath.com/category/worlds/exalted/>That sounds cool, how can I get into it?Read the 3e core book (link below). For mechanics of the old edition, play this tutorial:http://mengtzu.github.io/exalted/sakuya.htmlIt’ll get you familiar with most of the mechanics.>Gosh that was fun. How do I find a group?Roll20 and the Game Finder General here on /tg/. good luck>Resources for Third Edition>3E Core and Splatshttps://www.mediafire.com/folder/b54o6teut3fx6/Exalted_3eComment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>97833591The long and short of it is that Solar Brawl is very flashy, but from what I've seen it's individual Charm costs ramp up very quickly. Whereas Infernal Brawl is comparatively modest, but is way more generous with scenelongs/permanent effects. If the Solar gets the timing right and pops off a good attack, nothing can stop him. But that's a big if, there's a reason why Dodge has often been recommended as a supplement to Brawl, and Infernal Brawl kinda approaches fights with both being and adapting to worst case scenarios. Worth noting that Hero-Sundering Hands forces a grappled foe to either accept the highest crippling injury possible (which doesn't count for their maximum) and Star-Swallowing Cosmos Collapse (showy name but it just lets you grapple out to short range) implies Infernal Brawlers have much less to fear from multiple opponents and battlegroups.>Blasphemous Miracle ProvidenceFor me, the big breakthrough was seeing Distant Whisper Wind (influence someone in Essence X10 miles briefly, or everyone in extreme range for a prolonged period), Spoken Sigil Ideogram (sub Linguistics for another social Charm's Ability. Did I mention Performance has a separate Charm to use it's Charms interchangeably for all kinds of performance? Or War) and Conceptual Rebus Concatenation (use TWO Simple Linguistics Charms together!) together in Linguistics. And after some consultation realising that yes, you CAN blast people with your Torments while ravaging their Resolve.>the main thingMercifully not only do Infernals have a lot of tools to even the odds (like the Brawl Charms I mentioned), but Shadow Spite Curse is back (in Larceny) and better than ever at absolutely fucking over everyone else's rolls. Best thing is unlike Abyssals, Infernals are much less reliant on actually landing penalties on people; the overall Charm design is more about either winning the war even if the battle's lost or throwing out costly to deal with effects at crazy ranges.
>>97833660>real, cooler NPC InfernalsHolden, of course, claims he had no idea what he was thinking when writing that. And yeah, Essence really discouraged me as well. I do wish there was a bit more substance to what Infernals currently have, but I'll gladly take it over either Cosmic Exalted Akuma or the SJWs of Hell.>Interpreting these bodiesIt's a reasonable take, one thing I will never be used to with 3e is lots of things going unexplained or confusingly worded when 2e at least tried to lay all the cards on the table when it wasn't OUTRIGHT withholding the big boys' statblocks from you.One thing that strikes me about the draft demons' statblocks is they look much more incomplete than the ones in HDNP, and what struck me about a lot of HDNP demons was that in many cases they weren't MEANT to be combat monsters. So my final cope is that the actual, published version of Ligier, Ululaya and the lot may just have a few extra things to clarify how their celestial bodies work or add to their powerset. It doesn't have to be anything too showy, I would be quite pleased with a Principle Invoking Onslaught-style hack of a Merit that just goes "Ligier's might transcends mere physicality. He can make these effects with Presence, Performance, Occult etc which makes them manifest as pillars of hellfire erupting from beneath the foe, rains of molten metal, environmental hazards with X Difficulty and Y damage etc etc etc" It's not a hope I'm holding onto particularly strongly, because I've consistently seen 3e's development take the path of least resistance and most low effort, shallow, reactionary kneejerk response to prior editions' content. But 3e Infernals has restored enough of my optimism to wait and hope at least. That and fill in the feedback form for what little good it'll do.
Speaking of Infernal Bureaucracy, while the whole arsenal of bureaucratic curses is very creative and all, looking through Solar Bureaucracy I find it funny that there is one (1) Solar Charm (Woe-Capturing Web) that is designed to hard counter all of them as long as the Solar can match the mote cost of said curse. There is no roll-off or anything. The curse just gets negated or returned to sender by the Solar who can maintain it for as long as the motes are committed.I'm not even mad, it's fucking hilarious how that one Charm exists specifically to punish counter-organisational mystic hubris.
>>97834034Looking back on Brawl, I see what you mean. 3e always challenged me when it came to comparing cumulative effect or advantage because of how every non-Simple Charm as potentially in play at any time (insert another jab at charm bloat here). That said, I *was* relieved to see that they weren't afraid to make more permanent effects available to Infernals; I was concerned they'd back away from the self-transformative design approach for Infernal powers (although thankfully, nothing as unavoidably punitive as some of the 2e charms like Witness to Darkness or Hateful Wretched Noise, which I've never not seen houseruled). Scene or day-long cooldowns on e.g. Crack the Sky, or Shadow Spite Curse, really make me feel bad though. I understand why they're there (begrudgingly), but I do think Vance or whoever is in charge now overuses the idea when they were principally a throttle for perfect defenses.Although after a closer reading of One Hand Fury, it seems to me that while transforming your arm into a weapon is permanent in itself, the surcharge effect functions solely as an adjunct to Infernal Monster Awakened and only lasts as long as that charm does (i.e. one scene).>3CDsI think their limitation is also a function of spirits now having bespoke Charms rather than drawing exclusively from a generalized list, which has its own advantages and disadvantages (primarily being the sheer amount of stuff they need to meaningfully interact with player Exalts at their intended level of power). Arguably demons like Ligier deserve more exclusive treatment - I would've liked to have seen his sorcery and "realm-warping martial arts" (cf. RoGD2) better represented as well, but they'd need to draw a line somewhere, and I think 3e's Charm approach itself is also to blame for that. Getting him to an adequate level was the primary goal, which if I'm correct just merges into your point about design path of least resistance.
>>97834521I'm absolutely convinced, because the Exalts weren't written in parallel, that this was a combination of Holden and Morke future-proofing Solar Bureaucracy against unforeseen shenanigans that could unhinge the Ability set, and some degree of Holden's philosophy of Solar favoritism manifesting itself. I've found his pattern of going just slightly too far with Solars very consistent in his work from Ink Monkeys to ExWod. Can't argue that it's fun when you benefit from it though, and to be fair to the guy, Solars being first out the gate has always been to their detriment each edition.
The /btg/ is dead! Long live the /btg/!Melee Mechs EditionPrevious Thread: >>97821886================================>BattleTech Introductory Guide & PDFshttps://battletech.com/qsr/>Rookie Guideshttps://tinyurl com/ydtr589ehttps://pastebin.com/HZvGKuGxhttps://files.catbox.moe/l1gjfi.jpgComment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>97834835Neo-Zeon nonsense! Ruins the whole profile.
>>97834849>Ruins the whole profile.Disagree.
>>97834842I don't like how weathering looks on models.
>>97834693>Still amazed by the sheer variety of IS BA yet they decided that omnimechs in the 3060s were a waste of resources.Even the Clan still produce standard mechs.
>>97834933It's a real shame the Clans relegate their standard machines to backwater worlds or militia-esque units. Some IS mechs would look fucking awesome in the colours of mainline Clan units.
